municipal electric utilities in minnesota
TRANSCRIPT
Municipal Electric Utilities
in Minnesota
Presented by
Minnesota Municipal Utilities Association
‘R OwanuadlHdla:k °'°'“
Bauddle
lShpl1angym, INGMOHMlwarren
VBQN ITIWI HIV!’ FIIS
East Grand Forks E M
0Clca:urook V _ , GrammaracOF at "9""Nlolsvlle °‘ T8,,” wwwmno ‘Bu; .lBiwdJ|k
$11811 Kauwan. H emuHam Cohas-mo 0 ' "*""°‘M’ om: Rmichl Nwum
HarborsHarley Balm Pallmmgggl IDGIIOI Lakes prod“.
lflamasvllle .p,,1,,.,,ONe0“s;l3'M':s omun M.
_ Q ‘ '359'“ ‘Branad °°“La"Breckenridge Hmnnghga andClams! .Rmda|
IElbOll Lake .p|,-_-QINQXUUFI .Mu-5
|Sad: CantoOMdroao
|.I|.lh
IPl‘il'I'.8lO‘1~=M-M Municipal Electric°"°""" '°""‘°"»<- ~ amen 'E'“"“$m 8-Gas Utilitiesnew .OUlcl'Illeld '5"""“ ..cllUQ ma-Mwm ’""i" ‘M '°<**"<> -~ aw» of Minnesota
HUl¢fl|fBOI‘lOGl'l'\;NFIiI I _ Gnu C?5il-B‘awe Qagnmm 'Sl1d:opee
Redwood Fnllsl ""3"" wgfiorttoglmlr Piagla M ow
mu" 0'-lvrm cum ‘commQTylm Soepy Eyu flew UIm.st Pug gmmn
waimwd l-Bk%QY5i3' lJaneavil|e.°wdVWSBNORO _ 514""; Mgdq wag” mm lficcheslar
Mcunlnn taken gKassan .81 CharlesDlgdllflih u'%Yl?d¢°'" IT|urrnn lflournnq Prailiam .PeuW.|
ews r nLWgmRmh£nmW:rllI ‘loo .NF'*'HImnm Ofluoifilb ""“". 5P‘i"9 ‘AM’ 'E%v9Ll;n.c‘i mi“MM". . kg" I W i I i 0“,
§igdo:_R':lr\d Efifinfmm 7M;fl Eitznn
‘R OwanuadlHdla:k °'°'“
Bauddle
lShpl1angym, INGMOHMlwarren
VBQN ITIWI HIV!’ FIIS
East Grand Forks E M
0Clca:urook V _ , GrammaracOF at "9""Nlolsvlle °‘ T8,,” wwwmno ‘Bu; .lBiwdJ|k
$11811 Kauwan. H emuHam Cohas-mo 0 ' "*""°‘M’ om: Rmichl Nwum
HarborsHarley Balm Pallmmgggl IDGIIOI Lakes prod“.
lflamasvllle .p,,1,,.,,ONe0“s;l3'M':s omun M.
_ Q ‘ '359'“ ‘Branad °°“La"Breckenridge Hmnnghga andClams! .Rmda|
IElbOll Lake .p|,-_-QINQXUUFI .Mu-5
|Sad: CantoOMdroao
|.I|.lh
IPl‘il'I'.8lO‘1~=M-M Municipal Electric°"°""" '°""‘°"»<- ~ amen 'E'“"“$m 8-Gas Utilitiesnew .OUlcl'Illeld '5"""“ ..cllUQ ma-Mwm ’""i" ‘M '°<**"<> -~ aw» of Minnesota
HUl¢fl|fBOI‘lOGl'l'\;NFIiI I _ Gnu C?5il-B‘awe Qagnmm 'Sl1d:opee
Redwood Fnllsl ""3"" wgfiorttoglmlr Piagla M ow
mu" 0'-lvrm cum ‘commQTylm Soepy Eyu flew UIm.st Pug gmmn
waimwd l-Bk%QY5i3' lJaneavil|e.°wdVWSBNORO _ 514""; Mgdq wag” mm lficcheslar
Mcunlnn taken gKassan .81 CharlesDlgdllflih u'%Yl?d¢°'" IT|urrnn lflournnq Prailiam .PeuW.|
ews r nLWgmRmh£nmW:rllI ‘loo .NF'*'HImnm Ofluoifilb ""“". 5P‘i"9 ‘AM’ 'E%v9Ll;n.c‘i mi“MM". . kg" I W i I i 0“,
§igdo:_R':lr\d Efifinfmm 7M;fl Eitznn
Largest Municipals in Minnesota
Rochester (48,219)
Moorhead (16,712)
Shakopee (16,139)
Austin (12,432)
Anoka (11,818)
Owatonna (11,302)
Alexandria (9,555)
Elk River (9,207)
Chaska (9,444)
Willmar (9,223)
Hibbing (8,173)
Brainerd (7,824)
New Ulm (7,028)
Hutchinson (7,027)
Grand Rapids (6,942)
Detroit Lakes (6,585)
Marshall (6,505)
North St. Paul (6,349)
Fairmont (6,004)
Buffalo (5,377)
By number of customers in 2010
Typical Municipals in Minnesota
73% (90) have fewer than
2,500 customers
40% (48) have fewer than
1,000 customers
Smallest Municipals in Minnesota
Whalan (42)
Nielsville (57)
Alpha (76)
Dunnell (117)
Bigelow (131)
Peterson (154)
Eitzen (152)
Ceylon (214)
Shelly (153)
Kandiyohi (252)
Rushmore (212)
Newfolden (218)
Alvarado (248)
Round Lake (255)
Brewster (259)
Randall (353)
Halstad (351)
Kasota (342)
Brownton (388)
Stephen (392)
By number of customers in 2010
Municipal and Co-op
Size Comparison Average
Municipal vs. Average Co-op
Median
Municipal vs. Median Co-op
2,898
16,235
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
16,000
18,000
Cu
sto
me
rs
Municipal
Co-op
1,239
6,345
0
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
7,000
Cu
sto
me
rs
Municipal
Co-op
Minnesota Electric Sales by Sector
(2007)
Source: 2007 Minnesota Utility Data Book; Minnesota Department of Energy Security
Investor-owned
66%
Cooperative 20%
Municipal 14%
In MWHs
U.S. Electric Sales by Sector (2012)
Investor-Owned Utilities 57.3%
Publicly Owned Utilities 15.3%
Cooperatives 11.0%
Power Marketers
15.2%
Federal Power Agencies 1.2%
(in MwH)
Source: 2012-13 Annual Directory & Statistical Report; American Public Power Association
T V§
"l=|._.-~J"-"‘;-
T V§
"l=|._.-~J"-"‘;-
Wholesale Power Suppliers
for Minnesota Municipals
Public Power 58%
WAPA 13%
Cooperative 13%
Investor-owned 16%
Minnesota Municipal Power Agency’s Faribault Energy Park
Source: MMUA
r
_r_.lELY
*_.~i:.-F '
‘fl-._____:-’l"‘¥"~."\_~ 3';-k;"' R5'-<5-.
|W{‘
'1;
3!} .=.\,~ - ',"_
'|;'..""
__.-'
.1",
$3
~' -.' _. I —. Q."YT-(I -1
- 4..r.._ 5':-1- _
1
ii
-.- -
."I
r
_.-nq_'_I - _
-'J_|'_
-ii‘ :,‘:'P‘
-1"'\
.1‘I-P‘
I?-'-1 1:1") . 1‘ E=~ P, if-#55’E i
|,‘
-x
,-
_,_
1I
1
'2
. U F -‘I_-:4 Ir.’
.J| . " ' -5!! tFf,‘ -_t ti"
I,’-
¢’ ,
_c,|-'-.-Il.r7-
P11;
._HI-liar ,,*_
_.,.4 _--- -- -- d- .4.""'-
fly., -x'- _......s:'-v¢.d---
._-_.,_
t‘_;-"‘q~',',‘jj_‘_
. ,-
fitflit
J|
' .---'."~1I¢='»=.;-.~. *1 .
..P \,
r
_r_.lELY
*_.~i:.-F '
‘fl-._____:-’l"‘¥"~."\_~ 3';-k;"' R5'-<5-.
|W{‘
'1;
3!} .=.\,~ - ',"_
'|;'..""
__.-'
.1",
$3
~' -.' _. I —. Q."YT-(I -1
- 4..r.._ 5':-1- _
1
ii
-.- -
."I
r
_.-nq_'_I - _
-'J_|'_
-ii‘ :,‘:'P‘
-1"'\
.1‘I-P‘
I?-'-1 1:1") . 1‘ E=~ P, if-#55’E i
|,‘
-x
,-
_,_
1I
1
'2
. U F -‘I_-:4 Ir.’
.J| . " ' -5!! tFf,‘ -_t ti"
I,’-
¢’ ,
_c,|-'-.-Il.r7-
P11;
._HI-liar ,,*_
_.,.4 _--- -- -- d- .4.""'-
fly., -x'- _......s:'-v¢.d---
._-_.,_
t‘_;-"‘q~',',‘jj_‘_
. ,-
fitflit
J|
' .---'."~1I¢='»=.;-.~. *1 .
..P \,
Municipal Power Agencies
Northern MunicipalPower Agencyit -MMPA
are 1?Q§@filE%£§D
| I i-J |||lL
f ‘F "a1|F"E l:-i 'u'..'l||: ::.: -‘-'.lm:'.fiq|:-"|:-,'
MISSOURIRIVEREusncv SERVICES.
"ruurProud Energy Partner
-_
- r
Northern MunicipalPower Agencyit -MMPA
are 1?Q§@filE%£§D
| I i-J |||lL
f ‘F "a1|F"E l:-i 'u'..'l||: ::.: -‘-'.lm:'.fiq|:-"|:-,'
MISSOURIRIVEREusncv SERVICES.
"ruurProud Energy Partner
-_
- r
Easll3ran:| Forks
i I
. F I
Q I
Olivia I
Elu1‘la|c- *’~"l*-1N|1lr1|"| II. PaulI
1 chili‘:-|Elrmr-.-nlen
I 'A|.|mgt|:m.. Shalrupeu
wi|-|1hmp II Le Sueur1| II * I f 1
“I"l'lHN'I1i Mu||l1:||'|n|i-'nm1r Agent;
‘ Managed by Avant Energy- Est. 1992- Full requirement contracts- 11 members. mnstly In theMetro area and south centralMinn.
I I-1-I II .1 1|I 1|‘. Ii I I 1|I I ||'l I I
Easll3ran:| Forks
i I
. F I
Q I
Olivia I
Elu1‘la|c- *’~"l*-1N|1lr1|"| II. PaulI
1 chili‘:-|Elrmr-.-nlen
I 'A|.|mgt|:m.. Shalrupeu
wi|-|1hmp II Le Sueur1| II * I f 1
“I"l'lHN'I1i Mu||l1:||'|n|i-'nm1r Agent;
‘ Managed by Avant Energy- Est. 1992- Full requirement contracts- 11 members. mnstly In theMetro area and south centralMinn.
I I-1-I II .1 1|I 1|‘. Ii I I 1|I I ||'l I I
• Rochester, MN • Est. 1977, 36 employees • All requirements contracts • 357 MW of generation (41% of Sherco III Plant) • Partner with NSP • 18 members
SMMPA
00 0 it 0
1. O O ‘I
VI”
0
00
° .e.o.00 0'
OIt O
Q I-
Grand Marais
' ' Souflrem Minnesota. ' ~ - ' Municipal Power Agency
0" 0
" 0° Mora.
. Princeton QNorth Branch.
Q .
¢ ' ..Litchfie|d' ' .O . 9 Q-
‘ Q
' 0 . Q . 1-
Reclwood Falls. ¢ 0 ‘ . .New PragueO . C
LHKB Cit0 .51 ‘Pater
0 . . O ' Wase-ca‘ .O"'*'3t°"""a.ROmister0 0 0 .Ell3urnirlg Prairie ,
0'lNE||5 _ . re 5mg
0 ‘*0. O . .. ° A“5t"". Spnngvallegf‘ Lo
00 0 it 0
1. O O ‘I
VI”
0
00
° .e.o.00 0'
OIt O
Q I-
Grand Marais
' ' Souflrem Minnesota. ' ~ - ' Municipal Power Agency
0" 0
" 0° Mora.
. Princeton QNorth Branch.
Q .
¢ ' ..Litchfie|d' ' .O . 9 Q-
‘ Q
' 0 . Q . 1-
Reclwood Falls. ¢ 0 ‘ . .New PragueO . C
LHKB Cit0 .51 ‘Pater
0 . . O ' Wase-ca‘ .O"'*'3t°"""a.ROmister0 0 0 .Ell3urnirlg Prairie ,
0'lNE||5 _ . re 5mg
0 ‘*0. O . .. ° A“5t"". Spnngvallegf‘ Lo
• Thief River Falls • Est. 1977, 3 employees • All requirements contract • 128 MW of capacity (30% of Coyote Plant) • Partner with Minnkota Power Cooperative • 12 members, 10 in NW MN
NMPA R. oseau.
‘Ste phen. O
‘Warren
Fnsalnn.
HalstadO
‘We rroad
Batldetie
Itmer River Falls
Q
.Bagle~_.t .' 0 '0'0 I "'
0-L
NORTIIERN .\'|l.'N]Cl[-'1-\l, l’U\\"ER .-\GEf\l(I\
_- .' 1 NMPA1-" 0
0 . '1- . i
i
I _II l_AI
R. oseau.
‘Ste phen. O
‘Warren
Fnsalnn.
HalstadO
‘We rroad
Batldetie
Itmer River Falls
Q
.Bagle~_.t .' 0 '0'0 I "'
0-L
NORTIIERN .\'|l.'N]Cl[-'1-\l, l’U\\"ER .-\GEf\l(I\
_- .' 1 NMPA1-" 0
0 . '1- . i
i
I _II l_AI
~ ‘ * ' I “HeartlandConsumerr . _ Power District
Marshall
I Ii
Q I I
Grove City ,I I" u I ‘ '
r " 0
-I
-I TylerMadeira‘."-' -
-Leite Crystal]
Truman 1|
' ' - Madison, South Dakota- Est. 1969- Partial. supplemental orfull requirements supplier- Partner in Laramie FliuerStation. other resources- El members in oenlral an-:1southwest Minn.
1' " -'-I
~ ‘ * ' I “HeartlandConsumerr . _ Power District
Marshall
I Ii
Q I I
Grove City ,I I" u I ‘ '
r " 0
-I
-I TylerMadeira‘."-' -
-Leite Crystal]
Truman 1|
' ' - Madison, South Dakota- Est. 1969- Partial. supplemental orfull requirements supplier- Partner in Laramie FliuerStation. other resources- El members in oenlral an-:1southwest Minn.
1' " -'-I
Latte Peri-t. I _
Mmmead .D"B'1iDlt LakesIBarr-asvllle Wagons mp.“r~=l=-~=~ H.-at i - ' ‘MISSOURI
_ _ - RIVEREuwnmhu Alesandna ' _ greener slnvlctat"
' Seuit Centre' '- Melroee
O|'1El|'Ni"B 'Bg|1$g|-|
‘Madison
[Marshall
wnflmmk St. James-
‘-J""‘-"'i“ tliiorthingtort hatafiad
II . ' I 1
|. ‘I 1-
. |. " I - I I l I.‘
* Sioux Falls 5.0.- Est. 1955
Supplemenal contracts- Laramie Hiver Station partner
QHutohln5o-l'1 1 24 members in central andsouthern Minn.
Latte Peri-t. I _
Mmmead .D"B'1iDlt LakesIBarr-asvllle Wagons mp.“r~=l=-~=~ H.-at i - ' ‘MISSOURI
_ _ - RIVEREuwnmhu Alesandna ' _ greener slnvlctat"
' Seuit Centre' '- Melroee
O|'1El|'Ni"B 'Bg|1$g|-|
‘Madison
[Marshall
wnflmmk St. James-
‘-J""‘-"'i“ tliiorthingtort hatafiad
II . ' I 1
|. ‘I 1-
. |. " I - I I l I.‘
* Sioux Falls 5.0.- Est. 1955
Supplemenal contracts- Laramie Hiver Station partner
QHutohln5o-l'1 1 24 members in central andsouthern Minn.
Public Power 58%
WAPA 13%
Cooperative 13%
Investor-owned 16%
Minnesota Municipal Power Agency’s Faribault Energy Park
Source: U.S. EIA, Form EIA-861, "Annual Electric Power Industry Report."
Wholesale Power Suppliers
for Minnesota Municipals
2008
_A___|___ .‘__fiT___H.‘I_*_r__Mm~_________“__H1___'______III____¥_
V&‘__
_if_hL_f”_‘"HF__‘____
_mi_|_J_n_n_l_H_l"__"__HIU_|_‘|4I
I ||____l|.__._1|I_____I
1
H____
_a
L
Y
iii
_____
J:
IrI|__I
___
I-JII_
___
E1!
_filfI
__I4!I _|Jm LL”IMd__IIIIif ‘
__I_:I
pmI1*% in “£______.__ I/|________I| _______||_f'____I____ __|_“______F3£3LEkgMW¢ ______:W_;____?NMfind
_A___|___ .‘__fiT___H.‘I_*_r__Mm~_________“__H1___'______III____¥_
V&‘__
_if_hL_f”_‘"HF__‘____
_mi_|_J_n_n_l_H_l"__"__HIU_|_‘|4I
I ||____l|.__._1|I_____I
1
H____
_a
L
Y
iii
_____
J:
IrI|__I
___
I-JII_
___
E1!
_filfI
__I4!I _|Jm LL”IMd__IIIIif ‘
__I_:I
pmI1*% in “£______.__ I/|________I| _______||_f'____I____ __|_“______F3£3LEkgMW¢ ______:W_;____?NMfind
Federal Hydropower
Garrison Dam
47 municipal utilities in Minnesota
receive non-polluting federal
hydropower from the Western Area
Power Administration (WAPA)
-I-I
_ :2?-.4
=\
' --,,__
-._,____‘fiT_?__fl| t _ ..W.
_ ______,_,__
*'-'-—-=r_=-
—r .— ~r— - . 7-4.-oi-.;-4- ———i-—Y*'?"-‘-\ _.-Q - —
-
- _'-=-;-=--=-:-
Lp} __ _,__
_ _ _ _. _"_.--5_-'1.‘-_-_ ' -T
1-r_ __-' - U l | I
-I|l!||_. -_;____éh?'.-' -' _?I- -:
-_,.._'- __' -_ _ 7 '“ -____
i|llI
-I-I
_ :2?-.4
=\
' --,,__
-._,____‘fiT_?__fl| t _ ..W.
_ ______,_,__
*'-'-—-=r_=-
—r .— ~r— - . 7-4.-oi-.;-4- ———i-—Y*'?"-‘-\ _.-Q - —
-
- _'-=-;-=--=-:-
Lp} __ _,__
_ _ _ _. _"_.--5_-'1.‘-_-_ ' -T
1-r_ __-' - U l | I
-I|l!||_. -_;____éh?'.-' -' _?I- -:
-_,.._'- __' -_ _ 7 '“ -____
i|llI
47 Municipal
Recipients of
Federal
Wholesale
Power
Federal Hydropower Qlitephen
0 Q olden, .W9lTHri
East GrandIT River FallsForks
Q
Nielsville QShe“ Fossion
Hash? ‘Lake ParkQgfhegd LSKB
.Barnesvil|e‘We
‘ pies.Breclrenndge Hflgiflg ,
O
T Granite Fall S. .Q|ivia
O‘Elbow Lake ,
Qfitlexandria.Sauk tre
.Me| eBenson
l'1t]‘|Vl||B 0 K3-miydqi
Wll Q.Madison I mar. Litchfig
Sleepy E§e'r>"e" Springfield. .We 51-brook. 5i. J8I"I'lB S. 9 . O
Mot La QunalngtwjLuveme ‘mom °
OQ O
RecMoodFalls. F°$'*“‘ " .Marshallj : ,
Hagirga 0 0.
0 . 5.
' 0
O . O
.
. rt ‘ on .La'§-afield . ° °°Adri@iL‘Yg‘w?a¢ksm! “£1 O31 ' ' '
Qlitephen0 Q olden
, .W9lTHri
East GrandIT River FallsForks
Q
Nielsville QShe“ Fossion
Hash? ‘Lake ParkQgfhegd LSKB
.Barnesvil|e‘We
‘ pies.Breclrenndge Hflgiflg ,
O
T Granite Fall S. .Q|ivia
O‘Elbow Lake ,
Qfitlexandria.Sauk tre
.Me| eBenson
l'1t]‘|Vl||B 0 K3-miydqi
Wll Q.Madison I mar. Litchfig
Sleepy E§e'r>"e" Springfield. .We 51-brook. 5i. J8I"I'lB S. 9 . O
Mot La QunalngtwjLuveme ‘mom °
OQ O
RecMoodFalls. F°$'*“‘ " .Marshallj : ,
Hagirga 0 0.
0 . 5.
' 0
O . O
.
. rt ‘ on .La'§-afield . ° °°Adri@iL‘Yg‘w?a¢ksm! “£1 O31 ' ' '
Renewable Energy
Minnesota Renewable Energy Standard (RES)
7% by 2010
12% by 2012
17% by 2016
20% by 2020
25% by 2025
gr-‘:1!-L‘ I.-|'l'lL|i |I||||- '|".||_ .- ll I -||'|
L I I H L ' I |
gr-‘:1!-L‘ I.-|'l'lL|i |I||||- '|".||_ .- ll I -||'|
L I I H L ' I |
Renewable Energy
Large Public Wind Power
Wapsipinicon Wind Farm (100 MW)
Rugby Wind Farm (40 MW)
Odin & Marshall (38 MW)
Wapsipinicon Wind Farm
_ _
"—_'_' .i'-—--"".f:I=
. ' 1: _
IF-I
2I F
—
-§ - —
1- - —
q
—‘M . I
_ -
.
Li
5
'1‘
Li
_ _
"—_'_' .i'-—--"".f:I=
. ' 1: _
IF-I
2I F
—
-§ - —
1- - —
q
—‘M . I
_ -
.
Li
5
'1‘
Li
Renewable Energy
Anoka
Brownton
Buffalo
Chaska
Arlington
Le Sueur
North St. Paul
Olivia
Shakopee
Winthrop
East Grand Forks
Fairmont Redwood Falls
Moorhead
Worthington
Mountain Lake
Willmar
Small Public Wind Power
Communities
Willmar Municipal Utilities wind turbine
- \- \
Renewable Energy
Municipal Hydropower Rochester
Granite Falls
Lanesboro
Redwood Falls
Thief River Falls
.'|. -I:-: _r__ _|._. _:_ I
1 filkt ' I
_.
_'._- _,.,i1-_.+IIq__-_1
" "1' 11- -___| 1-; -_ _.|II.__.
\.rn.:-I
-\.
innj---u-
.'|. -I:-: _r__ _|._. _:_ I
1 filkt ' I
_.
_'._- _,.,i1-_.+IIq__-_1
" "1' 11- -___| 1-; -_ _.|II.__.
\.rn.:-I
-\.
innj---u-
Renewable Energy
Refuse-derived Energy
Elk River
Glencoe
Fosston
Rochester
Mora
Elk River Landfill Gas Electric Generation Station
' _ 5 !__. ..-_.,_uW ; r: UH-_| -I
;|"';.___._ .5-I;l-.|__._.§‘:1 av-1
.7..-
ifi;
:-?'-fl¢;...r¢i.;,-_-.- ,,-' - r _ '.j_ .-",1-:"!"f ' .-'.J'::1':"'.?,.":"""" -F’.-"..'_.r
. . ’ " »'-'1':~*"»:a%
"Q
_\_ I.-
n
QC,-.2
‘E5’-=-*~".*-=-JL.
""I*§?
I—|.L1.
_______..___: g
.|I'_
P‘-.
11
1"
IJ—-|.€_
II"
.- .-.,[email protected]
U'l;__1- _|
II I
II
' _ 5 !__. ..-_.,_uW ; r: UH-_| -I
;|"';.___._ .5-I;l-.|__._.§‘:1 av-1
.7..-
ifi;
:-?'-fl¢;...r¢i.;,-_-.- ,,-' - r _ '.j_ .-",1-:"!"f ' .-'.J'::1':"'.?,.":"""" -F’.-"..'_.r
. . ’ " »'-'1':~*"»:a%
"Q
_\_ I.-
n
QC,-.2
‘E5’-=-*~".*-=-JL.
""I*§?
I—|.L1.
_______..___: g
.|I'_
P‘-.
11
1"
IJ—-|.€_
II"
.- .-.,[email protected]
U'l;__1- _|
II I
II
Renewable Energy
Biomass
Virginia
Hibbing
Willmar*
Le Sueur*
Willmar corn cob test stock
*in development
_-ii-__L___-ii-__L__
Renewable Energy
Biodiesel
Litchfield Diesel-Biodiesel Generator
Many publicly owned diesel-
electric generators are
advancing the biodiesel
industry by utilizing 2%-20%
biodiesel blended fuel.
|I‘NJ_|_!|rill
_J__________
I
‘IIIIfI I
f____
1_____
i___‘_h__
*2v."h_M|_
|I‘NJ_|_!|rill
_J__________
I
‘IIIIfI I
f____
1_____
i___‘_h__
*2v."h_M|_
Transmission
Municipal utilities are
“transmission-dependent”
w_H_‘__€h__________-__fl_2
TH_____IIH__Q
____fl_____p_
__ *___
5___I
_HF___-_
w_H_‘__€h__________-__fl_2
TH_____IIH__Q
____fl_____p_
__ *___
5___I
_HF___-_
Local Regulation –
Local Accountability
City of Blooming Prairie
Public Utilities Commissioner
Utility General Manager
City Councilperson
Mayor
Public Utilities Commissioner
Public Utilities Commissioner
Public Utilities Commissioner
*______L \\\_____J‘
_)_r_l'___
__
__
_______
__i
fii‘
I__
_-_____ ________“_______
______I"_H_rl___
___‘___?
“____/__q_E_I1_l_|I_'_r_J"_q__H Ph_I_____ _D___LiIi___|_
I1
%_a‘H
|£8-____"q_
__I_____
I_J
1Qk
___“.MW"HIII'1':_
_
_____‘_
_ ||In___’?_
_____J
1‘___ ___!______"LE"_____
I In"___‘-__"___‘_
I
_*—_r____%_
‘_I-M‘
fin
_'_“"__ __“_____
_'_
_L|'
I _I_~____“Ir_HL_w_"Hb_“
_l|_ _______
_'@_‘|_
_______
G‘___“
_ _'1‘l_
I‘KiJ_
_gm
I__W_“__d_*_w‘_
I
___6____‘
__i
*______L \\\_____J‘
_)_r_l'___
__
__
_______
__i
fii‘
I__
_-_____ ________“_______
______I"_H_rl___
___‘___?
“____/__q_E_I1_l_|I_'_r_J"_q__H Ph_I_____ _D___LiIi___|_
I1
%_a‘H
|£8-____"q_
__I_____
I_J
1Qk
___“.MW"HIII'1':_
_
_____‘_
_ ||In___’?_
_____J
1‘___ ___!______"LE"_____
I In"___‘-__"___‘_
I
_*—_r____%_
‘_I-M‘
fin
_'_“"__ __“_____
_'_
_L|'
I _I_~____“Ir_HL_w_"Hb_“
_l|_ _______
_'@_‘|_
_______
G‘___“
_ _'1‘l_
I‘KiJ_
_gm
I__W_“__d_*_w‘_
I
___6____‘
__i
Governed by Minnesota laws
and regulations
Conservation Improvement Program (CIP)
Renewable wholesale power (RES)
Cold Weather Rule
Facility siting
Service territory
Open meetings
Data practices
Energy Efficiency & Conservation
Project Conserve (Elk River)
Home Energy Reports (Owatonna & Austin)
Energy Efficiency Improvement Loans (Marshall)
Neighborhood Energy Challenge (Rochester)
Griffin Project (Ely)
Workforce Development
Homegrown Talent
Lineworker training
Supervisor training
Natural gas system training
__xL
____
|_ liuili __II||____:__l__I_
|_ _____-__.__‘__h__A
Jr5I?
‘__ _L_
____‘___¢L‘LI_I_H]___I{‘II
i_—H’________ if____‘___|$_"_J I§mJ __‘%_HIMF__ V E_
1I
___
‘__ _'____.il_“_
H
_I _A1
IE“!___|_ |_
L _Qiit
___‘Rgdhm
;_J_________
\ ‘J____IEL‘_H
_'|Irm-_‘______‘_ 1
______
r
OI_
____|
__|___
It_fl_
__|_E_
1*3_
tl
__xL
____
|_ liuili __II||____:__l__I_
|_ _____-__.__‘__h__A
Jr5I?
‘__ _L_
____‘___¢L‘LI_I_H]___I{‘II
i_—H’________ if____‘___|$_"_J I§mJ __‘%_HIMF__ V E_
1I
___
‘__ _'____.il_“_
H
_I _A1
IE“!___|_ |_
L _Qiit
___‘Rgdhm
;_J_________
\ ‘J____IEL‘_H
_'|Irm-_‘______‘_ 1
______
r
OI_
____|
__|___
It_fl_
__|_E_
1*3_
tl
Workforce Development
MMUA Training Center – Marshall, MN
"' “ —--uniiii “I; 1 ‘I’ ‘II i Ii.-
,,,,—'——-
4- 4* __"'_l ._J'. '.1_:-!¢ i?
J.
‘Fl?
- -I‘
' ' ' * ~11" ii-‘IT 5 . _'3
*3
‘=-*—~—-‘L-
i
"III "--\_'F-
"--III~
-F*_ -E‘--Ii-I1-"'!‘|
_ I. #11:‘; - - I|_ ll. I '
1I-_-
11' —*-*11-u.
'|—'1
.|-“FIG-"I"_-I _ ‘1:I1 '
I. 1- -- |r |'
."i'l"- '5-'7'. .1 . 1. _1l'~|I-.-1T".
I .-, . 1
‘ -1*".-'-1' ., --.r.._‘
-lI=-""'“"1=‘"- "-_‘—_‘—_.:=
jlfiir 1-_
1' . .-. -.
I J‘ _""'?—n- _ _ 1
-i
If.i _ _ J _ F J '.Ep- l
| L-‘___ _ _ ‘_ __ :'JF_ _ T ' _|_ “ \ "' ' u---!!-"' ___ "'
u .|- ,_
I I1 | -n.
-I ‘I |.
3.‘,-___#~
1~.-
_4.- __¢—'
M ‘___ __ _ _-'-
J ___' "_ __-- -J --
-' _|—" - _-:- -
I_ in. ,1,“ __ _- ,- +- ".~-".‘1=‘=.;-_=- . '- _ _
' -""" '1- -- H‘--.-1-_ , '. _ '- -'1§,,_|.‘,= ‘ 2-I?‘-.1. "Pk-_ '- ._
1" I4‘ RF F "
':h'._ - ,I ._ "_‘ . ' F_ | | n- ' Q‘ ‘I _ J I. 1, _ I _ I". I
- L - ‘ .1-' ' .- 1- '=---3. -r.-;. ,
I"
"' “ —--uniiii “I; 1 ‘I’ ‘II i Ii.-
,,,,—'——-
4- 4* __"'_l ._J'. '.1_:-!¢ i?
J.
‘Fl?
- -I‘
' ' ' * ~11" ii-‘IT 5 . _'3
*3
‘=-*—~—-‘L-
i
"III "--\_'F-
"--III~
-F*_ -E‘--Ii-I1-"'!‘|
_ I. #11:‘; - - I|_ ll. I '
1I-_-
11' —*-*11-u.
'|—'1
.|-“FIG-"I"_-I _ ‘1:I1 '
I. 1- -- |r |'
."i'l"- '5-'7'. .1 . 1. _1l'~|I-.-1T".
I .-, . 1
‘ -1*".-'-1' ., --.r.._‘
-lI=-""'“"1=‘"- "-_‘—_‘—_.:=
jlfiir 1-_
1' . .-. -.
I J‘ _""'?—n- _ _ 1
-i
If.i _ _ J _ F J '.Ep- l
| L-‘___ _ _ ‘_ __ :'JF_ _ T ' _|_ “ \ "' ' u---!!-"' ___ "'
u .|- ,_
I I1 | -n.
-I ‘I |.
3.‘,-___#~
1~.-
_4.- __¢—'
M ‘___ __ _ _-'-
J ___' "_ __-- -J --
-' _|—" - _-:- -
I_ in. ,1,“ __ _- ,- +- ".~-".‘1=‘=.;-_=- . '- _ _
' -""" '1- -- H‘--.-1-_ , '. _ '- -'1§,,_|.‘,= ‘ 2-I?‘-.1. "Pk-_ '- ._
1" I4‘ RF F "
':h'._ - ,I ._ "_‘ . ' F_ | | n- ' Q‘ ‘I _ J I. 1, _ I _ I". I
- L - ‘ .1-' ' .- 1- '=---3. -r.-;. ,
I"
Disaster Assistance
East Grand Forks Flood of 1997
St. Peter Tornado of 1998
Granite Falls Tornado of 2000
Roseau Flood of 2002
Rushford Flood of 2007
Wadena Tornado of 2010
Hurricane Sandy of 2012
Wadena, 2010
1- .-- _4";-
-- - -' ...- ._>-' _~ -';;_;.f_~_ ' ' , - 4-1‘, --. -- .,___1' . - :_-I -‘.-
1 P -J
.- -',‘I". 1‘
'I
,__
.""'q'I -": 1.;--' ",. -"__-3;. - 4:;_,.‘__;-.|;. I-L--;;,. _ — —-—__--j_
l ‘Ii J.'IJI
-I
fir _.--_ . |-_\q--u
.-1I1'I'v:-nT_u'j'.|r'.'rv| .~\
I-rum. - ' .'
I
Z‘
'1.uI— ..-.11;
-iv? r1— —
I./..—-._-u-
.- .-—'1$
I‘:-I--L
-".-n
-. |_fr_ _ .- -v_\
'1
nllrnllu II‘
-'-V.
"\I--.-' (_
'.-.1:
Si"ii.-
‘u.
4.1.11-111-11-1....
.-..-.\-'_-
»-
?*, :2"-"'5,.1:'--\_
*..
‘u
._ u..
"“"'-I-1u»._.__.
:_1. -.
-4. _I ___ ""'-‘-In...._,
\_; ' " " ‘ --'- --' -1»:--'¢:*.._:f~‘-3?-T? I. ~ lg-$1; ‘-M-géz-- P 5,1; "‘,-as
_..--*‘f"°'j*.-»-
at_
-— _-1.. ‘d.
%
JIF‘
- 'fI, ‘__~L1-*5‘-Y‘. ~ ‘i _ Q‘1 - I_‘ N. t I. _j-n.;- ---E-“‘*
- ‘- 4 5
T
‘xE....-___._..._..
\-___ '?--"fie-:=-~
" H-“.-\-- -'',‘:'_""L’-'4-_?‘R.’-'¢ It?_
\1“\-|.,_ 1- I} '-|"',I' -.. 1av - .. -<- -_-‘ .- .-u%‘ '5
\_ .1":-1! --. Q-
. :"";.~‘=:-~.. -.
‘ '_1IIIII'.l#:I-II|\-in-iulflnr
'-
1- .-- _4";-
-- - -' ...- ._>-' _~ -';;_;.f_~_ ' ' , - 4-1‘, --. -- .,___1' . - :_-I -‘.-
1 P -J
.- -',‘I". 1‘
'I
,__
.""'q'I -": 1.;--' ",. -"__-3;. - 4:;_,.‘__;-.|;. I-L--;;,. _ — —-—__--j_
l ‘Ii J.'IJI
-I
fir _.--_ . |-_\q--u
.-1I1'I'v:-nT_u'j'.|r'.'rv| .~\
I-rum. - ' .'
I
Z‘
'1.uI— ..-.11;
-iv? r1— —
I./..—-._-u-
.- .-—'1$
I‘:-I--L
-".-n
-. |_fr_ _ .- -v_\
'1
nllrnllu II‘
-'-V.
"\I--.-' (_
'.-.1:
Si"ii.-
‘u.
4.1.11-111-11-1....
.-..-.\-'_-
»-
?*, :2"-"'5,.1:'--\_
*..
‘u
._ u..
"“"'-I-1u»._.__.
:_1. -.
-4. _I ___ ""'-‘-In...._,
\_; ' " " ‘ --'- --' -1»:--'¢:*.._:f~‘-3?-T? I. ~ lg-$1; ‘-M-géz-- P 5,1; "‘,-as
_..--*‘f"°'j*.-»-
at_
-— _-1.. ‘d.
%
JIF‘
- 'fI, ‘__~L1-*5‘-Y‘. ~ ‘i _ Q‘1 - I_‘ N. t I. _j-n.;- ---E-“‘*
- ‘- 4 5
T
‘xE....-___._..._..
\-___ '?--"fie-:=-~
" H-“.-\-- -'',‘:'_""L’-'4-_?‘R.’-'¢ It?_
\1“\-|.,_ 1- I} '-|"',I' -.. 1av - .. -<- -_-‘ .- .-u%‘ '5
\_ .1":-1! --. Q-
. :"";.~‘=:-~.. -.
‘ '_1IIIII'.l#:I-II|\-in-iulflnr
'-
Helping Cities to Grow Wisely
Partnering for business and residential development
_
J___
_‘________‘_@1____%
____I___-ll___R_
______________:
_'__f_‘f__
__§_____ __‘tI__
__?__ _____________:“___‘In__T_______?__fi_fl‘?|_____m______-H________I’_______‘___£_A I___fi_,__1}‘
_:____I‘__
l__FI__I T&_,fi________ _r___m____________T____;r______\]WII5____h_V_A_I__}___XF_U____ _'___k___{________“__I ___ ‘Q_ __ __J
_U11;}__ ____ ‘_\_______H_“____
_ I___’_____f____”__*
________
I__
I;_
_ In
‘___
______
__________‘___CL
____
"__M__
L___qt”i___iL
_M‘_ __‘__
_
___7x
_____
__‘__
___
_____‘__
HII
_________-__
___‘_____
_ _____
___
_____
______’___
___J___ ___ _‘
g_______
__I___
______,_____%___I’___Iw_III1|_I1"_
___
;_______
I__
__H“)_i_|_
_I___,____“H__
_‘‘_-
I-q
______________________
__a___"__L
__
__
_ __________J_'___
__‘_Ik_
___"w___.__'
_%&
_
J___
_‘________‘_@1____%
____I___-ll___R_
______________:
_'__f_‘f__
__§_____ __‘tI__
__?__ _____________:“___‘In__T_______?__fi_fl‘?|_____m______-H________I’_______‘___£_A I___fi_,__1}‘
_:____I‘__
l__FI__I T&_,fi________ _r___m____________T____;r______\]WII5____h_V_A_I__}___XF_U____ _'___k___{________“__I ___ ‘Q_ __ __J
_U11;}__ ____ ‘_\_______H_“____
_ I___’_____f____”__*
________
I__
I;_
_ In
‘___
______
__________‘___CL
____
"__M__
L___qt”i___iL
_M‘_ __‘__
_
___7x
_____
__‘__
___
_____‘__
HII
_________-__
___‘_____
_ _____
___
_____
______’___
___J___ ___ _‘
g_______
__I___
______,_____%___I’___Iw_III1|_I1"_
___
;_______
I__
__H“)_i_|_
_I___,____“H__
_‘‘_-
I-q
______________________
__a___"__L
__
__
_ __________J_'___
__‘_Ik_
___"w___.__'
_%&
Local Service
K.’
W ‘"1. 1!?‘ .
Working for you to build a better community-Buffalo Municipal UIHTIFES
K.’
W ‘"1. 1!?‘ .
Working for you to build a better community-Buffalo Municipal UIHTIFES
Community Pride
Litchfield
1-|' ' .
"I
I--._,r'
1'1-i I I- - |_
. '1' I" I..‘_.;-__-.|
la.T
._ ‘E51% iF I__ i::q-
_-1
. I.—"" -1- ' I. ' _ - ." j
'_. .‘_ r __ .,|-ill‘ -.1: _ ‘I I.
-...=-u- -1'-.1i' -..... - .- 11a.‘-_1‘?'-" --1": .
I!‘
1-
1-|' ' .
"I
I--._,r'
1'1-i I I- - |_
. '1' I" I..‘_.;-__-.|
la.T
._ ‘E51% iF I__ i::q-
_-1
. I.—"" -1- ' I. ' _ - ." j
'_. .‘_ r __ .,|-ill‘ -.1: _ ‘I I.
-...=-u- -1'-.1i' -..... - .- 11a.‘-_1‘?'-" --1": .
I!‘
1-
Tradition
Owatonna Municipal Power Plant
More than 60 cities in Minnesota are served today by a municipal electric
utility founded over 100 years ago.
Photo courtesy of the Owatonna People’s Press
V §‘ _ it;'.J__ *m§Q;
7%§wu ,‘¥q;i
H
‘Iski ' I. I 3
‘Ea-qé‘
“'5 Iq .- . #1: §~qh._ __ nut“
§
— '?;_l:--.g-.1 ‘xxx, "\
A R‘\ ‘% A
. '- I ,..--Iv \"‘\-. . _.__I.'.".-1.‘ 1 N -\\ '1‘\u§,“1§= \\\;\\ Vi. ,_;5\ ,3‘ \\~.
Lif ‘\.#;~_\
*’d*-
-1_"!."""-"""
.3. .. ‘KM:-._ ‘l‘,$;\..;‘|J|
2??"
.. - '~i_.'3_-__-.1‘ - =-1|f‘g";=\'=_‘-;' __ '
ll? GK.1
V §‘ _ it;'.J__ *m§Q;
7%§wu ,‘¥q;i
H
‘Iski ' I. I 3
‘Ea-qé‘
“'5 Iq .- . #1: §~qh._ __ nut“
§
— '?;_l:--.g-.1 ‘xxx, "\
A R‘\ ‘% A
. '- I ,..--Iv \"‘\-. . _.__I.'.".-1.‘ 1 N -\\ '1‘\u§,“1§= \\\;\\ Vi. ,_;5\ ,3‘ \\~.
Lif ‘\.#;~_\
*’d*-
-1_"!."""-"""
.3. .. ‘KM:-._ ‘l‘,$;\..;‘|J|
2??"
.. - '~i_.'3_-__-.1‘ - =-1|f‘g";=\'=_‘-;' __ '
ll? GK.1
Municipal Electric Utilities
in Minnesota
Presented by
Minnesota Municipal Utilities Association