national housing federation case study - discourse analysis

10
Chloe Hardy – Head of Campaigns Understanding the Conservatives through their language

Upload: ncvo-the-national-council-for-voluntary-organisations

Post on 05-Dec-2014

1.480 views

Category:

Technology


2 download

DESCRIPTION

Chloe Hardy, Head of

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: National Housing Federation case study - discourse analysis

Chloe Hardy – Head of Campaigns

Understanding the Conservatives through their

language

Page 2: National Housing Federation case study - discourse analysis
Page 3: National Housing Federation case study - discourse analysis

Responsibility

Judgement

Opportunity

Social mobility

Civility

Neighbourhood pride

Social Progress

X Broken Society

X Welfare Dependence

Conservative Party Terms

Page 4: National Housing Federation case study - discourse analysis

X Calcifying

Conservative Party Terms: Social Housing

Dependency

Deprivation

Disadvantage

Inflexibility

Negative impact

Locked

XXXXXX

Choice

Aspirations

Right to move

Flexibility

Rewards

Exit Opportunity

Page 5: National Housing Federation case study - discourse analysis

Federation Discourse

• Reach potential

• Affordable homes

• Support independence

• Cohesive communities

• Marginalised / vulnerable people

• Compounding poverty

• Mixed communities

• Need / range of needs

• Regeneration

• Social exclusion

• ‘Specialist support’

• ‘Social investment’

• ‘A place for everyone’

• ‘Meeting local needs’

• ‘Tailored to individuals’

Page 6: National Housing Federation case study - discourse analysis

Dissonance

• Different terms, same apparent meaning• Same term, different meaning• Different terms, different values• Terms with difficult associations

Page 7: National Housing Federation case study - discourse analysis

Options

• Do nothing• Shift emphasis• Adopt concepts that resonate• Unpack ideas

Page 8: National Housing Federation case study - discourse analysis

Discourse analysis on a shoestring

• Speeches, manifesto, policy docs, think pieces• A few colleagues• Post-it notes

Page 9: National Housing Federation case study - discourse analysis

Discourse analysis on a shoestring

• Divide the material• Ask people to highlight words/phrases/ideas that

are repeated• Write onto post-its• Work to together to group post-its• Discuss as you go

Page 10: National Housing Federation case study - discourse analysis

Discourse analysis on a shoestring

• Are there words/concepts you share?• Are there concepts you share but describe

differently?• Are words you share but mean different things?• Are there concepts which they use and you

don’t?