national utility rate database - illinois state...badriram rajagopalan oj rdan thompson student...

32
National Utility Rate Database National Utility Rate Database 1

Upload: others

Post on 21-May-2021

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

National Utility Rate DatabaseNational Utility Rate Database

1

Page 2: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Illinois State Universityy

National Database of Utility Rates and Rate Structure

David G. Loomis, Ph.D.David G. Loomis, Ph.D.Executive Director, Institute for Regulatory Policy Studies

Director, Center for Renewable EnergyProfessor of Economics, Illinois State University, y

Illinois State University 2

Page 3: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

ROWChina & TaiwanEuropeJapanU.S.U.S. Share

Our Sputnik Moment

Sources: PV News (2/1993, 3/2001, 3/2006) and Navigant Consulting (2/2011)

PV

Module

Ship

ments (M

W)

U.S

. Mar

ket

Shar

e

1990 2000 2010*

1995: 43%

2000: 27%

2010: 7%

38

Page 4: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

“We’re telling America’s scientists and engineers that if

they assemble teams of the best minds in their fields, and

focus on the hardest problems in clean energy, we’ll fund

the Apollo projects of our time.” .

- President Obama

2011 State of the Union

39

Page 5: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

JFK’s Challenge America’s Response

1960’s Moon Shot

40

Page 6: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

SunShot is

the Apollo Mission of Our Time

41

Page 7: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Goal: Cost- Competitive Solar

without subsidy

=

Page 8: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

75% Cost Reduction

by the End of the Decade

43

Page 9: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Module Price Decreases

Source: Mints, P. (2011). Photovoltaic Manufacturer Shipments, Capacity, & Competitive Analysis 20010/2011.

Report # NPS-Supply6. Palo Alto, CA: Navigant Consulting Photovoltaic Service Program. 44

$0

$4

$8

$12

$16

$20

$24

1980 1988 1996 2004 2012

Avg M

od

ule

Pri

ce

(C

urr

ent

and 2

009 $

/ W)

2009/Real $/W

Page 10: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Down the Solar Learning Curve

Source: Mints, P. (2011). Photovoltaic Manufacturer Shipments, Capacity, & Competitive Analysis 20010/2011.

Report # NPS-Supply6. Palo Alto, CA: Navigant Consulting Photovoltaic Service Program.

$1

$10

$100

0.1 1. 10. 100. 1,000. 10,000. 100,000.

Glo

bal A

vg M

od

ule

Pri

ce

(2009 $

/W)

Cumulative PV Module Shipments (MW)

45

Page 11: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

You are helping reduce Soft Costs.

Page 12: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

~$6.50

~$5.50

~$4.00

$0

$1

$2

$3

$4

$5

$6

$7

Residential Commercial Utility

PV

Syst

em

Pri

ce /

WD

C

2010 PV System Prices

BOS-non-hardwareBOS-hardwarePower electronicsModule

Balance of Systems - Soft Costs

47

Page 13: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

WV

MD

NJ

CT

RI

MA

FL FL

VT VT NH NH

2030 Utility Scale PV with SunShot

OR

ID

NV

MT ND

SD

NE

WY

UT

NM AR

MS

AZ SC

OK

KS

ME

DE

WA

CA CO

TX

MO

IL

IA

MN

WI

MI

OH

KY

TN

AL GA

VA

NY

PA

LA

NC

IN

Installed PV (GW)

< 0.1

0.1 - 1

1 - 5

5 - 10

10 - 20

20 - 30

> 30

OR

ID

NV

MT ND

SD

NE

WY

UT

NM AR

MS

AZ SC

OK

KS

ME

WV

WA

CA CO

TX

MO

IL

IA

MN

WI

MI

OH

KY

TN

AL GA

VA

NY

PA

LA

MD

NC

IN

CT

RI

NJ

MA

DE

Page 14: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

15-18% of America’s Electricity

from Solar by 2030.

49

Page 15: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Outline

Institute for Regulatory Policy Studiesg y y Key Personnel Introductions Goals Goals Database Population Timelines Public Budget Informationg Closing

Illinois State University 3

Page 16: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Institute for Regulatory Policy Studies

Created in 1997, the Institute is housed within the

g y y

Department of Economics in the College of Arts and Sciences at Illinois State University.

The Institute serves the regulatory community with education, communication, and research on policy issues p yof interest to consumers, regulators, and utilities in Illinois and throughout the nation.

The Institute supports the Master’s Degree Program in Applied Economics with a sequence in Electricity, Natural pp q yGas, and Telecommunications Economics.

Illinois State University 4

Page 17: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Key Personnel Introductions

ISU Business Point of Contact - Janet Goucher

y

ISU Information Technology Sarah Walczynski Badriram Rajagopalan Jordan Thompson Student Programmers

ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant to Executive Director Alexander Echele – Graduate Student – Research

Associate Research Assistants – undergraduate students

Illinois State University 5

Page 18: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Goals

Create systems and materials necessary to populate a comprehensive and reliable database of utility rates and rate structures.C f d l h Create user interfaces and materials that are most appropriate to different user groups.

P l t d k t th d t b f tilit t d Populate and keep current the database of utility rates and rate structures with proper quality control measures.

Publicize the database and demonstrate its usefulness at solar Publicize the database and demonstrate its usefulness at solar industry events, through social media, and via other means as appropriate.pp p

Plan to maintain database for at least 5 years after grant funding ends.

Illinois State University 6

Page 19: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Database Populationp

Illinois State University 7

Page 20: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Database Population 2p

Illinois State University 8

Page 21: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Database Population 3p

Illinois State University 9

Page 22: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

en.OpenEI.org

Page 23: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

OpenEI Electric Utility Rates

Page 24: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Utility Rate Basic Information

Page 25: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Demand Charges

Page 26: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Energy Charges 1

Page 27: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Energy Charges 2

Page 28: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Timelines –Year 1 Year 1

Activity Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4Activity Q1 Q2 Q3 Q41. Design compatible database structure2. Design back-end interface3. Design training materials End of Q2 Milestone: Systems and materials necessary to populate a comprehensive and reliable database of utilitypopulate a comprehensive and reliable database of utility rates and rate structure are ready to begin populating databaseGo/No Go Criteria: Is database, back-end interface and training materials sufficient to cover all different types of rate structures? If yes continue project If no discontinue orrate structures? If yes, continue project. If no, discontinue or redesign.

Illinois State University 10

Page 29: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Timelines –Year 1 (cont’d)Year 1

Activity Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4

( )

4. Design user interface5. Design user manual 6 Train associates and assistants6. Train associates and assistants7. Populate database8. Quality control and rate changes9. Publicize databaseEnd of Q3 Milestone: 386 utilities completed in databaseEnd of Q4 Milestone: User interfaces and manual ready; 773 yutilities completed; Database presented at two solar events and over social media.Go/No Go Criteria: Are user interfaces and manual sufficient forGo/No Go Criteria: Are user interfaces and manual sufficient for all user types?If yes, continue project.If di ti d iIf no, discontinue or redesign.

Illinois State University 11

Page 30: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Timelines –Year 2Year 2

Activity Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4y

1. Populate database2 Q lit t l d t h2. Quality control and rate changes3. Publicize databaseEnd of Q1 Milestone: 1,159 utilities completed in databaseEnd of Q2 Milestone: 1,545 utilities completed in databaseEnd of Q3 Milestone: 1,932 utilities completed in databaseE d f Q4 Mil t 2 318 tiliti l t d D t bEnd of Q4 Milestone: 2,318 utilities completed; Database presented at two solar events and over social media.Go/No Go Criteria: Were a sufficient number of utilities completed in the database?If yes, continue.If no discontinue or modify collection methodIf no, discontinue or modify collection method.

Illinois State University 12

Page 31: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Timelines –Year 3Year 3

Activity Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4Activity Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4

1 Populate database1. Populate database

2. Quality control and rate changes

3 P bli i d t b3. Publicize database

End of Q1 Milestone: 2,704 utilities completed in database

End of Q2 Milestone: 3,090 utilities completed in database

End of Q3 Milestone: 3,476 utilities completed in database

End of Q4 Milestone: 3,863 utilities completed; Database presented at two solar events and over social media.

Illinois State University 13

Page 32: National Utility Rate Database - Illinois State...Badriram Rajagopalan oJ rdan Thompson Student Programmers ISU Economics Nick Bowden – IRPS Staff Adrienne Hahn – IRPS Assistant

Closingg

Dr. David G. LoomisIllinois State UniversityIllinois State University

Campus Box 4200N l IL 61761Normal, IL 61761

[email protected]

Illinois State University 14