negative list final - bharat petroleum sfk · - marks given by individual committee members/ lpg is...
TRANSCRIPT
Marketing
1 Dealer / Distribhtor selection
- Financial / Bank / Pan details/Income tax return
- Land details/ property details
- Field Verification of Credentials report
- Marks given by individual Committee Members/ LPG is draw system
No details if applications under scrutiny and selection process not completed 8(1) (h)
2 No details if the applicant has not applied
3 Copy of Letter of Intent
4 Copy of letter of appointment
5 Dealer / Distributor Agreement Copy
6 Sales figures of individual dealers/distributors
7 Commercial cylinder sales
8 Dealer / Distributor / COCO Operator earnings / Outstandings
9 Staff details of dealers / distributors
10 Location details of LPG Godowns, LPG Plants, Oil installations and Refinery
11 Bids / Tender documents of third party
12 Technical specifications of products
13 Any matter which is sub-judice/ Matter is in Arbitration
14 Technical and administrative approvals
15 Address / phone no. of employees other than field staff in any form/ NO residence address of
proprietor of the distributorship. 8 (1) (j)
16 Internal estimates of any tender & cost of operating Company tank lorries
17 Details on pipeline routes
No information on Hypothetical situation/Opinion sought of PIO
voluminous information disproportionately engaging resourse and time
Numerous Multiple Unrelated Questions
No information on RTI Application Sent on Stamped Paper / Court Fee Affixed
Lease/rental details paid to Land lords 8 (1) (j)
20 An information which will affect the safety and security of LPG Bottling Plant
Negative list
(Information which will not be disclosed to the RTI applicant as per section 8 (1) of RTI Act)
Finance
1 Price built up of free products except HSD, LPG & SKO
2 Details of bank borrowings and rate of interest
3 Internal audit reports
4 Details of court cases
5 Vednor payment details
6 discounts/ Margins offered to customers
HR
1 Medical reports of the employees
2 Nomination made by employee for PF/Gratuity etc.
3 Performance Appraisal Reports of the employees
4 Vigilance investigation reports
5 Opinions sought by Advocates/Consultants/other experts etc.
Refinery
1 Bids / Tender documents of third party
2 Technical and administrative approvals
3 Drawings and layout plans
4 Operational Manuals, Project Operational Parameters, Plant Operation Log-books & sheets
5 FR, DPR & other studies
6 Evaluation Reports
7 Information related to Research & Analysis
8 Ongoing Contracts with Confidentiality Clauses
9 Price and agreement details for crude procurement
10 Any details of Security Arrangement
11 Details on land acquisition and PAP
Others
1 Board and Sub-Committee Agenda & Minutes
Explaination
2 (f) :2 (f) :2 (f) :2 (f) : eliciting opinion from CPIO no information asked
Section 6(1) : Section 6(1) : Section 6(1) : Section 6(1) : Prescribed fees not enclosed
Section 7(9)Section 7(9)Section 7(9)Section 7(9)
An information shall ordinarily be provided in the form in which it is sought unless it would disproportionately divert the resources
of the public authority or would be detrimental to the safety or preservation of the record in question.
Section 8(1) a,b,cSection 8(1) a,b,cSection 8(1) a,b,cSection 8(1) a,b,c
a. National Security - If disclosure would affect the sovereignty and integrity of India
b. Contempt of Court - If disclosure forbidden by a court/tribunal
c. Parliamentary Privilege - If disclosure would cause breach of privilege of Parliament/State Legislature
Section 8(1) d Section 8(1) d Section 8(1) d Section 8(1) d
Trade Secrecy / Commercial Confidence - information including commercial confidence, trade secrets or intellectual property, the
disclosure of which would harm the competitive position of a third party, unless the competent authority is satisfied that larger
public interest warrants the disclosure of such information;
Section 8(1) (e)Section 8(1) (e)Section 8(1) (e)Section 8(1) (e)
Fiduciary relationship - information available to a person in his fiduciary relationship, unless the competent authority is satisfied
that the larger public interest warrants the disclosure of such information.
What is ‘Fiduciary’ relationship ? ‘fiduciary’ is derived from Latin word ‘fiducia’(trust). Fiduciary Relationship exists between: Lawyer and Client, b) Doctor and Patient, c) Bank and Customer, d) Trustee and Beneficiary, e) Organisation and Reporting
Officer in respect of CR of an Employee
Section 8(1) (f),(g),(h),(i )Section 8(1) (f),(g),(h),(i )Section 8(1) (f),(g),(h),(i )Section 8(1) (f),(g),(h),(i )
(f) Foreign government - Information received in confidence from foreign Govt.
(g) Safety of informer in law enforcement - If disclosure would endanger life or physical safety or identify source of information or
assistance given in confidence
(h)Investigation - if disclosure would impede process of investigation
(i) Cabinet papers - Cabinet papers including records of deliberations of Council of Ministers/ Secretaries/other officers
Section 8(1) (j) & 9Section 8(1) (j) & 9Section 8(1) (j) & 9Section 8(1) (j) & 9(j) Privacy - information which relates to personal information the disclosure of which has no relationship to any public activity or
interest, or which would cause unwarranted invasion of the privacy of the individual unless the PIO is satisfied that the larger
public interest justifies the disclosure of such information
Section 9 - In case of infringement of copyright subsisting in a person other than the State
Clause
8 (1) (j)
8 (1) (j)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (d)
No public interest at large
8 (1) (e)
8 (1) (e)
8 (1) (e)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (j)
Not held by us
8 (1) (a)
8 (1) (j)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (h)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (a)
7(9)
6(1)
6(1)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (a)
(Information which will not be disclosed to the RTI applicant as per section 8 (1) of RTI Act)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (h)
8 (1) (j)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (j)
8 (1) (j)
8 (1) (j)
8 (1) (h)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (j)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (a)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (d)
8 (1) (j)
8 (1) (d)
