new technologies and equipment 2015 - uc cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastorefiles/234-2824.pdf ·...

28
3/18/2015 1 New Technologies and Equipment 2015 Deirdre Holcroft Holcroft Postharvest Consulting [email protected] Produce Marketing Association: 5 DISRUPTIVE TECHNOLOGIES IN THE FRESH PRODUCE INDUSTRY 1. Nanotechnology 2. Sensors and realtime monitoring 3. Filtration 4. DNA fingerprinting 5. Big data http://www.pma.com/system/files/Ideas_Paper5_Disruptive_Technologies_in_the_Fresh_Produce_Industry.pdf Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Upload: haphuc

Post on 18-May-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

1

New Technologies and Equipment2015

Deirdre Holcroft

Holcroft Postharvest Consulting

[email protected]

Produce Marketing Association:5 DISRUPTIVE TECHNOLOGIES IN THE FRESH PRODUCE INDUSTRY

1. Nanotechnology

2. Sensors and real‐time monitoring

3. Filtration

4. DNA fingerprinting

5. Big data

http://www.pma.com/system/files/Ideas_Paper‐5_Disruptive_Technologies_in_the_Fresh_Produce_Industry.pdf

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 2: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

2

Why is sensing

so important?

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 3: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

3

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 4: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

4

Topics

1. Temperature sensing

2. Ethylene sensing 

3. Ethylene control

4. Ripening  and sensing

5. Decay or quality sensing

Temperature Sensing

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 5: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

5

Post Mortem versus Real Time

Data from Intellipur  www.intellipur.com

Power Off  16 hours of temp 

abuse!

Power Off 16 hours of temp abuse!Reached 4.8°C

Power Off 7 hours of temp 

abuse!

Post Mortem versus Real Time

Data from Intellipur  www.intellipur.com

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 6: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

6

Real Time Tracking Systems

Post‐harvest Handling: Temperature

Science

ManagementTechnology

Response to data

Postharvest principles

Measuring and recording data

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 7: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

7

Typical Ethylene Concentrations

Rural: < 5ppb

Urban: <50 ppb

Heavy traffic: <1000 ppb1 ppm 

= 1 sec in 11.5 days

1 ppb = 1 sec in nearly 32 years 

Typical Ethylene Concentrations

DC: <13 ppmRetail: <2 ppm

Processor: < 133 ppm

Flower coolers: 

13 ppm

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 8: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

8

With apples: 200 ppb

Without apples: 29 ppb

Cold storage (apples + pears): <30 ppm

CA storage: <250 ppm

Typical Ethylene Concentrations

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 9: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

9

Ethylene Effects on Shelf Life

Product Temp (°C)

Shelf life (days)

100 ppb <5 ppb

Butter lettuce 5 6 7

Green beans 0 14 20

Orange 2.5 80 130

Strawberry 0 4 10

Broccoli 5 14 35

Wills et al.,  1999.

19‐147% increase in shelf 

life

Ethylene Sensing

Gold Std Prices from 2014

Equipment Manufacturer/ Supplier PriceDetection limit 

(ppb; nL/L)Response time

Kitagawa pump & tubes Kitagawa $395 ($64 tubes) 100 ppb 2 ‐10 min

Sensidyne Sensor & tubes Sensidyne $435 ($78 tubes) 100 ppb

Gasman CEA Instruments $616  100 ppb  90% in 20 sec

Dräger Pac 7000 Dräger $875 1000 ppb

Ethylene sensor with display  North East Postharvest $1,550 1000 ppb 140 sec

Detcon Model DM‐700‐C2H4 Detcon $1,065‐1,955 500 ppb  140 sec

ICA515E or ICA 56 ICA $1290 or  $1,540 200 ppb 90% in 60 sec

4000 Series  Interscan $2,365‐2,500 50 ppb to 20 ppm

 LD series  Interscan $3,810‐4,805 50 ppb to 20 ppm

 F‐900 or  CID‐900  Felix Instruments $6,700 10 ppb <3 min

Explorer (portable GC) Photovac, Inc. $25,000 100 ppb 1‐4 min

LGR Los Gatos Research  $27,000   1 ppb 1 second data rate 

EDT 300 (Sensor Sense) Sensor Sense B.V. $40,000 0.3 ppb 5 sec

Ultraportable Greenhouse Gas Analyzer Los Gatos Research  >$30,000 100 ppb 

Tiger‐I 2000 C2H4 Tiger Optics ? 1 ppb 80% in 2 min

G2106 Picarro Picarro $52,500  0.2 ppb 5 sec/5 min

Gas chromatograph Many manufacturers $14,000‐ $50,000 5 to 100 ppb  4‐10 mins

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 10: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

10

Highly sensitive ethylene detector for on line 

measurements of biological samples

Photo acoustic method

ETD‐300 SensorSense Ethylene detector

ETD‐300 ethylene detector

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 11: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

11

control mock 1x Bc 1x

User friendly software data displayed in real‐time

Control

Mock infection

Infected with Botrytis 1x

Infected with Botrytis 2x

Infected with Botrytis 3x

ppb/v

1500 ppb

www.sensor‐sense.nl

Units: ppb/v or nL/h15 ppb

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 12: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

12

Ethylene Monitoring Using Cavity Ring‐Down Spectroscopy ‐ Picarro

Laser based optical absorption spectroscopy

Cavity Ring‐Down Spectroscopy versus Gas Chromatography (Dr Adel Kader at UC Davis)

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 13: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

13

CRDS Kiwifruit Cold Storage Monitoring

Kiwifruit stored with Asian pears until 10/14

144 ppb

Cavity Ring Down Spectroscopy

Cavity Ring‐Down Spectroscopy: Detection at the Speed of Light

http://www.tigeroptics.com/app/tigeroptics/info/cavity_ring_down_spectroscopy.php

http://www.lgrinc.com/

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 14: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

14

A single, portable analyzer capable of simultaneous measurements of :• ethylene (100  ppb to 1000 ppm)• carbon dioxide (100 ppm to >10%)• water vapor (noncondensing)

http://www.lgrinc.com/

ExplorerPortable, battery operated 

gas chromatograph with a PID 

(photoionization detector)

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 15: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

15

F‐900 Portable Ethylene Gas Analyzer

Includes options for :C2H4 – different ranges

CO2 – different ranges (respiration; CA)and O2

Research kit with sampling chamber

InexpensiveSmall

Simple FabricationLow Power

One Chip – Multiple Sensors

SnO2 nanoparticle‐based passive capacitive sensor

Single walled carbon nanotube‐based devices Biosensors Labels

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 16: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

16

Slides provided by: Jan M. Schnorr, CTO, C2Sense LLC, March 2014 & 2015

[email protected]

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 17: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

17

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 18: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

18

Better Tools

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 19: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

19

Ethylene Management

Methods to reduce ethylene production and/or action:

Ventilation

Controlled or Modified Atmospheres

Ethylene oxidation

Ethylene adsorption

1‐MCP

Wills et al., 2014. Reduction of energy usage during storage and transport of bananas by management of exogenous ethylene levels. 

Postharvest Biology and Technology:

Ship for 19 days at 24°C <2 ppb (summer)19 days at 17°C <40 ppb (winter) 

Ethylene Control in Domestic Refrigerators

• 4 refrigerators each for control and Extrafresh discs (KMnO4)

• 6 Extrafresh discs/refrigerator

• Refrigerator doors were opened for 30 seconds 2 x  day (early am & pm) to simulate mealtime activity in the home. 

• Set temp 4°C/39°F

• 3 weeks for test 

• produce assessed 2 / weekApples, asparagus, avocados, broccoli, green 

cabbage, cauliflower, carrots, celery, cucumber, grapes, green pepper, kiwifruit, lemons, lettuce, honeydew melon, mushrooms, nectarines, pears, 

satsumas, strawberries, tomatoes (!)

Rees et al., 2011

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 20: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

20

Ethylene Control in Domestic Refrigerators

Opening the door reduced ethylene= ventilation

Extrafreshreduced ethylene 

BUT little effect on fresh produce quality

Refrigerators were set at 4°C/39°F (manufacturer’s  instructions). 

Rees et al., 2011

Ozone on Ethylene

Ethylene (ppm or uL/L) in rooms at 1°C (32°F) 

containing apples and pears when left untreated (control) 

or when exposed to a constant concentration of 0.4 

ppm ozone (Skog & Chu, 2001).

Effect of 0.04 ppm ozone on ethylene concentration in rooms containing 50 kg McIntosh apples as the ethylene source (Skog & Chu, 2001)

Control (no ozone) 1.5 – 2.0 ppm ethylene40 ppb ozone non detectable 

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 21: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

21

Ozone on Ethylene 

A sealed (59.8 m3) container at 0°C (32°F) with ethylene 3.8 ppm (3.8 uL/L) and an ozone generator (Palou, Smilanick, Crisosto & Mansour, 2001). 

Ozone reduced ethylene BUT

unless ozone was high it did not totally eliminate 

ethylene. 

OSHATWA = 300 ppb (0.3 ppm)STEL = 100 ppb (0.1 ppm)

Ethylene Release Canister®

Activated when required Supplies ethylene at a 

constant rate for up to 7 days

Ideal for conditioning small orders

Reduced cost vs. ripening room installation or expansion

Small Scale or In‐Transit RIPENING

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 22: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

22

RIPENESS SENSING

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 23: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

23

93% would purchase a pre‐pack with ripesense® again

85% would increase the frequency of their pear purchasing

“I didn’t know pears could taste this good”

What consumers say about 

ripesense®

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 24: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

24

Launched in 2008: ripesense®

for avocado 

Ripening and Sensing

• Provides real‐time ethylene readings 

• Ethylene is measure by stable and reliable optical infrared sensor from SmartGas (Germany)

• Ethylene generators can produce ethylene on demand according to setpoints

• Controlled through an internet based system 

• Email or text alerts

• Historical data on ethylene, temp, RH and CO2 (big data)

Catalytic Generatorswww.catalyticgenerators.com

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 25: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

25

VOC for Early Decay Detection

E‐noses  or Electronic Noses

Palottino et al., 2012. Electronic nose application for determinationof Penicillium digitatum in Valencia oranges. J. Sci. Food Agric. 92, 2008–2012.

Use of a printed disposable sensor array to detect food spoilage

Slides provided by: Nuria Queralto, PhD, iSense, March 2014

[email protected]

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 26: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

26

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 27: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

27

‘Big Data’  

Science

ManagementTechnology

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis

Page 28: New Technologies and Equipment 2015 - UC Cooperative ...ucanr.edu/datastoreFiles/234-2824.pdf · New Technologies and Equipment 2015 ... Ethylene sensor with display North East Postharvest

3/18/2015

28

Advances in measuring equipment 

Increased connectivity ‐ rapid data transfer 

Passive to active responses

‘Big data’ 

Conclusions …

Holcroft, Deirdre "New Technologies and Equipment" (c) 2015 Postharvest Technology Center, UC Davis