newman fallacy academic freedom academic boycott
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
1/25
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
2/25
F Am
Fm Am
B I
M J K - N m
An Najah University, Nablus, Palestine
I u u , u b b u
u v u m m bu . Bu u
u jb,
v .
C Cvz
he world witnessed the apex of the siege on Gaa in early 2008
P k b u
m u Gz S. Au
m I v Gv Cv v b -
m mu bk u, m,
, m Gz v m m
M S Uv P. CR: Te New Centennial Review, V. 8, N. 2, 2008, . 87110. issn 152-687
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
3/25
F A m F m . . .
k m u Gz v b
, u U S. S Ju 2007, I-m
Gz m v
um, b shoah(Hb Hu) b M V, I u m:
T m Qm [k] k
, b u mv b shoah bu u
u m uv (I M, 2008).
P v u I k
Gz u v, m m , u. I,
qu b m P u- b u m Gz b
b u m v uv,
W Bk b. L , K A-Mu u
Gz v m u B
Uv u uk; mbz u
P u.1 T L K Su Cm,
m m u z B, z vu
b, u E m-
. K v u u P
u m u.
I P b u
b I mu b bu b u bu
m u P Cm
Am Cuu B I (PACBI). I
u u u
P uv, Bz, 1975. I uu m
b ubj I b m u u
P m m m b m
P u, u, m u v b u
. I W Bk, b Bz u , D.
H N, Lb 1974. I u
P uv, , k
u intiada 1987, b P u
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
4/25
M a r c y J a n e K n o p - N e w m a n
(Bu Mu 2006). B 1988 1992, uv-
m , P u u uu
(Bu Mu 2006) m, mqu, u,
mmu , u . S 1992 Bz uv
, P u mv u v
u u u u, u, k,
J- uu W Bk. M ,
intiada, P m u v bm
m uv v u v
b , b I Am (Bu Mu2006).
T b v u bk m
b P. Bu b m C
E u bu u b, u v-
m , U S v b, vm,
v b m , ,
-Smm. T m PACBI k m b -
z u P b b I u,
vm u m -
mvm Su A. T , , P
Cv S C b, vm I
u m uv um
b 171 u, , z, uv
(P Cm, 2005). Tu E
u, N A Fu H Eu-
(NAFHE), b, C U Pub
Em (CUPE) M 2006.2 M , Uv C
U (UCU) E Ru 0, m
u P b b u UCU b or
inormation and discussion mmb b u
m m k I m
u (R 2007). I m m -
m, u, u b Am J
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
5/25
F A m F m . . .
Cmm (AJC) k u u- New York imes (Fu 1),
B I Uv? B Ou, ! b 00
Am uv . T u m
m Cumb Uv L B , I k qu I uv , v v u-
v mm uu
m, m, mu- mk
. Au mu b UCU
u mmb v u b, B,
m m, m u ,
bu v m , u b, u v b bu b.
T AJC u B m v umb
u k v m b I u-
, m m U S. I, k
m m u M E u Cumb v
bm mm v .4 W B
uv u m
, u, m v,
u v m Cumb
mmm vu. Nv ,
b E , umb qu
bu u m m m b. S,
k qu
: W m m ? I m m
v? Su m m b m m
v ? A m m
b u?
I m b qu
Cvz . T mu k -
k m v b
b , k v u .
E b, vm, m
P m u u u
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
6/25
M a r c y J a n e K n o p - N e w m a n
Fig.
1.
AmericanJewi
shCommittee,www.ajc.org
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
7/25
F A m F m . . .
Su A.5 Mv, - Su A -
, u Ab Dm uu, m
b Su A P v mk m:
W Su A mmb u m
- mvm apartheid. A, bu-
, , , ! Su A, , mb-
m m bm m. A bu
u u, u u, v
j u. N, , apartheid I, m S
W bantustans k P u u . H
. Y ju v v. (uu
2005, 12)
T mk Su A
b, vm, mvm m
Bk I Su A. U bu
P mvm m u
u Z m . Au m
- mvm
uu b m b Su A,
m b vk.6 I Su A, I, m -
u m m v
. R, uv u u k
u u u
z P.
T uv u b Sm
V, P Eu Uv W Su
A:
T uv Su A u u-
u qu ju u . Uv
Su Au b k
: v mu u m ; v
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
8/25
M a r c y J a n e K n o p - N e w m a n 3
, mm, u b u u-
; m k u
buu. Mv, umb m k
, u uv, u u qu, v m
u. (V 2006)
A u Su A, I uv
u u. V
b v ju m u u b I m
:
A umb I m v u
m u v
P, ju k, ,
. C m A S,
v I vm m b
Ab: W 2.5 m v - Gz, b
um . T bm v b m
. . . . S, m v, v k k
k. A , v . (V 2006)
V m m u Su A I
m qu m m m m-
u u vu qu um
v. F Gz m m
mm I m
.
I, b m u-
m b I b b
U S , m m
m? I 2006, Am A Uv P (AAUP)
v m B, I, b ubj b
P, I, Su A . T m v k
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
9/25
F A m F m . . .
, u m ub Academe,
u V qu bv.
m ju ; u b m -
b.7 T AAUP ubj b u ju u b
m v m m (AAUP 2006). Au
AAUP u vu m m u vm m
Su A, v v m b Su A
m b.
AAUP v m qu bu m
m v b m . I, m m b u
u k jb. Hv, U S, uu -
I
uu m m. O m
u Nm Fk DPu Uv J M-
Cumb Uv u
.8 I k u ju P mv u-
m u m m,
m m v ? Am m b
u u u b
vm u vm.
Bu b I u u
, m u b
u - , u m m
m .
T mm u m m
m b m I. T m, m
k, mm v um b u
u b, vm, I, u
, mk m ju
u P. T v b vv
m m u -
m u u m u u m m
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
10/25
M a r c y J a n e K n o p - N e w m a n
k. T m v Hv L A
Dz. O Dz v b. I
m b I, u m
b bm
. . . bu v m . O u
m , b m .
T k uv ;
m , m m
, . (Juu Dz 2007)
Au Dz u b m m,
u- m u
m b I bm v
bk mu u
m m m -Sm (: m
I) b u v. Bu
m, m u , Dz
vu m m, I m m,
ju m - v u F-
k. Dz u uu
b b m bk ub Fk
Beyond Chutzpah b Uv
C P bu Gv A Sz. I Dm-
b 22, 2004, Sz, Dz :
I k u b v m -
vv b Uv C P ub
vu -Sm bk b u m u
-Nz Gm Au. T bk qu
z b mm m- v
u z Te Protocols o the Elders o Zion. I m
I v B D UCP,
um m . I u
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
11/25
F A m F m . . .
v m , I k m u u u
b v , u I. (Dz 2004)
T bvu m Dz k u
m I. T v
k u I .
W Gv Sz u m m
u F Amm m
v b. W Dz u v Fk bk
m b ub, u m m DPuUv, u u uv Fk-
u.9
W u v v b b -
m m m b I m . W
b m -Smm
k , u u u
m m m v
. I u v b m
, Dz, D P Dv Hz, v
m I, -Smm,
k u m uu. Sm
u k () b bu
b -Smm um v b I
u v m u
k uu ju m .
W AAUP m b, u-
m k qu m mk
b k u m b. :
A u -
, , , z m? H u u
m m v Gm uv u Nz? Su
v b u H b
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
12/25
M a r c y J a n e K n o p - N e w m a n
uv? C ub m m m v
v m v b b? (AAUP
2006)
Ev mu bu v m b -
b , m J vmz u mu .
W ub bu m v u
m b u k
u k -Sm. Su qu
m m m k
b vu m k . R, u J um b J u-
u k vmz mu
b mu.10 U J u um
mu u um v,
m m, k u
-Smm . A Fk u, I
mm m u u,
vb -mz , m J -
(2005, 2). F m m
I m shoah Hu
Gz? D b m u
m I m u u AAUP
qu ?
T m -Smm u
v mb -
b m mb I ,
v I uv. T PACBI b
m k m:
W I P , b
Z m :
D b Nkb u v
P u
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
13/25
F A m F m . . .
bm u b u-
u b ; M
u z W Bk (u E Jum)
Gz 1967 v UN u;T m m
P z I, mb u m
Su A.(P Cm 2008)
Cm m m b A
N C (ANC) Luk 1989:
T uu m b v m
ANC m m.
A v m, u b u mvm ,
u - , UN -
, uu, , m b
mmu Su A u
b mmum. (ANC 1989)
B ANC PACBI m u vu
m , u
U N. T P b mk vu
u v b vu m
m 1948 P Ou .11
I I u m
u
vu .12 R, ANC
mu m m. Au
AAUP u bu, m vm m,
u , bv
v m. Hv,
b u AAUP m Nz Gm, u AAUP
mm J , Jv W, ,
u v u Nz m
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
14/25
M a r c y J a n e K n o p - N e w m a n
? W m u u u
u k u u m k
mv m ?
L Dv M Bk, v b -vv m u PACBI , u
bu u P u b
b I bm . F
Z v m m W -
P u. . . . m bk
, P v b
-Sm u . T Z mv u k
m vm u u mk
, m v . (Bk Dv 2006)
N u k 60 , -u I uv-
v vvm u u u
b u mu. Mv,
I m v k u u
vm v b z b
uv mmu. Tu, b m
u k b I b u I
m mu b. I, I P, I
m k u
b, b m :
C b u m
mmb m. Bu I m
mmu, , u mb mm I
u b m uv, Uv H,
M 2002. A v u u uv
m, b u m m, uu
m , m vm
P uu . (P 2005)
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
15/25
F A m F m . . .
Fu, P mk m -
m m uv
u v. T I m
u u b, bu u- m m m R. I
I u u b,
m m u:
W u u m
u. Yu m v m b
uub b mmu
u u. Bu . T
m, m mu v ,
u b u u m .
T m mmu u
u u v b m u
. Yu bm Su A -
. (R 2002)
Bu P um m m
m U S m k Fk
M, R u qu m m
-u v, m u b
u u. O m m u
b k m b
m m, bu m -
m m b
u v k vu. I
, u Eu U, I m
m, uu, v, m b
bu u qu um
v v . O , Eu-
U v b u u
I m u; , m
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
16/25
M a r c y J a n e K n o p - N e w m a n
I m v u u I-
u v v. Au m
m mk I
k bv j P, u u, uk O A, u u
qu u P bm m
ubm m .1
T vu I m b m
u P b b v vu
m u m k. I
b I m z v v m u m m
Ou, m J C u:
. . . I m b u v k ub
m u E Jum, W Bk Gz,
, v m u v b-
I m z vm
P u. (C 2007)
T I m u u
u v b Pu
I k R P v
b u u m u
m I m. I u b b I
m u mvm u
z P.
A I b b qu bu P
u, I u qu u-
P v, mvm, u
v I m. T qu u C
I m, b , v k u
P vu, u, z. M-
v, C :
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
17/25
F A m F m . . .
Pu I uv v v
u u ub uu -
P u v, u b I
u bu qum, k ju u , k, b , zu,
W b m u-
v.(C 2007)
T m I u m v
m mvm v P,
u u. Au Uv D HumR u um
b u , m, , bu
m v right m m. T qu u-
, u, m u k I b
umb v v u m P. I
qu u u b v u
u k. T qu, I bv, mu
b k, mu b m
m bm qu m m.
I u u I U S
m J u -Sm k -
mu b m v z I
v P um u mvm
P v m m,
bm. I mm MC
1950 Am k u
m uu u, k u ju
v m m qu,
k u m m, u
I bu U S.14 I u
m m bm b, m
m mu b -
vu. H Gu, u MM Uv,
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
18/25
M a r c y J a n e K n o p - N e w m a n 3
C ( v b I
mu15), u , u vu m
b - u m, k
um bm u:
I, u vbu vu , m m,
b, m , v v,
b - , u m u
u, m u, u
m u v v. (Gu 2007, 18)
T k U S v u umb
m, u I,
bu U.S. - m A Iq,
u W Cu. A u, Gu u, -
m u m
m, b vu (2007, 146). Tu,
m m v
, , mu - jk
mv m b b m m
m; m m qu vu m .
I , u Om Bu Ju Bu v u
u m m k b
m u k u-
. I, Ju Bu , Ou u b-
m m (2006, 15). I , uu
v P um b
m m. Bu I u u , P b
mv m u um
v, u m m.
I Bu m m b
m m, m um , v-
, b b Om Bu m
m . I , v, Bu u:
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
19/25
F A m F m . . .
I v m m, v, u-
m b , b u
v; , , m ,
b u u -m. T : v m u b .
O b b , v . I u
m m , b m
b , u
m m vv u ,
m m, u u m? (2006, 11)
Bu qu m m b u-
u u m mk v
u m b I. F Bu quu-
I m m u k v
bu v P v ,
ub u -
m b bu I m u u
, , m um
v u m.
I v b u k b bu -
m m m u b b
, u m. F m m b
u m b
I um v P u U
S, C, E, I b
. I m v ,
b b mvm, v u, m m v
. A k m m , I ,
b u u , P
u k m u m
P.
Au m m b v
U S, P,
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
20/25
M a r c y J a n e K n o p - N e w m a n
I, m k qu m u.
F B AJC New York imes
m u W, D.C., AJC
v -I bb z u k m. I C, Am m u, k
I bb u I v
J u vmz u W W II b qu.
I ju B AJC b, C -
u HR 467 Ju 2007, m UCU m m:
Rv S Jk L u, B bm vm
m, u bz v m um um . P v
bu k u . I
m b , mu u vu -
: , u, m, m (U.S. C 2007). T
bm Rv Jk L m v m
v, u v uu b
k u: P m I
mb Am vu u m m. T
muv u bm vm. I, b mvm
u um . Bu m -
ub m m
Iv b u u b,
vu m m.
Mv, z k AAUP, Jk L u
u mu b u b: I u
u bu P, u uu u m
I P m m u
mu v b , I (U.S. C
2007). I m, , P
m. I , k u -
m Hm b, v m m
v . Tu, C m P
(u u) k I , k
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
21/25
F A m F m . . .
m m z
P u .
T b Am m u C-
. T v I v vu m I bb W,
D.C. F , m -I bb z k AJC,
Am I Pub A Cmm (AIPAC), A-Dm
Lu (ADL) v vu m vv u u
u u u I, uu
u b u u W,
D.C., u (: ) - C H. A m b b v , AIPAC
u mu -I m, ADL m
mu. J Mm S W u
u uv bb v u :
P-I u vu v u mu b
u, , m, uuum
u mu. T v b uu m
v b C H v m, bu k
b v. D u um I
u Ou , m
I mu v . (2007, 185)
Gv b v m b I
- -Smm mu u -P-
- , u m
v . A m m, mu
v J u
I m u,
u, , ub u k m P Jmm C. 16 A
mmum, u u qu
u m m, J m u
I P, I m
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
22/25
M a r c y J a n e K n o p - N e w m a n
mmu m um v
. Rk m m v
bz m b
b, vm, mvm. I m k - v , bu m m
P .
n o t e s
I k D O, L Mu, S D. H u bk
u.
1. S D M www.letkhaledstudy.co.uk.
2. Vu u z v j m,
v u m I: Cu E (Fbu 2006), P-
b Cu USA (Auu 2005), W Cu Cu (M 2005).
F m m m, C A I A,
www.caiaweb.org.. T b u AJC b, www.ajc.org.
4. S m F B?: S v. R T P Am
Fm.
5. Obvu b m Su A
m Z I, bu m mkb m
. S Abum, One Country.
6. Au m - mvm
Su A v m b m
, u m u u m :
M N. Yu, Liberation and Democratization; A Sk, omorrow is Another
Country; F Njub Nb,Race or Sanctions.
7. S S Jk, B Mz B Iu.
8. Sm A A, W S, Ju, J Kv, R K, N Abu E-Hj,
Ju C m m v b u k
I.
9. F v b Dz DPu Uv-
m, http://normannkelstein.wordpress.com.10. O u Nz Hu k, K , Worlds o Hurt.
11. F u I, J CkBlood and Religion.
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
23/25
F A m F m . . .
12. Sm k b k Av Sm, m Sv,
I P. I u, I P Te Ethnic Cleansing o Palestine.
1. F u
P, S R, Failing Peace, E W. S, Te End o the Peace
Process.
14. I m k b I Su A
, A Abum u U.S. u m Su
A uv, , bu U S Su A
b W vu mmum
u A. Lk, U.S. u I muu
(2006, 18586). Au m k ,
u U.S. m m k m. W
m m 1950 u MCm
m u m .15. S www.caiaweb.org/node/505.
16. S, , Jmm CPalestine, Peace Not Apartheid J Dmm
m bu C bk u,Jimmy Carter: A Man From Plains.
r e f e r e n c e s
Abum, A. 2006. One Country: A Bold Proposal to End the Israeli-Palestinian Impasse. N
Yk: M Bk.
A N C (ANC). 1989. P P Cuu Am B
A b N Euv Cmm A N C. www.
anc.org.za/ancdocs/pr/1989/pr0500.html( M 8, 2008).
Am A Uv P (AAUP). 2006. R Am B.
Academe Online 2, . 5. www.aaup.org/AAUP/pubsres/academe/2006/SO/Boycott/
OnAcademicBoycotts.html.
Bk, M; L Dv. 2006. I D B. Counterpunch, Sm-
b 18: .
Bu, Rm; H Mu. 2006. Am Fm N. I Students Under Oc-
cupation ake a Stand: Photographs rom the Right to Education Photography Project, .
Rm: Bz Uv.
Bu, Ju. 2006. I/P P Am Fm.Radical Philoso-
phy15: 817.
C, Jmm. 2006.Palestine, Peace Not Apartheid. N Yk: Sm & Su.
C, J. 2007. T Am B I Uv. Naked Punch, M 26.
www.7station.cn/nakedpunch/comments_detail.asp?ArtistID=22 ( Nvmb 14,
2007).
C A I A. 2007.Labour or Palestine. : O D P.Ck, J. 2006. Blood and Religion: Te Unmasking o the Jewish and Democratic State.
L: Pu Bk.
Dmm, J. 2007.Jimmy Carter: A Man rom Plains. N Yk: S Pu C.
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
24/25
M a r c y J a n e K n o p - N e w m a n
Dz, A. 2004. L Gv A Sz, Dmb 22. www
.normannkelstein.com.
Fk, Nm G. 2005.Beyond Chutzpah: On the Misuse o Anti-Semitism and the Abuse o
History. Bk: Uv C P.
Gu, H A. 2007. Te University in Chains: Conronting the Military-Industrial-Academic
Complex. Bu, CO: Pm.
I M W P Hu. 2008. Te Guardian, Fbu 29. www.guardian
.co.uk/world/2008/eb/29/israelandthepalestinians1.
Jk, S. 2006. B Mz B Iu. Inside Higher Ed, Smb 15.
http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/09/15/boycott.
Juu, A; A Dz. 2007. T Cm F A A-Smm.
imes Online, Ju 1. www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/columnists/guest_contributors/
article1928865.ece.
K-Nm, M. 2005. F B?: S v. R T P Am Fm.Palestine-Israel Journal12, . 2: 1018.
L K Su. 2007. www.letkhaledstudy.co.uk ( Fbu 7, 2007).
M, D. 2007. I b P. Te Independent, D-
mb 4. www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/israeli-prisoner.
Mm, J J.; S M. W. 2007. Te Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy. N
Yk: F, Su, Gu.
Nb, F Njub. 2004.Race or Sanctions: Arican Americans against Apartheid, 19461994.
Bm: I Uv P.
P Cm Am Cuu B I (PACBI). 2005. P-
v b, vm I u m-
uv um . www.pacbi.org/
boycott_news_more.php?id=66_0_1_10_M11 ( Ob 9, 2007).
. 2008. C m uu b I. http://pacbi.org/campaign_state-
ment.htm ( M 8, 2008).
P, I. 2005. B G. Te Guardian, A 20. http://education.guardian.co.uk/higher/
news/story/0,,146206,00.html.
. 2006. Te Ethnic Cleansing o Palestine. L: O W.
R, . 2002. W Am BA R I Cm.Indymedia Israel,
M 17. http://www.tau.ac.il/~reinhart/political/17_05_02_Academic_Boycott.html.
R, Wm. 2007. B B Du. Columbia Spectator, Smb 4. www
.columbiaspectator.com/node/26317.
R, S. 2007.Failing Peace: Gaza and the Palestinian-Israeli Confict. L: Pu Bk.
S, E W. 2001. Te End o the Peace Process: Oslo and Ater. N Yk: V.
Sk, A. 1995. omorrow is Another Country: Te Inside Story o South Aricas Road to
Change. C: Uv C P.
, K. 1995. Worlds o Hurt: Reading the Literatures o rauma. Cmb: Cmb U-v P.
uu, Ab Dm M. 2005. F. I Speaking the ruth: Zionism, Israel, and the
Occupation, . M P, 912. Nm, MA: Ov B P.
-
7/31/2019 Newman Fallacy Academic Freedom Academic Boycott
25/25
F A m F m . . .
U S C. Hu. 2007. Condemning the Decision by the University and College
Union o the United Kingdom to Support a Boycott o Israeli Academia, HR R. 467.
V, Sm. 2006. T Su A B E.Academe Online 2, . 5. www.aaup
.org/AAUP/pubsres/academe/2006/SO/Boycott/Te+SouthAricanBoycott.htm#salim.
Yu, M N. 2000. Liberation and Democratization: Te South Arican and Palestinian Na-
tional Movements. M: Uv M P.