nl2040 pbl 100909 site - centraal planbureau · 4 new cpb scenario study question how will we earn...
TRANSCRIPT
1www.nl2040.nl
The Netherlands of 2040
2
Times Are a-Changin’
3
Times Are a-Changin’
4
New CPB Scenario Study
Question
How will we earn our daily bread in 2040?
Approach
Scenarios to deal with uncertainty
Answer
Smart people
Strong cities
Policy
5
Specialisation of Work …
Brainstorm
Blueprint Prototype
Chips
Packaging
Retail
RetailRetail
Retail
Production
6
Smart People
Specialisation
Communication technology …
… leads to unbundling of tasks …
… global knowledge exchange …
… and production by specialist workers
7
Generalisation
8
Smart people
... or generalisation
Mechanics masters more complex systems
Insurance agents with broad portfolio
Expert system to diagnose illness
Design programmes
Write your own emails
9
Smart People
Specialisation
Communication technology …
… leads to unbundling of tasks …
… global knowledge exchange …
… and production by specialist workers
Generalisation
Information technology …
… bundles tasks …
… performed by autonomous workers
10
Cities Are the Place to Be
Stockholm
Barcelona Tokyo
Dallas
Packaging
Retail
RetailRetail
Retail
Production
11
Concentration of Economic Activity …
12
Strong Cities
Concentration
Economies of scale …
… with face-to-face interactions …
… to develop new technologies
13
… or Scattering of Economic Activity
14
Strong Cities
Concentration
Economies of scale …
… with face-to-face interactions …
… to develop new technologies
Scattering
Networks of small cities …
… with excellent connections …
… facilitated by ICT
15
Scattering
Concentration
GeneralisationSpecialisation
Two Uncertainties
16
Four Scenarios
Scattering
Concentration
GeneralisationSpecialisation
Metropolitan Markets
Cosmopolitan Centres
Talent Towns
Egalitarian Ecologies
17
Talent Towns
• Communication technology: specialists
• Interaction and surroundings: small cities
• Very dynamic: opportunities and challenges
• High incomes, yet high competition
• Low incomes under pressure
• Netherlands: business services
• Manufacturing to Asia
18
Talent Towns
• Communication technology: specialists
• Interaction and surroundings: small cities
• Very dynamic: opportunities and challenges
• High incomes, yet high competition
• Low incomes under pressure
• Netherlands: business services
• Manufacturing to Asia
19
Cosmopolitan Centers
• Bio- and nanotechnology: science based
• Communication: global division of tasks
• Cities: clusters of specialised activity
• Risk: other city takes over
• Substantial income inequality
• Examples of possible Dutch clusters:
• water, biomass, medical, logistics, creative
20
Cosmopolitan Centers
• Bio- and nanotechnology: science based
• Communication: global division of tasks
• Cities: clusters of specialised activity
• Risk: other city takes over
• Substantial income inequality
• Examples of possible Dutch clusters:
• water, biomass, medical, logistics, creative
21
Egalitarian Ecologies
• Information technology: generalists
• Product variation: local demand
• Medium-sized cities: quality
• Moderate growth of incomes:
• Limited technological progress
• Wealth to raw materials suppliers
• East and south of Netherlands flourish
22
Egalitarian Ecologies
• Information technology: generalists
• Product variation: local demand
• Medium-sized cities: quality
• Moderate growth of incomes:
• Limited technological progress
• Wealth to raw materials suppliers
• East and south of Netherlands flourish
23
Metropolitan Markets
• Bio- and nanotechnology break through
• Large firms: marketable applications
• Research centres and face-to-face contact
• Metropolis attracts firms and people
• Hinterland lags behind
• Large income inequality
• Netherlands large enough?
24
Metropolitan Markets
• Bio- and nanotechnology break through
• Large firms: marketable applications
• Research centres and face-to-face contact
• Metropolis attracts firms and people
• Hinterland lags behind
• Large income inequality
• Netherlands large enough?
25
The Magic Circle of Policymaking
26
Attractors (A) and mobile production factors (M)
AMAMIdeas
0++++++Mobility
AAMMDemand
AMAMWorkers
MMEECCTT
27
Policy making for the place of business
0NLEUEUInfra between cities
WorldNLEUNLRegulation across cities
+++++++City regulation
++++++0City infrastructure
MMEECCTT
28
Connections and the structure of cities
localgloballocal and global
globalIdeas
Randstad++
ConnectedCondensedVirtualStructure
limitedcontinentalglobalglobalFinal goods
localnationallocal and global
continentalWorkers
MMEECCTT
29
Wrapping Up
Smart people earn our income
Strong cities glue smart people together
30www.nl2040.nl