notes on the republic by plato - chapters 5 to 9
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
1/24
[U^S`W_
O [U^S`W_VWVZ%%ZXaWZUZYS`[`[S\\^[SU\[_[\Z`WcSWVV
O [U^S`W_\[_[\`[[U^S`W_cS_WZYSYZYZU[ZbW^_S`[ZST[a`[cXW_[aVTWbWV
O [U^S`UW`[V[U^S UVS[YaWS_ZYSZVSZ_cW^ZY]aW_`[Z_`[_`aS`WU^`US`ZZY
O S`[S`W _S_`S``[YW`SSZ`[SUZ[cWVYW`W`^a``Wa_ _[[`WSZVcZ[bW^YWZ`c`[a`W `ZYZ[c`WW`WZ`[X_V_WS_W
O ZW[X`WU[\SZ`_[X`_W`[V[X]aW_`[ZZY_`S`c`WSU]aW_`[ZZ`WS^YaWZ``WSZ_cW^W _WVXa^`W S_`^SS W^_SSV__[Z_SVV
a\SZV WU[Z`^SVU``W_WbW_WSYSW[XV^SaY`_WS^W`^S\\WVS`[aY WS^WZ[`U[ZbZUWVT WU[ZUa_[Z WSbWZ[`ZY`[_S[Z`W_aTWU`
O S`[SVW[U^S`W_`WUWZ`^SXYa^WZ_T[[_SZY`[_`ZVS[YaWX[^
O S`[_`S^ _c`SXSS^VWSX^WZV_\a_`UWS`[S_[U^S`W_Z`W^^[YS`W`W\W^_[Zc``WVWSSZV\^[bW`W^WS^WU[Z`^SVU`[Z_SZV
ZSVW]aSUW_cW^W`S`VWS_U[ZUW^ZWV
O W[U^S UW`[V[XU[Z_`SZ`\[_[\US`ZZYWZU[a^SYW_S`[`[TaV[Z_[cZVWS__[cZ [aY`_T^SZUZYScSX^[_\cS`[U^S`W_TWWbWV
bW^bWc[XS`[_a`[\ S
O S`[a_WVSVW_U^\`[Z[XSa`[\SZ_`S`W`[YbW_[W[X_[^SSZV\[`USbWc_
O W^W\aTU[[_`[VWXZWa_`UWS`[TWWbW_`S``_WS_W^`[_WW ZY_Z
`WS^YW S`W^`SZ`W_S_[`W[[S`cS`SW_Sa_`_`S WZ_`WSV[XSa_`ZVbVaS
O S`[_`[\S`WU`WZ_S^WVbVWVZ`[`^WWUS__W_`WU[[Z\W[\W`W_[VW^_SZV`WYaS^VSZ_
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
2/24
O WYaS^VSZ_S^W`W[Z[ZW_c`\[`US\[cW^`WS^W`WYW_ US__c`TW``W^WVaUS`[ZST[[YUSSZVWU[Z[U_`SZVS^V_
O W\a^\[_W[X`WU`_X[^`WY[[V[X`Wc[WZ[`X[^`WY[[V[X`WZVbVaS
O [WZS^W`[SbWU[\W`WW]aS`S_ W^[^YZSZS`a^W_`W_SW`W
VXXW^WZUW_SbWZ[`ZY`[V[c`\[`U_
O S^^SYWc[aVTWVXXW^WZ`W^Wc[aVTWXW_ bS_ZcU`WTW_`WZc[aVTWYbWZ`[`WTW_ c[WZ`[SbWUV^WZS`[aY`c[aVTW
\^W_WZ`WVS_USZUW
O UV^WZc[aVTW SWZX^[`W\S^WZ`_S`T^`SZVVWX[^WVUV^WZc[aVTW\a`ScS
O ZUWZ[[ZWZ[c_c[`W^W\S^WZ`_S^W`W_[aVUSWbW^[ZWXS`W^
[`W^T^[`W^__`W^SZVVSaY`W^_ZW_\^bS`W\[__W__bW
W[`[Z_
O a_`UW_WbW^[ZWV[ZY`W [cZ[Tc`[a`Z`W^XW^ZYc``W[`W^US__W_
O S`[S[c_ZW]aS`W_[X\[cW^SZV\^bWYWc`[a`Za_`UWS_ WYaS^VSZ_S^W_a\W [^Z`[aY`[cWbW^`_VXXUa``[Z[cc[S_`W
[_`_\[`USc_WSZV`_S^V`[Z[cXS\[`USZca_W__Z
`W\aTUZ`W^W_`^S`W^ SZ_[cZ[^Z`WTWZWX`_[X_US__
O _`_VWS[Xa_`UWSZV`WW_`S`X[[cU[\S`TWc`\[_[\`Zb[bW_SZWVaUS`[Z`S`_`aZ`_Z`WYWZUWS`[_a`[\S[ZSUWbW_ZcS^SZVWZ[aY`[WS`ZUW_\W[\WS^W`[TWW\`Z`W_WUS__W_
UWZ_[^WVZcS``WWS^ZY[bW^ZWVT`[_Wc[W`[`WT^WVWbW_`[UZS\^[UW__[XS^`XUS_WWU`[ZVaUS`[ZcZ[``^bWZ_aUS
_`S`W
O W_`S`Wa_`TWX[aZVWV[Zb^`aW_c_V[U[a^SYWV_U\ZWSZVa_`UWa_`UWTWZY`WV[ZSZ`
O _V[_YSZWVX^[`WYaS VSZ_Z[cWVYW
O [a^SYW_YSZWVX^[[c`WWW\`W[\Z[Z[X`WW_`ST_WVWVaUS`[Z`W^_[VW^_c[Z USZYW`W^WVaUS`[ZZ`WXSUW[X\WS_a^W\SZ[^XWS TWUSa_W[X[c`W_`S`WT^ZY_`Wa\
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
3/24
O WXV_U\ZW_YSZWVTWUSa_W`WVW_^W_[X`WW__^W_\WU`STWS[^`S^WU[Z`^[WVT`WVW_^W_SZVc_V[[X`W_a\W^[^Z[ `WXV_U\ZW_SU[Z`^[[XcWSVW_^W_SZVS\\W``W_^[VaUW_SS^[ZTW`cWWZ`W
US__W_
O a_`UW_`S`[ZWSZa_`V[`W[T`S`WZS`a^S__a`WVX[ SZVZVZY[a^Ta_ZW__SZVZ[`Z`W^XW ZYc`\W[\WSZa_`S_[WW\_[cZ\^[\W^`
O S`[`WZ_WW_[c_VWS_ST[a`Sa_`_`S`WS\\`[Sa_`ZVbVaSS`[TWWbW_`W_[aVa`S`WTW`W_SW
O W_`S`W_a_``S_S`_b^`aW_cWZ`S_`^WW\S^ _`WU[[Z\W[\W`W_[VW _SZV`WYaS^VSZ_[S`[TWWbW_`S``WZVbVaS
a_`SbW W_SW`^WWWWWZ`_Z`W^\W^_[ZS`
[WZ
O WSW_S^W\_UScWSW^[cWbW^`W_[aV_`_S^W`W^W_\[Z_T`W_[XSW_
O S`[a_W_`WSZS[Y[XcS`UV[Y__[aV`WXWSW_\W^X[^`W_SWYaS^VVa`W_[^_`S[WSZV[[SX`W^`W\a\_
O W^WS_[Z_`W_[aV_S^W`WVa`W_[XWZ`[^WVaUW`WTa^VWZ
O W^WX[^WWZSZVc[WZ_[aVTWWVaUS`WV`[`W_SWWbW`SaY`WbW^`ZY`[`W_SW_`SZVS^VSZV_SWScS
O `[aY`S[[^VUa[a_W\W WZUWc[aV_[c`W\W[\W`_`W^Y`U[UW
O WVWS[Xc[WZSZVWZSbZYVXXW^WZ`[UUa\S`[Z_USWX^[`WVWS`S``WSbWVXXW^WZ`ZS`a^W_[cWbW^S`[S^YaW_`S`TSVWZSZV[ZY
S^WVWZSbW[\\[_`WZS`a^W__[aV[aX[^TV[ZWX^[TWZYSV[U`[^
SZVbUWbW^_S
O [WZSbW`WUS\ST`[X`SZYbS^[a_[UUa\S [Z_S`[aY`WcTWcWSW^`W_[aV_`\S^`U\S`W
O [WZSZVWZ_[aV_S^WSU[[ZWVaUS`[Z
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
4/24
O W_[aVT^ZYa\`W^UV^WZZU[[Z
O W_[aVSbWSU[[Z^W_\[Z_T`S_WZ
O W_[aVWWZWW\\WSUWZ`WU`US\SYZZcS^SU`S_YaS^VSZ_aZ`c``WWZ
WXS
O WZSZVc[WZYaS^VSZ__[aVTWX[^TVVWZTSc`[bW`[YW`W^S[ZWZ_W\S^S`W[a_W[V_
OWYaS^VSZ_cSbWSZVXWWV`[YW`W^`WcSbWZ[\^bS`W[W[^\^[\W^ WcSbWZ[\[__W__[Z_[X`W^[cZTa`YW` W^VST^WSV
X^[[`W^_Z\SWZ`X[^`W^_W^bUW_
O [\S^WZ`_[aVZ[c`_UVSZVZ[UV_[aVZ[c`_\S^WZ`
O WTW_`WZcTWT^WVc``WTW_`c[WZS_[X`WZS_\[__TWZXW^[^WZc`ZXW^[^c[WZS__WV[S_\[__TW ^`XUS_WWU`[Z^WVW
bW_`[U
O WcS^ SZYW^WYaS`WVXW_`bS_`WZaTW^[XaZ[Z_^WZY[Z[caU\W[\WcS_ZWWVWV [WW\`W_`S`WU[Z_`SZ`Z[``[[S^YWTa`Z[``[[_S
O Z`WXW_ bS_`W^Wc[aVTWS__`W[XV^ScZY[`_
O WcS^V_X[^[aZYWZc[\W^X[^WVcWZTS``Wc[aVTW[^WX^W]aWZ`[\\[^ aZ`W_`[_WW\c``WTW_`c[WZ
O WUV^WZ[XTW``W^YaS^VSZ_cTW`SWZ`[Za^_W^W_S`_W\S^S`W\S^ _[X`WU``WUV^WZ[XZXW^[^YaS^VSZ_[^VWXWU`bWUV^WZcTW_WU^W`
V_\[_WV[X
O [WZ_[aVSbWUV^WZTW`cWWZWZ_[aVSbWUV^WZX^[cWZW\S__W__\^WS_S^aZZW `[
O V^WZT[^Z[a`[X W_WU[ZV`[Z_cTWWY`S`W^WWU`WVUbSZV^WY[a_
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
5/24
O S_``WT^WWVZYSYW WUSZ_WW\S^[aZVTa`Z[`c`SZ^WS`bWSZVZ[UV^WZ
aS^VSZ_TWZWX`_
O Y[[V_`S Wc_WWWbW^[ZW_ZVbVaSYSZ[^[__S_`W^[cZS[ZWaZ`
O Wc_S^W`W_SWXWWZY_[X_[^^[cSZV[
O X`WaS^VSZ_^WXW^^WV`[WbW^[ZWS_T^[`W SZV__`W^XS`W SZV[`W^W`U`Wc[aV_[cWbW^[ZW`W_SW[bW`WSU`SUU[^VZY`[`W
[\\[_WV^WS`[Z_\[a`^WS`_[W[ZW[aUS[a^T^[`W^W`W^W
[a^T^[`W^
O W`WSU`W^UV^WZ`[TWSbWSUU[^VZY`^WS`ZYWbW^[ZWS_[`W
T^[`W^XS`W^__`W^W`U
O _`WSbWZ[\^[\W^``W^WZ`W^W_`c[aVTWVWZ`USZ[ X`_
O WSbWZ[[ZWZ[UV^WZZ[XSSZV WUSa_W[_ S^YaWZ`_^W[bZY`Wc[aV^W[bW]aS^^W_TW`cWWZ\W[\W
O WZ[X`W_SWSYWUSZXY`S[ZY_ WSU[`W^`[VWXWZV`W_WbW_`_cWZU[a^SYW`W`[WW\\_USX`
O XSSZS_SZS^YaWZ`c`SZ[`W WUSZSU`a\[Z`XY`Z_ WSV[XW``ZY`Y^[cZ`[_[W`ZYc[^_W
O VW^WZSbWSa`[^`[bW [aZYW^WZ
O [aZYW^WZc[aV`^WS [VW^WZ[a`[X^W_\WU`TWUSa_W[X^W_\WU SZVXWS^W[c[aV`^WS`[a^XS`W^
O WaS^VSZ__[aVbWS`\WSUWTWUSa_W`WTWSbWS_SXS[ZWaZ``WSbWZ[\^[\W^ _[SbWVWZ`USZ`W^W_`_`WXY`[a`]aS^^W_Z_`WSV
[XW``ZY W_W^[VW^WZc[aVTW^W_\WU`WV
O W\[[^c[Z SbW`[XS``W^ W^U
O [VXXUa`W_[^SZW`W_`S`S^WUSa_WVT^S_ZYSXS
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
6/24
O [T[^^[cZY[^\SZY[ZW_VWT`_
O W^bU`[ W_c[aVTW[^WV_`ZYa_WV
O W^bU`[^c[aVT ZY_WUa^``[`Wc[WU[aZ`
O Wc[aVZ[c S``W^WUV^WZS^W[[WVSX`W^
O WS^WWVZ[Z[a T`W^XW[cU`WZ_
WaW_[XS^
aW_c`UV^WZ
O WZSZVc[WZc_W^bW`[YW`W^
O Wc`SW`WUV^WZ`[cS^c``WcWZ`W^W[VWZ[aY
O WUV^WZcTWSTW [YW`a_W`[`W^Xa`a^WVa`W_WS[ZYS\\^WZ`UW_\
O WUV^WZcSbW`[XW`UUS^^SZVSW`W_WbW_a_WXa`[`W^[`W^_SZVXS`W^_
O V^WU`]a[`W
O WcSW`WUV^WZcS`UcS Ta`cS_[SW_a^W`W _SXW
O WcWZ_a^W`W^_SXW`T[ZT^ZYZY`WS[ZY`[`WUS\SYZ_TS``W_`S`S^W_SXWSb[VZYVSZYW^[a_[ZW_
O Wc[aV\a``^a_`c[^ [XXUW^_`[SU`S_`W^WSVW^_SZV[[SX`W^`W
O Wc[aV\a``WUV^WZ[Z[^_WTSU[ZY[[V[^_W_X`YW _`[[VSZYW^[a_`W[XXUW^_cWSV W`[_SXW`
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
7/24
aW_cWZXY`ZY
O [cS^V_[VW^_WZc[^aZScSX^[TS``W_[aVTWSVWZ`[XS^W^_[^S^`_SZ_
O ZU[cS^V_[VW `SWZ\^_[ZW _[aVTWSTSZV[ZWV`[`W^US\`[ _
O ^SbW_[VW^__[aVTW\^S_WVZX^[Z`[X`WS^`W_[aVTWU^[cZWV
O ^SbW_[VW^__[aV_SW`WSZV[X`W^XW[cUS\SYZW^_SZV`WUV^WZSZV`W_[aVS_[__`W
O bW^[ZW_X[^TVVWZX^[^WXa_ZY`W__W_[X`WT^SbW_[VW `c[aVSW\W[\WcSZ``[cZSZScS^VX[^T^SbW^WbWZ[^W
O WT^SbW_[VW^c[aVS_[TW^WcS^VWVc`_[ZY`WTW_`_WS`S``W`STW`WX^_`Ua`[XX`W[Z`SZVU[Z`Za[a_^WX_`ZY_`S`S_[ZU^WS_W_
_`^WZY`\^[bW_\_]aW
O WZc[VWS`TS``Wc[aVTW[Z[a^WVSZV`[aY`[XS_[YaS^VSZ_\^`_[X`WWS^`_WVZY[^`SWZX^[S^
O Wcc[^_\`WS_YaS^VSZ_\^`_
aW_c`WZWW_
O [_SbW^X[^US\`a^WVWZ`[\^WbWZ`TS^TS^SZTWSb[a^
O `W^^WW_`S`W_c[aVX[[c_a`
O [_`^\\ZY[XU[^\_W_W`WV[Y_ST`[X_ZS^ZYS` W_`[ZW_`^[cZS``Ta`WW\ZYUWS^[X W[ZW`^[cZY`W_`[ZW_
O[cTa^S_
O [VW_WU^S`[Z[X`W\W_
O [VWbS_`S`ZYSZV_[ Ta^ZZY`WU^[\_[X`WWZWW_
O W_[VW^_S^WS[cWV`[`SWSWS _c[^`[XS^bW_`
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
8/24
XXW^WZUWTW`cWWZ^WW_SZVS^TS^SZ_
O ^WWXY`ZY^WWUb_`^XWTWUSa_WZ`W^ZSSZVV[W_`UZS`a^SX^WZV_
O ^WWXY`ZYTS^TS^SZ_cS^TWUSa_WX[^WYZSZVW`W^ZSZS`a^SWZWW_
O ^WW_S^WY[[VSZVUbWV`WSbWU[[Z WY[ZSZV`W`Z[X^WWUWS_`W^[cZSZV
O WcU[^^WU`XW[c^WW_ZSX^WZVcSSU`Z`W_\^`[XU[^^WU`[Z
W[_[\W^^aW^
S`_S\[_[\W^
O S`[X^_`_S_WV[W_Z SbW`[_[c WVWSUSZTW\a`Z\^SU`UWS\SZ`W^\SZ`_S\U`a^W[XSZVWSTWSa`XaSZ_WSZc[^_ TWUSa_WWUSZZ[`
_[W`S`_aUSSZU[aV^WSW_
O S`[`WZ_S_W_VWS_`S`WUSZZ[`U[W`[XWaZ`\[_[\W^_TWU[WZY_[X`Wc[^V
O \[_[\W^_SSZc[[bW_c_V[[\SWS^ZZYZ[cWVYWSZV`^a`
O W\[_[\W^a_`TW\S__[ZS`WST[a`Z[cWVYWZ[`\UWa_`TWZ`W^W_`WVZSS_\WU _[XZ[cWVYW
O W\[_[\W^a_`[bW`[_WW`W ^a`
O ^a`SZVc_V[S^WU[ZZWU`WVSZVXS\[_[\W^^WS[bW_c_V[`_ZWUW__S^`S``W[bW`^a`c`S\S__[ZS_[
O S`[VW_U^TW_`^a`TW\SZZYZ[cWVYW
O Z[cWVYW_^WS`WV`[cS`_
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
9/24
O Z[cWVYW_`W[_`\[cW^XaXSUa`
O SUa`_[W`ZY`S`[aUSZ[ZVWZ`XTcS`UZY`_WXXWU`W_Y`SZVWS^ZY
O Z[cWVYWSZV[\Z[ZS^WVXXW^WZ`
O \Z[Z_ZW`W^Z[cWVYWZ[^YZ[^SZUWTa`_[W`ZYZTW`cWWZ
O W[\Wc[S^WZ`W^W_ WVZTWSa`Xa`ZY_SZVa_`SU [Z_Ta`USZZ[`_WWTWSa`Z`_WX[^a_`UWZ`_WX[ZSbW[\Z[Z_
O W[\Wc[S^WZ`W^W_ WVZW`W^ZSaZUSZYZY`ZY_[ZSbWZ[cWVYW
O W[\Wc`Z[cWVYWS^W\[_[\W^_SZV_[aV^aW
WUW__S^US^SU`W^_`U_[XS\[_[\W^
O [bW[XZ[cWVYW
O [bW[X`^a`
O \[_[\W^_[aVZ[`TWY^WWVc`[ZW[ `^aU[ZUW^ZWVST[a``
O [WSZZW__
O [\W``ZW__
O W_[aVZ`^WYS^VaSZXWS_SZ`ZY[XY^WS \[^`SZUW
O Wc[Z`TWSX^SV[XVWS`
O Wc[Z`TWU[cS^V
O a_`TWcWTSSZUWV
O a_`TWYWZW^[a_
O [`T[S`Xa
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
10/24
O a_`TWa_`SZVUbWV
O a_`SbWSY[[VW[^
O ZVc`S_WZ_W[X\^[\[^`[Z
O WXU[Z`^[
O ^WSV`[Xb_[Z
[_[\W^_SbWTWWZU[^ a\`WVZS`[_`W W\^W_WZ`\[_[\W^_USWV
[\_`_S^W\SV`[`WSU\W[\WST[a`[c`[YW`Z`[\[cW^[c`[YW U^[cV_`[W
[a_[SZV_[S`[W\SZ_`W^WS_[Zc\[_[\W^_S^W_WWZS_a_WW__Z`W^
_[UW`
S^W\[_[\W^_S`WVZS`[__[UW`
O Wa_W_ WSZS[Y[XST[S``[W\SZc_[UW`_WW_\[_[\W _S_a_WW__
O [TWSTW`[ZSbYS`WST[S`[aZWWVUW^`SZ__SZV`WZWWV`[TW`SaY`SZV`WS_`[TW_WZ`_`aVZY`
O WU^Wc[ZST[S`^WWU``WVWS`S`ZSbYS`[Z___a_`TW`SaY``^WS`WZZY [a^VW^SZ[ZWc[_S_`USZ
O WU^Wc W[bW`W ^bS_SZXSU`[Z`S`[\\[_W_`W
O ZWSZV^aY_`WUS\`SZ[^X[^UW_[XX
O _SZcZ[cZSbYS`W`WT[S`WSZSS`Wa^
O WU^WcSV^W_`_SZ\^S_ZY__WSSZ_\`[`WWbW^[ZWW_Wa_a_WW__
O WSbWZ[VWS`S`S`^aWZSbYS`[^a_ Z[c`W_WS_`W_`S^_ WcZV_
O WSbWZ[VWS`S` WS^WTWZYZSbYS`WVTSZSS`Wa^
O W_[\_`_S^W`W_WSS`Wa^_
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
11/24
O `^aW\[_[\W^_[aVZ[`SbW`[TWYX[^\W[\W [`SW_V^WU`[Z
O SSYW`[\[_[\_V[ZWT`[_Wc[\^W`WZV`[\^SU`_W`
O [[V]aS`W__aUS_Y[[V[[_cWS`\[cW^Xa_[USSZVXSU[ZZWU`[Z_^aZSZVV_`^SU`S\[_[\W^
O bWZXSSZS_S W\^Wb[a_Y[[V]aS`W_[XS\[_[\W^WcTWU[^^a\`WVTS_[\_`
O W[aZYSZcTW[bWVT W\[\aS^`\^S_WTSWU^[cV_`S` W_[\_`Zb`W_SZVWcTWYZSY^WWZYc`\[\aS^VWS_^S`W^`SZ
`ZZY`ZY_`^[aY_WXSZV[[ZYX[^`^a`SZVZ[cWVYW
O W\aZ_WZ`_SZVVWS``[`[_Wc[c[Z`_`WZ`[`WcS_[U[^^a\``W[aZYSZZ`[TWZYWS_[\_`
O __TSVS_[\_`_`WSUZ[`ZYTa`U[ZbWZ`[ZSbWc_WVSZVW\^W__WVT`WS__[X`W\W[\W`WWW`
O _[\_`USZZ[``WTW`cWWZY[[VZW__SZV^Y`SZVc^[ZY
O W_WSSZZUS^YW[XS^YWSZSWUSZ`W[a[c`[_[[`WSZVSZZ[`T[[ZYS``_ZS`a^WTa`WUSZ``W[ac`WSZSSU`_`_
cS[^cUSU`[Z_S^WY[[V[^TSVcU[ZW_S^WZWUW__S^SV^STW
a_WXa
O W[aZY\[_[\W^c[aVTW[bWVT`W_[\_`_SZV`[_WS^[aZV
O [_WS^[aZV_WWZY_Y[[V]aS`W_c`^`[a_WX[^`W^[cZ\a^\[_W_TXZYc`XS``W^
O _XS``W^cSW\^VWXa
O bWZX_[W[ZWV[W__[c`W^Y`\S`_U[\SZ[Z_cZ[`_a\\[^`
O W^WX[^WWUSZZWbW TWU[WS\[_[\W^
O [TWS\[_[\W^[aa_`TWT^[aY`a\`W^Y`cSSZVZ[`TWZXaWZUWVTc^[ZY_[a^UW_
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
12/24
[cS\[_[\USWSVW^USZW_`
O W^W_Z[W_`ZY_[UW`ZS`[_`WcW^WS\[_[\USZS`a^WUSZ_a^bbW
O W[Z_[UW``S`_Y[[VWZ[aY_S`[_^W\aTU
O V^WZ_[aV[ZTWYbWZ`W\[_[\US`^SZZY`WUSZaZVW^_`SZV
O V^WZ_[aVVWb[`W`W_WbW_`[`W T[VW_
O WZ`WS^W[^WS`a^W`W^WZ`S ^SZZY_[aVTWZU^WS_WV
O WZ`W^W_ ^WZY`XS_Y^[c[V`Wc[ZU[ZUWZ`^S`W[Z\[_[\
O Z`W^W\aTUaS^VSZ_a_`TW\[_[\W^_
O [aa_`c[^a_`S_S^V[Z[a^\_US`^SZZYS_[a Z`WWU`aS[ZW
O [TWSaS^VSZ[aa_ TW`W_`WV [_WWX[aUSZ\a^_aW`WYW_ X[^[XZ[cWVYW
O WYW_`X[^[XZ[cWVYW_ WX[^_
WX[^_
S`_Y[[V
O \[_[\W^a_`Z[ccS`_Y[[V
O ^VZS^\W[\W`Z`S`\WS_a^W_`WY[[V
O S`[V_SY^WW__SZY S``W^WS^WTSV\WS_a^W_
O WS_a^WUSZZ[`TW[[VTWUSa_W`_TSVSZVY[[VS``W_SW`W
O `[aY_[W`ZY_S\\WS^`[TWY[[V`_TW``W `[SbW_[W`ZY`S`_^WSY[[V
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
13/24
O [\_`US`WV\W[\WTWWbWZ[cWVYW_`WY[[V
O S`[VW_U^TW_Y[[Vc``W_W[X`W_aZ
O WX[^[X[[V_W`W_aZ
O W_aZ_`W_[a^UW[XY^[c`SZVY`WY[[V_`W_[a^UW[X`^a`SZV^WS`
O W_aZYbW_b_T``[[TWU`_WY[[VYbW_aZVW _`SZVZY`[ [aY`
O Z[cWVYWSZV`^a`S^W`[Y[[VcS`_aZ_ZWSZV_Y`S^W [`W_aZ
O aZ_ZW_USa_WVT`W_aZWZ[cWVYW_USa_WVTY[[V
O W_aZ_`WXSUa`[X_Y`WY[[V_`WXSUa`[XZ[cWVYW
WVbVWVZW
O WZ`S_ S`W_S^WVbVWVTX[a^_aT_WU`[Z_
O Z`WYWZUW`__XaaZVW _`SZVZY`_`Wb_[Z[Xa S`W`^a`WSUWVTVSWU`U_\WWU
O WS_[Z`W\^[UWVa^W[XS WS`U_VWVaU bW
O WWXU[[Z_WZ_WTWWX_[Z\_US`ZY_WZS`a^S_UWZUW_TWUSa_W`WUSZZWbW^^WSUa S`W`^a``WS^W[ZU[ZUW^ZWVc``ZY_Z W
USZYWSTWc[^V
O a_[Z W\W^UW\`[Z[X_SV[c_SZV^WXWU`[Z_
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
14/24
WZ`WYWZ`^WS`WX[^_
O S`WS`U_V[W_Z[`W_`Z`Wb_TWc[^V[aUSZZ[`_WWZaTW^_
O WZ[a Z[XXYa^W_[aS^W`ZZY[X`W[^YZS_cU`W^W_WTW
O WZ[aV^ScS_]aS^W[aS^W[ZV^ScZYS[VWW^WXWU`[Z_ZcS W^`W^WS[TWU`_[XZbW_`YS [ZS^W[Zb_TW`[`WWW[X^WS_[Z
O SWU`U`SW_S\S^`S__a\`[Z_`T^WS_VWS_V[cZ`[`W_`S^`ZY\[Z`SZVcWZ`S`VWS_aZVW^_`[[V``WZ[bW_X[^cS^V`SZY`WSUU[Z_W]aWZUW
`[TaVa\SU[ZUa_[Z
O SWU`UV[W_Z`a_W\_USS``W^_`[bW_`^[aYX[^_
O UWZUWUSZZ[`TW^WS_[ZTWUSa_W``SW_S__a\`[Z_S_XSU`
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
15/24
S`[_USbW
O S`[_USbWVW_U^TW_YZ[^SZUW[X[a^aSZU[ZV`[Z
O \[_W_ W\^[TW[XTWWXSZVa_[Z
O W[\W`WZV`[`^a_``W^_WZ_W_SZVS`[_[c_`WX[[_ZW__[X`S`
O WUSZ^W\SUWS`[_USbWc``_[VW^ZVSUZWS`WVSYW_S^W`W_SV[c_[Z`WcSa_[Z_`[^WSXW
O S`[_[c_`WZ`WWU aSY^[c`[X_[W[ZWc[bW_SXW[Xa_[ZSZVTWWXZ`[SXW[X\[_[\
OWUSbW_SZW`WZVWVW`S\[
O bW^`ZYcW_WW_\W XWU`^WXWU`[Z_[X`Wa S`W[^_cU_aT_W]aWZ`^W\^W_WZ``^a`SZV^WS`
O Z__`[^S`[W_`ST_W_SUSbWZcU\^_[ZW^_S^WUSZWVV[cZSZVX[^UWV`[[[a\[Z`WX^[Z`cS[X`WUSbW
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
16/24
O WS^WZVS^ZW__[XT[aZV`[`WX[[^SZVaZSTW [`a^Z`W^WSV_`[_WWcS`Y[W_[ZTWZV`W
O [`WTSU[X`W\ _[ZW^_W`W\a\\W`WW^_c[US_`_SV[c_[Z`WcScU`W\^_[ZW^_\W^UWbWS_^WS`
O W\^_[ZW^_aZSTW [`a^Z`W^WSV_c[aVZ[cZ[`ZYW_WTa``W_SV[c_SZV\W^UWbW`_S_`W^[cZ^WS`
O __[c_a_`S`cS`cW\W^UWbWS_^WSX^[T^`_U[\W`WXS_WTS_WV[Z[a \W^XWU`Z`W^\^W`S`[Z_[X^WS`SZV[[VZW__
O ZUW`W\ _[ZW^_^WWS_WVW_X[^UWV`[[[a\[Z`WX^WSZV[TWU`_`S`[ZUWVU S`WV_\W^UW\`[Z[X^WS`SZVW`a_^WSW_`W_WZWcSYW_Z
X^[Z`[XS^WZ[c WSUUW\`WVX[^_[X^WS`
O S`[VW_U^TW_`Wb_[Z[X`W^WS ^a``[TWSUZY`[`WWW_[X`W\^_[ZW^_SZV[c`Wc[aVZS`a^STWZUZWV`[Y[ZYTSUSZVbWcZYcS``WSbWScS__WWZS_S\WS_SZ`SZV\SZW__SUUW\`SZUW[X`^a`
O __`SYW[X`ZZY_Z[`WVS_TWWX
O WXWS^[X WaZ^WU[YZWV[a`_VWc[^Vc[aV^W_a`Z`W\^_[ZW^TWZYX[^UWV`[UT`W_`WW\S_UWZ`[X`WUSbWSZV_`W\[a`_VWZ`[`WT^Y`_aZ
O ZUW`W\ _[ZW^UT_[a`[X`WUSbWSZV_XaW _WVZ`W_aZ_^S_[U^S`W_U[Z`ZaW_`[W\SZ`W\ _[ZW^_TWcVW WZ`XWS^SZVTZVZW__ [`W[TWU _WcS_Z[cTWZY`[VcW^W^WS
O WZS`a^S^WSU`[Z[X`W\^_[ZW^c[aVTW`[^WU[YZW_SV[c_SZV^WXWU`[Z_X`W^_WW_SVa_ `[`W_aZY`WTWYZ_`[_WW`W_SZV
\W[\WZ`W^[cZW_`WZUW
O _^WU[YZW_`WU[YZ`bW_`SYW\^[UW__[X`[aY`
O WZ`W\ _[ZW^[[_a\`[`W_SZV[[_Z`[ WaZSZV^WU[YZW_`S_`WUSa_W[XS`S`_S^[aZVWS_\W^UWbWV`W[^[X`W[[V
O _\[Z`Z`W\S__SYWS^_`WUSS_`W\ _[ZW^c[Z[`[ZYSY[cS_TZV`[`W[^[X`W[[VS_cWS_`WTS_U [^_ZYWZW^SZ[c_ScS^W[X^WS`SZV`^a`
O WZ`_S_[UUa^^WV`Wa`S`W_`SYW[X`[aY`S_TWWZSUWbWVSZV`S`_aZVW^_`SZVZY
O WZ]a^W_c[aV`W\^_[ZW^cSZ``[^W`a^Z`[`WX[^W^SUUW\`WV^WS`[X`^a`[ c_U[Z`WZ`[ZWZX[[cZY_ZWcaZVW^_`[[V\W^UW\`[Z
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
17/24
[X^WS`[`SaU[ZSZV[U^S`W_SY^WW`W\^_[ZW^c[aV^S W^_aXXW^SZXS`W`SZ^W`a^ZZY`[_\^Wb[a_XW
O \[Z^W`a^ZZY`[`WSbW`W[`W^\^_[ZW^_SaYS``W^WWS_WV\^_[ZW^SZV^VUaWX[^ SZY`Wa_WW__S_UWZ`[a`[X`WUSbWZ`WX^_`\SUW
[_`_ST``[_WW_SV[c_S_cWS_`W[`W^_
O W[`W^_USZZ[`aZVW^_ SZV_[W`ZY`WSbWW``[W\W^WZUW_[`_a\
`[`_\^_[ZW^`[^W\^W_WZ`WSVW^_\X[^`_S[ZWc[_U[Z_U[a_[X
Y[[VZW__`_S``_\[Z``S`S`[VW_U TW_`W\[_[\W^ZY_c[SbW^WU[YZWV`W[^_[X[[VZW__S_SbZYSVa``[TW^W_\[Z_TWWSVW^_SZV
`[Z[`XWWU[Z`W\`X[^`[_Wc[V[Z`_S^W_WZY`WZWZ`
VaUS`[Z[X`W[_[\W^
O _UV^WZ`W_[aVTW`^SZWVX[^cS^
O WcSbW\_US`^SZZY`W^S`a^WSZVa_U
O WcZWWVS`WS`U_TWUSa_WWbW^\^SU`USSZV_UWZ`XUSU`b`^W]a^W_`
O WcZWWVXbWS`WS`USV_U\ZW_
^`W`UU[aZ`ZYSZVUSUaS [ZT[`WSV`WZVZ`[`^a`[VW _USZa_W``[[^YSZW`W S^W_\[_[\W^__[`WUSZUSUaS`W[\W_`W
ZV`[a_W\a^W`[aY``[YW``[`^a`W[\Wc[S^WY[[VS`USUaS`[Z_S^W
]aUS`WS^ZZY[`W^`ZY_
SZWYW[W`^ZcS^a_WXaX[^Z[cZY[c`[\`UUS\[^`SWa\\[_`[ZZ`W^_[X\[_[\YW[W`^U_S\W_S^WW`W^ZS`WV^WU``W
\[_[\W^_^WS_[Za\cS^V_
[VYW[W`^ZVWbW[\WVZS`[_ WS`[_S_ S``W_`S`W_[aVW\[^W`[^W
_`^[Z[\W^UW\`[ZZ`WZY W[Z`__WS_[Z_SZVWS _^SZ`WZV`[`ZST_`^SU`WVW__a_`^S`[Z_`[`W_`aV[X`^aW^WS`[`^aW
\^[Y^W__USZTWSVWS``W[WZ`
S^[ZU_WS_`^[Z[Z[`^aW\^[Y^W__USZTWSVWS `W[WZ`
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
18/24
O WSZX[Ua__[Z WZVc` Wb_[Z[X[[VS_`Wa`S`W[TWU`bW
O WcZWWV`^SZZYZ\a^W\[_[\SWU`U
O WS^ZZYSWU`U_^WS WV`[S`[_USbW`_`W\[Z`cW^W`WSZ[[_S``W_aZWXZV_`WX[^[XY[[V
O SWU`U_S\^[UW__[X^S`[ZSS^YaWZ``^WW_[Z^WS_[Zc`[a`SZSVX^[`W_WZ_W_
O SWU`UWSZ_V_Ua__[Z
O SWU`U_U^`US[XSS__a\`[Z_SZV`VW_ ^[_`WSZV`^W_`[c[^[a`cS`WSU`ZY_Z`_WX
O ^WU`]a[`W
O WVSWU`USZUSZ`W^WX[^WXZV`WW__WZ`SZS`a^W[X`ZY_
O W^W_Z[_`aVST[bW`WVSWU`UW`[V
WWU`[Z[X^aW^_SZV`WUa^^Uaa
O WcU[[_W`W^^aW^_c[cTWYaS^VSZ_c[cTW\[_[\W^_T[[ZYS``W_`WSVW_`SZVT^SbW_`SZVTW_`[[ZY
O WcS_[[[S``W^[^SZ`WY^`SZV`[aYZW__
O WZWWVSZS`a^SS\``aVWX[^`WWVaUS`[ZS`[cSZ`_`[YbW`W
O Z`WWU`aSWSYW^ZW__
O a_`WS^ZWS_
O [[VW[^W_VW`W^ZS`[ZSZVSX[ZVZW__X[^S^Vc[^
O WZWWV`[TWZ`WWU`aSSZVW\_USc[^[`W^c_W WS^WU^\\WV
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
19/24
O S`WS`U__[aVTW`SaY`[aZYTa` Wc[Z`X[^UW`W`[WS^Z`WW__[Z_cTWYbWZZ`WX[^[X\S
O WcS_[V[\_US`^SZZY`_U[\a_[^SZV`WTW`SWZ`[cS`UTS``W_`Wc[[X[^`[_W[_`U[X[^`STWc``
O [c`W\W X[^Z\_US`^SZZYcS_[TWa_WV`[`W_ `W
O ``cWZ`_[W[X`WcTW\^[[`WV
O ``^``[_Wc[_[c`WY^WS`W_`\W^_WbW^SZUWZ`W^_`aVW_[XcS^SZV[`W^Va`W_cTW\^[[`WV
O S`[_S_`S``WVSWU UUSZV[S^ [`WaZ`^SZWVZV`X_`Wc`ZV_U\ZW
O WcWS^ZUW^`SZ[\Z[Z_SZVVWS_Va^ZYUV[[VcWZTWZY`^SZWVZ`WVSWU`US_aZVW _`SZVZY_cTW`[^Z`[_^WV_T`[_WST[bW
SZVWcY^[cT``W^[X`
O WcTWU[WS^WTWTWUSa_WWc_WWZ[VXXW^WZUWTW`cWWZbSaW_W^Y`SZVc^[ZY[Z[a^SZVV_Y^SUW
O X`WS^W[aZYSZV`Wa_W`WVSWU`UW [V`WSTa_W`SZVa_W`ZSV_Ua__[Z_SZVXZV_WXSZV`[_WS^[aZV[X`WZ\^[bWVc^[ZY_[
W_`S^`TWWbZY`S`Z[`ZY_`^aW
O `_TW``W^`[`WSU_[W[ZWc[_[VW^S_`WS^W[^W^WS_[ZSTWSZVca_W`WVSWU`UW`[V^W_\[Z_T
O [SX`W \_US`^SZZY`WSbWXbWWS^_[XZ`WZ_bW\[_[\
O X`WWZWS^_SX`W^`S``Wa_`[VS`S^[^\^SU`US\[_`[ZS`[W]aS`W_``[_WZVZY`WSZTSUZ`[`WUSbW
O WZ`WS^WXX``[_Wc[SbW\S__WV`W\^SU`USSZVZ`WWU aS`W_`c_\WZV`W^W_`[X`W^XWZ\[_[\
O WWSV_[UW`Z^[`S`[Z`WTWU[WaW^_TWUSa_W`_`W^ZWUW__``W^Va`Z[`TWUSa_W`WcSZ``[
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
20/24
O WZ`WbWXZ_WV`W^UUW`W^W`^WS``[SZ_SZVSZVTWU[WY[VW`^WS`WVWVbZ`W_
\W^XWU`[UW`W_
O [a^VXXW^WZ`_[UW`W_
O `W[`W^_[UW`W_S^Wc^[ZY
O WX[a^VXXW^WZ`_[UW`W_S^WW]aS`[X[a^VXXW^WZ` \W[X\W[\W
O W^WS^WXbW`\W_[XZVbVaSUS^SU W^_
S^U
O W\S^`SZ_
O `S^S^_`[U^SUbZYZS_WX\[\aS`[Z
O [\W^_[Z_S[cWV`[SbW\W^_[ZS\[__W__[Z_SZV`W[cW^US__W_c[^WUa_bWX[^`WTWZWX`[X`Wa\\W^US__W_
O S`[VW_U^TW_[c`W^VWS_`S`WUSZYW_`[SS^U
O WVWS_`S`WUSZYW_TWUSa_W`W^W_Ub_ ^XWS[ZY`W^aZYUS__
O W[^VW^cSWSVZY`[YaS^VSZ_S`ZY`Wc^[ZYZV[X\W[\W
O WUV^WZcTWaZYX`WV
O WcZ[`bSaW`W^ ^SZZYSZVcZWYWU `
O aW^_cTWS\\[Z`WV S`SbW[_``WaS^VSZ___
O WcSZ`\^[\W^`[ZW
O _cWSV`[_`^XWSZVcS^
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
21/24
O `[aY`__`S Wc[aVSbW]aS`W_WS`[_\W^XWU`_`S`W^W_\WU`X[^Sa`[^`S``WZ`[Z`[\_USSZV`S^`^SZZYW`U
O [cWbW Z_`WSV[X[VZYZ`WYWZUWS_`W[_`\[^`SZ`US^SU W^_`UX[^S`^SZW^`Wc\^WXW^cS^WZ
O Wc\^WXW^^aW _c[S^W_\WWS^`SZVSbW`^U_SZV_`^S`WY_
`S`S^WZWWVWVZcS^
O W^WcS_[TWS_`^[ZYTa`VVWZ\S__[ZX[^[ZW
O WUSa_W`WSbW`[VW`W^[bWX[^[ZW`WcTW_SZVU^aWST[a``
O WcWZ[`W^\WS_a^W_Z_WU^W`Sb[VZY`WScTWUSa_W`WSbWZWYWU`WV`W`^aW\^ZU\W_[X\[_[\
O [_`\[^`SZ`XWS`a^W_T`[ZSZVSU[\W``bW_\^`
S^US^SU`W^
O T`[a_SZVU[\W``bW
O WXcWVSZVW__WVaUS`WV
O `W`U
O ZW^YW`U
O ^W`[ZZW^aZUW^`SZ`SZVU[ZXU`
O WSV`[_`WZTa`aZSTW [W\^W___WX
OWcTWS^_`[__SbW_TWUSa_W[X_\W^XWU`WVaUS`[Z
O WZ[aZYWVW_\_W[ZWTa`S_WY^[c_[VW^WccSZ``[^W
O _XS`W cZ[`TWWWZZSZY[ZWST`[a_[^\[`US\W[\Wc_SZVW X[^`W WT[_[`W^SZV`W_W^bSZ`_SZV\W[\W[a`_VW
O W_WW_`S`\W[\WW_XS`W^V[Z`YW`aU[Z[a^[^Y[^
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
22/24
O W_`[^ZT`c[ZXaWZUW__XS`W^_^S`[ZSZS`a^WSZV[`W^\W[\W_VWS[XST`[Z
O WU[[_W_`WVVWY^[aZV_[WS_S_\`US^SU`W^ZU[ZXU`W`W_[UW`_\`TW`cWWZ^USZV\[[^
O `[a`[ZW[a[_WWbW^`ZY_[US_`SZVZY__[[Z
YS^UUUS^SU`W^
O ^aWYS^U_cS`TWUSWZ[cZZ`W_`S`W_S_US\`S_ZcUWbW^[ZWc[^_X[^`W^[cZ\W^_[ZSYSZ
O [W[TWU``[SW[ZW
O S^UUX[c_Z`[[YS^UU
O WS^UUSZS_S_[Zc[SV^W__XS`W^SZVX[[c_Z_X[[`_`W\_
O W_[Z_WW__XS`W^c^WUWVZ_[W\[`USV_S_`W^
O WZ[[ZYW^bSaW_U[a^SYWSZVST`[Z
O WVaUWV [\[bW^`WS_`[WS^Z_bZY_[c
O WcWS^ZSX[^`aZWSZVY[X^[ST`[a_ [Y^WWV
O WcTWWU[Z[USSZVS^Vc[^ZYTa c_S`_X[Z_ZWUW__S^cSZ`_^W\^W__[`W^VW_^W_
O SU[XSZWVaUS`[ZT^WWV_TSVVW_^W_S`[aY`WS^W^W\^W__WV
O SVVW_^W_^W\^W__WVX[^TSV^WS_[Z_X[^WS\W_[ZW_`c[aVTW^aWVTXWS^[X[_ZYTa_ZW__
O \WZV`W[ZW[X[`W^_
O aS\W^_[ZS`ZWbW S`\WSUWc`_WX_TW``W^VW_^W_S_`W^`Wc[^_W
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
23/24
W[U^SU
O WX[^[XW[U^SUZ[cZTS [cS_cVVXXW^WZ``[`[VS_ZS^WW_`S`W[ZS_S_WU`[Z[X`W\[\aS`[Z\[__T\W[\WX^[SU``W_W[X`WZ_SV Wb[`WTa`WSU[ZW[X`W_W\W[\WcS_S[cWV
`[_`ZY[bW^ZWZ`SZVV_Ua__WY_S`[Z
O ]aS`[X\[`US[\\[^`aZ`SZVX^WWV[X[^`WZVbVaS
O YS^UY[W_Z`[VW[U^SUTWUSa_W`W^W_SU[X^W_ ^SZ`Z`W\a^_a`[XYW``ZYS_^US_\[__TW
O W^aW^_WZU[a^SYWW`^SbSYSZUWcUWSZ_[aZYWZ[X`WZTWU[W\[[^SZVZVWT`
O W_WWZTWU[WSZY^[X`[_Wc[SbWVW\^bWV`W[X`W^\^[\W^`
O [ZYX[^^Wb[a`[Z
O W[ZWSW^_SW[^W[SZ_SZVVWSZVY^S`W_WS_ZY`[ZU^WS_WZ\[[^TWYYS^_
O WcTWU[WVWcSZ``[_[[`W W^\SZ\WS_a^W
W[U^S`US^SU`W^
O WSZ[YS^UUUS^SU`W^cSbWS_[Z
O W_`^SZX^[\WS_a^W_ S`WSV`[W\WZ_W^S`W^`SZ\^[X`
O WT[YW`_S`S_`W[X`W_WX[^TVVWZ\WS_a^W__WTSVX[[V
O W`_U^`U__X^[_XSTa`_a\\[^`X^[X^WZV_WSVZY`[ZZW^U[ZXU`
O _ZV_XWVc`[\Z[Z_SZV_ZX[^S`[Z
O \WZV_S[`[X`WSZVWXX[^`[ZaZZWUW__S^VW_^W_
O WWbW_S\WS_a^W_S^WW]aSSZV_[aVSbWW]aS^Y`_
-
8/6/2019 Notes on the Republic by Plato - Chapters 5 to 9
24/24
O WbW_X^[VS`[VSZVaYZY`W\WS_a^W[X`W[WZ`[ZWVSc[WZSZVcZW`WZW`cS`W SZVS_`^U VW`
O WTWWbW_W_X^WWSZVW]aSTa`_^aWVT_VW_^W_Z[[ VW^[^^W_ ^SZ`Z_XW
^SZZ
O [ZXU`[X USZV\[[ ZVW[U^SUWSV_`[S`^SZ`_^_WZ\[cW^S_`W\[\aS US\[Zc`_[cZ\^bS`WS^SZVY^[cZY[\\^W__[Z
O `^SZ`_S_ZYW\W _[Zc[U[Z`^[_S_`S`WcW`W^XS^[ Z[`S`[_SZXSa`c``W`^SZZ_ S``W`^SZ`a_`\^[bW_WX`[TWTW``W^
`SZS[X__aTWU`_`[TWU[Z_VW^WVSc[^`^aW Ta`S_`__\[__TW
`cXS
O YS^UXWVaW`[WUW__VW_^WX[ cWS`
O W[U^SUXS_TWUSa_W[XWUW__VW_^WX[^TW^