notice second division nov 11 2015
TRANSCRIPT
7/24/2019 Notice Second Division Nov 11 2015
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/notice-second-division-nov-11-2015 1/6
REPUBLIC
OF THE
PHILIPPINES
SUPREME
COI.IRT
Manila
SECOND
DIVISION
I{OTICE
Sirs/Mesdames:
Please take
notice
that
ihe Ccurt,
Second
Dittision,
issued
a
Resolution
dated
1 1
November
20L5
which
reads
as
follows:
*G.R.
No.
21925
7
(Alfrecto Y.
Po
vs.
Ombudsman
Conchifa
carpio
Morales
of
the
office
of
the
ombudsman,lYationol
Bureau
of
Investigation
and Ernesto
de
las Sontos).-
Considering
the
allegations,
issues
and arguments
adduced
ih
the
petition
for
review
on
certiorari
assailing
the I)ecision
dated
16
September
2014
and
Resolution
dated
18 June
2015 of
the Court
of
Appeals,
l,zlanila
in
CA=G.R.
SP
No.
130682,
the
Court
resolves
to DENY
the
petition
for
failure
to
sufficiently
show
any
reversible
error in
the
assailed
judgment
to warrant
the exercise
of
this
Court's
discretionary
appellate
jurisdiction,
aud
for
raising
substantially factual
issues.
Brion, J.,
on
leave;
Relses, J.,
designated
acting
member
per
S.O.
No,
2274.
Mendoza,
J.,
on
leave;
Perlas-Bernabe,
J-,
designated
acting
member
per
S.O.
No. 227l.'
Very
truly
yours,
MA.
LOURDES
C.
PERFECTO
Division
Clerk
of
Court
By:
Div
INO-TUAZON,
;i*k #c" **'lfit'/rt'
(23s)
-NTORE.
7/24/2019 Notice Second Division Nov 11 2015
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/notice-second-division-nov-11-2015 2/6
EPUBLIC
OF
THE
PF,IILIPPINES
REGIONAL
TRtrAL
COURT
FIRST
JUDICIAL
REGIOhI
BRANCH
6,
BAGUIO
CITY
THE
PE
LE
PHILIPPI
ES,
P
TI-NE
intiff,
CRIMINAL
CASE
NO.
36gS2.R
(M\TCC
Crirn.
tVo.
730536)
FoT:
PERJURY
s"
ALBI
A
DEC S ON
itled
case
is
an
appeal
from
the
Decislon
dated
ftvtrareh
:10,
ed
by
MTCC
Branch
1,'Baguio
City.
lt
was
naffled
x5
i
on
Nll
h
26,
2015.
Thereafter,
the
parties
we "e
nequired
sn-*irra onnaql
hniefe
Thn nrivate cornnlainAnt'S
eir
appeal
briefs.
The
prlvate
cornplalnant's
to
tl'ris
Co
to submit
appellee
aeeursed
for Judicia
resol'i;tIon
Eispu
nSe
af
sfi
titeO
on
April
27
,
2015
while
the
appellant's
bnief
cf
on
May
21,
2A15.
This
ease
was
erroneoulsly
set
Resolution (JDR)
henee
it
was
only
submitted
fon
mber
9,
2015.
Decision
dated
March
18,
2015
found
aeculsed-
Atbiento
guilty
of the
crime
of
per.lury as
defined
t
perjury
defined
and
penalized
wnder
Articte
vised
Penal
Code.
There
being
na
attendant
ed-appellant
on
November
'15,
2012
before
notary
ne
Rarang
where
he
stated
that
Ernesto
de
los
appellant
under
Arti
of
the
SSAi
rland
n
183
the
Revi?ed
Penal
Code.
The
dispositive
portiont
FORE,
in
conforrnity
with
the
foregoing,
accused
ORLA/VDC
R.
ALB/E,VTO
Euifty
cfifne
the
|s,
the
court
senfences
hirn
to
suffer
an
t
of
indeterminate
penalty
of
30
days
of
rn
ifs
maximum
period
to
2
years
and
4
sof
Cosfs
ainst
the
accused.
DERED."
XO
the
matter
is
the
Salaysay
(sworn
statennent)
executed
acct.t
Rosa
ublic
the
atff
x83
Santos,
acc
n
a
qualified
theft
case
docketed
as
Criminal
I
i
7/24/2019 Notice Second Division Nov 11 2015
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/notice-second-division-nov-11-2015 3/6
(UMI)
o
appelXant
s
against
oath
in
his
la
'{3"
akali,
apli
yon,
ku
pa
kal
png
'f
4.
na
kon
d
CI
es
"4
to'04-E".
o
Atty.
Ernesto
de
/os
Sanfos
sariling
temPorary
electrica
ay
mabilis
na
rneter
pa{:a
sa
ease
Ntro.
Toulrist
Inn
306-
BPTI)
BPTI
uet
uet
,
did
not
steal
electricity
frorn
thre
Benguet
Fine
The
Board
of
Trustees
of
the
university
of
f\ltranila
T',he
instant case
for
perjury against
accused-
by
UM
President
Ennily
de
Leon
orl
May
12,
2A13
lant
for
making
the
followinE
statennents
ulnder
naong
June
2'1,
2007"
x
x
x
tem
rneter
na
sumusukat
sa
konsumao
ng
te
CTLL
Buitding.
Ang
katunaYan
ng
;
ang
dalawang
lingga rnula
sa
nasabing
ng
firoposed
CTLL
buitding
ay
nakabitan
rlg
sariting
rnetro
ng
CTLL
Buf
lding
ay
uyZuy
na
ito
bitang
Annexes
"S" and
"3-A"'
makabitan
ng
sariling
rnetro,
ay
nagsirnwla
Buitding
na
magbayad
na
ng
sarili
nitang
kuryeite.
Ang
katwnayan
ng
kanilang
ay
'katakip
ng
Sataysay
na
ito
bilang
o
.17
pa
Bu
rysay
kong
ito
ay
aking
isinagawa
n'\yq
patinay
ia
sirnula
nang
itayg
a"ng
C.TLL
"ala
bitang
Dely's
lnn,
ay
hindi
ito
kumuha
a
E
kuryente
na
nagdadaaan
sa
tnetra
ng
kaw
Pa
s
Tiurist lnn
o
kumanekta
ng
"ill7gaf"
sa
xxxx
r
the
lower
court
erred
in
finding
llant
made
a
statement
under
8en
ng
nan
Be
t
ita
SA
The
ay
ma
sariii
ning
metro
na
sumusukat
ng
kaniyang
k
uma.
e
Towrist
lnn.
Ang
paggamit
ng
ATLL
Euilding
,rrner
ng
tsenguet
Flnes
a)/
kindi
lugan
ng
Pagnanakaw
nE
kwryente
ng
eJ
sapag
kat
ang
CTLL
Euilding
bago
pa
man
xxxx"
were the
issues
raised
by
the
accused-appefllant
tn
that
the
oath
or
-a
a,
t"ris bni
affidavit
upon
a
material
matter'
rl
i
I
I
I
I
i
I
7/24/2019 Notice Second Division Nov 11 2015
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/notice-second-division-nov-11-2015 4/6
Decisiort
Criminal
Case
i6992-R
"wh
r
the
lowen
court
gravely
erred
that
plie
for
service
connectlon
was
not
in
nGe
y
accused-aPPellant.
in
finding
presented
a
p
ofa
who
CTL
lseho
San
ed-ap
I
who
bui d
5.W
ap
e
W
nga
The
rime
Art.
83.
F
affi
pplied
buildi
owned
by
the
said
Atty.
Ernesto
d,q
los
her
the
lower
count
erred
in
finding
that
the
rllant
made
a
willfui
and
dellbenate
assertlon
f
iln
stating
that
it
was
Ennesto
de
ios
Santos
fon
a
temporary
electric
conneetion
for
the
hen
the
lswer
court
erred
in
tinding that
the
rllant
made
a
willful
arrd
deliberate
assertlon
J
in
statlng
that
it
was
Atty'
Ernesto
de
los
aid
for
the
eleetricity
coRsurRed
by
the
CTI-I-
rer
the
lower
count
erred
in
finding
that
prior
i
"f
tn"
electrical
apptication
of
Atty'
Ernesto
ofa
San
thr
trr(
to
de
SLI
,io*
on
APnil
15,
Z}fi,
he
had
been
y
using/taking
the
electricity
of
the
BpTl'
ther
the
lower
court
erred
in
giving
weight
to
,ts
of
Policanpio
Lacsa
that
he
connected
the
eriod
to
prision correccional
in
its
minimum
6e
imposed
upon
any
person
who,
knowin.gly
I
statements
and
not
being
inclurded
in
the
the
next
preceding
articles,
shall
testify
of
the
CflU
building
to
that
of
BFTi'
ether
the
lower
court
gravely
erred
sed-appellant
of
ttre
cnime
of
perjury'
COURT'S
RULING
per.iury
as
defined
and
penalized
under
Article
reads:
/se
fesfim
ony
in
other
cases
and
periury
.i
nation.
The
penalty
of
arresto
rnayor
in
its
in
183
of
the
max
perit
m
shall
ti
NS
und
oath
make
an
affidavit,
upon
any
material
matten
ii,
'1
I
I
I
I
rii
l
iI
I
I
7/24/2019 Notice Second Division Nov 11 2015
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/notice-second-division-nov-11-2015 5/6
l,
i
I
I
t
Any
lieu
me
of
oath
L/d
aeo
f]
an
oned
lt
that
is
me
petent
person
authorized
to
admlnister
an
in
which
the
law so
requlres'
,
in
case
of
a
solernn
affirmation
made
in
r.
shall
eornmii
L''Y
of
the
.fals-[?: :
,
i-'itil
;ft
ih.
thnee
precedins
antieles
-t
rfi
suffer
the
respective
penalties
il
,I
I
I
./
a)
b)
The
leme
of
perjury
are:
evi
made
a statement
under
oatl"r
on
executed
affi
a
it
upon
a
rnatenial
matter"
;;;;i
ut
affidavit
was
.
made,
,{?:i-:
';ffi[Lt,;rd-il;d
ts
neceive
and
admlnister
nt
sr
affidavit,
the
acctlsed
nrade
a
wlllful
te
assertiorl
of
a
falsehood'
L?;?#;;i.lT
ririJavit
eontaining
the
falsitv
is
by
law
or
made
fon
a
legal
Purpose'
thene
is
aeaused
allegatio
ful
examination
of
the
records'
the
Cotlrt
finds
tha]
lence
directly
sunitantiatlng
the
accusation
thal
t
comnnitted
perjury'
The,
private
eomplaiRantts
cused-appellant"#iliiirv
and
d.eliberately
asserted
e
>ly
her
infenenee";;;ilb
frorm
the
faet
that
aeeused
d
a
Sa/a
ysay
'o
tuuo'
oT
Etneuto
de
los
Santos'
alseho
appella
As
exeeu
WAS
in
the
q
litied
of
th
ateriali
de
los
n
r,
Service
onne
Sa/aYsa
whiah
pointed
out
by
the
accused-appellant'
the
Sa/aysaJ
d
etennn
I
native
fi
h.
;;
i
ri
;ry
;"
; y-
:f
::--P3-1fl
j
_lrxu:'H;;;rJ
ilu:n"sis
to
eonetude
that
the
Sa/aysay
would
serve
to
col'lvict
or
acquit
Es"r'lesto
qualitied
theft
case'
i
Ernesto
Bajo,
a
los
ccused-appellant's
Exhibit
'l'13"
(Applieation
-
fQr
on)
is
a
slarins
"']0"*""
*,^i" y3:;:""lili?*f,:-ft
ffjr:;ft3'ii#r
the
account
was
under
the
name*Q{
iantos.
This
troi
*'=
testitled
to
P-Y,}ryi:
B^?,ll3yl3
'-?il;"""""'
+hd
";hibit
has
been
adn'ritted
in
evidenQe,
th
e
state
rne
nt
;f
";;;";;ut o
n
"witn
911
-9'11*:F3"i
;:
}[:].,5'orJ'*1..,;;'il"d
f9r
fle
service
connectioin.
rt
stated
in
his
satavsav
that
it
J;{EJ:::1fl:,
L4i
1$ifltlpijri"IhJ"
IiJ
ti]"'*
i'
no
farsehood
,??*]"11
'it'
il-
#lo
triilr.
-
ir,"
application
for
temporaiy
BENECO
snows
that
lt
was
under
the
narne
lJ
Santos.
There
;;"
no
falsehood
committed
wh$n
I
and
it
who
Accuse
pel
ated
that
Santos
as
he
ofi
ccn
Ennesto
del
7/24/2019 Notice Second Division Nov 11 2015
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/notice-second-division-nov-11-2015 6/6
aeeused
nt stated
in
hls
Salaysay
that after
the
nret$r
installat
n, the CT[-L
building oommerlced
payment
of
its electrieflll
;cused-appellant based
his
statenrents
on
BEi{EeOp
60RSUrTl
neeords
present
nd
is
not
'
privy
to
whatever
payrnent
arrangem"t u
UM and CTLI-.
lower
eourt
erred
in
passing
upon
the
issue on
whether
Qn
had
=n
a theft
of electricity
use by
Ernesto de
los Santqs
i
is for the
propei
tribunal
to
nule.
upCIn
aft$r
evidence.
The sole issue
in
this
instant
ease
{u
:cused-appellant cornmltted
perjuny
in
his
Salaysay.
" Th
not the
and
B
p "ese
on
of
whether
not
rules tl'r
made
detersml
e
rirninaI
or-r
tsEhl
ion
ase
CO
Il,
the
of
per.
ngl
the
to
the
elements
of the crime
of
perjury,
tl'lis eourt
and third
elements
are
not
present.
The
statennents
l-appelNant
in his Sa/ays ay
are
not nnateria
in
thp
good
fai I
amd
deli
d-appellant
rn
hrs
sa/aysay
are
Rot rnatenal rn
tr]F
the
guilt
or
innocence of
Ernesto
de
[o,s
Santos
iil
r.
32306-R.
Accused-appellant
based his staternent$
*'Ja
,*o Jd;;;G
f{T--';riu**,,t,
were
h;; ;;F
'etation
of
the said
docunnents
and
he
did
not wiilfullp
assert
a
falsehood.
I
I
lourt
finds that
the
accused-appellant
is
not
guiffiy
{t
I
lry'
l
)RE, in view of the foregoing,
.iudgment
is nenderefl
ssailed
Decision
dated
Nltrarch
10, Z}ffi issued
"h[
,
Baguio
City
and
hereby
enters a
new
one
acqulttinp
s and
docurnents.
His
statemerrts were his
ow
tion of
the said
docunnents
and
he
did
not wiilfull
Orlando
Albiento of the crime of
perjuny
as
the
aets
eh
ed do
constitute
perjury.
lrlo costs.
ORDE
ED"
7,
2015.
Bagulo City.
Ct'
s'CS,
GEGIL A
ON
S.
DU
Acting
Presiding
J
EREF
reversi
thre
eflTec-
aecused
ppel
I
,1,
I