nr^kqfq^qfsblkfqlofkdlcprmbocff^i ab^vbslirqflkfkmi^pqboba … · 2015. 11. 15. · oovm=...

9
OOUU SWrucWural Analysis of HisWorical ConsWrucWions – Jerzy Jasieńko (ed) © 2012 DPNH ProcławH PolandH ISSN 0860-2395H ISBN 978-83-7125-216-7 nr^kqfq^qfsb Mlkfqlofkd lc prmbocfCf^i abC^v bslirqflk fk mi^pqboba ^ka rkmi^pqboba lrqallop M^plkov Bitelli dabriele N I Colla Camilla O I dabrielli blena P I dirardi cabrizio 4 I rbertini crancesco R fn masonry materialsI the superficial decay is a widespread problemI both when the masonry is unplastered and with plasterK Aggressive environmental agents such as moisture and salts trigger the damage by propagating through the material capillary poresK Although studies have been carried out on salt crystallization and their damaging effectsI for the preservation of masonry buildingsI due to their high number and to their cultural importanceI it is required to better investigate the phenomena on real cases in their specific microclimaticK cor these purposesI it would be important to have at disposal testing and monitoring tools capable of following the evolution of these processes since the beginningK oepeated visual inspections are commonly used to monitor the superficial decay but this is a subjective and qualitative techniqueK ft would be important to apply image based diagnostic techniques capable of providing quantitative informationK eighJresolution laser scanning by triangulation technique of the masonry surface has the advantage of being contactless and rapidK fn an experimental set up in BolognaI ftalyI largeJsize brick masonry walls were builtI stored outdoors and exposed to weathering over O summersK fn a OJheader brick wallI one main face is unplastered and one plasteredK Before the start of the second ageing seasonI moisture and salt capillary rise was simulated by lowJconcentrated sodium chloride solution EMKNB JwtFK qhe aim was to favour solution evaporation and salt crystallization and provoke material damageK Pa data acquisition by a triangulation laser scanning system was repeated at the end of both seasons and meshes derived from point clouds data comparedK qhe proposed procedure successfully extracted quantitative information about areas of material spalling and detachment even in the initial phases of decayK heywords: MonitoringI aecayI MasonryI iaser scannerI mlaster NK fkqolarCqflk ^ka obpb^oCe obnrfobMbkqp qhe material decay caused by aggressive environmental agents is a widespread problem in masonry surfaces both when they are unplastered and with plasterK qhese degradation processes are mainly caused by water which may penetrates into the material pores in different ways such as by capillarityI percolation or vapourK qhe water is also responsible of the transport of dissolved salts Eeventually presentF which during brine evaporation may precipitate as crystals on the external material surfaces or beneath themK ft is the increase in size of the salt crystals inside the pores to cause tensions eventually to overpass the material resistance threshold xNI OzK qhis phenomenaI although common in masonry materials is rather complex as the resulting damage is due to the interaction ofsalts with the specific environmental conditionK peveral studies have been carried out on salt crystallization and their damaging effects in porous materials but they are mainly aimed at investigating the behaviour of single material units by means of laboratory analysis xPI 4zK fn additionI open questions are still remaining iKeK about the correlation between results from accelerated aging test and the real natural damage in structures or about proper N mrofKI afCAj aeptKI bngineering cacultyI rniversity of BolognaI gabrieleKbitelli]uniboKit O arKI CfofJbC and afCAj aeptKI bngineering cacultyI rniversity of BolognaI camillaKcolla]uniboKit P mhKaK studentKI afCAj aeptKI bngineering cacultyI rniversity of BolognaI elenaKgabrielli4]uniboKit 4 arKI afCAj aeptKI bngineering cacultyI rniversity of BolognaI fabrizioKgirardi]uniboKit R mrofKI afCAj aeptKI bngineering cacultyI rniversity of BolognaI francescoKubertini]uniboKit

Upload: others

Post on 11-Dec-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: nr^kqfq^qfsblkfqlofkdlcprmbocff^i ab^vbslirqflkfkmi^pqboba … · 2015. 11. 15. · OOVM= qh=wal=w=xpos==atur=eather=E=t=microclimat==BolognI=krthe=fF==O= summe=urtheI=fo=t=star==th=secon=agein=seasonI=moistur=an=sal=apill=ri=f=t=

=

OOUU=

SWrucWural Analysis of HisWorical ConsWrucWions – Jerzy Jasieńko (ed) © 2012 DPNH ProcławH PolandH ISSN 0860-2395H ISBN 978-83-7125-216-7

nr^kqfq^qfsb Mlkfqlofkd lc prmbocfCf^i abC^v bslirqflk fk mi^pqboba ^ka rkmi^pqboba lrqallop M^plkov Bitelli dabrieleNI Colla CamillaOI dabrielli blenaPI dirardi cabrizio4I rbertini crancescoR fn= masonry= materialsI= the= superficial= decay= is= a= widespread= problemI= both= when= the= masonry= is=unplastered=and=with=plasterK=Aggressive=environmental=agents=such=as=moisture=and=salts=trigger= the=damage=by=propagating= through=the=material=capillary=poresK= Although=studies= have=been=carried=out=on=salt= crystallization=and= their= damaging=effectsI= for= the=preservation= of= masonry=buildingsI=due= to=their=high=number=and=to=their=cultural=importanceI=it= is=required=to=better= investigate=the=phenomena=on =real =cases =in =their =specific =microclimaticK =cor =these =purposesI =it =would =be =important =to =have =at =disposal= testing=and=monitoring=tools=capable=of=following=the=evolution=of=these=processes=since=the=beginningK=oepeated=visual=inspections=are=commonly=used=to=monitor=the=superficial=decay=but=this=is=a= subjective= and= qualitative= techniqueK= ft= would= be= important= to= apply= image= based= diagnostic=techniques= capable= of= providing= quantitative= informationK= eighJresolution= laser= scanning= by=triangulation=technique=of=the=masonry=surface=has=the=advantage=of=being=contactless=and=rapidK=fn=an=experimental=set=up=in=BolognaI=ftalyI=largeJsize=brick=masonry=walls=were=builtI=stored=outdoors=and=exposed=to=weathering=over=O=summersK=fn=a=OJheader=brick=wallI=one=main=face=is=unplastered=and=one= plasteredK= Before= the= start= of= the= second= ageing= seasonI= moisture= and= salt= capillary= rise= was=simulated=by=lowJconcentrated=sodium=chloride=solution=EMKNB=JwtFK=qhe=aim=was= to=favour=solution=evaporation= and= salt= crystallization= and= provoke= material= damageK= Pa= data= acquisition= by=a=triangulation=laser=scanning=system=was=repeated=at=the=end=of=both=seasons=and=meshes=derived=from=point=clouds=data=comparedK=qhe= proposed= procedure= successfully= extracted= quantitative= information= about= areas= of= material=spalling=and=detachment=even=in=the=initial=phases=of=decayK===heywords: MonitoringI aecayI MasonryI iaser scannerI mlaster NK fkqolarCqflk ^ka obpb^oCe obnrfobMbkqp =qhe=material= decay=caused=by=aggressive=environmental=agents= is=a=widespread=problem=in=masonry=surfaces= both= when= they= are= unplastered= and= with= plasterK= qhese= degradation= processes= are= mainly=caused=by=water=which=may=penetrates=into=the=material=pores=in=different=ways=such=as=by=capillarityI=percolation= or= vapourK= qhe= water= is= also= responsible= of= the= transport= of= dissolved= salts= Eeventually=presentF=which=during=brine=evaporation=may=precipitate=as=crystals=on=the=external=material=surfaces=or=beneath=themK=ft=is=the=increase=in=size=of=the=salt=crystals=inside=the=pores=to=cause=tensions=eventually=to=overpass= the=material= resistance=threshold= xNI=OzK= qhis=phenomenaI= although=common= in=masonry=materials=is=rather=complex=as=the=resulting=damage=is=due=to=the=interaction=of=salts=with=the=specific=environmental=conditionK=peveral= studies= have= been= carried= out= on= salt= crystallization= and= their= damaging= effects= in= porous=materials=but=they=are=mainly=aimed=at=investigating=the=behaviour=of=single=material=units=by=means=of=laboratory= analysis= xPI= 4zK= fn= additionI= open= questions= are= still= remaining= iKeK= about= the= correlation=between=results=from=accelerated=aging=test=and=the=real=natural=damage=in=structures=or=about=proper=================================================N=mrofKI=afCAj=aeptKI=bngineering=cacultyI=rniversity=of=BolognaI=gabrieleKbitelli]uniboKit=O=arKI=CfofJbC=and=afCAj=aeptKI=bngineering=cacultyI=rniversity=of=BolognaI=camillaKcolla]uniboKit=P=mhKaK=studentKI=afCAj=aeptKI=bngineering=cacultyI=rniversity=of=BolognaI=elenaKgabrielli4]uniboKit==4=arKI=afCAj=aeptKI=bngineering=cacultyI=rniversity=of=BolognaI=fabrizioKgirardi]uniboKit==R=mrofKI=afCAj=aeptKI=bngineering=cacultyI=rniversity=of=BolognaI=francescoKubertini]uniboKit=

Page 2: nr^kqfq^qfsblkfqlofkdlcprmbocff^i ab^vbslirqflkfkmi^pqboba … · 2015. 11. 15. · OOVM= qh=wal=w=xpos==atur=eather=E=t=microclimat==BolognI=krthe=fF==O= summe=urtheI=fo=t=star==th=secon=agein=seasonI=moistur=an=sal=apill=ri=f=t=

=

OOUV=

techniques= to=be=used= in=masonry= structures= for= successfully=monitoring= the= time=evolution=of= these=environmental=effectsK=joreoverI=for= the=preservation=of=masonry=buildingsI=due=to=their=high=number=and=to=their =cultural =importanceI =it =is =required=to=better =investigate =these=phenomena=directly=on=real =cases=in=their=specific=microclimatic=environmentK=oepeated=visual=inspections=are=commonly=used=to=monitor=such=superficial=decay=but=this=is=a=subjective=and=qualitative=techniqueK=qhusI= for= these= purposesI= it= would= be= important= to= have= at= disposal= nonJdestructive= testing= and=monitoring= tools= capable= of= quantitatively= detecting= and= following= the= evolution= of= these=processes=since=the=beginningK==Among=the=available=surface=imaging=methodsI=there=is=a=wide=range=of=tools=able=to=create=Pa=models=of= the=objects;= these=have=been=used=in= the= last= several=years= in=various=application= fields= Ecivil= and=mechanical= engineeringI= cultural= heritageI= medicineI= forensicsI= etcF= by=considering= various= range=of=object= sizes= at= different= scales= xRzK= konethelessI= two= basic=approaches= can=be= distinguishedW= imageJbased=systemsI=where=Pa=models=are=generated=using=digital=imagesI=and=rangeJbased=systems=that=use=scanning=systems=with=different=technologies=xSzK==qhe=acquisition=of=Pa=models=by=means=of= laser=scannersI= thanks=to=the=technical=development= in=the=last= few=years=coupled=with=the=decrease=in=the=cost=of=scanning=equipmentI=as=well=as=the=spreading=use=of=hardware=with=high=computational=and=graphic=capabilityI=have=made=this=technique=accessible=to= a= much= larger= audienceK= fn= additionI= as= the= technique= is= contactlessI= rapid= and= able= to= provide=quantitative= informationI= it= may= be= used= for= monitoring= the= superficial= environmental= decay= in=outdoors=masonryK==OK ^fM lc qeb tloh =qhe= research= work= herein= presented= was= aimed= at= finding= proper= methodologies= for= following= the=evolution=of=degradation=processes=connected=to=moisture=and=salt=movements=in=masonry=since=their=initial=stageK=tith= this=purposeI=a= large=brick=masonry=wallI=with=one=main=side=unplastered=and=one=plasteredI= subjected= to= natural= weathering= and= brine= damp= rise= was= studied= by= means= of= an= image=based=diagnostic=techniqueW=highJresolution=laser=scanning=by=triangulation=techniqueK=fn=this=paper=the=methodology=followed=for=the=diagnosis=was=presented=together=with=some=preliminary=results=of=this=onJgoing= experimental= campaign= in= order= to= evaluate= the= reliability= of= the= technique= in= monitoring=quantitatively=the=superficial=decay=evolution=in=masonry=surfacesK==PK bumbofMbkq^i tloh

PKNK aescription of the specimen A=OJheader=masonry=wall=Especimen=mkaAF=of=nominal=dimensions=NPM=×=OR=×=NPM=cmP=Eb=×=s=×=hFI=made=of=solid=brick=units=and=natural=hydraulic= lime=mortar= jointsI=N=cm=thickI=was=consideredK=qhe=specimen= presents= one= main= face=unplastered= Efront= sideF= and= one=plastered= Erear= sideFK= qhe=plaster=layerI= N= cm= thickI= was= made=by=using= the=same= mortar= mix= of= the= vertical= and= horizontal= masonry=joints= EcigK= NFK= fn= additionI= in= the= front= sideI= some= inclusions= of= different= stones= Elimestone= and=sandstoneF=have=been=inserted=at=different=heights=in=the=wallK==

=aF====== =bF====== =cF=

cigK N=jasonry=wall=mkaA=with=basins=for=brineI=at=the=baseW=aF=front=sideI=bF=rightJhand=sideI==cF=rear=sideI=plastered=EP=jay=OMNNF=

Page 3: nr^kqfq^qfsblkfqlofkdlcprmbocff^i ab^vbslirqflkfkmi^pqboba … · 2015. 11. 15. · OOVM= qh=wal=w=xpos==atur=eather=E=t=microclimat==BolognI=krthe=fF==O= summe=urtheI=fo=t=star==th=secon=agein=seasonI=moistur=an=sal=apill=ri=f=t=

=

OOVM=

qhe=wall=was=exposed=to=natural=weathering=Ein=the=microclimate=of=BolognaI=korthern=ftalyF=over=O=summers;=furtherI=before=the=start=of=the=second=ageing=seasonI=moisture=and=salt=capillary=rise=from=the=wall=base=was=simulated=by=lowJconcentrated=sodium=chloride=solution=EMKNB=JwtFK=qhis=natural=ageing=process= provokes= material= damage= by= favouring= solution= evaporation= and= salt= crystallization= on= the=masonry=surface=or=beneath=itK==PKOK Pa laser scanner survey fn=this=experimental=workI=a=triangulating=desktop=laser=scanner=has=been=usedI=which=is=proven=to=be=a=reliable= technology= for= nonJcontact= surface= measurementsK= qhe= technique= is= called= triangulation=because=the=laser=spotI=the=camera=and=the=laser=emitter=form=a=triangleI=and=exploiting=the=principle=of=the=topographic=forward=intersection=it=is=possible=to=determine=the=position=of=a=point=in=the=Pa=space=defined=by=the=instrumental=reference=system=EcigK=OFK=qhe=distance=between=the=laser=emitter=and=the=camera=sensor=Erepresenting=one=side=of=the=triangleF=is=known=by=the=constructor=specificationI=and=it=is= called= ±baseline”= EbFK= qhe= outJcoming= angle= EαF= of= the= laser= beam= is= also= known= by= a= prior=calibration=of=the=rotating=mirrorK=qhen=the=laser=beam=undergoes=a=reflection=on=the=targeted=surfaceI=and=its=footprint=on=the=receiving=sensor=Eusually=a=CCa=or=CjlpFI=makes=it=possible=to=calculate=the=angle=EβFK=qhese=three=informations=EαI=βI=bF=combined=with=the=trigonometric=formulas=ENFI=EOFI=fully=determine=the=coordinates=of=the=points=cloud=in=which=the=surface=can=be=discretizedK=collowing= a= process= of= triangulationI= the= points= cloud= can= be= converted= into= a= mesh= of= trianglesI=which= constitute= the=Pa= surface=of= the=objectK= ff= the=device= is= able= to= capture=also= the= color=odB=informationI= it= is= possible= to= texturize= the= surfaceK= lne= acquisition= is= generally= not= sufficient= to=recover=the=entire=surface=for=objects=greater=than=the=instrument’s=field=of=viewK=cor=this=reasonI=in=order=to=describe=the=entire=surface=in=the=best=wayI=additional=scan=positions=from=different=points=of=view=are=adoptedK==

= =cigK O iayout=of=a=triangulation=laser=scanner

=

cm

cm yx == gb tan;tan = ENF==

= =

bagb

ga

ab tantan

;

tantan

tantan

;

tantanN +

=+

=+

=bzbybx AAA =

EOF==

PKPK qest equipments qhe=laser=scanner=used=in=this=work=is=produced=by=kextbngine=fncK=and=is=based=on=jultiJstripe=iaser=qriangulation= EjiqF= technologyK= qhe= laser= scanner= acquires= the= data= in= two= different= modes=corresponding= to= two= different= baselinesW= jacro= mode= and= tide= modeK= pome= constraints= on= the=distance=between=the=object=and=the=scanner=are=given=for=each=mode=Eqable=NFK==

Page 4: nr^kqfq^qfsblkfqlofkdlcprmbocff^i ab^vbslirqflkfkmi^pqboba … · 2015. 11. 15. · OOVM= qh=wal=w=xpos==atur=eather=E=t=microclimat==BolognI=krthe=fF==O= summe=urtheI=fo=t=star==th=secon=agein=seasonI=moistur=an=sal=apill=ri=f=t=

=

OOVN=

qable N=kextbngine=laser=scanner=specifications==

aimensions OO4=×=VN=×=OTT=mm=

Macro Mode tide Mode

cield of siew NPxNM=cm= PRxOR=cm=

torking distance NU=cm= 4M=cm=

^ccuracy –NOT=µm= –PUN=µm=

oesolution OMM=amf= TR=amf=

qexture density 4MM=amf= NRM=amf=

mointsLsec RMMMM= RMMMM=

=qhe=choice=of=the=scan=mode=depends=on=the=object’s=size=and=the=desired=output=accuracyK=qhe=scanner=mounts =a =couple =of =twin =arrays =of =Class =four =Nj =NMJmt =solidJstate =lasers =with =custom =optics =at =a=SRMJnm=wavelengthK=qhe=scanner=also=features=twin=P=jm=Cjlp=odB=image=sensorsI=and=builtJin=white=light= texture= illuminators=xTI=Uz=qhis= technique=was=chosen=because=it= is=contactlessI= rapid=and=capable= of= providing= quantitative= informationI= thus= it= could= be= helpful= in= order= to= monitor= the=degradation=processes=caused=by=moisture=and=salt=movements=since=the=beginningK==QK a^q^ ^Cnrfpfqflk =qhe= evolution= of= the=superficial= decay= caused=by=aggressive= environment= on=both= main= surfaces= of=wall=mkaA=was=monitored=by=means=of=the=above=described=laser=scanner=instrumentK==qhe=first=acquisition=campaign=was=carried=out=at=the=end=of=the=Nst=weathering=season=Elctober=OMNMF=and=the=Ond=campaign=was=repeated=after=one=year=Ekovember=OMNNF=at=the=end=of=the=Ond=ageing=seasonK==aue=to=the=small=field=of=view=of=the= instrument=usedI=a=single=scan=acquisition=was=not=sufficient=to=capture=the=entire=surfaceI=although=considering=the=±wide=mode=configuration”=EOR=×=PR=cmF=which=is=the=more=suitable=field=of=view=in=this=caseI=and=a=number=of=scanJpositions=was=necessary=for=covering=one=stripe=of=the=wall=surfaceK=qhusI=in=both=measurement=campaignsI=multiple=scans=have=been=recordedI=overlapping=a=certain=area=between=two=contiguous=scansI=and=then=combining=them=togetherK==aespite=thisI=due=to=the=large=dimensions=of=the=wall=compared=with=the=instrument=field=of=viewI=only=two=vertical=sections=of=the=specimen=have=been=scanned=Eone=on=the=front=side=and=one=on=the=rear=side=of=the=wallFK=qhis=choice=was=made=in=order=neither=to=not=dilate=excessively=the=data=acquisition=time=nor=the=subsequent=data=analysis=timeK=fn=detailI=on=the=front=side=of=the=wallI=the=vertical=section=AJA=was =surveyed =by =S =scanJpositions =while =on =the =rearI =plastered =sideI =the =central =section =EBJBF =was =considered=by=means=of=U=scanJpositions=EcigK=PFK==

=

cigK P tall=mkaAW=monitored=surfaces=in=the=frontJside=EleftF=and=back=plastered=side=ErightF

Page 5: nr^kqfq^qfsblkfqlofkdlcprmbocff^i ab^vbslirqflkfkmi^pqboba … · 2015. 11. 15. · OOVM= qh=wal=w=xpos==atur=eather=E=t=microclimat==BolognI=krthe=fF==O= summe=urtheI=fo=t=star==th=secon=agein=seasonI=moistur=an=sal=apill=ri=f=t=

=

OOVO=

About=one=hour=was=required=to=scan=each=testing=positionK=kote=that=every=scanned=area=was=recorded=with=its=own=particular=reference=system=as=it=was=not=possible=to=establish=and=maintain=in=time=a=rigid=reference=system=on=the=object =framework=due=to=logistical =constraints =of =the=laboratory=setup=EiKeK =it =was =not =feasible =to =cover =the =wall =surfaces =or =a =portion =of =them =for =a =long =periodFK =All =the =measurements=have=been=performed=keeping=the=laser=scanner=perpendicular= to=the=wall=surface=to=be=monitoredI= about= 4M= cm= away= from= it= and= a= tripod= was= used= to= vary= the= relative= height= of= the=instrumentK==fn=this=phase=of=the=workI=another=problem=encountered=was=the=position=of=the=brick=wall=because=of=its= outdoors= storage= and= of= no= protection= against= the= sunK= Critical= environmental= illuminationI= eKgK=excessive=brightness=may=badly=affect=the=data=acquisition=as=the=used=laser=scanner=is=very=sensitive=to=this=parameterK=qhis=results=in=poor=odB=coloursI=and=in=poor=separation=between=the=laser=line=and=the=background= colour= of= the= surfaceI= hence= making= detection= difficultK= qo= avoid= these= problemsI= the=survey= is= better= performed=during= the=nightI= or= after= darkening= the=work=environment= with=panels=or=curtainsK =fn =this =experimental =caseI =the =Ond= option= was= followed= and= the= masonry= wall= and= the=equipment=were=covered=with=a=large=plastic=sheet=creating=a=dark=testing=area=below=EcigK=4FK=

=

== =

cigK Q jasonry=wall=and=surrounding=testing=area=covered=with=a=plastic=sheet=EleftFI==example=of=laser=scanner=survey=ErightF==

=RK a^q^ sfpr^ifw^qflk ^ka ^k^ivpfp

RKNK sisualization of the data As= already= mentionedI= multiple= scans= have=been= collected=at= each= measurement= position= in=order= to=capture=at=least=a=section=of=the=masonry=surface;=thenI=to=visualize=and=analyze=the=whole=set=of=data=collected=in=each=positionI=the=scan=images=have=to=be=combined=togetherK=cirst=of=allI=as=each=mesh=is=oriented= with= its= own= scanner= reference= systemI= a= relative= repositioning= was= performedI= aimed= at=reconstructing=the=original=object=geometry=and=thus=at=visualizing=correctly=the=dataK==fn=the=preliminary=phase=of=this=processI=the=approximate=Pa=rototranslation=matrix=has=been=calculated=by=measuring=at= least=P= tieJpoints= in=O=contiguous=scans=which=are=manually=selectedK=qhe=procedure=has= then= continued= involving= an= algorithm= able= to= minimize= the= difference= between= two= clouds= of=pointsW=the=fterative=Closest=moint=EfCmFK=qhis=algorithm=is=conceptually=simple;=it=iteratively=estimates=the=transformation=parameters=necessary=to=minimize=the=distance=between=the=points=of=two=raw=scans=and=then= it= transforms= the=coordinates=using=such=valuesK=qhusI=a= fine=alignment=of=each=scan=can=be=obtainedK= lnce= all= the= meshes= are= aligned= in= the= same= reference= systemI= they= have= been= merged=together=in=order=to=create=an=only=surfaceK==qhis= process= has=been= followed=for= each=of= the= two=measurement= campaigns= thus=obtaining=surfaces=consisting=of=Pa=merged=models=that=can=be=compared=between=each=other=EcigK=RI=cigK=SFK==

Page 6: nr^kqfq^qfsblkfqlofkdlcprmbocff^i ab^vbslirqflkfkmi^pqboba … · 2015. 11. 15. · OOVM= qh=wal=w=xpos==atur=eather=E=t=microclimat==BolognI=krthe=fF==O= summe=urtheI=fo=t=star==th=secon=agein=seasonI=moistur=an=sal=apill=ri=f=t=

=

OOVP=

cigK R mkaA=crontI=footprints=of=the=scanJpositions=and=Pa=merged=models=of=OMNM=EleftF=and=OMNN=EcenterFI=texturized=subJarea=ErightF

=

cigK S mkaA=BackW=footprints=of=the=scanJpositions=and=Pa=merged=models=of=OMNM=EleftF=and=OMNN=EcenterFI=texturized=subJarea=ErightF

=auring=this=±merging”=procedureI=problems=that=may=occur=in=this=kind=of=test=have=been=encounteredK=ft=is=knownI=that=with=elongated=and=plane=objects=where=the=scans=are=essentially=positioned=along=one=directionI=problems=may=arise=with=their=alignmentK=ff=the=central=scans=are=strongly=connected=to=each=otherI=the=scans=at=the=extremes=present=only=one=side=constrained=and=the=residuals=are=usually=larger=in=this=areaK=qhis=occurs=in=our=caseI=and=thusI=not=to=affect=the=data=quality=a=subJarea=has=been=chosen=for=each=monitored=positionK===RKOK aata analysis and discussion of results qhe=meshes=derived=from=the=point=clouds=measured=at=the=end=of=each=ageing=period=have=been=used=separatelyI=first=of=allI=to=perform=a=visual=inspectionK=qhis=is=possibleI=with=Pa=modelI=especially=when=a=photographic=texture=is=superimposed=to=the=meshK=fn=detailI=some=detachment=areas=and=areas=with=material=losses=have=been=identified=in=both=measuring=campaignsK=qhusI=it=was=possible=to=detect=the=appearance=of=superficial=decay=also=at=the=very=beginning=phases=of=natural=weatheringK==fn=order=to=make=considerations=over=the=variations=over=time=in=the=Pa=geometry=of=the=object=caused=by=material=spallingI=or=to=salt=crystallization=cyclesI=the=surface=±OMNM”=was=subtracted=to=the=±OMNN”=oneI=generating=a=displacement=mapK=fn=cigK=TI=the=OMNNJOMNM=difference=displacements=maps=for=both=sides=of=the=wall=are=presentedK==qhe= highest= and= lowest= values= correspond= to= a= major= change= of= the= surface= occurred= in= time= are=reported=in=cigK=TK=fn=the=front=sideI=not=plasteredI=the=greater=area=of=negative=displacements=is=visible=at=masonry=course=S=Efrom=the=baseF=in=the=natural=stone=inclusionK=qhusI=it=seems=that=this=material=was=more=sensitive=to=the=natural=environmental=ageing=than=the=bricks=or=the=mortar=layersK=

Page 7: nr^kqfq^qfsblkfqlofkdlcprmbocff^i ab^vbslirqflkfkmi^pqboba … · 2015. 11. 15. · OOVM= qh=wal=w=xpos==atur=eather=E=t=microclimat==BolognI=krthe=fF==O= summe=urtheI=fo=t=star==th=secon=agein=seasonI=moistur=an=sal=apill=ri=f=t=

=

OOV4=

=

cigK T aisplacement=map=in=xmmzW=mkaJA=cront=and=Back==

fn=the=rear= sideI= the=greater=negative=displacements= are=concentrated=along=a= straight=horizontal= line=that=is=located=at=about=the=same=height=from=the=wall=base=that=in=the=front=sideI=which=approximately=corresponds=to=the=level=of=moisture=riseK=fn=additionI=some=sparse=pitting=phenomena=can=be=identified=in=the=entire=plastered=surfaceK===cor=a=more=thorough=study=of=the=surface=it=is=possible=to=split=the=changes=affecting=each=constituent=materialK=qhusI=in=this=case=two=classes=have=been=createdW=one=concerning=the=bricks=and=one=for=the=mortar=layersI=considering=the=stones=as=part=of=the=±brick”=classK=fn=additionI=it=has=been=created=a=third=class= concerning= the=outliersW= outliers= are=errors= that= have=been=easily=recognized=by= the=operatorK= fn=detailI= in= this= specific=case=some=displacements= were= caused=by= the=presence=of= labels= sparse=in= the=surfaceK=qhese=labels=were=present=only=in=one=of=the=two=yearsI=and=their=presenceI=when=the=surface=comparison=is=performedI=could=be=incorrectly=interpreted=as=a=material=variationK=By= examining= the= three= classesI= called= respectively= BricksI= jortar= and= lutliersI= the= percentage= of=material= that= can= be= considered= acquired= Epositive= valuesF= or= lost= Enegative= valuesF= are=represented=with=cake=diagrams=EcigK =UFK =qhe=material =belongs=to=one=class =instead=of =the=other =according=to=the=threshold=usedK=qhe=threshold=value=correspond=to=the=instrumental=accuracy=in=the=tide=mode=Eσ=Z=–=MKPUN= mmFK= qhusI= the= areas= with= displacements= contained= in= this= range= can= be= considered= without=surface=variationsK==

=

cigK U mkaJA=diagrams

Page 8: nr^kqfq^qfsblkfqlofkdlcprmbocff^i ab^vbslirqflkfkmi^pqboba … · 2015. 11. 15. · OOVM= qh=wal=w=xpos==atur=eather=E=t=microclimat==BolognI=krthe=fF==O= summe=urtheI=fo=t=star==th=secon=agein=seasonI=moistur=an=sal=apill=ri=f=t=

=

OOVR=

qable O=Analysis=of=the=comparison=between=the=OMNN=and=OMNM=Pa=model==

mka-^ cront Class mositive w=[=HMKPUN kegative w=<=−MKPUN fn tolerance

^rea Emm^OF

Mortar NNNRKVT= OUNVKPM= =

Brick ROMKNP= NU4TKMT= =

lutliers MKMM= UTKOS= =

qot NSPSKNM= 4TRPKSP= NS4PUNKPR=

solume Emm^PF

Mortar NNPKSM= 4SPKTN= =

Brick 4NK4U= SMVK4M= =

qot NRRKMU= NMTPKNO= =

mka-^ Back mositive w=[=HMKPUN kegative w=<=−MKPUN fn tolerance

^rea Emm^OF qot PSMPKM4= ROONKNO= NVVU4UK4T=

solume Emm^PF qot UP4KSR= PNMRKOM= ==crom =these =dataI =it =is =possible =to =note =that =both =surfaces =of =the =wall =have =suffered =some =damagesI =despite=of=the=different=orientation=and=the=presence=of=plasterK=fn=both=surfacesI=the=negative=areas=are=almost =two =times =greater =than =the =positiveI =acquired =areas =Ein =percentageFK =eoweverI =the =rear =sideI =although=it=is=exposed=to=the=korthI=presents=more=changes=than=the=surface=without=plasterK==fn=the=latterI= it=seems=that=the=moisture=and=salt=movements=have=affected=greater=the=mortar=than=the=brick =surfacesK =qhe =decay =of =the =mortar =appears =almost =in =the =same =percentage =as =swelling =or =salt =crystallizations=Epositive=areasF=and=material=losses=Enegative=areasFK= fn=the=bricksI= the=negative=areas=are= also= due= to= material= losses;= insteadI= the= positive= areas= are= only= apparent= because= the= volume=increase=is=mainly=due=to=some=flakes=that=are=separating=at=this=time=point=Ematerial=lossesFK==SK ClkCirpflk =fn=an=experimental=set=up=in=BolognaI=ftalyI=a=OJheader=brick=wall=with=one=main=face=unplastered=and=one=plastered= has=been=consideredK= qhis= masonry=specimen=has=been=subjected= to=moisture=and= lowJconcentrated=sodium=chloride=solution=EMKNB=JwtF=rise=from=the=baseK=qhe= resulting= superficial= decay= has= been= monitored=by= means= of= a= Pa= toolK= fn=particularI= laser= data=acquisitions= were= performed= on= selected= area= of= the= wall= and= repeated= at= the= end= of= two= ageing=seasonsK= jultiple= scans= have= been= recorded= and= then= combined= togetherK= fn= order= to= make=considerations= among=the=variations=over= time= in= the=Pa=geometry=of= the=object= caused=by=material=spalling=that=are=coming=outI=or=to=some=salt=crystallization=cyclesI=the=surface=collected=in=±OMNM”=was=subtracted= to= the=±OMNN”= onesI= generating=a= difference= displacements= mapK= fn=additionI= the= changes=affecting= the=surfaces= have=been= split= among=the=construction=materials= Ebricks=and= mortarF=and=the=percentage=of=material= that=can=be=considered=acquired= Epositive=valuesF= or= lost= Enegative=valuesF=are=represented=with=cake=diagramsK=crom= this= preliminary= result= it= is= possible= to= conclude= that= the= proposed= procedure= was= able= to=successfully= extract= quantitative= information= about= areas= of= material= spelling= and= detachment= in=unplastered=and=plastered=masonry=even=in=the=initial=phases=of=decayK===^ChkltibadbMbkqp =qhe= authors= would= like= to= thank= the= buropean= Commission= for= founding= the= cmTJbksJOMMTJN=pjooep=–=mrojectJkumberW=ONOVPV=EwwwKsmoohsKeuF=and=the=project=officer=jK=ChapuisK===obcbobkCbp xNz Binda= iKI= Baronio= dK= ENVUTF= jechanisms= of= jasonry= aecay= aue= to= palt= CrystallizationK=

aurability of Building MaterialsI=nK4I=blsevierI=AmsterdamI=OOTJO4MK=

Page 9: nr^kqfq^qfsblkfqlofkdlcprmbocff^i ab^vbslirqflkfkmi^pqboba … · 2015. 11. 15. · OOVM= qh=wal=w=xpos==atur=eather=E=t=microclimat==BolognI=krthe=fF==O= summe=urtheI=fo=t=star==th=secon=agein=seasonI=moistur=an=sal=apill=ri=f=t=

=

OOVS=

xOz pcherer= dKtK= EOMM4F= ptress= from= crystallization= of= saltK= Cement and Concrete oesearchI= P4W=NSNPJNSO4K=

xPz tendler= bK= EOMMOF= iaboratory= measurement= on= saltJloaded= brick= samples= in= periodically=changing= climate= conditionsK= The study of palt aeterioration MechanismsI= bdK= qK= von=honowI=eelsinkiI=cinlandI=UNJUTK=

x4z iubelli=BK=EOMMSF=podium chloride damage to porous building materialsK=mha=qhesisK=xRz BlaisI=cK=EOMM4F=A=review=of=OM=years=of=range=sensors=developmentK=gK blectronic fmagingI=NPW=

OPNJO4MK=xSz pansoni=dK;=qrebeschi=jK;=aocchio=cK=EOMMVF=ptateJofJqheJArt=and=Applications=of=Pa=fmaging=

pensors=in=fndustryI=Cultural=eeritageI=jedicine=and=Criminal=fnvestigationK=pensorsI=VW=RSUJSMNK=xTz Bitelli=dKI=pimone=AKI=dirardi=cKI=iantieri=CK=EOMMVF=Caratterizzazione=di=superficie=e=tessitura=del=

manto=stradale=mediante=tecniche=a=scansione=laserI=Bollettino pfcbTI=PW=RRJSUK=xUz duidiI= dK;= oemondinoI= cK;= jorlandoI= dK;= ael= jastioI= AK;= rcchedduI= cK;= melagottiI= AK= EOMMTF=

merformances=evaluation=of=a=low=cost=active=sensor=for=cultural=heritage=documentationI=fnW=Uth lptical PaI=wurichI=VJNO=gulyI=RVJSVK=