numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in...

23
Numerical investigation of the Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in black PMMA ignition delay time in black PMMA at high heat fluxes at high heat fluxes Nicolas BAL Guillermo REIN University of Edinburgh [email protected]

Upload: others

Post on 10-Mar-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

Numerical investigation of the Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in black PMMA ignition delay time in black PMMA at high heat fluxesat high heat fluxesNicolas BAL ‐ Guillermo REIN

University of Edinburgh

[email protected]

Page 2: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

Solid ignition = f(Many parameters)

Solid ignition: black PMMA samplesClassical ignition theory: Main assumptions:

Inert solid up to ignition;

Surface temperature as ignition criterion;

Material properties are temperature independent;

Absorption of the radiation at the surface;

Solid sample behaves as semi‐infinite;

Page 3: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

Ignition delay time for black PMMA samples

Page 4: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

Ignition delay time

WHY ?

Delay to ignition

Page 5: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

Heat transfer

Pyrolysis modelPyrolysis reaction

∆HgError:40 kW/m2 => 10%200 kW/m2 => 2%

Page 6: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

Why develope a new pyrolysis model?

What is the minimum set of mechanisms that explains the experimental observations?

ExcessiveSimplicity?

Disproportionate Complexity?

Page 7: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

Comparison assumptionPyrolysis model

Pyrolysis reaction controlled by {A;E}SOLID;

Mass flux criterion;

In‐depth radiation absorption possible;

Solid sample behaves as semi‐infinite;

Material properties are temperature

independent;

Pyrolysis gases flow well out of the sample;

Endothermic contribution from pyrolysis

reaction ignored ;

Oxidation reaction ignored;

Inert solid up to ignition;

Classical theory

Surface temperature as ignition criterion;

Absorption of the radiation at the surface;

Solid sample behaves as semi‐infinite;

Material properties are temperature

independent;

Heat losses combined in a total heat

transfer coefficient;

Page 8: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

Mechanism responsible for the ignition delay at high heat fluxesKinetics, heat losses and critical mass flux

temperature dependency of the material properties

Reaction scheme

In‐depth radiation absorption

Page 9: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

Kinetics, heat losses and critical mass flux

Mechanism responsible for the ignition delay at high heat fluxes

Page 10: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

Reaction scheme

Mechanism responsible for the ignition delay at high heat fluxes

Page 11: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

temperature dependency of the material properties

Mechanism responsible for the ignition delay at high heat fluxes

Rhodes Steinhaus

Page 12: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

In‐depth radiation absorption

Mechanism responsible for the ignition delay at high heat fluxes

Page 13: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

In‐depth radiation absorption

Mechanism responsible for the ignition delay at high heat fluxes

Page 14: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

Impact of the black carbon coating

Page 15: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

Temperature profiles

Page 16: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

CONCLUSION AND SCOPE OF PROGRESSTime to ignition measurements match perfectly with the classical theory up to

50 ‐60 kW/m2 for black PMMA samples.

Page 17: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

CONCLUSION AND SCOPE OF PROGRESSFor heat fluxes higher than 70 kW/m2, a delay is observed in comparison

with the classical ignition theory prediction.

Page 18: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

CONCLUSION AND SCOPE OF PROGRESSA simple pyrolysis model was developed

Main assumption:

SIMPLIFICATIONS ARE REQUIRED WHERE THE PRECISION DOES NOT WARRANT THE INCLUSION OF HIGHER LEVELS OF COMPLEXITY

Page 19: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

CONCLUSION AND SCOPE OF PROGRESSThe only mechanism which enables to describe the delay on the classical theory prediction

was the in‐depth radiation absorption.

Page 20: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

CONCLUSION AND SCOPE OF PROGRESSBy applying a black carbon coating on the top surface of the sample, the effective in‐depth

radiation absorption increases.

Page 21: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

QUESTIONS

Page 22: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms
Page 23: Numerical investigation of the ignition delay time in …docs.gdrfeux.univ-lorraine.fr/Chatou1/EDINBURGH01.pdfWhy develope a new pyrolysis model? What is the minimum set of mechanisms

Flame at 2000 K: 907 kW/m2

Pool fire (0.5 m x 9.45 m) Kerosene: Peak heat flux to object immersed: 150 kW/m2 (HRR_rad ≈ 45 kW/m2 )

Peak HRR polystyrene keyboard: 22 kW (HRR_rad ≈ 6.6 kW/m2 )

Peak HRR wooden desk (0.6 * 1.2 *0.8 m) : 650 kW (HRR_rad ≈ 195 kW/m2 )

Bench scale mattress Polyurethane :400 kW/m2 (HRR_rad ≈ 120 kW/m2 )

Heat flux to the walls inside a compartment containing a hot gas layer

Heat fluxes from a window flame 0.5m above the top of the window for different size propane fires inside the compartment