nyc district council of carpenters - disciplinary … · 2019-10-22 · *defrauding the brotherhood...

233
FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION 2013-49 Charles McNally (LU 157) vs. Justine Kuhn (LU 157) *Causing dissension *Improper harassment *Violating the obligation *****Member accused of harassment, violating the obligation and causing dissension at the workplace***** •Trial dates - 8/22/13 & 9/19/13 •Pled GUILTY to "Improper harassment" & "Violating the obligation" . •Penalty is time served as member was previously terminated from employment •Found NOT GUILTY of "Causing dissension" 2012-288 Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) vs. David Blumenberg (LU 157) *Violating the obligation *Hindering investigation of allegations of corruption or misconduct *Hindering the conduct of investigations *****Member accussed of violating the obligation by failing to respond to a summons sent by the Inspector General Office***** •Trial date - 9/26/13 •Found GUILTY of all charges •Penalty is Expulsion 2012-188 Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) vs. Hanson James (LU 45) *Improper harassment *Violating the obligation *****Member accused of harassment***** •Charges withdrawn on 9/26/13 2013-93 William Jackson (LU 157) vs. Sergio Martins (LU 926) *Improper harassment *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member accused of harassment***** •Charges withdrawn on 10/3/2013 NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

Upload: others

Post on 14-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

2013-49

Charles McNally (LU 157)

vs.

Justine Kuhn (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment, violating

the obligation and causing dissension at the

workplace*****

•Trial dates - 8/22/13 & 9/19/13

•Pled GUILTY to "Improper harassment" & "Violating the

obligation" .

•Penalty is time served as member was previously

terminated from employment

•Found NOT GUILTY of "Causing dissension"

2012-288

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

David Blumenberg (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accussed of violating the

obligation by failing to respond to a summons

sent by the Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 9/26/13

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is Expulsion

2012-188

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Hanson James (LU 45)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/26/13

2013-93

William Jackson (LU 157)

vs.

Sergio Martins (LU 926)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/3/2013

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

Page 2: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-18

Gerald Matthews (NYCDCC)

vs.

Barry S. Quinn (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused with working without a

Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/3/2013

2012-289

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Terrence Carryl (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 10/17/13

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion, but will be set aside if member pays a

$500 fine and reports to IG Office for interview.

•Also recommended to be brought for Shop Steward review.

2012-275

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

William Heaney (LU 1556)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 10/17/13

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $250 fine, Letter of Reprimand and member

must take the Trade Unionism class

2013-82Waali Smith (LU 926) vs.

Jack Johnson (LU 45)

*Causing dissension

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 10/17/13

•Found NOT GUILTY

2013-81

Gerald Matthews (NYCDCC)

vs.

Frank Purpura (LU 2287)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working alongside non-

union workers*****

•Settled on 10/17/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to notify union when on working on jobsite

Page 3: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-80

Gerald Matthews (NYCDCC)

vs.

Joseph Profeta Jr. (LU 20)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of allowing non-union

workers to perform Carpenter's work*****

•Settled on 10/17/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to protect union jurisdiction and notify union of

violations of jurisdiction

2013-51

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Adam Hunter (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 11/14/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2013-53

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Thomas O'Malley (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 11/14/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2013-60

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Sebastian Estrada (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 11/14/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

Page 4: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-61

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Leonard Lua (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 11/14/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2013-62

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Ivan Hernandez (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 11/14/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2013-63

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Sean Geohegan (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 11/14/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2013-64

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Antonio Vega (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 11/14/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

Page 5: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-65

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Nephtali Gonzalez (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 11/14/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2013-66

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Rodrigo Zayas (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 11/14/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2013-67

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jose Vega (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 11/14/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2013-68

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Alberto Godoy (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 11/14/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

Page 6: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-106

Kenneth Bluhm (NYCDCC)

vs.

Michael Senese (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of lying to Council Rep

about manpower use on jobsite*****

•Settled on 11/14/13

•Pled GUILTY to "Violating the obligation" ; all other charges

withdrawn

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2012-247

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Aaron Anderson (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*Failure to report employment

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Settled on 11/21/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $50 fine

within 60 days

2013-20

Gerald Matthews (NYCDCC)

vs.

Trevor Whyte (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/21/13

2013-21

Gerald Matthews (NYCDCC)

vs.

Scott Deines (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Trial date - 11/21/13

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $1,500 fine; further misconduct within 1 year

results in expulsion.

Page 7: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-19

Gerald Matthews (NYCDCC)

vs.

Justin Deines (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Trial date - 11/21/13

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $500 fine

2013-23

Gerald Matthews (NYCDCC)

vs.

Joseph Padilla (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Trial date - 11/21/13

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $1,000 fine

2013-22

Gerald Matthews (NYCDCC)

vs.

Gregory Conrad (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Trial date - 11/21/13

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $1,000 fine

2013-69

Thomas Gaulrapp (NYCDCC)

vs.

Thomas Vespa (LU 20)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/9/13

Page 8: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-72

Thomas Gaulrapp (NYCDCC)

vs.

Cosmo Marino (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/9/13

2013-36

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Lloyd Debenedetto (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

contractor*****

•Settled on 12/12/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $125

fine within 60 days

2013-38

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Thomas Mulligan (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of improperly

documenting his social security number to the

union*****

•Settled on 12/12/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $125

fine within 60 days

2013-99

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Norman Greene (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/12/13

Page 9: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-94

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

John Carmody (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/12/13

2013-100

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Brian Cooper (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/12/13

2013-101

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

David Gibson (LU 950)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/12/13

2013-138

Justine Kuhn (LU 157)

vs.

John Musumeci (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment and

retaliation towards another member*****

•Case dismissed 12/12/13

Page 10: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-153

Justine Kuhn (LU 157)

vs.

Charles McNally (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment and

retaliation towards another member*****

•Case dismissed 12/12/13

2013-158

Christopher Wallace (NYCDCC)

vs.

William McKeithan (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Failing to pay working dues assessment

*****Member accused of failing to pay union

dues and working dues assessment while

continuing to work for a signatory

contractor*****

•Charges withdrawn 12/18/13

2013-104

Gerald Matthews (NYCDCC)

vs.

Nicholas Milohnic (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/19/13

2012-246

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

McDonald Romain (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*Failure to report employment

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Settled on 12/19/13

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $50 fine

within 60 days

Page 11: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-159

Lawrence Larson (NYCDCC)

vs.

Daniel Brine (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Failing to pay working dues assessment

*****Member accused of failing to pay union

dues and working dues assessment while

continuing to work for a signatory

contractor*****

•Case dismissed 12/20/13

2013-160

Lawrence Larson (NYCDCC)

vs.

Michael Raftery (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Failing to pay working dues assessment

*****Member accused of failing to pay union

dues and working dues assessment while

continuing to work for a signatory

contractor*****

•Case dismissed 12/20/13

2012-143

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

John Bradley (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of violating OSHA and CBA

rules by putting divers in a potentially unsafe

environment and exposing Divers to unnecessary

risks*****

•Settled on 1/3/14

•Pled NOLO CONTENDERE to "Violating the obligation" ; all

other charges withdrawn

•Agreed to comply with OSHA and CBA requirements in the

future

Page 12: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-35

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Runcie Burris (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/6/14

2013-124

Kenneth Bluhm (NYCDCC)

vs.

Chad McCullough (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/9/14

2013-125

Kenneth Bluhm (NYCDCC)

vs.

Anthony Zilli (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/9/14

2013-126

Kenneth Bluhm (NYCDCC)

vs.

Charles Trinkle (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/9/14

2013-127

Kenneth Bluhm (NYCDCC)

vs.

Ernest Mattia (LU 255)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/9/14

2013-128

Kenneth Bluhm (NYCDCC)

vs.

Michael Lorenzo (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/9/14

Page 13: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2012-142

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Peter Barner (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of violating OSHA and CBA

rules by putting divers in a potentially unsafe

environment and exposing Divers to unnecessary

risks*****

•Settled on 1/9/14

•Pled NOLO CONTENDERE to "Violating the obligation" ; all

other charges withdrawn

•Agreed to comply with OSHA and CBA requirements in the

future

2013-114

Graham Davis (LU 157)

vs.

Michael Palminteri (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of violating his obligation

to procure employment for fellow members*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/23/14

2013-115

Graham Davis (LU 157)

vs.

Kenneth Knapp (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of violating his obligation

to procure employment for fellow members*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/23/14

2013-96

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Noel Costello (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Working without a shop steward"

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/23/14

Page 14: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-123

Elijah Thomas (LU 157)

vs.

Charles Light (LU 926)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 1/23/14

•Found NOT GUILTY

2013-105

Latisha Roberts (LU 926)

vs.

Brenton Wint (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 12/19/13

1/30/14

2/20/14

•Found NOT GUILTY

2013-89

Graham McHugh (NYCDCC)

vs.

Pedro Acevedo (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Trial date - 2/20/14

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $2,500 fine due within 90 days; failure to pay

results in expulsion; also if member is convicted of working

non-union in the future, member is to be expelled

2014-17

Miguel Bonilla (LU 157)

vs.

Michael Collins (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Advocating separation

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Improper steward appointment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Case dismissed - 3/13/14

Page 15: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-28

Michael Collins (LU 157)

vs.

Miguel Bonilla (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*Improper steward appointment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/13/14

2014-29

Stephen McCann (NYCDCC)

vs.

Baldomero Jeronimo (LU 45)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Working while registered on the OWL

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory company while registered on the

OWL*****

•Case dismissed 3/13/14

2013-71

Thomas Gaulrapp (NYCDCC)

vs.

John Fritz (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of not reporting job,

working alongside non-union workers, working

without a shop steward *****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/13/14

2013-70

Thomas Gaulrapp (NYCDCC)

vs.

Andrew Ewing (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of not reporting job,

working alongside non-union workers and

working without a shop steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/13/14

Page 16: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-133

Mangito Fowlkes (NYCDCC)

vs.

Frank Calarco (LU 279)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of not correcting the 50/50

match on the jobsite and verbally harassing the

shop steward*****

•Settled on 3/13/14

•Pled NOLO CONTENDERE to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $1 fine within 10 days and submit a Letter

of Apology

2012-249

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Lennox George (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*Failure to report employment

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Trial date - 3/20/14

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $125 fine and a Letter of Reprimand

2013-90

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Zbiginiew Lauk (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Trial date - 3/20/14

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is Expulsion and a $5,000 fine

2013-91

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Andrew Robinson (LU 253)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Trial date - 3/20/14

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is Expulsion and a $5,000 fine

Page 17: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-16

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael Harrigan (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/31/14

2013-107

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Donald Weber (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/9/14

2013-152

John Montgomery (NYCDCC)

vs.

John Valenchis (LU 1163)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working for a non-

signatory company*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/10/14

2013-84

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Samanthus Merchant (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*Failure to report employment

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Settled on 4/10/14

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $125

fine within 90 days

Page 18: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-85

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Lloyd Debenedetto (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*Failure to report employment

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Settled on 4/10/14

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $125

fine within 90 days

2013-92

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Sefkiga Vucetovic (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*Failure to report employment

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Settled on 4/10/14

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $125

fine within 90 days

2013-74

Brian McLaughlin (NYCDCC)

vs.

Edwin Gonzalez (LU 1809 )

*Crossing or working behind a picket line

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

signatory company*****

•Trial date - 4/24/14

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $7,500 fine payable within 90 days; failure to

comply results in expulsion

2013-73

Brian McLaughlin (NYCDCC)

vs.

Ronald Turner (LU 1556)

*Crossing or working behind a picket line

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

signatory company*****

•Trial date - 4/24/14

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $7,500 fine payable within 90 days; failure to

comply results in expulsion

2013-129

Tyrone Bullock (LU 2287)

vs.

James Hatton (LU 251)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 4/24/14

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a $1,000 fine payable within 90 days and

probation for 1 year; if a violation of 51(A) (5) occurs within

that year and guilt is found, member is to be expelled.

Page 19: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2012-138

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Joseph Koines (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of violating OSHA and CBA

rules by putting divers in a potentially unsafe

environment and exposing Divers to unnecessary

risks*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/7/14

2013-108

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gaetano Decicco (LU 20)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/8/14

2014-1

Brian McLaughlin (NYCDCC)

vs.

Kenneth Woolley (LU 20 )

*Causing dissension

*Advocating division of the funds

*Improper harassment

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Crossing or working behind a picket line

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a company

on the shutdown list*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/8/14

2014-3

Graham McHugh (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jason Vargas (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/8/14

Page 20: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-4

Graham McHugh (NYCDCC)

vs.

Joshua Mayfield (LU 251)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/8/14

2014-5

Graham McHugh (NYCDCC)

vs.

Andy Mei (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/8/14

2013-117

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Brenton Wint (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/8/14

2013-86

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Frank D'Andrea (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/8/14

Page 21: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-119

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Dan Florescu (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/9/14

2013-111

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Daniel Hanley (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/9/14

2013-88

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Reginaldo Da Silva (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/9/14

Page 22: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-83

Edward Carey (NYCDCC)

vs.

Nicolas Mieses (LU 2287)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

signatory company*****

•Settled on 5/15/14

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

• Agreed to serve for 4 picket duty assignments

2012-134

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Glenn Michael Bera (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of violating OSHA and CBA

rules by putting divers in a potentially unsafe

environment and exposing Divers to unnecessary

risks*****

•Settled on 5/15/14

•Pled GUILTY to "Violating the obligation" ; all other charges

withdrawn

•Agreed to comply with OSHA and CBA requirements in the

future

2013-143

George Chylinski (LU 157)

vs.

Eugenius Sikorski (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/22/14

2012-250

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Thomas Higgins (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*Failure to report employment

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Trial date - 5/22/14

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a Letter of Reprimand

Page 23: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-109

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Walter Barcliff (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/28/14

2014-73

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Anthony Costa (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/6/14

2014-66

Robert Joule (NYCDCC)

vs.

Filippo Vastano (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working short handed

on a three person job*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 6/12/14

2014-46

Graham McHugh (NYCDCC)

vs.

Yuriy Tulba (LU 252)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

******Member accused of working for a non-

signatory company*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/12/14

Page 24: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-45

Graham McHugh (NYCDCC)

vs.

Mariusz Obrycki (LU 252)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

******Member accused of working for a non-

signatory company*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/12/14

2013-34

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Raimundo Argueta (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Lumping

******Member accused of working for a non-

signatory company*****

•Settled on 6/19/14

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $250

fine within 90 days

2013-50

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Thomas Hennessey (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 6/19/14

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2013-52

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Donald Bauer (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 6/19/14

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

Page 25: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-156

Paul Sanabria (LU 157)

vs.

John Felice (LU 45)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment and

allowing non-union work to occur on the

jobsite*****

•Trial date - 6/19/14

•Found GUILTY of "Improper harassment ", "Defrauding the

brotherhood " and "Violating the obligation "

•Penalty is a $1,001 fine, a 3 month suspension and a Letter

of Reprimand

•"Causing dissension " dismissed by Trial Chair

2013-95

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Michael Blackwood (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Trial date - 6/26/14

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a $250 fine per count ($1,000 total) payable

within 90 days, a letter of reprimand and member must

complete the Trade Unionism course; also expulsion if

member is found guilty of any violation within the next 3

years; if no violations, expulsion penalty is withdrawn.

2013-98

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Peter Waldron (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Trial date - 6/26/14

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is expulsion

Page 26: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-97

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Seamus O'Hara (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Trial date - 6/26/14

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2014-34

Ivo Jozovic (LU 157)

vs.

Alexander Frederick (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 6/26/14

2012-248

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

George Cebek (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*Failure to report employment

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Trial date - 6/26/14

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a $50 fine per count ($150 total) payable within

90 days and a Letter of Reprimand

2014-76

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Roger Carter (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/9/14

Page 27: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-133

Manuel A. Flores (LU 2790)

vs.

Jaime I. Betancourt (LU 2790)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/10/14

2013-164

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Paul San Paolo (LU 45)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of circumventing the

apprenticeship program*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 7/10/14

2013-163

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Mario Flaim (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of manipulating required

skills to procure a job*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 7/10/14

2014-74

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC)

vs.

Anthony Santostefano (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Crossing or working behind a picket line

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

contractor*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/10/14

Page 28: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2012-137

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Brian Gordon (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of violating OSHA and CBA

rules by putting divers in a potentially unsafe

environment and exposing Divers to unnecessary

risks*****

•Trial dates - 6/26/14 & 7/17/14

•Found NOT GUILTY of charges

2012-133

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Darryl Nowak (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of violating OSHA and CBA

rules by putting divers in a potentially unsafe

environment and exposing Divers to unnecessary

risks*****

•Trial dates - 6/19/14 & 7/24/14

•Found NOT GUILTY of charges

2013-142

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Winston Joseph (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/29/14

Page 29: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-57

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Keith Doherty (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/29/14

2014-56

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Landi (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/29/14

2013-139

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Robert Killeen (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/29/14

Page 30: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-130

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Paul Biggs (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/30/14

2013-131

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

James Wrenn Jr. (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/30/14

2014-40

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Bueti (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/30/14

Page 31: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-78

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Alan Ferreira (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/30/14

2014-71

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Julio A. Beltran (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/30/14

2014-170

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael Palminteri (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/13/14

2014-84

Martin Tuozzo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jose Luis Sa (LU 253)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working alongside non-

union workers and failing to cooperate with

Council Representative*****

•Settled on 8/14/14

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a

$200 fine within 60 days

Page 32: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-35

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

George Aragona (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/14/14

2014-182

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Craig H. Wikoff (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/14/14

2014-136

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Carmine Bonura (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/14/14

2013-162

Justine Kuhn (LU 157)

vs.

Charles McNally (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment and

slander*****

•Trial date - 8/21/14

•Found NOT GUILTY of all charges

Page 33: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-161

Justine Kuhn (LU 157)

vs.

John Musumeci (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment and

slander*****

•Trial date - 8/21/14

•Found NOT GUILTY of all charges

2014-67

Thomas Roller (LU 45)

vs.

Keith Vaccaro (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 8/21/14

•Found NOT GUILTY of "Improper harassment" and

"Violating the Obligation"

• Found GUILTY of "Causing dissension"

•Penalty is a Letter of Reprimand to remain on file for one

year

2014-14

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jonathan Perez (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/26/14

2013-149

Gerald Matthews (NYCDCC)

vs.

Sean Burns (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

signatory company*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/14

2013-166

Radames Saez (LU 2790)

vs.

Rogers Roy Watson (LU 2790)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 8/28/14

•Found NOT GUILTY of all charges

2014-87

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Paul Bossong (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/11/14

Page 34: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-42

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Francisco Pena (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Working without a shop steward

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/11/14

2014-89

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

James Conlin (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/11/14

2014-93

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Robert Grogan (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/11/14

2014-63

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jairo Bueno (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Violating membership qualifications

*****Member accused of being a member of two

Labor Unions simultaneously*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/11/14

2014-64

Jeremy Milin (NYCDCC)

vs.

David Cole (LU 290)

*Causing dissension

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of continuing to work for

job on shutdown list after being advised not

to*****

•Settled on 9/11/14

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $100

fine within 30 days

Page 35: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-196

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Frank Marino (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/16/14

2014-257

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Andrew Yoder (LU 454)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/16/14

2014-228

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Anthony Abbate (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/17/14

2014-232

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Peter Capitelli (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/17/14

2012-135

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Brian Sanchez (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of violating OSHA and CBA

rules by putting divers in a potentially unsafe

environment and exposing Divers to unnecessary

risks*****

•Trial dates - 7/24/14 & 9/18/14

•Found NOT GUILTY of charges

Page 36: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2012-136

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Kenneth Rolf Thompson (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of violating OSHA and CBA

rules by putting divers in a potentially unsafe

environment and exposing Divers to unnecessary

risks*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/18/14

2014-253

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Edward Schuster (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/22/14

2014-249

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Albert Puglise (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/22/14

2013-103

Brian Conlon (NYCDCC)

vs.

Octavio Cadena (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for company on

the shutdown list and without a Shop

Steward*****

•Trial date - 9/25/14

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $2,500 fine per count ($5,000 total) and

expulsion

Page 37: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-102

Brian Conlon (NYCDCC)

vs.

Robson Barreto (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for company on

the shutdown list and without a Shop

Steward*****

•Trial date - 9/25/14

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a Letter of Reprimand and a $1,000 fine per

count ($2,000 total) due within 6 months; failure to make

payment results in expulsion, also member will be placed on

probation for 12 months and if found guilty of any similar

violations within that timeframe, he is to be expelled.

2014-255

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Timothy Troll (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/6/14

(Member paid WDA associated with charges )

2014-273

Thomas Gorman (LU 157)

vs.

Vito Pistone (LU 157 )

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Settled on 10/9/14

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Apologized and agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2014-251

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Marcelino Rodriguez (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/9/14

(Member paid WDA associated with charges )

Page 38: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-77

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Christian Cassidy (LU 20)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/14/14

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-69

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Cathal Tierney (LU 20)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/14/14

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2013-55

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Terje Kristiansen (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/21/14

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2013-41

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jemal Vaughn (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/23/14

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 39: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-43

Thomas Gorman (LU 157 )

vs.

Kenneth Reisig (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 10/23/14

•Found NOT GUILTY of charges

2014-211

Victorious Rachmiel (LU 157)

vs.

Keith Kennedy (LU 926)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 10/23/14

2014-237

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Frank L. Evangelista (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/3/14

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2013-157

Christopher Wallace (NYCDCC)

vs.

Edwin A. Bobcombe (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Council shall receive working dues

*Failure to pay working dues assessment

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/11/14

2014-303

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Marcin Panas (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/12/14

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 40: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-107

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Miano (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/12/14

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-112

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Vere D. Ogarro (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/12/14

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-101

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Manuel Lopes (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/12/14

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-204

Martin Tuozzo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Reynaldo Gonzalez (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/13/14

2014-198

Martin Tuozzo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Mark W. Dwyer (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/13/14

Page 41: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-203

Martin Tuozzo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Mark Chin Too (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/13/14

2014-200

Martin Tuozzo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Martin D. Valdez (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/13/14

2013-40

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ryan J. Blumenberg (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 11/20/14

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2013-79

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John F. Sexton (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 11/20/14

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

Page 42: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-37

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

David Conway (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

contractor*****

•Trial date - 11/20/14

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2014-284

Michael Zebadiah Broomes (LU 926)

vs.

Mariusz Skalny (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 12/11/14

2014-83

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Antonio Naranjo Arteaga (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of registering with Local

Union under a false name*****

•Settled on 12/11/14

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $100

fine within 30 days

2014-60

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Robert E. Joule Jr. (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of submitting a false

qualification card to the Labor Technical

College*****

•Settled on 12/11/14

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to pay a $100 fine within 60 days

2013-87

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ramon Oscar Diaz (LU 4112)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 12/18/14

•Found NOT GUILTY of charges

Page 43: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-116

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

David Scalcione (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 12/18/14

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $1,000 fine due within 90 days and member

must appear for interview with IG Office within 90 days;

failure results in expulsion.

2013-42

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kize Thomas (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 12/18/14

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine due within 90 days and member must

appear for interview with IG Office within 90 days; failure

results in expulsion.

2014-233

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gregory Clark (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/23/14

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-244

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Hugh McCallion (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/23/14

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 44: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-79

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

William A. Adamchik (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/23/14

(Member deceased )

2014-47

Paul Sanabria (LU 157 )

vs.

Todd Stone (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/6/15

2014-215

Martin Tuozzo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Ramon E. Canas (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/7/15

2013-145

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Matthew May (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/7/15

2013-112

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Leslaw Sarzynski (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/7/15

Page 45: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-113

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

Slawomir Konior (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/7/15

2013-144

Walter Clayton (NYCDCC)

vs.

John Dougherty (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/7/15

2014-317

Edward Johnson (LU 926 )

vs.

David Tullgren (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 1/8/15

2014-213

Martin Tuozzo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Ezequiel Leal (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/8/15

2014-214

Martin Tuozzo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Hugo F. Sousa (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/8/15

2014-216

Martin Tuozzo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jose Fernandes (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/8/15

2014-217

Martin Tuozzo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Joao H. Correia (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/8/15

Page 46: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-32

Anthony Madaio (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jay Vecchione (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/14/15

2014-30

Anthony Madaio (NYCDCC)

vs.

Valerie Adams (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/14/15

2014-31

Anthony Madaio (NYCDCC)

vs.

Ronald Ross (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/14/15

2014-33

Anthony Madaio (NYCDCC)

vs.

Manickchand Badal (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/14/15

2014-327

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John J. Molerio (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/14/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-361

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Vincent Esposito (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/14/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 47: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-150

Christopher Wallace (NYCDCC)

vs.

Fitzroy Brown (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working at unreported

job, failing to pay dues, failing to pay WDA and

failing to report benefit shortage*****

•Trial date - 1/15/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2014-2

Christopher Wallace (NYCDCC)

vs.

Vasyl Maslo (LU 252)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working along non-

union workers on a job on the shutdown list*****

•Trial date - 1/15/15

•Found NOT GUILTY of "Lumping"

•Found GUILTY of "Defrauding the brotherhood" and

"Violating the obligation"

•Penalty is a Letter of Reprimand

2014-75

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC)

vs.

Michael Vecchione (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Crossing a picket line

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of owning and operating a

non-union company*****

•Trial date - 1/15/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2013-151

John Montgomery (NYCDCC)

vs.

Douglas Griffin (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

contractor*****

•Trial date - 1/15/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

Page 48: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-323

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ralph Malave (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/16/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2014-336

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Tyler Germann (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/20/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-353

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Edward Thompson (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/5/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-354

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John David Wells (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/5/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2014-357

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Zachary Zotollo (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/5/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

Page 49: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-355

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ryan West (LU 211)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/5/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2014-351

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Robert Schickling (LU 277)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/5/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2014-360

Mitchell Sonntag (LU 157 )

vs.

Peter Corrigan (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of causing

disruption/dissension during Local Union

Meeting*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/12/15

2014-359

Frank Schiavone (LU 157 )

vs.

Peter Corrigan (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment and causing

disruption/dissension during Local Union

Meeting*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/12/15

Page 50: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-322

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Luis Sandoval (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Working without a shop steward

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

contractor*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 2/12/15

2014-320

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Rivelino Zavala (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Working without a shop steward

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

contractor*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 2/12/15

2014-319

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Bacilio Egoavil (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Working without a shop steward

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

contractor*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 2/12/15

Page 51: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-321

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Dalton Watson (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Working without a shop steward

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

contractor*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 2/12/15

2014-289

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael James Power (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to be present as Shop Steward during

all assigned working hours

*Failure to maintain Shop Steward records

*****Member accused of failing to report job

attendance and inaccurately reporting hours

worked*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 2/12/15

2014-315

Denis Pupovic (NYCDCC)

vs.

Vito Pistone (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused using Laborers to perform

Carpenters work*****

•Settled on 2/12/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2014-314

Denis Pupovic (NYCDCC)

vs.

Edwin Deroche (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused using Laborers to perform

Carpenters work*****

•Settled on 2/12/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2014-316

Denis Pupovic (NYCDCC)

vs.

Patrick Kirby (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused using Laborers to perform

Carpenters work*****

•Settled on 2/12/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

Page 52: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-379

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Frank Arizzi (LU 4112)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/17/15

(Not officially a UBC member)

2014-220

Kenneth Bluhm (NYCDCC)

vs.

Vincenzo Ljuba (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of harassment and

ignoring manning ratio on jobsite*****

•Trial date - 2/19/15

•Found NOT GUILTY of "Improper harassment"

•Found GUILTY of "Violating the obligation" and "Failing to

protect memberships' interest"

•Penalty is a Letter of Reprimand and member is not to be

sent out as an Acting Shop Steward in the future

2015-44

Anthony DiMarco (NYCDCC)

vs.

John Lawler (LU 252)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of owning a company that

employs non-union workers*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/19/15

2014-197

Michael Ettinger (LU 45)

vs.

Fredy Dupont (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment and causing

dissension*****

•Trial date - 2/19/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a Letter of Reprimand, $900 fine and member

must take the next available Trade Unionism Class

Page 53: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-328

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Randolph Condi (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/25/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-373

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Damien Calders (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/25/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2014-65

Jeremy Milin (NYCDCC)

vs.

Marc Dileone (LU 290)

*Causing dissension

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for company on

the shutdown list*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 2/26/15

2014-149

Thomas Auguste (LU 157)

vs.

John Riley (LU 45)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 2/26/15

•Found NOT GUILTY of all charges

Page 54: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-272

Magdalena Sepulveda (LU 157)

vs.

George Zaffuto (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment and causing

dissension*****

•Trial date - 2/26/15

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Penalty is a $250 fine, member must take the next available

Sexual Harassment Class and case is to be referred to the

Shop Steward Review Board

2014-41

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Amin Soriano-Encarnacion

(LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Working without a Shop Steward

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 3/12/15

2014-370

Gerald Matthews (NYCDCC)

vs.

Albert Mendoza (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite

without a Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/12/15

Page 55: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-138

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Philbert Thomas (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/12/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2013-122

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gary Wagner (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 3/19/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $900 fine due within 30 days and member must

report to IG Office for interview within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2013-132

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Maurilio Dos Santos (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/19/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2014-313

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Adrian Quituizaca (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working non-union and

without a Shop Steward*****

•Trial date - 3/19/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $1500 fine due within 30 days

Page 56: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-312

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Manuel Quituisaca (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working non-union and

without a Shop Steward*****

•Trial date - 3/19/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $1500 fine due within 30 days

2014-227

John Clark (LU 157)

vs.

Marek Chociej (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Improper report of work hours for other

company member

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 3/19/15

2015-109

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Abel Barajas Alvarez (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/25/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2013-43

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Frank Calda (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 3/26/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $1600 fine due within 30 days and member

must report to IG Office for interview within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

Page 57: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-135

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Younker (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 3/26/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $500 fine due within 30 days and member must

report to IG Office for interview within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2013-154

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Christian Zepeda (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/26/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-20

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Patrick Sutherland (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/9/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-144

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Godwin Delph (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/9/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 58: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-113

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ephfram Lawhorne (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/9/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2015-135

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kenyon Beaubrun (LU 252)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/9/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2013-146

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Derick Lewis (LU 4112)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/9/15

(Not officially a UBC member)

2015-107

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Arthur Blackinger (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/9/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

Page 59: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-141

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gerard McEntee (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/9/15

(Membership expelled prior to charges being filed)

2014-132

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Sullivan (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/9/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2013-118

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Mariusz Martula (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/9/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2014-402

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

James Joseph Russell (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/9/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 60: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-409

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Patrick Wolf (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/9/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2013-165

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Oddo (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Settled on 4/9/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $500 fine within 60 days

2014-369

Mangito Fowlkes (NYCDCC)

vs.

Juan Enriquez (LU 279)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 4/9/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2014-368

Mangito Fowlkes (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jose Llivichuzhcha (LU 279)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 4/9/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2014-134

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Richard Cannata (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/14/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 61: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-137

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Marc Pieranrozzi (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/16/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2013-134

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jamey Meyers (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 4/16/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2013-136

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Brian Jennings (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 4/16/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $750 fine and expulsion but expulsion will be

set aside if member appears for interview after two

telephone attempts and one mailing attempt at contact.

2014-36

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Wilgems Dupont (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 4/16/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $750 fine and expulsion but expulsion will be

set aside if member appears for interview after two

telephone attempts and one mailing attempt at contact.

Page 62: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-78

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Daniel Chirila (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of lending his union card

to another member*****

•Trial date - 4/16/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2014-311

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Darrell Earl Woods (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to fulfill Acting

Shop Steward duties*****

•Trial date - 4/23/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a $500 fine due within 60 days but will be

reduced to $250 if member attends a New Member

Orientation class in May 2015

2014-224

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Frank Lamorte (LU 20)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a

steward and for a non-union company*****

•Trial date - 4/23/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2014-223

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Justin Emmanuel Greigg (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a

steward and for a non-union company*****

•Trial date - 4/23/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a Letter of Reprimand and $500 fine due within

60 days but will be reduced to $250 if member attends a

New Member Orientation clasS

2014-16

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Claudio Guinansaca (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/8/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 63: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-152

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Manuel D. Barros (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/8/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-153

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Nuno Barrosa (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/8/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-165

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Laurel V. Kalambakal Jr. (LU 1977)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/8/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-157

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John A. Damalio (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/8/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 64: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-162

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John V. Halter, LU 373

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/8/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-221

Kevin Kleming (NYCDCC)

vs.

Turlough "Sam" Noone (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

* Improper harassment

* Violating the obligation

* False accusations

*****Member accused of harassement*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/12/15

2015-163

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Vincent I. Gandolfo (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/12/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-62

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jose Navarro ( LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

* Improper harassment

* Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a shop

steward while company was on shut down

list*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/14/15

Page 65: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-57

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Robert Torres (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

* Improper harassment

* Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a shop

steward while company was on shut down

list*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/14/15

2015-60

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jose L. Torres (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

* Improper harassment

* Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a shop

steward while company was on shut down

list*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/14/15

2014-158

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Carlos Deleg (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/14/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-141

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jonathan G. Perez (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/12/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 66: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-81

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Boguslaw D. Skarzynski (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 5/14/15

2014-148

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Randy Mickey Challenger (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member refused to produce Union Work

Card to Inspectors from I.G. Office*****

•Settled on 5/15/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2015-46

James Makin (NYCDCC)

vs.

Timmy Lynch (LU 1556)

* Defrauding the Brotherhood

* Lumping

* Violating the obligation

* Failing to protect member's interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-

union contractor******

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 5/14/15

2014-199

Martin Tuozzo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Joel Vargas (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment *****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/14/15

2014-201

Martin Tuozzo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jaime A. Beltran (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment *****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/14/15

Page 67: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-50

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Roy Bakke (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/15/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-51

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Steven Bakke (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/15/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-202

Martin Tuozzo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Adam Gottfried (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 5/21/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2015-121

Glenn Hatcher (NYCDCC)

vs.

Wayne Collier (LU 2287)

*Job referral list violation

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the Job Referral List*****

•Trial date - 5/21/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Penalty is a $250 fine and a Letter of Reprimand

2014-362

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Anthony Rodriguez (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-

union contractor******

•Trial date - 5/21/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Penalty is a $1,000 fine and a Letter of Reprimand

Page 68: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-189

Jaret Curcio (LU 1556)

vs.

Brian McLaughlin (NYCDCC)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused not enforcing trade

rules*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 5/21/15

2014-190

Jaret Curcio (LU 1556)

vs.

Brian McLaughlin (NYCDCC)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of not enforcing 50/50

rule*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 5/21/15

2014-191

Jaret Curcio (LU 1556)

vs.

Brian McLaughlin (NYCDCC)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of not enforcing NCA II

Agreement*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 5/21/15

2014-192

Jaret Curcio (LU 1556)

vs.

Brian McLaughlin (NYCDCC)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of not enforcing

apprentice ratio*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 5/21/15

2014-193

Jaret Curcio (LU 1556)

vs.

Brian McLaughlin (NYCDCC)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of removing a shop

steward as an act of retaliation*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 5/21/15

2014-52

Walter E. Clayton Jr. (NYCDCC)

vs.

Derek Alexander (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment *****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/21/15

Page 69: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-53

Walter E. Clayton Jr. (NYCDCC)

vs.

Adam Gottfried (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment *****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/21/15

2014-51

Walter E. Clayton Jr. (NYCDCC)

vs.

James Lee (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment *****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/21/15

2015-229

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Errol Clarke (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/27/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-111

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Maurice Netti (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 5/28/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a $250 fine due by 7/1/15, member must pay

outstanding balance of $3,363.14 for WDA by 7/1/15 and

member must complete 2 picket duty assignments by

12/31/15

2014-106

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Juan Mejia (LU 251)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 5/28/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a $250 fine due by 7/1/15, member must pay

outstanding balance of $3,477.87 for WDA by 7/1/15 and

member must complete 2 picket duty assignments by

12/31/15

Page 70: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-155

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Anthony Duncan (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 5/28/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine and member must report to IG Office

for interview by 9/1/15; failure to show results in expulsion

2014-10

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Paul Trejo (LU 1185)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 5/28/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine due by 7/1/15 and member must

report to IG Office for interview by 9/1/15; failure to show

results in expulsion

2014-8

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Adam Markevitch (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 5/28/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine due by 7/1/15 and member must

report to IG Office for interview by 9/1/15; failure to show

results in expulsion

2014-13

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Fritz (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 5/28/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine due by 7/1/15 and member must

report to IG Office for interview by 9/1/15; failure to show

results in expulsion

Page 71: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-88

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Christopher Abato (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 5/28/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Penalty is a $125 fine due by 7/1/15, member must pay

outstanding balance of $2,362.14 for WDA by 7/1/15 and

member must complete 2 picket duty assignments by

12/31/15

2014-7

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Allan Kides (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/28/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-18

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael Pedone (LU 20)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/28/15

2014-85

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Thomas Daquanni (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 5/28/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a $250 fine due by 7/1/15, member must pay

outstanding balance of $2,477.26 for WDA by 7/1/15 and

member must complete 2 picket duty assignments by

12/31/15

Page 72: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-97

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Edward Feliciano (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 5/28/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Penalty is a $125 fine due by 7/1/15, member must pay

outstanding balance of $1,693.36 for WDA by 7/1/15 and

member must complete a second picket duty assignment by

12/31/15 (in addition to regular 2015 picket duty )

2014-27

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Sal Zarzana (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Violating the Consent Decree

*****Member accused of violating the Consent

Decree by engaging in extortion****

•Trial date - 5/28/15

•Found GUILTY of "Violating the obligation"

•"Violating the Consent Decree" WITHDRAWN

•Penalty is expulsion

2015-259

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael Mashack (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/2/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-235

Paul Sanabria (LU 45)

vs.

Samanthus Merchant (LU 926)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 6/11/15

2015-120

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jeffrey James Todd (LU 1556)

*Advocating division of the funds

* Advocating separation of any subordinate

body

* Violating the obligation

* Working for a non-union company

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/11/15

Page 73: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-24

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Raymond Gorman (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*Violating membership qualifications

*****Member accused of being a member of two

Labor Unions simultaneously*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/18/15

2014-99

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Fernando Figueroa (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 6/18/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine due within 60 days and member must

pay outstanding balance of $1,930.98 for WDA within 60

days; failure results in expulsion

2014-104

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Darrin Lyons (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 6/18/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine due within 60 days and member must

pay outstanding balance of $2,325 for WDA within 60 days;

failure results in expulsion

2014-371

Michael Power (LU 157)

vs.

Joseph Aurilia (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Advocating division of the funds

* Improper harassment

* Working for a non-union company

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of not following contract

rules for matching, sending members to a job for a

different rate and cash benefits, instructing men

to work in unsafe conditions and allowing laborers

to perform carpenter work*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 6/18/15

Page 74: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-39

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Nicolas Bellaby (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/19/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2014-21

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph F. Libasci Jr. (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/19/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-197

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Quincy G. James (LU 210)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/19/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-91

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Nuno Manuel Alfonso Gouveia (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/19/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-90

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Albert Francis (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/19/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-92

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Conor Grady (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/19/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 75: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-132

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph G. Cloonan Jr.(LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/19/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-105

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ruben Martinez (LU 251)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/23/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-167

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jerry J. Rosario (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/23/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-243

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Bueti (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/2/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed))

2014-171

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Christopher Paopao (LU 62)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/2/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed))

2014-173

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Alexander Romero(LU 1977)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/8/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 76: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-174

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Adan Sanchez (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/8/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-227(Amended)

John Clark (LU 157)

vs.

Marek Chociej (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Improper report of work hours for other

company member

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 7/9/15

2014-184

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Rowan Titley (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*Failing to perform union activity

*****Member accused of asking another member

to fullfill his picket duty obligation*****

•Settled on 7/9/15

•Pled GUILTY to "Defrauding the brotherhood " and

"Violating the obligation "

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $250

fine within 60 days

•"Failing to promote and protect memberships' interest " and

"Failing to perform union activity " dismissed by Trial Chair

2014-188

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Peter Monforte (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*Failing to perform union activity

*****Member accused of submiting a doctored

picket duty receipt*****

•Settled on 7/9/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $500

fine within 60 days

Page 77: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-186

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jose Pineiro (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working non-

union*****

•Settled on 7/9/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $1,000

fine within 60 days

2014-187

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Walter Nyborg (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working non-

union*****

•Settled on 7/9/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $500

fine within 60 days

2014-188

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Hugh McCallion (LU 290)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working non-

union*****

•Settled on 7/9/15

•Pled GUILTY to "Defrauding the brotherhood " and

"Violating the obligation "

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $1,500

fine within 60 days

•"Failing to promote and protect memberships' interest "

dismissed by Trial Chair

2014-179

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Octavius Williams (LU 1809)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/9/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 78: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-59

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Fernando Barajas (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

* Defrauding the brotherhood

* Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a

steward and while company is on shutdown

list*****

•Settled on 7/16/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to take the next available Trade Unionism class

2015-61

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jesus Garcia (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

* Defrauding the brotherhood

* Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a

steward and while company is on shutdown

list*****

•Settled on 7/16/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to take the next available Trade Unionism class

2014-54

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Gina (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 7/23/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $500 fine due within 60 days and member must

report to IG Office for interview within 60 days; failure to

comply results in expulsion

2014-62

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

William Ryan (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Violating membership qualifications

*****Member accused of being a member of two

Labor Unions simultaneously*****

•Trial date - 7/23/15

•Found NOT GUILTY of all charges

Page 79: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-70

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jonathan Carhart (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 7/23/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $500 fine due within 60 days and member must

report to IG Office for interview within 60 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-61

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gary Dowd (LU 157)

* Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

* Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for cash*****

•Trial date - 7/23/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $1,500 fine due within 60 days and a Letter of

Reprimand; failure to pay results in expulsion

2014-25

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Moizes Trindade (LU 157)

* Defrauding the brotherhood

* Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of posing as a laborer on

the jobsite*****

•Trial date - 7/23/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2015-236

James McDonnell (LU 1556)

vs.

Peter Hermansen (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

* Improper harassment

* Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to assist with

diffusing conflict on jobsite between

members*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 8/13/15

2015-238

James McDonnell (LU 1556)

vs.

William Vadney (LU 1556)

* Improper harassment

* Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of failing to diffuse

conflict on jobsite between members*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 8/13/15

Page 80: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-237

James McDonnell (LU 1556)

vs.

Paul Bartha (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

* Improper harassment

* Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 8/13/15

2015-312

James McDonnell (LU 1556)

vs.

Joseph Niedzwiecki (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

* Improper harassment

* Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of failing to diffuse

conflict on jobsite between members*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 8/13/15

2014-212

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Giovani Vasconcellos (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/13/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-206

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Anderson DaSilva (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/13/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 81: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-258

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Manuel Hernandez (LU 2287)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Settled on 8/13/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 90 days

2014-259

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jose Veras (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Settled on 8/13/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $100

fine within 60 days

2014-261

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Yuriy Tulba (LU 252)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Settled on 8/13/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $100

fine within 60 days

Page 82: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-262

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Norris Ryner (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Settled on 8/13/15

•Pled GUILTY to "Defrauding the brotherhood " and

"Violating the obligation "

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $100

fine within 60 days

•"Failing to promote and protect memberships' interest "

dismissed by Trial Chair

2014-263

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Raymond Carey (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of using hostile language

on the jobsite*****

•Settled on 8/13/15

•Pled GUILTY to "Improper harassment " and "Violating the

obligation "

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and take a sexual

harassment class within 1 year of the settlement.

•"Failing to promote and protect memberships' interest "

dismissed by Trial Chair

2014-235

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Wojciech Czerwinski (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/13/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-252

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Steven Rudolph (LU 454)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/13/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 83: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-366

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Anthony Caroppoli (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*Failure to report employment

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Settled on 8/13/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges •Agreed

to pay a $50 fine within 60 days

2014-364

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

David Mansfield (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Settled on 8/13/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $250

fine within 60 days

2015-231

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Clifford Lee (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/14/15

2014-102

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Eric Lynch (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/20/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed))

2014-113

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Javier Ortiz (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 8/20/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$3,062.48 for WDA and $250 fine within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

Page 84: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-108

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Cesar Deras (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 8/20/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$3,182.93 for WDA and $250 fine within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-117

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gerry Riordan (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 8/20/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$2,624.29 for WDA and $250 fine within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-109

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kevin Mooney (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 8/20/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$1,820.18 for WDA and $250 fine within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-94

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ian Horton (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 8/20/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$2,161.65 for WDA and $250 fine within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-72

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kensley Norian (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 8/20/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due within 60 days and member must

report to IG Office for interview within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

Page 85: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-80

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Alexander Francis (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 8/20/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due within 60 days and member must

report to IG Office for interview within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-11

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jeremy Meyers (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 8/20/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due within 60 days and member must

report to IG Office for interview within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-72

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Robert Larsen (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 8/20/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due within 60 days and member must

report to IG Office for interview within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-82

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Frederick (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Settled on 8/20/15

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $100 fine within 60 days

Page 86: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-307

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Freddy Navarro (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Trial date - 8/27/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a Letter of Reprimand and member must take the

next available Trade Unionism class

2014-410

Mangito Fowlkes (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jose Silva (LU 290)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward and letting Laborers perform Carpenter

work*****

•Trial date - 8/27/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $600 fine, Letter of Reprimand and member

must take the next available Trade Unionism class

2015-63

Glen Moguel (LU 926)

vs.

Coydette Beharie (LU 290)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/27/15

2015-376

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Ecker (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/27/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-231

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Shawn Bryan (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-303

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Slawsky (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 87: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-269

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kevin Wilder (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-230

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Christopher Bruno (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-330

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Patrick

Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael Duque (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-229

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Cesar Andreu (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-236

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Matthew Egan (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-239

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Adam Greenholtz (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 88: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-240

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Andrew John (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-242

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Bernard Kaminskas (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-243

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Lyons (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-246

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Brian Ortiz (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-247

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joaquim Pereira (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-250

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Robert Ricevuto (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 89: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-254

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kevin Clark (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-335

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Anthony Duncan (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-238

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Stephen Florio (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-209

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Farnese Silva (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2014-183

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Dexter Walcott (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

Page 90: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-208

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Dione Batista (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2014-194

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Alaor Rodrigues (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/28/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2013-120

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Steven Minunno (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/4/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2013-121

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Steven Minunno (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/4/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 91: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-360

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC)

vs.

Boyd Hodge (LU 926)

*Causing dissension

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Crossing or working behind a picket line

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of directing carpenters at a

non-union site*****

•Settled on 9/10/15

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $100 fine within 30 days and assist with the

concrete program.

2015-426

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC)

vs.

Richard D'Alessio (LU 22)

*Causing dissension

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Crossing or working behind a picket line

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of refusing to share

information at a non-union job site*****

•Settled on 9/10/15

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to provide the information previously refused.

2015-482

Kevin Fleming (NYCDCC)

vs.

Fernando Carcamo (LU 2287)

*Advocating division of the funds

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working at a site not

called in and without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 9/10/15

•Pled GUILTY to "Violating the obligation "

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $500

fine within 90 days.

•"Advocating division of the funds " dismissed by the Trial

Chair

Page 92: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-483

Kevin Fleming (NYCDCC)

vs.

John Cummings (LU 2287)

*Advocating division of the funds

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working at a site not

called in and without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 9/10/15

•Pled GUILTY to "Violating the obligation "

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $500

fine within 90 days.

•"Advocating division of the funds " dismissed by the Trial

Chair

2015-484

Kevin Fleming (NYCDCC)

vs.

Martin Criado (LU 2287)

*Advocating division of the funds

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working at a site not

called in and without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 9/10/15

•Pled GUILTY to "Violating the obligation "

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $500

fine within 90 days.

•"Advocating division of the funds " dismissed by the Trial

Chair

2015-420

Courtney Coaxum (LU 926)

vs.

Mariusz Skalny (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 9/10/15

2015-485

Sefkija Vucetovic (LU 1556)

vs.

Emanuel Pyros (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/11/15

Page 93: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-492

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Orlando Ortiz (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/11/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-340

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Marlon Dale Mindley (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/11/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-148

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Victor Obreiter (LU 251)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/11/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-374

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Brian Nolan (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/14/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 94: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-139

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Richard Lopez (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 9/17/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due within 30 days and member must

report to IG Office for interview within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-142

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jose Neto (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 9/17/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due within 30 days and member must

report to IG Office for interview within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-140

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Pena (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 9/17/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due within 30 days and member must

report to IG Office for interview within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-100

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Franz Kirstein III (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 9/17/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$2,598.15 for WDA and $250 fine within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

Page 95: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-116

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Juan Pimentel (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 9/17/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$2,219.40 for WDA and $250 fine within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-115

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Adam Phillips (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 9/17/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$2,004.60 for WDA and $250 fine within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-124

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Christopher Tanzi (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 9/17/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$2,789.62 for WDA and $250 fine within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-125

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Wendel Thornton (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 9/17/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$2,690.71 for WDA and $250 fine within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

Page 96: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-95

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gerald Kelleher (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 9/17/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$5,035.56 for WDA and $250 fine within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-110

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kevin Morris (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 9/17/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$2,131.42 for WDA and $250 fine within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-58

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Chris Capobianco (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Trial date - 9/17/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine due within 60 days

2014-143

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Premnath Gopaul (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/17/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 97: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-140

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Steven Quattrochhi (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/17/15

(Member cooperating with IGO)

2015-366

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Anthony Condon (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/18/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-313

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Alison Silverman (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/18/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-460

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

George Greco (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/24/15

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

Page 98: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-59

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Walter Marano (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of operating a non-union

company*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/24/15

(Member signed BCA agreement with NYCDCC)

2014-306

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Venancio Albanez (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Settled on 9/24/15

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $100 fine within 60 days

2014-114

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Paul Ortolani (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 9/24/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$3,443.19 for WDA and $300 fine within 60 days; failure

results in expulsion and member must complete 2 days of

picket duty

2014-131

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

David Yuengling (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 9/24/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$2,109.56 for WDA and $300 fine within 60 days; failure

results in expulsion and member must complete 2 days of

picket duty

Page 99: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-123

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Suriano (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 9/24/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$3,360.83 for WDA and $300 fine within 60 days;failure

results in expulsion and member must complete 2 days of

picket duty

2014-120

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Steven Roloff (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 9/24/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$1,947.23 for WDA and $300 fine within 60 days;failure

results in expulsion and member must complete 2 days of

picket duty

2014-122

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Wahid Street (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 9/24/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$1,947.72 for WDA and $300 fine within 60 days; failure

results in expulsion and member must complete 2 days of

picket duty

2014-121

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG) Martin

Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Mark Stobierski (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 9/24/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$5,531.05 for WDA and $300 fine within 60 days; failure

results in expulsion and member must complete 2 days of

picket duty

Page 100: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-145

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Fredy Mejia (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*Failure to report employment

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Trial date - 9/24/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $175 fine, a Letter of Reprimand and member

must complete 1 additional day of union participation

2014-146

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Edwin Santana (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*Failure to report employment

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Trial date - 9/24/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $175 fine, a Letter of Reprimand and member

must complete 1 additional day of union participation

2015-494

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Marco Quito (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/2/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-276

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Daniel Nolan (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/8/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 101: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-274

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Adrian Quituizaca (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/8/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-287

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Thomas Meyer (LU 255)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/8/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-277

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Daniel Nolan (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/8/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-297

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Peter Lanza (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/8/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 102: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-293

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Shaun Campbell (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/8/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-265

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jan Klinovsky (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/8/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-278

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael Ward (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Violating membership qualifications

*****Member accused of being a member of two

Labor Unions simultaneously*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/8/15

(Member not a cardholder for alternate Labor Union)

2015-06

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Travis Rivera (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for wages less

than CBA*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 10/8/15

Page 103: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-281

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joe Cedeno (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/8/15

(Duplicate charges)

2015-07

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Yvette White (LU 45)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Settled on 10/8/15

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $125 fine within 30 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2015-533

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ciaran Canavan (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/14/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-270

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Mariusz Skalny (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/14/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 104: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-260

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Walter Clayton (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Violating the Consent Decree

*****Member accused of communicating with

individuals convicted of labor racketeering****

•Settled on 8/13/15

•Pled GUILTY to "Violating the obligation "

•Agreed to pay a $500 fine within 60 days, receive a Letter

of Reprimand and banned from sitting on any LU 2790

committee until 10/1/19

•"Violating the Consent Decree " dismissed by Trial Chair

2014-129

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Daniel Velasquez (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 10/15/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$2,689.35 for WDA and a $250 fine

2014-96

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Franklyn Edwards (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 10/15/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$4,734.49 for WDA and a $250 fine

2014-126

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Luis Urgiles (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Trial date - 10/15/15

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is member must pay outstanding balance of

$2,367.69 for WDA and a $250 fine

Page 105: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-373

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC- OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Douglas Carroll (LU 2287)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for wages less

than CBA*****

•Settled on 10/15/15

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 60 days, receive a Letter

of Reprimand and restriction from becoming a Shop Steward

for 24 months

2014-411

Darren Haskins (LU 157)

vs.

Thomas Gorman (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/20/15

2014-425

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC)

vs.

Junior Browne (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Crossing or working behind a picket line

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of crossing picket line to

work on non-union jobsite*****

•Trial date - 10/22/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

Page 106: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-425

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Luis Barajas (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*Sent as Acting Steward, left job without

notification

*****Member accused of leaving job without

notifying the union after being dispatched as an

Acting Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/22/15

2015-45

James Makin (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jason Roy Jr. (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of crossing picket line to

work on non-union jobsite*****

•Trial date - 10/22/15

•Found NOT GUILTY of "Lumping"

•Found GUILTY of "Defrauding the brotherhood", "Violating

the obligation" and "Failing to protect memberships'

interest"

•Penalty is expulsion

2015-254

Grigory Shabashevich (LU 157)

vs.

Brian Hess (LU 251)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a Saturday

without informaing the Shop Steward*****

•Trial date - 10/22/15

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a letter of reprimand, 1 picket duty assignment to

be completed by 12/31/15 and probabtion for 12 months; if

member is brought up on charges in that timeframe, a $750

fine will be imposed.

2015-85

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Lewis Ianuale (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 107: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-66

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Frank Ciccolella (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-90

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael Lorenzo (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-36

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Eugene Sarantapoulas (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-34

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Mark Allen Redden (LU 1090)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-30

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Charles Allen Lemaster (LU 1090)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-18

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Vincent Bruno (LU 1090)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 108: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-81

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Osbourne Gordon (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-196

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Maurice James (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-205

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jamie O'Neill (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-157

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ricardo Weste (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-158

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jeffrey Wilkenson (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-184

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Richard Clefstad (LU 56)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 109: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-103

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

William Widergren (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-129

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Thomas Calvaruso (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-139

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jerry Hicks (LU 251)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-146

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Thomas Miller (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-279

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ronald Coye (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/29/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-05

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Davinder Singh (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for wages less

than CBA*****

•Settled on 11/12/15

•Pled GUILTY to "Violating the obligation " all other charges

withdrawn

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $250

fine within 60 days

Page 110: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-255

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC- OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Alexander Morera (LU 254)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of failing to notify District

Council of non-union workers on site*****

•Settled on 11/12/15

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2015-09

Edward Brandon (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Thomas Hennessey (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of underpaying a union

member*****

•Settled on 11/12/15

•Pled GUILTY to "Defrauding the brotherhood " and

"Violating the obligation "

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 60 days

•"Failing to promote and protect memberships' interest "

dismissed by Trial Chair

2015-175

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC- OIG)

Russell Kennedy (NYCDCC - OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Tomasz Sobolewski (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of underpaying a union

member*****

•Settled on 11/12/15

•Pled GUILTY to "Defrauding the brotherhood " and

"Violating the obligation "

•Agreed to pay a $120 fine within 90 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

•"Failing to promote and protect memberships' interest "

dismissed by Trial Chair

2015-239

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Frank Bernard (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for wages less

than CBA*****

•Settled on 11/12/15

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $150 fine within 60 days

2015-501

Jerome Christian (LU 157)

vs.

Christal Johnson (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/12/15

Page 111: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-538

DuVal Jones (LU 20)

vs.

Christal Johnson (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/12/15

2015-502

Dominick Cassissa (LU 20)

vs.

Christal Johnson (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 11/12/15

2015-486

Linda Dugue (LU 157)

vs.

Rayneir Gamboa (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 11/12/15

2015-537

Linda Dugue (LU 157)

vs.

James Smith (LU 157)

*Advocating separation

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to resolve conflict

on site and unjust layoff*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 11/12/15

2015-480

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Leonardo Jimenez (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working for a company

on the shutdown list*****

•Settled on 11/12/15

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $100 fine within 60 days

2015-497

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Francis Betlewicz (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/13/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 112: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-499

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Marc Chavanne (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/13/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-443

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Steven Banyai (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-292

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Bobby Mattox (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-521

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Richard Della-Penta (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-510

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Daniel Birch (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-465

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Eric Kise (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-442

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael Asaro (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 113: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-453

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

James Courtney (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-283

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Andrew Ewing (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-266

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Rayborn Glascow (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-268

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Alexander Romero (LU 1977)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-271

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Leroy Williams (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-307

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

David Terrano (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-298

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Patterson (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-403

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Anthony Rivara (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 114: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-396

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Santiago Laureano (LU 157)

*Violating the obligationx

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-345

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Sean Arthur O'Leary (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-357

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Radhames Valdera (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-517

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Vincent Perrone (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-415

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Dustin Undermark (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/17/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-552

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joe Witt (LU 251)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/18/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-324

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Slawomir Bury (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/18/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 115: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-394

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

James O'Neill (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/18/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2014-346

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Andrew Perkins (LU 803)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/18/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-314

John Terlemezian (LU 1556)

vs.

Brian Vohs (LU 1556)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 11/19/15

•Found NOT GUILTY of charge

2015-392

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Carlos Figueroa (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/1/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-406

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Timothy Ryan (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/1/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-187

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Timothy Doran (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/1/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-280

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Louis Defede (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/1/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

Page 116: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-512

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Shannon (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/1/15

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-316

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC- OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Todd Stone (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of selling counterfeit

certification cards*****

•Settled on 12/10/15

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $100 fine within 60 days

2015-544

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jason Sandy (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of failing to report to work

as an Acting Shop Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/10/15

2015-240

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Luszczyk (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/10/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 117: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-292

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Vincent Dini (LU 20)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/10/15

(Member assisting IGO with information on non-union work)

2015-433

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael Caulfield (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/10/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-370

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Timothy McNair (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/10/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 118: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-372

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Manuel Diaz (LU 2287)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for wages

other then those in CBA*****

•Settled on 12/10/15

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $700 fine within 90 days

2015-226

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Bokun (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/14/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-318

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kyle Kennedy (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/16/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-359

Emmanuel Christiano (LU 157)

vs.

Bart Buigues (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 12/17/15

Page 119: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-250

Kevin Fleming (NYCDCC)

vs.

Muller Oliveira (LU 2287)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

contractor*****

•Trial date - 12/17/15

•Found NOT GUILTY of "Lumping"

•Found GUILTY of "Defrauding the brotherhood" and

"Violating the obligation"

•Penalty is a $2,000 fine and a Letter of Reprimand

2015-262

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Brian Sanchez (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/17/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-245

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

William Nicolis (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/18/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-432

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Marwan Hinnawi (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/18/15

(Member did not require an interview)

Page 120: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-244

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Albert Charles (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/21/15

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-168

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Robert Del Grosso (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/6/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-305

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ruben Figueroa (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/7/16

(Investigation closed)

2015-317

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Frank Orlando (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/8/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 121: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-164

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Shawn O'Connell (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/8/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-324

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Paul Russo (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/11/16

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2015-340

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Waldemar Konefal (LU 251)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to pay working

dues assessment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/14/16

(Member paid WDA associated with charges)

2015-225

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Delroy Pryce (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/18/16

(Investigation closed)

Page 122: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-117

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Orlando Calderin (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/19/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-118

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Sammy Calderin (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/19/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-172

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Daniel McGarvey (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/19/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-567

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Profeta Jr. (LU 20)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/19/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 123: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-222

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael Euler (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/21/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-252

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

George Chin (LU 251)

*Causing dissension

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of engaging in unsafe

conduct on jobsite which caused injury to a fellow

member*****

•Trial date - 1/21/16

•Found NOT GUILTY of all charges

2015-424

Thomas Gaulrapp (NYCDCC)

vs.

Shawn R. McEnteer (LU 251)

*Causing dissension

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a shop

steward while in position of forman*****

•Trial date - 1/21/16

•Found GUILTY of "Violating the obligation"

•Penalty is a $250 fine due and probation for 18 months; if

found guilty of a similar violation within that timeframe, he is

to be expelled.

•Found NOT GUILTY of "Causing dissension"

2015-258

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Perez (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/27/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 124: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-44

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

George Harrison (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 1/28/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due within 60 days and member must

report to IG Office for interview within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-180

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Patrick Fitzmaurice (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 1/28/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due within 60 days and member must

report to IG Office for interview within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2014-181

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael Librizzi (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 1/28/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due within 60 days and member must

report to IG Office for interview within 30 days; failure

results in expulsion

2015-176

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gregory F. Lanza (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/1/16

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

Page 125: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-438

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jason M. Meister (LU 272)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/10/16

(Member made arrangements to comply with obligation)

2015-52

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Luigi Ruotolo (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/11/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-110

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Curran (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/11/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-104

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Judson Romualdo (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges dismissed by the Trial Chair on 2/11/16

Page 126: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-105

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gonzalo Ferreras (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges dismissed by the Trial Chair on 2/11/16

2016-4

Tyrone Rodney (LU 157)

vs.

Cesar Andreu (LU 290)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by the Trial Chair on 2/11/16

2015-572

Kenneth Bluhm (NYCDCC)

vs.

Arkiem McClain (LU 20)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to report to work

after accepting the job*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/11/16

2014-412

Mangito Fowlkes (NYCDCC)

vs.

Stephen Wilhelm (LU 373)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Trial date - 2/25/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $250 fine and a Letter of Reprimand

2014-413

Mangito Fowlkes (NYCDCC)

vs.

Tim Burdett (LU 373)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Trial date - 2/25/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $250 fine and a Letter of Reprimand

Page 127: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-414

Mangito Fowlkes (NYCDCC)

vs.

Zach Wilhelm (LU 373)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Trial date - 2/25/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $250 fine and a Letter of Reprimand

2015-251

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Michael Beatty (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of engaging in unsafe

conduct on jobsite which caused injury to a fellow

member*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/25/16

2015-249

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Julio Ruiz (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of failing to perform

Acting Shop Steward duties*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/25/16

2015-479

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Frank O'Neill (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of failing to report to work

after accepting the job*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/25/16

Page 128: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-576

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Richard Frusciante (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/29/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-4

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joe Reilly (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/1/16

2015-547

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Lionel Mincey (LU 251)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/7/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-573

James Gegan (NYCDCC - OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC - OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Frank Lee (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to perform shop

steward duties*****

•Settled on 3/10/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to surrender shop steward skills for 8 months and

receive a Letter of Reprimand

Page 129: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-310

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Margarito Perez (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Failing to report working at a location

*Failing to work on site without a shop

steward

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward and failing to notify union of job*****

•Settled on 3/10/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to take a Trade Unionism class within six months;

failure results in a $500 fine

2016-6

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Margarito Perez (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 3/10/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to take a Trade Unionism class within six months;

failure results in a $500 fine

2014-308

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Carlos Soto (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Failing to report working at a location

*Failing to work on site without a shop

steward

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward and failing to notify union of job*****

•Settled on 3/10/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to take a Trade Unionism class within six months;

failure results in a $500 fine

Page 130: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-5

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Carlos Soto (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 3/10/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to take a Trade Unionism class within six months;

failure results in a $500 fine

2015-315

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Vincent Gandolfo (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Trial date - 3/17/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $525 fine and a Letter of Reprimand

2015-253

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Younker (LU 253)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Trial date - 3/17/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $900 fine due within 30 days

2015-256

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Randy Garcia (LU 279)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Settled on 3/17/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to take a Trade Unionism class and pay a $100 fine

Page 131: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-257

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Bienvenido Garcia (LU 279)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to promote and protect memberships'

interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-

signatory contractor*****

•Settled on 3/17/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to take a Trade Unionism class and pay a $100 fine

2016-27

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Denson Regis (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/22/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-291

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Mervin Yearwood (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/24/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-282

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Geraldo DaSilva (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/24/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 132: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-147

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jose Siso (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Violating membership qualifications

*****Member accused of being a member of two

Labor Unions simultaneously*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/24/16

(Member retired from NYCDCC)

2014-269

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Christopher Begley (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 3/24/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2014-275

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Rupert McLeod (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 3/24/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine

2014-195

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Stephen Fogarty (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 3/24/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine

Page 133: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-205

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Salvador Vicenty (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 3/24/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine

2014-302

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Anthony Pully (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 3/24/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2013-163

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Mario Flaim (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of manipulating OWL skills

to obtain job*****

•Settled on 3/23/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2015-165

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Juan Oyola (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/28/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 134: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-261

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Juan Oyola (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/28/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-379

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Juan Oyola (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/28/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-264

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Salvatore Filiano (LU 291)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/14/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-367

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Christopher Lee (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/14/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 135: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-431

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Marcel Vasile (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/14/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-557

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Edward Matthews (LU 253)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 4/14/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $100 fine within 90 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2015-561

Daniel Dunbar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Yakov Engelman (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward and for a non-union comapny*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/14/16

2015-562

Daniel Dunbar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Carmelo Carcione (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward and for a non-union comapny*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/14/16

Page 136: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-294

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Derick Jones (LU 20)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/14/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-296

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joe Cedeno (LU 20)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/14/16

(Member charged with similar violation on another charge)

2015-436

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jesus Figueroa (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/18/16

(Investigation closed)

2015-427

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Carlos Rodriguez (LU 45)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 4/21/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $100 fine within 60 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

Page 137: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-371

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Anthony Calabro (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of violating the Consent

Decree by engaging in extortion****

•Trial date - 4/21/16

•Found GUILTY of charge

•Penalty is expulsion

2014-358

Edward Brandon (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szaabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Trevor Smith (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Charges dismissed by the Trial Chair on 4/21/16

2014-290

Edward Brandon (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szaabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Vernon Tonge (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 4/21/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $150 fine within 60 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2014-299

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joe Cedeno (LU 20)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 4/21/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $450 fine

Page 138: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-300

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ismael Rivera (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/21/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-106

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ismael Rivera (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/21/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-304

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Steve Bolthausen (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 4/21/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $450 fine

2015-361

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Karl Hodge (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/22/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 139: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-548

Kevin Fleming (NYCDCC)

vs.

Daniel Graca (LU 251)

*Defrauding the United Brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working on a job not

called in and with alongside a non-union

worker*****

•Trial date - 4/28/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine and Letter of Reprimand

2015-570

Linda Dugue (LU 157)

vs.

James Smith (LU 157)

*Improperh harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to resolve conflict

on site and unjust layoff*****

•Trial date - 4/28/16

•Found NOT GUILTY of all charges

2015-543

Chandrashekar Singh (LU 2790)

vs.

Ishwar Ramsoondar (LU 2790)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by the Trial Chair on 5/12/16

2016-9

David Maffia (LU 157)

vs.

Edward Saunders (LU 157)

* Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment and filing

complaint with jobsite HR dept rather than trying

to handle conflict through the union*****

•Charges dismissed by the Trial Chair on 5/12/16

2015-542

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Fernando Cunningham (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/12/16

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

Page 140: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-541

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Fernando Cunningham (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/12/16

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2015-491

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Rider Zambrana (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/12/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-583

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Carlos Garcia (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Trial date - 5/26/16

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2015-574

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jason Picorelli (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/27/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 141: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-580

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Dain Barach (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/6/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-551

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jason Picorelli (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/7/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-532

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jeffroy Whittingham (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/9/16

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2016-45

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Darvin Ochoa (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Charges dismissed by the Trial Chair on 6/9/16

Page 142: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-7

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Fadil Sadiku (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Charges dismissed by the Trial Chair on 6/16/16

2015-536

Kevin Fleming (NYCDCC)

vs.

William Trella (LU 2287)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Trial date - 6/16/16

•Found NOT GUILTY of charges

2015-565

Levi Messinetti (LU 157)

vs.

William Walsh (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Defrauding the United Brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of submitting meeting

minutes with false statements*****

•Charges dismissed by the Trial Chair on 6/16/16

2015-579

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Chandradat Mahoye (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/23/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 143: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-39

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Chandradat Mahoye (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/23/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-12

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Felix Boyd (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 6/23/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine

2014-375

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Vincenzo Ljuba (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 6/23/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine

2015-582

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC- OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Desmond Dailey (LU 251)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date on 6/23/16

•Found GUILTY to all charges

•Penalty is a Letter of Reprimand and completion of the

Sexual Harassment Course

Page 144: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-49

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jesse Eldora (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/6/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-560

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Lou Fusaro (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/14/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-18

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Francesco Ingallinera (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/14/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-15

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Adam Tavernia (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/14/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 145: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-585

Joseph Lauer (LU 157)

vs.

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Defrauding the United Brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*violating the Consent Decree

*****Member accused of violating the Obligation

and Consent Decree*****

•Charges dismissed by the Trial Chair on 7/14/16

2015-586

Joseph Lauer (LU 157)

vs.

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Defrauding the United Brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*violating the Consent Decree

*****Member accused of violating the Obligation

and Consent Decree*****

•Charges dismissed by the Trial Chair on 7/14/16

2015-587

Joseph Lauer (LU 157)

vs.

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC - OIG)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Defrauding the United Brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*violating the Consent Decree

*****Member accused of violating the Obligation

and Consent Decree*****

•Charges dismissed by the Trial Chair on 7/14/16

Page 146: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-588

Joseph Lauer (LU 157)

vs.

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Defrauding the United Brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*violating the Consent Decree

*****Member accused of violating the Obligation

and Consent Decree*****

•Charges dismissed by the Trial Chair on 7/14/16

2015-589

Joseph Lauer (LU 157)

vs.

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Defrauding the United Brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*violating the Consent Decree

*****Member accused of violating the Obligation

and Consent Decree*****

•Charges dismissed by the Trial Chair on 7/14/16

2016-2

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Linus Alphonse (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 7/14/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 180 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

Page 147: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2013-75

Daniel Saraceno (LU 1556)

vs.

Joseph Passero (LU 1556)

*Misappropriating funds

*Defrauding the United Brotherhood

*Furnishing a list of the membership to an

unauthorized person

*Divulging the business of any subordinate

body to an unauthorized person

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of giving out membership

information without approval*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/15/16

2015-563

Daniel Dunbar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Dudley Davis (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Trial date - 7/21/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine

2014-266

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Steven Bakke (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 7/28/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine

Page 148: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-111

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Luis Velez (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 7/28/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine

2014-318

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Rosato (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 7/28/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine

2015-108

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Miguel Ribeiro (LU 212)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 7/28/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine

2015-571

William McKenna (LU 157)

vs.

Thomas McGonnigle (LU 157)

*Misappropriating funds

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of using union funds for

personal business*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/28/16

Page 149: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-35

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Pedro Desousa (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/11/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-36

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Orlando Delacruz (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/11/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-32

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Celim Matthews (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of falsifying an OSHA

certification*****

•Settled on 8/11/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2016-49

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Carlos Deleg (LU 279)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 8/11/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 60 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

Page 150: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-48

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Thomas Garcia (LU 45)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 8/11/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 60 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2016-10

Brian Conlon (NYCDCC)

vs.

David Cales (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to report to

dispatched job*****

•Trial date - 8/18/16

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Penalty is expulsion but can be avoided if a $300 fine is paid

within 3 months and the Trade Unionism Class is completed

within 3 months

2015-422

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Dwaine Morris (LU 2790)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of performing

piecework*****

•Settled on 8/18/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $1,000 fine within 90 days

2015-429

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Jeffroy Whittingham (LU 2790)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of performing

piecework*****

•Settled on 8/18/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $1,000 fine within 90 days

Page 151: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-430

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Howard Ledgister (LU 2790)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of performing

piecework*****

•Settled on 8/18/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $1,000 fine within 90 days

2015-428

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Roy Reid (LU 2790)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of asking other members

to perfom piecework*****

•Settled on 8/22/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $2,000 fine within 120 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2014-283

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Miroslaw Lakota (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Violating membership qualifications

*****Member accused of being a member of two

Labor Unions simultaneously*****

•Trial date - 8/25/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $1,000 fine and expulsion

2014-365

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Leonard Scaffidi (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*Failure to report employment

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Settled - 8/25/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

Page 152: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-50

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Eddie Kendle (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/8/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-64

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jesus Brito (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/8/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-59

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Alfredo Ramirez (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/8/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-53

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Randy Cooper (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*****Member accused of working on a jobsite in

place of another member who was

dispatched*****

•Settled - 9/8/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $250

fine within 90 days

Page 153: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-52

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Kevin Auguste (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*****Member accused of sending another

member to a jobsite in his place*****

•Settled - 9/8/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $500

fine within 90 days

2015-369

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Howard Ledgister (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/8/16

(Matter has been resolved)

2014-309

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Mauricio Diaz (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a shop

steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/14/16

2016-8

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Manuel Nestor Armas (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of failing to report to

dispatched job as acting steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/14/16

Page 154: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-44

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

James Gegan (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Victor Chuchuca (LU 279)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Trial date - 9/15/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $1,000 fine due in 60 days and a Letter of

Reprimand

2016-73

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Jose Pagan (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 9/15/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $1,000 fine within 180 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2016-70

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Richard Paul (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/20/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-487

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Salvatore Piccirillo Jr. (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 9/22/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

Page 155: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-10

Edward Brandon (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

William Giannini (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of conspiring with another

member to have his son sponsored into the Union

as a journeyman receiving apprentice wages with

journeymen benefits*****

•Settled on 9/22/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 30 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2015-08

Edward Brandon (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Robert Giannini (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of agreeing to receive

apprentice wages with journeymen benefits in

return for sponsorship into the Union*****

•Settled on 9/22/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $125 fine within 30 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2015-170

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Richard Osbourne (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/22/16

(Member is no longer with NYCDCC)

2015-171

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Lamont Dees (LU 604)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 9/22/16

•Found GUILTY of charge

•Penalty is a Letter of Reprimand

Page 156: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-206

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Anthony Melchiori (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 9/22/16

•Found GUILTY of charge

•Penalty is a Letter of Reprimand and $50 fine payable in 90

days

2015-223

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Goitram Persaud (LU 45)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 9/22/16

•Found GUILTY of charge

•Penalty is a $200 fine payable in 90 days

2015-248

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Jose Galante (LU 252)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 9/22/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2015-224

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Jose Galante (LU 252)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 9/22/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

Page 157: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-140

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Pena (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Penalty modified - 9/22/16

•Penalty now reflects a $150 fine and expulsion but

expulsion can be avoided if member reports to IG Office for

interview within 60 days

2014-11

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jeremy Meyers (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Penalty modified - 9/22/16

•Penalty now reflects a $150 fine and expulsion but

expulsion can be avoided if member reports to IG Office for

interview within 60 days

2016-75

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Dwaine Morris (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/13/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-77

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Julio Candia (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/13/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 158: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-58

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Darian James (LU 45)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 10/13/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $600 fine within 180 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2016-56

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Ronald Richardson (LU 45)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 10/13/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $125 fine within 30 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2016-51

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

James Gegan (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Anthony Robinson (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 10/13/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $125 fine within 30 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2016-42

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Steven Krauss (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/13/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 159: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-75

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Timothy Hough (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/20/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2014-268

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Arena (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/20/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-40

Joseph Digiorno (LU 1556)

vs.

Luis Condes (LU 1556)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair 10/20/16

2015-242

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Elias Duran (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 10/20/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due in 60 days

Page 160: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-241

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Vernon Sutton (LU 212)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 10/20/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due in 60 days

2015-435

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Verne Montelpasse (LU 1539)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 10/20/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due in 60 days

2015-434

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Peter Sansone (LU 80)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 10/20/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due in 60 days

2015-535

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Pascone (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 10/27/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine and 1 year suspension from all union

sponsored activities

Page 161: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-545

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Navado Bailey (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 10/27/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $600 fine

2015-488

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Alvaro Gonzales (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 10/27/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $600 fine

2015-363

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Mariusz Hanus (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 10/27/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine

2015-377

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Vladislav Ljavenec (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 10/27/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine

Page 162: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-263

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Thomas Sitone (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 10/27/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine

2016-93

Anthony Iuni (LU 157)

vs.

Frank Necco (LU 290)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/9/16

2016-94

Anthony Iuni (LU 157)

vs.

Robert Busking (LU 290)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of setting up coworker to

get in trouble on jobsite*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/9/16

2016-92

Thomas Gaulrapp (NYCDCC)

vs.

Frank Necco (LU 290)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*****Member accused of forcing workers to start

early and work through lunch without overtime

pay*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/9/16

Page 163: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-496

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Thomas James (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/10/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-89

Daniel Dunbar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Sheldon Daniels (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward and failing to report job*****

•Settled - 11/10/16

•Pled guilty to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and complete an

additional day of picket duty by December 31, 2016

2016-90

Daniel Dunbar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Shawn Moss (LU 277)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward and failing to report job*****

•Settled - 11/10/16

•Pled guilty to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and complete an

additional day of picket duty by December 31, 2016

2016-72

Jose Jarquin (LU 157)

vs.

Anthony Verdino (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by TC on 11/17/16

Page 164: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-490

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Edward McDougall (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/28/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-57

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Joseph Giresi (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 12/8/16

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 180 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2016-79

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Thomas Monaco (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Settled on 12/8/16

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to pay a $50 fine within 30 days and receive a Letter

of Reprimand

2016-80

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

David Schmidt (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Settled on 12/8/16

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to pay a $50 fine within 30 days and receive a Letter

of Reprimand

Page 165: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-81

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Michael Hughes (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Settled on 12/8/16

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to pay a $50 fine within 90 days and receive a Letter

of Reprimand

2016-97

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gheorghe Lup (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/8/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-99

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kenn Goodwin (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/8/16

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2016-101

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Cesar Rodriguez (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/8/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 166: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-365

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Anthony Tirlokhi (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/13/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-500

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jeffrey Zamora (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 12/15/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine and Letter of Reprimand

2015-546

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

David Hassett (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 12/15/16

•Found NOT GUILTY of all charges

2015-549

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Marco Franco-Rivera (LU 212)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 12/15/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine and Letter of Reprimand

Page 167: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-423

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Enrique Groos (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 12/15/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine and Letter of Reprimand

2015-489

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jhon Maza (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 12/15/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine and Letter of Reprimand

2015-247

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Tim Liquori (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 12/15/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine and Letter of Reprimand

2015-221

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Oliveiro Ribeiro (LU 212)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 12/15/16

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine and Letter of Reprimand

Page 168: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-569

Linda Dugue (LU 157)

vs.

Rayneir Gamboa (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 12/22/16

•Found NOT GUILTY of all charges

2016-98

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Faustino Hernandez (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/21/16

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-105

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Quinton Lyndell Tittle (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 12/28/16

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2016-134

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph McDonough (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/3/17

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

Page 169: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-132

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Domingo Suarez (LU 1556)

*Advocating division of the funds

* Defrauding the brotherhood

* Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of letting Laborers perform

Timbermen work*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/10/17

2016-96

Jose Jarquin (LU 157)

vs.

Anthony Verdino (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by TC on 1/12/17

2016-129

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jorge Coyago (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 1/12/17

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 60 days take the Trade

Unionism Class

2016-128

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Francisco Perez (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 1/12/17

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 60 days take the Trade

Unionism Class

2016-133

Brian McLaughlin (NYCDCC)

vs.

Kevin Nelson (LU 1556)

* Violating the obligation

*Working while registered on the OWL

*****Member accused of sending another

member to dispatched job in his place*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/12/17

Page 170: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-566

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Garett Douglas (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/18/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-575

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Richard Frusciante (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/18/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-566

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Garett Douglas (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/19/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-122

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Juan Carlos Lopez (LU 252)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/19/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 171: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-24

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Anthony Stevens (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 1/19/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $225 fine due in 90 days and Letter of

Reprimand

2016-22

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Krzyszof Golaszewski (LU 252)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 1/19/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due in 90 days

2016-11

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jonathan Galeas (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 1/19/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due in 90 days

2016-20

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Luis Salazar (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 1/19/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due in 90 days

Page 172: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-539

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jerry Stocchetti (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 1/19/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due in 90 days

2015-568

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kevin Mallen (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 1/19/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due in 90 days

2016-19

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Stanislaw Losinski (LU 252)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 1/19/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due in 90 days

2016-46

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Matthew Leschinski (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 1/19/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due in 90 days and a Letter of

Reprimand

Page 173: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2015-559

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Ulrich (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/25/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2015-493

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Alrick Joseph (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/25/17

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2016-108

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Julio Candia (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Trial date - 1/26/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine due within 180 days

2016-125

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Robert Cascini (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 1/26/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $2,500 fine due within 180 days

Page 174: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-131

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Todd Stone (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/8/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-142

Kenneth Bluhm (NYCDCC)

vs.

Thomas Ahearn (LU 251)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/8/17

2016-141

Kenneth Bluhm (NYCDCC)

vs.

Joseph Slattery (LU 251)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/8/17

2016-140

Kenneth Bluhm (NYCDCC)

vs.

Ronald Renter (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/8/17

Page 175: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-139

Kenneth Bluhm (NYCDCC)

vs.

Thomas Bianco (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/8/17

2016-74

Steven Klement (LU 2287)

vs.

Jeffrey Tolk (LU 2287)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 2/23/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•No penalty imposed

2015-564

Daniel Dunbar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Andrew Ewing (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Trial date - 2/23/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $500 fine and Letter of Reprimand

2016-71

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Lesroy Byrde (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Trial date - 2/23/17

•Found GUILTY to all charges

•Penalty is a $1,500 fine, a Letter of Reprimand and member

must complete the Trade Unionism Class.

Page 176: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-63

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Christopher Duignan (LU 212)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 2/23/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine and Letter of Reprimand

2016-26

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Daniel Ruckstuhl (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 2/23/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine and Letter of Reprimand

2016-38

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ulices Correa (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 2/23/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine and Letter of Reprimand

2016-21

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Edward Tamarez (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 2/23/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine and Letter of Reprimand

Page 177: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-135

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Robert McCloskey (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/24/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2017-9

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jordan Caraballo (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/2/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2017-102

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ivor Baker (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 3/9/17

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $500 fine within 180 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2016-113

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC - OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Dominik Zych (LU 926)

*Violating membership qualifications

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of submitting a fraudulent

letter of intent to gain entry to the union*****

•Settled on 3/9/17

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $150 fine within 60 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

Page 178: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-116

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC - OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Pawel Lupinski (LU 926)

*Violating membership qualifications

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of submitting a fraudulent

letter of intent to gain entry to the union*****

•Settled on 3/9/17

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $150 fine within 60 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2016-84

Linda Dugue (LU 157)

vs.

Keith Reid (LU 290)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 3/16/17

•Found NOT GUILTY of all charges

2016-43

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kevin Doyle (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 3/16/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine and Letter of Reprimand

2016-41

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Carlos Cruz (LU 279)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 3/16/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine and Letter of Reprimand

Page 179: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-17

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Christopher Berlingo (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/17/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-78

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Elvis Browne (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 3/23/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine and Letter of Reprimand

2016-33

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Rui Marques (LU 290)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of owning and operating a

non-union company*****

•Trial date - 3/23/17

•Found GUILTY to all charges

•Penalty is expulsion and a $15,300 fine

2016-86

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Miguel Cintron (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/23/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 180: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-138

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Elijah Brooks (LU 212)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/29/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-137

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Elijah Brooks (LU 212)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/29/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-95

Brian McLaughlin (NYCDCC)

vs.

Matthew Cudeyro (LU 255)

*Causing dissension

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of utilizing Laborers to

perform Dockbuilder work*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/11/17

2017-1

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Ariel Espinal (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 4/13/17

•Pled GUILTY to "Defrauding the brotherhood " , all

other charges dismissed as part of the settlement

•Agreed to pay a $500 fine within 60 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

Page 181: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-2

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Juan Diaz (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 4/13/17

•Pled GUILTY to "Defrauding the brotherhood " , all

other charges dismissed as part of the settlement

•Agreed to pay a $500 fine within 60 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2016-136

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Perry Viggiano (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/17/17

(Member in compliance with investigation)

2017-10

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Felix Boyd (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/17/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2017-22

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Zenon Kulesza (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/18/17

(Member completed investigative interview with IGO)

Page 182: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-54

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

James Gegan (NYCDCC- OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Clever S. Peralta (LU 279)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 4/20/17

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 180 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2016-88

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Julien Simon (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 4/20/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine

2016-85

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Alvaro Gonzales (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 4/20/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine

2017-7

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Juan Servin (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 4/20/17

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $150 fine within 30 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

Page 183: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-6

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ariel Servin (LU 2287)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 4/20/17

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $150 fine within 30 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2017-3

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Edy Catalan (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 4/20/17

•Pled GUILTY to "Defrauding the brotherhood " , all

other charges dismissed as part of the settlement

•Agreed to pay a $500 fine within 60 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2016-83

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gavin Hart Jr. (LU 210)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/9/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-87

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Peter Andruzzi (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/9/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 184: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-127

Peter Corrigan (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jaime Flores (LU 212)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of utilizing Laborers to

perform Dockbuilder work*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/10/17

2017-16

Juan Donado (LU 45)

vs.

Bruce Hill (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by TC on 5/11/17

2017-23

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC- OIG))

vs.

Jesse Lohrer (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 5/11/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2017-34

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gonzalo Ferreras (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/1/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 185: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-100

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Akil Brockington (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 6/15/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine and Letter of Reprimand

2016-34

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gregory Lanza (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges dismissed by TC on 6/15/17

2016-61

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John McGrath (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/15/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-126

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Sean Dixon (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 6/15/17

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 180 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

Page 186: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-109

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Vere Looby (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

company*****

•Settled on 6/15/17

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 180 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2017-25

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Shorn Pink (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of presenting fraudulent

OSHA card on jobsite*****

•Settled on 7/13/17

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $200 fine within 180 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2016-76

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Wesley Williams (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 7/20/17

•Found GUILTY of charge

•Penalty is a $50 fine due in 60 days

2016-31

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Salvador Vicenty (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 7/20/17

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is expulsion

(penalty basis is because this is the member's second time

being charged with the same violation and he failed to

comply with the penalty imposed on the first charge)

Page 187: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-121

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Woodfall (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 7/20/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine due in 60 days

2017-35

Bernard Brady (NYCDCC)

vs.

Ryan McCormack (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Trial date - 7/27/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion but expulsion will be held in abeyance

upon paying a $900 fine within 30 days.

(penalty higher because of association with the union)

2013-116

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

David Scalcione (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Penalty modified - 7/27/17

•Penalty now reflects a $750 fine and Letter of Reprimand

payable within 60 days.

(penalty higher to ensure member's cooperation with the

IGO investigation)

Page 188: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-33

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Robert Drake (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/31/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2017-55

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Timothy McDonagh (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/4/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2017-12

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jose Vasquez (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Settled on 8/17/17

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 30 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2016-123

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Arnold Drange (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 8/17/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $300 fine and a Letter of Reprimand

Page 189: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-5

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael Degeorge (LU 20)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 8/18/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2016-34

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gregory Lanza (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges dismissed by TC on 8/24/17

2016-100

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Akil Brockington (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 8/24/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine and a Letter of Reprimand

2017-41

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

James Gegan (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Errol Gordon (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/1/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 190: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-52

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ray Nicosia (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/8/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2017-52

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

James Gegan (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jorge Bonilla (LU 212)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/12/17

(Member is deceased)

2017-63

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Thomas Lawrence (LU 212)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/14/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2017-44

Brian Conlon (NYCDCC)

vs.

George Munoz (LU 290)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 9/14/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $100 fine within 60 days

Page 191: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-43

Brian Conlon (NYCDCC)

vs.

Justin Dehoyos (LU 290)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 9/14/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $100 fine within 60 days

2017-42

Brian Conlon (NYCDCC)

vs.

Shawn O'Connell (LU 290)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 9/14/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $100 fine within 60 days

2017-51

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Miroslaw Bartnik (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 9/14/17

2017-50

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Robert Anczarski (LU 20)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 9/14/17

Page 192: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-57

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

James Ndjom (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 9/14/17

2017-56

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Rolando Callist (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 9/14/17

2017-60

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Meto Mersimouski (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 9/14/17

2017-61

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Richard Green (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 9/14/17

Page 193: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-41

James Gegan (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Yauheni Fedarovich (LU 20)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/18/17

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2015-368

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Fitzroy Muirhead (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 9/21/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due in 60 days and a Letter of

Reprimand

2017-29

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Gavin Hart (LU 210)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Trial date - 9/21/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion but expulsion will be held in abeyance

upon paying a $4,500 fine within 30 days and receiving a

Letter of Reprimand.

2017-36

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Antonio Barros (LU 212)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 9/21/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine due in 60 days and a Letter of

Reprimand

Page 194: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-15

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Donahue (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for cash for a

signatory contractor.*****

•Settled on 9/28/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 30 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2017-13

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Tomy Vasquez (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for cash for a

signatory contractor.*****

•Settled on 9/28/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 30 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2017-14

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Jordan Caraballo (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for cash for a

signatory contractor.*****

•Settled on 9/28/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 30 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2017-11

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Woodfall (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for cash for a

signatory contractor.*****

•Trial date - 9/28/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

Page 195: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-31

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Edsel Langhorne (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/6/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2017-28

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael Leahy (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/16/17

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2017-26

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Rodrigo Cabrera (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/17/17

(Membership suspended prior to charges being filed)

2017-53

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Ryan McCormack (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a nonunion

contractor*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/18/17

(Member charged for same violation by Organizing Rep.)

Page 196: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-37

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

James Gegan (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Francisco Lapa (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 10/19/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $150 fine and a Letter of Reprimand

2017-24

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Winston Evans (LU 20)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of submitting fraudulent

OSHA card on jobsite*****

•Settled on 10/19/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $200 fine within 6 months.

2017-21

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

James Gegan (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Dejan Galic (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of defrauding nonunion

worker out of money to gain entry into the

union*****

•Settled on 10/19/17

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to pay a $500 fine within 6 months and receive a

Letter of Reprimand.

2017-49

Barry Berman (NYCDCC)

vs.

Dragan Matovic (LU 2287)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working alongside

nonunion workers*****

•Trial date - 10/26/17

•Found NOT GUILTY of all charges

Page 197: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-63

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Thomas James Lawrence III (LU 212)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/26/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2017-8

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kenneth Bradey (LU 253)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/27/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2017-30

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Iberico Goncalves (LU 254)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/2/17

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 198: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-71

Brian McLaughlin (NYCDCC)

vs.

John Juliani (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

*Advocating separation of any subordinate

body from the United Brotherhood

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working on a jobsite

with a non-union worker*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/8/17

2017-46

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Francis Marino (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

contractor*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 11/9/17

2017-45

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Suraj Singh (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

contractor*****

•Charges dismissed by TC on 11/9/17

Page 199: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-39

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

John Moutinho (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 11/16/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $500 fine and a Letter of Reprimand

2017-31

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kenneth Maldonado (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working for a non-union

contractor*****

•Trial date - 11/16/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion but will be held in abeyance if member

pays a $2,000 fine within 90 says and receives a Letter of

Reprimand

2017-59

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Charlemagne (LU 212)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

*****Member accused of working while

registered on the job referral list*****

•Settled on 12/14/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2017-77

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Cesar Carrera (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company and without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 12/14/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

Page 200: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-76

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Alejandro Ruiz (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company and without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 12/14/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2017-75

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Omar Alvarez (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company and without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 12/14/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2017-74

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Rogelio Garcia (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company and without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 12/14/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

Page 201: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-73

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Juan Ruiz (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company and without a Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 12/14/17

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2017-64

Kevin Fleming (NYCDCC)

vs.

Charles Hess (LU 251)

*Violating the obligation

*Improper steward appointment

******Member accused of working without a

Shop Steward and not notifying NYCDCC of job

******

•Trial date - 12/21/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $250 fine due in 90 days and a Letter of

Reprimand

2017-65

Kevin Fleming (NYCDCC)

vs.

Angel Tejada (LU 251)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working without a

Shop Steward and not notifying NYCDCC of job

******

•Trial date - 12/21/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $50 fine due in 90 days and a Letter of

Reprimand

Page 202: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-66

Kevin Fleming (NYCDCC)

vs.

Fernando Rodrigues (LU 251)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working without a

Shop Steward and not notifying NYCDCC of job

******

•Trial date - 12/21/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $250 fine due in 90 days and a Letter of

Reprimand

(penalty high because member is a foreman)

2017-67

Kevin Fleming (NYCDCC)

vs.

Ryan Gardiner (LU 251)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working without a

Shop Steward and not notifying NYCDCC of job

******

•Trial date - 12/21/17

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $25 fine due in 90 days and a Letter of

Reprimand

2017-79

Stephen McCann (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jorge Castrillon (LU 1556)

*Advocating separation from the brotherhood

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working without a

Shop Steward and failing to notify union*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 1/11/18

Page 203: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-78

Stephen McCann (NYCDCC)

vs.

John Proffer (LU 1556)

*Advocating separation from the brotherhood

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working without a

Shop Steward and failing to notify union*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 1/11/18

2017-72

Brian McLaughlin (NYCDCC)

vs.

Joseph Marchese (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

*Advocating separation from the brotherhood

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working without a

Shop Steward and failing to notify union*****

•Settled on 1/11/18

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to complete three (3) additional Union Activities by

12/31/18; failue to complete all Union Activities results in a

$500 fine for each not completed

2017-90

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jose Barajas (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

*Advocating separation from the brotherhood

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working without a

Shop Steward*****

•Settled on 1/11/18

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

Page 204: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-119

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Avdyl Bruncaj (LU 926)

*Violating membership qualifications

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of submitting a

fraudulent letter of intent*****

•Trial date - 1/18/18

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2016-117

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Nello Micle (LU 926)

*Violating membership qualifications

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of submitting a

fraudulent letter of intent*****

•Trial date - 1/18/18

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2016-111

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Mariusz Zielinski (LU 926)

*Violating membership qualifications

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of submitting a

fraudulent letter of intent*****

•Trial date - 1/18/18

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2017-19

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Nickolaus Shuster (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 1/23/18

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

Page 205: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-1

Denis Pupovic (NYCDCC)

vs.

William Kane (LU 2287)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/8/18

2017-82

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Michael Devita (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 2/8/18

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2017-87

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Timothy Kanhai (LU 45)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of agreeing to receive

wages and benefits for less hours than he actually

worked*****

•Settled on 2/8/18

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 180 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2017-66

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC - OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Wojiech Zabazny (LU 926)

*Violating membership qualifications

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of submitting a fraudulent

letter of intent to gain entry to the union*****

•Trial date - 2/15/18

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

Page 206: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-67

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Stefan Sudol (LU 926)

*Violating membership qualifications

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of submitting a fraudulent

letter of intent to gain entry to the union*****

•Trial date - 2/15/18

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2017-92

Barry Berman (NYCDCC)

vs.

Francis Santana (LU 2287)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working alongside non-

union workers and without a shop steward*****

•Trial date - 2/22/18

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $900 fine due in 90 days and a Letter of

Reprimand

2017-81

Michael Piccirillo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Robert Deltufo (LU 251)

*Causing dissension

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Settled on 3/5/18

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $150 fine within 60 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2017-84

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Matthew Jensen (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of owning and operating

a non-union company*****

•Settled on 3/8/18

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $1,000 fine within 90 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

Page 207: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2014-367

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

vs.

Michael Dolphin (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Violating the Consent Decree

*****Member accused of knowingly associating

with members of La Cosa Nostra and engaging in

racketeering activity*****

•Trial date - 3/15/18

•Found GUILTY of "Violating the obligation "

•Penalty is expulsion

•"Violating the Consent Decree " dismissed by Trial Chair

2017-27

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Brigitte Harris (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of creating and utilizing

fraudulent LU 157 sick donation checks*****

•Trial date - 3/22/18

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2017-95

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Timothy Callow (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working on a jobsite

with non-union workerslaborers*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/3/18

Page 208: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-3

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

William Salazar (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Settled on 4/13/18

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $200 fine within 180 days

2017-70

Brian McLaughlin (NYCDCC)

vs.

David Schmidt (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working alongside a

non-union worker and cancelling a dispatch*****

•Trial date - 4/19/18

•Found NOT GUILTY of all charges

2017-88

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC)

vs.

Keith Romany (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Trial date - 4/19/18

•Found GUILTY of charge

•Penalty is a $50 fine due in 30 days.

Page 209: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2017-83

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Patrick Aiello (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of owning and operating

a non-union company*****

•Trial date - 4/26/18

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is expulsion.

2017-93

Dominic Frank (LU 157)

vs.

Jeffrey Stawkowski (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 4/26/18

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is a $900 fine due in 90 days and a Letter of

Reprimand

2018-9

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Sean Thegg (LU 20)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of purchasing and

displaying a fraudulent OSHA card*****

•Settled on 5/10/18

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $1,000 fine within 270 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

Page 210: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-12

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Anthony Imbriale (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of purchasing and

displaying a fraudulent OSHA card*****

•Settled on 5/16/18

•Pled GUILTY to all charges

•Agreed to pay a $1,500 fine within 270 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2018-7

Salvatore Tagliaferro (NYCDCC)

vs.

Maxime Depeault (LU 761)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a company

that is not signatory to NYCDCC*****

•Trial date - 5/17/18

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2018-7

Salvatore Tagliaferro (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jonathan Hache (LU 761)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a company

that is not signatory to NYCDCC*****

•Trial date - 5/17/18

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

Page 211: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-5

Michael Piccirillo (NYCDCC)

vs.

Olanrewaju Ibrahim (LU 20)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of failing to report to job

after being dispatched*****

•Trial date - 5/24/18

•Found GUILTY of charge

•Penalty is expulsion

2017-80

Christian Castillo (LU 1556)

vs.

Niat Astafaj (LU 157)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 5/24/18

•Found GUILTY of all charge

•Penalty is a $600 fine due in 90 days and a Letter of

Reprimand

2018-14

Daniel Dunbar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jeffrey Myhre (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Violating Executive Secretary-Treasurer

management policy

******Member accused of working alongside non-

union Laborers on a non reported job without a

Steward.******

•Settled on 6/14/18

•Pled GUILTY to "Violating the obligation"

•Agreed to pay a $500 fine within 30 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

•"Defrauding the brotherhood", "Failing to protect

memberships' interest" and "Violating Executive Secretary-

Treasurer management policy" withdrawn

Page 212: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-27

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Juan Manuel Gallardo (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 6/14/18

•Pled GUILTY to "Violating the obligation"

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

•"Defrauding the brotherhood" and "Failing to protect

memberships' interest" withdrawn

2018-28

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Ralph Lahoud (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 6/14/18

•Pled GUILTY to "Violating the obligation"

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

•"Defrauding the brotherhood" and "Failing to protect

memberships' interest" withdrawn

2018-29

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Anis Banushaj (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 6/14/18

•Pled GUILTY to "Violating the obligation"

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

•"Defrauding the brotherhood" and "Failing to protect

memberships' interest" withdrawn

Page 213: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-6

Salvatore Tagliaferro (NYCDCC)

vs.

Frances Paquin (LU 761)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a company

that is not signatory to NYCDCC*****

•Trial date - 6/21/18

•Found GUILTY of all charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2017-18

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Stanislaw Kofin (LU 2790)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 6/21/18

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2017-58

James Gegan (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Danny Avalos (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

*Violating membership qualifications

*****Member accused of being a member of two

Labor Unions simultaneously**** *

•Charges withdrawn on 6/26/18

Page 214: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-13

Robert Joule (NYCDCC)

vs.

Andrew Delia (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Trial date - 6/28/18

•Found GUILTY of "Defrauding the brotherhood", "Violating

the obligation" and "Failing to protect memberships'

interest"

•Penalty is expulsion

•Found NOT GUILTY of "Violation of Job Referral System

Rules "

2018-30

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Dylan Pitt (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Settled on 7/12/18

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to pay a $150 fine within 90 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2018-18

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Alfredo Ramirez (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 7/12/18

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

Page 215: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-15

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Francisco Perez (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 7/12/18

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 90 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2018-16

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Mauricio Perez (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 7/12/18

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 90 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2018-17

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Carlos Soto (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a Shop

Steward*****

•Settled on 7/12/18

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $250 fine within 90 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

Page 216: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-22

Denis Pupovic (NYCDCC)

vs.

Nigel Bates (LU 290)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of failing to report to

work*****

•Trial date - 7/19/18

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2018-31

Kevin Fleming (NYCDCC)

vs.

Samuel Ahmad (LU 2287)

*Lumping

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Trial date - 9/20/18

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is expulsion

2014-286

Martin Szabunio (NYCDCC- OIG)

Edward Brandon (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Joseph Lauer Jr. (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of creating a labor union

while holding membership within UBCJA*****

•Trial date - 9/27/18

•Found GUILTY of charge

•Penalty is expulsion and a $50,000 fine

2018-36

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jaime Jones (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Settled - 10/11/18

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

Page 217: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-38

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jan Taveras (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Settled - 10/11/18

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2018-39

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Enoch Laurent (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Settled - 10/11/18

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2018-40

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jose Urena (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Settled - 10/11/18

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2018-37

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Edy Catalan (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Settled - 10/11/18

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to pay a $500 fine within 30 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

Page 218: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-23

Brian Conlon (NYCDCC)

vs.

Shawn Clark (LU 290)

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of failing to report to

work*****

•Trial date - 10/18/18

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a $450 fine due in 60 days, a Letter of Reprimand

and a Letter of Apology to Brian Conlon

2018-41

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

Pedro Batista (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/22/18

2018-42

Thomas King (NYCDCC)

vs.

George Jimenez (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 10/22/18

2018-11

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Peter Fitzsimons (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of operating in capacity of

Supervisor for a non-union company**** *

•Trial date - 10/25/18

•Found GUILTY of charge

•Penalty is expulsion and a $50,000 fine

(per UBC Decision on Appeal, case to be retried with

new trial panel)

Page 219: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-44

Clark Morrissey (LU 2790)

vs.

Jean Cassagnau (LU 45)

*Improper harassment

******Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 11/8/18

2018-26

James Gegan (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Tyler Stratton (LU 1556)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 11/15/18

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2018-4

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - IGO)

vs.

Luigi Rizzo (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union comapny*****

•Settled on 1/10/19

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $200

fine within 90 days

2018-47

Anthony Linton (LU 212)

vs.

Keny Dooker (LU 926)

*Causing dissension

*Defrauding the brotherhood

******Member accused of causing dissension on

jobsite by failing to maintain confidentiality of

another member concerning an issue on site

*****

•Trial date - 1/24/19

•Found NOT GUILTY of all charges

Page 220: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-10

Michael Donnelly (NYCDCC - IGO)

vs.

Michael Devita (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union comapny*****

•Settled on 1/29/19

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $200

fine within 90 days

2018-57

James Gegan (NYCDCC - IGO)

vs.

Tyler Stratton (LU 1556)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of attempting to receive

payment for someone joining Local 1556*****

•Settled on 2/5/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $125

fine within 90 days

2018-61

Peter Corrigan (LU 212)

vs.

Liam Philbin (LU 212)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*Making False Accusations

******Member accused of being a false

witness*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 2/14/19

Page 221: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-62

Peter Corrigan (LU 212)

vs.

Thomas Gorman (LU 212)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

*Making False Accusations

******Member accused of creating a false

allegation*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 2/14/19

2018-58

Thomas Gorman (LU 212)

vs.

Peter Corrigan (LU 212)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges dismissed by Trial Chair on 2/14/19

2018-25

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC - IGO)

vs.

John McEvoy (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working as a

supervisor for a non-union company*****

•Trial date - 2/28/19

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is expulsion and a $25,000 fine

2018-45

Barry Berman (NYCDCC)

vs.

Angel Tejada (LU 279)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Trial date - 2/28/19

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is expulsion but expulsion will be held in abeyance

upon paying a $800 fine within 30 days.

(higher penalty because of prior disciplinary history and

failure to pay fine)

Page 222: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-46

Barry Berman (NYCDCC)

vs.

Roberto Brito (LU 279)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Settled on 2/28/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $250

fine within 90 days

2018-50

Eric Tyznar (NYCDCC)

vs.

James Neville (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Trial date - 3/14/19

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is expulsion.

2018-20

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC - IGO)

vs.

Kenrick Thomas (LU 2287)

*Violating the obligation

*Violation of Job Referral System Rules

******Member accused of working while being

registered on the job referral list*****

•Settled on 3/14/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $150

fine within 30 days

Page 223: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2019-1

John Corrigan (LU 212)

vs.

Thomas Gorman (LU 212)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*Making False Accusations

******Member accused of making a false

allegation*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/28/19

2018-59

Thomas Gorman (LU 212)

vs.

John Corrigan (LU 212)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 3/28/19

2019-5

Robert Anton (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

James Quinn (LU 212)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 4/2/19

(Member appeared for investigative interview with IGO)

2018-49

Eric Tyznar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Johnstan Joseph (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Trial date - 4/25/19

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is expulsion

Page 224: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-63

Kevin Zielinski (LU 2287)

vs.

Tyrone Bullock (LU 2287)

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 5/23/19

•Found NOT GUILTY of charges

2019-3

Tyrone Bullock (LU 2287)

vs.

Kevin Zielinski (LU 2287)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

*****Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 5/23/19

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a $500 fine due in 60 days and a Letter of

Reprimand

2019-10

David Pie' (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Tracy Mooring (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Settled on 6/13/19

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $250

fine within 60 days

Page 225: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2019-11

David Pie' (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Wiliam Greene (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Settled on 6/13/19

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $250

fine within 60 days

2019-12

David Pie' (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Salvatore Lombardo (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Settled on 6/13/19

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $250

fine within 60 days

2019-14

David Pie' (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Glenford Nicholas (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Settled on 6/13/19

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $250

fine within 60 days

Page 226: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2019-15

David Pie' (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Milton Walters (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Settled on 6/13/19

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2019-17

David Pie' (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kieli McKoy (LU 926)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Settled on 6/13/19

•Pled GUILTY to charge

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand and pay a $250

fine within 60 days

2018-51

Eric Tyznar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Carlos Marques (LU 1556)

*Causing dissension

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Trial date - 6/27/19

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a $1,500 fine due in 60 days and a Letter of

Reprimand

(higher penalty because member was a General Foreman and

aware of the jobsite conditions, there were multiple trades on site

and the Council lost money by not having a steward)

Page 227: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2018-52

Eric Tyznar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Michael Hawkins (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Trial date - 6/27/19

•Found GUILTY of "Violating the obligation "

•Penalty is a Letter of Reprimand

•Found NOT GUILTY of "Causing dissension "

2019-2

John Vega (LU 926)

vs.

Kevin Sebade (LU 45)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of harassment*****

•Trial date - 6/27/19

•Found NOT GUILTY of all charges

2019-31

Michael White (NYCDCC)

vs.

Edgar Bonilla (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Settled on 7/11/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2019-32

Michael White (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jaroslaw Cedrowski (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Settled on 7/11/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

Page 228: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2019-33

Michael White (NYCDCC)

vs.

Grzegorz Kubis (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/11/19

2019-34

Michael White (NYCDCC)

vs.

Sebahtin Moustafa (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Charges withdrawn on 7/11/19

2019-35

Michael White (NYCDCC)

vs.

Dariusz Gregorczuk (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Settled on 7/11/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2019-36

Michael White (NYCDCC)

vs.

Dariusz Krupa (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Settled on 7/11/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

Page 229: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2019-37

Michael White (NYCDCC)

vs.

Robert Szalewicz (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working without a

steward*****

•Settled on 7/11/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to receive a Letter of Reprimand

2019-18

David Pie' (NYCDCC - IGO)

vs.

Patrick Spillane (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working as a Forman

for a non-union company*****

•Trial date - 7/24/19

•Found GUILTY of charge

•Penalty is expulsion and a $50,000 fine

(higher penalty based on two years of medical coverage paid out,

working for non-union company, evidence of working as a foreman,

sworn statement filled out and the cost of the investigation and trial)

2016-120

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Grzegorz Suchorzepka (LU 926)

*Violation of qualifications of membership

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of submitting a

fraudulent letter of intent*****

•Settled on 7/26/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $150 fine due in 60 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

Page 230: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2016-68

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Marek Krawel (LU 926)

*Violation of qualifications of membership

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of submitting a

fraudulent letter of intent*****

•Settled on 7/29/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $150 fine due in 60 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2016-112

Scott Danielson (NYCDCC - OIG)

Peter Marsalisi (NYCDCC- OIG)

Ramadan Ibric (NYCDCC - OIG)

Patrick Kennedy (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Krzystof Kumor (LU 926)

*Violation of qualifications of membership

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of submitting a

fraudulent letter of intent*****

•Settled on 7/29/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $150 fine due in 60 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2018-60

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Marlon James (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of letting Laborers

perform Carpenter work on an unreported job and

without a steward*****

•Trial date - 8/29/19

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a Letter of Reprimand

Page 231: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2019-4

Carl Zanchelli (NYCDCC)

vs.

Marlon James (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of letting Laborers

perform Carpenter work******

•Trial date - 8/29/19

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a Letter of Reprimand

2019-41

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Daniel Sullivan (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/3/19

2019-43

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Rohan White (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

*Hindering investigation of allegations of

corruption or misconduct

*Hindering the conduct of investigations

*****Member accused of violating the obligation

by failing to respond to a summons sent by the

Inspector General Office*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/3/19

2019-47

Eric Tyznar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Randy Williams (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working on an

unreported job and without a steward******

•Charges withdrawn on 9/12/19

Page 232: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2019-49

Matthew Angelletta (NYCDCC - IGO)

vs.

Ronald Cornell (LU 157)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of filing fradulent Shop

Steward Reports*****

•Settled on 9/12/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $500 fine due in 90 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2019-48

Eric Tyznar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jamaal Medford (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working on an

unreported job and without a steward******

•Settled on 9/12/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $100 fine due in 60 days and receive a

Letter of Reprimand

2019-51

Eric Tyznar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Paul Borkowski (LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working alongside non-

union workers and without a steward******

•Settled on 9/12/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $75 fine due in 60 days and receive a Letter

of Reprimand

Page 233: NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY … · 2019-10-22 · *Defrauding the brotherhood *Violating the obligation *Failing to protect memberships' interest *****Member

FILE # PARTIES CHARGES RESOLUTION

NYC DISTRICT COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS LOG

2019-52

Eric Tyznar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Antoni Kosciuch (LU 20)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working alongside non-

union workers and without a steward******

•Settled on 9/12/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $75 fine due in 60 days and receive a Letter

of Reprimand

2019-53

Eric Tyznar (NYCDCC)

vs.

Jan Niemczyk(LU 926)

*Defrauding the brotherhood

*Violating the obligation

*Failing to protect memberships' interest

******Member accused of working alongside non-

union workers and without a steward******

•Settled on 9/12/19

•Pled GUILTY to charges

•Agreed to pay a $75 fine due in 60 days and receive a Letter

of Reprimand

2019-7

Paul Edwards (NYCDCC- OIG)

vs.

Kenn Goodwin (LU 157)

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of working for a non-

union company*****

•Trial date - 9/26/19

•Found GUILTY of charges

•Penalty is a $1,000 fine and Letter of Reprimand

(penalty due to prior disciplinary history)

2019-20

Joseph Firth (LU 157)

vs.

Anthony Iuni (LU 157)

*Causing dissension

*Improper harassment

*Violating the obligation

******Member accused of harassment*****

•Charges withdrawn on 9/26/19