oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - matt england.pdf · • mk3l model in...

59
Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus Matthew England and (many) collaborators Climate Change Research Centre (CCRC) and ARC Centre of Excellence for Climate System Science The University of New South Wales www.science.unsw.edu.au/~matthew

Upload: trinhngoc

Post on 09-Aug-2019

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus

Matthew England and (many) collaborators Climate Change Research Centre (CCRC)

and ARC Centre of Excellence for Climate System Science The University of New South Wales

www.science.unsw.edu.au/~matthew

Page 2: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Interdecadal Pacific/Atlantic Ocean variability and the ongoing warming ‘hiatus’

Matthew England and (many) collaborators Climate Change Research Centre (CCRC)

and ARC Centre of Excellence for Climate System Science The University of New South Wales

www.science.unsw.edu.au/~matthew

PACIFIC DRIVER??

ATLANTIC DRIVER??

Page 3: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

A century of global climate change and variability….

Page 4: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

El Nino / La Nina events have a significant impact…..

Page 5: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

El Nino / La Nina events have a significant impact…..

Page 6: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Recent Pacific Ocean trends A century of interdecadal

Pacific variability….

Page 7: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Recent Pacific Ocean trends A century of interdecadal

Pacific variability….

Page 8: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Recent climate trends….

1992-2011 ERA-Interim SLP and wind stress trends

England et al. 2014

Page 9: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Recent climate trends….

1992-2011 AVISO sea surface height trends

England et al. 2014

Page 10: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Recent climate trends….

1992-2011 HadISST sea surface temperature trends

England et al. 2014

Page 11: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Recent surface trends. Sea surface temperature (shading) from NOAA OISST11 and

surface wind velocity (arrows) from ERA interim12. Trends are evaluated with monthly anomalies from January 2001 to October 2013 and scaled to ten-year changes.

2001-2013 trends

Page 12: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Recent climate trends….

1992-2011 GISS surface air temperature trends

England et al. 2014

Page 13: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Australian context?

Page 14: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Recent Pacific Ocean trends….

England et al. 2014

Page 15: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

How anomalous is the trade wind acceleration….?

England et al. 2014

Page 16: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

How anomalous is the trade wind acceleration….?

England et al. 2014

Page 17: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What do the Pacific wind trends do in models….?

OCEAN GCM, SIMPLE ATMOSPHERE

Page 18: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What does this mean for climate projections….?

England et al. 2014

Page 19: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What does this mean for climate projections….?

England et al. 2014

Page 20: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Projections of a rebound in warming out of the current hiatus

Matthew England and (many) collaborators Climate Change Research Centre (CCRC)

and ARC Centre of Excellence for Climate System Science The University of New South Wales

www.science.unsw.edu.au/~matthew

Page 21: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

SAT and SST TRENDS 2013-2030

PACIFIC TEMPERATURE TRENDS 2013-2030

DEPT

H

LONGITUDE

A REVERSAL OF CIRCULATION AND T ANOMALIES SEEN DURING THE HIATUS

Page 22: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What about the role of the Atlantic?

Perspective on Chen and Tung (2014) Science

Page 23: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What about the role of the Atlantic?

Chen and Tung (2014) Science

ATLANTIC OCEAN HEAT CONTENT TRENDS

ATLANTIC

HIATUS 14 YEARS ACCELERATING 14 YEARS

Page 24: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What about the role of the Atlantic?

Estimated change in SST due to a shutdown in the AMOC

Rahmstorf (2002)

Page 25: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What about the role of the Atlantic?

Freshwater forcing

NADW overturning

Page 26: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Freshwater forcing

NADW overturning

Global mean SAT

Page 27: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Freshwater forcing

NADW overturning

Global mean SAT

Page 28: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Anomalies in SST and SSS during an Atlantic hiatus

What about the role of the Atlantic?

Page 29: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

NA SST

NA SSS

What about the role of the Atlantic?

Page 30: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Conclusions

• Recent observed trade wind trend unprecedented

Page 31: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Conclusions

• Recent observed trade wind trend unprecedented

• Beyond the variability seen in CMIP models

Page 32: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Conclusions

• Recent observed trade wind trend unprecedented

• Beyond the variability seen in CMIP models

• Cooling impact can account for the hiatus • Ocean heat uptake • Teleconnections from cool East Pacific SST

Page 33: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Conclusions

• Recent observed trade wind trend unprecedented

• Beyond the variability seen in CMIP models

• Cooling impact can account for the hiatus • Ocean heat uptake • Teleconnections from cool East Pacific SST

• Hiatus could persist for much of the present decade

• Warming out of hiatus likely rapid and likely to be +ve IPO-like

Page 34: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Conclusions

• North Atlantic hiatuses are associated with a cooler SST and fresh SSS in the North Atlantic

Page 35: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Conclusions

• North Atlantic hiatuses are associated with a cooler SST and fresh SSS in the North Atlantic

• Required SSS anomalies are >> observed

Page 36: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Conclusions

• North Atlantic hiatuses are associated with a cooler SST and fresh SSS in the North Atlantic

• Required SSS anomalies are >> observed

• Present warming hiatus has a NA climate that contributes to +ve SAT anomalies

Page 37: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus

Matthew England and (many) collaborators Climate Change Research Centre (CCRC)

and ARC Centre of Excellence for Climate System Science The University of New South Wales

www.science.unsw.edu.au/~matthew

Page 38: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What impact would the observed Pacific wind trends have in models….?

1. In an OGCM/EBM 2. In a coupled climate model

Page 39: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Pacific wind trends added to both an OGCM and a coupled climate model

1. In the UVic ICCM (2° and ¼° OGCMs)

2. In the CSIRO Mk3L coupled model (~1.7° OGCM)

Page 40: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Ocean model experiments

• UVic / MOM model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, EBM atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice • Model solutions integrated for 1000+ yrs • Experimental design:

• Control climatological unperturbed experiment • Trade wind trends applied

Page 41: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Climate model experiments

• Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice • Model solutions integrated for 1000+ yrs • Experimental design:

• Control climatological unperturbed experiment • Trade wind trends applied

Page 42: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Coupled model captures ocean heat uptake and teleconnections

Page 43: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What does this mean for climate projections….?

Page 44: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What about past hiatus periods?

Page 45: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice
Page 46: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice
Page 47: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice
Page 48: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What do the Pacific wind trends do in models….?

OCEAN GCM, SIMPLE ATMOSPHERE

Page 49: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What do the Pacific wind trends do in models….?

OCEAN GCM, SIMPLE ATMOSPHERE

Page 50: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What do the Pacific wind trends do in models….?

OCEAN GCM, SIMPLE ATMOSPHERE

Page 51: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What do the Pacific wind trends do in models….?

SPIN UP

OCEAN GCM, SIMPLE ATMOSPHERE

Half the hiatus

Page 52: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What about the role of the Atlantic?

Page 53: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice
Page 54: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice
Page 55: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice
Page 56: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice
Page 57: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

What’s happened in 2014?

Page 58: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice

Chen and Tung (2014) Science

What about the role of the Atlantic?

Page 59: Oceanic circulation role in the ongoing warming hiatus - Matt England.pdf · • Mk3L model in global configuration • 3D ocean GCM, 3D atmosphere • Dynamic/thermodynamic sea-ice