o'hanlon: cut f-35 program
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
1/28
Foreign Policyat BROOKINGS
Michael OHanlon
Dfs Budgts dAmr Pwr
POLICY PAPER
Number 24, December 2010
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
2/28
Foreign Policyat BROOKINGS
Michael OHanlon
D B A P
POLICY PAPER
Number 24, December 2010
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
3/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
i i
ta B l e o F co n te n ts
I n t r o d u c t i o n
rillion Dollar Deicits and the Decline o Great Powers 4
Understanding the Fiscal Challenge
Saving $60 Billion or 10% in the Annual Deense Program 3
Conclusion 22
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
4/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
1
in t r o d u c t i o n
I 98, US GDP ,
b bby ,
p
U S, C W
Jp Gy -
qy S , , US
Gy p -
b by ( y) Ep
U (EU) E y; Jp -
p
bbb, b p
pp , b
y, p
A ,
T p p
y pC p p-p R y b p b
U S p-
y W I -
? W b
A p y
y y ? M ,
, x U
S y -
b p by pb
py? P py pp y,
x U S, p
b y
pp, p
b p p
?
T pp q by x-
p b q b -
y y p y I
py p A-
b Fy, -
b -
p ,
pp xp p b
k b
b A I -
, by
p , j- p US
by A pp
y b b, x, -
Iq A p
O
k C p-
by U
S 2 T
p , -
p, ,
O , xp, M Mb, Te Frugal Superpower: Americas Global Leadership in a Cash-Strapped Era (N Yk: PbA, 2)
2 O C U S p, xp A B C W J Py, Preventive Deense: A New Security Strategyor America (W, DC: Bk, 999); pp 92-22; C F B, C F, N R Ly, Dk J M,Chinas Rise: Challenges and Opportunities(W, DC: P I I E CSIS, 28), pp 22-229
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
5/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
2
, pby b
p, , pp,
p -p
b p3 B y
A y p p
by y -
p k C, z,
z p y b p N
y US Dp D
p y4 A
, y pp x US
b k b
b y p
b , b py- p-
jpz by y
y y
US by p p-
y p p-
b j-p
N y y ; U S
k ,
y k
x-
p b, y
p p-
H,
b j
A pbby y
y - , y by
p
ky
y C J C S
A M, Sy D G,
Sy S C US
b y
y y 5 M
b b y A p-
, , A pb ky y
p py,
by pbby
b b y b p7
T pp b p
US b ,
ppp , b
p b z P-
ppp S ,
y p-
k b
My
P p p
, y -
by D 9, -
p ypy 8 9 p
p (GDP); 97,
b 8 p j -
5 p GDP; R bp
98, p GDP b
C W I
99, y 5 p p
3 p D P
G W B, ( )
4 p by 25 y
27; x 45 p b
5 p by 29/2 S ,
( pp b)
y 8
3 J D Sb, Principles o Global Security(W, DC: Bk, 2)4 S xp, J ,Airsea Battle: A Point-o-Departure Operational Concept(W, DC: C S By
A, 2); A F Kp, 7 Deadly Scenarios(N Yk: B Bk, 29), 9-29; R C, Mk B, M SC, Dk E, K L Pp, Entering the Dragons Lair(S M, C: RAND, 27); S E J DL, , Coping with the Dragon (W, DC: N D Uy, 27)
5 A Mk M: N Db I O B Sy T, Hungton Post,J 24, 2, b [ Nb 8, 2]
R H C F R p; xp R N H, War o Necessity, War o Choice(N Yk:S S, 29)
7 Of M B, Historical ables: Budget o the U.S. Government, Fiscal Year 2011 (W, DC: G POf, 2), p 4
8 Of M B, Historical ables: Budget o the U.S. Government, Fiscal Year 2011 (W, DC: G POf, 2), p 4
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/06/24/adm-mike-mullen-national_n_624096.htmlhttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/06/24/adm-mike-mullen-national_n_624096.htmlhttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/06/24/adm-mike-mullen-national_n_624096.htmlhttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/06/24/adm-mike-mullen-national_n_624096.html -
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
6/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
3
By , z P b
b y p ( b p, 45 p
28, I
I S S)9 Ay, y
29 2 y p
(pp 7 b y) x
C W -j p 45 b by 5 p (xp 29 -
, p) I,
p x C W -
y I ,
y p z
A p, , -
y p (y b,
38 b, 55 b py 29)
T b y ,
, y pbby
T US b , y
y pb y ,
b
A Y
,
y p
C W A ,
, b -y py
W k p Oy by y x
p
b x ( f) T ky y
y , p-
z p -
, p xy
B , k k
A b y y
y 2 y
9 I I S S, Te Military Balance 2010(Ox, E: R, 2), p 48 Of M B, Historical ables, pp 2, 83
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
7/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
4
tr i l l i o n do l l a r de F i c i t s a n d t h e
de c l i n e o F great Po w e rs
T y,
y b ky y
p b ,
y z y -
y b , -
S z P
, y , , y, b
, Cz H-
, pp b
, y b
b kp p
Uy, by
, by b y ,
py p
k p q
ppy
A Ep y py,
p
pp T Sp A Hbb
/p, P K-
y, p y y
b k W y b k
y 7 y, y
p Sbq-
y, N p
p p k
by p -
bb -
y z y -
y p k F,
B, R2 B p
9 y y y z pp
(7 p 3) p-
y p p -
b y
pp y
2 y I -
p, xp, 3
p 87 4 p 93 ( Gy
y 3 p, U
S 23 3 p)4
I p-W W II , S -
, pp, y y
U S C W -
b N,
b , x-
y p T pb j
US Jp Gy
T
A y b ,
Ty, History o the Peloponnesian War(N Yk: P Bk, 98); S z, Te Art o War(L: Ox Uy P,93); A F Kp, F Cy Cp: T P My R, Te National Interest(F 994); SpB,Military Power(P, NJ: P Uy P, 24); M C, echnolog y and War(N Yk: F P, 99); Mx B, War Made New: echnolog y, Warare, and the Course o History, 1500 to oday(N Yk: G Bk, 2)
2 P Ky, Te Rise and Fall o the Great Powers (N Yk: R H, 987), pp x-x, 993 Ky, Te Rise and Fall o the Great Powers, p 994 A L Fb, Te Weary itan: Britain and the Experience o Relative Decline, 1895-1905(P, NJ: P Uy P, 988),
pp 2, 33
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
8/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
5
, by b
y p C W b
y A P
Rb Gp :5
T S-
W W 98
kb yF p
95, p
9 y y 97 D-
ppxy y-y p,
p p I-
p
, y , -
p
p[,] -
y- Px B, A-
y b I
b
b x Ky p
V W
9A b -
p p, U S
p
A p Gp bk,
ky q j A
p A
p -
b p
pp ,
Gp y , :
T k U S
b
p p
p
I b p -
b, -
by
b b
Cy, S U , p
US y 99,
Jp bbb b,
Gy -
B by 2 y,
p-
y p pp k -
y 99
, , j -
I 2 y,
A k b
p, py C, p
S H y
j p ,
98, k qy -
U S -
y y b b
b p p k -
y I
, b pyk pb k
US y, y x pb
y 7 T q , -
y? D pb
bk b p b
- -
- y p?8
5 Rb Gp, Te Political Economy o International Relations(P, NJ: P Uy P, 987), pp 34-347 Rb Gp, War and Change in World Politics(L: Cb Uy P, 98), p 247 S P H, T USD R? Foreign Aairs(W 988/89), pp 7-98 F p bj A py p pb , E S E, Understanding Americas
Contested Primacy(W, DC: C S By A, 2); W C W, T Sby UpW, International Security, 24, (S 999), pp 5-4; M M, Sy Mk P k: US P I P Ey, World Politics, , (Jy 29), pp 2-54; By P, C C: MyF US Hy, International Security, 28, (S 23), pp 5-4; Cp Ly, T Up I R:T C E U S Up M, International Security, 3, 2 (F 2), pp 47-72; A L Fb, TS Ip R E D, Political Science Quarterly, 4, 3 (F 989), pp 4-43
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
9/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
6
T U S y p
I p p,
2 p b GDP
p p py 25 p
x- 9
T p 5 p
U S W W II
US p p- y b y p-
b (py) k by I
, y US y
p y Ep
Jp, y -
p k S K
T, US GDP
p b by
b A y
k T
W p ,
p, y
pb y k
US 2
A b y,
ky U-
S y b T
W P C -
y, , b p -
Nx b
y p M, U S
y y y ,
S W y ,
b b b
yp p Ep p
p2 E j -
W p
pb y , V,
p , y
U S
y A , j y -
z A- -
(T S Cp C -
R C y
k , b y y
y p pp)
T kb -
y qy
A y, U S b
y p -
y 8 p b GDP
8 p b y
p b 22 T y
NAO , y b
E A W P, R P
L A , (
y b q y, A y
pp , I, G Cp-
C, Iq A Aby,
Pk I b p
y ; , y
A j , y
C R y -
b q k
A A p
I, N K, pp Vz-
, Sy B
y 2 p
b p y p T
k
U S xy
9 W Bk, World Development Report 2010(W, DC: 29), p 38, b [ Ob , 2]
2 G J Ikby,Ater Victory: Institutions , Strategic Restraint, and the Rebuilding o Order ater Major Wars(P, NJ: P UyP, 2)
2 Sp M W, Te Origins o Alliances(I, NY: C Uy P, 99) W y b Ap p aming American Power(N Yk: WW N C, 2) B p b W py S xp pp -2 bk
22 M E OH, Budgeting or Hard Power: Deense and Security Spending Under Barack Obama (W, DC: Bk, 29), p 24;I I S S, Te Military Balance 2010(Ox, E: R, 2), pp 42-48; W Bk,World Development Report 2010(W, DC: 29), pp 378-38
http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTWDR2010/Resources/5287678-1226014527953/Statistical-Annex.pdfhttp://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTWDR2010/Resources/5287678-1226014527953/Statistical-Annex.pdfhttp://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTWDR2010/Resources/5287678-1226014527953/Statistical-Annex.pdfhttp://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTWDR2010/Resources/5287678-1226014527953/Statistical-Annex.pdf -
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
10/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
7
T A A
Jp Ny , y p,
py, -
b y y23 E
p , A
b y W-b -
k C, R, I
b p pp- b - py
p
PRC ,24 -
pp, pp
pp z25 M,
b, I y ky b
A D y b -
p b, b -
pb
U S, y y
I pp b
2 W -p p,
by C, y -
pp U S
T b
, y 58
p
A 27 W US -
p b
, - US k p
( I ) -
p b T
xp k U S
,
b B b p
y j p
A U Sb
pb y, p p-
, p pp, -
, , ,
I b p,
y b py T U S
k, -
p T
b ,
k , -
, k y
b
p GDP by by
py xp y
94 - by -
p p
I , US
b p GDP, b ,
8
p 2 p b -
28 My - -
p pp p ,
W b29 Aby,
j p b b
b F xp, C p
- pp,
, DVD py, , k
y 3 C
23 Jp S Ny, J, T F A P, Foreign Aairs, 89, (Nb/Db 2), pp 2-224 F W, C Pp Dy: T L C, W, DC, Bk, Spb 2, b [ Nb 8, 2]25 N I C, Global rends 2025: A ransormed World(W, DC: 28), pp 24-272 O I y py, Sp P C S Dp,Arming Without Aiming: Indias Military Modernization
(W, DC: Bk, 2), pp -28 I p I y k C - j p B b b p (y - GDP), I p --
p py xp pp p j , SH I G W Op C, I Sp E M, A Bp b F R, Te Economist, Ob 2-8,2, pp , 75-77
27 L Tp, R I D: A R D B, Lx I, A, V, A 29, p 528 I My F, World Economic Outlook(Ob 2), p 24, b [ Ob , 2]; W B R, J Rb Ky, P G P, Rb Bxby, R App H O US E C, M E OH, , Opportunity 08: Independent Ideas or Americas Next President, (W, DC: Bk, 28), pp 22-23
29 A A, Te Emerging Markets Century: How a New Breed o World-Class Companies Is Overtaking the World(N Yk: F P,27), pp 9-5
3 F Zk, Te Post-American World(N Yk: W W N C, 28), p 9
http://www.brookings.edu/articles/2010/09_china_population_wang.aspxhttp://www.brookings.edu/articles/2010/09_china_population_wang.aspxhttp://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/weo/2010/02/pdf/tables.pdfhttp://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/weo/2010/02/pdf/tables.pdfhttp://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/weo/2010/02/pdf/tables.pdfhttp://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/weo/2010/02/pdf/tables.pdfhttp://www.brookings.edu/articles/2010/09_china_population_wang.aspxhttp://www.brookings.edu/articles/2010/09_china_population_wang.aspx -
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
11/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
8
S K Jp b p-
b; U S by p b-
p b3 T
-
, ,
A p py32
T U S pb Dp b b
- y
y,
y k p, -
p p GDP 22
p 979 j 5 p
33 Upy ,
p, b b
y pp k k
H py y bb y
y, p y
b , b-
jb y
W y pp, y - -
k p y
F , A
b
, py
b xp p
( p p, b
y y A pp y
) Up by
b y f 34 T
Ob b y py
, b y
ky -
b y b- z
- E bp,
- -p ,
y, py -
97 b
2835
S y
y pb
by b k ypy 2
4 pp y,
3 p-
y W E
F3 A x-
, ,
y
b
Oy p A -
y ,
25 33 p
38 p K37
A k
p U S y
-p j p bb
py C p
pp 2 b py
x b 8 b
b p38 T
pp
p y
q y E pb
- ,
3 Spb A Jp, Spb S, ky, Jp, M, 2, b [ Nb 2, 2]
32 I B, Te End o the Free Market(N Yk: P, 2), pp 8-2433 Ex Of P, Economic Report o the President 2010(W, DC: 2), b B-2, b [ Ob 8, 2]34 H B P, Ay L, Rb S, Py M C: E G Up Mby A A, M
E OH, , Opportunity 08: Independent Ideas or Americas Next President, (W, DC: Bk, 28), pp 22-229
35 R Hk Ib V S, Ak Py Iqy: R F G Oppy, M E OH,, Opportunity 08: Independent Ideas or Americas Next President, (W, DC: Bk, 28), p 23
3 Jy J Kz, C M M, B F M, S, y, E, M (SEM) EI L Op, W, DC, C R S, My 22, 2, p ; W E F, Te GlobalCompetitiveness Report 2009-2010(G, Sz: 29), p 7
37 D M W, Brain Gain: Rethinking U.S. Immigration Policy(W, DC: Bk, 2), p 338 S P R Oz, D, C B Of, I I, y b US S C
F, Jy , 28, p 8
http://www.sajn.or.jp/c/statistics/Shipbuilding_Statistics_Mar2010.pdfhttp://www.sajn.or.jp/c/statistics/Shipbuilding_Statistics_Mar2010.pdfhttp://www.gpoaccess.gov/eop/tables10.htmlhttp://www.gpoaccess.gov/eop/tables10.htmlhttp://www.gpoaccess.gov/eop/tables10.htmlhttp://www.gpoaccess.gov/eop/tables10.htmlhttp://www.sajn.or.jp/c/statistics/Shipbuilding_Statistics_Mar2010.pdfhttp://www.sajn.or.jp/c/statistics/Shipbuilding_Statistics_Mar2010.pdf -
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
12/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
9
ppy p
b b pbby b
S b y ;
xp, My 33 b
p b
py y
b ( y z
b)39 C, , p O ,
A y p b
y, p
by
p4
39 Cp W H M A P, R B A C, N L C, W, DC, Ob 2,b [ Ob 7, 2]; My S , Washington Post, Ob 3, 2, p A8
4 J S Df, Over a Barrel: Te Costs o U.S. Foreign Oil Dependence(S, C: S Uy P, 28), pp -2
http://www.nlc.org/http://www.nlc.org/ -
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
13/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
10
understanding t h e F i s c a l ch alle n g e
I y, b
y p D b
b -
y, x-
W b ,
y T -
p j 2 p 35 y
,
b D b -
, b by pb b
b b
4 p GDP b
p I xp 7 p by
x
y
, y p
b4
M, b py b
by A; by 42
B by A,
y p A
ppy, k qy, T y-
kp p U S,
y by
p EU
, H, y p
A p
y I p -
p U S b
-
by, y k y
93 by py W E F43
C pj p-
, Ty b y
b p pp I x
k B y -
y kp p b -
pp,
5 b by -
by b C-
b pb x p GDP y 22,
kp xb
pb 44
S b b Ty
, b q
q ,
p ky
-A Ty k x-
4 S xp, C B Of, Te Budget and Economic Outlook: An Update(W, DC: A 2), p 442 D M Wk, Comeback America: urning the Country Around and Restoring Fiscal Responsibility(N Yk: R H, 29), p 2243 D M Sk, Te World Is Curved: Hidden Dangers to the Global Economy(N Yk: P, 29), pp 2-; K Sb, , T
Gb Cp Rp 29-2, W E F, G, Sz, 29, p 22; Zk, Te Post-American World,pp 9-2
44 W A G My MG, T F I N: A B P Sbz Pb Db P E G,W, DC, Bk I, Spb 2, p
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
14/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
11
y b
ypb , j ,
A
US y H
k b y b
py (CBO
pj py 2 b- 2 y 8 b 22,
y b p b
b)45
S
k p -
p ,
p? T p
q
T by
, A b p GDP
b b
x
4 T,
b b kp
b p GDP A b-
pp pb py y
p GDP b
xp GDP pb
I , z b
GDP b Spy,
b pb - GDP
- GDP
y, b z
y y 47
kp p,
27 b y p-
by p
j b p
b Iq A, y
US GDP y p
b 2 A B- x
bk z y p,
y p 58 b
( y 725 b y p
k x) A x
B x py 3
b , p b
y py- k 9 b
y W b B
x x, pj
b 8 b, 4 p GDP,
I k p b-
q (T b y -
xp 5
b y, b y
P
b z -j
pp-
T qy pb
p b b b y
)48
kp b y
, 8 b
b T
4 b y p , x
y, x W
y y,
y by py
by p T, y kp
(
P k y, -
k b py
pb
y p) B -
p b 5 p p, y
y b xp b b-
(A p, b
k,
45 C B Of, Te Budget and Economic Outlook, pp , 2-224 G MG, T F I N, p 447 P Oz, O N, D, Te New York imes, Spb , 2, b [ Ob 7, 2]
Oz y 3 p GDP b , y b py48 C B Of, Te Budget and Economic Outlook, p 4
http://www.nytimes.com/http://www.nytimes.com/ -
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
15/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
12
p y b-
pp 2 p y b
, b
b )
T b b
I p -
, b p b y , x py, I
p p b
k -
y p,
y b pp b
b I j
N, b b;
by -
D-R k , y
xp (I pp
p - - p
b ky
p Ty pp z -
- p y, -
b by b
p )49 N-
, b b; ,
b b b p
I , k
p b xy pp-
y b-
by, p b p
O p , Sy G y
b p
p P Ob -
P y b k
b
T ,
, , A-
y b p
py p pb
b ,
p b
A , b -
b
b , b
yy p CBO b T b
y k b p p -
py M
p, , ,
qp , qp z-
, k p
T -
pj p k
b y y
by Sy G; p
I , CBO
b q
x b b 2 p
- (
q) My b
27 b
b ky b py
not p y b-
j 5
T, , pp
y, b
b, I
27 y y y,
y
y kp
By p, x y , -
j b p b b
b xp 2 ,
y -
xp b, x
54 b b p
49 S S P D D A R, -, R A F, Bp Py C, W, DC, Nb2, pp 9-7, b [ Nb 7, 2]
5 C B Of, Long-erm Implications o the Fiscal Year 2010 Deense Budget (W, DC, Jy 2), pp -33, b [ Spb 2, 2]
http://www.bipartisanpolicy.org/sites/default/files/FINAL%20Report%202011.16.10.pdfhttp://www.cbo.gov/http://www.cbo.gov/http://www.bipartisanpolicy.org/sites/default/files/FINAL%20Report%202011.16.10.pdf -
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
16/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
13
saving $60 B i l l i o n o r 10% in t h e
an n ual de Fe n se Pro g ram
My b-
b b p -
b pp US p
, qky p
T p, b y pp
b by k py
y b U S k k py P y, I
b pb k b -
py -y
p pyk Sy G
jb y
p, b k -
k y
, y b
p y b
- b (-
p k Ay b y y
)5 W b b qp
py A DD y
- p
p, p b-
y, bp
T pp p
b p k
p , bqy, p
p:
) OUGHER MANAGEMEN
2) SMALLER GROUND FORCES (ONCE
CURREN WARS ARE OVER)
3) MORE SELECIVE
MODERNIZAION EFFORS
I , pp b b b y y T
b 2 b y,
k , , b
y by G, pp-
b S
pp ; y
p y, py -
22 p
p A R,
py b
tougher management
S b by -
pp Sy G
py, py Ob -
I y 29, p
Ay F Cb Sy, -
p F-22 , y -
p bb, -
y -b q p
j R&D , DDG-
5 S M J S, D, Aq S M, D Aq: Ob Wp PP Aq R, GAO--7, G Aby Of, W, DC, My 9, 2, p 4
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
17/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
14
y I 2, pp J F
C, b f
y, b k by
p y y
T b C -
by p k
p pp b y, p F xp, -
b 99 pz-
pp , y
3 p pp
p B y
pz y , b 3 p-
,
p
A , y p
I
p; ,
P
b y p xpy
p Spy, k
:52
A S-
y G J F C
pb -
, b
z y
p E y -
E
j pp b
S ,
Ep C, p
b y b p
p A k b
b 2
b y,
-
y
I y p -
y G py b
, b
yp p CBO p
b 5 b53
C y x -
DD T k -
b pp y ,
, y
b U S,
b y y B
y b -
, -
b fy CBO p
b y b
y b y 54
I y
p T RICARE y p
xy y
W b b -
, by , y
x y p -
y, b z x
( ) N
b b
; , , -
y py
yp y y
R
y y b
y
b y55
52 F yp , Sp J Hy W J Py, C-C, T QDR Pp: M A NSy N 2 Cy, W, DC, Q D R Ip P, 2, pp 7-79, b [ Ob 2, 2]
53 O , C B Of, Budget Options(W, DC, 29), pp 24-25, b [ Ob 2, 2]
54 C B Of, Budget Options, pp 28-2955 C B Of, Te Eects o Proposals to Increase Cost-Sharing in RICARE(W, DC: 29), p 4
http://www.usip.org/files/qdr/qdrreport.pdfhttp://www.usip.org/files/qdr/qdrreport.pdfhttp://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/102xx/doc10294/08-06-BudgetOptions.pdfhttp://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/102xx/doc10294/08-06-BudgetOptions.pdfhttp://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/102xx/doc10294/08-06-BudgetOptions.pdfhttp://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/102xx/doc10294/08-06-BudgetOptions.pdfhttp://www.usip.org/files/qdr/qdrreport.pdfhttp://www.usip.org/files/qdr/qdrreport.pdf -
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
18/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
15
E b by -
, T y y -
by 2 y
P b (k py-
4K p )
p py
p R RICARE L yby C
99 y
,
p , p-
y y b-
y by b
A k, z -
k , k -
y y k T k
y kby
p q
p y b y
p -
y pp E
k k T
by p pp b -
b
smaller ground Forces
O Iq A y
, y b pb
US Ay M Cp
C y B 5 T
y 5 p , -
b T -
b bp
, Ap, Py, C,
R pp -y p57
p , -
y US Ay b 55, -y -
, p , b
py ( , y 8,
N G j 3,
Ay R) T US M Cp b
2, , 5, M -
py 58 By , Ay 2 472, M
Cp b 7,59 Ex -
, , k 5 p p
ppxy
I , y
45 b b
Ay 28 N G T
Ay 3 b b
8 p T
M, z y -
y b
, y
4 y A , 5
p , pp-
y, Ay b
b 38 b N
G b 24, b -
7 b N
G , py T M
p pp 2 , y 3
y py
F k , b US y
py Iq A ypy -
b 2 b b --
b 22 Iq
y C py
b p
56 For a similar argument see Sustainable Deense Task Force, Debt, Defcits, and Deense: A Way Forward, available at [accessed September 15, 2010], p. vii.
57 S xp, Fk W K, Finding the arget: Te ransormation o American Military Policy(N Yk: E Bk, 2), pp8-97, 222-23, 28-28
58 I I S S, Te Military Balance 2010(Ox, E: R, 2), pp 32-3859 I I S S, Te Military Balance 2000(Ox, E: Ox Uy P, 2), pp 2-3 Sy D Rb G, Quadrennial Deense Review Report(W, DC: Dp D, Fby 2), p 4 L by P Oz, D, C B Of, S K C, C, S C B, W,
DC, Fby , 28, p 4, b [ Ob 2, 2]
http://www.comw.org/pda/fulltext/1006SDTFreport.pdfhttp://www.comw.org/pda/fulltext/1006SDTFreport.pdfhttp://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/89xx/doc8971/02-11-WarCosts_Letter.pdfhttp://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/89xx/doc8971/02-11-WarCosts_Letter.pdfhttp://www.comw.org/pda/fulltext/1006SDTFreport.pdfhttp://www.comw.org/pda/fulltext/1006SDTFreport.pdf -
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
19/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
16
T p b Ay
M Cp y py
y
b b py F
, :2, p
k :5 A 38 Ay b b
, 24 N G b b ,
M y b b py b
b ( M y
q Ay b) 4 N-
G b, 2 T
b p k
99 p
Iq y 23;
pk 5 2 b
y 2 B
b py 22 b
py 27/28 j Iq A,
y K K
b-z p
S b
k j
xp pb p-
k 5 p py
( xp, y y
- py b )3
N y y f py I,
pb , p Pk,
N K (y,
y )
Y
Ty b q
p Iq A-
( x z) Ty
b zb pbby q
N K k
S K F z
by -
A 4
E k p bz -p , US
p f p T , y
f p y
py , b
b
p
M, b
k x US p
I ,
,
j y y -
, b k x
-/- p, - p
, by 5
F 5 p py y
p p -
b 2 b y, p I
p
y y
B y b b -
b y
py ; ,
y -
b b T
p k Gy J-
p, b by ky
U S, p b
2 S xp, Sy D L Ap, Report on the Bottom-Up Review(W, DC: Dp D, 993), pp 2-2;T Dy, Operation Iraqi Freedom: A Strategic Assessment(W, DC: A Ep I, 24), pp 32-5; AyH C, Te Iraq War: Strategy, actics, and Military Lessons(W, DC: CSIS, 2), pp 37-4; M R G GB E , Cobra II: Te Inside Story o the Invasion and Occupation o Iraq(N Yk: P Bk, 2), pp 38-54; DOb, Te wo Koreas: A Contemporary History(R, M: A-Wy, 997), p 35;
3 O Iq , xp, Kby K, Te Surge: A Military History(N Yk: E Bk, 29), pp xx-xxx4 K M Pk, D L By, M Iyk, Sz My, M E OH, B R, Which Path to Persia: Options
or a New American Strategy toward Iran (W, DC: Bk, 29), pp 94-985 R S,Moving U.S. Forces: Options or Strategic Mobility(W, DC: C B Of, 997); M E
OH, Deense Strategy or the Post-Saddam Era (W, DC: Bk, 25), pp -2
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
20/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
17
y , Jp
p, y y b lessxp kp
b ky y py
b , b p,
E ,
b py pp -b T b y -
y z b
A ,
p, ,
, p pb
y ppy
j b E y p
k ppy b
,
xp qp
y S -
b y
y pp b y
, b k
k b -
f7 A , -
b by 5 p
y
more selective modernizationwithattentiontothe industrial Base
A y pp
z p US y q-
qp T pp -
b y p
, 99, p-
b by -
R- B
T U S k
p y y
b qp R
bp,
b qp
b y
T bk y y
y, S p x,
, 98 b
y b I , y y
p 99 U S
bk xb fy
8 py p A
99 p, US
y , jb
T y I ,
q b zb by
- ,
py b ypy
j p b-
T y by
y q b
p ppp
b pp p y
b y p p-
y
T b k p
,, 99
j , , xpy
y US b
jb p9 I -
, j j
bB, Ry, Np
G, Lk M, G Dy-
b pb
yp p y j
A , b
b kp , b
y
M OH, Unnished Business: U.S. Overseas Military Presence in the 21st Century(W, DC: C N ASy, 28), p 37
7 S R W T, Eects o Weapons Procurement Stretch-Outs on Costs and Schedules(W, DC: C B Of, 987),pp 7-8; M E OH, Te Science o War(P, NJ: P Uy P, 2), pp 8-3
8 R W T, Te Economic Eects o Reduced Deense Spending(W, DC: C B Of, 992), pp 5-429 B by Rb H , S V P, Lk M, T B Ap D, W, DC, Spb 2, p 8
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
21/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
18
b b b -
7 C pb py b ,
k y 7 T by kp
k p b 72
I y b kp y
b
p, b b N , P
p b x b-
y I , p,
(RD&E) b 8 b-
, p b q b
by 73 B-k p -
8 b p,
p, 55 b
b p 22 by
S y y 74
A b pby
p y p bk
b kp , F, p
b , y
y y b b C W y
p T k
P py p
2 y W
, b p p-
, py b p-
, p y b j
b S-k
R, b --
- -- , q -
b, p ,
pp
7 By D W, Te U.S. Deense Industrial Base: Past, Present and Future(W, DC: C S By A,28), pp 32, 8-9
7 Ap I A, T U C: I B Cq D Sy C, A, V, Jy 29, p 72 Hy Py, T QDR Pp, pp 84-973 O y, xp 2 , q b b 5 b y, RD&E
b b 5 b W, Te U.S. Deense Industrial Base, pp 2-2874 S Dp D, S Aq Rp Sy b, Db 3, 29, b [ Spb 3, 2], pp 2-2375 S G L D, A Cp G U S, Mxz DD P F N F C
S Iy Pp, W, DC, G Aby Of, Jy , 2, b 7 M E OH, Te Science o War(P, NJ: P Uy P, 29), pp 8-3; Ay B, Paying or Military
Readiness and Upkeep: rends in Operation and Maintenance Spending(W, DC: C B Of, 997), pp 5-577 Sp J Hy W J Py, C-C, T QDR Pp: M A N Sy N 2
Cy, W, DC, Q D R Ip P, 2, p 53, b [ Ob 2, 2]
-S U S
, p, by, -
DD py
S, y b p p
xp
b 75
xp -- p y p
y p
T, p y
p p p,
y p
b p
F, b
py py , -
py
bysomethingb, , b
qp A , p
y b
7 A y A F
2 y , Ny
M Cp 5,
p yp p -
yp y
b 77
S q pb y -
y y by C W y y -
, b by - A
p b E b
, p- -
b y (
http://www.acq.osd.mil/ara/2009%20DEC%20SAR.pdfhttp://www.acq.osd.mil/ara/2009%20DEC%20SAR.pdfhttp://www.gao.gov/http://www.usip.org/files/qdr/qdrreport.pdfhttp://www.usip.org/files/qdr/qdrreport.pdfhttp://www.gao.gov/http://www.acq.osd.mil/ara/2009%20DEC%20SAR.pdfhttp://www.acq.osd.mil/ara/2009%20DEC%20SAR.pdf -
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
22/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
19
pp p ), -
py ( xp), p z
b y y
p B , xp,
A F Ny M Cp p
by 2,5 F-35 b j p
25 b
I y pb p k b -
z A b y
y z US
Ny, xp, C b
b
I p j b
P G Ay xp
b p A
by xp pb
Ty y xp b -
y - k
p (k bb, y by
G b) C b-
p and
k p
b p78 B -
p y -
, ,
, b p
xp p xp
py k
ppy
F , I
pp x p z-
p y -
:
Wp k x -
p
b py T -
by b -
b p b b bkC p y,
b, -
pp 79
Wp pp b
p S, b -
b A b
y T ,
y p
z
py
y, b 8
Wp p pyy
y b 8
Wp p -
, b y ,
py N
p z pp M
Cp pb pb x-
p O b ;
p b yp
ppy b
p
y p 82
78 S xp T G Mk, S B D, Proceedings(J 2), pp 3-4, b [Spb 5, 2]; Sp J Hy W J Py, -, T QDR Pp: M A N Sy N 2 Cy, W, DC, 2, b [ Ob , 2]; J V ,
AirSea Battle: A Point-o-Departure Operational Concept(W, DC: C S By A, 2)79 S PW S, Wired or War: Te Robotics Revolution and Confict in the 21stCentury(N Yk: P P, 29); M E
OH, echnological Change and the Future o Warare(W, DC: Bk, 2), p 58 F xp , My C M, Slide Rules and Submarines: American Scientists and Subsurace Warare in
World War II(H, H: Uy P P, 22); p yb, xp Sp P R, Winning the Next War(C Uy P, 99)
8 T N-MCy A 982 D Az A p p xby 5 p S Dp D, S Aq Rp (SAR) Sy b, W, DC, Ap 2,2, p 3, b [ Nb 2, 2]
82 F p , y y y , (k -p p y p ), T P M B, Te Pentagons New Map: War and Peace in the wenty-FirstCentury(N Yk: GP P, 24) I B -p ky b b k x pp by
http://www.usni.org/http://www.usip.org/files/qdr/qdrreport.pdfhttp://www.acq.osd.mil/ara/2009%20DEC%20SAR.pdfhttp://www.acq.osd.mil/ara/2009%20DEC%20SAR.pdfhttp://www.usip.org/files/qdr/qdrreport.pdfhttp://www.usni.org/ -
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
23/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
20
I , p y
b :83
C M Pp F
(F) Sp, p M
p b p,
-
( b - p ) b 2 b
P p
j k F-35 T yp
F-35, -k -
pby, b , b U
S F-22
p pb-
x Dp p-
p k, by F-35
p b p F- F-8, b
4 b
S bk -pp
p, p
-b y C
Ak, A -b ,
HAAD -b ,
-b - y
pp E-
p (P MEADS) A
, p p
, b 4 b
SLBM -pp -
p -
Dp Ey
p p px,
b b-b b
b T b
xy b
k b p z; -
, by pby
D5
pb p
b p A (b DD p, DD p,
DE ) b 25 b
Rp M Cp V-22 -
Opy p x--
p b
b
C M Cp Exp-
y F V, p
y pb ,
b 75
H -
p L Cb Sp,
pp b
b b y
k -
, y
p p C G
p S ( -
p k
),
b 2 b
A -
p
9, pp-
5 b84 T b y by
pz
83 O , C B Of, Budget Options(W, DC, 29), pp 5-2, b [ Ob 2, 2]; Dp D, S Aq Rp (SAR)Sy b, Db 3, 29, pp 2-23, b [ Ob 2, 2]; M E OH,A Skeptics Case or Nuclear Disarmament(W, DC: Bk, 2), pp -3
84 M E OH, Te Science o War(P, NJ: P Uy P, 29), p 2
http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/102xx/doc10294/08-06-BudgetOptions.pdfhttp://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/102xx/doc10294/08-06-BudgetOptions.pdfhttp://www.acq.osd.mil/ara/2009%20DEC%20SAR.pdfhttp://www.acq.osd.mil/ara/2009%20DEC%20SAR.pdfhttp://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/102xx/doc10294/08-06-BudgetOptions.pdfhttp://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/102xx/doc10294/08-06-BudgetOptions.pdf -
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
24/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
21
p A M-
, A
p -p P I-
O 85
T b x I
b by
b 5 b by - pp b
85 O , p , xp, Rb D Kp,Monsoon (N Yk: R H,2); R C B, Te Perils o Proximity(W, DC: Bk, 2), A S Ek, W C L III, JD Mky, D G U S E I O Sy,Asian Security, , 3 (Spb-Db 2), pp24-237
p O b
p, k pp, p -
b My
pp , , p
p z
k ppy by
b k
b q 2 b
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
25/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
22
co n clus io n
O p
k j T
U S y
p-W W II
y py -
, M
; GDP p
p y-
By b -
b p y
p p y pbby
b pp b
p -
b y p-
y B k k pp
I, k I
y y Ty k
y p b
My p-
pp k y
k p y
p A ,
by y - b by
z y k
T py,
x py, p -k P p
b b
H, p
, q -
y b b q
S p p b U Sby P b b pb ppyT by xp p
b y
T b p p C b ; p k k y p p U S, y, Ty b - y
I b k p b - 5 b , by y by SyG, y b T k US, A- y, p pp b M -, , p z- b
T U S p- xp - I , , y x b - p T -y k pp
b
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
26/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
23
E ky - k k
B-Sp
p ,
b b p p
p j -
y T
p y y pp
xp j y H, , y
b b b p
b p b
pby p
p y U S
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
27/28
F o r e i g n P o l i c y a t B r o o k i n g s
Defense Budgets and American Power
24
aBo ut t h e auth o r
Michael OHanlon S F D- R F Py Bk H
D R Bk 2
Cy D I OH pz
US y, y , -
y A py H
P Uy jp J Hpk Uy OH -
y Sy S I
Sy Ay B B j Bk,
OH k y y
C B Of
OH bk A Skeptics Case or Nu-
clear Disarmament (Bk, 2), T S
W (P Uy P, 29)
Budgeting or Hard Power (Bk, 29) H
k bk A
p py, b Bk-
Iq, Pk, A , p- OH bk Hard
Power: Te New Politics o National Security (
K Cpb)
-
8/8/2019 O'Hanlon: Cut F-35 program
28/28
T Brkgs Isttut1775 Mssustts Av., NW
Wsgt, D.C. 20036brkgs.du