ooa and recent developments in acm shameel farhan 201341

24
OOA and Recent Developments in ACM -A review Submitted to Prof. Wang Rumin Department of Applied Chemistry School of Science, NPU, Xi’an, China Prepared by Shameel Farhan PhD Student (Carbon foam core sandwich structures) Student ID 2013410005 CIRTM: co-injection RTM Crystic VI: vacuum infusion (Scott Bader) DRDF: double RIFT diaphragm forming (University of Warwick) LRI: liquid resin infusion MVI modified vacuum infusion (Airbus) * Quickstep * use of liquids for enhanced heat transfer in infusion RFI: resin film infusion RIFT: resin infusion under flexible tooling (ACMC Plymouth) RIRM: resin injection recirculation moulding SCRIMP Seeman Composites Resin Infusion Molding Process (TPI) VAIM: vacuum-assisted injection moulding VAP vacuum assisted processing (patented by EADS) VARI: vacuum assisted resin injection system (Lotus Cars) VARIM: vacuum assisted resin injection moulding V(A)RTM: vacuum (-assisted) resin transfer moulding VIM: vacuum infusion moulding. VIMP: vacuum infusion moulding process VM/RTM Light: a hybrid RIFT/RTM (Plastech) VIP: vacuum infusion process OOA Is it a game changer for all applications in the industry? OOA-BMI Quiet revolution

Upload: shameel-farhan

Post on 15-Apr-2017

381 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

OOAandRecentDevelopmentsinACM-A review

Submitted toProf. Wang RuminDepartment of Applied Chemistry School of Science, NPU, Xi’an, China

Prepared by Shameel FarhanPhD Student (Carbon foam core sandwich structures)Student ID 2013410005

CIRTM: co-injection RTM Crystic VI: vacuum infusion (Scott Bader)DRDF: double RIFT diaphragm forming (University of Warwick)LRI: liquid resin infusionMVI modified vacuum infusion (Airbus)* Quickstep * use of liquids for enhanced heat transfer in infusionRFI: resin film infusionRIFT: resin infusion under flexible tooling (ACMC Plymouth)RIRM: resin injection recirculation mouldingSCRIMP Seeman Composites Resin Infusion Molding Process (TPI) VAIM: vacuum-assisted injection mouldingVAP vacuum assisted processing (patented by EADS)VARI: vacuum assisted resin injection system (Lotus Cars)VARIM: vacuum assisted resin injection mouldingV(A)RTM: vacuum (-assisted) resin transfer mouldingVIM: vacuum infusion moulding.VIMP: vacuum infusion moulding process VM/RTM Light: a hybrid RIFT/RTM (Plastech)VIP: vacuum infusion process

OOA

Is it a game changer for all applications in the

industry?

OOA-BMI

Quiet revolution

Page 2: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

Out-Of-Autoclave(OOA)

OOA actually mean “never in the autoclave”, or “autoclave never needed” or technically “outside of the autoclave.” Speeding up the production process while at the same time achieving “autoclave material performance and overall quality” without autoclave.

There are several out of autoclave technologies in current use including resin transfer molding RTM), Same Qualified Resin Transfer Molding (SQRTM), vacuum-assisted resin transfer molding (VARTM), and balanced pressure fluid molding. The most advanced of these processes can produce high-tech net shape aircraft components.

The Quickstep™ Process (balanced pressure molding) changes the way advanced composites are manufactured by using a unique fluid-based technology for curing the composite materials. It is an OOA process. It works by trapping the laminate between a free floating rigid (or semi-rigid) mold that floats in a Heat Transfer Fluid (HTF). The mold and laminate are separated from the circulating HTF by a flexible membrane or bladder. The HTF can then be rapidly heated and then cooled to cure the laminate.

Fig.1 Schematic of Quickstep™ Process

Benefits of Quickstep™ Process Lower capital costs – typically around two-thirds of the cost of an

equivalent capacity autoclave Lower energy consumption for heating/cooling of the laminate Eliminates the need for compressed air or nitrogen use Only 1 to 4 psi operating pressures on parts

Page 3: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

No oven size restrictions Reduction in cure cycle times from 50-90% compared with autoclave and

oven using commercial prepregs Very accurate part temperature control Enhanced repeatability in cure cycles – evenly distributed heat-up and

cool-down Rapid heating aids full resin flow through and between laminate layers

for improved inter-laminar properties and improved surface quality Limited exotherm (when the material generate its own heat from the

chemical reaction) even in laminates that are 2 inches thick Quickstep’s unique ability to halt and then recommence the cure reaction

at any point in the cycle makes it possible to co-cure, join and bond one composite part to another

Ability to form entire integrated components without secondary bonds or fasteners

Reduces end product weight and part count No complex backing structure, resulting in lower costs per mold No need to delay the commencement of curing while waiting for other

parts, as occurs with large batch autoclaves Lower development costs due to faster iteration of experiments Curing of conventional autoclave or oven-style pre-pregs, including

phenolics Low pressure processing allows for the use of lighter weight cores Cured honeycomb structures have less print-through of the honeycomb

cell patterns, but with improved adherence at the bond points Low resin viscosity improves surface wetting of foam cores

OOA-BMIsThe development of OOA bismaleimide (BMI) systems has been a “quiet revolution” in OOA processing development. Or it needs to be a goal for everyone. Cytec developed OOA-BMI in 2011. For 17 years, Maverick Corp. (Blue Ash, Ohio) has produced polyimide resins, which they sell to prepreggers like Renegade Materials Corp. (Dayton, Ohio). Maverick and Renegade, in fact, have worked closely together since 2008 and were recently joined by Akron Polymer Systems (Akron, Ohio) and NASA Glenn (Cleveland, Ohio) as partners in an OOA Materials for High-Temperature Composite Applications project. The effort benefits from a recently awarded Third Frontier Grant from the U.S. state of Ohio. The team’s contribution and Ohio’s matching funds will total $2 million over two years, during which BMI and polyimide systems will be developed for service temperatures of 400°F to 700°F (204°C to 371°C). Dr. Robert Gray, Maverick president and director of product development, reports

Page 4: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

that polyimides enable service temperatures between 400°F/204°C and 700°F/371°C and cost $100/lb to $250/lb, while BMI resins provide up to 350°F/177°C hot/wet performance and cost $70/lb to $100/lb. But processing BMI resins is a little easier because, unlike polyimides, they do not form reaction byproducts, such as water and alcohol, during cure. Gray believes that most fabricators are limited to processing only BMI materials for high-temperature applications. However, Gray plans to reduce the complexity of processing polyimides by moving away from very low viscosity resins toward systems of greater molecular weight, formulated for VBO-curing prepregs. Military applications for polyimide composites include stator vanes leading into the compressor in jet engines, exhaust flaps in back of the engines, and outer bypass ducts. Polyimide structures also can handle extreme environments in and around commercial aircraft engines. Maverick and Renegade have identified many structural applications for polyimides, including UAV and low-observable applications. By offering more affordably processed OOA polyimides, Maverick’s program could help aircraft designers cut weight by reducing the need for insulation and shielding, especially on launch vehicles and other space platforms where weight is super critical. Currently, PMR-15 (supplied by Cytec as CYCOM 2237), the industry-standard polyimide, requires autoclave cure at 200 psi/13.8 bar. Gray explains, “Very few composites manufacturers have large, high-temperature autoclaves. If we can process polyimides OOA, we could dramatically expand the high-temp composite parts supplier base and broaden the use of these lightweight materials. “But what is the driver for an OOA BMI? According to industry consultant Jeff Hendrix, most BMI and polyimide parts that require performance above ~275˚F/~135˚C are used in engines, and don’t typically need to be large. These parts fit into current autoclaves, and most, in fact, are compression molded. “It’s not the upper use temperature that drives selection of BMIs, but the superior notched properties at even lower temperatures that makes them attractive to many programs,”

AFRL’s Russell agrees, noting that “5250-4 BMI [produced by Cytec] was used heavily in the JSF [program], even where no elevated service temperature was needed, simply because it was able to deliver higher stiffness-to-weight and strength-to-weight ratios due to its hot/wet performance, which means lighter structures. “Russell also sees the need for higher temperature performance in future programs. Thus, OOA BMIs are of interest to us.” Russell says that NASA has an interest because the use of BMI in the nose-cone of its launch vehicles could eliminate costly, heavy insulation materials.

Page 5: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

No more autoclaves?Bombardier’s LearJet has taken a major step by pursuing an all-composite OOA fuselage, but most manufacturers of large commercial structures will probably wait and see. Ostermeier sees military aerospace moving toward OOA faster than commercial aircraft, and if NASA does produce out-of-autoclave launch-vehicle sections reliably, he predicts that it could change composites manufacturing quite a bit. Hendrix maintains his skepticism, “I believe OOA has a bright future, but people should be careful because they think it is so much cheaper. “For Hahn, however, the issue is OOA’s utility in real-world production vs. R&D programs, where the driver for decision-making often is a program deadline. “The OOA materials we are looking at right now cost the same as the autoclave primary structure materials in use,” she notes. “But if they allow us to complete tooling in six weeks, and then proceed to prototyping and production much more quickly, it could win in trade studies for an application.” Offering weight, cost and process advantages, these “hot zone” resins is moving down the thermometer and into OOA. Although autoclave cure isn’t going away, designers of composite aero structures continue to beat the drum for matrix resins that can be processed OOA by a number of means. Yet they’re also searching for superior resin performance, particularly in terms of damage tolerance. This quest has put the spotlight on BMI and benzoxazine resinsystems. Each offers an attractive alternative to established epoxies.

Fig. 2 Bombardier’s LearJet all-composite OOA fuselage

BMI excels in high-temperature applications. However, much of its use on the F-35 Lightning II Joint Strike Fighter is due to its superior hot/wet performance at more moderate temperatures, which enables damage-tolerant structures at lower mass than can be achieved with epoxy. At a cost now comparable to high-performance epoxies, BMI is encroaching on epoxy’s recent gains in the OOA prepreg market. At a cost and performance level between standard epoxies and BMI, benzoxazine is increasingly viewed as a way to attack the cost of composite structures throughout the supply chain, not only because of its room-temperature stability and processing advantages, but because it also satisfies

Page 6: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

complex structural demands and meets supply, surface finish and health and safety requirements.

OOA BMI: Drivers and difficultiesUntil now to date, four such systems are commercially available (see Table 1). Dr. James K. Sutter, materials lead for large-scale composite structures at NASA Glenn Research Center (Cleveland, Ohio), has evaluated many OOA BMI systems, and presented the results at recent SAMPE Tech conferences and High Temple Workshops. “When I surveyed the industry with regard to BMI development in 2011, only three companies responded that they had an OOA system to meet our challenging requirements,” he reports. One was Stratton Composite Solutions (Marietta, Ga.), whose BMI-1 resin is now used in resin transfer molding (RTM) and vacuum-assisted RTM (VARTM) more than in prepreg. The company is developing a BMI foam for high-temperature tooling board. The other two suppliers, TenCate Advanced Composites (Nijverdal, The Netherlands, and Morgan Hill, Calif.) and Renegade Materials Corp. (Springsboro, Ohio), have since made significant product improvements as they’ve worked with NASA.

Fig. 3 Future OOA-cured composite structure for AresV.

Page 7: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

“OOA BMI is attractive because it enables affordable, lightweight tooling with excellent machinability and durability,” says Sutter. “The same tools made from Invar would be at least three times heavier and more costly, while epoxies cannot meet the temperatures or durability required.” NASA is also interested in the ability to make very large composite launch vehicle structures with higher service temperatures. Sutter explains, “For every 50°C [90°F] increase in Tg we can take out 1,000 lb [454 kg] in thermal protective system (TPS) weight.”According to Chris Ridgard, associate technical fellow at advanced materials supplier Cytec Aerospace Materials (Tempe, Ariz.), the use of BMI is being driven not just by tooling and applications where service temperatures exceed 350°F/177°C, but also by the increasing use of composites in structures that need improved hot/wet and open-hole compression (OHC) performance at moderate temperatures, such as 80°C to 120°C (176°F to 248°F). Ridgard details, “Most of the BMI structures on the F-35 use it because it outperforms epoxy and enables stronger, lighter weight parts.” Stratton Composite’s owner, Bob Stratton, also touts BMI’s better resistance to fluid ingress and gives supporting data for its superior strength retention: “BMI can offer a room-temperature OHC of 52 ksi (359 MPa) and at 220°F (104°C) it is still 49 ksi (338 MPa), where a typical structural epoxy goes from 40 ksi to 30 ksi (276 MPa to 207 MPa) or below at the same temperatures.”Previously, BMI was thought to be too expensive. “But now,” Stratton asserts, “BMI can be processed at the same cost as high-temperature epoxy resins.” NASA’s Sutter quotes $75/lb for carbon fiber/BMI prepreg, compared to $70/lb for intermediate-modulus (IM) carbon fiber/epoxy prepreg. Stratton cites BMI’s long cycle times on programs such as the U.S. F-22 jet fighter, an F-35 predecessor, as a significant cost issue that is now being addressed. “Cytec materials used on the F-22 required a 13-hour autoclave cycle because they had a six-hour cure,” he recalls. “However, we have demonstrated a cycle time of less than 3.5 hours using the OOA Quickstep process.”

OOA- BMI for toolingCytec’s Industrial Materials business has released a new OOA BMI tooling system, HTM520, that features a standard 375°F/190°C cure and post cureoptions at higher temperatures, with good machinability. Having withstood more than 200 thermal cycles between 20°C/68°F and 177°C/350°F with no micro cracking during tests, it also offers what is expected to be a long service life.Ridgard discusses the difficulties in developing an OOA BMI system. “If you look at why BMIs don’t process as well out of autoclave, you see two factors,” he points out. “First, OOA epoxy prepregs have been designed with evacuation

Page 8: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

channels” — less than 100 percent impregnation provides dry fiber paths — “so that you can edge breathe the laminate, whereas BMIs tend to flow too much and close off such evacuation channels. Second, the high levels of vacuum used in the production of aircraft structures tend to volatize some of the resin components; thus, the volatiles in the resin must be controlled because there is no autoclave or RTM pressure to push them back into solution.” Ridgard says Cytec has achieved the necessary control of flow and volatiles in its HTM520 system, which also results in better cured-ply thickness control. “If you push the viscosity up, the system is more stable so that resin does not flow all over the place. The tighter rein on thickness can also result in significantly reduced shimming and assembly costs for structures.” Ridgard says it would not surprise

Page 9: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

him to see a flow-controlled structural BMI based on HTM520 used with an autoclave because it gives that much better part accuracy, which is critical for most aerospace structures. But what about applications beyond tooling? Cytec’s BMI product manager, Mark Ostermeier, answers, “Cytec has a strong interest in using similar materials for structural applications. There has been huge growth in OOA epoxy materials, which are moving toward higher cure and service temperatures.” That said, Cytec has seen mixed industry interest, with some requesting BMI performance using vacuum-bag only processing while others want only significantly improved notched properties.

Fig. 4 OOA-cured tool made from Cytec Aerospace Materials’HTM520 BMI tooling prepreg.

“These could go hand-in-hand,” Ostermeier allows, “but there is no specific program demanding such a product.”A potential fifth source, Hexcel (Stamford, Conn.), is working to develop an OOA BMI prepreg with thermal, mechanical and automated-layup capabilities equivalent to its autoclave-cure M65 product, but with enhanced toughness, targeted primarily for aerospace primary structures but also for vacuum-bag only (VBO) tooling. “We can produce void-free OOA parts,” claims Hexcel chemist Bob Buyny. “Now, it’s a matter of fine-tuning for specific programs and being ready to scale up production.” Although Hexcel has definite program targets, there are, thus far, no set timelines for qualifications.

Benzoxazine: The contenderBenzoxazine was discovered in the 1940s. Huntsman Advanced Materials (Basel, Switzerland, and The Woodlands, Texas) began working with it in the late 1980s, and Henkel Aerospace (Bay Point, Calif.) followed a decade later.

Page 10: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

Even though benzoxazine was qualified for printed-circuit boards (PCBs) very quickly in 2000 — it was one of the few readily available nonhalogenated materials that met all of the performance requirements — systems for structural composites weren’t commercialized until 2008. Huntsman sells benzoxazine building-block components to prepreggers, resin formulators and adhesives manufacturers, while Henkel offers a range of formulated prepregs, infusion resins and adhesives. “This market has been slower to develop,” explains Huntsman’s composites marketing manager, Carl Holt, “because of the conservative nature of commercial aerospace and the extensive background epoxies have, including material databases.” Another difficulty is that benzoxazine can require cure temperatures higher than the 350°F/177°C standard for aero structures. Huntsman observes that benzoxazine processing temperatures and times can be varied widely using many different catalysts. Through its development of proprietary catalysts, only two of Henkel’s six benzoxazine systems — three for structural prepreg and three for structural infusion — require a cure over 200°C/392°F. The others cure at close to 177°C/350°F.Formed by reacting phenol, formaldehyde and amine, the chemistry of benzoxazine is unique in that its additive reaction results in ring opening polymerization (ROP), which produces a high molecular weight polymer and imparts near-zero cure shrinkage and two other key features: (1) it creates a reactive site that makes benzoxazine an über-reactive polymer for hybridizing with other resins, including epoxy, phenolic and BMI; and (2) it enables benzoxazine to polymerize with itself (homopolymerize) to form polybenzoxazine thermoset networks very similar to phenolic. Roger Tietze, a senior scientist technologist for Huntsman, points out, “This is why you get phenolic type properties without the condensation reaction which makes phenolic so difficult to process.” David Leach, Henkel’s global composites segment manager, explains, “The processing is basically the same as epoxy, and you don’t have the issues with voids during cure that must be managed with phenolics. In addition, the heat of reaction is lower than epoxies.” Henkel claims that a 19-mm (0.75-inch) thick, 150-ply laminate can be cured with a 5°C/min (9°F/min) ramp rate without an uncontrolled exotherm.

Between epoxy and BMI“There is a lot of interest because of the material’s advantages,” says Holt. These include high stiffness, excellent thermal properties (high Tg), lower moisture absorption and better flammability resistance (high char yield) than epoxies. Leach points out that benzoxazine also has better resistance to ultraviolet (UV) radiation than epoxies, with cured resin showing no discoloration, chalking or

Page 11: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

degradation after 95 days in outdoor exposure. Although reports from university studies show exotic benzoxazines with Tg as high as 300°C to 350°C (572°F to 662°F), Tietze says more common formulations exhibit a glass transition between 150°C and 250°C (302°F and 482°F). Like BMI, higher Tg systems have increased molecular weight and crosslinking, which gives them higher modulus and service temperature but also results in brittleness, so they need to be toughened to prevent micro cracking. Leach explains that the benzoxazine formulation Henkel supplied to Airtech International (Huntington Beach, Calif.) for its Beta Prepreg tooling system is different than what Airtech offers in its structural products. “They were looking for long tooling life at elevated temperature, so we developed that system with a Tg of 250°C [482°F] for 200°C [392°F] continuous service, obtained via post-cure.” However, he notes that “the benzoxazine formulations we have now are starting to get into the BMI service temperatures.”

That is almost unavoidable because, just like BMI, Henkel’s benzoxazine products are targeted toward epoxy’s shortfall in hot/wet performance. Leach says most epoxies have a maximum hot/wet service temperature of 120°C/250°F. All of Henkel’s benzoxazine products have a continuous service temperature of 120°C or higher and claim excellent hot/wet properties. “Traditionally, designers have been more interested in improved retention of hot/wet properties at 250°F and below,” Leach explains, “but more are finding hot spots that demand higher service temps with the recent trend of increased composites in airframes. We see this as a big growth area in the future.”

Stratton claims that BMI chemistry is not inherently more expensive than epoxies. “Perhaps that’s true,” says Leach, “but that’s not been the experience in the industry, to date.” He notes that the amount of BMI actually flying is small compared to epoxies. Compared to BMI, Leach again cites savings with benzoxazine due to elimination of frozen storage and thawing, but he adds that “there are also process cycle time and ease of layup advantages for both manual and automated placement.”

Benzoxazine’s futureAlthough BMIs are clearly ahead developmentally and commercially, and some users caution that it has not yet attained the maturity of BMI and still requiredevelopment in several areas, including OOA processing, benzoxazines are coming on strong. Henkel has OOA benzoxazine systems for prepreg and infusion, and Huntsman has liquid benzoxazines in commercial development. Dave Nesbitt, president of Matrix Composites (Rockledge, Fla.), a specialist in

Page 12: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

the design, development and qualification of complex integrated composite structures, sees potential for benzoxazine. Matrix is working with several customers to put benzoxazine composites into production, but Nesbitt, too, sees a need for continued product development. “Benzoxazine offers a unique blend of properties — the burn resistance and smoke toxicity benefits of phenolic but with the strength and modulus of BMI,” he notes. “That opens a lot of doors.” Indeed, benzoxazine is said to offer the flame, smoke and toxicity (FST) performance of phenolic without its voids and processing difficulties. That has it poised to push large, integrated structures into aircraft and other transportation interiors.

However, Nesbitt cautions that those who use benzoxazine “must work through some of its processing challenges, as with any new material.” He adds, “We have had great success at high pressures (>100 psi) in both RTM and autoclave environments, but benzoxazine is more challenging to process at lower pressures typical of VARTM, infusion and VBO curing. These are manageable, though, when appropriate measures are taken to ‘vent’ the outgassing that occurs during cure at low pressure.” That said, Henkel presented its development of a void-free 48-ply OOA-cured laminate using its BZ prepreg and the Boeing-developed double vacuum bag debulk (DVD) process in its “Out of Autoclave Composite Repair” presentation at SAMPE 2013 (May 6-9, Long Beach, Calif.).“The industry has a comfort level with BMI that is not there yet with benzoxazine,” says Cytec’s Ridgard. “It will be cautious in developing applications to make sure there are no hidden problems like cyanate ester showed with moisture.”

Huntsman’s Holt doesn’t entirely disagree: “It took the industry many years to develop epoxies to meet toughened properties and cure processing requirements.” Benzoxazine, he admits, must negotiate a similar transition, “but there is no reason why it can’t be developed to meet all of these needs.”Indeed, benzoxazine is demonstrating a unique and almost limitless ability to react with other resins (e.g., epoxy, phenolic, BMI, thiol) and produce hybrid formulations with exceptional properties

Benzoxazine + BMI?Resin supplier Huntsman Advanced Materials (Basel, Switzerland and The Woodlands, Texas) sees benzoxazine resins as traditional chemistry boundary breakers that open whole new resin-system possibilities. For example, a recent patent application describes novel benzoxazine/thiol compositions that are useful in coatings, sealants, adhesives and many other applications.

Page 13: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

“Traditionally, this cannot be achieved with epoxy,” explains Huntsman scientist technologist Dong Wang. “This shows how benzoxazine’s chemistry is overcoming obstacles in polymer formulation and processing.” Recently, in fact, there has been a flurry of research activity on blends of bismaleimide (BMI) and benzoxazine, including a 2013 Chinese patent application specifically for composites applications that claims the blend exhibits improved thermal stability and toughness vs. benzoxazine alone, yet it maintains the inherent machinability of the latter.

“The ability to achieve truly unique resin properties is practically limitless,” claims Wang, “because not only can benzoxazine react with so many polymers but there is such a wide variety of amine and phenol monomers which can also be combined and tailored to affect the final system performance.” Researchers in India, for example, report modifying benzoxazine’s Tg by 149°C/88°F simply by playing with the monomer feed ratio.

Huntsman predicts that such custom tailoring of resins will be the norm in structural composites within 15 to 20 years.

Page 14: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

LatestCompositeShowcase

First Smart Carbon Fiber BikeCanadian based company Vanhawks have introduced the world’s first carbon fiber smart bike that allows you to connect to your smart phone via Bluetooth.The bike, called Valour connects to iOS, Android and Pebble smart watches through Bluetooth and tracks rider statistics in real-time including the route, distance, speed, and time. Valour’s LED handlebar indicators are connected to the smart phone’s GPS navigation and give riders turn-by-turn directions, reducing the distraction of having to look at a smartphone screen. The Valour also includes, the industry’s first sensor-driven blind spot detector, which alerts the rider of any object in their blind spot through haptic feedback in the handle bar grips. Onboard sensors monitor ride statistics in real-time and syncs the data with the Vanhawks app. The route data gathered by the sensors will also let the riders know where the safest routes are. Every Valour is connected to each other through a mesh-network, and is alerted when one goes missing, aiding in its recovery. The frame of the bike is developed from carbon fiber using proprietary technology which makes internal walls to reinforce critical load bearing points in the frame. Its carbon fiber technology, replicates the construction of human bones, making the bike frame strong enough to withstand the toughest roads and potholes. The Valour weighs in at just over 7kgs, making it light enough to carry up flight of stairs without breaking a sweat.

The Vanhawks Valour is available for a limited pre-order now on Kickstarterstarting at $999. The Valour will ship in Autumn 2014.

Fig. 5 Valour smart carbon fiber bike.

Page 15: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

Nike Air Jordan XX8The Jordan Brand, a division of Nike has unveiled the Air Jordan XX8, the 28th shoe in the Jordan range. The new basketball shoe boasts an ultra-modern stealth design and more technological advances. This ultra-light shoe designed by Tinker Hatfield has a load of new enhancements over the previous model. The Air Jordan features a high-performance; stretch-synthetic shroud that provides a sleek exterior, while a molded external heel counter is made out of carbon fiberfor lightweight support. A multi directional outsole pattern provides excellent traction and durability for the court. Schoeller mesh, a Swiss fabric used in premium motorcycling jackets, is used in the shroud that encompasses the shoe to provide an extra layer of support, stability and style for the athlete.

Fig. 6 Nike Air Jordan XX8 shoes.

It will only be available in Houston on February 15, 2013, and then nationwide on Saturday, February 16, for a suggested retail price of $250.

Human Powered Helicopter Lifts OffLast summer a team of engineering students from the Clark School of Engineering at the University of Maryland created a human-powered helicopter called Gamera, they managed to get it off the ground and keep it aloft for 11 seconds. However their new model, the Gamera II managed to stay airborne for a solid 50 seconds, smashing the world record.

The Gamera II has been improved from its predecessor in many ways. It is 105 feet across, and each of the four rotors is 42 feet long. Thanks to the weight saving benefits of carbon fiber the entire helicopter weighs just 32 kilos, which is over 13 kilos lighter than the previous design.

Page 16: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

Luno chair made by carbon fiber string at different positions.The amazing Luno chair is the creation of Korean based designer Il Hoon Roh and is the result of experiments conducted by suspending carbon fiber string at different positions. Made from carbon fiber string woven together by hand, the Luno (Latin for curve) chair is the result of many experiments conducted by suspending string at various positions, the designer allowed gravity to shape the final form resulting in smooth natural curvature. To create the curves, a hexagonal shape was used on the surface, and carbon fiber strings were woven from the surface to the metal base.

Fig. 7 Luno carbon fiber chair.

Zodiac Aerospace have teamed up with Hexcel to develop a new introduce the L3, a lightweight composite aircraft seat.The L3 is a revolutionary passenger seat dedicated for medium/short-haul flights, offering good space to passengers and to airlines a higher density and a lighter weight, below 4 kg per passenger. The manufacturing process of the seat, resulting from cooperation between Zodiac Seats and Hexcel will ensure a quick manufacturing and delivery time compared to current seats. The all-composite seat has been manufactured using Hexcel’s carbon fiber prepreg product which provided light weight, mechanical resistance and an aesthetic appearance. The armrests and tray tables are manufactured from Hexcel’s HexMC compression molding process, providing a unique look and strong resistance.

Page 17: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

Fig. 8 L3 lightweight composite aircraft seat.

New Transparent Fiber Composite Materials for Future DevicesOn January 30, 2014, the US Patent & Trademark Office published a patent application from Apple titled "Transparent Fiber Composite." Apple's invention relates to transparent composite materials, and more particularly to relatively transparent composites formed with fibers encapsulated in a resin. Apple has been experimenting with composite materials since 2007 as we detailed in a 2010 patent report. This is all part in parcel of research that Apple is heavily investing in so as to find new materials for future devices. The wearable computer is one such category that will be able to take advantage of composite materials such as the one found in today's patent filing.

As most fiberglass cures, the fiberglass can appear to take on a slight green hue imparted by the resin. Colored resins can be easier to handle during the manufacturing process. Many fiberglass objects can be painted or have a coverlay applied to both hide the green color and provide a final finish for the fiberglass object. It can be desirable to have low cost, high strength, relatively clear fiber reinforced composites. Relatively clear fiberglass composites can enable lightweight and strong housings that can include a clear window for either displays or even camera lenses.

Apple's invention generally describes various embodiments that relate to relatively transparent fiber reinforced composites. In one embodiment, a fiber for the composite can be selected and an index of refraction related to the fiber can be determined. A sizing can be selected for application to the fiber such that an index of refraction of the sizing can be within a tolerance amount of the index of

Page 18: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

refraction of the fiber. A resin can be selected for the composite such that an index of refraction of the resin is also within the tolerance amount of the determined index of refraction of the fiber. A transparent fiber-resin composite is disclosed. In one embodiment, the transparent fiber-resin composite can include a glass fiber, a sizing and a resin where the sizing and the resin are selected to have an index of refraction similar to a determined index of refraction of the glass fiber. In one embodiment, the glass fiber can include less than 0.1% of iron oxide. A method of forming a transparent fiber-resin composite by injection molding is disclosed. In one embodiment, a chopped glass fiber is selected and the index of refraction of the glass fiber is determined. A sizing for the chopped glass fiber is selected with an index of refraction similar to the index of refraction of the glass fiber. The sizing is applied to the glass fiber and a resin is selected with an index of refraction similar to the index of refraction of the glass fiber. The glass fiber is mixed with the resin and the mixture is injection molded.

Silk fibers come on strong in composites13 May 2014 | Cordelia Sealy

Fig. 9 SEM images of the plain weave textiles: (a) flax, (b) hemp, (c) silk A, and (d) silk B. SEM images of cross-sections of silk rovings and fibers in (e) and (f).

Silk fibers from spiders and silk worms could prove an effective and novel reinforcement in bio composites, according to research carried out at the University of Oxford. Many different fibers are used as reinforcing agents in composites, but demands for sustainable materials are spurring interest in natural fibers. Liquid composite and compression molding are the most common

Page 19: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

manufacturing process, in which reinforcement fibers are arranged in a ‘preform’, a polymer filling agent is introduced, and the two are molded or compressed together. The more compressible the fiber reinforcement, the higher the fiber content that can be achieved in the composite.

Darshil U. Shah and colleagues have found that silk reinforcements are far more compressible than typical plant fibers and even glass fiber textiles [Shah, D. U., et al., Composites: Part A 62 (2014) 1-10, DOI: 10.1016/j. Unlike plant fibers such as flax and hemp, which typically form bundles, silk from the silkworm Bombyx mori, for example, is created as long, smooth individual threads. These threads or filaments, which can reach up to 1500 m, have almost triangular-shaped cross sections that fit together much more snugly than cylindrical plant fibers.

Textiles woven from silk fibers are much easier to compact than those woven from hemp or flax, according to the study. Comparing silk, hemp, and flax woven textiles in a scanning electron microscope reveals that silk has a much tighter and more ordered weave with much less ‘fluffiness’ or loose, disordered fibers. When it comes to making bio composites, this means that less compaction pressure is required to achieve a particular fiber volume fraction. For a given compaction pressure, the volume fraction of silk fibers was 10-15% higher than the best flax reinforcement. In fact, silk composites with fiber volume fractions of up to 60% could be produced at low compaction pressures, suggests Shah. Silk fiber reinforcements have another benefit over plant fibers in that they can withstand bending without breaking better than plant fibers, improving the mechanical performance of the composite. According to the researchers, the findings mean that silk fibers could overcome the bottleneck facing plant fiber reinforcements and enable the manufacture of high fiber-content bio composites.“Not only are silk reinforcements significantly more compressible than plant fiber reinforcements, but their compactibility exceeds that of even glass fiber textiles,” explains Shah. “Consequently, silk fiber reinforcements offer a unique opportunity in the production of high fiber volume fraction natural fiber composites.”Not only would silk-reinforced composites be more sustainable because less energy is required to produce the fibers, but less environmentally unfriendly polymer filler would be needed. Ultimately, these composites could offer better mechanical performance too, particularly where light-weight and high-toughness are required, as well as sustainability.

Page 20: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

3D vascular system allows for self-healing of composite materials22 April 2014 | Laurie Donaldson

Scientists have turned to nature to develop a 3D vascular system that permits high-performance composite materials such as fiberglass to heal both autonomously and repeatedly. Damage to such fiber-reinforced composites, commonly used within engineered structures in aerospace, automotive, civil, naval and even sporting goods due to their effective strength-to-weight ratio, can be difficult to detect and repair using traditional approaches. The team, from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, whose research was published in the journal Advanced Materials [Patrick et al. Adv. Mater. (2014) DOI: 10.1002/adma.201400248], were looking to solve the problem in composites of small cracks that become irreversible damaged by delamination, limiting the wider deployment of such materials in industry. They demonstrated the first repeated healing in a fiber-reinforced composite system using vasculature patterns of micro-channels that integrate dual networks that are isolated from each other – an epoxy resin and hardener acting as liquid healing agents sequestered in two different micro channel networks. As fiber-composite laminates are produced by the weaving and stacking of multiple layers, it is comparatively easy for the structure to separate between the layers. In this new 3D vascular system, when a fracture breaks apart the separate networks, the healing agents are automatically released into the crack plane. On coming into contact with one another in situ, or within the material, they polymerize to form a structural glue at the damage site and were shown to heal the material over multiple cycles. It is important the vascular networks do not run in straight lines to allow the healing agents to mix properly once released. Therefore the vessels were overlapped, significantly improving their resilience and life span. The team introduced the same process used for making laminates to stitch in a line made from a bio-friendly polymer (termed “sacrificial fiber”) within the composite. Once this was achieved, the system was heated to melt and evaporate the sacrificial fibers so that hollow micro channels remained, which became the vasculature for the self-healing system. The method therefore integrates seamlessly with standard manufacturing processes for polymer composites and is also highly scalable.

Page 21: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

The approach could be used in structures prone to cyclic damage and are critically important for the safety and performance of engineered systems. The team is now continuing to explore biomimetic vasculatures through more advanced fabrication techniques, which could lead to even more complex vascular architectures, including multi-scale and branched networks.

AshortdiscussiononShortBeamSheartestmethodforcompositematerials

Dr. Donald F. Adams (Wyoming Test Fixtures (Salt Lake City, Utah) suggests larger support and loading cylinders for the Short Beam Shear test method. The primary attraction of the SBS method for many users is the simplicity, the small size of the test specimen and the ease with which the test can be performed. As a result, the SBS method is widely used. Yet it is not without its detractors. The test method loads a beam specimen in three-point bending, as shown in Fig. 10. The term “short beam” indicates that the support span length, s, is a low multiple of the specimen thickness, t. The goal is to force the beam specimen to fail in a shear mode. This can be achieved because the shear stress is independent of the support length, whereas the flexural (bending) stresses are a linear function of the support length. Thus, the shorter the beam, the greater the shear stress relative to the bending stresses.

The SBS test method was first standardized by ASTM in 1965, as ASTM D 2344, and titled “Apparent Interlaminar Shear Strength of Parallel Fiber Composites by Short-Beam Method.” The standard suggested using a support span length-to-specimen thickness ratio, s/t, of 5 for glass-fiber-reinforced composites and 4 for all other reinforcing fibers, including carbon, steel, boron, aramid and so forth. The questionable distinction for glass fibers was based primarily on some limited analytical studies that were being conducted at the time. The use of “apparent” in the title was to acknowledge that the shear stresses in the short beam are not only not uniform, but also are accompanied by tensile and compressive axial stresses as well as through-the-thickness tensile and compressive stresses. Simply put, it was well known that the SBS method was not a “pure shear” test, as would have been desirable. Nevertheless, it was considered a shear test. In the 2000 revision of ASTM D 2344, however, the title was altered to “Short-Beam Strength of Polymer Matrix Composite Materials and Their Laminates.” The word “shear” was deleted from the title and from the definition of the strength quantity it measures. In spite of these negative implications, the SBS test continues to be used extensively for the same reason

Page 22: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

as always — it is easy to perform and can provide a good comparative assessment of material performance, even if it does not necessarily provide accurate quantitative data. Notably, the revised method eliminated the separate s/t ratio for glass fiber composites. The standard now specifies that s/t = 4 be used for all types of fiber-reinforced polymers. And although the originally defined 0.250-inch diameter loading cylinder and 0.125-inch diameter specimen support cylinders were retained, consistent with ASTM’s decision to require “soft” rather than “hard” conversions from U.S. customary units to SI units, the SI “equivalent” diameters became 6 mm and 3 mm rather than the previous 6.35 mm and 3.2 mm.The soft conversions raise an obvious question: Is it necessary to use different cylinders if a test is being conducted per the SI version of the standard? The strict answer, of course, is yes. But it has been clearly demonstrated during the past decade that small changes in cylinder diameter make little difference in the test results.

Further, these studies have demonstrated experimentally and numerically that larger cylinder diameters are beneficial because they induce more uniform stresses within the beam specimen. Using small-diameter cylinders introduces high local stress concentrations. Larger cylinders spread the applied load over a wider specimen surface area, resulting in more uniform internal stress states in the specimen. In fact, it would be logical to size the cylinders in proportion to the specimen thickness and, thus, the anticipated failure load. However, this has not yet been proposed and, perhaps, is not practical. A standard loading cylinder diameter as large as 25 mm/1 inch has been suggested.1However, considering the small thickness of a typical specimen, a loading cylinder diameter of 12.7 mm/0.50 inch, with a corresponding diameter of 6.35 mm/0.25 inch for the support cylinders, is a more practical option (Fig. 1b). Note that, for the three-point bending SBS test depicted in Fig. 1, the reaction forces at the supports are one-half the force applied on the loading cylinder, justifying the use of smaller support cylinders. In fact, if the test specimen is relatively thin, there isn’t sufficient space between the support points to accommodate a large-diameter cylinder. For example, on a typical 2.5-mm/0.10-inch thick specimen with a support span ratio of 6, the distance between supports will be a mere 15 mm/0.60 inch, indicating that the largest support cylinder diameter can be only 15 mm/0.60 inch. Of course, it isn’t necessary to use full cylinders because it is only the radius of the surface in contact with the specimen that is significant. Thesesame studies also have shown that the s/t ratio has a strong influence on the obtained “apparent shear strength” and the failure mode. From Fig. 1a, it can be inferred that, as s/t decreases from the value of 4, the support cylinders get closer to being directly under the loading cylinder, and there will be more of a through-

Page 23: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

the-thickness crushing of the specimen, rather than bending, thus altering the failure mode away from shear. Correspondingly, if s/t becomes too great — that is, if the specimen is no longer a short beam — the previously noted flexural (axial tensile or compressive) failures will occur rather than a shear failure. Most likely, there will be compressive failures at or near the specimen surface under the loading point, where the stress concentrations occur. Studies indicate that an s/t ratio in the range of 4 (the current ASTM recommendation) to 9 is favorable.1 Therefore, standardizing a ratio of 6 or 7 would be reasonable. In this s/t range, there is typically one large and abrupt load drop at failure, with shear cracks visible at or near the midthickness of the specimen, typically in the region midway between the loading and support points where the shear stress is greatest. In summary, it is suggested that ASTM D 2344 be revised to specify an s/t ratio of 6, a loading cylinder diameter of 12.7 mm/0.50 inch and a support cylinder diameter of 6.35 mm/0.25 inch, as depicted in Fig. 1b. These modifications are minor, will have relatively little influence on direct comparisons of new results with legacy values, and will provide more consistent shear failure modes.

Fig. 10 Short Beam Shear specimen test configurations. Source: Don Adams

AnewtermMelding

Melding is a combination of "melting" and "welding", where one semi-cured part melts into another semi-cured part to form one integrated component with no physical difference or secondary bonds.

Page 24: OOA and recent developments in ACM Shameel Farhan 201341

MELTING + WELDING = MELDING

By using the Quickstep curing process, a section of the part can be fullycured while another section can be left partially cured or uncured. The partially cured or uncured sections can then be joined using the Quickstep Melding Process. To do this, the partially cured or uncured sections are laid together and cured simultaneously, as shown in the schematic below. A layer of pre-preg fibercan then be used to cover the joint between the two sections, thereby melting and chemically bonding with the part and mechanically bridging the joint.

Fig. 11 Melding.