--

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

9090

: : , , , ,

, , // ..

Operational Risk ManagementOperational Risk Management -- ORMORM(( -- ). ).

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

:: ,, ,, ..

:: 20012001,, ..

:: (( ))..

:: (( // --6644))..

:: ,, ..

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

HH

((), ),

--

..

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

, , .

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

, , , , , , :: , , ;;

,, :: ,, ,,

. .

,, ::

99 ,, ..

99 ,, . .

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

3 3 ::

99 ..99 --

((Target Target FixaritionFixarition).).

99 (Follow (Follow tthe he Leader). Leader).

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

((Hazard)Hazard) --,, ..

((Hazard Hazard SeveritySeverity)) , , ..

((Mishap Mishap ProbabilityProbability)) ,, ..

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

((Risk)Risk) ..(( // ))..

((Risk Risk Assessment)Assessment)

, , -- ..

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

((Residual Residual RiskRisk)) , , , , , , ..

((ORMORM)) , , , , ..

((Risk AssessmentRisk Assessment CodeCode)) , , , , (( RACRAC).).

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

99 ,, ..

99 ,, ..99 ,, ..

99 ,, ..

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

5 /:

1: (Identify Hazards)

2: -(Assess Hazards)

3: (Make Risk Decisions)

4: (Implement Controls)

5: (Supervise)

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

5. Supervise

4. Implement Controls

1. Identify Hazards

2. Hazard Assessment3. Make Risk

Decisions

11

((Identify HazardsIdentify Hazards))

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

11

((Identify HazardsIdentify Hazards))

(( ))::

99 ..99 ..99

..

99 ..

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

11

((Identify HazardsIdentify Hazards))

5. Supervise

4. Implement Controls

1. Identify Hazards

2. Hazard Assessment

3. Make Risk Decisions

22 --

((Assess HazardsAssess Hazards))

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

22 --

((Assess HazardsAssess Hazards))

, , , , ..

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

22 --

((Assess HazardsAssess Hazards))

33

((Make Risk DecisionsMake Risk Decisions))

5. Supervise

4. Implement Controls

1. Identify Hazards

2. Hazard Assessment

3. Make Risk Decisions

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

--

-- --

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

33

((Make Risk DecisionsMake Risk Decisions))

,, . .

:: --

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

33

((Make Risk DecisionsMake Risk Decisions))

44

((Implement ControlsImplement Controls))

5. Supervise

4. Implement Controls

1. Identify Hazards

2. Hazard Assessment

3. Make Risk Decisions

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

::

((Engineering ControlsEngineering Controls))

((Administrative Controls)Administrative Controls)

((Personal Protective Equipment)Personal Protective Equipment)

((Additional Leadership Control MeasuresAdditional Leadership Control Measures))

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

44

((Implement ControlsImplement Controls))

55 ((SuperviseSupervise))

5. Supervise

4. Implement Controls

1. Identify Hazards

2. Hazard Assessment

3. Make Risk Decisions

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

55 ((SuperviseSupervise))

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

((ORM ORM Process Process LevelsLevels))

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

((TimeTime CCriticalritical ORMORM)) ((DeliberateDeliberate ORMORM)) ((InIn Depth Depth ORMORM))

((Time Critical)Time Critical)

(Deliberate)(Deliberate)

(In Depth)(In Depth)

((ORMORM)),,

, ,

, ,

, , ..

OOPPEERRAAIIOONNAALL

RRIISSKK

MMAANNAAGGEEMMEENNTT

((Risk Risk Assessment Assessment MatrixMatrix))

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

,, 22 ..

, , ..

,, ..

, , , , ..

,, , , ..

, , ,, ,, ..

((Hazard Hazard SeveritySeverity))

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

,,

. .

,, ::

99 ,,99 ,,99 ,,99 ,,99 ,, , , 99 ..

IVIV

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

((Hazard Hazard SeveritySeverity))

,,

,,

..

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

((MishapMishap ProbabilityProbability))

: :

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

. .

. .

..

..

T T

A B

11 11 22 33

11 22 33 44

22 33 44 55

IVIV 33 44 55 55

((Risk AssessmentRisk Assessment CodeCode))

1 2 3 4 5

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

((Risk Risk Assessment Assessment MatrixMatrix))

DESERT STORMDESERT STORM

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

1717 19911991

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

17 17 19911991

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

CodyCody::

.. .. //.. ,, . . ,,

FLIRFLIR ..

17 17 19911991

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

17 17 19911991

((RACRAC1), 1), Cody Cody ..

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

::

// .. .. ..

. .

1.1. ,, . .

2.2. ,, , , (( ),), ..

3.3. ,, ,, , , ..

--

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

(())

..

..

..

..

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

5. Supervise

4. Implement Controls

1. Identify

Hazards2. Hazard

Assessment3. Make Risk Decisions

T T

A B

11 11 22 33

11 22 33 44

22 33 44 55

IVIV 33 44 55 55

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT

((Time Critical)Time Critical)

(Deliberate)(Deliberate)

(In Depth)(In Depth)

((ORMORM)),,

, ,

, ,

, , ..

OOPPEERRAAIIOONNAALL

RRIISSKK

MMAANNAAGGEEMMEENNTT

OO

PP

EE

RR

AA

II

OO

NN

AA

LL

RR

II

SS

KK

MM

AA

NN

AA

GG

EE

MM

EE

NN

TT