optimized wind and solar power forecasts for india · high/low wind seasons and model tuning. solar...

56
© Overspeed Oldenburg Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 Operational wind & solar power forecasting Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India Dr. Hans-Peter (Igor) Waldl, Overspeed, Germany Overspeed GmbH & Co. KG, Germany D. Heinemann (University of Oldenburg, Germany), K. Balaraman, G. Giridhar (NIWE, India) Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India 1

Upload: others

Post on 05-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019

Operational wind & solar power forecasting

Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India

Dr. Hans-Peter (Igor) Waldl, Overspeed, Germany

Overspeed GmbH & Co. KG, Germany

D. Heinemann (University of Oldenburg, Germany), K. Balaraman, G. Giridhar (NIWE, India)

Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India 1

Page 2: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Overspeed: 30 Years of Experience

• Core: Consulting for investors, banks, project developers

• R&D as background

• System development

• Main areas:

Thomas Pahlke

Dr. Hans-Peter Waldl

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 2

Page 3: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Wind Energy Consulting

Assessments

System and Software Development

Wind and Solar Power Predictions

[email protected]

Wind and Solar Power Predictions

Wind energy Consulting

Assessments

System and Software Development

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 3

Page 4: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Anemos predictions: What is Anemos?

• Leading edge research and development

• Prediction models and modules

• Wind and Solar Power Prediction System

• Commercial wind & solar predictions

• Today: More than 130 GW of predictions worldwide

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 4

AU.SA

Page 5: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Offshore wind farm development Sandbank 24

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 5

Page 6: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Underground storage for hydrogen: Salt dome

© IVG AG

5000

m

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 6

Page 7: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Hydrogen (P2X) long-term storage

© IVG AG

-2000 m

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 7

Page 8: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Activities in India

• REMC advice

• Wind and solar power predictions

• Satellite-based very short-term predictions

• Training for NIWE team (GIZ): Indigenous solar power prediction system for India

• Training for REMC operators (GIZ)

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 8

Page 9: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning

Solar power: Soiling of PV panels

Daily patterns and the atmosphere

Curtailment and unavailability

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 9

Solar power: Sat-based forecasting methods

Page 10: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 10

Page 11: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Tuning affected by high/low wind period

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 11

Page 12: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Models and adaptive tuning

• Adaptive model tuning improves forecasts over time

• Includes some „forgetting factor“

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 12

Mod

el e

rror

Page 13: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Auto-adaptive model improvement

Model error improvement over 6 month

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 13

Page 14: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Tuning affected by high/low wind period

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 14

Page 15: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

• Adaptive model tuning improves forecasts over time

• Includes some „forgetting factor“

• Discarding of old observations from the process must take into account seasonality

Models and adaptive tuning

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 15

Page 16: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Thermal status of the atmosphere

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 16

Page 17: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Strong thermal influences

Strong daily pattern.

Noon

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 17

That‘s a wind farm, not solar!

Pow

er

Page 18: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Vertical wind speed profile

regular high irradiation

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 18

Page 19: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Wind farm with strong thermal influences

Appropriate modelling of the atmosphere is crucial

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 19

Page 20: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Power Data: Curtailment and unavailability

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 20

Page 21: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Curtailment and unavailability

Auto-detection helps for better tuning and forecasts

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 21

Page 22: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Solar power: Seasons

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 22

Page 23: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

PV Power Production, clear sky

© NIWE

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 23

Page 24: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

PV Power Production, broken clouds

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019

As for wind: Model tuning algorithms must be optimised

24

Page 25: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Solar power: Soiling of PV panels

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 25

Page 26: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Losses due to soiling

• Soiling could reduce the PV output up to 15 % or more

• Cleaning routine in place in most farms

• Rain has high impact on the effect

• Local measurements help

© pv-tech.com

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 26

Page 27: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Soiling experiment

NIWE/overspeed/Uni Oldenburg:

First long-term soiling experiment in India (Sahana L., this conference)

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 27

Page 28: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Solar power: Sat-based forecasting methods

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 28

Page 29: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Prediction Principles: Short-term

5 min 15 min 3 h 6 h intraday day ahead

10 d

time

Online SCADA NWP domain

Historical SCADA

Mod

el

type

s In

put

Dat

a

Statistical models NWP + physical/statistical modelling

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 29

Page 30: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Big cloud field over south-east Australia

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 30

Page 31: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Prediction Principles: Short-term

5 min 15 min 3 h 6 h intraday day ahead

10 d

time

Online SCADA NWP domain

Historical SCADA

Mod

el

type

s In

put

Dat

a

Sat images

Statistical models NWP + physical/statistical modelling

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 31

Page 32: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

• EL S 6 Consecutive satellite images

Cloud prediction Irradiation Motion Vector Field

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 32

Page 33: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 33

Page 34: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 34

Page 35: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 35

Page 36: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 36

Page 37: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 37

Page 38: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 38

Page 39: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 39

Page 40: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 40

Page 41: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 41

Page 42: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 42

Page 43: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 43

Page 44: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 44

Page 45: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 45

Page 46: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 46

Page 47: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 47

Page 48: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 48

Page 49: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 49

Page 50: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 50

Page 51: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Example roof-top, NWP-based, Brisbane

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019

Actual Production

Weather data based prediction

51

Page 52: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Example roof-top, sat-based, 1 hour ahead

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019

sat based prediction

52

Page 53: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Prediction Principles: Extreme Short-term

5 min 15 min 3 h 6 h intraday day ahead

10 d

time

Online SCADA NWP domain

Historical SCADA

Mod

el

type

s In

put

Dat

a

Sat images

Statistical models NWP + physical/statistical modelling

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 53

Sky cams

Page 54: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

India is a challenging environment!

• Strong seasonal effects

• Strong thermal influences

• SCADA data influenced by no-availability

• Aerosoles and humidity play a big role

• Soiling has to be taken into account

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 54

Page 55: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

India is a challenging environment!

• Very-shert-term forecasting with Indian satellite

• Fine tuning of models and processes improves predictions significantly

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 55

[email protected]

Page 56: Optimized Wind and Solar Power Forecasts for India · High/low Wind Seasons and Model Tuning. Solar power: Soiling of PV panels. Daily patterns and the atmosphere . Curtailment and

© O

vers

peed

Old

enbu

rg

Workshop Large-scale Grid Integration of Renewables in India, Delhi Sep. 2019 56