“optimizing high dose odts using doe designs”using doe designs
TRANSCRIPT
“Optimizing High Dose ODTsODTsUsing DOE DesignsUsing DOE Designs”
(OOrally rally DDisintegratingisintegrating TTabletsablets)
Feb 3, 2008
Cecil W. Propst [email protected]
Presentation Outline
• What is an ODT? Who requires it?• How is it designed?• Therapeutic benefits?• How is it tested?• Regulatory Requirements• Basis for Design for High Dose Actives• SPI Pharma – Formulation Wizard
What is an ODT?The Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER) states an ODT to be (1998):
"A solid dosage form containing medicinal substances, which disintegrates rapidly, usually within a matter of seconds, when placed upon the tongue.”
Alias: Quick DissolveQuick Dissolve Fast MeltFast MeltRapid DisintegratingRapid Disintegrating Flash MeltFlash MeltMouth DispersingMouth Dispersing
Market a standard or a trademark!
Who requires (prefers) ODT?• Patients who have difficulty in swallowing tablets especially
children and elderly (approx. 1/3 of the patients have difficulty swallowing)– Parkinson, Migraine, Epilepsy, Schizophrenia
• Convenience “on-the-move”, requires no water intake • Compliance• Quicker onset of action (Migraine, ED, Insomnia)• “Preference for the wafer drug delivery system [Zydis] over
tablets was noted by 75% of the sample population. The findings were consistent for younger (<60 years) and older (>60 years) subjects”
Ref: Schwartz et al. J Clin Pharmacol 1995; 35: 362-367
• Four out of five patients would prefer ODTs vs swallow tablets. (Market Survey)
4
Little water
Limited Insolubles
Fast to disintegrate
Fast to dissolve
Smooth mouth feel
5
Therapeutic benefits of ODTs
• Buccal, Mucosal, Sublingual Absorption (Pre –GI)– Avoid first pass effects
• Might be able to lower API dosing with same AUC – therapeutic effect – (Migrane, ED)
• Less side effects due to potential lower dosing– Increase permeability /bioavailability (insomnia drug) – Faster adsorption
• Faster onset of action? (Lower tmax)– Proven with API’s (due to API adsorption in mouth)
• Consumers perception of “quicker relief”
6
Bioequivalence - Selegiline ODTFirst-pass metabolism greatly reduced!
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
Time (hours)
Plas
ma
Con
c. (n
g/m
l)
Immediate Release Tab (10 mg)
Lyophilized ODT (1.25 mg)
Slide courtesy of Cardinal Health 7
How are ODTs tested?
• FDA recommends the USP/EP Disintegration Method
30 seconds is fast for the test!
Less than 12 up and down motions inUSP/EP unit..
8
USP/EP Compliant Units (Automatic Endpoint)
1) Time lift2) Proximity
sensor3) Conductivity
100 um spaceErweka, Distech
9
What types of products are in ODT form?What types of products are in ODT form?
• Products that disintegrate in a few seconds (Lyophilized)
• Majority disintegrate in less than 30 seconds (Direct Compression)
• Some are intentionally made to disintegrate in 1 - 2 minutes (Buccal adsorption longer oral residence sought)
• Analgesics/Pain/Migraine (Ibuprofen - APAP)• Cough/Cold/Antihistamine• Psychiatric/Neural medications (ED therapy)• Anti-emetic, Other
ODT Brands • Alavert™ ODT (Loratidine)• Aricept® ODT (Donepazil)• Benadryl® FastMelt™
• Claritin® RediTabs®
• Dimetapp® Quick Dissolve• Excederin® Quicktabs™
• Feldene® Melt• Maxalt® MLT (Rizatriptan)• NuLev®
• Paracetamol ODT• Parcopa® (Carbadopa/Levodopa)• Pepcid® RPD
• Prevacid® SoluTab(Lansoprazole)
• Risperdal® M-tab (Risperidone)• Remeron® SolTab™
(Mirtazapine)• Tempra® FirsTabs• Tramadol® ODT (Tramadol)• Triaminic® Softchews®
• Zofran ODT® (Ondansetron)• Zolpidem ODT®
• Zomig-ZMT® Rapimelt(Zolmitriptan)
• Zoton FasTab®
• Zyprexa® Zydis™(Olanzapine)
Products above are registered trademarks of Cima, Novartis, BMS, Pfizer, GSK, Schwarz, Schering Plough, Tap, Janssen, Eli Lilly, Merck. Pharmaburst is used with APIs in RED.
Harmonization
Legal definition!
12
Regulatory Guidance Summary/Targets
1. USP/EP Disintegration Test is recommended2. Test media: Must pass disintegration time in saliva
or water without chewing or drinking liquids3. Disintegration time: ODTs must disintegrate in less
than 30 seconds4. Tablet weight recommended: Not to exceed 500 mg.
Larger tablets may have an effect on patient safety and compliance, regulators say.– The extent of component solubility can influence the acceptability
of a larger tablet being labeled an ODT.
To fit within the Orally Disintegrating Tablet Classification
Deadline to submit comments to US FDA is June 8, 2007 13
Consumer PreferencesAPI should be…………..• Effective• Easy to Take• Quick Acting• Convenient to carry• Pleasant Tasting• Robust• Cost effective
“It is estimated that more than 50% of patients do not comply with dosing recommendations primarily due to: poor taste, difficulty in administration, or inconvenience”. www.eurand.com
MysteriesMysteriesCan Can ODTODT’’’’ss Deliver:Deliver:
Convenient to carryConvenient to carryEasy to take/ Fast MeltingEasy to take/ Fast MeltingQuick onset/less side effectsQuick onset/less side effectsPleasant TastePleasant TasteGreater StabilityGreater StabilityRobust TabletsRobust TabletsCost EffectiveCost Effective
Taste Masking• Taste vs Speed in ODTs
– If the product tastes bad, the consumer could care less about speed and may prefer the swallow tablet
– If a product tastes great the consumer may prefer the ODT over aconventional tablet solely based upon taste
• Poor taste can negate benefits of convenient dosing– Difficulty in administration (Pediatric and Geriatric patients)– General inconvenience (Need to find something to drink)
Taste Masking Systems
Particles small enough. Non-gritty. Not broken in compression.
Meet dissolution criteria.
• Approaches to reduce drug dissolution on unit dispersion in the mouth• pH modification• pH of minimum solubility
– Complexation/Partitioning• Ion-exchange Resins• Emulsions
– Coating/Microencapsulation• Coating must withstand tablet forming process
– Fracture of coatings– Provide control release profile– Conventional addition of flavours and masking agents
Pharmacaps
Pharmacaps
Pleasant Taste
Non Gritty – smooth!!
16
Tablet Requirements
– USP Disintegration <30s – Robust units of good appearance and can be
removed intact from blister pocket without significant residue
– Survive packaging into bottles < 1% friability– Acceptable physical and chemical stability
• ICH stability conditions • Requirements as for immediate release solid
oral dosage forms
17
Pharmaburst ®• Pharmaburst™ is a specially engineered excipient
system• Free flowing white powder• Made with pharmaceutical
monographed excipients• Smooth mouth feel• Rapid disintegration properties• Cost effective• In-house development on standard equipment• Can be manufactured at standard temperature and
humidity conditions
Optimization of Tablet Design!
Optimize tablet diameter to height for force distribution (4:1)(Tool Diameter Selection)
Same compressed tablet density for porosity (Targeted final tablet density)Same compression force per unit surface area
19
In Pharmaburst Design Space!
Chose Matrix of High Dose Actives for Design Challenge!
Tool Selection Guide
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
100 300 500 700 900 1100
Tab Wt., mg
Tool
Siz
e, m
m
Optimized around true density of Pharmaburst
And final tablet density targets..
Pharmaburst Design SpaceActives:• Pharmaburst
Evaluated:HardnessThicknessFriabilityODT disintegrationUSP disintegrationEjection Force
Challenge:< 30 sec USP disintegration<1% Friability> 5 kP hardness
21
Tablet Weight600, 900, 1200, 1500 mgForce/Area40, 60, 80 N/mm2
60 N / mm2 centers the compressed density
N/mm2mgUnits601050Center20450Scale Units00.512-0.511+-0.510--0.59+-8+0.57--60+50-4++30-0.52-+1
Force (KN)Weight (mg)Row
<0.000114.870.14472.1515Interaction (a x b)
<0.000143.780.09414.1193Force/Area (b)
<0.000128.850.12553.6197Tablet Weight (a)
<0.000199.570.07977.9348Intercept
Prob > tt RatioStd. ErrorEstimateTerm
Parameter Estimates
<.0001240.9014812C. Total
Prob > F0.07240.652019Error
1105.4280.0832240.249463Model
F-RatioMean SquareSum of SquaresDFSource
Analysis of Variance
13Observations
y = 3.6197 (a) + 4.1193 (b) + 2.1515 (a x b)^0.5 + 7.93488.643077Mean of Response
0.269158Root Mean Square Error
0.996391Rsquare Adj
0.997293Rsquare Placebo Fity = Hardness in kPa = Tab Weightb = F/A
Pharmaburst ®
5
10
15
20
25
30
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18
Hardness (kp)
USP
/EP
Dis
inte
grat
ion
(sec
)
24
Pharmaburst ®
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18
Hardness (kp)
Fria
bilit
y (%
)
25
Pharmaburst ®
• Lloyds LR 30K– Measures compressed
density– BFI (Brittle Fracture
Index)– SI (Strain Index)– BI (Bond Index)
Active Classification:
Actives for Matrix Challenge!• Aspirin
(Plastic with a low energy high strain distance displacement)
• Acetominophen(Elastic with higher energy recovery strength)
• Ibuprofen (Ductile with a high strain distance displacement)
Design with Actives!Actives:• Placebo• Ibuprofen • Paracetamol• Aspirin
Evaluated:HardnessThicknessFriabilityODT disintegrationUSP disintegrationEjection Force
Challenge:< 30 sec USP disintegration<1% Friability> 5 kP hardness
29
Amounts %: Tablet Weight100% : 600, 900, 1200, 1500 mg10, 25, 40 %: 500, 750, 1000 mg10, 25, 40 %: 600, 900, 1200 mg20, 30, 40 %: 300, 600, 900 mg
Experimental Design- Aspirin
Design for Wizard
2x2x2 Factrol2 level of API
10% and 40%2 level - tab. wt.
600 and 1200 mg2 levels for force per area
40 & 80 N/mm2
2 center points 25%, 900 mg, 40 N/mm2
2 center points around face area25%, 900 mg, 40 N/mm2 & 80 M/mm2
Active %
Tabl
et W
t, m
g
F/A, N/mm2
1200
600
80
40
10 %
40 %
+ -0
Design Prediction
Active Ingredient AspirinDesired Dose (mg) 250
Desired Tablet Weight (mg) 500Desired Tooling Diameter (mm) 11
Compression Force (KN) 7PositiveOutliers
Oral Disintgration Time 25.0 SecondsBP/USP (sec) 16.4 Seconds < 30 13.6Hardness (kp) 6.7 kP > 5 1.7Friability (%) 0.3 % < 0.5 0.2
Thickness (mm) 3.8 mmEjection (N) 115.2 Newtons < 100 -15.2
INPUT VARIABLES
OUTPUT RESULTS Targets
Not Stated
Tablet Wizard
Click Here To Launch
32
Experimental Design- ApAp
Active %
Tabl
et W
t, m
g
F/A, N/mm2
1200
600
80
40
10 %
40 %
+ -0
Design for Wizard
2x2x2 Factrol2 level of API
10% and 40%2 level - tab. wt.
600 and 1200 mg2 levels for force per area
40 & 80 N/mm2
2 center points 25%, 900 mg, 40 N/mm2
2 center points around face area25%, 900 mg, 40 N/mm2 & 80 M/mm2
6090025%Center2030015%Scale Units+0012-0011++-100009--+8-++7+++6-+-5+--4---3+-+20001
Force/AreaWeight (mg)[APAP], %Row
187-343.06.5605.117.013.51493500/65 mg Pharmaburst
plus Caffeine
19434541.05.9508.817211500500 mg Pharmaburst using APAP-E
18329550.95.1919.716201200325 mg Pharmaburst using APAP-E
9820300.74.5874.31410750160 mg Pharmaburst using APAP-E
8214290.73.5824.411737580 mg Pharmaburst using APAP-E
Acetaminophen
Tablet Wt. (m
g)
Diam
eter mm
Hardness (kP)
Thickness (mm
).
Friability (%).
OD
T (Sec)
USP/EP D
isint. (Sec).
Ejection Force (N).
Force (KN
).
Paracetamol Examples
Ibuprofen Examples
15823440.35.2678.21715.51400400 mg Pharmaburst Iubprofen
8816291.04.5334.1149700200 mg Pharmaburst Iubprofen
8517300.74.1885.11312500100 mg Pharmaburst Iubprofen
Ibuprofen
Tablet Wt. (m
g)
Diam
eter mm
Hardness (kP)
Thickness (mm
).
Friability (%).
OD
T (Sec)
USP/EP D
isint. (Sec).
Ejection Force (N).
Force (KN
).
ODTs Summary
• Can improve bioavailability for selected compounds• Can deliver topical activity• Can improve onset of therapeutic action• Can improve product stability through freeze-drying• Can improve compliance• Easy to swallow• Convenient to use • Unique dosage form• Preferred by patients to tablets• Provides patent-protected line extensions
PatentsCompany: SPI Pharma, Patent Application #: US 2003/0118642 A1, Technology:
“Pharmaburst”, Title: Co-processed carbohydrate system as a quick-dissolve matrix for solid dosage forms.
Company: Akina, Inc., Patent #: WO 2004/100857, Technology: “Frosta” Title: Highly Plastic Granules for Making Fast Melting Tablets
Company: Cima Labs, Inc., Patent: US 6,024,981 also WO/98/46215, plus continuation US 6,221,392 B1, Technology: DuraSolv and/or OraSolv, Title: Rapidly Dissolving Robust Dosage Form
Company: Therics, Inc., Patent #: US 6,471,992 B1, Technology: “Flash Dose”, Title: Dosage form exhibiting rapid Disperse properties, methods of use and process for the manufacture of same.
Company: Yamanouchi Pharmaceutical Co., Patent #: US 5,576,014, Technology: “Wowtabs”, Title: Intrabuccally dissolving moldings and production process thereof
Van Scoik KG. Solid Pharmaceutical Dosage in Tablet Triturate Form and Method of Producing the Same. US Patent No. 5,082,667 1992.
Masaki K. Intrabuccally-Disintegrating Preparation and Production Thereof. US Patent No. 5,466,464 1995.
Blank RG et al. Fast-Dissolving Dosage Forms. US Patent No. 4,946,684. 1990Hienemann H, Rothe W. Preparation of Porous Tablets. US Patent No. 3,885,026. 1975Roses BJ, Blair J. Rapidly Soluble Oral Dosage Forms, Methods of Masking the Same and
Compositions. US Patent No. 5,762,961. 1998Eurand International S.p.A. Fast-Disintegrating Tablets. US Patent No. 6,596,311. 2003Others