order in the matter of mishka finance and trading ltd

Upload: shyam-sunder

Post on 01-Jun-2018

230 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    1/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 1 of 68 

     WTM/RKA /ISD / 30 /2015

    SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA

    ORDER

    UNDER SECTIONS 11(1), 11(4) AND 11B OF THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE

    BOARD OF INDIA ACT, 1992 AND SECTION 12A OF THE SECURITIES

    CONTRACTS (REGULATION) ACT, 1956

    IN THE MATTER OF MISHKA FINANCE AND TRADING LIMITED

    1.  Pursuant to detection of a huge rise in the traded volume and price of the shares of Mishka

    Finance and Trading Limited {formerly known as Pyramid Finance and Trading Limited and

    hereinafter referred to as " Mishka "} on Bombay Stock Exchange Limited ("BSE") during the

    period from February 14, 2013 to December 31, 2014 (hereinafter referred to as

    "Examination Period"), Securities and Exchange Board of India ("SEBI") undertook

    preliminary inquiry in the dealings in the said scrip.

    2.  On January 16, 2014, pursuant to a stock split, the face value of shares of  Mishka   reduced

    from ₹10/- to ₹1/- per share. During the period from February 14, 2013 to February 14,

    2014 ("Patch I"), the price of the scrip of  Mishka opened at ₹5.50/, rose to a high of ₹499/-

    (unadjusted and ₹49.90/- adjusted to Share Split) and closed at ₹499/- (unadjusted and

    ₹49.90/- adjusted to Share Split) with an average volume of 390 shares. During the period

    February 17, 2014 to December 30, 2014 ("Patch II"), the price of the scrip moved between₹29.05/- to ₹57/- but the average volume in the scrip sharply jumped to 2,97,319 shares. An

    illustration of price/volume movement in the scrip of  Mishka  during the Examination Period

    is given below:

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    2/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 2 of 68 

    3.  It was noticed that trading in the scrip of  Mishka  was suspended from January 07, 2002 to

    May 09, 2012 on account of non-payment of listing fees. Prior to that, on September 30,

    2011, Mishka  had a total share capital of ₹49,80,000/- comprising 4,98,000 shares of ₹10/-

    each with a total of 7 shareholders (five promoters and two public). The five promoters, viz. 

    Embassy Finance and Consultants Pvt. Ltd., Sulab Impex Limited, Tohee Trading and Agencies Pvt. Ltd., Wave Inter Trade Pvt. Ltd. and Mr. Vijay Kumar Jain, and 2 other

    entities, viz.  Ms. Rashmi Jain and Mr. Ankit Jain sharing common address with Mr. Vijay

    Kumar Jain at 701, Arcadia Building, Nariman Point, Mumbai 400021, are  prima facie related

    to each other. The entire share capital of  Mishka  was in physical form as on September 30,

    2011. Thereafter, these 7 shareholders transferred 4,96,000 shares to 452 entities (hereinafter

    referred to as "Promoter related entities ") directly / indirectly in physical form during the period

    from December 11, 2011 to February 05, 2013. The list of all the Promoter related entities   is

    annexed as Part I of Annexure A. In the meantime, on September 24, 2012,  Mishka  made a

    preferential allotment of 7,93,700 shares at a premium of ₹75/- per share to 46 entities (List

    is annexed as Part II of Annexure A) including one promoter, viz. Pearl Arcade Trading

    Private Limited. These shares allotted by  Mishka   were under a compulsory lock-in till

    September 23, 2013. Thereafter,  Mishka  announced a bonus of 7 shares on every 1 share on

    February 06, 2013. As a result thereof, the share capital of  Mishka   increased to

    ₹10,33,36,000/- comprising 1,03,33,600 shares of ₹10/- each. Thereafter, on January 16,

    2014, Mishka  split its shares from ₹10/- per shares to ₹1/- per share. Consequent to these

    actions, the share capital of  Mishka  increased to 10,33,36,000 shares having the face value of

    ₹1/- each.

    4.  From the Annual Reports of Mishka  for Financial Year ("FY") 2011-12 and FY 2012-2013, it

     was observed that it is in the business of financing, investment and trading activities and it

    had incurred a loss of ₹12 Lakh during FY 2011-12 and earned a profit of ₹12 Lakh during

    FY 2012-13. Further, from the Annual Report of  Mishka   for FY 2012-2013, it is observed

    that for FY ended 2012 the earning per shares ("EPS") of  Mishka  was ₹-2.4/- and for the FY

    ended March 31, 2013, EPS was ₹0.12/-. During the Examination Period, no material

    corporate announcement was made by  Mishka   which could support such price rise in its

    scrip. Thus, the sharp rise in the price of the scrip of  Mishka  during the Examination Period was not supported by its fundamentals or any other genuine factor. It is interesting to note

    that the shares of  Mishka   were suspended till May 09, 2012. Between May 10, 2012 and

    September 23, 2012, there was no trading in the scrip of Mishka . Strangely, in spite of such

    trifling fundamentals and tarnished track record of long period of suspension of trading and

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    3/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 3 of 68 

    below par market price, Mishka  was able to garner funds aggregating to ₹6,74,64,500/- from

    aforesaid 46 entities through preferential allotment at a premium of ₹75/- per share within a

    short span of four months of revocation of suspension. Investment in a company having

    such poor and meagre fundamentals cannot  prima facie   be termed as a rational investment

    behaviour. Such investments, as in this case, normally could be made only if the allottees hada nexus with  Mishka   and its directors/promoters and the issue of these shares was under a

    prior arrangement between them.

    5.  It was observed that within a short period after the preferential allotment, a significant

    increase in the price of the scrip took place which continued during and after the period of

    lock in on the shares allotted to the preferential allotees. Considering the fact that prior to the

    preferential allotments, no trading occurred in the scrip of  Mishka , the increase in the traded

     volume in the period after preferential allotment was found to be substantial and abnormal.

    In light of the above, in order to observe the price volume behaviour of the scrip, the tradingin the scrip was analysed in two Patches with a focus on the following:-

     

     The trading frequency;

       The volume generated;

      Contribution to price rise;

      Buying behavior as observed from Last Traded Price ("LTP") data.

    6.  On analysis of trading activity in the scrip, it was observed that during the Examination

    Period, two sets /groups of entities were mainly involved. While one group of entities was

    primarily involved in pushing the price up during Patch-1 (when the volume in the scrip was

     very low) by contributing to positive LTP through first trades with negligible order quantity,

    the other group of entities was acting as buyer in Patch-2 in order to provide exit to

    preferential allottees/Promoter related entities  and in the process creating artificial volume. The

    role/connection/relationship of these two groups is discussed in subsequent paragraphs.

    Patch 1: February 14, 2013 to February 14, 2014:

    7.  During Patch 1 the scrip price opened at ₹5.50 and closed at ₹49.90/- (adjusted and ₹499/-

    unadjusted). During this period, the scrip was traded with an average volume of 390 sharesper day and total volume of 73,760 shares in 189 trading days with an average of 1 trade per

    day. It was observed that price of the scrip was influenced by certain entities primarily

    through first trades during this period. These entities merely by putting 1 or 2 trades per day

     with negligible/ very less quantity of buy order contributed significantly to the price rise.

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    4/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 4 of 68 

    From LTP analysis, it was observed that price of the scrip increased from ₹5.50 to ₹49.90

    (adjusted and ₹499/- unadjusted) mainly through first trades in 188 such instances.

    8.  It was observed that in Patch 1, out of a total of 188 instances of trades establishing new high

    price in the scrip, four entities namely, Shyam Kanheyalal Vyas, Bharat Bagri, ManjulabenSukhdev Pandya and Jayesh Narendra Kesharia, established new high price on 99 instances.

     The contribution of these four entities in establishing new high price was ₹251.61/- out of

    total price rise of ₹339/-, which constitutes 74.23% of the total new high price. The details of

    contribution to price rise by these four entities during Patch 1 are as under:

     Table I : Contribution to price rise in Patch 1 by four entities.

    PAN Name

    Name reflected

    in the InterimOrder

    PositiveLTP

    Contributionas a buyer

    % to Total

    Positive LTPContribution

     ACTPV2787Q Shyam Kanheyalal Vyas First Financial Ltd 235.46 69.46

     AADHB8488A Bharat Bagri BagriRadford, FirstFinancial Ltd 8.5 2.51

     AAEHJ1610D Jayesh NarendraKesharia Radford 5.25 1.55

     ALVPP7764JManjulaben SukhdevPandya Radford 2.4 0.71

     Total 251.61 74.23

    9. 

    It is observed that the entities named in the above Table were instrumental in contributing tothe price rise of the scrips of Radford Global Limited and First Financial Services Limited

    and are already restrained from dealing in securities market in whatsoever manner vide

    interim orders dated December 19, 2014 in the scrips of Radford Global Limited and First

    Financial Services Limited for contributing to price rise in the respective scrips.

    Patch 2: From February 17, 2014 to December 31, 2014:

    10. During Patch 2, the price of the scrip opened at ₹50.85/-, touched a high of ₹57/- and

    touched a low of and closed at₹

    29.05/-. However, the average volume in the scrip jumpedsharply from 390 shares (as it was in Patch 1) to 2,97,319 shares per day.

    11. On analysis of trading activity during Patch 2, certain related/connected entities to  Mishka

     were found to be net buyers to the preferential allottees / Promoter related entities  and thereby

    created artificial demand for the supply of shares from preferential allottees / Promoter related

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    5/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 5 of 68 

    entities. During Patch 2, significant increase in the trading volume was  observed and it appears

    that most of the entities were acting as counterparty to the Preferential Allottees/ Promoter

    related entities. Also on further examination direct/ indirect relationship was established among

    these entities through Know Your Client ("KYC") details, bank statements, off-market

    transactions amongst themselves, information available on the Ministry of Corporate Affairs("MCA") website, etc. List of these entities is annexed as Part III of Annexure - A and

    hereinafter they shall be referred to as the " Exit Providers ". Since the Exit Providers , Preferential

     Allottees and Promoter related entities have been  prima facie   found to be connected/related to

     Mishka / its promoters, they shall hereinafter collectively be referred to as " Mishka  Group".

    12. Considering the large number of related/connected entities of  Mishka  Group, a set of 112

    entities (hereinafter referred to as the "Shortlisted Group") were shortlisted on the basis of

    following parameters, viz.

     A. 

     All the Exit Providers ;B.  All the Preferential Allottees who have sold Mishka's shares and;

    C.  All the Promoter related entities who have sold more than 2,00,000 shares.

    13.  The particulars of the members of the Shortlisted Group are given in the following table :

     Table II: List of Shortlisted Entities:

    Promoter related entities

    S. No. PAN Name

    1 ABBPR3992G ANIL SATYANARAYAN ROONGTA2 ACRPC4740L RITESHKUMAR AMITKUMAR CHATTERJEE

    3 ACHPS7762G ATUL MORESHAWAR SAVE

    4 AKKPP3508Q PARUL RUPESH PODDAR

    5 AAOHS4973C SUNIL KUMAR JAIN & SONS HUF

    6 AAGHR7451A RAVI KHANNA HUF

    7 AAGPA3508D GAJANAND AGARWAL

    8 AACPA9922H PANKAJ AGARWAL

    9 AANPG3179K BHARAT GANDOTRA

    10 AJVPK5048G AADIST KHANNA

    11 ARIPK3181H BHAVYA KHANNA

    12 AAIPK5106B JYOTI KHANNA

    13 AFMPK8726N RAVI KHANNA

    14 ACNPA1462H LALIT AGARWAL

    15 AELPP0183N RUPESH KUMAR PODDAR

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    6/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 6 of 68 

    16 AAEHD5856M DINDAYAL MALCHAND AGARWAL HUF

    17 AACPA5733E KRISHAN AGARWAL

    18 ACRPJ3552D SEEMA JAIN

    19 BHKPS8506F JAY N SHAH

    20 ABYPJ9937E SUNIL KUMAR JAIN

    21 AAGPS9497R NAVINCHANDRA K SHAH

    22 AAGPS9498A MALTI NAVINCHANDRA SHAH

    23 AGLPP3159L ROHINI VIJAYSINGH PATWARDHAN

    24 BEIPA7823N PRANIT AGARWAL

    Preferential Allottees

    25  AEFPS6298M BRIJ BHUSHAN SINGAL

    26  AALFG1236F GOKULDHAM ENTERPRISES LLP

    27  AACPD7055J NITIN KUMAR DIDWANIA

    28  AAGPS6393C PRAKASH MANGILAL SURYA

    29  AAAPZ1721B SHRENIK NALIN ZAVERI30  AADPK9309F MAHESH KUMAR KHATRY

    31  AADPK1946Q PRAKASH CHAND KHATRY

    32  ADGPC1107P TARUN KUMAR CHANDAK

    33  ACAPS1025K KALAWATI SHARMA

    34  AGMPS2776H PRAKASH CHAND SHARMA

    35  ABYPV5751G CHIRAG MAHESHKUMAR VYAS

    36  AAAPU2596F SHEETAL SANJAY UDESHI

    37  ACUPJ1252F NARESH JALAN

    38 AABHN4403P NARESH JALAN

    39  ACFPJ2428J MAHABIR PRASAD JALAN

    40  AACHM0965N MAHABIR PRASAD JALAN

    41  AECPC7959J HARLEEN KAUR

    42  AEJPB6903J SAVITA BANSAL

    43  ABTPS0026N SMT RASHMI JAIN

    44  AAJPA2349H JIGNESH M. AMIN

    45  AADPJ5579L VIMAL JAIN

    46  AJGPS8091J SARAD KUMAR B JAIN

    47  AADPC6863A ASHOK KUMAR CHOWATIA

    48  ABQPL6153L TARACHAND L SHAH49  AADPC6859J MADANLAL BABULAL CHOWATIA

    50  ACSPB5838R SHANKAR BATRA

    51  ABHPA9244J SADHNA RANI

    52  AGEPA7936K RANIDEVI AGARWAL

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    7/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 7 of 68 

    53  AADHR3405B RAVINDER KUMAR GUPTA (HUF)

    Exit Providers  

    54 AAKPS3276J Manharlal Narottamdas Shah

    55 AAACE2862P Esha Securities Ltd

    56 AACCA3220D Amrit Sales Promotion Pvt Limited57 AADCS5411K Symphony Merchant Pvt Ltd

    58 AABCB3052B Bazigar Trading Private Limited

    59 AAGCR1715E Rangan Vincom Private Limited

    60 AACCL3868N Ladios Trading Private Limited

    61 AADCT8403C Topwell Properties Private Limited

    62 AAMCS1712Q Signet Vinimay Private Limited

    63 AAMCS1711P Sanklap Vincom P Ltd

    64 AAECR0580M Runicha Merchants Private Limited

    65 AAACW8004B Winall Vinimay Private Limited Ltd

    66 AAPCS7492G Spice Merchants Private Limited67 AAJCA4459K Apex Commotrade Private Limited Ltd

    68 AAICS0688K Skm Travels Private Limited

    69 AAICS6023N Scope Vyapar Private Limited

    70 AAACV8378B Vibgyor Financial Servicepvt Ltd

    71 AACCH4303G Helpful Investment Advisory Private Limited

    72 AABCF5486H Function Financial Consultants Private Limited

    73 AAECK7329P Kapeeshwar Vintrade Private Limited

    74 AAMCS8721P Sinjan Overseas Pvt Ltd

    75 AABCW0317N Wonder Procon Private Limited Wppl76 AACCH8885R Helot Properties Pvt Ltd

    77 AAECC9285A Cheroot Vanijya Pvt Ltd

    78 AATCS3687H Sidhiman Vyapaar Private Limited

    79 AAECV4988P Vishnudham Marketing Private Limited

    80 AAECT5548F Triala Dealers Private Limited

    81 AAICM4750C Mobixa Distributors Private Limited

    82 AALCA7880J Antaryami Traders Private Limited

    83 AAFCG2554B Gajgamini Merchandise Private Limited

    84 AAICM6982C Muchmore Vincom Private Limited85 AAECD5782B Dreamlight Exim Private Limited

    86 AAFCG4773J Goldensight Traders Private Limited87 AAACD9125E Dynamic Portfolio Management & Services Ltd

    88 AABCR1974J Ritesh Commercial Holdings Limited

    89 AADCR6224M Ritesh Projects Private Ltd.

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    8/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 8 of 68 

    90 AAECS0352C Stardox Vinimoy Private Limited

    91 AABCR3482R Raina Vyapaar Private Ltd

    92 AABCR2904A R C Suppliers Private Lim Ited

    93 AABCH2251E Hari Om Suppliers Pvt. Ltd.

    94 AADCK9346B Kalakar Commercial Private Limited

    95 AAFCB0211J Blue Horizon Commosales Private Limited

    96 AAGCR8142P Rochak Vinimay Private Limited

    97 AAGCR7017M Rochi Dealcom Private Limited

    98 AAECD9323N Duari Marketing Private Limited

    99 ACIPS8803M S N Srinivasan

    100 BABPS7447D Amit Singh

    101 AADCI5139E Indrawati Nirman Pvt Ltd

    102 AAGCR4662J Reachsmart Construction Pvt Ltd

    103 AABCO6950F Overload Financial Advisory Pvt Ltd

    104 AARCS9144H Sebika Commodities Private Limited

    105 AATCS4365E Samridhipurn Services Private Limited

    106 AAFCR9881C Reachsmart Dealtrade Private Limited

    107 AATCS6718D Swarnprakash Traders Private Limited

    108 AAECD8010E Dhyaneshwar Dealers Pvt Ltd

    109 AAECD8235D Dhlriti Traders Pvt Ltd

    110 AAGCR6009M Ramya Mercantile Pvt Ltd

    111 AAFCB4546A Badamisati Apartments Private Limited

    112 ATIPM7500N Arunavo Mukherjee

    14. It is observed that during Patch 2, the Preferential Allottees/Promoter related entities  were the

    net sellers and the Exit Providers were the net buyers, a snapshot of which is given below:-

     Table III - Exit provided by Exit Providers  to Preferential allottees/Promoter related entities  

    Category Sharessold

    % of Totalallottedshares

    Shares purchased from preferentialallottees/Promoter related

    entities

    % to ExitProviderGrossBought Volume

    GrosssharesBoughtby ExitProviders  

    Shares boughtby ExitProviders  as% to MarketBought

     Volume

    Preferential Allottee

    18921835 61.00% - - - -

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    9/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 9 of 68 

    Promoterrelatedentities

    31838149 93.76% - - - -

    Exit

    Provider

    - - 25476894 90.84% 28044592 46.47%

    15. 

    It is observed from Table III that most of the trades were taking place between the

    preferential allottees/Promoter related entities   and  Exit Providers . During this period, the

    Preferential allottees/Promoter related entities  were found to be selling and in the process

    making a huge profit/gain. It was observed that  Exit Providers   contributed 46.47% to the

    Gross buy trade during Patch 2. The details of counter parties for sale transactions by

    preferential allottees/ Promoter related entities   is given below: 

     Table - IV: Details of counter parties for sale transactions

    Sr.No.

    Client PAN Client Name GrossBuy inPatch 2

    % toMark et Volume

    Shares purchasedfrom preferentialallottes/PromtoerGroupentitiesduring post split period

    % ofsharesboughtfrom preferentialallottesto thegrossBuy bytheclient

    1 AAECD8235D Dhlriti Traders Pvt Ltd 8726858 14.46 8485818 97.24

    2 AAGCR6009M Ramya Mercantile Pvt Ltd 5376722 8.91 5290081 98.39

    3 AAPCS7492G Spice Merchants PrivateLimited

    2872178 4.76 2100797 73.14

    4 AAJCA4459K Apex CommotradePrivate Limited Ltd

    2249188 3.73 1961565 87.21

    5 AAACW8004B Winall Vinimay PrivateLimited Ltd

    1090076 1.81 976671 89.6

    6 AAECV4988P Vishnudham Marketing

    Private Limited

    666225 1.1 490025 73.55

    7 AAECD5782B Dreamlight Exim PrivateLimited

    579939 0.96 426525 73.55

    8 AAMCS1712Q Signet Vinimay PrivateLimited

    445464 0.74 361354 81.12

    9 AAFCG2554B Gajgamini MerchandisePrivate Limited

    408025 0.68 356151 87.29

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    10/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 10 of 68 

    10 AAECD9323N Duari Marketing PrivateLimited

    422360 0.7 347260 82.22

    11 AAECR0580M Runicha MerchantsPrivate Limited

    327650 0.54 204035 62.27

    12 AATCS3687H Sidhiman Vyapaar Private

    Limited

    328890 0.54 313840 95.42

    13 AAICS6023N Scope Vyapar PrivateLimited

    310000 0.51 310000 100

    14 AAACE2862P Esha Securities Ltd 295500 0.49 295500 100

    15 AALCA7880J Antaryami Traders PrivateLimited

    284385 0.47 260075 91.45

    16 AAECC9285A Cheroot Vanijya Pvt Ltd 284250 0.47 269250 94.72

    17 AAFCB4546A Badamisati ApartmentsPrivate Limited

    195000 0.32 181160 92.9

    18 AAECS0352C Stardox Vinimoy PrivateLimited

    180000 0.3 180000 100

    19 AABCO6950F Overload Financial Advisory Pvt Ltd

    174260 0.29 174260 100

    20 AABCR3482R Raina Vyapaar Private Ltd 166540 0.28 166540 100

    21 AAMCS1711P Sanklap Vincom P Ltd 151049 0.25 131049 86.76

    22 AACCH8885R Helot Properties Pvt Ltd 149650 0.25 128660 85.97

    23 AAICM4750C Mobixa DistributorsPrivate Limited

    137600 0.23 104250 75.76

    24 AAICM6982C Muchmore VincomPrivate Limited

    114400 0.19 104650 91.48

    25 BABPS7447D Amit Singh 114320 0.19 114320 100

    26 AAICS0688K Skm Travels PrivateLimited

    111000 0.18 110900 99.91

    27 AAGCR8142P Rochak Vinimay PrivateLimited

    109000 0.18 90150 82.71

    28 AAFCB0211J Blue HorizonCommosales Private Ltd

    102570 0.17 79780 77.78

    29 AABCF5486H Function FinancialConsultants PrivateLimited

    87300 0.14 53300 61.05

    30 AABCH2251E Hari Om Suppliers Pvt.Ltd.

    81500 0.14 81450 99.94

    31 ACIPS8803M S N Srinivasan 339000 0.56 296985 87.6132 AACCA3220D Amrit Sales Promotion

    Pvt Limited70000 0.12 60000 85.71

    33 AAACV8378B Vibgyor FinancialServicepvt Ltd

    70000 0.12 0 0

    34 AACCH4303G Helpful Investment Advisory Private Limited

    71663 0.12 71663 100

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    11/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 11 of 68 

    35 AAECT5548F Triala Dealers PrivateLimited

    70000 0.12 69800 99.71

    36 AADCR6224M Ritesh Projects PrivateLtd.

    72195 0.12 72195 100

    37 AAFCR9881C Reachsmart Dealtrade

    Private Limited

    57000 0.09 57000 100

    38 AAMCS8721P Sinjan Overseas Pvt Ltd 56000 0.09 56000 100

    39 AABCW0317N Wonder Procon PrivateLimited Wppl

    50000 0.08 50000 100

    40 AAGCR7017M Rochi Dealcom PrivateLimited

    52500 0.09 52500 100

    41 AABCR2904A R C Suppliers Private LimIted

    45000 0.07 45000 100

    42 AAFCG4773J Goldensight TradersPrivate Limited

    38000 0.06 5000 13.16

    43 AADCS5411K Symphony Merchant Pvt

    Ltd

    32500 0.05 32500 100

    44 AABCB3052B Bazigar Trading PrivateLimited

    29500 0.05 29500 100

    45 AAECD8010E Dhyaneshwar Dealers PvtLtd

    185500 0.31 165500 89.22

    46 AACCL3868N Ladios Trading PrivateLimited

    25000 0.04 25000 100

    47 AADCT8403C Topwell PropertiesPrivate Limited

    25000 0.04 25000 100

    48 AADCK9346B Kalakar CommercialPrivate Limited

    25000 0.04 25000 100

    49 ATIPM7500N Arunavo Mukherjee 20000 0.03 20000 10050 AARCS9144H Sebika Commodities

    Private Limited13785 0.02 13785 100

    51 AATCS6718D Swarnprakash TradersPrivate Limited

    15000 0.02 15000 100

    52 AAACD9125E Dynamic PortfolioManagement & ServicesLtd

    15955 0.03 15955 100

    53 AADCI5139E Indrawati Nirman Pvt Ltd 72000 0.12 72000 100

    54 AAKPS3276J Manharlal NarottamdasShah

    11650 0.02 11650 100

    55 AAGCR4662J Reachsmart ConstructionPvt Ltd

    9900 0.02 9900 100

    56 AABCR1974J Ritesh CommercialHoldings Limited

    11545 0.02 11545 100

    57 AAECK7329P Kapeeshwar VintradePrivate Limited

    11000 0.02 11000 100

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    12/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 12 of 68 

    58 AATCS4365E Samridhipurn ServicesPrivate Limited

    6000 0.01 6000 100

    59 AAGCR1715E Rangan Vincom PrivateLimited

    2000 0 2000 100

     Total 28044592 46.47 25476894 90.84

    16. It is observed that 29 preferential allottees made a collective profit of ₹91.87 crore on their

    total investment of ₹2.01 crore, a substantial return of approximately 4569% on their

    investment in a period of 27 months (including the lock in period). It is evident from the

    above analysis of trading in Patch 2 that the  Exit Providers  provided a hugely profitable exit to

    the Preferential allottees, who also were related directly/indirectly to  Mishka . The profit

    earned by the allottees during Patch 2 is given below:-

     Table V: Details of the trades carried out by allottees and profit calculation

    S.No.

    Name of Allottee

    PAN of Allottee

    No.ofShares Allotted

     Adjustment toBonusandShareSplit

     AdjustedPurchaseCost

    No. ofSharessold

     AverageSellingPrice

    ProfitMadeon SoldShares

    Sharesheld bytheentity

    1

    GOKULDHAMENTERPR ISES LLP

     AALFG1236F

    25000 2000000 1.0625 2000000 50.9599770176

    0

    2PRAKASHMANGILAL SURYA

     AAGPS6393C

    20000 1600000 1.0625 1306850 37.62 47777357

    293150

    3 JIGNESHM. AMIN

     AAJPA2349H

    11700 936000 1.0625 1066300 48.4550533906

    -130300

    4SHRENIKNALINZAVERI

     AAAPZ1721B

    12500 1000000 1.0625 1000000 52.7851717459

    0

    5MAHESHKUMARKHATRY

     AADPK 9309F

    12500 1000000 1.0625 1000000 54.9053833135

    0

    6 PRAKASHCHANDKHATRY

     AADPK 1946Q

    12500 1000000 1.0625 1000000 53.73 52664913

    0

    7

     TARUNKUMARCHANDAK

     ADGPC1107P

    12500 1000000 1.0625 1000000 49.6848619650

    0

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    13/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 13 of 68 

    8KALAWA TISHARMA

     ACAPS1025K

    12500 1000000 1.0625 1000000 47.4546384450

    0

    9PRAKASHCHAND

    SHARMA

     AGMPS2776H

    12500 1000000 1.0625 1000000 47.2046139608

    0

    10

    CHIRAGMAHESHKUMAR VYAS

     ABYPV 5751G

    12500 1000000 1.0625 1000000 46.1845119625

    0

    11

    NITINKUMARDIDWANI A

     AACPD7055J

    25000 2000000 1.0625 997385 39.5938430782

    1002615

    12SHEETALSANJAYUDESHI

     AAAPU2596F

    12500 1000000 1.0625 981850 52.1450145741

    18150

    13 VIMAL JAIN

     AADPJ5579L

    7500 600000 1.0625 600000 53.6031524600

    0

    14NARESH JALAN

     ACUPJ1252F

    12500 1000000 1.0625 592500 50.0529022944

    407500

    15NARESH JALAN

     AABHN4403P

    12500 1000000 1.0625 587500 50.1828859136

    412500

    16MAHABIRPRASAD JALAN

     ACFPJ2428J

    12500 1000000 1.0625 584000 54.2731071500

    416000

    17MAHABIRPRASAD

     JALAN

     AACHM

    0965N

    12500 1000000 1.0625 470000 54.89253007

    25

    530000

    18SHANKAR BATRA

     ACSPB5838R

    5000 400000 1.0625 400000 50.4119739502

    0

    19HARLEENKAUR

     AECPC7959J

    12500 1000000 1.0625 356950 55.1619310416

    643050

    20SAVITABANSAL

     AEJPB6903J

    12500 1000000 1.0625 314000 55.0516950775

    686000

    21SARADKUMAR B JAIN

     AJGPS8091J

    7500 600000 1.0625 312500 51.1315645969

    287500

    22

    SMT

    RASHMI JAIN

     ABTPS0026N 12500 1000000 1.0625 277500 55.07 14988106 722500

    23

     ASHOKKUMARCHOWATI A

     AADPC6863A

    7500 600000 1.0625 259500 51.5213092706

    340500

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    14/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 14 of 68 

    24 TARACHAND LSHAH

     ABQPL6153L

    7500 600000 1.0625 245500 52.6212657981

    354500

    25

    MADANL AL

    BABULALCHOWATI A

     AADPC

    6859J 7500 600000 1.0625 228500 51.38

    114967

    19 371500

    26BRIJBHUSHAN SINGAL

     AEFPS6298M

    49000 3920000 1.0625 120000 55.006472580.8

    3800000

    27SADHNARANI

     ABHPA9244J

    12500 1000000 1.0625 100000 55.205413750

    900000

    28

    RANIDEV I AGARWAL

     AGEPA7936K

    12500 1000000 1.0625 77000 48.743671437.5

    923000

    29RAVINDER KUMARGUPTA

     AADHR 3405B

    2000 160000 1.0625 44000 55.072376300

    116000

    17.  The transactions wherein the entities of  Exit Providers  bought most of the shares sold by the

    Preferential allottees and Promoter related entities cannot be just a coincidence particularly when

    sellers are connected with  Mishka / its promoters / directors by virtue of being Preferential

    allottees/ Promoter related entities  and other factors mentioned in Annexure A. It is interesting

    to note that prior to Patch 1, the entire share capital of  Mishka   was with Preferential

     Allottees, Promoters and the entities who received shares from the promoters. Hence, duringPatch 1 the entities related to Promoter Group sold the shares in very less quantity and

    certain entities pushed up the price of the scrip by buying these shares from them. It is also

    observed that during Patch 1 the shares of  Mishka   were not in demand by the general

    investors of the market and saw a very low volume on most of the trading days and hence

    could not have commanded the price as observed in Patch 2. In any market, a sudden supply,

    if not matched by similar demand, leads to price fall. Considering the same, any rational

    investor would not have dumped a large number of shares without facing the risk of a

    significant price fall until and unless he was sure of the demand side absorbing the supply. In

    this peculiar case, the  Exit Providers   created the demand against the supply from thepreferential allotters/Promoter related entities . In the whole process, the principle of price

    discovery was kept aside and the market lost its purpose. It is evident from the above analysis

    that the Exit Providers  provided a hugely profitable exit to the Preferential allottees/ Promoter

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    15/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 15 of 68 

    related entities . This could be possible only if the Preferential Allottees, Promoter related

    entities, Exit Providers , Mishka  and its promoter/ directors were hand in glove with each other.

    18. From the above examination and factors as described in Annexure A, I am of the  prima facie  

     view that the Preferential allottees, Promoter related entities ,  Mishka   and  Exit Providers   are

    connected to each other. In this regard, I note that the Hon'ble SAT has in many cases such

    as Classic Credit Ltd. vs. SEBI (SAT Appeal no. 68/2003, Order dated December 8, 2006),

    Classic Credit Ltd. vs. SEBI (SAT Appeal no. 76/ 2003, Order dated January 9, 2007) and

    Veronica Financial Services Ltd. vs. SEBI (SAT Order dated August 24, 2012) has held that

    connection/ relations can be established on the basis of factors including common addresses,

    common directors/ shareholders, etc.

    19. It is pertinent to mention that the key to the scheme of operations employed by  Mishka Group

     prima facie lies in the preferential allotment of shares made by Mishka . Due to a lock-in of one

    year on shares any gains made on the sale of such shares makes the allottees eligible for long

    term capital gains ("LTCG"). Further, the promoters of Mishka by offloading the shares to its

    connected entities in physical form one year prior to resumption of trading in the scrip, have

    also made the transferees eligible for LTCG. From the observations of the preliminary

    inquiry it is inter alia noted that :-

       As on September 30, 2011,  Mishka   had only 7 shareholders (5 under promoters and 2

    under public category).

       Thereafter, the aforesaid 7 shareholders transferred a total of 4,96,000 shares to 452

    entities directly/indirectly during the period from December 11, 2011 to February 05,

    2013.

      In the meantime,  Mishka   also allotted 7,93,700 shares to 46 related/ associated entities

    including 1 promoter, viz.  Pearl Arcade Trading Private Limited, at an exorbitant

    premium of ₹75/- per share on September 24, 2012.

     

     Then, on February 06, 2013,  Mishka   announced bonus shares in the ratio of 7:1. As a

    result, the share capital of Mishka increased to 1,03,33,600 shares.

       Thereafter, suddenly trading started in the scrip of  Mishka   from February 14, 2013. In

    Patch 1, i.e. from February 14, 2013 to February 14, 2014, the price of the scrip graduallyincreased from ₹5.50/- to ₹499/- (unadjusted) and ₹49.90/- (adjusted) with very low

     volume.

      Prior to February 14, 2013, the entire share capital of  Mishka  was with Promoters,

    Promoter related entities  and Preferential allottees.

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    16/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 16 of 68 

      Once the price of the scrip increased exponentially, Mishka  announced a stock-split in the

    ratio of 1:10 on January 16, 2014 to make a passage for preferential allottees to exit since

    the stock split would reduce the per share price and increase liquidity.

      One month after the stock split, i.e. from February 17, 2014 the preferential allottees and

     promoter related entities  started selling the shares to entities connected / related, directly orindirectly, to Mishka , thereby making huge profits.

       The said price movement was not backed by fundamentals of Mishka and its financials.

    20. From the facts stated above, it can safely be assumed that the entire modus operandi of allotting

    shares on a preferential basis at a premium, announcing a stock split and then bringing in

    connected entities to provide exit was a scheme devised to make ill-gotten gains. Further, the

    modus operandi of pumping the share price artificially and then dumping the price so that the

    same cycle could be repeated, demonstrates the mala fide   of the  Mishka Group.  Also the

    mechanism is presumably being used to deceive the authorities by laundering black money

    and making tax-free profits. 

    21. Further, from the copy of the special resolution passed under section 81(1A) of the

    Companies Act, 1956 submitted by Mishka to BSE, it is noted that Mishka  had disclosed to its

    shareholders that the purpose of aforesaid fund raising through preferential allotment was to

    meet requirements for:

    a) 

    capital expenditure including acquisition of company/business;

    b)  funding long term working capital requirements;

    c) 

    marketing;

    d)  setting up of offices abroad and;

    e)  for other approved corporate purposes.

    22.  As part of its inquiry, SEBI had advised the directors, Company Secretary and promoters of

     Mishka   vide emails/letters to appear for a meeting on December 05, 2014 and again on

    December 12, 2014 at SEBI-Head Office. On both instances, Mishka's  management failed to

    appear for the meeting. Thereafter, SEBI by way of an email as well as letter dated January

    16, 2015, advised  Mishka   to submit its bank account details highlighting the credit entries

    pertaining to proceeds of preferential allotment and debit entries pertaining to utilisation of

    preferential allotment along with documentary evidence. The said details were sought in order

    to ascertain the genuineness of the preferential allotment made by  Mishka . Mishka  vide letter

    dated January 22, 2015 submitted its reply. From the bank statement submitted by Mishka , it

    is observed that out of the total amount i.e. ₹6,74,64,500 raised by  Mishka   through this

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    17/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 17 of 68 

    allotment, ₹2,00,00,000 were given to the share broker CD Equisearch Pvt. Ltd, ₹2,21,21,221

    to Esha Securities Limited and ₹2,00,00,000 to one Mr. Jitendra Dewoolkar. This amounted

    to total ₹6,21,21,221 (almost 92% of the proceeds). The aforesaid utilisation of proceeds of

    preferential allotment does not appear to be for any of the aforesaid purposes as  Mishka  did

    not use them for either capital expenditure or acquisition of company/business or towards working capital or setting up office abroad or for marketing.

    23.  In view of the above, I note that the funds received as proceeds of preferential allotment

     were transferred to various entities and were not used for the purposes as envisaged in the

    special resolution passed under section 81(1A) of the Companies Act, 1956. Further, as per

    the communication received from BSE vide email dated January 21, 2015, no corporate

    announcement has been made by Mishka  as required under Clause 43 (a) of listing agreement

    indicating the non-utilisation of the proceeds from the preferential allotment for the purpose

    they were raised. Thus,  Mishka  has  prima facie   failed to comply with Clause 43 (a) of listingagreement which reads as follows:

    Clause 43 (a)

    "The Company agrees that it will furnish on a quarterly basis a statement to the Exchange indicating the

    variations between projected utilisation of funds and / or projected profitability statement made by it in its

     prospectus or letter of offer or object /s stated in the explanatory statement to the notice for the general

    meeting for considering preferential issue of securities and the actual utilisation of funds and/or actual

     profitability"

    24. In the facts and circumstances of this case, I am of the view that the preferential allotment

     was used as a tool for implementation of the dubious plan, device and artifice of  Exit

    Providers, preferential allottees and Promoter related entities . One could argue that in order to

    make LTCG, the preferential allottees in question could have bought in secondary market

    and waited for a year before selling the shares. In the instant case, probably the preferential

    allotment route was preferred over secondary market route because the share capital of

     Mishka  prior to preferential allotment was very small, i.e., 4,98,000 shares (Face Value: ₹10)

    to accommodate the required fictitious LTCG of₹

    254 crore approximately. As such thecapital expansion through preferential allotment and stock split provided much bigger source

    to the persons involved in terms of volume and price manipulation to facilitate the whole

    operation.

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    18/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 18 of 68 

    25. From the above facts and circumstances it can reasonably be inferred that the preferential

    allottees along with Promoter related entities acting in concert with  Exit Providers  have misused

    the stock exchange system to generate fictitious LTCG. It is pertinent to note that LTCG is

    tax exempt. Further, it appears that  Mishka   did not utilize the proceeds of preferential

    allotment as per the resolution submitted by it to the exchange. It is noted that SEBI hasalready passed interim orders in the matters of Moryo Industries Limited, Radford Global

    Limited and First Financial Services Limited where the modus operandi was that the price of the

    scrip increased substantially only on account of the trading activity of the group/related

    entities when substantial number of shares were locked in and non transferable/tradable.

    Further, the preferential allottees acting in concert with the specified groups have misused the

    stock exchange system to generate fictitious LTCG so as to convert their unaccounted

    income into accounted one with no payment of taxes as LTCG is tax exempt, and funds

    brought in by way of preferential allotment was invested in the shares of connected

    companies and by way of purported loans to a group of entities connected with the aforesaidcompanies for the purpose other than those disclosed.

    26. Since prior to the trading in its scrip during the Examination Period, Mishka  did not have any

    significant financial standing in the securities market, in my view, the only way it could have

    increased its share value is by way of market manipulation. In this case, it is noted that the

    traded volume and price of the scrip increased substantially only after  Exit Providers,

    Preferential Allottees and Promoter related entities started trading in the scrip. The average

     volume increased by 762% during Patch 2.  Exit Providers  were trading in the scrip above the

    LTP and their trades created artificial volumes and manipulated the price of the scrip during

    the Examination Period. It is further noted that on the days when  Mishka Group was not

    trading, the trading volumes in the scrip were very low and the substantial increase in traded

     volumes as observed in this case was mainly due to their trading. I further note that  Exit

    Providers, Preferential allottees and Promoter related entities traded amongst themselves as

    substantiated by their matching contribution to net buy and net sell in Patch II. There was no

    change in the beneficial ownership of the substantial number of traded shares as the buyers

    and sellers both were part of the common group and were acting in concert to provide

    LTCG benefits to the Preferential allottees and Promoter related entities. In view of the

    above, I prima facie find that Exit Providers, Preferential allottees and Promoter related entities used

    securities market system to artificially increase volume and price of the scrip for creating

    bogus non taxable profits (i.e. LTCG).

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    19/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 19 of 68 

    27. In addition to the above it is noted that prior to February 14, 2013, i.e. from when the trading

    in the scrip started, the entire share capital of  Mishka  was with the promoters, Promoter related

    entities and preferential allottees. During the period from February 14, 2013 to February 14,

    2014, the price of the scrip increased by around 100 times with the trading volume as meager

    as 390 shares per day. The trading volume suddenly increased to 2,97,319 shares per dayduring the period from February 17, 2014 to December 31, 2014, when  Exit Providers ,

    preferential allottees and Promoter related entities started trading in the scrip. The  prima facie  

    modus operandi  appears to be same as that used in the matter of Radford Global Limited where

    the stock exchange mechanism was used for the purpose of availing LTCG tax benefit and

     Mishka  was found actively involved in the whole design to misuse stock exchange mechanism

    to generate bogus LTCG.

    28. I am of the considered view that the scheme, plan, device and artifice employed in this case,

    apart from being a possible case of money laundering or tax evasion which could be seen bythe concerned law enforcement agencies separately, is  prima facie also a fraud in the securities

    market in as much as it involves manipulative transactions in securities and misuse of the

    securities market. The manipulation in the traded volume and price of the scrip by a group of

    connected entities has the potential to induce gullible and genuine investors to trade in the

    scrip and harm them. As such the acts and omissions of Exit Providers, Preferential allottees and

    Promoter related entities are ‘ fraudulent’ as defined under regulation 2(1)(c) of the SEBI

    (Prohibition of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices relating to Securities Market)

    Regulations, 2003 (‘PFUTP Regulations’) and are in contravention of the provisions of

    regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d) and 4(1), 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) thereof and section 12A(a),

    (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992. The said provisions are reproduced hereunder:-

    SEBI ACT

    Prohibition of manipulative and deceptive devices, insider trading and

    substantial acquisition of securities or control.

    "12A. No person shall directly or indirectly —  

    (a) use or employ, in connection with the issue, purchase or sale of any securities listed or proposed to be

    listed on a recognized stock exchange, any manipulative or deceptive device or contrivance in

    contravention of the provisions of this Act or the rules or the regulations made thereunder;

    (b) employ any device, scheme or artifice to defraud in connection with issue or dealing in securities which

    are listed or proposed to be listed on a recognised stock exchange;

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    20/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 20 of 68 

    (c) engage in any act, practice, course of business which operates or would operate as fraud or deceit upon

    any person, in connection with the issue, dealing in securities which are listed or proposed to be listed on a

    recognised stock exchange, in contravention of the provisions of this Act or the rules or the regulations

    made thereunder;"

    PFUTP REGULATIONS, 2003

    "Prohibition of certain dealings in securities

    3. No person shall directly or indirectly  —  

    (a) buy, sell or otherwise deal in securities in a fraudulent manner;

    (b) use or employ, in connection with issue, purchase or sale of any security listed or proposed to be listed

    in a recognized stock exchange, any manipulative or deceptive device or contrivance in contravention of the

     provisions of the Act or the rules or the regulations made there under;

    (c) employ any device, scheme or artifice to defraud in connection with dealing in or issue of securities

    which are listed or proposed to be listed on a recognized stock exchange;

    (d) engage in any act, practice, course of business which operates or would operate as fraud or deceit upon

    any person in connection with any dealing in or issue of securities which are listed or proposed to be listed

    on a recognized stock exchange in contravention of the provisions of the Act or the rules and the

    regulations made there under.

    4. Prohibition of manipulative, fraudulent and unfair trade practices

    (1) Without prejudice to the provisions of regulation 3, no person shall indulge in a fraudulent or an

    unfair trade practice in securities.

    (2) Dealing in securities shall be deemed to be a fraudulent or an unfair trade practice if it involves fraud

    and may include all or any of the following, namely:-

    (a) indulging in an act which creates false or misleading appearance of trading in the securities market;

    (b) dealing in a security not intended to effect transfer of beneficial ownership but intended to operate only

    as a device to inflate, depress or cause fluctuations in the price of such security for wrongful gain or

    avoidance of loss;

    (c)………………………………………………………………

    (d)…………………………………………………… ……………

    (e)any act or omission amounting to manipulation of the price of a security;(f)…………………………………………………… ……………….

    (g) entering into a transaction in securities without intention of performing it or without intention of

    change of ownership of such security; "

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    21/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 21 of 68 

    29. I note that the directors of Mishka during the relevant time (i.e. Ankit Garodia, Jugalkishore

    P Sharma, Kumar Vasishtha and Rameshwar Manohar Wagh), being in control of the day to

    day affairs of Mishka , had the knowledge of its acts and omissions. They were also under an

    obligation to ensure that acts and transactions of  Mishka  were not in violation of any of the

    applicable provisions of SEBI Regulations or other applicable laws. I, therefore,  prima faciefind that these directors as well as  Mishka  were responsible for  Mishka   's acts and omissions

    in this case.

    30. I am of the opinion that a detailed investigation of the entire scheme employed in this case is

    necessary to find out the role of any other entity therein including LTP contributors,

    connection amongst the concerned entities and the ultimate owners of funds used for

    manipulating the price of the scrip. Therefore, while SEBI would investigate into the

    probable violations of the securities laws, the matter may also be referred to other law

    enforcement agencies such as Income Tax Department, Enforcement Directorate andFinancial Intelligence Unit for necessary action at their end as may be deemed appropriate by

    them.

    31. SEBI strives to safeguard the interests of a genuine investor in the Indian securities market.

     The acts of artificially increasing the price of scrip mislead investors and the fundamental

    tenets of market integrity get violated. Under the facts and circumstances of this case, I  prima

     facie find that the acts and omissions of  Mishka Group as described above are inimical to the

    interests of participants in the securities market. Therefore, allowing the entities that are  prima

     facie found to be involved in such fraudulent, unfair and manipulative transactions to continueto operate in the market would shake the confidence of the investors in the securities market.

    32. I have considered the observations in the preliminary inquiry and noted that the shortlisted

    entities as mentioned in Table II are connected directly/indirectly with  Mishka / its promoters

    on account of factors described in Annexure A. The five promoters who were holding the

    shares in physical form had transferred their holding in off-market to certain entities as

    mentioned in Table II. Further, Mishka  also allotted shares under preferential allotment. Once

    the shares were allotted/ transferred to the preferential allottees/promoter related group,

    certain entities started moving the price of the scrip upwards by trading in very low volumes. The counter parties of these entities were those entities who received shares from the

    promoters in physical form. After lock-in of 1 year on preferential shares was over, the  Exit

    Providers  gave exit opportunity to the preferential allottees as well as promoter related entities.

    From the bank statement of Mishka , I find that  Mishka  has transferred funds to some of the

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    22/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 22 of 68 

     Exit Providers . I also note that the shortlisted entities have contributed majorly to the market

     volume both at buy and the sell side.

    33. Further I note that, vide Interim Orders dated December 19, 2014, Mr. Shyam Kanhaiyalal

     Vyas and Mr. Bharat Bagri have already been restrained from accessing securities market

    directly or indirectly in whatsoever manner in the matter of First Financial Services Limited

    and Mr. Bharat Bagri, Mr. Jayesh Narendra Kesharia and Ms. Manjulaben Sukhdev Pandya

    have already been restrained from accessing securities market directly or indirectly in

     whatsoever manner in the matter of Radford Global Limited for suspected price

    manipulation in the respective scrips. Further,  Mishka   Finance and Trading Limited, Spice

    Merchants Private Limited, Apex Commotrade Private Limited, Winall Vinimay Private

    Limited and Signet Vinimay Private Limited have also been restrained from accessing

    securities market directly or indirectly, in whatsoever manner, in the matter of Radford

    Global Limited for suspected volume manipulation and for giving exit opportunity topreferential allottees of Radford Global Limited.

    34. Based on the aforesaid findings and taking into consideration the similar modus operandi   of

    market manipulation adopted in similar matter of Radford Global Ltd, as observed by SEBI

    in its Order, it  prima facie   appears that certain market manipulations are taking place in the

    scrip of Mishka. I note that currently major portion of the shareholding (around 66.17%) lies

     with the preferential allottees, promoter related entities, exit providers  and the promoters of Mishka.

    It is also pertinent to mention that vide SEBI's Order in the matter of Radford Global Ltd,

    Mishka itself has been restrained from buying, selling or dealing in the securities market, tillfurther directions and the said restraint is in operation as on date. Considering the above, I

    am of the view that as an interim, preventive and remedial measure and to maintain orderly

    development in the securities market, in the interests of securities market and investors, it

     would also be necessary to take immediate steps regarding trading in the scrip of Mishka on

    the stock exchange.

    35. Considering these facts and the indulgence of a listed company in such a fraudulent scheme,

    plan, device and artifice as prima facie found in this case, I am convinced that this is a fit case

     where, pending investigation, effective and expeditious preventive and remedial action isrequired to be taken by way of ad interim ex -parte in order to protect the interests of investors

    and preserve the safety and integrity of the market.

    36. In view of the foregoing, in order to protect the interests of investors and the integrity of the

    securities market, I, in exercise of the powers conferred upon me in terms of section 19 read

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    23/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 23 of 68 

     with sections 11(1), 11(4) and 11B of the SEBI Act, 1992, pending inquiry/investigation and

    passing of final order in the matter, hereby issue the following directions:

    a)  Following persons/entities are restrained from accessing the securities market and

    buying, selling or dealing in securities, either directly or indirectly, in any manner, till

    further directions:-

    S. No. PAN Name

    1 AAACP2548R Mishka Finance and Trading Limited

    Mishka's Promoters

    2 AAACW0576A WAVE INTER TRADES PVT LTD

    3 AAACE1313P EMBASSY FINANCE & CONSULTANTS P LTD

    4 AAACT1354P TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIES PVT LTD

    5 AAICS7362Q SULABH IMPEX LTD

    6 AAFCP6925M PEARL ARCADE TRADING PRIVATE LIMITED

    7 AAAPJ3197K VIJAY KUMAR JAINMishka's Directors

    8 ARRPG4567A Ankit Garodia

    9 ABLPS6840A Jugalkishore Pralhadrai Sharma

    10 AKNPV5025B Amit Kumar Vasishtha

    11 ABLPW8901G Rameshwar Manohar Wagh

    Promoter related entities

    12 ABBPR3992G ANIL SATYANARAYAN ROONGTA

    13 ACRPC4740L RITESHKUMAR AMITKUMAR CHATTERJEE

    14 ACHPS7762G ATUL MORESHAWAR SAVE

    15 AKKPP3508Q PARUL RUPESH PODDAR

    16 AAOHS4973C SUNIL KUMAR JAIN & SONS HUF

    17 AAGHR7451A RAVI KHANNA HUF

    18 AAGPA3508D GAJANAND AGARWAL

    19 AACPA9922H PANKAJ AGARWAL

    20 AANPG3179K BHARAT GANDOTRA

    21 AJVPK5048G AADIST KHANNA

    22 ARIPK3181H BHAVYA KHANNA

    23 AAIPK5106B JYOTI KHANNA

    24 AFMPK8726N RAVI KHANNA

    25 ACNPA1462H LALIT AGARWAL

    26 AELPP0183N RUPESH KUMAR PODDAR27 AAEHD5856M DINDAYAL MALCHAND AGARWAL HUF

    28 AACPA5733E KRISHAN AGARWAL

    29 ACRPJ3552D SEEMA JAIN

    30 BHKPS8506F JAY N SHAH

    31 ABYPJ9937E SUNIL KUMAR JAIN

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    24/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 24 of 68 

    32 AAGPS9497R NAVINCHANDRA K SHAH

    33 AAGPS9498A MALTI NAVINCHANDRA SHAH

    34 AGLPP3159L ROHINI VIJAYSINGH PATWARDHAN

    35 BEIPA7823N PRANIT AGARWAL

    36 AABHA9528A ANIL SATYANARAYAN ROONGTA HUF

    Preferential Allottees 37 AEFPS6298M BRIJ BHUSHAN SINGAL

    38 AAAHB6923R BRIJ BHUSHAN SINGHAL (HUF)

    39 AALFG1236F GOKULDHAM ENTERPRISES LLP

    40 AACPD7055J NITIN KUMAR DIDWANIA

    41 AAGPS6393C PRAKASH MANGILAL SURYA

    42 AAAPZ1721B SHRENIK NALIN ZAVERI

    43 AADPK9309F MAHESH KUMAR KHATRY

    44 AADPK1946Q PRAKASH CHAND KHATRY

    45 ADGPC1107P TARUN KUMAR CHANDAK

    46 ACAPS1025K KALAWATI SHARMA47 AGMPS2776H PRAKASH CHAND SHARMA

    48 ABYPV5751G CHIRAG MAHESHKUMAR VYAS

    49 AAAPU2596F SHEETAL SANJAY UDESHI

    50 ACUPJ1252F NARESH JALAN

    51 AABHN4403P NARESH JALAN (HUF)

    52 ACFPJ2428J MAHABIR PRASAD JALAN

    53 AACHM0965N MAHABIR PRASAD JALAN (HUF)54 AECPC7959J HARLEEN KAUR

    55 AEJPB6903J SAVITA BANSAL

    56 ABTPS0026N SMT RASHMI JAIN

    57 AAJPA2349H JIGNESH M. AMIN

    58 AADPJ5579L VIMAL JAIN

    59 AJGPS8091J SARAD KUMAR B JAIN

    60 AADPC6863A ASHOK KUMAR CHOWATIA

    61 ABQPL6153L TARACHAND L SHAH

    62 AADPC6859J MADANLAL BABULAL CHOWATIA

    63 ACSPB5838R SHANKAR BATRA

    64 ABHPA9244J SADHNA RANI

    65 AGEPA7936K RANIDEVI AGARWAL

    66 AADHR3405B RAVINDER KUMAR GUPTA (HUF)

    Exit Providers 67 AAKPS3276J Manharlal Narottamdas Shah

    68 AAACE2862P Esha Securities Ltd

    69 AACCA3220D Amrit Sales Promotion Pvt Limited

    70 AADCS5411K Symphony Merchant Pvt Ltd

    71 AABCB3052B Bazigar Trading Private Limited

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    25/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 25 of 68 

    72 AAGCR1715E Rangan Vincom Private Limited

    73 AACCL3868N Ladios Trading Private Limited

    74 AADCT8403C Topwell Properties Private Limited

    75 AAMCS1712Q Signet Vinimay Private Limited

    76 AAMCS1711P Sanklap Vincom P Ltd

    77 AAECR0580M Runicha Merchants Private Limited78 AAACW8004B Winall Vinimay Private Limited Ltd

    79 AAPCS7492G Spice Merchants Private Limited

    80 AAJCA4459K Apex Commotrade Private Limited Ltd

    81 AAICS0688K Skm Travels Private Limited

    82 AAICS6023N Scope Vyapar Private Limited

    83 AAACV8378B Vibgyor Financial Servicepvt Ltd

    84 AACCH4303G Helpful Investment Advisory Private Limited

    85 AABCF5486H Function Financial Consultants Private Limited

    86 AAECK7329P Kapeeshwar Vintrade Private Limited

    87 AAMCS8721P Sinjan Overseas Pvt Ltd88 AABCW0317N Wonder Procon Private Limited Wppl

    89 AACCH8885R Helot Properties Pvt Ltd

    90 AAECC9285A Cheroot Vanijya Pvt Ltd

    91 AATCS3687H Sidhiman Vyapaar Private Limited

    92 AAECV4988P Vishnudham Marketing Private Limited

    93 AAECT5548F Triala Dealers Private Limited

    94 AAICM4750C Mobixa Distributors Private Limited

    95 AALCA7880J Antaryami Traders Private Limited

    96 AAFCG2554B Gajgamini Merchandise Private Limited

    97 AAICM6982C Muchmore Vincom Private Limited98 AAECD5782B Dreamlight Exim Private Limited

    99 AAFCG4773J Goldensight Traders Private Limited

    100 AAACD9125E Dynamic Portfolio Management & Services Ltd

    101 AABCR1974J Ritesh Commercial Holdings Limited

    102 AADCR6224M Ritesh Projects Private Ltd.

    103 AAECS0352C Stardox Vinimoy Private Limited

    104 AABCR3482R Raina Vyapaar Private Ltd

    105 AABCR2904A R C Suppliers Private Lim Ited

    106 AABCH2251E Hari Om Suppliers Pvt. Ltd.

    107 AADCK9346B Kalakar Commercial Private Limited

    108 AAFCB0211J Blue Horizon Commosales Private Limited

    109 AAGCR8142P Rochak Vinimay Private Limited

    110 AAGCR7017M Rochi Dealcom Private Limited

    111 AAECD9323N Duari Marketing Private Limited

    112 ACIPS8803M S N Srinivasan

    113 BABPS7447D Amit Singh

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    26/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 26 of 68 

    114 AADCI5139E Indrawati Nirman Pvt Ltd

    115 AAGCR4662J Reachsmart Construction Pvt Ltd

    116 AABCO6950F Overload Financial Advisory Pvt Ltd

    117 AARCS9144H Sebika Commodities Private Limited

    118 AATCS4365E Samridhipurn Services Private Limited

    119 AAFCR9881C Reachsmart Dealtrade Private Limited120 AATCS6718D Swarnprakash Traders Private Limited

    121 AAECD8010E Dhyaneshwar Dealers Pvt Ltd

    122 AAECD8235D Dhlriti Traders Pvt Ltd

    123 AAGCR6009M Ramya Mercantile Pvt Ltd

    124 AAFCB4546A Badamisati Apartments Private Limited

    125 ATIPM7500N Arunavo Mukherjee

    LTP Contributors

    126 ACTPV2787Q Shyam Kanheyalal Vyas

    127 AADHB8488A Bharat Bagri (HUF)

    128 AAEHJ1610D Jayesh Narendra Kesharia (HUF)129 ALVPP7764J Manjulaben Sukhdev Pandya

    b)   Trading in the securities of Mishka Finance and Trading Limited shall be suspended

    till further directions.

    37.  This order shall come into force with immediate effect. The stock exchanges and the

    depositories are directed to ensure that all the above directions are strictly enforced.

    38.  This order is without prejudice to the right of SEBI to take any other action that may be

    initiated against the aforementioned entities in accordance with law. The persons/entities

    against whom this order is passed may file their objections, if any, within twenty one days

    from the date of this order and, if they so desire, avail themselves of an opportunity of

    personal hearing before SEBI, on a date and time to be fixed on a specific request, received

    from the said persons/entities.

    Sd/-

    Date: April 17th, 2015 RAJEEV KUMAR AGARWAL 

    Place: Mumbai WHOLE TIME MEMBER  

    SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    27/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 27 of 68 

     Annexure - A

    Company Directors and its Promoter

    S.No.

    PAN Name Relationship

    1 AAACP2548R Mishka Finance and Trading Limited

    Mishka Finance Ltd ( Bank of Baroda: A/c No: 12920200000506 ) transferred funds to Pine Animation Ltd ( Allahbad Bank: A/c No:50103075412 ) who also has fund transaction withBlue Circle Services Ltd, who is observed to havefund transactions with Amrit Sales Promotion Pvt.Ltd.(HDFC Bank-A/c No: 00080340006392 ) .

    2 AAACW0576A WAVE INTER TRADES PVT LTD

    Promoter of Mishka as per share holding patternfor September 2011.

    3 AAACE1313P EMBASSYFINANCE &

    CONSULTANTS PLTD

    Promoter of Mishka as per share holding patternfor September 2011.

    4 AAACT1354P TOHEE TRADING& AGENCIES PVTLTD

    Promoter of Mishka as per share holding patternfor September 2011.

    5 AAICS7362Q SULABH IMPEXLTD

    Promoter of Mishka as per share holding patternfor September 2011.

    6 AAFCP6925M PEARL ARCADE TRADINGPRIVATE LIMITED

    Promoter of Mishka as per Shareholding patternfor September 2012.

    7 AAAPJ3197K VIJAY KUMAR

     JAIN

    Promoter of Mishka as per share holding pattern

    for September 2011.8 AAGPJ3942C ANKIT JAIN Share Common Address with Mr. Vijay Kumar

     Jain.

    9 AAGPJ3943D RASHMI JAIN Share Common Address with Mr. Vijay Kumar Jain.

    Part I-Promoter related entities

    S.No.

    PAN Name Relationship

    10 AEPPS9885J ANJALI ATUL SAVE ANJALI ATUL SAVE received shares in physical

    form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    11 ACHPS7762G ATULMORESHAWARSAVE

     ATUL MORESHAWAR SAVE received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    28/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 28 of 68 

    12 ATLPM3500D CHANCHALMUNDHRA

    CHANCHAL MUNDHRA received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    13 AAEHD5856M

    DINDAYALMALCHAND

     AGARWAL HUF

    DINDAYAL MALCHAND AGARWAL HUFreceived shares in physical form from EMBASSY

    FINANCE & CONSULTANTS P LTD14 ABMPM7213N JAGDISH PRASAD

    MUNDHRA JAGDISH PRASAD MUNDHRA received sharesin physical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    15 AAHHM8275N

     JAGDISH PRASADMUNDHRA HUF

     JAGDISH PRASAD MUNDHRA HUF receivedshares in physical form from EMBASSYFINANCE & CONSULTANTS P LTD

    16 AECPC0899M JITENDRAHIRALALCHHATRISHA

     JITENDRA HIRALAL CHHATRISHA receivedshares in physical form from EMBASSYFINANCE & CONSULTANTS P LTD

    17 AAIHK2913E KAILASH S

    PARASRAMPURIAHUF

    KAILASH S PARASRAMPURIA HUF received

    shares in physical form from EMBASSYFINANCE & CONSULTANTS P LTD

    18 ACNPA1462H LALIT AGARWAL LALIT AGARWAL received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    19 AAAPW9319A MEGHA RAVI WATTAMWAR

    MEGHA RAVI WATTAMWAR received sharesin physical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    20 CBRPK3025K NIDHI N KEDIA NIDHI N KEDIA received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &

    CONSULTANTS P LTD21 AACHN4765M

    NIRMAL KUMAR VARUN KUMARHUF

    NIRMAL KUMAR VARUN KUMAR HUFreceived shares in physical form from EMBASSYFINANCE & CONSULTANTS P LTD

    22 ACQPM1847D NIRMALA DEVIMUNDRA

    NIRMALA DEVI MUNDRA received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    23 AHPPK4767L NITIN S KEDIA NITIN S KEDIA received shares in physical formfrom EMBASSY FINANCE & CONSULTANTSP LTD

    24 AIDPC8188J PAVAN JITENDRA

    CHHATRISHA

    PAVAN JITENDRA CHHATRISHA received

    shares in physical form from EMBASSYFINANCE & CONSULTANTS P LTD

    25 AGLPP9975C PRAMOD KPARASRAMPURIA

    PRAMOD K PARASRAMPURIA received sharesin physical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    29/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 29 of 68 

    26 BEIPA7823N PRANIT AGARWAL PRANIT AGARWAL received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    27 ADUPC7841C PRASHANT JITENDRA

    CHHATRISHA

    PRASHANT JITENDRA CHHATRISHAreceived shares in physical form from EMBASSY

    FINANCE & CONSULTANTS P LTD28 AALHR3103E RAVI B

     WATTAMWAR HUFRAVI B WATTAMWAR HUF received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    29 AACPW5728R RAVI BHASKAR WATTAMWAR

    RAVI BHASKAR WATTAMWAR receivedshares in physical form from EMBASSYFINANCE & CONSULTANTS P LTD

    30 ACRPC4740L RITESHKUMAR AMITKUMARCHATTERJEE

    RITESHKUMAR AMITKUMARCHATTERJEE received shares in physical formfrom EMBASSY FINANCE & CONSULTANTSP LTD

    31 AJRPP8338A RITU PPARASREAMPURIA

    RITU P PARASREAMPURIA received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    32 AJQPP3219D SEEMA PPARASRAMPURIA

    SEEMA P PARASRAMPURIA received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    33 AFGPC0469L TRIPTI PCHATTERJEE

     TRIPTI P CHATTERJEE received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    34 ATMPK6409J VEDANSHU N

    KEDIA

     VEDANSHU N KEDIA received shares in

    physical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    35 AABPA6690F AJAY AGARWAL AJAY AGARWAL received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    36 AALHA0585K AJAY AGARWALHUF

     AJAY AGARWAL HUF received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    37 AGSPK0865D ASHISH KUMAR ASHISH KUMAR received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    38 AMCPS6985L BASANT KUMARSARAWGI

    BASANT KUMAR SARAWGI received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    39 AACCG5437G GOLCHHAENTERTAINMENTPVT LTD

    GOLCHHA ENTERTAINMENT PVT LTDreceived shares in physical form from EMBASSYFINANCE & CONSULTANTS P LTD

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    30/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 30 of 68 

    40 AKGPG2899H HITESH GOLCHHA HITESH GOLCHHA received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    41 AAVPN4041M M NAVEEN KUMAR M NAVEEN KUMAR received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &

    CONSULTANTS P LTD42 ACDPJ5852G MITTALAL JAIN MITTALAL JAIN received shares in physical

    form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    43 AAHPB4095P RITU S SARAF RITU S SARAF received shares in physical formfrom EMBASSY FINANCE & CONSULTANTSP LTD

    44 ANQPS5905F SANDEEP V SARAF SANDEEP V SARAF received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    45 ACRPJ3552D SEEMA JAIN SEEMA JAIN received shares in physical formfrom EMBASSY FINANCE & CONSULTANTSP LTD

    46 ACVPA2214M SHALU AGARWAL SHALU AGARWAL received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    47 AJJPS0924R SHANTHA KUMARIM

    SHANTHA KUMARI M received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    48 AATPJ6081F ABHAY KUMAR JAIN

     ABHAY KUMAR JAIN received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &

    CONSULTANTS P LTD49 AACHA9181N ASHOK KUMAR

    REDH HUF ASHOK KUMAR REDH HUF received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    50 AABPP6520D MAHENDRAPARAKH

    MAHENDRA PARAKH received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    51 ALQPS1421G MAMTA SARAOGI MAMTA SARAOGI received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    52 AFGPJ7251R MANJU JAIN MANJU JAIN received shares in physical formfrom EMBASSY FINANCE & CONSULTANTSP LTD

    53 ALDPS1562M MANOJ KUMARSARAOGI

    MANOJ KUMAR SARAOGI received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    31/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 31 of 68 

    54 ABEPJ7147G MOOLCHAND JAIN MOOLCHAND JAIN received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    55 AYOPA2382B NIKUNJ S AGARWAL

    NIKUNJ S AGARWAL received shares inphysical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &

    CONSULTANTS P LTD56 ADCPJ9848A PUSHPADEVI JAIN PUSHPADEVI JAIN received shares in physical

    form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    57 ACWPM0498C PUSHPADEVI JAIN PUSHPADEVI JAIN received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    58 AIQPJ7756E RASHMI JAIN RASHMI JAIN received shares in physical formfrom EMBASSY FINANCE & CONSULTANTSP LTD

    59 AAXHS4963F SANDEEP REDH

    HUF

    SANDEEP REDH HUF received shares in

    physical form from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    60 ACOPJ2654F SAROJ JAIN SAROJ JAIN received shares in physical formfrom EMBASSY FINANCE & CONSULTANTSP LTD

    61 AGBPJ8881F SUNAYANA JAIN SUNAYANA JAIN received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    62 ARAPJ5108K SWETA JAIN SWETA JAIN received shares in physical formfrom EMBASSY FINANCE & CONSULTANTSP LTD

    63 AFOPJ4431P VIKAS JAIN VIKAS JAIN received shares in physical formfrom EMBASSY FINANCE & CONSULTANTSP LTD

    64 AJVPK5048G AADIST KHANNA AADIST KHANNA received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    65 AAIPK5106B JYOTI KHANNA JYOTI KHANNA received shares in physicalform from EMBASSY FINANCE &CONSULTANTS P LTD

    66 AFMPK8726N RAVI KHANNA RAVI KHANNA received shares in physical formfrom EMBASSY FINANCE & CONSULTANTSP LTD

    67 AZAPG1972C TEJAS GALA TEJAS GALA received shares in physical formfrom TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIES PVTLTD

    68 AAMPM6353N

    KHYATI SHAH KHYATI SHAH received shares in physical formfrom TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIES PVT

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    32/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 32 of 68 

    LTD

    69 AAAPS5162P SACHIN V SHAH SACHIN V SHAH received shares in physicalform from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIESPVT LTD

    70 AAXPM9091Q DAYANAND

     ASSARAM MODANI

    DAYANAND ASSARAM MODANI received

    shares in physical form from TOHEE TRADING& AGENCIES PVT LTD

    71 AADPB1550B KAUSHALKANHAYALALBAGADIA

    KAUSHAL KANHAYALAL BAGADIAreceived shares in physical form from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIES PVT LTD

    72 AGOPP6473A MADHU GOPALPODDAR

    MADHU GOPAL PODDAR received shares inphysical form from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIES PVT LTD

    73 AAEPS7956D POONAMKAUSHALBAGADIA

    POONAM KAUSHAL BAGADIA receivedshares in physical form from TOHEE TRADING& AGENCIES PVT LTD

    74 BDNPS6529M PRAMILA SURESHSARDA

    PRAMILA SURESH SARDA received shares inphysical form from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIES PVT LTD

    75 ABFPM2698Q PREMLATARAMANANDMODANI

    PREMLATA RAMANAND MODANI receivedshares in physical form from TOHEE TRADING& AGENCIES PVT LTD

    76 AFYPM3247A RAKESHSHASHIKANTMEHTA

    RAKESH SHASHIKANT MEHTA receivedshares in physical form from TOHEE TRADING& AGENCIES PVT LTD

    77 ABEPM0793M RAMANAND

    GANESHLALJIMODANI

    RAMANAND GANESHLALJI MODANI

    received shares in physical form from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIES PVT LTD

    78 AABPM7263N SONAL RAKESHMEHTA

    SONAL RAKESH MEHTA received shares inphysical form from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIES PVT LTD

    79 AYPPS3019L SURESHGIRDHARILALSARDA

    SURESH GIRDHARILAL SARDA receivedshares in physical form from TOHEE TRADING& AGENCIES PVT LTD

    80 ADAPT3696A MEGHNASANJAYKUMAR TIBREWAL

    MEGHNA SANJAYKUMAR TIBREWALreceived shares in physical form from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIES PVT LTD

    81 AAUPT1451A SANJAYKUMARSAJJANKUMAR TIBREWAL

    SANJAYKUMAR SAJJANKUMAR TIBREWALreceived shares in physical form from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIES PVT LTD

    82 AAAPG9125E GOPALDASGOENKA

    GOPALDAS GOENKA received shares inphysical form from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIES PVT LTD

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    33/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 33 of 68 

    83 AAVPG4863E KESHAV GOENKA KESHAV GOENKA received shares in physicalform from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIESPVT LTD

    84 AADPG1423E SUDHA GOENKA SUDHA GOENKA received shares in physicalform from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIES

    PVT LTD85 AIUPR9150N ANAND RANEJA ANAND RANEJA received shares in physicalform from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIESPVT LTD

    86 AFOPR0263B HEMRAJ RANEJA HEMRAJ RANEJA received shares in physicalform from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIESPVT LTD

    87 BNNPK9250R KAVITA RANEJA KAVITA RANEJA received shares in physicalform from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIESPVT LTD

    88 AACPA9922H PANKAJ AGARWAL PANKAJ AGARWAL received shares in physicalform from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIESPVT LTD

    89 BHKPS8506F JAY N SHAH JAY N SHAH received shares in physical formfrom TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIES PVTLTD

    90 AAGPS9498A MALTINAVINCHANDRASHAH

    MALTI NAVINCHANDRA SHAH receivedshares in physical form from TOHEE TRADING& AGENCIES PVT LTD

    91 AAGPS9497R NAVINCHANDRA KSHAH

    NAVINCHANDRA K SHAH received shares inphysical form from TOHEE TRADING & AGENCIES PVT LTD

    92 AGGPP5739B ANSHUPRAKASHCHANDR  A PODDAR

     ANSHU PRAKASHCHANDRA PODDARreceived shares in physical form from WAVEINTER TRADES PVT LTD

    93 AAAHB0041C BALKISHAN JAJUHUF

    BALKISHAN JAJU HUF received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADESPVT LTD

    94 AABPJ5859P BALKISHANNATHMAL JAJU

    BALKISHAN NATHMAL JAJU received sharesin physical form from WAVE INTER TRADESPVT LTD

    95 ASLPA3561D GAURAV SANJAY AGARWAL

    GAURAV SANJAY AGARWAL received sharesin physical form from WAVE INTER TRADES

    PVT LTD96 AAJPJ4245M KANTABALKISHAN JAJU

    KANTA BALKISHAN JAJU received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADESPVT LTD

    97 APNPJ3353H KASTURI SANJAY JOSHI

    KASTURI SANJAY JOSHI received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADESPVT LTD

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    34/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 34 of 68 

    98 AKWPJ4412F KETKI SANJAY JOSHI

    KETKI SANJAY JOSHI received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADESPVT LTD

    99 AHGPJ3412J NIDHI ALKESHRAWKA

    NIDHI ALKESH RAWKA received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADES

    PVT LTD100 ASFPK9445C NIPUN N KEDIA NIPUN N KEDIA received shares in physicalform from WAVE INTER TRADES PVT LTD

    101 AKKPP3508Q PARUL RUPESHPODDAR

    PARUL RUPESH PODDAR received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADESPVT LTD

    102 AAUPK7874L PRABHA B KEDIA PRABHA B KEDIA received shares in physicalform from WAVE INTER TRADES PVT LTD

    103 ABEPA0559R RANJANA MANISH AGARWAL

    RANJANA MANISH AGARWAL receivedshares in physical form from WAVE INTER TRADES PVT LTD

    104 AGLPP3159L ROHINI VIJAYSINGHPATWARDHAN

    ROHINI VIJAYSINGH PATWARDHANreceived shares in physical form from WAVEINTER TRADES PVT LTD

    105 AELPP0183N RUPESH KUMARPODDAR

    RUPESH KUMAR PODDAR received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADESPVT LTD

    106 ABGPJ9472Q SANJAY AMBADAS JOSHI

    SANJAY AMBADAS JOSHI received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADESPVT LTD

    107 AJUPK3727B SHALINI NIRMALKEDIA

    SHALINI NIRMAL KEDIA received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADES

    PVT LTD108 AGLPP8828J VIJAYSINGHMADHAVRAOPATWARDHAN

     VIJAYSINGH MADHAVRAOPATWARDHAN received shares in physical formfrom WAVE INTER TRADES PVT LTD

    109 AAAHV1190E VIJAYSINGHPATWARDHANHUF

     VIJAYSINGH PATWARDHAN HUF receivedshares in physical form from WAVE INTER TRADES PVT LTD

    110 ABGPJ9502P VINITA SANJAY JOSHI

     VINITA SANJAY JOSHI received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADESPVT LTD

    111 AAAPD4655J BHARAT

    BHAWARLALDAGLIYA

    BHARAT BHAWARLAL DAGLIYA received

    shares in physical form from WAVE INTER TRADES PVT LTD

    112 AWAPS4811P DHAWAL C SHAH DHAWAL C SHAH received shares in physicalform from WAVE INTER TRADES PVT LTD

    113 AFHPP7452H JULIE VINODPARMAR

     JULIE VINOD PARMAR received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADESPVT LTD

    Brought to you by http://StockViz.biz

  • 8/9/2019 Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.

    35/68

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Order in the matter of Mishka Finance and Trading Ltd.  Page 35 of 68 

    114 AAAPD4654K LALITA BHARATDAGLIYA

    LALITA BHARAT DAGLIYA received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADESPVT LTD

    115 AABPP6339E MANGIBAI HPARMAR

    MANGIBAI H PARMAR received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADES

    PVT LTD116 AABPJ5807D REKHA RAKESH JAIN

    REKHA RAKESH JAIN received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADESPVT LTD

    117 AFHPP7451E SHARDA KPARMAR

    SHARDA K PARMAR received shares in physicalform from WAVE INTER TRADES PVT LTD

    118 AFHPP7450F VINOD HASTIMALPARMAR

     VINOD HASTIMAL PARMAR received sharesin physical form from WAVE INTER TRADESPVT LTD

    119 AFIPP6863R ABHISEK KUMARPODDAR

     ABHISEK KUMAR PODDAR received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADES

    PVT LTD120 ABEPA0558Q ARCHANA SANJAY

     AGARWAL ARCHANA SANJAY AGARWAL receivedshares in physical form from WAVE INTER TRADES PVT LTD

    121 AFEPP5775J ASHISH KUMARPODDAR

     ASHISH KUMAR PODDAR received shares inphysical form from WAVE INTER TRADESPVT LTD

    122 AOZPB0748K KAVITA BAPNA KAVITA BAPNA received shares in physicalform from WAVE INTER TRADES PVT LTD

    123 AMEPB5017G LAXMI K BAPNA LAXMI K BAPNA received shares in physicalform from WAVE INTER TRADES PVT LTD

    124 AMIPP7763K