overcoming the influence of human shadowing via …

6
International Journal of Industrial Electronics and Electrical Engineering, ISSN: 2347-6982 Volume-4, Issue-4, Apr.-2016 Overcoming the Influence of Human Shadowing Via Modified Building Using Frequency Selective Wallpapers For 60 GHZ 22 OVERCOMING THE INFLUENCE OF HUMAN SHADOWING VIA MODIFIED BUILDING USING FREQUENCY SELECTIVE WALLPAPERS FOR 60 GHZ 1 EMRAN ALI ALDORGAM, 2 NIDAL QASEM, 3 HADEEL YASEEN ALZOU’BI 1,2,3 Department of Electronics and Communications Engineering Al-Ahliyya Amman University Amman, Jordan E-mail: 1 [email protected], 2 [email protected], 3 [email protected] Abstract- The growing demand for a very high speed and bandwidth over wireless communications makes the millimeter wave (mm-wave) “60 GHz” a great choice to be studied and used in order to achieve this desire. While the propagating signal of this frequency can be easily blocked by any obstacle or body that faces it, This paper aims to solve this problem by using the Square Loop (SL) Frequency Selective Surfaces (FSS) in such a way to provide a stronger reflected signal to those shadowed positions as a result from the variety of the signal paths and enhancing the received signal power. As a result, minimizing the effect of human bodies which can attenuate 60 GHz signal. Keywords- 60GHz; Frequency Selective Surface; Human Modeling; Millimeter Wave. I. INTRODUCTION The development of wireless communications is stimulated by the consumer desire for access to information and entertainment. While contemporaneity unlicensed systems support moderate levels of wireless data traffic, as seen in Bluetooth and Wireless Local Area Networks (WLANs). Current technology is unable to supply data rates comparable to wired standards like Gigabit Ethernet (GbE) and High Definition Multimedia Interface (HDMI) [1]. As result of that data rates or bandwidths are never enough, while the wireless multimedia distribution market is ever growing [2]. So, an obvious solution to this problem is to resort to the 60 GHz band, where bandwidth is abundantly available [3]. Since the wavelength at 60 GHz is 5 mm which is too small, obstacles such human and furniture can block links easily. For example, blockage by a human can affect the link budget communication by 20-30 dB. So, movements of humans might cause a discontinuous blockage of millimeter wave links [4]. So, this paper suggests a novel technique that will control the propagation of indoor wireless environment at 60 GHz band by blocking the 60 GHz signal from propagating inside the area of interest using SL FSS to provide a stronger reflected signal as well as providing multipath propagation due to the variety of signal paths. II. SIMULATION RESULTS USING COMPUTER SIMULATION TECHNOLOGY (CST) MICROWAVE STUDIO (MWS) Previous researches showed that SL FSS has the best performance and stability to work within the angular sensitivity, cross polarization Transverse Electric (TE) or Transverse Magnetic (TM) modes, and small band separation [5]. Frequency Selective Surfaces (FSSs) are planar periodic structures which exhibit reflection and/or transmission properties as a function of frequency. The surface consists of thin conducting elements, usually printed on dielectric substrates for support. In general, the FSS structures can be divided into patch-type or aperture-type metallic elements, being periodic in either a one or two dimensional array. Based on the element geometry, FSSs have four operation modes: low- pass, high-pass, band- pass, and band-stop filter [6]. FSS is now used in many fields in military applications, antennas, medical applications, and wireless communications security [7-13]. As shown in Fig. 1, SL FSS is tested by using CST MWS for a range of different incidence angles from 0º to 60º. The transmission coefficient (S21) is presented for TE and TM modes, as shown in Fig. 2 and Fig. 3 respectively. The reflection coefficient (S11) is also presented for TE and TM modes, as shown in Fig. 4 and Fig. 5 respectively. All of the following figures for the transmission and reflection coefficients are expressed in a range of frequencies from 50 GHz to 70 GHz and a range of incident angles from 0º to 60º. The copper’s thickness is 0.07 mm and the relative permittivity value ε_r is 3. In order to design a suitable FSS, the attenuation value at the resonant frequency, 60 GHz, must exceed -25 dB to kill the signal [10, 11]. As shown in Fig. 2 and Fig. 3, the transmission coefficients for both TE and TM modes are more than this range. So, the signal will be dead when it tries to penetrate/go out of the area of interest. As well as, the reflection coefficients shown in Fig. 4 and Fig. 5 are even much smaller than -.05 dB at 60 GHz; this will let SL FSS acts as a perfect reflector inside the area of interest as stated before.

Upload: others

Post on 10-Jun-2022

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: OVERCOMING THE INFLUENCE OF HUMAN SHADOWING VIA …

International Journal of Industrial Electronics and Electrical Engineering, ISSN: 2347-6982 Volume-4, Issue-4, Apr.-2016

Overcoming the Influence of Human Shadowing Via Modified Building Using Frequency Selective Wallpapers For 60 GHZ

22

OVERCOMING THE INFLUENCE OF HUMAN SHADOWING VIA MODIFIED BUILDING USING FREQUENCY SELECTIVE

WALLPAPERS FOR 60 GHZ

1EMRAN ALI ALDORGAM, 2NIDAL QASEM, 3HADEEL YASEEN ALZOU’BI

1,2,3Department of Electronics and Communications Engineering Al-Ahliyya Amman University Amman, Jordan

E-mail: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]

Abstract- The growing demand for a very high speed and bandwidth over wireless communications makes the millimeter wave (mm-wave) “60 GHz” a great choice to be studied and used in order to achieve this desire. While the propagating signal of this frequency can be easily blocked by any obstacle or body that faces it, This paper aims to solve this problem by using the Square Loop (SL) Frequency Selective Surfaces (FSS) in such a way to provide a stronger reflected signal to those shadowed positions as a result from the variety of the signal paths and enhancing the received signal power. As a result, minimizing the effect of human bodies which can attenuate 60 GHz signal. Keywords- 60GHz; Frequency Selective Surface; Human Modeling; Millimeter Wave. I. INTRODUCTION The development of wireless communications is stimulated by the consumer desire for access to information and entertainment. While contemporaneity unlicensed systems support moderate levels of wireless data traffic, as seen in Bluetooth and Wireless Local Area Networks (WLANs). Current technology is unable to supply data rates comparable to wired standards like Gigabit Ethernet (GbE) and High Definition Multimedia Interface (HDMI) [1]. As result of that data rates or bandwidths are never enough, while the wireless multimedia distribution market is ever growing [2]. So, an obvious solution to this problem is to resort to the 60 GHz band, where bandwidth is abundantly available [3]. Since the wavelength at 60 GHz is 5 mm which is too small, obstacles such human and furniture can block links easily. For example, blockage by a human can affect the link budget communication by 20-30 dB. So, movements of humans might cause a discontinuous blockage of millimeter wave links [4]. So, this paper suggests a novel technique that will control the propagation of indoor wireless environment at 60 GHz band by blocking the 60 GHz signal from propagating inside the area of interest using SL FSS to provide a stronger reflected signal as well as providing multipath propagation due to the variety of signal paths. II. SIMULATION RESULTS USING COMPUTER SIMULATION TECHNOLOGY (CST) MICROWAVE STUDIO (MWS) Previous researches showed that SL FSS has the best performance and stability to work within the angular sensitivity, cross polarization Transverse Electric

(TE) or Transverse Magnetic (TM) modes, and small band separation [5]. Frequency Selective Surfaces (FSSs) are planar periodic structures which exhibit reflection and/or transmission properties as a function of frequency. The surface consists of thin conducting elements, usually printed on dielectric substrates for support. In general, the FSS structures can be divided into patch-type or aperture-type metallic elements, being periodic in either a one or two dimensional array. Based on the element geometry, FSSs have four operation modes: low- pass, high-pass, band-pass, and band-stop filter [6]. FSS is now used in many fields in military applications, antennas, medical applications, and wireless communications security [7-13]. As shown in Fig. 1, SL FSS is tested by using CST MWS for a range of different incidence angles from 0º to 60º. The transmission coefficient (S21) is presented for TE and TM modes, as shown in Fig. 2 and Fig. 3 respectively. The reflection coefficient (S11) is also presented for TE and TM modes, as shown in Fig. 4 and Fig. 5 respectively. All of the following figures for the transmission and reflection coefficients are expressed in a range of frequencies from 50 GHz to 70 GHz and a range of incident angles from 0º to 60º. The copper’s thickness is 0.07 mm and the relative permittivity value ε_r is 3. In order to design a suitable FSS, the attenuation value at the resonant frequency, 60 GHz, must exceed -25 dB to kill the signal [10, 11]. As shown in Fig. 2 and Fig. 3, the transmission coefficients for both TE and TM modes are more than this range. So, the signal will be dead when it tries to penetrate/go out of the area of interest. As well as, the reflection coefficients shown in Fig. 4 and Fig. 5 are even much smaller than -.05 dB at 60 GHz; this will let SL FSS acts as a perfect reflector inside the area of interest as stated before.

Page 2: OVERCOMING THE INFLUENCE OF HUMAN SHADOWING VIA …

International Journal of Industrial Electronics and Electrical Engineering, ISSN: 2347-6982 Volume-4, Issue-4, Apr.-2016

Overcoming the Influence of Human Shadowing Via Modified Building Using Frequency Selective Wallpapers For 60 GHZ

23

Fig. 1. The SL FSS dimensions, where P=1.4mm, g=0.2mm,

d=1.2mm,and s=0.1mm.

Fig.2. The transmission response (S21) for TE-mode of SL FSS.

Fig.3.The transmission response (S21) for TM-mode of SL FSS.

Fig.4.The reflection response (S11) for TE-mode of SL FSS.

Fig.5. Thereflection response (S11) for TM-mode of SL FSS.

Fig. 6 shows how the designed SL FSS works as band-stop filter for the 60 GHz. It blocks the waves of 60 GHz from port 1 to port 2. So, signal will be attenuated at port 2.

Fig.6.Signal propagation animation, from port 1 to port 2, at 60

GHz. Fig.7 shows how the designed SL FSS works for any frequencies rather than the frequency of interest. As an example, SL FSS will pass 2.4 GHz wave normally from port 1 to port 2.

Fig. 7. Signal propagation animation, from port 1 to port 2, at

2.4 GHz. III. HUMAN MODELING AT 60 GHZ The mm-wave range requires careful characterization of the antenna/human body interaction in order to evaluate, and possibly minimize, the variations of antenna characteristics and exposure levels induced to the body. To this end, knowledge of the dielectric properties of the human tissues is crucial for the numerical modeling and development of experimental phantoms. Any variations of the dielectric properties could directly impact the theoretical and experimental results [14]. Table I lists some typical values of the complex permittivity, at 60 GHz, for human skin, fat, muscle, and pure water at 20◦ C [15].

TABLE I. COMPLEX PERMITTIVITY AT 60 GHZ

Where:

휀 = 휀 − 푗 (1) 휀 : Complex permittivity. 휀 : Relative permittivity. 휔: Angular velocitymeasuredinradians per second.

Page 3: OVERCOMING THE INFLUENCE OF HUMAN SHADOWING VIA …

International Journal of Industrial Electronics and Electrical Engineering, ISSN: 2347-6982 Volume-4, Issue-4, Apr.-2016

Overcoming the Influence of Human Shadowing Via Modified Building Using Frequency Selective Wallpapers For 60 GHZ

24

휀 :Free space permittivity which equals 8.85×10^-

12 F/m. Well, there are two models to simulate the human body shadowing in an indoor environment. The first model is known as "Phantom Human" and the other is called "Salty-Lite". In general, the human body is represented as a parallelepiped circumscribed with Salty-Cylinder model. The lengths of sides of the basic rectangle will be equal to 0.305 m, the height is equal to 1.7 m, and the thickness is equal to 0.305 m [6, 16]. In this work, the human body represented as a parallelepiped circumscribed which contains skin, fat, muscles, and a cylinder with pure water at 20o C, as shown in Fig. 8.

Fig. 8.The human model used in this study.

IV. SIMULATION RESULTS USING WIRELESS INSITE SOFTWARE

‘Wireless InSite’ is the software tool used to give the closest scenario for signals propagating from Transmitter (Tx) to Receiver (Rx) inside the area of study [17]. The S11 and S21 parameters values for designed SL FSS have been exported to ‘Wireless InSite’. Most interestingly, ‘Wireless InSite’ gives results for the propagation without and with the designed SL FSS.

A small area of interest with only one room which has been investigated with and without SL FSS to check its effect on reflecting the frequency of interest of this study and improving the received signal power in presence of humans.

The comparison between scenarios with and without SL FSS has shown how the SL FSS affected the signal propagation and enhanced the received signal power. V. OPEN AREA SCENARIO

One room with dimensions 15×10 m is considered. SL FSS is attached on the wall scenario in order to band-stop 60 GHz. SL FSS is placed away from the wall by λ/10 in order to eliminate the coupling effect [18].

The area of interest has an omnidirectional antenna as a route of Rx's with a sensitivity of -64 dBm for 60 GHz [19]. The height of Rx’s is 1 m and the spaces

between the grid antennas of Rx's are 0.5 m. Tx has directional antenna with input power 10 dBm and gain of 14 dBi. The height of Tx is 2.5 m above the floor which is mounted on the ceiling. The electric parameters of the materials used in the room scenario are presented in Table II [17].

TABLE II. Electrical parameters used for building interfaces

A. First Case without SL FSS Wallpaper Fig. 9 shows the 2D view of the open area scenario with many persons standing randomly around. As well, this scenario consists of Tx and five route Rx's, each one has six points’, the whole distance between them is 0.5 m, 0.1m between each pair, that were arranged behind the person.

Fig.9.2D view for the open area scenario.

As shown in Fig. 10, the black parallelepiped represents a human which stands in the room, with no SL FSS attached on the wall, normal case. By tracking the strength of the propagating paths from Tx to Rx's, as an example Rx-route 3, the received 60 GHz signal power is very low because of the effect of human which will attenuate the propagating signal, as shown in Fig. 11.

Fig.10.3D view for the open area scenario with no SL FSS.

Page 4: OVERCOMING THE INFLUENCE OF HUMAN SHADOWING VIA …

International Journal of Industrial Electronics and Electrical Engineering, ISSN: 2347-6982 Volume-4, Issue-4, Apr.-2016

Overcoming the Influence of Human Shadowing Via Modified Building Using Frequency Selective Wallpapers For 60 GHZ

25

Fig.11. Powerof maximum 3 propagating paths from Tx to Rx-

route 3 without SL FSS. B. Second Case with SL FSS Wallpaper In this case, SL FSS is attached on the wall, as shown in Fig. 12. The SL FSS here will work as a perfect reflector for the 60 GHz signal, and denies the signal getting out of the room, which will minimize the effect of human in attenuating 60 GHz signal. By tracking the propagating paths from Tx to Rx-route 3, the received 60 GHz signal power will be much higher than first case where no SL FSS is around, as shown in Fig. 13 compared to Fig. 11.

Fig.12.3D view for the open area scenario with SL FSS.

Fig. 13.Power of maximum 3 propagating paths from Tx to Rx-

rout 3 with SL FSS. To prove the enhancement in the received signal power by adding SL FSS, comparisons between presence and absence of the SL FSS at every Rx point has been illustrated in Fig. 14 to Fig. 18. As shown in Fig. 14, the received power for Rx-route 1, without SL FSS, is varied between -77.9 dBm to -57.1 dBm, while with SL FSS case is varied between -74.7 dBm to -50.4 dBm. Where all points have been enhanced.

Fig.14.Received signal for Rx-route 1.

As shown in Fig.15, the received power with the no presence of SL FSS is varied between -67.4 dBm to -63.3 dBm, while in the presence of SL FSS is varied between -59.8 dBm to -52.1 dBm.

Fig.15.Received power for Rx-route 2.

As shown in Fig.16, the received power without SL FSS case is varied between -63.5 dBm to -63 dBm, while in case of SL FSS around is varied between -63.8 dBm to -57.3 dBm.

Fig.16.Received power for Rx-route 3.

Even for far Rx routes like Rx-rout 4 and Rx-route 5, as shown in Fig. 17 and Fig. 18 respectively, the power of the received signal in the presence of SL FSS has been enhanced. Where the received power without SL FSS for Rx-rout 4, as shown in Fig.17, is varied between -70.7 dBm to -67.9 dBm, while with SL FSS is varied between -63 dBm to -59.9 dBm. For Rx-route 5 without SL FSS, the received power is varied between -78.5 dBm to -77.6 dBm, while with SL FSS case is varied between -67 dBm to -60.1 dBm, as shown in Fig. 18.

Page 5: OVERCOMING THE INFLUENCE OF HUMAN SHADOWING VIA …

International Journal of Industrial Electronics and Electrical Engineering, ISSN: 2347-6982 Volume-4, Issue-4, Apr.-2016

Overcoming the Influence of Human Shadowing Via Modified Building Using Frequency Selective Wallpapers For 60 GHZ

26

Fig.17.Received power for Rx-route 4.

Fig.18.Received signal power at Rx-route 5.

VI. DELAY SPREAD Mean time of arrival and delay spread are the statistical measures of the time dispersion of the channel [20]. Both of them are explained mathematically in details in the following equations [17, 21]: The time of arrival is:

푡 = (2) Where: 푡 :Time of arrival. 퐿 : Total geometrical path length. C :The speed of light in free space.

And the mean time of arrival is:

t̅ = ∑

(3) And the Root Mean Square (RMS) delay spread is:

σ =∑

− t̅ (4)

Where: 푃 :Theaveraged received power. 푁 : The number of paths. 푃 : The time averaged power in watts of the i path. In this paper, the open area scenario is studied in the presence and absence of SL FSS, in order to show the effect of adding SL FSS to the mean time of arrival and delay spread values. In order to accomplish this, two Rx routes have been taken which are Rx- route 1 and Rx-route 3. As shown in Fig. 19, the average of the mean time of arrival in FSS case for Rx-route 1 was 37.5 ns. The minimum value was 13.2 ns and the maximum value was 61.8 ns. While without FSS, the average was 25.85 ns. The minimum value was 10.7 ns and the maximum value was 41 ns. As a result, these values

are within the acceptable range for 60 GHz [20]. Also, the mean time of arrival with SL FSS is higher than no SL FSS due to the richness in multipath in SL FSS case.

Fig. 19.Mean time of arrival for Rx-route 1.

As shown in Fig.20, the average of mean time of arrival in FSS case for Rx-route 3 was 53.15 ns, while with no SL FSS case was 51.1 ns.

Fig.20. Mean time of arrival for Rx-route 3.

As shown in Fig. 21, the average of delay spread for Rx- route1 in SL FSS case was 20.9 ns, while with no SL FSS was 13.2 ns.

Fig.21.Delay Spread for Rx-route 1.

As shown in Fig.22, the average of delay spread in SL FSS case for Rx-route 3 was 15.5 ns, while with no SL FSS was 10.8 ns.

Fig.22.Delay spread for Rx-route 3.

Page 6: OVERCOMING THE INFLUENCE OF HUMAN SHADOWING VIA …

International Journal of Industrial Electronics and Electrical Engineering, ISSN: 2347-6982 Volume-4, Issue-4, Apr.-2016

Overcoming the Influence of Human Shadowing Via Modified Building Using Frequency Selective Wallpapers For 60 GHZ

27

CONCLUSION Enhancing the received signal power for 60 GHz indoor wireless propagation environment in order to minimize the effect of human in blocking 60 GHz signal was investigated and demonstrated in this paper. The frequency response of SL FSS wall developed in this paper showed a good capability to deal with TE-mode and TM-mode waves. SL FSS was used as a band-stop filter to block 60 GHz propagation from outside/inside the area of interest and as a perfect reflector from inside. One room was investigated to simulate the SL FSS action and how it affects the signal propagation. The received signal power has been enhanced. Because of, it provided multipath propagation due to the variety of signal paths where diminished the influence of human shadowing. With the direct path obstructed by a human body, the signal power enhancement ranged from 3 dBm to 15 dBm, depending on the position of the human body and the angle of arrival of the path. Comparing simulations for a normal and a modified wall, as the stronger reflected paths from the modified wall have time delays more than to those of the dominant paths from the normal wall. For the same reason, in the presence of the modified wall, an increased portion of the total received power arrives at times similar to the mean delay time. Therefore, the RMS delay spread is increased slightly, which is still within an acceptable range. REFERENCES

[1] Choi, Sung-Woo, Il-Gyu Kim, and Jae-Min Ahn. "Architecture of baseband modem board for IEEE802. 11ad technology." In ICT Convergence (ICTC), 2013 International Conference on, pp. 101-104. IEEE, 2013.

[2] Guo, Nan, Robert C. Qiu, Shaomin S. Mo, and Kazuaki Takahashi. "60-GHz millimeter-wave radio: Principle, technology, and new results." EURASIP Journal on Wireless Communications and Networking 2007, no. 1 (2007): 48-48.

[3] Smulders, P. F. M. "60 GHz radio: prospects and future directions." InProceedings Symposium IEEE Benelux Chapter on Communications and Vehicular Technology, vol. 8. 2003.

[4] Singh, Sumit. "Medium Access Control and Bandwidth Allocation in Millimeter-Wave and WiFi Networks." PhD diss., UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA Santa Barbara, 2009.

[5] Mias, C., C. Tsakonas, and C. Oswald. "An investigation into the feasibility of designing frequency selective windows employing periodic structures."Radiocommunications Agency Final Rep (2001).

[6] Qasem, Nidal. "Enhancing wireless communication system performance through modified indoor environments." PhD diss., © Nidal Qasem, 2014.

[7] Kartal, Mesut, Bora Döken, and İsmail Güngör. "Design for the structural surface material enabling shielding for interference mitigation within the buildings in the unlicensed 2.4 ghz ISM band." In General Assembly and Scientific Symposium, 2011 XXXth URSI, pp. 1-4. IEEE, 2011.

[8] Taylor, Paul S., Edward Parker, and John C. Batchelor. "An active annular ring frequency selective surface." Antennas and Propagation, IEEE Transactions on 59, no. 9 (2011): 3265-3271.

[9] AlKayyali, Hussein, and Nidal Qasem. "Convoluted Frequency Selective Surface Wallpaper to Block the Industrial, Scientific, and Medical Radio Bands Inside Buildings." American Academic & Scholarly Research Journal 5, no. 3 special issue (2013): 106.

[10] Qasem, Nidal, and Rob Seager. "Studies on enhancing wireless signal for indoor propagation." In Antennas and Propagation Conference (LAPC), 2010 Loughborough, pp. 309-312. IEEE, 2010.

[11] Qasem, Nidal, and Rob Seager. "Frequency selective wall for enhancing wireless signal in indoor environments." In Antennas & Propagation Conference, 2009. LAPC 2009. Loughborough, pp. 573-576. IEEE, 2009.

[12] Dawod, Dalia, and Nidal Qasem. "Enhancing the capacity of MIMO systems via modified building using Frequency Selective wallpapers." In Information and Communication Systems (ICICS), 2015 6th International Conference on, pp. 171-176. IEEE, 2015.

[13] Qasem, Nidal, and Rob Seager. "Indoor band pass frequency selective wall paper equivalent circuit & ways to enhance wireless signal." In Antennas and Propagation Conference (LAPC), 2011 Loughborough, pp. 1-4. IEEE, 2011.

[14] Chahat, Nacer, Maxim Zhadobov, Ronan Sauleau, and Stanislav Alekseev. "New method for determining dielectric properties of skin and phantoms at millimeter waves based on heating kinetics." Microwave Theory and Techniques, IEEE Transactions on 60, no. 3 (2012): 827-832.

[15] Gustafson, Carl, and Fredrik Tufvesson. "Characterization of 60 GHz shadowing by human bodies and simple phantoms." In Antennas and Propagation (EUCAP), 2012 6th European Conference on, pp. 473-477. IEEE, 2012.

[16] Qasem, Nidal, and Rob Seager. "Overcoming the influence of people shadowing and enhancing MIMO capacity systems via modified environments." In Antennas and Propagation Conference (LAPC), 2012 Loughborough, pp. 1-4. IEEE, 2012.

[17] Remcom. (2015, November 15). Retrieved from http://www.remcom.com/electromagnetic-applications/

[18] M. Raspopoulos and S. Stavrou, "Frequency selective surfaces on building materials-air gap impact," Electron. Lett., vol. 43, pp. 700-702, 2007.

[19] Zhu, Yibo, Zengbin Zhang, Zhinus Marzi, Chris Nelson, Upamanyu Madhow, Ben Y. Zhao, and Haitao Zheng. "Demystifying 60ghz outdoor picocells." InProceedings of the 20th annual international conference on Mobile computing andnetworking, pp. 5-16. ACM, 2014.

[20] Xu, H., Kukshya, V., & Rappaport, T. S. (2002). Spatial and temporal characteristics of 60-GHz indoor channels. Selected Areas in Communications, IEEE Journal on, 20(3), 620-630.

[21] Qasem, Nidal, and Rob Seager. "Parametric studies in enhancing indoor wireless communication system via environmental modification." In Antennas and Propagation Conference (LAPC), 2012 Loughborough, pp. 1-4. IEEE, 2012.