pacific gas and electric company 2020 wildfire …pg&e’s approach to survey in responding to...
TRANSCRIPT
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
2020 WILDFIRE MITIGATION PLAN
ATTACHMENT 5
ADDITIONAL DETAIL ON
PG&E’S UTILITY SURVEY RESPONSES
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
WILDFIRE MITIGATION PLAN
ATTACHMENT 5
ADDITIONAL DETAIL ON
PG&E’S UTILITY SURVEY RESPONSES
Overview and Supplement to Utility Wildfire Mitigation Maturity Model
As part of a substantially revised 2020 Wildfire Mitigation Plan (WMP) process, the
CPUC Wildfire Safety Division (WSD) directed California utilities to complete a
supplementary self-assessment of Wildfire Mitigation Capabilities. The self-assessment
is based on a WSD developed model, the Utility Wildfire Mitigation Maturity Model
(UWMMM or Maturity Model), which describes a methodology and provides a
framework that can be used to assess utility capabilities in reducing wildfire risk and
corresponding maturity levels. As outlined by the WSD, the UWMMM is intended to
provide the CPUC and the public with a view of the utility’s wildfire mitigation capabilities
and identify leading practices that may be shared across California utilities.
The UWMMM is comprised of 52 distinct “capabilities” organized into 10 categories.
In addition, the WSD provided a Utility Survey containing 247 questions that map into
the 52 capabilities. Each California utility is required to self-assess itself along all
247 questions on both its current (January 2020) and future state (January 2023) –
these answers have been recorded and submitted through a digital survey alongside
the 2020 WMP submission, on February 7, 2020. A print-out of those responses is
included as Attachment 4 to PG&E’s 2020 WMP.
Utility Survey Supplemental Information
To support PG&E’s Maturity Model and Survey submission, PG&E is including the
following information to provide additional background and detail on how we
approached the survey and challenges identified in responding to it. PG&E
understands that, as the WSD has stated previously, this Maturity Model and associated
assessments against it are valuable and iterative. PG&E is providing this supplemental
information to improve understanding and information sharing about how PG&E
responded to this survey and to help inform this vital process going forward.
PG&E’s Approach to Survey
In responding to the multiple-choice Utility Survey questions, PG&E approached
each one as literally as possible while also erring on the conservative side when an
Atch5-1
answer fell between two options (i.e., PG&E would choose the lower score). PG&E
further relied on the guidance given in the Survey Response Instructions, which state
that a utility shall indicate that they meet a given response option if they meet all of the
characteristics described within that response option, across all instances where the
question is valid. From PG&E’s perspective, this standard was particularly impactful
with “binary” (i.e., only two options) survey questions given that the two options were
usually at opposite ends of a possible spectrum and a simple yes or no response does
not accurately reflect PG&E’s actual capabilities. In some of these instances, PG&E
had to rely on the professional judgement of Subject Matter Experts (SME) to best
interpret the spirit, intent and specifics of a question; for example, survey question G.I.a
asks “does the utility have a centralized database of situational, operational, and risk
data” with the simple options: no or yes. PG&E answered “yes” to this question,
because, although this data is actually housed in multiple databases, the data is
centralized in a way that is easily accessible and makes sense for various data traits
across multiple databases.
PG&E enlisted the inputs from many internal SMEs to answer the questions within
their expertise. All answers were then reviewed by the Electric Operations Leadership
(including both Category-specific Responsible Directors as well as more senior
Leaders), Legal, and Regulatory teams. PG&E understands that the survey questions,
in combination with other inputs, will be translated by the WSD into maturity “scores” for
each of the 52 capabilities in the UWMMM.
Finally, when self-assessing future state scores, PG&E typically identified a higher
maturity level than the current state in the cases where an established plan with line of
sight supports the future score. In addition, in areas where the answer and/or maturity
score did not change, PG&E is not necessarily stating that no actions will be taken to
improve; there are levels of maturity within each option. Moreover, in some cases
improvements are planned that do not precisely align with a higher answer level
(e.g., PG&E is improving in a way that may be different than what is identified in the
survey answer rubric), or, in other cases, technology, tools, and other actions are being
evaluated or implemented but it is not fully clear at this point how, if or when those
activities will increase performance to the higher answer. PG&E takes answering the
questions to improve the wildfire capability seriously and it will continue to pursue a
wide array of improvements for those goals that do and do not fully align with the WSD’s
Maturity Model for all of California’s utilities.
Atch5-2
Scoring Challenges
As mentioned above, PG&E read each question as literally as possible and
answered conservatively each survey question. Even when applying those principles,
PG&E ran into several issues that could cause confusion or misinterpretation of the
answer.
Survey questions and answer choices were often rigid, highly specific, and may or
may not align with leading practices. For example, multiple survey questions
(e.g., F.III.b, I.III.b, I.III.c) ask about % of customers contacted during events and
suggest that the leading practice is contacting greater than 99.9% of customers.
However, PG&E does not have up-to-date contact information for its entire customer
base as customers have ultimate control of their contact information—this is a common
issue in the utility industry. Therefore, regardless of amount of effort, attaining the top
score in this type of question is likely unattainable.
In the survey itself, questions with binary answers oftentimes are not connected to
other questions or comment fields that would provide further insight into the response.
For example, survey question E.IV.f asks “does the utility remove vegetation waste
along its right of way across the entire grid” while providing the options: no or yes.
PG&E does remove vegetation waste along some of its right of ways, but it does not
remove all vegetation waste along every right of way across the grid. To be
conservative, PG&E answered no for both current and future state, which is not truly
reflective of the situation.
Finally, while PG&E understands that the WSD will compute the final maturity
scores for each capability using the survey responses alongside other inputs, there will
likely be multiple instances where one survey question will have a disproportionate
impact on a maturity score for one or more of the 52 capabilities that may not truly
reflect PG&E’s level of maturity. As an example, on survey question J.V.a
(Capability 52) regarding fuel management,1 a strict interpretation of the answers
requires PG&E to submit the lowest answer, which is expected to result in the entire
capability being graded a ‘0’. Matching back to the maturity model, a ‘0’ score on
capability 52 reads broadly as “Utility does not collaborate with other agencies
conducting non-emergency wildfire planning and initiatives to reduce wildfire risk.”
1 Question J.V.a asks “where does the utility conduct substantial fuel management?” with the options: utility does not conduct fuel management, utility conducts fuel management along rights of way, or utility conducts fuel management throughout service area.
Atch5-3
If scored in that way (a “0” on capability 52 because of question J.V.a), this maturity
assessment would not be accurate as there are several aspects to collaboration on
“wildfire planning and initiative to reduce wildfire risk” that are not being incorporated
into the response due to one score on a single question.
While PG&E appreciates the challenges inherent in creating a model to assess a
concept as complex as utility wildfire mitigation activities, PG&E has some concerns
about public perception issues given some of the scoring challenges outlined above.
Moreover, the UWMMM was designed as a “one size fits all” model for all California
utilities, and some of the practices that the WSD defines as leading or at a higher
maturity level may not be the most prudent or impactful in reducing wildfire risk as it
specifically pertains to PG&E and its service territory.
Future Evolution
PG&E is supportive of a statewide approach to wildfire mitigation maturity and
agrees that the related benchmarking and best practices conversations will be
beneficial. PG&E is looking forward to robust conversations and idea sharing with the
WSD, other utilities, community partners, and the broader public on how continue to
evolve and improve the Maturity Model tool and overall wildfire risk reduction going
forward.
The tables that follow provide additional background and details on the Utility
Survey responses that were officially provided to the WSD through an online tool.
A download of those responses from the online survey tool has been provided in
Attachment 4.
Atch5-4
Uti
lity
Su
rv
ey
Re
sp
on
se
s
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
1C
lim
ate
sce
na
rio
mo
del
ing
an
d
sen
siti
vit
ies
A.I
.aH
ow
so
ph
isti
cate
d i
s u
tili
ty's
ab
ilit
y t
o
esti
ma
te t
he
risk
of
wea
ther
sce
na
rio
s?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
inco
rpo
rate
cli
ma
te s
cen
ari
os
into
its
ris
k m
od
elin
g a
t th
is t
ime.
In
th
e
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to a
pp
ly t
he
bes
t a
va
ila
ble
cli
ma
te i
nfo
rma
tio
n w
hen
co
nd
uct
ing
infr
ast
ruct
ure
wo
rk,
an
d d
evel
op
ing
des
ign
an
d c
on
stru
ctio
n s
tan
da
rds.
Ult
ima
tely
,
PG
&E
wo
uld
lik
e to
ha
ve
its
risk
mo
del
ing
an
d t
he
ov
era
ll a
sset
str
ate
gy
co
nsi
der
win
d
pa
tter
ns
an
d t
emp
era
ture
of
tra
nsf
orm
ers.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
1C
lim
ate
sce
na
rio
mo
del
ing
an
d
sen
siti
vit
ies
A.I
.bH
ow
are
sce
na
rio
s a
sses
sed
?i
ii"I
nd
epen
den
t" m
ean
s ei
ther
in
tern
al
(in
dep
end
ent
fro
m a
cco
un
tab
le t
eam
) o
r ex
tern
al.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
foll
ow
a f
orm
al
ass
essm
ent
pro
cess
wh
en l
oo
kin
g a
t cl
ima
te s
cen
ari
os.
PG
&E
do
es c
on
sid
er c
lim
ate
ch
an
ge
an
d i
ts i
mp
act
s o
n P
G&
E's
ter
rito
ry,
bu
t th
is
con
cep
t h
as
no
t b
een
fu
lly
op
era
tio
na
lize
d.
PG
&E
ha
s h
ired
a t
hir
d-p
art
y t
o c
on
du
ct
an
in
dep
end
ent
exp
ert
ass
essm
ent,
wh
ich
wil
l so
lid
ify
a f
orm
al
ass
essm
ent
pro
cess
in
the
futu
re.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
1C
lim
ate
sce
na
rio
mo
del
ing
an
d
sen
siti
vit
ies
A.I
.cH
ow
gra
nu
lar
is u
tili
ty's
ab
ilit
y t
o m
od
el
scen
ari
os
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y m
od
els
scen
ari
os
at
a r
egio
na
l le
vel
usi
ng
Ca
lifo
rnia
En
erg
y
Co
mm
issi
on
(C
EC
) cl
ima
te s
cen
ari
o a
na
lyse
s, w
hic
h a
re m
ap
ped
by
co
un
ty.
PG
&E
ha
s, a
nd
wil
l co
nti
nu
e to
ma
ke
effo
rts
to m
od
el s
cen
ari
os
at
the
circ
uit
lev
el.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
1C
lim
ate
sce
na
rio
mo
del
ing
an
d
sen
siti
vit
ies
A.I
.dH
ow
au
tom
ate
d i
s th
e to
ol?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
's c
lim
ate
sce
na
rio
mo
del
ing
to
ol
is n
ot
au
tom
ate
d,
an
d t
his
is
no
t fo
rese
en t
o
cha
ng
e in
th
e im
med
iate
fu
ture
.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
1C
lim
ate
sce
na
rio
mo
del
ing
an
d
sen
siti
vit
ies
A.I
.eW
ha
t a
dd
itio
na
l in
form
ati
on
is
use
d t
o
esti
ma
te m
od
el w
eath
er s
cen
ari
os
an
d
thei
r ri
sk?
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y l
oo
ks
at
fail
ure
mo
des
in
ass
et m
an
ag
emen
t, s
pre
ad
an
aly
sis
in
Tec
hn
osy
lva
, a
nd
wea
ther
sce
na
rio
s to
hel
p i
nfo
rm t
he
ba
sis
of
insp
ecti
on
s. I
n t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to i
nte
gra
te t
hes
e th
ree
com
po
nen
ts i
nto
a s
ing
le m
od
el t
o
esti
ma
te r
isk
.A
01
Cli
ma
te s
cen
ari
o
mo
del
ing
an
d
sen
siti
vit
ies
A.I
.fT
o w
ha
t ex
ten
t is
fu
ture
ch
an
ge
in
clim
ate
ta
ken
in
to a
cco
un
t fo
r fu
ture
ris
k
esti
ma
tio
n?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
tak
e fu
ture
cli
ma
te c
ha
ng
e in
acc
ou
nt
wh
en e
stim
ati
ng
fu
ture
wea
ther
an
d r
esu
ltin
g r
isk
. In
fu
ture
sce
na
rio
mo
del
ing
, P
G&
E p
lan
s to
ta
ke
into
acc
ou
nt
hig
her
ris
k a
cro
ss t
he
enti
re s
erv
ice
terr
ito
ry c
au
sed
by
th
e ch
an
gin
g c
lim
ate
.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
2Ig
nit
ion
Ris
k
Est
ima
te
A.I
I.a
Ho
w i
s ig
nit
ion
ris
k c
alc
ula
ted
? ii
iii
Qu
an
tita
tiv
e m
ean
s re
lati
ve
risk
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
use
s a
va
riet
y o
f to
ols
an
d p
roce
sses
to
rel
iab
ly c
ate
go
rize
th
e ri
sk o
f
ign
itio
n a
cro
ss t
he
gri
d i
nto
at
lea
st t
wo
ca
teg
ori
es f
or
bo
th t
ran
smis
sio
n a
nd
dis
trib
uti
on
. P
G&
E p
lan
s to
en
ha
nce
so
me
of
its
too
ls (
e.g
., R
EA
X,
Tec
hn
osy
lva
) to
all
ow
fo
r q
ua
nti
tati
ve
an
d a
ccu
rate
ass
essm
ent
of
the
risk
of
ign
itio
n a
cro
ss t
he
gri
d
ba
sed
on
ch
ara
cter
isti
cs a
nd
co
nd
itio
n o
f li
nes
, eq
uip
men
t, s
urr
ou
nd
ing
veg
eta
tio
n,
an
d l
oca
lize
d w
eath
er p
att
ern
s.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
2Ig
nit
ion
Ris
k
Est
ima
te
A.I
I.b
Ho
w a
uto
ma
ted
is
the
ign
itio
n r
isk
calc
ula
tio
n t
oo
l?
iii
No
ne
Cu
rren
t ig
nit
ion
ris
k c
alc
ula
tio
ns
are
ma
nu
al,
as
PG
&E
mu
st p
ull
in
form
ati
on
fro
m
sev
era
l d
isp
ara
te d
ata
ba
ses
to a
sses
s ri
sk.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
aim
s to
dev
elo
p a
n
inte
rfa
ce t
ha
t in
teg
rate
s su
ch d
ata
(e.
g.,
ou
tag
e h
isto
ry,
ass
et c
ha
ract
eris
tics
an
d
con
dit
ion
s) t
o p
art
iall
y a
uto
ma
te a
nd
str
eam
lin
e th
e ri
sk c
alc
ula
tio
n p
roce
ss.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
2Ig
nit
ion
Ris
k
Est
ima
te
A.I
I.c
Ho
w g
ran
ula
r is
th
e to
ol?
ii
iii
iG
ran
ula
rity
at
the
ass
et l
evel
is
ba
sed
on
ass
et
con
dit
ion
as
an
in
pu
t
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
ca
lcu
late
s ig
nit
ion
ris
k a
t a
pro
tect
ion
zo
ne
lev
el o
f g
ran
ula
rity
fo
r it
s
dis
trib
uti
on
sy
stem
. P
rote
ctio
n z
on
es a
re m
ore
gra
nu
lar
tha
n c
ircu
it l
evel
, b
ut
less
gra
nu
lar
tha
n s
pa
n l
evel
. T
ran
smis
sio
n i
gn
itio
n r
isk
is
ass
esse
d a
t th
e a
sset
lev
el b
y
usi
ng
co
mp
on
ent
typ
e, c
on
dit
ion
, a
nd
ch
ara
cter
isti
cs a
s in
pu
ts.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
an
tici
pa
te b
ein
g a
ble
in
corp
ora
te u
niq
ue
wea
ther
co
nd
itio
ns
at
the
equ
ipm
ent
lev
el
into
ig
nit
ion
ris
k e
stim
ate
s b
y 2
02
3.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
2Ig
nit
ion
Ris
k
Est
ima
te
A.I
I.d
Ho
w i
s ri
sk a
sses
smen
t co
nfi
rmed
?
Sel
ect
all
th
at
ap
ply
.
i a
nd
ii
i, i
i a
nd
iii
PG
&E
in
terp
rets
"re
al
tim
e le
arn
ing
" a
s
inco
rpo
rati
ng
les
son
s fr
om
pa
st e
ven
ts v
ery
qu
ick
ly,
alb
eit,
no
t in
sta
nta
neo
usl
y
Ex
per
ts c
an
be
inte
rna
l o
r ex
tern
al
pa
rtie
s.
PG
&E
pri
ma
rily
uti
lize
s ex
per
ts a
nd
his
tori
cal
da
ta t
o c
on
firm
pa
st r
isk
ass
essm
ents
.
PG
&E
als
o l
ever
ag
es l
earn
ing
s fr
om
pa
st e
ven
ts w
hen
co
nfi
rmin
g i
ts r
isk
ass
essm
ents
bu
t b
elie
ves
it
can
do
so
at
a q
uic
ker
pa
ce.
Mo
vin
g f
orw
ard
, P
G&
E a
ims
to i
nco
rpo
rate
lea
rnin
gs
fro
m p
ast
ris
k a
sses
smen
ts a
t a
qu
ick
er c
ad
ence
th
an
bef
ore
.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
2Ig
nit
ion
Ris
k
Est
ima
te
A.I
I.e
Wh
at
con
fid
ence
in
terv
al,
in
per
cen
t,
do
es t
he
uti
lity
use
in
its
wil
dfi
re r
isk
ass
essm
ents
?
ii
Qu
an
tita
tiv
e m
ean
s re
lati
ve
PG
&E
ass
esse
s w
ild
fire
ris
k u
sin
g a
rel
ati
ve
risk
met
ho
do
log
y t
ha
t d
oes
no
t in
clu
de
the
use
of
a q
ua
nti
fied
co
nfi
den
ce i
nte
rva
l. S
pec
ific
all
y,
PG
&E
ca
lcu
late
s ri
sk s
core
s b
y
mu
ltip
lyin
g t
he
exp
ecte
d c
on
seq
uen
ce o
f a
ris
k e
ven
t b
y t
he
lik
elih
oo
d o
f a
n r
isk
ev
ent
occ
urr
ing
(co
nsi
sten
t w
ith
D.1
8-1
2-0
14).
PG
&E
als
o f
act
ors
in
hig
h c
on
seq
uen
ce,
low
rela
tiv
e fr
equ
ency
ev
ents
(i.
e.,
tail
ev
ents
) u
sin
g a
Mu
lti-
Att
rib
ute
Va
lue
Fu
nct
ion
th
at
ass
oci
ate
s u
p t
o 1
0 t
imes
mo
re "
imp
ort
an
ce"
to t
ail
ev
ents
th
an
rel
ati
vel
y c
om
mo
n
even
ts.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to c
on
tin
ue
usi
ng
th
is m
eth
od
olo
gy
.
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
Atch5-5
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
3E
stim
ati
on
of
wil
dfi
re
con
seq
uen
ces
for
com
mu
nit
ies
A.I
II.a
Ho
w i
s es
tim
ate
d c
on
seq
uen
ce o
f
ign
itio
n r
ela
yed
?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
ca
teg
ori
zes
ign
itio
n e
ven
ts e
ith
er a
s a
lo
w o
r h
igh
ris
k t
o c
om
mu
nit
ies
an
d w
ill
con
tin
ue
do
ing
so
. P
G&
E i
s a
lso
alw
ay
s lo
ok
ing
fo
r a
pp
rop
ria
te w
ay
s to
id
enti
fy
ign
itio
n r
isk
su
ch a
s ra
nk
ing
th
e ri
sk o
f ci
rcu
its.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
3E
stim
ati
on
of
wil
dfi
re
con
seq
uen
ces
for
com
mu
nit
ies
A.I
II.b
Wh
at
met
rics
are
use
d t
o e
stim
ate
th
e
con
seq
uen
ce o
f ig
nit
ion
ris
k?
iii
Ca
tast
rop
hic
ev
ent
mea
ns
at
lea
st o
ne
fata
lity
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
use
s R
EA
X a
nd
Tec
hn
osy
lva
to
est
ima
te c
on
seq
uen
ce o
f ig
nit
ion
ris
k
usi
ng
po
ten
tia
l p
op
ula
tio
n i
mp
act
ed,
nu
mb
er o
f st
ruct
ure
s a
nd
nu
mb
er o
f a
cres
bu
rned
. T
hes
e to
ols
do
no
t in
clu
de
the
nu
mb
er o
f p
ote
nti
al
fata
liti
es.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
on
im
pro
vin
g i
ts e
stim
ati
on
mo
del
bu
t d
oes
no
t a
nti
cip
ate
ha
vin
g a
ir
qu
ali
ty a
nd
GH
G a
na
lyse
s b
ein
g i
nco
rpo
rate
d i
n t
he
esti
ma
tio
n b
y 2
02
3.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
3E
stim
ati
on
of
wil
dfi
re
con
seq
uen
ces
for
com
mu
nit
ies
A.I
II.c
Is t
he
ign
itio
n r
isk
im
pa
ct a
na
lysi
s
av
ail
ab
le f
or
all
sea
son
s?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
's i
gn
itio
n r
isk
im
pa
ct a
na
lysi
s is
av
ail
ab
le t
hro
ug
ho
ut
all
sea
son
s o
f th
e y
ear.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
3E
stim
ati
on
of
wil
dfi
re
con
seq
uen
ces
for
com
mu
nit
ies
A.I
II.d
Ho
w a
uto
ma
ted
is
the
ign
itio
n r
isk
esti
ma
tio
n p
roce
ss?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
's c
urr
ent
ign
itio
n r
isk
est
ima
tio
n p
roce
ss i
s n
ot
au
tom
ate
d.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
on
au
tom
ati
ng
th
e p
roce
sses
as
mu
ch a
s p
ract
ica
lly
fea
sib
le t
hro
ug
h i
nte
gra
tio
n
of
dif
fere
nt
da
ta s
ou
rces
.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
3E
stim
ati
on
of
wil
dfi
re
con
seq
uen
ces
for
com
mu
nit
ies
A.I
II.e
Ho
w g
ran
ula
r is
th
e ig
nit
ion
ris
k
esti
ma
tio
n p
roce
ss?
iii
iii
No
ne
Gra
nu
lari
ty f
or
ign
itio
n r
isk
est
ima
tio
n p
roce
sses
are
do
ne
at
the
ass
et l
evel
fo
r
dis
trib
uti
on
an
d a
t th
e ci
rcu
it l
evel
fo
r tr
an
smis
sio
n.
No
ch
an
ge
is e
xp
ecte
d i
n t
he
futu
re.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
3E
stim
ati
on
of
wil
dfi
re
con
seq
uen
ces
for
com
mu
nit
ies
A.I
II.f
Ho
w a
re t
he
ou
tpu
ts o
f th
e ig
nit
ion
ris
k
imp
act
ass
essm
ent
too
l ev
alu
ate
d?
iii
iIn
dep
end
ent
- ca
n e
ith
er b
e a
n i
nte
rna
l a
sses
smen
t
(in
dep
end
ent
fro
m r
esp
on
sib
le/a
cco
un
tab
le t
eam
)
or
an
ex
tern
al
thir
d p
art
y
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
ev
alu
ate
s o
utp
uts
of
the
ign
itio
n r
isk
im
pa
ct a
sses
smen
t to
ol,
bu
t th
e
eva
lua
tio
n i
s d
on
e b
y t
he
resp
on
sib
le t
eam
, n
ot
an
in
dep
end
ent
exp
ert.
In
th
e fu
ture
,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to i
nco
rpo
rate
in
dep
end
ent
ass
essm
ent
thro
ug
h e
ith
er e
xte
rna
l th
ird
pa
rty
or
an
in
tern
al
ass
essm
ent
tea
m t
ha
t is
in
dep
end
ent
of
the
tea
m
resp
on
sib
le/a
cco
un
tab
le f
or
exec
uti
ng
th
e ri
sk i
mp
act
an
aly
sis.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
3E
stim
ati
on
of
wil
dfi
re
con
seq
uen
ces
for
com
mu
nit
ies
A.I
II.g
Wh
at
oth
er i
np
uts
are
use
d t
o e
stim
ate
imp
act
?
ii
Veg
eta
tio
n a
nd
wea
ther
are
use
d t
o e
stim
ate
con
seq
uen
ce o
r sp
rea
d,
no
t li
kel
iho
od
of
ign
itio
n.
PG
&E
use
s v
eget
ati
on
an
d w
eath
er t
o e
stim
ate
th
e co
nse
qu
ence
(a
ka
sp
rea
d)
of
a
wil
dfi
re s
ho
uld
an
ig
nit
ion
ta
ke
pla
ce.
Th
ese
two
in
pu
ts,
alo
ng
wit
h o
ther
s su
ch a
s
mo
istu
re t
yp
es,
hel
p i
nfo
rm t
he
Tec
hn
osy
lva
ou
tpu
ts.
PG
&E
is
wo
rkin
g o
n d
evel
op
ing
solu
tio
ns
wit
h T
ech
no
sylv
a t
ha
t w
hen
ov
erla
id w
ith
ad
dit
ion
al
wea
ther
da
ta,
cou
ld
hel
p i
den
tify
veg
eta
tio
n s
pec
ies
or
stri
ke
tree
s. T
his
da
ta h
as
bee
n c
oll
ecte
d i
n T
ier
2/3
HF
TD
.A
Ris
k M
ap
pin
g a
nd
Sim
ula
tio
n
4E
stim
ati
on
of
wil
dfi
re a
nd
PS
PS
ris
k-
red
uct
ion
im
pa
ct
A.I
V.a
Ho
w i
s ri
sk r
edu
ctio
n i
mp
act
est
ima
ted
? i
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
ha
s a
n S
ME
in
form
ed p
roce
ss t
o e
stim
ate
th
e p
ote
nti
al
risk
red
uct
ion
by
in
itia
tiv
e, b
ut
do
es n
ot
ha
ve
eno
ug
h o
per
ati
on
al
his
tory
to
va
lid
ate
th
e ef
fect
iven
ess
of
the
risk
red
uct
ion
by
in
itia
tiv
e w
ith
th
e ex
cep
tio
n o
f P
SP
S.
PG
&E
ca
lcu
late
s a
PS
PS
de-
ener
giz
iati
on
sco
pin
g c
rite
ria
est
ima
ted
ris
k r
edu
ctio
n p
erce
nta
ge
tha
t is
ba
sed
on
his
tori
cal
ou
tag
e d
ata
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E w
ill
va
lid
ate
its
ris
k r
edu
ctio
n e
stim
ati
on
pro
cess
th
rou
gh
act
ua
l p
erfo
rma
nce
of
the
circ
uit
s.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
4E
stim
ati
on
of
wil
dfi
re a
nd
PS
PS
ris
k-
red
uct
ion
im
pa
ct
A.I
V.b
Ho
w a
uto
ma
ted
is
yo
ur
ign
itio
n r
isk
red
uct
ion
im
pa
ct a
sses
smen
t to
ol?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
's c
urr
ent
ign
itio
n r
isk
red
uct
ion
im
pa
ct a
sses
smen
t is
no
t a
uto
ma
ted
. In
th
e
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
on
au
tom
ati
ng
th
e a
sses
smen
t a
s m
uch
as
pra
ctic
all
y f
easi
ble
,
thro
ug
h i
nte
gra
tio
n o
f d
iffe
ren
t d
ata
so
urc
es.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
4E
stim
ati
on
of
wil
dfi
re a
nd
PS
PS
ris
k-
red
uct
ion
im
pa
ct
A.I
V.c
Ho
w g
ran
ula
r is
th
e ig
nit
ion
ris
k
red
uct
ion
im
pa
ct a
sses
smen
t to
ol?
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E's
cu
rren
t p
roce
ss f
or
esti
ma
tio
n o
f w
ild
fire
ris
k-r
edu
ctio
n i
mp
act
use
s S
MA
P
wh
ich
is
less
gra
nu
lar
tha
n r
egio
na
l. P
G&
E's
pro
cess
fo
r es
tim
ati
ng
PS
PS
ris
k
red
uct
ion
im
pa
ct y
ield
s a
hig
her
lev
el o
f g
ran
ula
rity
, lo
ok
ing
at
the
sco
pe
for
de-
ener
giz
ati
on
vs.
th
e a
ctu
al
for
pre
vio
us
PS
PS
ev
ents
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E p
lan
s to
imp
rov
e it
s es
tim
ati
on
of
wil
dfi
re a
nd
PS
PS
ris
k-r
edu
ctio
n i
mp
act
to
th
e ci
rcu
it l
evel
.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
4E
stim
ati
on
of
wil
dfi
re a
nd
PS
PS
ris
k-
red
uct
ion
im
pa
ct
A.I
V.d
Ho
w a
re i
gn
itio
n r
isk
red
uct
ion
im
pa
ct
ass
essm
ent
too
l es
tim
ate
s a
sses
sed
?
iii
i"I
nd
epen
den
t" c
an
eit
her
be
an
in
tern
al
ass
essm
ent
(in
dep
end
ent
fro
m r
esp
on
sib
le/a
cco
un
tab
le t
eam
)
or
an
ex
tern
al
thir
d p
art
y.
PG
&E
ass
ess
its
esti
ma
tes
of
ign
itio
n r
isk
red
uct
ion
im
pa
cts
wit
h l
imit
ed
form
al
evid
ence
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E p
lan
s o
n u
tili
zin
g e
xp
ert
ass
essm
ents
.
Atch5-6
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
4E
stim
ati
on
of
wil
dfi
re a
nd
PS
PS
ris
k-
red
uct
ion
im
pa
ct
A.I
V.e
Wh
at
ad
dit
ion
al
info
rma
tio
n i
s u
sed
to
esti
ma
te r
isk
red
uct
ion
im
pa
ct?
iiii
i"E
stim
ate
" in
clu
des
a r
ela
tiv
e p
rio
riti
zati
on
sca
le
fro
m l
ow
to
hig
h a
nd
th
is i
nfo
rms
ou
r w
ork
pri
ori
tiza
tio
n.
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
use
s ex
isti
ng
ha
rdw
are
ty
pe
an
d c
on
dit
ion
to
est
ima
te r
isk
red
uct
ion
imp
act
. F
or
tra
nsm
issi
on
, P
G&
E a
lso
use
s a
n O
per
ab
ilit
y A
sses
smen
t m
od
el t
ha
t
fact
ors
in
ma
inte
na
nce
ta
gs
/ eq
uip
men
t co
nd
itio
n.
PG
&E
ha
s st
ruct
ure
d i
ts w
ork
ma
na
gem
ent
in a
wa
y t
ha
t p
rio
riti
zes
risk
red
uct
ion
im
pa
ct,
bu
t d
oes
no
t q
ua
nti
fy i
t.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to g
ath
er a
dd
itio
na
l d
ata
th
at
can
be
inco
rpo
rate
d i
nto
calc
ula
tio
ns
use
d t
o e
stim
ate
ris
k r
edu
ctio
n i
mp
act
.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
5R
isk
ma
ps
an
d
sim
ula
tio
n
alg
ori
thm
s
A.V
.aW
ha
t is
th
e p
roto
col
to u
pd
ate
ris
k
ma
pp
ing
alg
ori
thm
s?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
foll
ow
a w
ell
def
ined
pro
cess
fo
r u
pd
ati
ng
ris
k m
ap
pin
g a
lgo
rith
ms.
PG
&E
pla
ns
on
cre
ati
ng
a w
ell
def
ined
pro
cess
es i
n t
he
futu
re.
PG
&E
do
es v
iew
dev
iati
on
s (m
ap
ped
in
ER
WIN
) a
nd
Tec
hn
osy
lva
act
s o
n d
evia
tio
ns.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
5R
isk
ma
ps
an
d
sim
ula
tio
n
alg
ori
thm
s
A.V
.bH
ow
au
tom
ate
d i
s th
e m
ech
an
ism
to
det
erm
ine
wh
eth
er t
o u
pd
ate
alg
ori
thm
s
ba
sed
on
dev
iati
on
s?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
use
s a
pa
rtia
lly
au
tom
ate
d p
roce
ss t
o d
eter
min
e w
het
her
to
up
da
te a
lgo
rith
ms
ba
sed
on
dev
iati
on
s. S
pec
ific
all
y,
Tec
hn
osy
lva
is
lin
ked
to
th
e C
AL
FIR
E f
ire
ale
rt
syst
em.
Th
is a
llo
ws
PG
&E
to
au
tom
ati
call
y a
cces
s a
nd
pro
cess
bu
rn f
oo
tpri
nt
da
ta
wit
h m
ach
ine
lea
rnin
g t
o u
pd
ate
its
sp
rea
d e
stim
ati
on
alg
ori
thm
s. P
G&
E u
ses
pa
rtia
l
au
tom
ati
on
wh
en e
stim
ati
ng
lik
elih
oo
d o
f ig
nit
ion
an
d d
oes
no
t a
nti
cip
ate
in
crea
sed
au
tom
ati
on
in
th
is c
ap
aci
ty.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
5R
isk
ma
ps
an
d
sim
ula
tio
n
alg
ori
thm
s
A.V
.cH
ow
are
dev
iati
on
s fr
om
ris
k m
od
el t
o
ign
itio
ns
an
d p
rop
ag
ati
on
det
ecte
d?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
's p
rop
ag
ati
on
det
ecti
on
s a
re c
alc
ula
ted
sem
i a
uto
ma
tica
lly
, b
ut
ign
itio
ns
dev
iati
on
s a
re n
ot
calc
ula
ted
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E w
ill
be
ma
nu
all
y c
alc
ula
tin
g
ign
itio
ns
dev
iati
on
s.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
5R
isk
ma
ps
an
d
sim
ula
tio
n
alg
ori
thm
s
A.V
.dH
ow
are
dec
isio
ns
to u
pd
ate
alg
ori
thm
s
eva
lua
ted
?
iii
i"I
nd
epen
den
t" c
an
eit
her
be
an
in
tern
al
ass
essm
ent
(in
dep
end
ent
fro
m r
esp
on
sib
le/a
cco
un
tab
le t
eam
)
or
an
ex
tern
al
thir
d p
art
y.
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
ha
s th
e a
bil
ity
to
ch
eck
his
tori
cal
ign
itio
n d
ata
an
d s
ub
seq
uen
tly
ad
just
fu
el i
gn
itio
ns,
bec
au
se m
od
els
rece
ive
inp
uts
fro
m C
AL
FIR
E.
Ad
dit
ion
all
y,
dec
isio
ns
to u
pd
ate
alg
ori
thm
s a
re b
ein
g e
va
lua
ted
by
th
e re
spo
nsi
ble
tea
m.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to u
se i
nd
epen
den
t a
sses
smen
t to
ev
alu
ate
dec
isio
ns
to u
pd
ate
alg
ori
thm
s.
AR
isk
Ma
pp
ing
an
d
Sim
ula
tio
n
5R
isk
ma
ps
an
d
sim
ula
tio
n
alg
ori
thm
s
A.V
.eW
ha
t o
ther
da
ta i
s u
sed
to
ma
ke
dec
isio
ns
on
wh
eth
er t
o u
pd
ate
alg
ori
thm
s?
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y u
ses
his
tori
c ig
nit
ion
an
d p
rop
ag
ati
on
da
ta t
o u
pd
ate
alg
ori
thm
s.
PG
&E
use
s T
ech
no
sylv
a,
wh
ich
als
o h
as
con
tra
cts
wit
h C
AL
FIR
E a
nd
oth
er u
tili
ties
.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to l
ever
ag
e d
ata
fro
m o
ther
uti
liti
es a
nd
oth
er s
ou
rces
, b
ut
an
tici
pa
tes
it b
ein
g d
iffi
cult
to
est
ab
lish
th
is d
ata
sh
ari
ng
an
d i
nte
rch
an
gea
bil
ity
by
20
23
.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
6W
eath
er
va
ria
ble
s
coll
ecte
d
B.I
.aW
ha
t w
eath
er d
ata
is
curr
entl
y
coll
ecte
d?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y c
oll
ects
wea
ther
da
ta f
rom
ov
er 6
00
in
sta
lled
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns.
PG
&E
curr
entl
y c
ap
ture
s h
um
idit
y,
pre
cip
ita
tio
n,
an
d a
tmo
sph
eric
win
d c
on
dit
ion
s. T
his
yea
r, P
G&
E w
ill
imp
rov
e it
s m
ap
pin
g o
f su
rfa
ce f
uel
s th
at
coex
ist
wit
h o
ver
hea
d
ass
ets,
wh
ich
wil
l th
en s
erv
e a
s a
n i
np
ut
for
the
fire
sp
rea
d m
od
el f
or
Tec
hn
osy
lva
.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
6W
eath
er
va
ria
ble
s
coll
ecte
d
B.I
.bH
ow
are
mea
sure
men
ts v
ali
da
ted
?ii
ii"M
easu
rem
ents
" re
fers
to
mea
sure
men
ts t
ak
en f
rom
PG
&E
's w
eath
er s
tati
on
s.
PG
&E
mea
sure
s a
ctu
al
wea
ther
da
ta t
o f
ore
cast
ed d
ata
. T
her
e is
a p
resc
rib
ed
cali
bra
tio
n f
or
ha
rdw
are
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns
tha
t is
a m
an
ua
l p
roce
ss t
ha
t re
qu
ires
dis
pa
tch
of
an
op
era
tor.
PG
&E
bel
iev
es t
he
ind
ust
ry b
est
pra
ctic
e is
ma
nu
al
at
this
tim
e a
nd
th
eref
ore
ha
s n
o p
lan
s to
ad
va
nce
bey
on
d t
his
res
po
nse
. E
xis
tin
g i
nd
ust
ry
bes
t p
ract
ices
are
no
t y
et a
uto
ma
ted
bec
au
se t
he
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns
use
ph
ysi
cal
rota
tin
g
dev
ices
th
at
mu
st b
e m
an
ua
lly
ma
nip
ula
ted
to
rec
eiv
e a
n o
utp
ut
fro
m t
he
sen
sors
.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
6W
eath
er
va
ria
ble
s
coll
ecte
d
B.I
.cA
re e
lem
ents
th
at
can
no
t b
e re
lia
bly
mea
sure
d i
n r
eal
tim
e b
ein
g p
red
icte
d
(e.g
., f
uel
mo
istu
re c
on
ten
t)?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
’s M
eteo
rolo
gy
tea
m u
ses
a h
igh
res
olu
tio
n i
n-h
ou
se m
eso
sca
le f
ore
cast
mo
del
(PO
MM
S)
to g
ener
ate
im
po
rta
nt
fire
wea
ther
pa
ram
eter
s in
clu
din
g w
ind
sp
eed
,
tem
per
atu
re,
rela
tiv
e h
um
idit
y,
an
d p
reci
pit
ati
on
at
a 3
-kil
om
eter
(k
m)
reso
luti
on
.
Ou
tpu
ts f
rom
PO
MM
S a
re u
sed
as
inp
uts
to
th
e N
ati
on
al
Fir
e D
an
ger
Ra
tin
g S
yst
em,
the
Nel
son
Dea
d F
uel
Mo
istu
re (
DF
M)
mo
del
, a
nd
a p
rop
riet
ary
Liv
e F
uel
Mo
istu
re
(LF
M)
mo
del
. In
ord
er t
o i
mp
rov
e th
e L
ive
Fu
el M
ois
ture
da
ta,
PG
&E
ha
s se
nt
ou
t it
s
Sa
fety
In
fra
stu
re P
rote
ctio
n T
eam
s (S
IPT
) to
cli
p s
am
ple
s o
f p
lan
ts a
nd
sh
ip t
o a
la
b
to m
easu
re t
he
mo
istu
re i
n a
n a
rea
. T
o b
ette
r u
nd
erst
an
d a
nd
fo
reca
st t
he
po
ten
tia
l o
f
an
ou
tag
e, P
G&
E a
lso
dev
elo
ped
an
d t
hen
op
era
tio
na
lly
dep
loy
ed t
he
Ou
tag
e
Pro
du
cin
g W
ind
(O
PW
) m
od
el.
See
sec
tio
n 5
.3.2
.1 -
Ad
va
nce
d w
eath
er m
on
ito
rin
g
an
d w
eath
er s
tati
on
s o
f th
e W
MP
fo
r m
ore
in
form
ati
on
on
PG
&E
's w
eath
er d
ata
va
ria
ble
co
llec
tio
n p
roce
ss.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
6W
eath
er
va
ria
ble
s
coll
ecte
d
B.I
.dH
ow
ma
ny
so
urc
es a
re b
ein
g u
sed
to
pro
vid
e d
ata
on
wea
ther
met
rics
bei
ng
coll
ecte
d?
iii
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
co
llec
ts o
ver
a t
era
by
te o
f w
eath
er d
ata
. S
ee s
ecti
on
5.3
.2.1
in
th
e W
MP
-
Ad
va
nce
d w
eath
er m
on
ito
rin
g a
nd
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns
of
the
WM
P f
or
mo
re i
nfo
rma
tio
n
on
PG
&E
's w
eath
er d
ata
va
ria
ble
co
llec
tio
n p
roce
ss.
Atch5-7
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
7W
eath
er d
ata
reso
luti
on
B.I
I.a
Ho
w g
ran
ula
r is
th
e w
eath
er d
ata
th
at
is
coll
ecte
d?
iii
ivW
eath
er d
ata
co
llec
ted
is
on
ly f
rom
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns.
PG
&E
's w
eath
er d
ata
co
llec
tio
n i
ncl
ud
es m
easu
rem
ents
fro
m o
ver
60
0 w
eath
er
sta
tio
ns
wh
ich
are
ca
lib
rate
d i
nto
hig
h r
eso
luti
on
mo
del
s. A
lth
ou
gh
, P
G&
E i
s th
e
larg
est
op
era
tor
of
uti
lity
ow
ned
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns,
it
do
es n
ot
curr
entl
y h
av
e en
ou
gh
wea
ther
pen
etra
tio
n t
o i
den
tify
rid
gel
ines
an
d w
ind
co
rrid
ors
in
a s
yst
ema
tic
fash
ion
an
d i
nst
ead
rel
ies
on
an
ad
ho
c p
roce
ss.
In o
rder
to
bet
ter
pre
dic
t w
eath
er o
n t
he
gri
d,
PG
&E
is
mo
vin
g t
o a
2/k
m r
eso
luti
on
mo
del
wh
ich
in
clu
des
52
ver
tica
l la
yer
s in
th
e
atm
osp
her
e.B
Sit
ua
tio
na
l
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
7W
eath
er d
ata
reso
luti
on
B.I
I.b
Ho
w f
req
uen
tly
is
da
ta g
ath
ered
iviv
Wea
ther
da
ta c
oll
ecte
d i
s o
nly
fro
m w
eath
er
sta
tio
ns.
PG
&E
's w
eath
er s
tati
on
s a
re c
urr
entl
y r
epo
rtin
g d
ata
ev
ery
10
min
ute
s (o
r 6
tim
es p
er
ho
ur)
. P
G&
E p
lan
s to
im
pro
ve
the
freq
uen
cy o
f w
eath
er d
ata
co
llec
ted
, b
ut
do
es n
ot
an
tici
pa
te h
av
ing
th
e a
bil
ity
to
ad
va
nce
to
ev
ery
min
ute
wit
hin
3 y
ears
.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
7W
eath
er d
ata
reso
luti
on
B.I
I.c
Ho
w g
ran
ula
r is
th
e to
ol?
ii
iii
Gra
nu
lari
ty o
f th
e to
ol
refe
rs t
o t
he
act
ua
l w
eath
er
mea
sure
men
ts o
bta
ined
th
rou
gh
PG
&E
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns
PG
&E
's w
eath
er s
tati
on
net
wo
rk i
s p
oin
t b
ase
d a
nd
ag
gre
ga
tes
up
to
a r
egio
na
l le
vel
bu
t ca
n b
e ex
tra
po
late
d t
o c
ircu
it l
evel
. P
G&
E's
sig
nif
ica
ntl
y v
ast
ser
vic
e a
rea
ma
kes
it
cha
llen
gin
g t
o a
gg
reg
ate
at
the
circ
uit
lev
el.
PG
&E
pla
ns
to c
on
tin
ue
to i
nst
all
mo
re
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns
an
d m
ov
e to
a 2
km
res
olu
tio
n b
y t
his
fir
e se
aso
n,
wh
ich
wil
l in
crea
se
wea
ther
da
ta g
ran
ula
rity
.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
7W
eath
er d
ata
reso
luti
on
B.I
I.d
Ho
w a
uto
ma
ted
is
the
pro
cess
to
mea
sure
wea
ther
co
nd
itio
ns?
iviv
Wea
ther
da
ta c
oll
ecte
d i
s o
nly
fro
m w
eath
er
sta
tio
ns.
PG
&E
's p
roce
ss t
o m
easu
re w
eath
er c
on
dit
ion
s is
fu
lly
au
tom
ate
d.
Da
ta f
rom
PG
&E
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns
is f
ed d
irec
tly
in
to a
pu
bli
c w
ebsi
te.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
8W
eath
er
fore
cast
ing
ab
ilit
y
B.I
II.a
Ho
w s
op
his
tica
ted
is
the
uti
lity
's
wea
ther
fo
reca
stin
g c
ap
ab
ilit
y?
iii
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
's w
eath
er f
ore
cast
ing
ca
pa
bil
itie
s u
se a
co
mb
ina
tio
n o
f w
eath
er s
tati
on
s a
nd
exte
rna
l w
eath
er d
ata
to
ma
ke
acc
ura
te f
ore
cast
s a
s in
dic
ate
d i
n s
ecti
on
5.3
.2.1
-
Ad
va
nce
d w
eath
er m
on
ito
rin
g a
nd
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns
of
the
WM
P.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
curr
entl
y u
se r
eal-
tim
e, m
ach
ine
lea
rnin
g c
ap
ab
ilit
ies;
ho
wev
er,
mo
st o
f it
s m
od
els
are
bu
ilt
on
ma
chin
e le
arn
ing
ca
pa
bil
itie
s th
at
giv
es P
G&
E t
he
ab
ilit
y t
o p
ote
nti
all
y
lev
era
ge
in t
he
futu
re.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
8W
eath
er
fore
cast
ing
ab
ilit
y
B.I
II.b
Ho
w f
ar
in a
dv
an
ce c
an
acc
ura
te
fore
cast
s b
e p
rep
are
d?
ii
Wea
ther
ca
n o
nly
be
"acc
ura
tely
" fo
reca
sted
les
s
tha
n t
wo
wee
ks
in a
dv
an
ce.
PG
&E
bel
iev
es t
ha
t a
n a
ccu
rate
wea
ther
fo
reca
st c
an
on
ly b
e p
red
icte
d l
ess
tha
n t
wo
wee
ks
in a
dv
an
ce.
Fo
r th
is r
easo
n,
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
ha
ve
an
y p
lan
s to
ach
iev
e a
sco
re
ab
ov
e a
(i)
in
th
is c
ase
. P
G&
E w
ou
ld v
alu
e th
e o
pp
ort
un
ity
to
en
ga
ge
wit
h a
n e
nti
ty
tha
t h
as
the
ab
ilit
y t
o a
ccu
rate
ly f
ore
cast
th
e w
eath
er a
t le
ast
tw
o w
eek
s in
ad
va
nce
.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
8W
eath
er
fore
cast
ing
ab
ilit
y
B.I
II.c
At
wh
at
lev
el o
f g
ran
ula
rity
ca
n f
ore
cast
s
be
pre
pa
red
?
iii
iii
Wea
ther
da
ta c
oll
ecte
d f
or
fore
cast
s is
on
ly f
rom
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns.
PG
&E
is
curr
entl
y a
ble
to
fo
reca
st a
t th
e ci
rcu
it l
evel
of
gra
nu
lari
ty.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
wil
l h
av
e a
2k
m r
eso
luti
on
gri
d b
ut
wil
l n
ot
be
ab
le t
o s
up
po
rt a
sp
an
lev
el o
f
gra
nu
lari
ty.
PG
&E
wil
l co
nti
nu
e to
fo
reca
st a
t th
e ci
rcu
it l
evel
as
ad
dit
ion
al
gra
nu
lari
ty
to t
he
spa
n l
evel
wil
l n
ot
lea
d t
o i
mp
rov
ed o
per
ati
on
al
act
ion
s.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
8W
eath
er
fore
cast
ing
ab
ilit
y
B.I
II.d
Ho
w a
re r
esu
lts
erro
r-ch
eck
ed?
iii
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
ch
eck
s w
eath
er f
ore
cast
ing
res
ult
s th
rou
gh
co
mp
ari
son
ag
ain
st
his
tori
cal
wea
ther
pa
tter
ns
an
d u
se o
f th
e N
ati
on
al
Cen
ter
for
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pre
dic
tio
n M
od
el E
va
lua
tio
n T
oo
l (N
CE
P M
ET
). T
his
to
ol
com
pa
res
mea
sure
d
wea
ther
da
ta f
rom
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns
an
d p
erfo
rms
au
tom
ati
c er
ror
chec
kin
g.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to c
on
tin
ue
chec
kin
g w
eath
er f
ore
cast
ing
res
ult
s fo
r er
rors
.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
8W
eath
er
fore
cast
ing
ab
ilit
y
B.I
II.e
Ho
w a
uto
ma
ted
is
the
fore
cast
pro
cess
? ii
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E's
fo
reca
stin
g p
roce
ss i
s a
mo
stly
au
tom
ate
d p
roce
ss.
It i
s n
ot
a f
ull
y a
uto
ma
ted
pro
cess
du
e to
th
e fa
ct t
ha
t th
e te
am
ha
s to
ta
ke
the
ou
tpu
ts f
rom
mu
ltip
le a
uto
ma
ted
pro
cess
es (
e.g
., d
eriv
ati
ve
fore
cast
mo
del
s) a
nd
per
form
a m
an
ua
l re
con
cili
ati
on
.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
an
tici
pa
te b
ein
g f
ull
y a
uto
ma
ted
by
20
23
.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
9E
xte
rna
l so
urc
es
use
d i
n w
eath
er
fore
cast
ing
B.I
V.a
Wh
at
sou
rce
do
es t
he
uti
lity
use
fo
r
wea
ther
da
ta?
iii
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
use
s a
co
mb
ina
tio
n o
f a
ccu
rate
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns
an
d e
xte
rna
l w
eath
er
da
ta s
ou
rces
as
men
tio
ned
in
sec
tio
n 5
.3.2
.1 -
Ad
va
nce
d w
eath
er m
on
ito
rin
g a
nd
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns
of
the
WM
P.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to s
tart
co
rrel
ati
ng
wh
ich
wea
ther
da
ta h
as
the
hig
hes
t a
ccu
racy
, b
ut
do
es n
ot
an
tici
pa
te a
chie
vin
g t
he
nec
essa
ry
lev
el o
f p
rog
ram
min
g t
o i
mp
lem
ent
this
in
th
e n
ext
3 y
ears
.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
9E
xte
rna
l so
urc
es
use
d i
n w
eath
er
fore
cast
ing
B.I
V.b
Ho
w i
s w
eath
er s
tati
on
da
ta c
hec
ked
fo
r
erro
rs?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
's w
eath
er s
tati
on
da
ta i
s cu
rren
tly
pro
cess
ed m
an
ua
lly
by
an
ex
tern
al
ven
do
r
usi
ng
au
tom
ate
d t
oo
ls.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
bel
iev
e th
at
va
lid
ati
ng
th
e lo
cati
on
of
its
nu
mer
ou
s w
eath
er s
tati
on
s is
th
e m
ost
eff
ecti
ve
use
of
met
eoro
log
y r
eso
urc
es i
n t
he
nex
t th
ree
yea
rs.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
9E
xte
rna
l so
urc
es
use
d i
n w
eath
er
fore
cast
ing
B.I
V.c
Fo
r w
ha
t is
wea
ther
da
ta u
sed
? ii
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E's
wea
ther
da
ta i
s u
sed
to
cre
ate
a s
ing
le v
isu
al
an
d c
on
fig
ura
ble
liv
e m
ap
(PO
MM
S)
tha
t is
use
d t
o h
elp
ma
ke
dec
isio
ns.
See
sec
tio
n 5
.3.2
.1 -
Ad
va
nce
d w
eath
er
mo
nit
ori
ng
an
d w
eath
er s
tati
on
s o
f th
e W
MP
fo
r m
ore
in
form
ati
on
.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
10W
ild
fire
det
ecti
on
pro
cess
es a
nd
cap
ab
ilit
ies
B.V
.aA
re t
her
e w
ell-
def
ined
pro
ced
ure
s fo
r
det
ecti
ng
ig
nit
ion
s a
lon
g t
he
gri
d?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
's c
urr
ent
pro
ced
ure
s fo
r d
etec
tin
g i
gn
itio
ns
alo
ng
th
e g
rid
in
clu
de
use
of
sate
llit
es,
rad
io m
on
ito
rin
g,
ver
ba
l re
cord
s fr
om
per
son
nel
in
th
e fi
eld
, a
nd
th
e
dis
pa
tch
sy
stem
fo
r C
AL
FIR
E i
n t
he
WS
OC
.
Atch5-8
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
10W
ild
fire
det
ecti
on
pro
cess
es a
nd
cap
ab
ilit
ies
B.V
.bW
ha
t eq
uip
men
t is
use
d t
o d
etec
t
ign
itio
ns?
iviv
No
ne
PG
&E
's W
SO
C u
ses
its
Ou
tag
e M
an
ag
emen
t T
oo
l a
nd
th
e G
OE
S 1
6/1
7 s
ate
llit
e
soft
wa
re,
to d
etec
t ig
nit
ion
s. D
etec
ted
ig
nit
ion
s a
re r
epo
rted
to
an
d m
on
ito
red
by
th
e
WS
OC
's 2
4/7
tea
m.
Th
e W
SO
C t
hen
ap
pli
es i
ts r
emo
tely
op
era
ted
ca
mer
as
to f
urt
her
an
aly
se a
nd
in
ves
tig
ate
an
y r
epo
rted
ig
nit
ion
s.B
Sit
ua
tio
na
l
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
10W
ild
fire
det
ecti
on
pro
cess
es a
nd
cap
ab
ilit
ies
B.V
.cH
ow
is
info
rma
tio
n o
n d
etec
ted
ign
itio
ns
rep
ort
ed?
iii
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
use
s a
mo
stly
au
tom
ate
d p
roce
ss i
n r
epo
rtin
g d
etec
ted
ig
nit
ion
s. F
or
exa
mp
le,
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
ha
s a
n a
uto
ma
ted
em
ail
no
tifi
cati
on
gen
era
ted
fro
m s
ate
llit
e
det
ecti
on
of
ign
itio
n t
ha
t is
dis
trib
ute
d t
o s
up
pre
ssio
n f
orc
es b
ut
no
t n
eces
sari
ly k
ey
sta
keh
old
ers.
PG
&E
's h
um
an
det
ecti
on
rep
ort
ing
pro
ced
ure
dir
ects
per
son
nel
to
dia
l
911
, w
hic
h t
hen
in
vo
lves
fir
e su
pp
ress
ion
fo
rces
. P
G&
E p
erso
nn
el i
n t
he
WS
OC
ha
ve
to g
ener
ate
an
d s
end
s em
ail
ale
rts
to k
ey i
nte
rna
l st
ak
eho
lder
s w
hen
a n
ew f
ire
is
iden
tifi
ed b
y a
hu
ma
n.
PG
&E
's C
ust
om
er C
are
tea
m i
s d
evel
op
ing
a t
oo
l th
at
wil
l b
e
ho
sted
on
th
e P
G&
E w
ebsi
te a
nd
wil
l sh
are
ale
rts
wit
h t
he
pu
bli
c.
BS
itu
ati
on
al
aw
are
nes
s a
nd
fore
cast
ing
10W
ild
fire
det
ecti
on
pro
cess
es a
nd
cap
ab
ilit
ies
B.V
.dW
ha
t ro
le d
oes
ig
nit
ion
det
ecti
on
soft
wa
re p
lay
in
wil
dfi
re d
etec
tio
n?
iiii
PG
&E
is
ma
kin
g t
he
ass
um
pti
on
th
at
"ig
nit
ion
det
ecti
on
so
ftw
are
in
ca
mer
as"
do
es n
ot
mea
n
soft
wa
re h
as
to b
e p
hy
sica
lly
in
th
e a
ctu
al
cam
era
s,
bu
t P
G&
E u
ses
cam
era
s fo
r fu
rth
er i
nv
esti
ga
tio
n o
f
an
y d
etec
tors
id
enti
fied
by
th
e sa
tell
ite
soft
wa
re.
PG
&E
use
s th
e G
OE
S 1
6/1
7 s
oft
wa
re i
n s
ate
llit
es t
o d
etec
t w
ild
fire
s, w
hic
h t
hen
ale
rts
PG
&E
's 2
4/7
WS
OC
, w
hic
h u
ses
rem
ote
ca
mer
as
to f
urt
her
in
ves
tig
ate
th
e si
tua
tio
n.
Th
is i
s cu
rren
tly
no
t a
n a
uto
ma
ted
pro
cess
es.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
pla
n t
o c
ha
ng
e th
is
det
ecti
on
pro
cess
in
th
e n
ear
futu
re.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
11A
pp
roa
ch t
o
pri
ori
tizi
ng
init
iati
ves
acr
oss
terr
ito
ry
C.I
.aH
ow
are
wil
dfi
re r
isk
red
uct
ion
init
iati
ves
pri
ori
tize
d?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E's
cu
rren
t p
lan
fo
cuse
s o
n t
he
per
form
an
ce o
f th
e g
rid
an
d p
rio
riti
zes
wil
dfi
re
risk
red
uct
ion
in
itia
tiv
es a
t th
e p
rote
ctio
n z
on
e (m
ore
gra
nu
lar
tha
n c
ircu
it)
lev
el.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
yet
ta
ke
into
acc
ou
nt
loca
l g
eog
rap
hie
s a
nd
cli
ma
te/w
eath
er
con
dit
ion
s. I
n t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to p
rio
riti
ze w
ild
fire
ris
k r
edu
ctio
n i
nit
iati
ves
targ
etin
g t
he
pro
tect
ion
zo
ne
lev
el,
ba
sed
on
ris
k m
od
elin
g d
riv
en b
y l
oca
l g
eog
rap
hy
an
d c
lim
ate
/wea
ther
co
nd
itio
ns,
fu
el l
oa
ds
an
d m
ois
ture
co
nte
nt
an
d t
op
og
rap
hy
.
No
te:
PG
&E
ha
s so
me
PS
PS
mit
iga
tio
ns
tha
t im
pa
ct n
on
HF
TD
are
as.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
12G
rid
des
ign
fo
r
min
imiz
ing
ign
itio
n r
isk
C.I
I.a
Do
es g
rid
des
ign
mee
t m
inim
um
G0
95
req
uir
emen
ts a
nd
lo
ad
ing
sta
nd
ard
s in
HF
TD
are
as?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E's
cu
rren
t g
rid
des
ign
mee
ts m
inim
um
GO
95
req
uir
emen
ts a
nd
lo
ad
ing
sta
nd
ard
s in
HF
TD
are
as.
PG
&E
rec
og
niz
es t
ha
t ci
rcu
its
on
rid
ge
lin
es m
ay
nee
d
dif
fere
nt
des
ign
cen
ters
an
d p
lan
s to
im
pro
ve
gri
d t
op
olo
gy
des
ign
req
uir
emen
ts i
n t
he
futu
re b
y i
nco
rpo
rati
ng
des
ign
s b
ase
d o
n a
n u
nd
erst
an
din
g o
f d
riv
ers
of
uti
lity
ign
itio
n r
isk
.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
12G
rid
des
ign
fo
r
min
imiz
ing
ign
itio
n r
isk
C.I
I.b
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
pro
vid
e m
icro
gri
ds
or
isla
nd
ing
wh
ere
tra
dit
ion
al
gri
d
infr
ast
ruct
ure
is
imp
ract
ica
ble
an
d
wil
dfi
re r
isk
is
hig
h?
iiii
Mic
rog
rid
s in
clu
des
tem
po
rary
gen
era
tio
n f
aci
liti
es.
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
pro
vid
es m
icro
gri
ds
wh
ere
tra
dit
ion
al
gri
d i
nfr
ast
ruct
ure
is
imp
ract
ica
ble
an
d w
ild
fire
ris
k i
s h
igh
. F
or
exa
mp
le,
du
rin
g t
he
PS
PS
ev
ents
th
at
too
k
pla
ce b
etw
een
Oct
ob
er 2
6-2
9 2
019
, P
G&
E p
rov
ided
tem
po
rary
gen
era
tio
n i
n t
he
form
of
mic
ro g
rid
s. T
hes
e te
mp
ora
ry g
ener
ati
on
so
luti
on
s h
elp
ed k
eep
po
wer
on
fo
r
ap
pro
xim
ate
ly 4
,86
0 c
ust
om
ers
acr
oss
po
rtio
ns
of
An
gw
in,
Ca
list
og
a,
Gra
ss V
all
ey,
an
d P
lace
rvil
le.
PG
&E
pla
ns
to c
on
tin
ue
an
d e
xp
an
d t
he
sta
nd
up
of
mic
ro g
rid
s fo
r
the
fore
seea
ble
fu
ture
.C
Gri
d d
esig
n a
nd
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
12G
rid
des
ign
fo
r
min
imiz
ing
ign
itio
n r
isk
C.I
I.c
Do
es r
ou
tin
g o
f n
ew p
ort
ion
s o
f th
e g
rid
tak
e w
ild
fire
ris
k i
nto
acc
ou
nt?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
's c
urr
ent
pro
cess
fo
r ro
uti
ng
new
po
rtio
ns
of
the
gri
d i
nv
olv
es a
pre
-wa
lk d
on
e
wit
h e
ng
inee
rin
g.
Th
e sy
stem
ha
rden
ing
pro
toco
l ta
kes
wil
dfi
re r
isk
in
to a
cco
un
t b
y
inv
olv
ing
a P
ub
lic
Sa
fety
Sp
ecia
list
(P
SS
) to
rem
ov
e a
sset
s w
hen
nec
essa
ry a
nd
dee
med
fea
sib
le.
PG
&E
's p
roto
col
is t
o r
ebu
ild
in
des
ign
, so
wh
en i
t is
no
t d
eem
ed
fea
sib
le t
o r
emo
ve
an
ass
et,
PG
&E
wil
l p
ut
it u
nd
erg
rou
nd
or
re-r
ou
te i
t.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
12G
rid
des
ign
fo
r
min
imiz
ing
ign
itio
n r
isk
C.I
I.d
Are
eff
ort
s m
ad
e to
in
corp
ora
te t
he
late
st a
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
stra
teg
ies
an
d
new
tec
hn
olo
gie
s in
to g
rid
to
po
log
y?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y m
ak
es e
ffo
rts
to i
nco
rpo
rate
th
e la
test
ass
et m
an
ag
emen
t st
rate
gie
s
an
d n
ew t
ech
no
log
ies
into
th
e g
rid
to
po
log
y.
Fo
r ex
am
ple
, a
t th
e en
d o
f 2
019
, P
G&
E
wo
rked
on
tes
tin
g t
he
mo
st e
ffec
tiv
e a
nd
fir
e re
sili
ent
po
les
for
syst
em h
ard
enin
g w
ith
a t
hir
d p
art
y l
ab
ora
tory
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E p
lan
s to
in
corp
ora
te a
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
stra
teg
ies
an
d t
ech
no
log
ies
acr
oss
th
e en
tire
ser
vic
e te
rrit
ory
ba
sed
on
ris
k s
pen
d
effi
cien
cy.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
13G
rid
des
ign
fo
r
resi
lien
cy a
nd
min
imiz
ing
PS
PS
C.I
II.a
Wh
at
lev
el o
f re
du
nd
an
cy d
oes
th
e
uti
lity
’s t
ran
smis
sio
n a
rch
itec
ture
ha
ve?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
's l
evel
of
red
un
da
ncy
fo
r tr
an
smis
sio
n a
rch
itec
ture
is
no
t en
tire
ly n
-1
red
un
da
nt,
alt
ho
ug
h m
ajo
rity
of
all
cir
cuit
s a
re.
PG
&E
is
min
imiz
ing
PS
PS
im
pa
cts
thro
ug
h m
icro
gri
ds,
tra
nsm
issi
on
lin
e ex
clu
sio
n,
incr
easi
ng
RO
W c
lea
ran
ce,
an
d
inst
all
ing
tra
nsm
issi
on
lin
e sw
itch
es.
PG
&E
fee
ls t
hes
e m
itig
ati
on
eff
ort
s m
ak
e m
ore
sen
se t
ha
n b
uil
din
g o
ut
pa
rall
el t
ran
smis
sio
n l
ines
to
in
crea
se r
edu
nd
an
cy.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
13G
rid
des
ign
fo
r
resi
lien
cy a
nd
min
imiz
ing
PS
PS
C.I
II.b
Wh
at
lev
el o
f re
du
nd
an
cy d
oes
th
e
uti
lity
’s d
istr
ibu
tio
n a
rch
itec
ture
ha
ve?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
's l
evel
of
red
un
da
ncy
fo
r d
istr
ibu
tio
n a
rch
itec
ture
is
no
t n
-1 r
edu
nd
an
t. P
G&
E
is m
inim
izin
g P
SP
S i
mp
act
s th
rou
gh
mic
rog
rid
s, d
istr
ibu
tio
n s
egm
enta
tio
n,
an
d
incr
easi
ng
rig
ht
of
wa
y c
lea
ran
ce.
PG
&E
fee
ls t
hes
e m
itig
ati
on
eff
ort
s a
re t
he
mo
st
pra
ctic
al
stra
teg
y.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
13G
rid
des
ign
fo
r
resi
lien
cy a
nd
min
imiz
ing
PS
PS
C.I
II.c
Wh
at
lev
el o
f se
ctio
na
liza
tio
n d
oes
th
e
uti
lity
’s d
istr
ibu
tio
n a
rch
itec
ture
ha
ve?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
aim
s to
use
sw
itch
es i
n H
FT
D a
rea
s to
in
div
idu
all
y i
sola
te c
ircu
its
such
th
at
no
mo
re t
ha
n 2
,00
0 c
ust
om
ers
sit
wit
hin
on
e sw
itch
, h
ow
ever
in
so
me
pa
rts
of
its
serv
ice
terr
ito
ry,
in p
art
icu
lar
tho
se t
ha
t a
re r
ad
iall
y f
ed,
it c
an
no
t is
ola
te l
ess
tha
n 2
,00
0
cust
om
ers
wit
hin
on
e sw
itch
. A
lso
, P
G&
E c
an
no
t m
inim
ize
imp
act
to
cu
sto
mer
s ju
st
on
sec
tio
na
liza
tio
n,
an
oth
er s
up
ply
so
urc
e is
nee
ded
.
Atch5-9
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
13G
rid
des
ign
fo
r
resi
lien
cy a
nd
min
imiz
ing
PS
PS
C.I
II.d
Ho
w d
oes
th
e u
tili
ty c
on
sid
er e
gre
ss
po
ints
in
its
gri
d t
op
olo
gy
?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
use
s eg
ress
po
ints
as
an
in
pu
t fo
r g
rid
to
po
log
y.
In 2
019
, P
G&
E
con
du
cted
a m
acr
o l
evel
of
an
aly
sis
for
egre
ss.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
is
wo
rkin
g t
o
per
form
hig
her
pre
cisi
on
an
aly
ses
wit
h e
gre
ss a
s a
n i
np
ut
to g
rid
to
po
log
y,
bu
t d
oes
no
t a
nti
cip
ate
get
tin
g t
o t
he
po
int
of
esti
ma
tin
g a
n e
xa
ct e
va
cua
tio
n t
ime
for
ever
y
cust
om
er.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
14R
isk
-ba
sed
gri
d
ha
rden
ing
an
d
cost
eff
icie
ncy
C.I
V.a
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
ha
ve
an
un
der
sta
nd
ing
of
the
risk
sp
end
eff
icie
ncy
of
ha
rden
ing
init
iati
ves
?
iiii
"Acc
ura
te"
mea
ns
as
clo
se t
o a
ccu
rate
as
po
ssib
le.
PG
&E
ha
s cl
ear
un
der
sta
nd
ing
of
the
rela
tiv
e co
st a
nd
eff
ecti
ven
ess
of
dif
fere
nt
init
iati
ves
. A
ccu
racy
ma
y n
ot
alw
ay
s b
e a
chie
ved
in
ev
ery
cir
cum
sta
nce
, b
ut
tha
t is
PG
&E
's g
oa
l. A
lth
ou
gh
it
ma
y n
ot
be
ach
iev
ed i
n t
he
nex
t th
ree
yea
rs,
PG
&E
is
wo
rkin
g t
ow
ard
s a
nd
th
riv
es t
o g
et t
o a
n u
ltim
ate
go
al
of
tail
ore
d c
ircu
mst
an
ces
of
dif
fere
nt
loca
tio
ns,
as
ever
y c
ircu
it p
rote
ctio
n z
on
e sh
ou
ld b
e ev
alu
ate
d f
or
risk
sp
end
effi
cien
cy.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
14R
isk
-ba
sed
gri
d
ha
rden
ing
an
d
cost
eff
icie
ncy
C.I
V.b
At
wh
at
lev
el c
an
est
ima
tes
be
pre
pa
red
?ii
iii
iN
on
eW
hil
e P
G&
E c
an
cu
rren
tly
pre
pa
re r
isk
ba
sed
gri
d h
ard
enin
g a
nd
co
st e
ffic
ien
cy
esti
ma
tes
at
the
pro
tect
ion
zo
ne
lev
el (
wh
ich
ca
n b
e a
su
bse
t o
f a
cir
cuit
), P
G&
E h
as
a
sta
nd
ard
ap
pro
ach
fo
r co
mp
ari
ng
in
itia
tiv
es a
nd
do
es n
ot
alw
ay
s es
tim
ate
at
the
circ
uit
lev
el.
PG
&E
bel
iev
es i
ncr
easi
ng
gra
nu
lari
ty t
o t
he
spa
n o
r a
sset
ba
se i
n t
he
futu
re w
ou
ld n
ot
be
ap
pro
pri
ate
an
d p
rese
nts
dif
ficu
lty
in
est
ima
tin
g r
isk
lev
els.
PG
&E
pla
ns
to u
se a
cir
cuit
ba
sed
ris
k e
stim
ate
or
mo
re g
ran
ula
r a
s n
eces
sary
(e.
g.
pro
tect
ion
zo
ne)
.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
14R
isk
-ba
sed
gri
d
ha
rden
ing
an
d
cost
eff
icie
ncy
C.I
V.c
Ho
w f
req
uen
tly
are
est
ima
tes
up
da
ted
? ii
iii
Th
is i
s m
easu
red
at
the
wil
dfi
re m
itig
ati
on
lev
el a
nd
is n
ot
on
ly a
t th
e g
rid
ha
rden
ing
pro
gra
m l
evel
.
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
est
ima
tes
wil
dfi
re m
itig
ati
on
ris
k s
pen
d e
ffic
ien
cy e
stim
ate
s le
ss
freq
uen
tly
th
an
an
nu
all
y a
nd
aim
s to
ach
iev
e a
nn
ua
l u
pd
ate
s.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
14R
isk
-ba
sed
gri
d
ha
rden
ing
an
d
cost
eff
icie
ncy
C.I
V.d
Wh
at
gri
d h
ard
enin
g i
nit
iati
ves
do
es t
he
uti
lity
in
clu
de
wit
hin
its
ev
alu
ati
on
?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y i
ncl
ud
es s
om
e g
rid
ha
rden
ing
in
itia
tiv
es w
ith
in i
ts r
isk
sp
end
effi
cien
cy e
va
lua
tio
n.
Fo
r ex
am
ple
, re
pla
cin
g n
on
-ex
emp
t eq
uip
men
t w
ith
sy
stem
ha
rden
ing
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E w
ill
focu
s o
n i
den
tify
ing
th
e co
mp
on
ents
th
at
yie
ld t
he
hig
hes
t ri
sk a
nd
wil
l in
clu
de
mo
re i
nit
iati
ves
th
at
are
aim
ed t
o r
emed
iate
th
ese
hig
h
risk
s in
its
ris
k s
pen
d e
ffic
ien
cy e
va
lua
tio
n.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
14R
isk
-ba
sed
gri
d
ha
rden
ing
an
d
cost
eff
icie
ncy
C.I
V.e
Ca
n t
he
uti
lity
ev
alu
ate
ris
k r
edu
ctio
n
syn
erg
ies
fro
m c
om
bin
ati
on
of
va
rio
us
init
iati
ves
?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
eva
lua
te r
isk
red
uct
ion
sy
ner
gie
s fr
om
co
mb
inin
g v
ari
ou
s in
itia
tiv
es a
t
this
tim
e b
eca
use
mo
re p
reci
sio
n i
s n
eed
ed.
In t
he
futu
re,
eva
lua
tin
g r
isk
sp
end
effi
cien
cy o
n s
yn
erg
y i
nit
iati
ves
wil
l b
e a
chie
va
ble
at
the
ass
et l
evel
.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
15G
rid
des
ign
an
d
ass
et i
nn
ov
ati
on
C.V
.aH
ow
are
new
ha
rden
ing
so
luti
on
init
iati
ves
ev
alu
ate
d?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y e
va
lua
tes
new
ha
rden
ing
so
luti
on
in
itia
tiv
es b
ase
d o
n i
nst
all
ati
on
in
to
gri
d a
nd
mea
suri
ng
dir
ect
red
uct
ion
in
ig
nit
ion
ev
ents
. F
or
exa
mp
le,
PG
&E
is
con
du
ctin
g a
pil
ot
in C
ali
sto
ga
usi
ng
Ra
pid
Ea
rth
Fa
ult
Cu
rren
t L
imit
er (
RE
FC
L)
pro
gra
m w
hic
h h
as
bee
n c
on
du
cted
wit
h S
iem
ens
an
d a
uti
lity
in
Au
stra
lia
. P
G&
E h
as
an
AT
S t
eam
th
at
is v
ery
ad
ept
in a
sses
sin
g v
iab
ilit
y o
f in
itia
tiv
es.
Mo
vin
g f
orw
ard
,
PG
&E
wil
l le
ver
ag
e in
dep
end
ent
thir
d p
art
y e
va
lua
tio
n w
hen
dee
med
ap
pro
pri
ate
. F
or
exa
mp
le,
PG
&E
is
test
ing
an
ult
raso
un
d i
nsp
ecti
on
met
ho
do
log
y i
n S
ou
th K
ore
a t
ha
t
is b
ein
g e
va
lua
ted
by
a t
hir
d p
art
y.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
15G
rid
des
ign
an
d
ass
et i
nn
ov
ati
on
C.V
.bA
re r
esu
lts
of
pil
ot
an
d c
om
mer
cia
l
dep
loy
men
ts,
incl
ud
ing
pro
ject
per
form
an
ce,
pro
ject
co
st,
geo
gra
ph
y,
clim
ate
, v
eget
ati
on
etc
. sh
are
d i
n
suff
icie
nt
det
ail
to
in
form
dec
isio
n
ma
kin
g a
t o
ther
uti
liti
es?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
sha
re p
ilo
t a
nd
co
mm
erci
al
dep
loy
men
t p
roje
ct d
ata
wit
h o
ther
uti
liti
es.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
wil
l fo
cus
on
sh
ari
ng
su
ch d
ata
wit
h t
he
sta
te a
nd
uti
liti
es w
ith
sim
ila
r o
per
ati
ng
en
vir
on
men
ts (
e.g
., A
ust
rali
a).
PG
&E
wil
l co
nti
nu
e to
sha
re i
nfo
rma
tio
n w
ith
in
du
stry
an
d a
cad
emia
, b
ut
no
t ex
ten
siv
ely
dri
ve
soci
ali
zati
on
.
CG
rid
des
ign
an
d
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
15G
rid
des
ign
an
d
ass
et i
nn
ov
ati
on
C.V
.cIs
per
form
an
ce o
f n
ew i
nit
iati
ves
ind
epen
den
tly
au
dit
ed?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
is
curr
entl
y r
equ
ired
to
rec
eiv
e in
dep
end
ent
au
dit
s a
s p
art
of
pro
ba
tio
n,
bu
t th
is
do
es n
ot
spec
ific
all
y c
ov
er n
ew i
nit
iati
ves
. P
G&
E h
as
a t
ech
nic
all
y a
dep
t A
TP
tea
m
tha
t is
ab
le t
o p
rov
ide
a s
ign
ific
an
t a
mo
un
t o
f o
ver
sig
ht
inte
rna
lly
to
un
der
sta
nd
th
e
effe
ctiv
enes
s (o
r la
ck t
her
eof)
of
new
in
itia
tiv
es.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
wil
l co
nti
nu
e to
use
in
dep
end
ent
au
dit
s w
hen
dee
med
nec
essa
ry a
nd
fin
an
cia
lly
ap
pro
pri
ate
fo
r n
ew
init
iati
ves
.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
16A
sset
in
ven
tory
an
d c
on
dit
ion
ass
essm
ents
D.I
.aW
ha
t in
form
ati
on
is
cap
ture
d i
n t
he
equ
ipm
ent
inv
ento
ry d
ata
ba
se?
iiii
i1)
No
ass
et m
an
ag
emen
t p
rog
ram
is
100
% a
ccu
rate
-
ther
e is
an
ass
um
ed m
arg
in o
f er
ror.
2)
Th
e ex
pec
ted
lif
ecy
cle
is n
ot
at
the
com
po
nen
t
lev
el.
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
ma
inta
ins
an
in
ven
tory
of
equ
ipm
ent
tha
t m
ay
co
ntr
ibu
te t
o w
ild
fire
risk
. T
he
inv
ento
ry r
epo
rts
equ
ipm
ent
ag
e, c
on
dit
ion
, a
nd
lif
e cy
cle.
In
th
e fu
ture
,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to f
urt
her
dig
itiz
e th
is e
ffo
rt t
o i
ncl
ud
e eq
uip
men
t in
spec
tio
n r
eco
rds
an
d
rep
air
s in
on
e ce
ntr
al
da
tab
ase
.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
16A
sset
in
ven
tory
an
d c
on
dit
ion
ass
essm
ents
D.I
.bH
ow
fre
qu
entl
y i
s th
e co
nd
itio
n
ass
essm
ent
up
da
ted
?
iiii
i."C
on
dit
ion
ass
essm
ent"
mea
ns
the
tim
e it
ta
kes
to
up
da
te t
he
syst
ems
aft
er t
he
insp
ecti
on
s a
re
com
ple
ted
.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
up
da
te c
on
dit
ion
ass
essm
ents
in
th
e d
ata
ba
se s
yst
em o
uts
ide
the
HF
TD
s. I
n t
he
HF
TD
s, P
G&
E u
pd
ate
s th
e sy
stem
aft
er i
nsp
ecti
on
s a
nd
on
an
an
nu
al
ba
sis.
In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E p
lan
s to
up
da
te t
he
syst
em o
n a
qu
art
erly
ba
sis.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
16A
sset
in
ven
tory
an
d c
on
dit
ion
ass
essm
ents
D.I
.cD
oes
all
eq
uip
men
t in
HF
TD
are
as
ha
ve
the
ab
ilit
y t
o d
etec
t a
nd
res
po
nd
to
ma
lfu
nct
ion
s?
iiii
"All
eq
uip
men
t" d
oes
no
t in
clu
de
ever
y a
ttri
bu
te
(e.g
. co
mp
on
ent
ma
nu
fact
ure
r),
for
ever
y
com
po
nen
t o
f th
e a
sset
.
PG
&E
ha
s a
sy
stem
an
d a
pp
roa
ch i
n p
lace
to
rel
iab
ly d
etec
t m
alf
un
ctio
ns
lik
ely
to
cau
se i
gn
itio
n i
n t
he
HF
TD
are
as.
Co
nti
nu
ou
s m
on
ito
rin
g o
f eq
uip
men
t is
no
t li
kel
y
du
e to
th
e fa
ct t
ha
t P
G&
E's
ser
vic
e te
rrit
ory
is
qu
ite
exte
nsi
ve.
Atch5-10
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
16A
sset
in
ven
tory
an
d c
on
dit
ion
ass
essm
ents
D.I
.dH
ow
gra
nu
lar
is t
he
inv
ento
ry?
iii
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
tra
cks
inv
ento
ry a
t th
e a
sset
lev
el.
Ea
ch p
ole
ha
s a
n e
qu
ipm
ent
ID i
n
SA
P.
PG
&E
pla
ns
to c
on
tin
ue
ma
inta
inin
g a
n i
nv
ento
ry a
t th
e a
sset
lev
el i
n t
he
futu
re.
It i
s im
po
rta
nt
to n
ote
th
at
no
t a
ll a
ttri
bu
tes
are
kn
ow
n a
t th
e a
sset
lev
el.
Fo
r ex
am
ple
,
com
po
nen
t m
an
ufa
ctu
rer
ma
y n
ot
be
kn
ow
n.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
17A
sset
in
spec
tio
n
cycl
e
D.I
I.a
Ho
w f
req
uen
t a
re y
ou
r p
atr
ol
insp
ecti
on
s?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y p
erfo
rms
pa
tro
l in
spec
tio
ns
on
tra
nsm
issi
on
an
d d
istr
ibu
tio
n a
sset
s
an
nu
all
y.
Th
is f
req
uen
cy i
s co
nsi
sten
t w
ith
min
imu
m r
egu
lato
ry r
equ
irem
ents
. In
th
e
futu
re,
the
pro
gra
m i
s m
ov
ing
fro
m a
pre
scri
pti
ve
tim
e cy
cle
freq
uen
cy t
o a
n a
pp
roa
ch
dri
ven
by
ris
k,
wit
h t
he
hig
hes
t ri
sk a
sset
s re
qu
irin
g m
ore
fre
qu
ent
an
d i
n-d
epth
insp
ecti
on
s th
an
lo
wer
ris
k a
sset
s. R
isk
is
dri
ven
by
ass
et h
ealt
h a
nd
co
nse
qu
ence
s o
f
ass
et f
ail
ure
s.D
Ass
et m
an
ag
emen
t
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
17A
sset
in
spec
tio
n
cycl
e
D.I
I.b
Ho
w a
re p
atr
ol
insp
ecti
on
s sc
hed
ule
d?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
sch
edu
les
pa
tro
l in
spec
tio
ns
ba
sed
on
an
nu
al
sch
edu
les
ou
tlin
ed i
n
gu
ida
nce
do
cum
ents
an
d i
n a
cco
rda
nce
wit
h r
egu
lato
ry r
equ
irem
ents
GO
16
5.
PG
&E
wil
l b
e sc
hed
uli
ng
pa
tro
l in
spec
tio
ns
on
up
-to
da
te s
tati
c m
ap
s o
f eq
uip
men
t ty
pes
an
d
env
iro
nm
ent
an
d i
s w
ork
ing
to
wa
rds
dev
elo
pin
g p
red
icti
ve
mo
del
ing
ca
pa
bil
itie
s.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
17A
sset
in
spec
tio
n
cycl
e
D.I
I.c
Wh
at
are
th
e in
pu
ts t
o s
ched
uli
ng
pa
tro
l
insp
ecti
on
s?
ii
Pa
tro
l sc
hed
ule
s a
re d
riv
en b
y t
he
reg
ula
tory
req
uir
emen
t.
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
up
da
tes
the
pa
tro
ls s
ched
ule
an
nu
all
y (
ba
sed
on
th
e m
inim
um
reg
ula
tory
req
uir
emen
t) w
ith
fu
ture
pla
ns
to m
ov
e to
a m
ore
dy
na
mic
an
d r
isk
-ba
sed
ap
pro
ach
th
at
wil
l ev
entu
all
y a
llo
w P
G&
E t
o i
mp
lem
ent
pre
dic
tiv
e m
od
elin
g o
f
equ
ipm
ent
fail
ure
pro
ba
bil
ity
an
d r
isk
.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
17A
sset
in
spec
tio
n
cycl
e
D.I
I.d
Ho
w f
req
uen
t a
re d
eta
iled
in
spec
tio
ns?
iii
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
per
form
s d
eta
iled
in
spec
tio
ns
of
tra
nsm
issi
on
an
d d
istr
ibu
tio
n l
ines
ab
ov
e m
inim
um
reg
ula
tory
req
uir
emen
ts i
n H
FT
D,
wit
h m
ore
fre
qu
ent
insp
ecti
on
s
for
hig
hes
t ri
sk e
qu
ipm
ent.
As
emer
gin
g t
ech
no
log
y b
eco
mes
av
ail
ab
le,
PG
&E
wil
l
con
tin
ue
to e
va
lua
te i
ts e
ffec
tiv
enes
s fo
r im
pro
vin
g i
nsp
ecti
on
s.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
17A
sset
in
spec
tio
n
cycl
e
D.I
I.e
Ho
w a
re d
eta
iled
in
spec
tio
ns
sch
edu
led
? i
iiN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y p
erfo
rms
det
ail
ed i
nsp
ecti
on
s o
f tr
an
smis
sio
n a
nd
dis
trib
uti
on
lin
es
ba
sed
on
a p
erio
dic
sch
edu
le.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
wil
l im
ple
men
t a
n a
na
lyti
cal
risk
info
rmed
ap
pro
ach
th
at
wil
l en
ab
le a
pre
dic
tiv
e ca
pa
bil
ity
fo
r sc
hed
uli
ng
det
ail
ed
insp
ecti
on
s.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
17A
sset
in
spec
tio
n
cycl
e
D.I
I.f
Wh
at
are
th
e in
pu
ts t
o s
ched
uli
ng
det
ail
ed i
nsp
ecti
on
s?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
's c
urr
ent
inp
uts
to
sch
edu
lin
g d
eta
iled
in
spec
tio
ns
are
ba
sed
on
up
-to
da
te
sta
tic
ma
ps
of
equ
ipm
ent
typ
es a
nd
en
vir
on
men
t. P
G&
E i
s w
ork
ing
to
wa
rds
dev
elo
pin
g p
red
icti
ve
mo
del
ing
ca
pa
bil
itie
s o
f eq
uip
men
t fa
ilu
res
an
d r
isk
.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
17A
sset
in
spec
tio
n
cycl
e
D.I
I.g
Ho
w f
req
uen
t a
re y
ou
r o
ther
insp
ecti
on
s?
iiii
Th
e fr
equ
ency
of
Po
le T
est
& T
rea
t (P
T&
T)
insp
ecti
on
s fo
llo
ws
the
10 y
ear
reg
ula
tory
req
uir
emen
t.
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
per
form
s se
ver
al
typ
es o
f o
ther
in
spec
tio
ns.
Th
e ca
den
ce o
f th
ese
oth
er i
nsp
ecti
on
s v
ary
, b
ut
are
ali
gn
ed w
ith
or
ab
ov
e m
inim
um
reg
ula
tory
req
uir
emen
ts.
Fo
r ex
am
ple
, P
ole
Tes
t &
Tre
at
insp
ecti
on
s a
re c
on
du
cted
ev
ery
ten
yea
rs,
as
req
uir
ed b
y r
egu
lato
ry r
equ
irem
ent.
Oth
er i
nsp
ecti
on
s a
re p
erfo
rmed
ab
ov
e
the
min
imu
m r
egu
lato
ry r
equ
irem
ent
as
ther
e is
cu
rren
tly
no
reg
ula
tio
ns
gu
idin
g t
he
freq
uen
cy o
f th
ese
oth
er i
nsp
ecti
on
s. T
her
e a
re d
iffe
ren
t g
uid
an
ce d
ocu
men
ts
go
ver
nin
g t
he
dif
fere
nt
typ
es o
f in
spec
tio
ns
(PT
&T
, in
fra
red
, L
iDA
R,
Co
ron
aC
am
, et
c).
PG
&E
wil
l co
nti
nu
e to
per
form
oth
er i
nsp
ecti
on
s a
s n
eces
sary
an
d i
n o
r ex
ceed
ing
com
pli
an
ce w
ith
an
y r
egu
lato
ry s
tan
da
rds.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
17A
sset
in
spec
tio
n
cycl
e
D.I
I.h
Ho
w a
re o
ther
in
spec
tio
ns
sch
edu
led
?i
iiN
on
eP
G&
E's
oth
er i
nsp
ecti
on
s a
re c
urr
entl
y s
ched
ule
d b
ase
d o
n a
nn
ua
l o
r p
erio
dic
sch
edu
les,
dep
end
ing
on
th
e ty
pe
of
insp
ecti
on
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E w
ill
be
sch
edu
lin
g
oth
er i
nsp
ecti
on
s o
n u
p-t
o d
ate
sta
tic
ma
ps
of
equ
ipm
ent
typ
es a
nd
en
vir
on
men
t.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
17A
sset
in
spec
tio
n
cycl
e
D.I
I.i
Wh
at
are
th
e in
pu
ts t
o s
ched
uli
ng
oth
er
insp
ecti
on
s?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
per
form
s se
ver
al
typ
es o
f o
ther
in
spec
tio
ns
(PT
&T
, in
fra
red
, L
iDA
R,
Co
ron
aC
am
, et
c).
Th
e in
pu
ts d
eter
min
ing
th
e fr
equ
ency
of
thes
e o
ther
in
spec
tio
ns
va
ry a
s th
ey a
re s
up
ple
men
tary
in
spec
tio
ns
tha
t m
ay
no
t b
e g
ov
ern
ed b
y r
egu
lato
ry
req
uir
emen
ts.
Th
ere
are
dif
fere
nt
gu
ida
nce
do
cum
ents
go
ver
nin
g t
he
dif
fere
nt
typ
es o
f
insp
ecti
on
s a
nd
th
eir
sch
edu
le.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
wil
l u
se p
red
icti
ve
mo
del
ing
of
equ
ipm
ent
fail
ure
pro
ba
bil
ity
an
d r
isk
to
do
det
erm
ine
the
insp
ecti
on
cy
cles
.
Atch5-11
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
18A
sset
in
spec
tio
n
effe
ctiv
enes
s
D.I
II.a
Wh
at
item
s a
re c
ap
ture
d w
ith
in
insp
ecti
on
pro
ced
ure
s a
nd
ch
eck
list
s?
iiii
iP
G&
E a
nsw
ered
un
der
th
e a
ssu
mp
tio
n t
ha
t d
iffe
ren
t
insp
ecti
on
ty
pes
ha
ve
chec
kli
sts
wit
h d
iffe
ren
t le
vel
s
of
det
ail
.
PG
&E
's c
urr
ent
pa
tro
l, d
eta
iled
, en
ha
nce
d,
an
d o
ther
in
spec
tio
n p
roce
du
res
an
d
chec
kli
sts
incl
ud
e a
ll i
tem
s re
qu
ired
by
sta
tute
an
d r
egu
lati
on
s. T
he
insp
ecti
on
chec
kli
sts
are
usu
all
y a
tta
chm
ents
to
th
e st
an
da
rd o
r p
roce
du
re.
Th
e fa
cto
rs c
urr
entl
y
dic
tati
ng
th
e in
spec
tio
n c
hec
kli
sts
are
lin
ked
to
th
e a
sset
ty
pe,
mo
da
lity
an
d
tech
no
log
y.
In f
utu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to i
ncl
ud
es l
ines
an
d e
qu
ipm
ent
typ
ica
lly
resp
on
sib
le f
or
ign
itio
ns
an
d n
ear
mis
ses
in t
he
chec
kli
sts
in o
rder
to
in
crea
se a
sset
insp
ecti
on
eff
ecti
ven
ess
to b
e m
ore
a r
isk
ba
sed
pro
cess
.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
18A
sset
in
spec
tio
n
effe
ctiv
enes
s
D.I
II.b
Ho
w a
re p
roce
du
res
an
d c
hec
kli
sts
det
erm
ined
?
ii
Ass
um
pti
on
- t
he
qu
esti
on
is
ask
ing
fo
r a
dif
fere
nt
pro
ced
ure
an
d/o
r ch
eck
list
fo
r ea
ch i
nsp
ecti
on
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
det
erm
ines
pro
ced
ure
s a
nd
ch
eck
list
ba
sed
on
sta
tute
an
d r
egu
lato
ry
gu
idel
ines
. P
G&
E f
eels
th
at
the
pro
ced
ure
s a
nd
ch
eck
list
th
at
are
cu
rren
tly
in
use
are
com
pre
hen
siv
e en
ou
gh
to
co
ver
th
e a
sset
s b
ein
g i
nsp
ecte
d.
PG
&E
ha
s b
uil
t a
dd
itio
na
l
insp
ecti
on
cri
teri
a t
o a
ssis
t in
det
ecti
ng
fa
ilu
re m
od
es t
ha
t co
uld
lea
d t
o i
gn
itio
ns.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
18A
sset
in
spec
tio
n
effe
ctiv
enes
s
D.I
II.c
At
wh
at
lev
el o
f g
ran
ula
rity
are
th
e d
epth
of
chec
kli
sts,
tra
inin
g,
an
d p
roce
du
res
cust
om
ized
?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
cu
sto
miz
es c
hec
kli
sts,
tra
inin
gs,
an
d p
roce
du
res
acr
oss
its
ser
vic
e
terr
ito
ry.
PG
&E
use
s d
iffe
ren
t m
eth
od
s fo
r a
cces
s, h
ow
ever
th
e in
spec
tio
n t
ask
s a
re
con
sist
ent.
In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E w
ou
ld l
ike
to m
ov
e to
a 's
ma
rt f
orm
' ap
pro
ach
, w
hic
h
wo
uld
be
mo
re c
on
dit
ion
s d
riv
en r
ath
er t
ha
n g
eog
rap
hic
all
y d
riv
en a
s th
ey d
on
't
bel
iev
e g
eog
rap
hic
all
y d
riv
en v
ari
ab
ilit
y l
ead
s to
gre
ate
r ex
ecu
tio
n r
isk
.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
19A
sset
ma
inte
na
nce
an
d
rep
air
D.I
V.a
Wh
at
lev
el a
re e
lect
rica
l li
nes
an
d
equ
ipm
ent
ma
inta
ined
at?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
aim
s to
ma
inta
in i
ts e
lect
rica
l li
nes
an
d e
qu
ipm
ent
as
req
uir
ed.
Ho
wev
er,
PG
&E
rec
og
niz
es t
ha
t it
nee
ds
to w
ork
to
im
pro
ve
the
pro
gre
ss t
ow
ard
s th
at
go
al.
PG
&E
ha
s p
rep
are
d a
co
mp
lia
nce
pla
n,
wh
ich
it
ha
s p
rese
nte
d t
o t
he
CP
UC
, w
hic
h
PG
&E
wil
l a
ttem
pt
to e
xec
ute
. P
G&
E d
oes
an
d w
ill
con
tin
ue
to d
o a
dd
itio
na
l
ma
inte
na
nce
in
are
as
of
gri
d w
ith
th
e h
igh
est
wil
dfi
re r
isk
.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
19A
sset
ma
inte
na
nce
an
d
rep
air
D.I
V.b
Ho
w a
re s
erv
ice
inte
rva
ls s
et?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
set
s se
rvic
e in
terv
als
ba
sed
on
wil
dfi
re r
isk
in
rel
eva
nt
are
as
as
sta
ted
in
th
e
WS
IP p
lan
. A
dd
itio
na
lly
, in
th
e W
SIP
Co
mp
lia
nce
pla
n,
PG
&E
per
form
ed a
mu
lti-
fact
or
rela
tiv
e ri
sk r
an
kin
g f
or
ever
y s
ing
le m
ain
ten
an
ce t
ag
- t
his
wil
l h
elp
in
20
20
, a
s
PG
&E
mo
ves
to
wa
rds
a c
ircu
it b
ase
d s
tra
teg
y f
or
sett
ing
ser
vic
e in
terv
als
.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
19A
sset
ma
inte
na
nce
an
d
rep
air
D.I
V.c
Wh
at
do
ma
inte
na
nce
an
d r
epa
ir
pro
ced
ure
s ta
ke
into
acc
ou
nt?
iii
Th
e w
ord
"p
roce
du
re"
is i
nte
rch
an
gea
ble
wit
h
"str
ate
gy
". T
he
qu
esti
on
wa
s in
terp
rete
d a
s b
ein
g
ab
ou
t a
sset
str
ate
gy
an
d n
ot
pro
ced
ure
lev
el.
Cu
rren
t P
G&
E m
ain
ten
an
ce a
nd
rep
air
str
ate
gie
s ta
ke
into
acc
ou
nt
wil
dfi
re r
isk
.
PG
&E
wil
l b
e a
dd
ing
per
form
an
ce h
isto
ry,
an
d p
ast
op
era
tin
g c
on
dit
ion
s to
its
ass
et
rep
air
an
d m
ain
ten
an
ce s
tra
teg
ies
in a
cco
rda
nce
wit
h i
ts m
an
ua
ls.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
20
QA
/QC
fo
r a
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
D.V
.aH
ow
is
con
tra
cto
r a
ctiv
ity
au
dit
ed?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y a
ud
its
con
tra
cto
r w
ork
th
rou
gh
an
est
ab
lish
ed a
nd
fu
nct
ion
ing
au
dit
pro
cess
to
ma
na
ge
an
d c
on
firm
wo
rk c
om
ple
ted
by
su
bco
ntr
act
ors
. P
G&
E h
as
an
Ele
ctri
c q
ua
lity
ass
ura
nce
gro
up
an
d a
sy
stem
in
spec
tio
ns
gro
up
. In
tern
al
au
dit
als
o
con
du
cts
ran
do
m s
am
pli
ng
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E p
lan
s to
mo
ve
to a
mo
re d
igit
al
pla
tfo
rm f
or
insp
ecti
on
s a
nd
co
nst
ruct
ion
clo
sure
. T
his
wil
l a
llo
w t
he
uti
lity
to
ass
ess
per
form
an
ce w
ith
a m
ore
cen
tra
lize
d a
nd
fo
rma
lize
d p
roce
ss o
f m
on
ito
rin
g a
nd
sam
pli
ng
co
ntr
act
or
wo
rk.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
20
QA
/QC
fo
r a
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
D.V
.bD
o c
on
tra
cto
rs f
oll
ow
th
e sa
me
pro
cess
es a
nd
sta
nd
ard
s a
s u
tili
ty's
ow
n
emp
loy
ees?
iiii
No
ne
Co
ntr
act
ors
are
ex
pec
ted
to
ad
her
e to
PG
&E
sta
nd
ard
s a
nd
pro
cess
es.
PG
&E
is
on
ly
all
ow
ed t
o t
rain
ex
tern
al
per
son
nel
on
PG
&E
tec
hn
olo
gy
th
at
con
tra
cto
rs w
ill
usi
ng
fo
r
thei
r jo
b.
PG
&E
ap
pli
es a
pp
rop
ria
te r
estr
ain
t w
ith
res
pec
t to
co
-em
plo
ym
ent.
Th
is
mea
ns
tha
t co
ntr
act
ors
ma
y f
oll
ow
th
eir
ow
n p
roce
sses
as
lon
g t
ho
se p
roce
sses
are
no
t
con
flic
tin
g w
ith
PG
&E
's s
tan
da
rds
an
d p
roce
du
res
an
d f
ina
l w
ork
is
com
pli
an
t.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
20
QA
/QC
fo
r a
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
D.V
.cH
ow
fre
qu
entl
y i
s Q
A/Q
C i
nfo
rma
tio
n
use
d t
o i
den
tify
def
icie
nci
es i
n q
ua
lity
of
wo
rk
per
form
an
ce a
nd
in
spec
tio
ns
per
form
an
ce?
iii
ivN
on
eQ
A/Q
C i
nfo
rma
tio
n i
s u
sed
on
ad
ho
c b
asi
s to
id
enti
fy d
efic
ien
cies
in
qu
ali
ty o
f w
ork
per
form
an
ce a
nd
in
spec
tio
n p
erfo
rma
nce
. P
G&
E i
s co
nti
nu
ing
to
tra
nsi
tio
n t
o m
ore
dig
ita
l w
ork
pa
per
s w
hic
h w
ill
all
ow
fo
r P
G&
E t
o r
egu
larl
y u
se Q
A/Q
C i
nfo
rma
tio
n t
o
iden
tify
def
icie
nci
es i
n t
he
futu
re.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
20
QA
/QC
fo
r a
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
D.V
.dH
ow
is
wo
rk a
nd
in
spec
tio
ns
tha
t d
o n
ot
mee
t u
tili
ty-p
resc
rib
ed s
tan
da
rds
rem
edia
ted
?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y u
ses
QA
/QC
in
form
ati
on
to
id
enti
fy s
yst
emic
def
icie
nci
es i
n q
ua
lity
of
wo
rk i
nsp
ecti
on
s. T
he
rem
edia
tio
n v
ari
es b
ase
d o
n t
he
typ
e o
f d
efec
t o
r n
on
-
con
form
an
ce.
Wo
rk a
nd
in
spec
tio
ns
tha
t d
o n
ot
mee
t u
tili
ty-p
resc
rib
ed s
tan
da
rds
ma
y
be
reso
lved
im
med
iate
ly,
gen
era
ted
as
a c
orr
ecti
ve
no
tifi
cati
on
in
SA
P,
call
ed f
or
ad
ho
c re
insp
ecti
on
, o
r m
ay
be
cap
ture
d i
n a
sep
ara
te p
lan
ned
in
spec
tio
n a
ctiv
ity
. In
th
e
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to i
mp
lem
ent
a m
ore
sy
stem
ati
c p
roce
ss f
or
reco
mm
end
ing
tra
inin
gs
ba
sed
on
wea
kn
esse
s id
enti
fied
th
rou
gh
th
e Q
A/Q
C p
roce
ss.
DA
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
20
QA
/QC
fo
r a
sset
ma
na
gem
ent
D.V
.eA
re w
ork
forc
e m
an
ag
emen
t so
ftw
are
too
ls u
sed
to
ma
na
ge
an
d c
on
firm
wo
rk
com
ple
ted
by
su
bco
ntr
act
ors
?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
use
s w
ork
forc
e m
an
ag
emen
t so
ftw
are
to
ols
, S
AP
an
d A
RC
OS
, to
ma
na
ge
an
d c
on
firm
wo
rk c
om
ple
ted
by
su
bco
ntr
act
ors
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E w
ill
con
tin
ue
to u
se w
ork
forc
e m
an
ag
emen
t so
ftw
are
to
ols
, a
lth
ou
gh
th
e te
chn
olo
gy
solu
tio
ns
ma
y d
iffe
r a
cro
ss p
rog
ram
s.
Atch5-12
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
21
Veg
eta
tio
n
inv
ento
ry a
nd
con
dit
ion
ass
essm
ents
E.I
.aW
ha
t in
form
ati
on
is
cap
ture
d i
n t
he
inv
ento
ry?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E m
ain
tain
s a
cen
tra
lize
d i
nv
ento
ry o
f v
eget
ati
on
cle
ara
nce
s b
ase
d o
n t
he
mo
st
rece
nt
insp
ecti
on
s. P
G&
E i
s a
wa
re o
f th
e to
p 1
0 m
ost
pro
ble
ma
tic
spec
ies,
an
d b
y
usi
ng
hy
per
spec
tra
l im
ag
ing
tec
hn
iqu
es,
sho
uld
be
ab
le t
o i
den
tify
wh
ere
tho
se s
pec
ies
gro
w.
In t
he
futu
re,
LiD
AR
ca
n b
e u
sed
to
mo
nit
or
hig
h r
isk
-tre
es a
cro
ss g
rid
.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
21
Veg
eta
tio
n
inv
ento
ry a
nd
con
dit
ion
ass
essm
ents
E.I
.bH
ow
fre
qu
entl
y i
s in
ven
tory
up
da
ted
? ii
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
em
plo
ys
an
an
nu
al
pru
nin
g c
ycl
e, a
nd
, a
s a
res
ult
, h
oli
stic
all
y u
pd
ate
s
the
its
Veg
eta
tio
n M
an
ag
emen
t D
ata
ba
se (
VM
D)
on
an
an
nu
al
ba
sis.
Ho
wev
er,
in
som
e ca
ses,
th
e in
ven
tory
ca
n b
e u
pd
ate
d m
ore
oft
en f
req
uen
tly
(e.
g.,
fo
r th
e
En
ha
nce
d V
eget
ati
on
Ma
na
gem
ent
pro
gra
m w
hic
h u
ses
mo
re m
ob
ile
da
ta c
ap
ture
met
ho
ds)
.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pro
ject
s th
at
it w
ill
evo
lve
to m
on
thly
up
da
tes
mo
re c
on
sist
entl
y,
as
the
uti
lity
aim
s to
uti
lize
mo
bil
e d
ata
ca
ptu
re i
n b
oth
its
Ro
uti
ne
an
d E
nh
an
ced
Veg
eta
tio
n M
an
ag
emen
t p
rog
ram
s.E
Veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
21
Veg
eta
tio
n
inv
ento
ry a
nd
con
dit
ion
ass
essm
ents
E.I
.cA
re i
nsp
ecti
on
s in
dep
end
entl
y v
erif
ied
by
th
ird
pa
rty
ex
per
ts?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
use
s a
th
ird
pa
rty
ven
do
r to
co
nd
uct
au
dit
s a
nd
pla
ns
to c
on
tin
ue
do
ing
so
in
the
fore
seea
ble
fu
ture
.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
21
Veg
eta
tio
n
inv
ento
ry a
nd
con
dit
ion
ass
essm
ents
E.I
.dH
ow
gra
nu
lar
is t
he
inv
ento
ry?
iviv
1. T
he
qu
esti
on
per
tain
s to
ro
uti
ne
veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
(i.e
., n
ot
enh
an
ced
veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent)
.
2.
Th
e "a
sset
" is
th
e tr
ee.
PG
&E
tra
cks
inv
ento
ry a
t th
e in
div
idu
al
tree
lev
el (
ass
et-b
ase
d)
an
d p
lan
s to
co
nti
nu
e
do
ing
so
in
th
e fo
rese
eab
le f
utu
re.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
22
Veg
eta
tio
n
insp
ecti
on
cy
cle
E.I
I.a
Ho
w f
req
uen
t a
re a
ll t
yp
es o
f v
eget
ati
on
insp
ecti
on
s?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E h
as
thre
e ty
pes
of
veg
eta
tio
n i
nsp
ecti
on
pro
gra
ms;
ro
uti
ne,
EV
M,
an
d t
ree
mo
rta
lity
in
spec
tio
n.
Th
e p
rog
ram
s a
re d
eplo
yed
ba
sed
on
th
e co
nd
itio
ns
of
the
serv
ice
are
a.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to i
ncr
ease
in
spec
tio
ns
ab
ov
e cu
rren
t
insp
ecti
on
cy
cles
, w
ith
mo
re f
req
uen
t in
spec
tio
ns
for
hig
hes
t ri
sk a
rea
s.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
22
Veg
eta
tio
n
insp
ecti
on
cy
cle
E.I
I.b
Ho
w a
re v
eget
ati
on
in
spec
tio
ns
sch
edu
led
?
ii
"En
vir
on
men
t" m
ean
s sc
hed
uli
ng
aro
un
d h
igh
elev
ati
on
sn
ow
, o
rch
ard
blo
om
per
iod
s a
nd
lim
ited
op
era
tin
g p
erio
ds
for
ag
ency
la
nd
s.
PG
&E
in
spec
tio
ns
are
per
form
ed a
nn
ua
lly
to
all
ow
ad
her
ence
to
th
e a
nn
ua
l p
run
ing
cycl
e. P
G&
E w
ill
pu
rsu
e a
co
nti
nu
ed e
vo
luti
on
of
its
veg
eta
tio
n m
an
ag
emen
t p
rog
ram
(in
clu
din
g r
ou
tin
e in
spec
tio
ns,
tre
e m
ort
ali
ty i
nsp
ecti
on
s a
nd
EV
M)
to f
urt
her
su
pp
ort
risk
-in
form
ed d
ecis
ion
ma
kin
g,
bu
t a
nn
ua
l in
spec
tio
ns
are
ex
pec
ted
to
rem
ain
as
the
insp
ecti
on
cy
cle.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
22
Veg
eta
tio
n
insp
ecti
on
cy
cle
E.I
I.c
Wh
at
are
th
e in
pu
ts t
o s
ched
uli
ng
veg
eta
tio
n i
nsp
ecti
on
s?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
in
spec
tio
ns
are
per
form
ed a
nn
ua
lly
to
all
ow
ad
her
ence
to
th
e a
nn
ua
l p
run
ing
cycl
e. P
G&
E w
ill
pu
rsu
e a
co
nti
nu
ed e
vo
luti
on
of
its
veg
eta
tio
n m
an
ag
emen
t p
rog
ram
(in
clu
din
g r
ou
tin
e in
spec
tio
ns,
tre
e m
ort
ali
ty i
nsp
ecti
on
s a
nd
EV
M)
to f
urt
her
su
pp
ort
risk
-in
form
ed d
ecis
ion
ma
kin
g,
bu
t a
nn
ua
l in
spec
tio
ns
are
ex
pec
ted
to
rem
ain
as
the
insp
ecti
on
cy
cle.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
23
Veg
eta
tio
n
insp
ecti
on
effe
ctiv
enes
s
E.I
II.a
Wh
at
item
s a
re c
ap
ture
d w
ith
in
insp
ecti
on
pro
ced
ure
s a
nd
ch
eck
list
s?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E's
in
spec
tio
ns
cap
ture
th
e cu
rren
t re
qu
irem
ents
def
ined
by
GO
95
, R
ule
35
, a
nd
PR
C 4
29
2 a
nd
42
93
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E w
ill
con
tin
ue
to e
xp
lore
an
d b
ette
r
un
der
sta
nd
veg
eta
tio
n t
yp
es t
yp
ica
lly
res
po
nsi
ble
fo
r ig
nit
ion
s a
nd
nea
r m
isse
s.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
23
Veg
eta
tio
n
insp
ecti
on
effe
ctiv
enes
s
E.I
II.b
Ho
w a
re p
roce
du
res
an
d c
hec
kli
sts
det
erm
ined
?
ii
No
ne
Pro
ced
ure
s a
nd
ch
eck
list
s a
re d
eter
min
ed b
y t
he
req
uir
emen
ts o
f G
O9
5,
Ru
le 3
5,
an
d
PR
C 4
29
2 &
42
93
. P
G&
E e
ven
tua
lly
pla
ns
to d
evel
op
a p
red
icti
ve
mo
del
ing
ca
pa
bil
ity
tha
t w
ou
ld i
ncl
ud
e d
ata
an
aly
tics
an
d c
rea
tin
g a
ris
k i
nfo
rmed
pro
cess
, b
ut
this
is
no
t
lik
ely
to
be
in p
rod
uct
ion
by
20
23
.E
Veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
23
Veg
eta
tio
n
insp
ecti
on
effe
ctiv
enes
s
E.I
II.c
At
wh
at
lev
el o
f g
ran
ula
rity
are
th
e d
epth
of
chec
kli
sts,
tra
inin
g,
an
d p
roce
du
res
cust
om
ized
?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
use
s st
an
da
rdiz
ed c
hec
kli
sts,
tra
inin
gs,
an
d p
roce
du
res
in i
ts
veg
eta
tio
n i
nsp
ecti
on
pro
cess
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E w
ou
ld l
ike
to m
ov
e to
a 's
ma
rt
form
' ap
pro
ach
, w
hic
h w
ou
ld b
e m
ore
co
nd
itio
ns
dri
ven
ra
ther
th
an
geo
gra
ph
ica
lly
dri
ven
, a
s P
G&
E d
oes
no
t b
elie
ve
a g
eog
rap
hic
all
y d
riv
en v
ari
ab
ilit
y l
ead
s to
gre
ate
r
exec
uti
on
ris
k.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
24
Veg
eta
tio
n g
row
-
in m
itig
ati
on
E.I
V.a
Ho
w d
oes
uti
lity
cle
ara
nce
aro
un
d l
ines
an
d e
qu
ipm
ent
per
form
rel
ati
ve
to
exp
ecte
d s
tan
da
rds?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
fo
llo
ws
the
min
imu
m r
egu
lato
ry s
tan
da
rds
on
cle
ara
nce
aro
un
d l
ines
an
d e
qu
ipm
ent
(ou
tlin
ed i
n G
O 9
5)
wit
h i
ts r
eco
mm
end
ed c
lea
ran
ce t
arg
ets,
wh
ere
po
ssib
le.
In s
om
e ca
ses,
mo
re c
lea
ran
ce i
s a
chie
ved
. P
G&
E r
eco
gn
izes
th
at
it i
s n
ot
alw
ay
s p
oss
ible
to
hit
set
ta
rget
s d
ue
to v
eget
ati
on
gro
wth
ra
tes.
Atch5-13
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
24
Veg
eta
tio
n g
row
-
in m
itig
ati
on
E.I
V.b
Do
es u
tili
ty m
eet
or
exce
ed m
inim
um
sta
tuto
ry o
r re
gu
lato
ry c
lea
ran
ces
du
rin
g
all
sea
son
s?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
mu
st m
eet
or
exce
ed m
inim
um
reg
ula
tory
cle
ara
nce
s d
uri
ng
all
sea
son
s to
ma
inta
in a
n a
nn
ua
l p
run
ing
cy
cle.
PG
&E
pla
ns
on
ma
inta
inin
g a
n a
nn
ua
l p
run
ing
cycl
e th
rou
gh
20
23
, a
nd
th
eref
ore
, w
ill
con
tin
ue
to m
eet
or
exce
ed t
he
reg
ula
tory
clea
ran
ce.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
24
Veg
eta
tio
n g
row
-
in m
itig
ati
on
E.I
V.c
Wh
at
mo
del
ing
is
use
d t
o g
uid
e
clea
ran
ces
aro
un
d l
ines
an
d e
qu
ipm
ent?
iii
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
ad
her
es t
o C
PU
C s
tan
da
rds
wh
en d
eter
min
ing
cle
ara
nce
s a
rou
nd
lin
es a
nd
equ
ipm
ent.
PG
&E
use
s ig
nit
ion
ris
k m
od
elin
g f
or
fall
-in
an
d b
low
-in
sce
na
rio
s. P
G&
E
spec
ies
gro
wth
ra
tes
uti
lize
s m
od
elin
g f
or
veg
eta
tio
n g
row
-in
mit
iga
tio
n,
an
d w
ill
con
tin
ue
to d
o s
o f
or
the
fore
seea
ble
fu
ture
.E
Veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
24
Veg
eta
tio
n g
row
-
in m
itig
ati
on
E.I
V.d
Wh
at
bio
log
ica
l m
od
elin
g i
s u
sed
to
gu
ide
clea
ran
ce a
rou
nd
lin
es a
nd
equ
ipm
ent
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E u
ses
forr
este
r a
na
lysi
s in
stea
d o
f b
iolo
gic
al
mo
del
ing
to
gu
ide
clea
ran
ce.
Fo
rres
ters
mee
t A
NS
I A
30
0 s
tan
da
rds
an
d p
rim
ari
ly u
tili
zes
Pa
rts
1 a
nd
9 o
f th
e
sta
nd
ard
s w
hen
ass
essi
ng
cle
ara
nce
aro
un
d l
ines
an
d e
qu
ipm
ent.
PG
&E
do
es p
lan
to
con
du
ct b
iolo
gic
al
mo
del
ing
as
a m
ore
cen
tra
lize
d,
syst
ema
tic,
an
d f
orm
ali
zed
ma
nn
er
to g
uid
e cl
eara
nce
in
th
e fu
ture
.E
Veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
24
Veg
eta
tio
n g
row
-
in m
itig
ati
on
E.I
V.e
Are
co
mm
un
ity
org
an
iza
tio
ns
eng
ag
ed
in s
etti
ng
lo
cal
clea
ran
ces
an
d p
roto
cols
?
ii
No
ne
Alt
ho
ug
h P
G&
E r
egu
larl
y e
ng
ag
es w
ith
co
mm
un
itie
s in
its
ser
vic
e te
rrit
ory
, th
e
com
pa
ny
ult
ima
tely
ad
her
es t
o s
tan
da
rds
an
d p
roto
cols
set
by
th
e C
PU
C (
i.e.
, G
O 9
5,
PR
C 4
29
2 a
nd
42
93
, E
SR
B-4
SE
MA
sta
nd
ard
). P
G&
E f
oll
ow
s a
set
of
sta
nd
ard
s a
nd
bel
iev
es d
ecen
tra
lize
d o
ver
sig
ht
wo
uld
no
t b
e b
est
pra
ctic
e si
nce
tec
hn
ica
l a
uth
ori
ty
ma
y b
e a
bse
nt.
Th
eref
ore
, d
iffe
ren
t v
ari
ab
les
ma
y b
e w
eig
hed
dif
fere
ntl
y d
epen
din
g o
n
loca
tio
n.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
24
Veg
eta
tio
n g
row
-
in m
itig
ati
on
E.I
V.f
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
rem
ov
e v
eget
ati
on
wa
ste
alo
ng
its
rig
ht
of
wa
y a
cro
ss t
he
enti
re
gri
d?
ii
"Acr
oss
th
e en
tire
gri
d"
mea
ns
all
of
PG
&E
's s
erv
ice
terr
ito
ry.
PG
&E
att
emp
ts t
o r
emo
ve
wa
ste
in H
FT
Ds;
ho
wev
er,
ther
e a
re u
niq
ue
circ
um
sta
nce
s,
such
as
pro
per
ty o
wn
ers
an
d t
erra
in,
tha
t m
ak
e it
in
fea
sib
le o
r im
pra
ctic
al
to r
emo
ve
veg
eta
tio
n w
ast
e a
cro
ss t
he
enti
re g
rid
. P
G&
E d
oes
no
t ex
pec
t th
ese
case
s to
ch
an
ge
by
20
23
.E
Veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
24
Veg
eta
tio
n g
row
-
in m
itig
ati
on
E.I
V.g
Ho
w l
on
g a
fter
cu
ttin
g v
eget
ati
on
do
es
the
uti
lity
rem
ov
e v
eget
ati
on
wa
ste
alo
ng
rig
ht
of
wa
y?
iiii
Th
is q
ues
tio
n a
pp
lies
to
are
as
wh
ere
PG
&E
per
form
s
wa
ste
rem
ov
al.
PG
&E
is
ab
le t
o r
emo
ve
som
e w
ast
e w
ith
in a
wee
k,
ho
wev
er,
ther
e a
re c
on
stra
ints
th
at
ma
ke
rem
ov
ing
veg
eta
tio
n w
ith
in t
he
wee
k a
cro
ss t
he
enti
re g
rid
un
ob
tain
ab
le.
Fo
r
exa
mp
le,
if p
erm
itti
ng
is
req
uir
ed t
o r
emo
ve
wa
ste,
th
e re
mo
va
l m
ay
ta
ke
ov
er a
wee
k.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
24
Veg
eta
tio
n g
row
-
in m
itig
ati
on
E.I
V.h
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
wo
rk w
ith
lo
cal
lan
do
wn
ers
to p
rov
ide
a c
ost
-eff
ecti
ve
use
fo
r cu
ttin
g v
eget
ati
on
?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es s
eek
wa
ys
to r
emo
ve
cost
fro
m v
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent,
bu
t d
oes
no
t
pro
act
ivel
y p
rov
ide
a c
ost
-eff
ecti
ve
use
fo
r cu
t v
eget
ati
on
to
th
e la
nd
ow
ner
s. P
G&
E
do
es w
ork
wit
h l
an
do
wn
ers
to p
rov
ide
them
wit
h t
he
op
tio
n f
or
PG
&E
to
rem
ov
e th
e
veg
eta
tio
n w
ast
e o
r le
av
e it
fo
r th
e la
nd
ow
ner
to
use
.E
Veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
24
Veg
eta
tio
n g
row
-
in m
itig
ati
on
E.I
V.i
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
wo
rk w
ith
pa
rtn
ers
to
iden
tify
new
co
st-e
ffec
tiv
e u
ses
for
veg
eta
tio
n,
tak
ing
in
to c
on
sid
era
tio
n
env
iro
nm
enta
l im
pa
cts
an
d e
mis
sio
ns
of
veg
eta
tio
n w
ast
e?
iiii
Th
is q
ues
tio
n a
pp
lies
to
all
veg
eta
tio
n w
ast
e cr
eate
d
du
rin
g v
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
act
ivit
ies.
PG
&E
reg
ula
rly
giv
es a
wa
y w
oo
d c
hip
s/w
oo
d a
nd
sen
ds
wa
ste
to c
o-g
ener
ati
on
pla
nts
.
PG
&E
als
o c
on
nec
ts w
ith
bio
ma
ss f
aci
liti
es t
o u
se v
eget
ati
on
wa
ste
as
a f
uel
su
pp
lier
.
PG
&E
wil
l co
nti
nu
e th
is b
eha
vio
r a
nd
wil
l ex
plo
re n
ew w
ay
s to
mit
iga
te
env
iro
nm
enta
l im
pa
cts
an
d e
mis
sio
ns
in t
he
futu
re.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
25
Veg
eta
tio
n f
all
-in
mit
iga
tio
n
E.V
.aD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty h
av
e a
pro
cess
fo
r
trea
tin
g v
eget
ati
on
ou
tsid
e o
f ri
gh
t o
f
wa
ys?
iii
iv1.
"S
yst
ema
tica
lly
" m
ean
s ef
fort
s a
re d
icta
ted
by
a
pro
cess
an
d n
ot
exh
au
stiv
ely
.
2.
"Co
mm
un
itie
s"m
ean
s st
ak
eho
lder
s.
PG
&E
use
s a
sy
stem
ati
c a
pp
roa
ch t
o t
rea
t v
eget
ati
on
ou
tsid
e o
f ri
gh
t o
f w
ay
s: 1
)
iden
tify
veg
eta
tio
n n
ear
con
du
cto
rs t
ha
t is
in
nee
d o
f w
ork
, o
ut
of
com
pli
an
ce,
or
tha
t
is a
sa
fety
ris
k,
2)
iden
tify
a p
resc
rip
tio
n o
f w
ork
, 3
) a
nd
cla
ssif
y a
pri
ori
ty a
nd
sch
edu
le.
If a
pre
scri
pti
on
of
tree
rem
ov
al
is i
den
tifi
ed a
nd
th
e tr
ee f
all
s o
uts
ide
of
PG
&E
rig
hts
of
wa
y,
PG
&E
id
enti
fies
th
e u
nd
erly
ing
fee
pa
rcel
ow
ner
, id
enti
fies
curr
ent
lan
d r
igh
ts,
an
d i
den
tifi
es n
ext
step
s b
ase
d o
n i
np
ut
fro
m P
G&
E's
La
nd
dep
art
men
t a
nd
Leg
al
Co
un
sel.
Th
rou
gh
its
Lo
cal
Cu
sto
mer
Ex
per
ien
ce t
eam
, P
G&
E
wo
rks
dir
ectl
y w
ith
th
e p
rop
erty
ow
ner
to
det
erm
ine
nex
t st
eps
ba
sed
on
all
fa
cto
rs
an
d i
np
ut
fro
m t
he
ow
ner
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E h
as
pla
ns
to e
ng
ag
e m
ore
act
ivel
y w
ith
com
mu
nit
ies
reg
ard
ing
tre
e re
mo
va
l.E
Veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
25
Veg
eta
tio
n f
all
-in
mit
iga
tio
n
E.V
.bH
ow
is
po
ten
tia
l v
eget
ati
on
th
at
ma
y
po
se a
th
rea
t id
enti
fied
?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
's v
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
per
son
nel
id
enti
fy p
ote
nti
all
y t
hre
ate
nin
g v
eget
ati
on
an
d a
dd
it
to t
he
on
lin
e A
RC
GIS
to
ol.
In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E w
ill
exp
lore
usi
ng
LiD
AR
to
iden
tify
str
ike
po
ten
tia
l w
ith
hy
per
spec
tra
l te
chn
iqu
es a
nd
Tec
hn
osl
yv
a t
o o
ver
lap
th
e
spre
ad
ris
k t
o m
od
el r
isk
.E
Veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
25
Veg
eta
tio
n f
all
-in
mit
iga
tio
n
E.V
.cIs
veg
eta
tio
n r
emo
ved
wit
h c
oo
per
ati
on
fro
m t
he
com
mu
nit
y?
iiii
No
ne
Wh
ile
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
alw
ay
s re
ceiv
e co
mp
lete
co
op
era
tio
n w
hen
en
ga
gin
g w
ith
lo
cal
com
mu
nit
ies
an
d l
an
do
wn
ers,
th
e u
tili
ty s
triv
es t
o d
evel
op
an
d m
ain
tain
pro
act
ive
com
mu
nic
ati
on
s w
ith
cu
sto
mer
s (e
.g.,
ma
iler
s),
an
d h
as
a f
orm
al
pro
cess
fo
r th
ose
wh
o r
efu
se t
he
veg
eta
tio
n m
an
ag
emen
t.E
Veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
25
Veg
eta
tio
n f
all
-in
mit
iga
tio
n
E.V
.dD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty r
emo
ve
veg
eta
tio
n w
ast
e
ou
tsid
e it
s ri
gh
t o
f w
ay
acr
oss
th
e en
tire
gri
d?
ii
"Acr
oss
th
e en
tire
gri
d"
mea
ns
all
of
PG
&E
's s
erv
ice
terr
ito
ry.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
rem
ov
e v
eget
ati
on
wa
ste
acr
oss
th
e en
tire
gri
d.
PG
&E
do
es r
emo
ve
wa
ste
fro
m c
erta
in p
ort
ion
s o
f th
e sy
stem
, b
ut
ther
e a
re i
nst
an
ces
in w
hic
h i
t is
infe
asi
ble
(e.
g.,
wh
en w
ast
e re
sid
es o
n p
riv
ate
pro
per
ty,
it i
s te
chn
ica
lly
la
nd
ow
ner
pro
per
ty).
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
exp
ect
this
to
ch
an
ge
by
20
23
.E
Veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
25
Veg
eta
tio
n f
all
-in
mit
iga
tio
n
E.V
.eH
ow
lo
ng
aft
er c
utt
ing
veg
eta
tio
n d
oes
the
uti
lity
rem
ov
e v
eget
ati
on
wa
ste
ou
tsid
e it
s ri
gh
t o
f w
ay
?
iiii
Th
is q
ues
tio
n a
pp
lies
to
are
as
wh
ere
PG
&E
per
form
s
wa
ste
rem
ov
al.
PG
&E
is
ab
le t
o r
emo
ve
som
e w
ast
e w
ith
in a
wee
k,
ho
wev
er,
ther
e a
re c
on
stra
ints
th
at
ma
ke
rem
ov
ing
veg
eta
tio
n w
ith
in t
he
wee
k a
cro
ss t
he
enti
re g
rid
un
ob
tain
ab
le.
Fo
r
exa
mp
le,
if p
erm
itti
ng
is
req
uir
ed t
o r
emo
ve
wa
ste,
th
e re
mo
va
l w
ill
tak
e o
ver
a w
eek
.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
25
Veg
eta
tio
n f
all
-in
mit
iga
tio
n
E.V
.fD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty w
ork
wit
h l
oca
l
lan
do
wn
ers
to p
rov
ide
a c
ost
-eff
ecti
ve
use
fo
r cu
ttin
g v
eget
ati
on
?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es s
eek
wa
ys
to r
emo
ve
cost
fro
m v
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent,
bu
t d
oes
no
t
pro
act
ivel
y p
rov
ide
a c
ost
-eff
ecti
ve
use
fo
r cu
t v
eget
ati
on
to
th
e la
nd
ow
ner
s. P
G&
E
do
es w
ork
wit
h l
an
do
wn
ers
to p
rov
ide
them
wit
h t
he
op
tio
n f
or
PG
&E
to
rem
ov
e th
e
veg
eta
tio
n w
ast
e o
r le
av
e it
fo
r th
e la
nd
ow
ner
to
use
.E
Veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
25
Veg
eta
tio
n f
all
-in
mit
iga
tio
n
E.V
.gD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty w
ork
wit
h p
art
ner
s to
iden
tify
new
co
st-e
ffec
tiv
e u
ses
for
veg
eta
tio
n,
tak
ing
in
to c
on
sid
era
tio
n
env
iro
nm
enta
l im
pa
cts
an
d e
mis
sio
ns
of
veg
eta
tio
n w
ast
e?
iiii
Th
is q
ues
tio
n d
oes
no
t re
fer
to a
ll v
eget
ati
on
wa
ste
crea
ted
du
rin
g v
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
act
ivit
ies.
PG
&E
reg
ula
rly
giv
es a
wa
y w
oo
d c
hip
s/w
oo
d a
nd
sen
ds
wa
ste
to c
o-g
ener
ati
on
pla
nts
.
PG
&E
als
o c
on
nec
ts w
ith
bio
ma
ss f
aci
liti
es t
o u
se v
eget
ati
on
wa
ste
as
a f
uel
su
pp
lier
.
PG
&E
wil
l co
nti
nu
e th
is b
eha
vio
r a
nd
wil
l ex
plo
re n
ew w
ay
s to
mit
iga
te
env
iro
nm
enta
l im
pa
cts
an
d e
mis
sio
ns
in t
he
futu
re.
Atch5-14
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
26
QA
/QC
fo
r
veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
E.V
I.a
Ho
w i
s co
ntr
act
or
an
d e
mp
loy
ee a
ctiv
ity
au
dit
ed?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
ha
s a
n a
ud
it p
roce
ss t
o m
an
ag
e a
nd
co
nfi
rm w
ork
co
mp
lete
d b
y c
on
tra
cto
rs
an
d s
ub
con
tra
cto
rs.
Th
is p
roce
ss a
pp
lies
to
bo
th p
re-i
nsp
ecti
on
an
d t
ree
wo
rk.
PG
&E
is i
n t
he
pro
cess
of
sch
edu
lin
g s
emi-
au
tom
ate
d a
ud
its
usi
ng
tec
hn
olo
gie
s su
ch a
s
gro
un
d b
ase
d L
iDA
R s
can
s.E
Veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
26
QA
/QC
fo
r
veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
E.V
I.b
Do
co
ntr
act
ors
fo
llo
w t
he
sam
e
pro
cess
es a
nd
sta
nd
ard
s a
s u
tili
ty's
ow
n
emp
loy
ees?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
req
uir
es c
on
tra
cto
rs t
o f
oll
ow
th
e sa
me
pro
cess
es a
nd
sta
nd
ard
s a
s it
s
emp
loy
ees.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
pla
n o
n c
ha
ng
ing
th
is r
equ
irem
ent
bef
ore
20
23
.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
26
QA
/QC
fo
r
veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
E.V
I.c
Ho
w f
req
uen
tly
is
QA
/QC
in
form
ati
on
use
d t
o i
den
tify
def
icie
nci
es i
n q
ua
lity
of
wo
rk p
erfo
rma
nce
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s
per
form
an
ce?
iviv
No
ne
PG
&E
sy
stem
ati
call
y a
nd
reg
ula
rly
use
s Q
A/Q
C i
nfo
rma
tio
n t
o i
den
tify
def
icie
nci
es i
n
qu
ali
ty o
f w
ork
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s p
erfo
rma
nce
.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
26
QA
/QC
fo
r
veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
E.V
I.d
Ho
w i
s w
ork
an
d i
nsp
ecti
on
s th
at
do
no
t
mee
t u
tili
ty-p
resc
rib
ed s
tan
da
rds
rem
edia
ted
?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
sy
stem
ati
call
y u
ses
QA
/QC
in
form
ati
on
to
id
enti
fy d
efic
ien
cies
in
qu
ali
ty o
f
wo
rk a
nd
in
spec
tio
ns
per
form
an
ce.
PG
&E
ma
y m
ak
e re
com
men
da
tio
ns
ba
sed
on
iden
tifi
ed w
eak
nes
sess
in
an
ad
ho
c a
nd
as
nee
ded
ma
nn
er,
bu
t d
oes
no
t p
lan
on
nee
din
g t
o r
eco
mm
end
tra
inin
gs
to a
ll o
f it
s th
ou
san
ds
of
con
tra
cto
rs b
y 2
02
3.
EV
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d
insp
ecti
on
s
26
QA
/QC
fo
r
veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
E.V
I.e
Are
wo
rkfo
rce
ma
na
gem
ent
soft
wa
re
too
ls u
sed
to
ma
na
ge
an
d c
on
firm
wo
rk
com
ple
ted
by
su
bco
ntr
act
ors
?
iii
PG
&E
is
inte
rpre
tin
g t
his
qu
esti
on
as
usi
ng
wo
rkfo
rce
ma
na
gem
ent
soft
wa
re t
oo
ls t
o c
on
firm
a
"sa
mp
lin
g"
of
wo
rk c
om
ple
ted
by
su
bco
ntr
act
ors
.
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
use
s a
so
ftw
are
-ba
sed
wo
rkfo
rce
ma
na
gem
ent
too
l, a
nd
ro
uti
ne
veg
eta
tio
n w
ork
wil
l b
e in
clu
ded
in
th
at
too
l b
y 2
02
3.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
27
Pro
tect
ive
equ
ipm
ent
an
d
dev
ice
sett
ing
s
F.I
.aH
ow
are
gri
d e
lem
ents
ad
just
ed d
uri
ng
hig
h t
hre
at
wea
ther
co
nd
itio
ns?
iviv
"Nea
r m
iss"
mea
ns
an
ev
ent
tha
t h
ap
pen
ed i
n
PG
&E
's s
yst
em b
ut
did
no
t ca
use
an
ig
nit
ion
.
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
ad
just
s g
rid
ele
men
ts d
uri
ng
hig
h t
hre
at
wea
ther
co
nd
itio
ns
by
incr
easi
ng
sen
siti
vit
y o
f ri
sk r
edu
ctio
n e
lem
ents
an
d m
on
ito
rin
g n
ear
mis
ses.
In
ad
dit
ion
, P
G&
E p
atr
ols
th
e o
uta
ge
are
a a
nd
ca
n l
ever
ag
e ri
sk m
ap
pin
g.
PG
&E
wil
l
con
tin
ue
to d
o t
his
in
th
e fu
ture
.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
27
Pro
tect
ive
equ
ipm
ent
an
d
dev
ice
sett
ing
s
F.I
.bIs
th
ere
an
au
tom
ate
d p
roce
ss f
or
ad
just
ing
sen
siti
vit
y o
f g
rid
ele
men
ts
an
d e
va
lua
tin
g e
ffec
tiv
enes
s?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
gri
d o
per
ati
on
s h
as
the
ab
ilit
y t
o g
rou
p c
ut-
ou
t d
evic
es t
ha
t a
re l
ink
ed
elec
tro
nic
all
y (
i.e.
, p
art
ial
au
tom
ati
on
) o
n t
he
dis
trib
uti
on
sid
e. A
dju
stin
g s
ensi
tiv
ity
is
stil
l m
an
ua
lly
wit
h r
ega
rds
to t
ran
smis
sio
n.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
bel
iev
e it
to
be
in t
he
bes
t
inte
rest
of
pu
bli
c sa
fety
an
d r
elia
bil
ity
to
im
ple
men
t a
fu
lly
au
tom
ate
d s
olu
tio
n i
n t
his
cap
aci
ty.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
27
Pro
tect
ive
equ
ipm
ent
an
d
dev
ice
sett
ing
s
F.I
.cIs
th
ere
a p
red
eter
min
ed p
roto
col
dri
ven
by
fir
e co
nd
itio
ns
for
ad
just
ing
sen
siti
vit
y o
f g
rid
ele
men
ts?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
ad
just
s sy
stem
op
era
tio
ns
(e.g
. re
-clo
sin
g)
wh
en m
eteo
rolo
gy
id
enti
fies
R4
an
d/o
r R
5 w
eath
er c
on
dit
ion
s. P
G&
E p
lan
s to
ma
inta
in t
his
pra
ctic
e, a
nd
wil
l
con
tin
ue
to c
on
sid
er o
ther
po
ten
tia
l a
dju
stm
ents
th
rou
gh
20
23
.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
28
Inco
rpo
rati
ng
ign
itio
n r
isk
fact
ors
in
gri
d
con
tro
l
F.I
I.a
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
ha
ve
a c
lea
rly
ex
pla
ined
pro
cess
fo
r d
eter
min
ing
wh
eth
er t
o
op
era
te t
he
gri
d b
eyo
nd
cu
rren
t o
r
vo
lta
ge
des
ign
s?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
tra
nsm
issi
on
fo
llo
ws
pro
ced
ure
14
00
an
d d
istr
ibu
tio
n f
oll
ow
s p
roce
du
re 2
70
0.
Th
is p
ract
ice
is e
xp
ecte
d t
o c
on
tin
ue
thro
ug
h 2
02
3.
PG
&E
is
no
t to
ex
ceed
em
erg
ency
rati
ng
s ev
en i
n c
on
tin
gen
cies
. If
, o
n t
he
tra
nsm
issi
on
s si
de,
th
ere
wa
s a
nee
d t
o
op
era
te t
he
gri
d b
eyo
nd
cu
rren
t o
r v
olt
ag
e d
esig
ns,
PG
&E
wo
uld
nee
d t
o g
o t
hro
ug
h a
spec
ial
pro
cess
to
ev
alu
ate
op
era
tio
ns
do
ne
ou
tsid
e em
erg
ency
ra
tin
gs.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
28
Inco
rpo
rati
ng
ign
itio
n r
isk
fact
ors
in
gri
d
con
tro
l
F.I
I.b
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
ha
ve
syst
ems
in p
lace
to
au
tom
ati
call
y t
rack
op
era
tio
n h
isto
ry
incl
ud
ing
cu
rren
t, l
oa
ds,
an
d v
olt
ag
e
thro
ug
ho
ut
the
gri
d a
t th
e ci
rcu
it l
evel
?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
ha
s sy
stem
s in
pla
ce t
o t
rack
op
era
tio
n h
isto
ry i
ncl
ud
ing
cu
rren
t,
loa
ds,
an
d v
olt
ag
e th
rou
gh
ou
t th
e g
rid
, b
ut
do
es n
ot
ha
ve
100
% v
isib
ilit
y.
Dis
trib
uti
on
op
era
tio
n h
isto
ry i
s tr
ack
ed i
n S
CA
DA
an
d t
ran
smis
sio
n o
per
ati
on
his
tory
is
tra
cked
in E
MS
an
d/o
r P
I. I
n t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
wil
l co
nti
nu
e to
ex
pa
nd
its
tra
ckin
g o
f
op
era
tio
n h
isto
ry,
bu
t d
oes
no
t a
nti
cip
ate
ha
vin
g a
fu
lly
au
tom
ate
d p
roce
ss b
y 2
02
3.
Atch5-15
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
28
Inco
rpo
rati
ng
ign
itio
n r
isk
fact
ors
in
gri
d
con
tro
l
F.I
I.c
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
use
pre
dic
tiv
e m
od
elin
g
to e
stim
ate
th
e ex
pec
ted
lif
e a
nd
ma
ke
equ
ipm
ent
ma
inte
na
nce
, re
bu
ild
, o
r
rep
lace
men
t d
ecis
ion
s b
ase
d o
n g
rid
op
era
tin
g h
isto
ry,
an
d i
s th
at
mo
del
rev
iew
ed?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E u
ses
pre
dic
tiv
e m
od
elin
g t
o a
sses
s a
sset
hea
lth
an
d p
rov
ide
po
ten
tia
l a
sset
fail
ure
in
form
ati
on
ba
sed
on
win
d c
on
dit
ion
s. H
isto
rica
l m
ain
ten
an
ce i
s o
ne
com
po
nen
t in
ass
et h
ealt
h.
Th
is m
od
el,
alo
ng
wit
h o
ther
fa
cto
rs,
is u
sed
to
ass
ess
an
y
rep
lace
men
ts,
reb
uil
ds
or
ma
inte
na
nce
req
uir
emen
ts.
Th
e m
od
el h
as
bee
n u
sed
,
rev
iew
ed,
an
d c
o-d
evel
op
ed b
y c
on
sult
an
ts w
ith
ex
per
ien
ce i
n a
sset
fa
ilu
re.
Th
e m
od
el
ha
s a
lso
bee
n c
on
sult
ed t
hro
ug
h U
CL
A.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
wil
l co
nti
nu
e to
use
th
is
mo
del
as
wel
l a
s le
ver
ag
e h
isto
rica
l d
ata
.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
28
Inco
rpo
rati
ng
ign
itio
n r
isk
fact
ors
in
gri
d
con
tro
l
F.I
I.d
Wh
en d
oes
th
e u
tili
ty o
per
ate
th
e g
rid
ab
ov
e ra
ted
vo
lta
ge
an
d c
urr
ent
loa
d?
iiii
PG
&E
in
terp
rets
th
e te
rm "
con
dit
ion
s" a
re t
ho
se t
ha
t
per
tain
to
th
e sy
stem
op
era
tio
ns
con
dit
ion
s, n
ot
exte
rna
l p
hy
sica
l co
nd
itio
ns
(e.g
., w
eath
er,
clim
ate
)
PG
&E
's f
oll
ow
s m
an
y o
per
ati
ng
sta
nd
ard
s a
nd
pro
ced
ure
s o
n v
olt
ag
e a
nd
cu
rren
t
ran
ges
th
at
mu
st b
e m
ain
tain
ed i
n t
he
tra
nsm
issi
on
sta
nd
ard
. O
n o
cca
sio
n,
the
vo
lta
ge
ma
y f
luct
ua
te o
ut
of
a n
orm
al
bo
un
d,
for
dis
trib
uti
on
in
sp
ecif
ic e
mer
gen
cy
circ
um
sta
nce
s th
at
are
wit
hin
PG
&E
sta
nd
ard
pro
toco
l. P
G&
E p
lan
s to
ma
inta
in t
his
ind
ust
ry p
ract
ice
in t
he
futu
re.
FF
. G
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
29
PS
PS
op
. m
od
el
an
d c
on
seq
uen
ce
mit
iga
tio
n
F.I
II.a
Ho
w e
ffec
tiv
e is
PS
PS
ev
ent
fore
cast
ing
?iv
ivP
SP
S f
ore
cast
eff
ecti
ven
ess
is m
easu
red
by
com
pa
rin
g P
SP
S e
ven
t fo
reca
sts
as
of
EO
C a
ctiv
ati
on
to a
ctu
al
nu
mb
er o
f P
SP
S e
ven
ts
Wh
en P
G&
E h
as
act
iva
ted
th
e E
mer
gen
cy O
per
ati
on
s C
ente
r (E
OC
) fo
r a
po
ten
tia
l
PS
PS
ev
ent,
th
ere
wer
e n
earl
y a
lwa
ys
sub
seq
uen
t w
eath
er c
on
dit
ion
s th
at
wa
rra
nte
d
PS
PS
. B
egin
nin
g i
n 2
018
, o
f th
e 11
tim
es P
G&
E h
as
act
iva
ted
its
EO
C f
or
a p
ote
nti
al
PS
PS
ev
ent,
it
ha
s d
e-en
erg
ized
10
of
tho
se t
imes
. G
iven
th
e o
ng
oin
g a
nd
pla
nn
ed
init
iati
ves
at
PG
&E
, th
e u
tili
ty e
xp
ects
to
ma
inta
in t
his
lev
el o
f fo
reca
st e
ffec
tiv
enes
s
thro
ug
h 2
02
3 (
see
sect
ion
5.3
.3 -
Sit
ua
tio
na
l A
wa
ren
ess
an
d F
ore
cast
ing
). P
G&
E d
oes
no
t b
elie
ve
fore
cast
eff
ecti
ven
ess
sho
uld
be
det
erm
ined
by
co
mp
ari
ng
fo
reca
st s
cop
e a
t
the
tim
e o
f E
OC
act
iva
tio
n t
o t
ha
t a
t th
e ti
me
of
de-
ener
giz
ati
on
, si
nce
PG
&E
del
iber
ate
ly e
mp
loy
ed a
"st
art
bro
ad
an
d n
arr
ow
th
e sc
op
e" s
tra
teg
y i
n t
he
20
19
wil
dfi
re s
easo
n.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
29
PS
PS
op
. m
od
el
an
d c
on
seq
uen
ce
mit
iga
tio
n
F.I
II.b
Wh
at
sha
re o
f cu
sto
mer
s a
re
com
mu
nic
ate
d t
o r
ega
rdin
g f
ore
cast
ed
PS
PS
ev
ents
?
iiiv
No
ne
Du
rin
g t
he
20
19 w
ild
fire
sea
son
, P
SP
S e
ven
t fo
reca
sts
wer
e co
mm
un
ica
ted
to
>9
5%
of
all
aff
ecte
d c
ust
om
ers
an
d 9
9%
of
med
ica
l b
ase
lin
e cu
sto
mer
s in
ad
va
nce
of
de-
ener
giz
ati
on
. B
y 2
02
3,
PG
&E
aim
s to
im
pro
ve
thes
e m
etri
cs t
o >
99
% o
f a
ll a
ffec
ted
cust
om
ers
an
d 9
9.9
% o
f m
edic
al
ba
seli
ne
cust
om
ers.
Acc
ura
te,
up
-to
-da
te c
ust
om
er
con
tact
in
form
ati
on
rem
ain
s a
ch
all
eng
e in
th
is e
ffo
rt,
ho
wev
er.
PG
&E
pla
ns
on
eng
ag
ing
oth
er a
gen
cies
an
d o
rga
niz
ati
on
s th
at
ma
y h
av
e m
ore
rel
eva
nt
info
rma
tio
n
tha
n t
ha
t co
nta
ined
in
Cu
sto
mer
Ca
re a
nd
Bil
lin
g r
eco
rds.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
29
PS
PS
op
. m
od
el
an
d c
on
seq
uen
ce
mit
iga
tio
n
F.I
II.c
Du
rin
g P
SP
S e
ven
ts,
wh
at
per
cen
t o
f
cust
om
ers
com
pla
in?
iii
iii
PG
&E
in
clu
des
bo
th f
orm
al
com
pla
ints
to
th
e C
PU
C
an
d P
SP
S-r
ela
ted
ca
lls
into
th
e cu
sto
mer
ca
re l
ine
in
its
cou
nt
of
com
pla
ints
.
Du
rin
g t
he
20
19 w
ild
fire
sea
son
, <
0.5
% o
f P
G&
E c
ust
om
ers
com
pla
ined
du
rin
g P
SP
S
even
ts.
Du
rin
g t
his
tim
e p
erio
d,
PG
&E
rec
eiv
ed 1
36
su
ch c
om
pla
ints
. P
G&
E h
op
es t
o
low
er c
om
pla
int
rate
s y
ear
ov
er y
ear
by
co
lla
bo
rati
ng
mo
re e
ffec
tiv
ely
wit
h p
ub
lic
ag
enci
es,
dev
elo
pin
g m
ore
tw
o-w
ay
dia
log
ues
wit
h c
om
mu
nit
ies,
an
d m
itig
ati
ng
PS
PS
imp
act
s in
gen
era
l.F
Gri
d o
per
ati
on
s
an
d p
roto
cols
29
PS
PS
op
. m
od
el
an
d c
on
seq
uen
ce
mit
iga
tio
n
F.I
II.d
Du
rin
g P
SP
S e
ven
ts,
do
es t
he
uti
lity
's
web
site
go
do
wn
?
iii
No
ne
Du
rin
g t
he
20
19 w
ild
fire
sea
son
, th
e w
ebsi
te w
ent
do
wn
tw
o t
imes
. P
G&
E i
ncr
ease
d
the
use
of
red
un
da
nci
es,
re-r
ou
tin
g,
an
d s
tres
s te
stin
g i
n r
esp
on
se t
o t
hes
e ev
ents
an
d
did
no
t ex
per
ien
ce w
ebsi
te d
ow
nti
me
thro
ug
ho
ut
the
rem
ain
der
of
the
wil
dfi
re s
easo
n.
PG
&E
pla
ns
to c
on
tin
ue
thes
e p
ract
ices
an
d a
ims
to a
vo
id w
ebsi
te d
ow
nti
me
alt
og
eth
er i
n t
he
futu
re.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
29
PS
PS
op
. m
od
el
an
d c
on
seq
uen
ce
mit
iga
tio
n
F.I
II.e
Du
rin
g P
SP
S e
ven
ts,
wh
at
is t
he
av
era
ge
do
wn
tim
e p
er c
ust
om
er?
vv
Th
is q
ues
tio
ns
refe
rs t
o w
ebsi
te d
ow
nti
me
acr
oss
all
even
ts/
tota
l cu
sto
mer
s fo
r a
ll e
ven
ts.
Du
rin
g t
he
20
19 W
ild
fire
Sea
son
th
ere
wer
e tw
o d
ow
nti
me
even
ts,
resu
ltin
g i
n a
to
tal
web
site
do
wn
tim
e o
f 2
,98
2 m
inu
tes.
Ap
pro
xim
ate
ly 2
mil
lio
n c
ust
om
ers
wer
e
imp
act
ed b
y P
SP
S o
ver
th
is t
ime.
Th
is t
ran
sla
tes
to a
ver
ag
e cu
sto
mer
do
wn
tim
e o
f le
ss
tha
n 0
.1 h
ou
rs.
PG
&E
in
crea
sed
th
e u
se o
f re
du
nd
an
cies
, re
-ro
uti
ng
, a
nd
str
ess
test
ing
in r
esp
on
se t
o t
he
do
wn
tim
e ev
ents
an
d d
id n
ot
exp
erie
nce
web
site
do
wn
tim
e
thro
ug
ho
ut
the
rem
ain
der
of
the
wil
dfi
re s
easo
n.
PG
&E
pla
ns
to c
on
tin
ue
thes
e
pra
ctic
es a
nd
aim
s to
av
oid
web
site
do
wn
tim
e a
lto
get
her
in
th
e fu
ture
.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
29
PS
PS
op
. m
od
el
an
d c
on
seq
uen
ce
mit
iga
tio
n
F.I
II.f
Are
sp
ecif
ic r
eso
urc
es p
rov
ided
to
cust
om
ers
to a
llev
iate
th
e im
pa
ct o
f th
e
po
wer
sh
uto
ff (
e.g
., p
rov
idin
g b
ack
up
gen
era
tors
, su
pp
lies
, b
att
erie
s, e
tc.)
?
iiii
No
ne
Du
rin
g t
he
20
19 w
ild
fire
sea
son
, P
G&
E a
ttem
pte
d t
o a
llev
iate
PS
PS
im
pa
ct t
hro
ug
h i
ts
cust
om
er r
eso
urc
e ce
nte
rs (
CR
Cs)
. W
hil
e a
men
itie
s v
ari
ed b
y e
ven
t, e
xa
mp
le
reso
urc
es i
ncl
ud
ed m
ob
ile
dev
ice
cha
rgin
g,
ice,
an
d b
lan
ket
s, a
nd
, a
s th
e se
aso
n
pro
gre
ssed
, P
G&
E i
ncr
ease
d c
oll
ab
ora
tio
n w
ith
co
un
ties
to
ev
olv
e it
s C
RC
am
enit
ies
an
d p
roto
cols
(e.
g.,
AD
A a
cces
s, h
ou
rs o
f o
per
ati
on
). M
ov
ing
fo
rwa
rd,
PG
&E
wil
l
con
tin
ue
to i
ncr
ease
co
lla
bo
rati
on
wit
h c
ou
nti
es a
nd
tri
ba
l a
gen
cies
to
im
pro
ve
the
CR
C c
ust
om
er e
xp
erie
nce
an
d i
nte
gra
te C
RC
op
era
tio
ns
mo
re c
oh
esiv
ely
wit
h c
ou
nty
emer
gen
cy o
per
ati
on
s (e
.g.,
pre
-id
enti
fy m
ore
CR
C l
oca
tio
ns)
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
30
Pro
toco
ls f
or
PS
PS
in
itia
tio
n
F.I
V.a
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
ha
ve
exp
lici
t th
resh
old
s
for
act
iva
tin
g a
PS
PS
?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
ha
s ex
pli
cit
thre
sho
lds
for
act
iva
tin
g a
PS
PS
, a
s a
ma
tter
of
last
res
ort
.
Atch5-16
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
30
Pro
toco
ls f
or
PS
PS
in
itia
tio
n
F.I
V.b
Wh
ich
of
the
foll
ow
ing
do
es t
he
uti
lity
tak
e in
to a
cco
un
t w
hen
ma
kin
g P
SP
S
dec
isio
ns?
Sel
ect
all
th
at
ap
ply
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
ha
s a
pa
rtia
lly
au
tom
ate
d s
yst
em w
hic
h r
eco
mm
end
s ci
rcu
its
for
PS
PS
an
d
wh
ich
is
then
va
lid
ate
d b
y S
ME
s. P
G&
E w
ill
con
tin
ue
to u
se t
his
pro
cess
fo
r th
e
fore
seea
ble
fu
ture
.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
30
Pro
toco
ls f
or
PS
PS
in
itia
tio
n
F.I
V.c
Un
der
wh
ich
cir
cum
sta
nce
s d
oes
th
e
uti
lity
de-
ener
giz
e ci
rcu
its?
Sel
ect
all
tha
t a
pp
ly.
i,ii
,iii
,iv
i,ii
,iii
,iv
No
ne
PG
&E
wil
l d
e-en
erg
ize
circ
uit
s fo
r n
um
ero
us
rea
son
s in
clu
din
g,
bu
t n
ot
lim
ited
to
:
• U
po
n d
etec
tio
n o
f d
am
ag
ed c
on
dit
ion
s o
f el
ectr
ic e
qu
ipm
ent,
• W
hen
cir
cuit
pre
sen
ts a
sa
fety
ris
k t
o s
up
pre
ssio
n o
r o
ther
per
son
nel
an
d t
he
sup
pre
ssio
n a
gen
cy h
as
req
ues
ted
de-
ener
giz
ati
on
,
• W
hen
eq
uip
men
t h
as
com
e in
to c
on
tact
wit
h f
ore
ign
ob
ject
s p
osi
ng
ig
nit
ion
ris
k a
nd
do
es n
ot
tak
e it
self
ou
t,
• If
cir
cuit
s a
re o
ver
loa
ded
,
• W
hen
ga
s le
ak
s a
re d
etec
ted
in
a v
ola
tile
atm
osp
her
e
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
30
Pro
toco
ls f
or
PS
PS
in
itia
tio
n
F.I
V.d
Giv
en t
he
con
dit
ion
of
the
gri
d,
wit
h
wh
at
pro
ba
bil
ity
do
es t
he
uti
lity
ex
pec
t
an
y l
arg
e sc
ale
PS
PS
ev
ents
aff
ecti
ng
mo
re t
ha
n 1
0,0
00
peo
ple
to
occ
ur
in t
he
com
ing
yea
r?
iiii
No
ne.
PG
&E
an
tici
pa
tes
an
av
era
ge
of
5-6
PS
PS
ev
ents
per
yea
r. I
n t
he
pa
st,
PG
&E
ha
s n
ot
exec
ute
d a
PS
PS
ev
ent
tha
t a
ffec
ted
les
s th
an
10
,00
0 p
eop
le.
Alt
ho
ug
h m
itig
ati
on
effo
rts
wil
l h
av
e a
n i
mp
act
on
th
e P
SP
S p
roce
ss,
PG
&E
an
tici
pa
tes
wit
h a
pro
ba
bil
ity
of
gre
ate
r th
an
5%
, h
av
ing
la
rge
sca
le P
SP
S e
ven
ts a
ffec
t m
ore
th
an
10
,00
0 p
eop
le i
n
the
com
ing
yea
r.F
Gri
d o
per
ati
on
s
an
d p
roto
cols
31
Pro
toco
ls f
or
PS
PS
re-
ener
giz
ati
on
F.V
.aIs
th
ere
a p
roce
ss f
or
insp
ecti
ng
de-
ener
giz
ed s
ecti
on
s o
f th
e g
rid
pri
or
to r
e-
ener
giz
ati
on
?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es h
av
e a
pro
cess
fo
r in
spec
tin
g d
e-en
erg
ized
sec
tio
ns
of
the
gri
d p
rio
r to
re-
ener
giz
ati
on
aft
er a
PS
PS
ev
ent.
Th
ere
is c
urr
entl
y a
n e
xis
tin
g p
roce
ss (
TD
-14
64
B-0
2)
for
acc
ura
tely
in
spec
tin
g d
e-en
erg
ized
sec
tio
ns
of
the
gri
d.
PG
&E
do
es h
av
e a
eria
l
too
ls,
bu
t n
ot
sen
sors
. P
G&
E i
s m
ak
ing
fo
rwa
rd p
rog
ress
, b
ut
do
es n
ot
bel
iev
e
au
gm
enta
tio
n w
ith
sen
sors
an
d a
eria
l to
ols
wil
l b
e co
mp
lete
20
23
.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
31
Pro
toco
ls f
or
PS
PS
re-
ener
giz
ati
on
F.V
.bH
ow
au
tom
ate
d i
s th
e p
roce
ss f
or
insp
ecti
ng
de-
ener
giz
ed s
ecti
on
s o
f th
e
gri
d p
rio
r to
re
ener
giz
ati
on
?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
's c
urr
ent
pro
cess
fo
r in
spec
tin
g d
e-en
erg
ized
sec
tio
ns
of
the
gri
d p
rio
r to
re
ener
giz
ati
on
is
ma
nu
al.
In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E p
lan
s to
mo
ve
to a
pa
rtia
lly
au
tom
ate
d
pro
cess
wh
ich
ma
y i
ncl
ud
e th
e u
se o
f L
iDA
R,
sate
llit
e im
ag
ery
an
d p
rog
ram
ma
ble
cam
era
tec
hn
olo
gy
.F
Gri
d o
per
ati
on
s
an
d p
roto
cols
31
Pro
toco
ls f
or
PS
PS
re-
ener
giz
ati
on
F.V
.cW
ha
t is
th
e a
ver
ag
e a
mo
un
t o
f ti
me
tha
t
it t
ak
es y
ou
to
re-
ener
giz
e y
ou
r g
rid
fro
m
a P
SP
S o
nce
wea
ther
ha
s su
bsi
ded
to
bel
ow
yo
ur
de-
ener
giz
ati
on
th
resh
old
?
iiiv
No
ne
PG
&E
's a
ver
ag
e a
mo
un
t o
f ti
me
to r
e-en
erg
ize
the
gri
d a
fter
th
e w
eath
er h
as
sub
sid
ed
fro
m a
PS
PS
ev
ent
is u
nd
er t
wen
ty-f
ou
r d
ay
lig
ht
ho
urs
. P
G&
E's
go
al
is t
o a
chie
ve
rest
ori
ng
in
un
der
da
yli
gh
t tw
elv
e h
ou
rs.
Th
is g
oa
l w
ill
be
ach
iev
ed b
y u
nd
erst
an
din
g
wh
at
lin
es c
an
be
pa
tro
lled
by
aer
ial
reso
urc
es a
nd
sec
uri
ng
mu
tua
l a
id e
arl
y.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
31
Pro
toco
ls f
or
PS
PS
re-
ener
giz
ati
on
F.V
.dW
ha
t le
vel
of
un
der
sta
nd
ing
of
pro
ba
bil
ity
of
ign
itio
ns
aft
er P
SP
S
even
ts d
oes
th
e u
tili
ty h
av
e a
cro
ss t
he
gri
d?
iiii
iP
G&
E i
s a
nsw
erin
g t
his
qu
esti
on
usi
ng
th
e
ass
um
pti
on
th
at
the
ign
itio
n r
isk
in
qu
esti
on
ref
ers
to “
the
risk
of
ign
itio
n f
rom
re-
ener
giz
ing
aft
er a
PS
PS
pa
tro
l”
PG
&E
pa
rtro
ls l
ines
im
pa
cted
by
PS
PS
co
nd
itio
ns
pri
or
to r
een
erg
iza
tio
n a
nd
use
s
tha
t in
form
ati
on
to
in
form
ab
ou
t th
e p
rob
ab
ilit
y o
f ig
nit
ion
.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
32
Ign
itio
n
pre
ven
tio
n a
nd
sup
pre
ssio
n
F.V
I.a
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
ha
ve
def
ined
po
lici
es
aro
un
d t
he
role
of
wo
rker
s in
sup
pre
ssin
g i
gn
itio
ns?
iii
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
ha
s ex
pli
cit
po
lici
es a
bo
ut
the
role
of
crew
s in
clu
din
g c
on
tra
cto
rs a
nd
sub
con
tra
cto
rs a
t th
e si
te o
f ig
nit
ion
.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
32
Ign
itio
n
pre
ven
tio
n a
nd
sup
pre
ssio
n
F.V
I.b
Wh
at
tra
inin
g a
nd
to
ols
are
pro
vid
ed t
o
fiel
d w
ork
ers?
iii
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
pro
vid
es t
rain
ing
an
d c
om
mu
nic
ati
on
s to
ols
to
im
med
iate
ly r
epo
rt i
gn
itio
ns
cau
sed
by
wo
rker
s o
r in
im
med
iate
vic
init
y o
f w
ork
ers.
In
ad
dit
ion
, su
pp
ress
ion
to
ols
an
d t
rain
ing
to
su
pp
ress
sm
all
ig
nit
ion
s a
re p
rov
ided
to
so
me
wo
rker
s. I
n t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
fo
rese
es t
he
use
of
SIP
T c
rew
an
d/o
r p
ub
lic
safe
ty s
pec
iali
sts
as
tra
iner
s;
ho
wev
er,
PG
&E
is
no
t su
re t
hey
wil
l h
av
e co
mm
un
ica
tio
n t
oo
ls f
un
ctio
nin
g w
ith
ou
t
cell
rec
epti
on
an
d t
rain
ing
by
su
pp
ress
ion
pro
fess
ion
als
pro
vid
ed b
y 2
02
3.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
32
Ign
itio
n
pre
ven
tio
n a
nd
sup
pre
ssio
n
F.V
I.c
In t
he
even
t w
ork
ers
enco
un
ter
an
ign
itio
n,
do
an
y m
ajo
r in
juri
es o
r
fata
liti
es o
ccu
r? I
n t
he
even
ts w
her
e
wo
rker
s h
av
e en
cou
nte
red
an
ig
nit
ion
,
ha
ve
an
y C
al/
OS
HA
rep
ort
ed i
nju
ries
or
fata
liti
es o
ccu
rred
in
in
th
e la
st y
ear?
ii
No
ne
In e
ven
ts w
her
e w
ork
ers
ha
ve
enco
un
tere
d a
n i
gn
itio
n,
PG
&E
ha
s n
ot
rep
ort
ed a
ny
Ca
l/O
SH
A i
nju
ries
or
fata
liti
es i
n t
he
pa
st y
ear,
as
rep
ort
ed i
n t
he
WM
P.
FG
rid
op
era
tio
ns
an
d p
roto
cols
32
Ign
itio
n
pre
ven
tio
n a
nd
sup
pre
ssio
n
F.V
I.d
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
pro
vid
e tr
ain
ing
to
oth
er
wo
rker
s a
t o
ther
uti
liti
es a
nd
ou
tsid
e th
e
uti
lity
in
du
stry
on
bes
t p
ract
ices
to
min
imiz
e, r
epo
rt a
nd
su
pp
ress
ign
itio
ns?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
tra
ins
mu
tua
l a
ssis
tan
ce c
rew
s b
efo
re s
end
ing
th
em o
ut
in P
G&
E
terr
ito
ry.
Ho
wev
er,
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
pro
act
ivel
y p
rov
ide
tra
inin
g t
o o
ther
wo
rker
s a
t
oth
er u
tili
ties
an
d o
uts
ide
the
uti
lity
in
du
stry
on
bes
t p
ract
ices
to
min
imiz
e, r
epo
rt
an
d s
up
pre
ss i
gn
itio
ns.
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
3D
ata
co
llec
tio
n
an
d c
ura
tio
n
G.I
.aD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty h
av
e a
cen
tra
lize
d
da
tab
ase
of
situ
ati
on
al,
op
era
tio
na
l, a
nd
risk
da
ta?
iii
"Cen
tra
lize
d d
ata
ba
se"
mea
ns
com
mo
n p
latf
orm
fo
r
da
ta r
ath
er t
ha
n c
om
ple
te i
nte
gra
tio
n o
f en
terp
rise
syst
ems.
PG
&E
's c
ust
om
er d
ata
, a
sset
da
ta,
wo
rk m
an
ag
emen
t d
ata
, G
IS d
ata
, o
per
ati
on
s d
ata
an
d e
ven
t d
ata
ha
ve
tra
dit
ion
all
y b
een
ma
na
ged
in
sep
ara
te s
yst
ems,
wit
h
ind
epen
den
t d
ata
sto
res.
PG
&E
ha
s p
lan
s to
in
teg
rate
po
rtio
ns
of
its
da
ta,
incl
ud
ing
the
Ele
ctri
c O
per
ati
on
s d
ata
- A
sset
Da
ta F
ou
nd
ati
on
(A
DF
).G
Da
ta g
ov
ern
an
ce
33
Da
ta c
oll
ecti
on
an
d c
ura
tio
n
G.I
.bIs
th
e u
tili
ty a
ble
to
use
ad
va
nce
d
an
aly
tics
on
its
cen
tra
lize
d d
ata
ba
se o
f
situ
ati
on
al,
op
era
tio
na
l, a
nd
ris
k d
ata
to
ma
ke
op
era
tio
na
l a
nd
in
ves
tmen
t d
ecis
ion
s?
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E p
lan
s to
use
ad
va
nce
d a
na
lyti
cs f
or
sho
rt a
nd
lo
ng
ter
m d
ecis
ion
ma
kin
g.
In t
he
sho
rt t
erm
, P
G&
E w
ill
use
Tec
hn
osy
lva
to
red
uce
rea
l ti
me
op
era
tio
na
l ri
sk.
In t
he
lon
g t
erm
, P
G&
E p
lan
s to
use
ad
va
nce
d a
na
lyti
cs t
o s
et i
nsp
ecti
on
cy
cles
an
d p
rio
riti
ze
syst
em h
ard
enin
g i
nit
iati
ves
.
Atch5-17
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
3D
ata
co
llec
tio
n
an
d c
ura
tio
n
G.I
.cD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty c
oll
ect
da
ta f
rom
all
sen
sore
d p
ort
ion
s o
f el
ectr
ic l
ines
,
equ
ipm
ent,
wea
ther
sta
tio
ns,
etc
.?
iiii
"Co
llec
t d
ata
fro
m a
ll s
enso
red
po
rtio
ns"
mea
ns
tha
t
da
ta i
s a
va
ila
ble
to
be
coll
ecte
d.
PG
&E
co
llec
ts d
ata
fro
m a
ll S
CA
DA
-en
ab
led
sen
sore
d p
ort
ion
s o
f el
ectr
ic l
ines
,
equ
ipm
ent,
an
d w
eath
er s
tati
on
s. H
ow
ever
, n
ot
all
sen
sors
are
SC
AD
A-e
na
ble
d.
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
3D
ata
co
llec
tio
n
an
d c
ura
tio
n
G.I
.dIs
th
e u
tili
ty's
da
tab
ase
of
situ
ati
on
al,
op
era
tio
na
l, a
nd
ris
k d
ata
ab
le t
o i
ng
est
an
d s
ha
re d
ata
usi
ng
rea
l-ti
me
AP
I
pro
toco
ls w
ith
a w
ide
va
riet
y o
f
sta
keh
old
ers?
ii
1) "
Sta
keh
old
ers"
mea
ns
inte
rna
l st
ak
eho
lder
s.
2)
PG
&E
in
terp
rets
"re
al
tim
e A
PI
pro
toco
ls"
as
mea
nin
g t
ha
t th
e d
ata
ba
se c
an
in
teg
rate
op
era
tio
na
l
an
d r
isk
da
ta i
n r
eal
tim
e o
r o
n a
reg
ula
r, f
req
uen
t
cad
ence
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
use
s a
SC
AD
A H
isto
ria
n a
nd
PI
syst
em i
n i
ts c
on
tro
l ce
nte
rs.
Wh
ile
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
bel
iev
e re
al-
tim
e p
roto
cols
wil
l b
e fe
asi
ble
by
20
23
, th
e u
tili
ty w
ill
wo
rk t
ow
ard
s a
mo
re d
yn
am
ic i
nte
rfa
ce f
or
ass
et p
erfo
rma
nce
in
th
e fu
ture
.
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
3D
ata
co
llec
tio
n
an
d c
ura
tio
n
G.I
.eD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty i
den
tify
hig
hes
t p
rio
rity
ad
dit
ion
al
da
ta s
ou
rces
to
im
pro
ve
dec
isio
n m
ak
ing
?
iiii
i"D
ata
ba
se"
is a
pp
lied
her
e w
ith
th
e a
ssu
mp
tio
n t
ha
t
ther
e w
ill
stil
l b
e a
hu
ma
n e
lem
ent
to t
his
pro
cess
.
PG
&E
id
enti
fies
hig
h-p
rio
rity
ad
dit
ion
al
da
ta s
ou
rces
to
im
pro
ve
dec
isio
n m
ak
ing
, a
s
seen
wit
h t
he
acq
uis
itio
n o
f th
e h
igh
-res
olu
tio
n c
am
era
s, w
eath
er s
tati
on
s, a
nd
sate
llit
es.
PG
&E
ha
s n
ot
per
form
ed t
his
ass
essm
ent
ho
list
ica
lly
acr
oss
th
e u
tili
ty.
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
3D
ata
co
llec
tio
n
an
d c
ura
tio
n
G.I
.fD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty s
ha
re b
est
pra
ctic
es f
or
da
tab
ase
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d u
se w
ith
oth
er u
tili
ties
in
Ca
lifo
rnia
an
d b
eyo
nd
?
ii
PG
&E
ass
um
es "
da
tab
ase
ma
na
gem
ent"
ref
ers
to
ho
w P
G&
E d
ecid
es w
hic
h t
yp
es o
f d
ata
sh
ou
ld b
e
coll
ecte
d a
nd
ho
w t
hey
sh
ou
ld b
e co
llec
ted
, n
ot
ho
w
the
da
tab
ase
its
elf
sho
uld
be
stru
ctu
red
PG
&E
is
no
t cu
rren
tly
sh
ari
ng
da
ta a
rou
nd
nea
r m
isse
s, c
au
ses,
or
fail
ure
s. T
his
is
larg
ely
du
e to
th
e fa
ct t
ha
t P
G&
E i
s co
llec
tin
g d
iffe
ren
t ty
pes
of
da
ta t
ha
n t
he
oth
er
IOU
S,
ma
kin
g i
t h
ard
to
sh
are
on
th
e d
ata
att
rib
ute
lev
el.
PG
&E
is
ab
le t
o s
ha
re e
ven
t
ba
sed
da
ta l
earn
ing
s. I
n t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
wo
uld
nee
d s
up
po
rt t
o d
efin
e co
nsi
sten
t
da
ta a
ttri
bu
tes
tha
t ca
n b
e ca
ptu
red
an
d s
ha
red
acr
oss
th
e IO
US
. P
G&
E a
nd
oth
er
IOU
s w
ill
be
coll
ecti
ng
sta
nd
ard
ized
da
ta i
n f
ire
spre
ad
mo
del
ing
(u
sin
g t
he
sam
e to
ol
-
Tec
hn
osy
lva
).G
Da
ta g
ov
ern
an
ce
34
Da
ta
tra
nsp
are
ncy
an
d
an
aly
tics
G.I
I.a
Is t
her
e a
sin
gle
do
cum
ent
cata
log
uin
g
all
fir
e-re
late
d d
ata
an
d a
lgo
rith
ms,
an
aly
ses,
an
d d
ata
pro
cess
es?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
bel
iev
es t
ha
t a
su
ite
of
clea
rly
ca
teg
ori
zed
do
cum
ents
is
mo
re e
ffec
tiv
e th
an
a
sin
gle
do
cum
ent
in t
his
in
sta
nce
. A
s su
ch,
PG
&E
ha
s a
su
ite
of
do
cum
ents
ca
talo
gu
ing
fire
rel
ate
d d
ata
, a
lgo
rith
ms,
so
urc
es,
an
d a
ssu
mp
tio
ns.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
ha
ve
futu
re
pla
ns
to c
on
soli
da
te t
he
info
rma
tio
n i
nto
a s
ing
le d
ocu
men
t b
eca
use
PG
&E
bel
iev
es
tha
t h
av
ing
mu
ltip
le d
ocu
men
ts t
ha
t a
re e
asy
to
fo
llo
w m
eets
th
e in
ten
t o
f th
is
qu
esti
on
.
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
4D
ata
tra
nsp
are
ncy
an
d
an
aly
tics
G.I
I.b
Is t
her
e a
n e
xp
lan
ati
on
of
the
sou
rces
,
clea
nin
g p
roce
sses
, a
nd
ass
um
pti
on
s
ma
de
in t
he
sin
gle
do
cum
ent
cata
log
?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
ha
s a
su
ite
of
do
cum
ents
ca
talo
gu
ing
fir
e re
late
d d
ata
, a
lgo
rith
ms,
so
urc
es,
an
d
ass
um
pti
on
s. P
G&
E d
oes
no
t h
av
e fu
ture
pla
ns
to c
on
soli
da
te t
he
info
rma
tio
n i
nto
a
sin
gle
do
cum
ent
bec
au
se P
G&
E b
elie
ves
th
at
ha
vin
g m
ult
iple
do
cum
ents
th
at
are
ea
sy
to f
oll
ow
mee
ts t
he
inte
nt
of
this
qu
esti
on
.G
Da
ta g
ov
ern
an
ce
34
Da
ta
tra
nsp
are
ncy
an
d
an
aly
tics
G.I
I.c
Are
all
an
aly
ses,
alg
ori
thm
s, a
nd
da
ta
pro
cess
ing
ex
pla
ined
an
d d
ocu
men
ted
?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E's
an
aly
ses,
alg
ori
thm
s, a
nd
da
ta p
roce
sses
are
do
cum
ente
d i
n m
ost
ca
ses,
bu
t
ma
y n
ot
be
exp
lain
ed i
n a
ll i
nst
an
ce.
PG
&E
pla
ns
on
im
pro
vin
g e
xp
lan
ati
on
s o
f it
s
do
cum
ente
d a
na
lyse
s, a
lgo
rith
ms
an
d d
ata
pro
cess
es i
n t
he
futu
re.
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
4D
ata
tra
nsp
are
ncy
an
d
an
aly
tics
G.I
I.d
Is t
her
e a
sy
stem
fo
r sh
ari
ng
da
ta i
n r
eal
tim
e a
cro
ss m
ult
iple
lev
els
of
per
mis
sio
n?
iii
iii
"Sy
stem
" m
ean
s a
pla
tfo
rm.
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
sh
are
s b
est
pra
ctic
es f
or
da
tab
ase
ma
na
gem
ent
an
d u
se w
ith
oth
er
uti
liti
es i
n C
ali
forn
ia a
nd
bey
on
d v
ia s
ever
al
pla
tfo
rms:
1)
the
AR
CG
IS p
ort
al
sha
res
rea
l-ti
me
ma
ps
to c
ou
nti
es,
2)
the
PS
PS
po
rta
l sh
are
s th
e cu
sto
mer
im
pa
cted
lis
ts t
o
loca
l g
ov
ern
men
t, a
nd
3)
PG
&E
's w
ebsi
te s
ha
res
oth
er p
ub
lic
da
ta.
PG
&E
wil
l
con
tin
ue
to e
xer
cise
th
is b
eha
vio
r in
th
e fo
rese
eab
le f
utu
re.
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
4D
ata
tra
nsp
are
ncy
an
d
an
aly
tics
G.I
I.e
Are
th
e m
ost
rel
eva
nt
wil
dfi
re r
ela
ted
da
ta a
lgo
rith
ms
dis
clo
sed
?
iii
iii
"Alg
ori
thm
" eq
ua
tes
to t
he
met
ho
do
log
y u
sed
.P
G&
E p
ub
licl
y d
iscl
ose
s th
e m
eth
od
olo
gy
th
at
sup
po
rts
the
da
ta a
lgo
rith
ms
bu
t d
oes
no
t sh
are
th
e sp
ecif
ic l
ines
of
cod
e.
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
5N
ear-
mis
s
tra
ckin
g
G.I
II.a
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
tra
ck n
ear
mis
s d
ata
fo
r
all
nea
r m
isse
s w
ith
wil
dfi
re i
gn
itio
n
po
ten
tia
l?
iii
"Nea
r m
iss"
mea
ns
an
ev
ent
tha
t h
ap
pen
ed i
n
PG
&E
's s
yst
em b
ut
did
no
t ca
use
an
ig
nit
ion
.
PG
&E
tra
cks
nea
r m
iss
da
ta (
ha
zard
s a
nd
da
ma
ges
) d
uri
ng
a P
SP
S e
ven
t, b
eca
use
if
ener
giz
ed,
tho
se n
ear
mis
ses
cou
ld h
av
e cr
eate
d a
po
ten
tia
l ig
nit
ion
. P
G&
E a
lso
cap
ture
s o
uta
ge
an
d w
ires
do
wn
in
form
ati
on
, a
nd
a s
ub
set
of
tha
t d
ata
co
uld
be
con
sid
ered
nea
r-m
iss
da
ta.
Du
rin
g n
orm
al
op
era
tio
ns,
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
ha
ve
a r
ob
ust
wa
y t
o c
ap
ture
all
nea
r m
iss
da
ta a
t th
is t
ime.
In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E w
ill
form
ali
ze a
pro
cess
to
ca
ptu
re n
ear
mis
s d
ata
du
rin
g n
orm
al
op
era
tio
ns.
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
5N
ear-
mis
s
tra
ckin
g
G.I
II.b
Ba
sed
on
nea
r m
iss
da
ta c
ap
ture
d,
is t
he
uti
lity
ab
le t
o s
imu
late
wil
dfi
re p
ote
nti
al
giv
en a
n i
gn
itio
n b
ase
d o
n e
ven
t
cha
ract
eris
tics
, fu
el l
oa
ds,
an
d m
ois
ture
?
iii
"Nea
r m
iss"
mea
ns
an
ev
ent
tha
t h
ap
pen
ed i
n
PG
&E
's s
yst
em b
ut
did
no
t ca
use
an
ig
nit
ion
.
PG
&E
is
ab
le t
o s
imu
late
wil
dfi
re p
ote
nti
al
giv
en a
n i
gn
itio
n v
ia t
wo
mo
del
s,
Tec
hn
osy
lva
an
d R
EA
X.
Th
ese
mo
del
s u
tili
ze w
eath
er a
nd
en
vir
on
men
tal
inp
uts
fro
m
PG
&E
’s i
nte
rna
l h
igh
-res
olu
tio
n w
eath
er s
yst
em,
PO
MM
S.
Wh
ile
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
mea
sure
nea
r m
isse
s ex
pli
citl
y,
the
uti
lity
mea
sure
s o
uta
ges
an
d
wir
es d
ow
n i
nst
an
ces,
a s
ub
set
wh
ich
are
co
nsi
der
ed n
ear-
mis
ses.
In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E
wil
l im
ple
men
t a
del
iber
ate
pro
cess
to
id
enti
fy n
ear
mis
ses.
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
5N
ear-
mis
s
tra
ckin
g
G.I
II.c
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
ca
ptu
re d
ata
rel
ate
d t
o
the
spec
ific
mo
de
of
fail
ure
wh
en
cap
turi
ng
nea
r m
iss
da
ta?
iii
"Nea
r m
iss"
mea
ns
an
ev
ent
tha
t h
ap
pen
ed i
n
PG
&E
's s
yst
em b
ut
did
no
t ca
use
an
ig
nit
ion
.
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
tri
es t
o c
ap
ture
th
e d
irec
t fa
ilu
re w
hen
ca
ptu
rin
g n
ear
mis
s d
ata
.
PG
&E
wil
l im
ple
men
t a
dd
itio
na
l ca
use
an
aly
sis
to b
ette
r ex
pla
in t
he
spec
ific
mo
de
of
fail
ure
wh
y a
fa
ilu
re o
ccu
rred
.
Atch5-18
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
5N
ear-
mis
s
tra
ckin
g
G.I
II.d
Is t
he
uti
lity
ab
le t
o p
red
ict
the
pro
ba
bil
ity
of
a n
ear
mis
s in
ca
usi
ng
an
ign
itio
n b
ase
d o
n a
set
of
even
t
cha
ract
eris
tics
?
iii
"Nea
r m
iss"
mea
ns
an
ev
ent
tha
t h
ap
pen
ed i
n
PG
&E
's s
yst
em b
ut
did
no
t ca
use
an
ig
nit
ion
.
At
this
tim
e, P
G&
E's
is
ab
le t
o p
red
ict
the
pro
ba
bil
ity
of
an
ig
nit
ion
ba
sed
on
win
d-
rela
ted
ev
ents
on
ly.
PG
&E
's T
ran
smis
sio
n O
per
ab
ilit
y A
sses
smen
t (O
A)
mo
del
con
sid
ers
the
lik
elih
oo
d o
f a
sp
ecif
ic t
ran
smis
sio
n l
ine
ass
et f
ail
ure
un
der
cer
tain
win
d
loa
din
g c
on
dit
ion
s. P
G&
E p
lan
s to
co
nti
nu
e to
en
ha
nce
th
e O
A m
od
el.
Als
o,
PG
&E
's
met
eoro
log
y t
eam
use
s a
n O
uta
ge
Pro
du
cin
g W
ind
(O
PW
) m
od
el,
wh
ich
pre
dic
ts t
he
pro
ba
bil
ity
of
a i
gn
itio
n b
ase
d o
n a
set
of
win
d-
rela
ted
ch
ara
cter
isti
cs.
PG
&E
wil
l
evo
lve
to a
mo
re h
oli
stic
pro
ba
bil
ity
mo
del
in
th
e fu
ture
.
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
5N
ear-
mis
s
tra
ckin
g
G.I
II.e
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
use
da
ta f
rom
nea
r
mis
ses
to c
ha
ng
e g
rid
op
era
tio
n
pro
toco
ls i
n r
eal
tim
e?
ii
"Nea
r m
iss"
mea
ns
an
ev
ent
tha
t h
ap
pen
ed i
n
PG
&E
's s
yst
em b
ut
did
no
t ca
use
an
ig
nit
ion
.
PG
&E
's g
rid
op
era
tors
in
terp
ret
da
ta o
n a
rea
l-ti
me
ba
sis
as
pa
rt o
f th
eir
no
rma
l
cou
rse
of
bu
sin
ess.
PG
&E
do
es c
ha
ng
e g
rid
op
era
tio
n p
roto
cols
no
t n
eces
sari
ly b
ase
d
on
rea
l ti
me
da
ta,
bu
t b
ase
d o
n f
ore
cast
ed w
eath
er.
Fo
r ex
am
ple
, P
G&
E w
ill
dis
ab
le
recl
osu
re o
per
ati
on
s th
rou
gh
ou
t th
e fi
re s
easo
n a
nd
wil
l te
st t
hem
ba
ck i
n w
hen
it
is
low
fir
e ri
sk i
s fo
reca
sted
. P
G&
E w
ill
use
lea
rnin
gs
tha
t co
me
ou
t o
f th
e n
ear
mis
s
an
aly
sis
to a
dju
st t
he
gri
d o
per
ati
on
s p
roto
cols
du
rin
g t
he
fire
sea
son
in
th
e fu
ture
.
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
6D
ata
sh
ari
ng
wit
h
the
rese
arc
h
com
mu
nit
y
G.I
V.a
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
ma
ke
dis
clo
sure
s a
nd
sha
re d
ata
?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E i
s fo
cuse
d o
n s
ha
rin
g r
equ
ired
da
ta w
ith
th
e re
sea
rch
co
mm
un
ity
. P
G&
E
curr
entl
y s
ha
res
the
"co
rrec
tiv
es"f
ou
nd
du
rin
g t
he
enh
an
ced
in
spec
tio
ns
pro
cess
on
its
pu
bli
c-fa
cin
g w
ebsi
te,
(wh
ich
is
bey
on
d a
ny
req
uir
emen
ts),
an
d p
lan
s to
sh
are
ev
en
mo
re i
n t
he
futu
re.
On
occ
asi
on
, P
G&
E r
ecei
ves
an
d r
esp
on
ds
to r
equ
ests
bey
on
d
req
uir
emen
ts f
rom
lo
cal
go
ver
nm
ents
(i.
e.,
the
dis
trib
ute
d e
ner
gy
res
ou
rce
pla
n f
or
PS
PS
mit
iga
tio
n).
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
6D
ata
sh
ari
ng
wit
h
the
rese
arc
h
com
mu
nit
y
G.I
V.b
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
in
en
ga
ge
in r
esea
rch
?ii
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E p
art
icip
ate
s in
sev
era
l re
sea
rch
in
itia
tiv
es s
uch
as:
1)
the
Ele
ctri
c P
rog
ram
Inv
estm
ent
Ch
arg
e (E
PIC
) P
rog
ram
(P
G&
E p
rov
ides
fu
nd
ing
to
ad
dre
ss e
mer
gin
g g
rid
nee
ds)
, 2
) in
dep
end
ent
clim
ate
rep
ort
s, a
nd
3)
pa
rtn
erin
g w
ith
th
e B
. J
oh
n G
arr
ick
Inst
itu
te f
or
the
Ris
k S
cien
ces,
Un
iver
sity
of
Ca
lifo
rnia
Lo
s A
ng
eles
(U
CL
A)
to
lev
era
ge
the
rig
oro
us
mo
del
ing
use
d i
n t
he
nu
clea
r in
du
stry
to
per
form
th
oro
ug
h a
nd
com
ple
x w
ild
fire
ris
k a
sses
smen
ts a
nd
ma
na
gem
ent
pla
nn
ing
. P
G&
E w
ill
con
tin
ue
to
fun
d i
nd
epen
den
t a
nd
co
lla
bo
rati
ve
rese
arc
h a
nd
ap
ply
th
e re
sea
rch
to
oth
er u
tili
ties
,
wh
ere
po
ssib
le.
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
6D
ata
sh
ari
ng
wit
h
the
rese
arc
h
com
mu
nit
y
G.I
V.c
Wh
at
sub
ject
s d
oes
uti
lity
res
earc
h
ad
dre
ss?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
pa
rtic
ipa
tes
in s
ever
al
rese
arc
h i
nit
iati
ves
su
ch a
s: 1
) th
e E
lect
ric
Pro
gra
m
Inv
estm
ent
Ch
arg
e (E
PIC
) P
rog
ram
(P
G&
E p
rov
ides
fu
nd
ing
to
ad
dre
ss e
mer
gin
g g
rid
nee
ds)
, 2
) in
dep
end
ent
clim
ate
rep
ort
s, a
nd
3)
pa
rtn
erin
g w
ith
th
e B
. J
oh
n G
arr
ick
Inst
itu
te f
or
the
Ris
k S
cien
ces,
Un
iver
sity
of
Ca
lifo
rnia
Lo
s A
ng
eles
(U
CL
A)
to
lev
era
ge
the
rig
oro
us
mo
del
ing
use
d i
n t
he
nu
clea
r in
du
stry
to
per
form
th
oro
ug
h a
nd
com
ple
x w
ild
fire
ris
k a
sses
smen
ts a
nd
ma
na
gem
ent
pla
nn
ing
. P
G&
E w
ill
con
tin
ue
to
fun
d i
nd
epen
den
t a
nd
co
lla
bo
rati
ve
rese
arc
h,
wh
ere
po
ssib
le.
GD
ata
go
ver
na
nce
3
6D
ata
sh
ari
ng
wit
h
the
rese
arc
h
com
mu
nit
y
G.I
V.d
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
pro
mo
te b
est
pra
ctic
es
ba
sed
on
la
test
in
dep
end
ent
scie
nti
fic
an
d
op
era
tio
na
l re
sea
rch
?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
ha
s w
ritt
en a
n i
nte
rna
l w
hit
e p
ap
er o
n e
va
lua
tin
g t
he
effe
ctiv
enes
s o
f v
isu
al
enh
an
ced
in
spec
tio
n w
ith
a d
ron
e v
s. w
ith
a h
elic
op
ter.
PG
&E
's r
esea
rch
fo
un
d t
ha
t
the
two
are
co
mp
ara
ble
fo
r in
spec
tio
n o
f w
oo
d p
ole
s, b
ut
the
dro
ne
is m
ore
eff
ecti
ve
for
stee
l st
ruct
ure
s. W
hil
e th
is e
xa
mp
le i
s cu
rren
tly
in
tern
al,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to c
on
tin
ue
to c
on
du
ct s
cien
tifi
c a
nd
op
era
tio
na
l re
sea
rch
, a
nd
sh
are
bes
t p
ract
ices
fo
r th
e
fore
seea
ble
fu
ture
.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
37
Sce
na
rio
an
aly
sis
acr
oss
dif
fere
nt
risk
lev
els
H.I
.aF
or
wh
at
risk
sce
na
rio
s is
th
e u
tili
ty a
ble
to p
rov
ide
pro
ject
ed c
ost
an
d t
ota
l ri
sk
red
uct
ion
po
ten
tia
l?
iii
iP
G&
E i
nte
rpre
ts t
his
qu
esti
on
as
ask
ing
if
ther
e a
re
bu
sin
ess-
case
ty
pe
an
aly
ses.
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
ca
lcu
late
s to
tal
pro
ba
bil
ity
of
risk
red
uct
ion
in
its
Ris
k A
sses
smen
t
Mit
iga
tio
n P
ha
se (
RA
MP
), h
ow
ever
it
do
es n
ot
incl
ud
e sc
ena
rio
s. I
n t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
wil
l im
pro
ve
its
calc
ula
tio
ns
by
in
clu
din
g m
ore
da
ta c
ap
ture
d i
n t
he
up
gra
ded
ER
P
syst
em a
nd
in
crea
sin
g t
he
lev
el o
f g
ran
ula
rity
in
its
ris
k m
od
elin
g b
y i
ts n
ext
RA
MP
fili
ng
.H
Res
ou
rce
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
37
Sce
na
rio
an
aly
sis
acr
oss
dif
fere
nt
risk
lev
els
H.I
.bF
or
wh
at
lev
el o
f g
ran
ula
rity
is
the
uti
lity
ab
le t
o p
rov
ide
pro
ject
ion
s fo
r ea
ch
scen
ari
o?
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E's
gra
nu
lari
ty i
n p
rov
idin
g p
roje
ctio
ns
for
dif
fere
nt
scen
ari
os
is d
on
e a
t th
e
pro
gra
m l
evel
. P
G&
E p
lan
s to
pro
vid
e p
roje
ctio
ns
at
the
circ
uit
lev
el.
Th
is w
ill
be
do
ne
by
tra
ckin
g o
per
ati
on
al
an
d f
ina
nci
al
da
ta d
iffe
ren
tly
.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
37
Sce
na
rio
an
aly
sis
acr
oss
dif
fere
nt
risk
lev
els
H.I
.cD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty i
ncl
ud
e a
lo
ng
ter
m (
e.g
.,
6-1
0 y
ear)
ris
k e
stim
ate
ta
kin
g i
nto
acc
ou
nt
ma
cro
fa
cto
rs (
clim
ate
ch
an
ge,
etc.
) a
s w
ell
as
pla
nn
ed r
isk
red
uct
ion
init
iati
ves
in
its
sce
na
rio
s?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
in
clu
des
in
its
RA
MP
fil
ing
a l
on
g t
erm
(e.
g.,
6-1
0 y
ear)
ris
k e
stim
ate
tak
ing
in
to a
cco
un
t m
acr
o f
act
ors
(cl
ima
te c
ha
ng
e, e
tc.)
as
wel
l a
s p
lan
ned
ris
k
red
uct
ion
in
itia
tiv
es i
n i
ts s
cen
ari
os
an
aly
sis
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
37
Sce
na
rio
an
aly
sis
acr
oss
dif
fere
nt
risk
lev
els
H.I
.dD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty p
rov
ide
an
est
ima
te o
f
imp
act
on
rel
iab
ilit
y f
act
ors
in
its
scen
ari
os?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
do
es n
ot
incl
ud
e re
lia
bil
ity
fa
cto
rs i
nto
sce
na
rio
an
aly
sis,
bu
t p
lan
s o
n
dev
elo
p t
his
ca
pa
bil
ity
in
th
e fu
ture
, w
hic
h w
ill
req
uir
e a
dd
itio
na
l re
sou
rces
.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
38
Pre
sen
tati
on
of
rela
tiv
e ri
sk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
for
po
rtfo
lio
of
init
iati
ves
H.I
I.a
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
pre
sen
t a
ccu
rate
qu
ali
tati
ve
ran
kin
gs
for
its
init
iati
ves
by
risk
sp
end
eff
icie
ncy
?
iiii
Inte
rpre
tin
g t
he
wo
rd "
acc
ura
te"
as
mea
nin
g
red
uct
ion
in
th
e p
rob
ab
ilit
y o
f a
ris
ky
ev
ent
PG
&E
in
clu
des
acc
ura
te q
ua
lita
tiv
e ri
sk s
pen
d e
ffic
ien
cy r
an
kin
gs
in v
ari
ou
s p
ub
lic
fili
ng
s, i
ncl
ud
ing
th
e R
AM
P,
GR
C,
an
d W
MP
. P
G&
E p
lan
s to
co
nti
nu
e th
is p
ract
ice
thro
ug
h 2
02
3.
Atch5-19
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
38
Pre
sen
tati
on
of
rela
tiv
e ri
sk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
for
po
rtfo
lio
of
init
iati
ves
H.I
I.b
Wh
at
init
iati
ves
are
ca
ptu
red
in
th
e
ran
kin
g o
f ri
sk s
pen
d e
ffic
ien
cy?
iii
Co
mm
erci
al
is d
efin
ed a
s in
itia
tiv
es t
ha
t a
re a
lrea
dy
ma
rket
tes
ted
PG
&E
ca
ptu
res
com
mo
n c
om
mer
cia
l in
itia
tiv
es i
n t
he
ran
kin
g o
f ri
sk s
pen
d e
ffic
ien
cy.
By
20
23
, co
ntr
ols
an
d m
itig
ati
on
s w
ill
be
incl
ud
ed.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
38
Pre
sen
tati
on
of
rela
tiv
e ri
sk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
for
po
rtfo
lio
of
init
iati
ves
H.I
I.c
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
in
clu
de
fig
ure
s fo
r
pre
sen
t v
alu
e co
st a
nd
pro
ject
ris
k
red
uct
ion
im
pa
ct o
f ea
ch i
nit
iati
ve,
clea
rly
do
cum
enti
ng
all
ass
um
pti
on
s
(e.g
. u
sefu
l li
fe,
dis
cou
nt
rate
, et
c.)?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
curr
entl
y d
ocu
men
t a
ll p
rese
nt
va
lue
an
d r
isk
red
uct
ion
ass
um
pti
on
s
for
its
po
rtfo
lio
of
risk
red
uct
ion
in
itia
tiv
es.
Wh
ile
PG
&E
aim
s to
pro
gre
ss t
o m
ore
circ
uit
-lev
el R
SE
est
ima
tes,
th
ese
esti
ma
tes
do
no
t n
eces
sari
ly m
ap
to
pro
ject
-lev
el
esti
ma
tes.
PG
&E
ex
pec
ts t
o e
vo
lve
clo
ser
to p
roje
ct-l
evel
RS
E e
stim
ate
s, w
hic
h w
ou
ld
ena
ble
do
cum
enta
tio
n o
f p
roje
ct-l
evel
ass
um
pti
on
s, h
ow
ever
, th
is m
ay
no
t b
e fe
asi
ble
for
all
pro
ject
s b
y 2
02
3.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
38
Pre
sen
tati
on
of
rela
tiv
e ri
sk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
for
po
rtfo
lio
of
init
iati
ves
H.I
I.d
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
pro
vid
e a
n e
xp
lan
ati
on
of
thei
r in
ves
tmen
t in
ea
ch p
art
icu
lar
init
iati
ve?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E d
oes
pro
vid
e a
n e
xp
lan
ati
on
of
inv
estm
ents
fo
r ea
ch i
nit
iati
ve,
wh
ich
in
clu
des
exp
ecte
d o
ver
all
red
uct
ion
in
ris
k.
Th
ere
are
in
sta
nce
s w
her
e P
G&
E h
as
incl
ud
ed t
he
exp
ecte
d o
ver
all
red
uct
ion
in
ris
k a
nd
est
ima
tes
of
imp
act
on
rel
iab
ilit
y f
act
ors
. F
or
exa
mp
le,
PG
&E
did
th
is w
hen
lo
ok
ing
at
recl
ose
rs a
nd
fo
r P
SP
S c
ust
om
er o
uta
ge
ho
urs
.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
38
Pre
sen
tati
on
of
rela
tiv
e ri
sk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
for
po
rtfo
lio
of
init
iati
ves
H.I
I.e
At
wh
at
lev
el o
f g
ran
ula
rity
is
the
uti
lity
ab
le t
o p
rov
ide
risk
eff
icie
ncy
fig
ure
s?
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y p
rov
ides
ris
k e
ffic
ien
cy f
igu
res
for
dif
fere
nt
scen
ari
os
at
the
pro
gra
m
lev
el,
ho
wev
er,
in t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to i
ncr
ease
RS
E g
ran
ula
rity
to
th
e ci
rcu
it
lev
el.
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
ha
s th
e a
bil
ity
to
est
ima
te r
isk
mit
iga
tio
n a
t th
e p
rote
ctio
n z
on
e
lev
el (
i.e.
, m
ore
gra
nu
lar
tha
n c
ircu
it l
evel
, b
ut
no
t a
s g
ran
ula
r a
s sp
an
lev
el),
ho
wev
er,
mea
suri
ng
co
st a
t th
is l
evel
is
a c
ha
llen
ge.
PG
&E
aim
s to
att
ain
th
is l
evel
of
cost
gra
nu
lari
ty b
y 2
02
3.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
39
Pro
cess
fo
r
det
erm
inin
g r
isk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
of
veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
init
iati
ves
H.I
II.a
Ho
w a
ccu
rate
of
a r
isk
sp
end
eff
icie
ncy
calc
ula
tio
n c
an
th
e u
tili
ty p
rov
ide?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
ca
n p
rov
ide
acc
ura
te r
isk
sp
end
eff
icie
ncy
ca
lcu
lati
on
s fo
r m
ost
cle
ara
nce
s a
nd
typ
es o
f v
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
init
iati
ves
. H
ow
ever
, P
G&
E d
oes
no
t cu
rren
tly
calc
ula
te R
SE
est
ima
tes
for
con
tro
ls e
ffo
rts.
In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E p
lan
s o
n i
ncl
ud
ing
such
co
ntr
ols
eff
ort
s in
RS
E e
stim
ate
s a
nd
aim
s to
pro
du
ce a
ccu
rate
rel
ati
ve
RS
E
fig
ure
s fo
r co
ntr
ols
an
d r
isk
mit
iga
tio
n i
nit
iati
ves
.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
39
Pro
cess
fo
r
det
erm
inin
g r
isk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
of
veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
init
iati
ves
H.I
II.b
At
wh
at
lev
el c
an
est
ima
tes
be
pre
pa
red
?i
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
ev
alu
ate
s v
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
init
iati
ves
at
the
pro
gra
m l
evel
. In
the
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to e
va
lua
te v
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
init
iati
ves
at
the
circ
uit
lev
el.
Th
is i
s co
nsi
sten
t w
ith
oth
er P
G&
E g
oa
ls w
ith
res
pec
t to
RS
E g
ran
ula
rity
.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
39
Pro
cess
fo
r
det
erm
inin
g r
isk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
of
veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
init
iati
ves
H.I
II.c
Ho
w f
req
uen
tly
are
est
ima
tes
up
da
ted
? ii
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E a
nn
ua
lly
up
da
tes
risk
sp
end
eff
icie
ncy
of
veg
eta
tio
n m
an
ag
emen
t in
itia
tiv
es.
Th
is f
req
uen
cy w
ill
con
tin
ue
in t
he
futu
re.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
39
Pro
cess
fo
r
det
erm
inin
g r
isk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
of
veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
init
iati
ves
H.I
II.d
Wh
at
veg
eta
tio
n m
an
ag
emen
t in
itia
tiv
es
do
es t
he
uti
lity
in
clu
de
wit
hin
its
eva
lua
tio
n?
iii
iv"A
ll"
refe
rs t
o a
ll i
nit
iati
ves
an
d c
on
tro
ls s
pec
ific
all
yP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y i
ncl
ud
es a
ll v
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
risk
red
uct
ion
in
itia
tiv
es i
n i
ts
RS
E e
va
lua
tio
n.
Ho
wev
er,
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
curr
entl
y i
ncl
ud
e v
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
con
tro
ls e
ffo
rts
in s
uch
ev
alu
ati
on
. P
G&
E a
ims
to i
ncl
ud
e su
ch c
on
tro
ls e
ffo
rts
in
futu
re R
SE
ev
alu
ati
on
s b
y 2
02
3.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
39
Pro
cess
fo
r
det
erm
inin
g r
isk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
of
veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent
init
iati
ves
H.I
II.e
Ca
n t
he
uti
lity
ev
alu
ate
ris
k r
edu
ctio
n
syn
erg
ies
fro
m c
om
bin
ati
on
of
va
rio
us
init
iati
ves
?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
eva
lua
te r
isk
red
uct
ion
sy
ner
gie
s fr
om
co
mb
inin
g v
ari
ou
s v
eget
ati
on
ma
na
gem
ent
init
iati
ves
at
this
tim
e b
eca
use
mo
re p
reci
sio
n i
s n
eed
ed.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
on
ev
alu
ati
ng
ris
k s
pen
d e
ffic
ien
cy o
n s
yn
erg
y i
nit
iati
ves
wil
l b
e
ach
iev
ab
le b
y i
mp
rov
ing
mo
del
ing
an
d d
ata
ca
pa
bil
itie
s.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
40
Pro
cess
fo
r
det
erm
inin
g r
isk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
of
syst
em
ha
rden
ing
init
iati
ves
H.I
V.a
Ho
w a
ccu
rate
of
a r
isk
sp
end
eff
icie
ncy
calc
ula
tio
n c
an
th
e u
tili
ty p
rov
ide?
iiii
Inte
rpre
tin
g t
he
wo
rd "
acc
ura
te"
as
mea
nin
g
red
uct
ion
in
th
e p
rob
ab
ilit
y o
f a
ris
ky
ev
ent
PG
&E
ca
n p
rov
ide
acc
ura
te r
isk
sp
end
eff
icie
ncy
ca
lcu
lati
on
s b
ase
d o
n i
ts s
yst
em
ha
rden
ing
in
itia
tiv
es,
as
des
crib
ed i
n t
he
WM
P.
Ho
wev
er,
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
curr
entl
y
calc
ula
te R
SE
est
ima
tes
for
con
tro
ls e
ffo
rts.
In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E p
lan
s o
n i
ncl
ud
ing
such
co
ntr
ols
eff
ort
s in
RS
E e
stim
ate
s a
nd
aim
s to
pro
du
ce a
ccu
rate
rel
ati
ve
RS
E
fig
ure
s fo
r co
ntr
ols
an
d r
isk
mit
iga
tio
n i
nit
iati
ves
.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
40
Pro
cess
fo
r
det
erm
inin
g r
isk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
of
syst
em
ha
rden
ing
init
iati
ves
H.I
V.b
At
wh
at
lev
el c
an
est
ima
tes
be
pre
pa
red
?i
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
ca
n p
rep
are
est
ima
tes
for
det
erm
inin
g r
isk
sp
end
eff
icie
ncy
of
syst
em
ha
rden
ing
in
itia
tiv
es a
t th
e p
roje
ct l
evel
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E w
ill
be
pre
pa
rin
g
esti
ma
tes
at
the
circ
uit
lev
el.
Atch5-20
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
40
Pro
cess
fo
r
det
erm
inin
g r
isk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
of
syst
em
ha
rden
ing
init
iati
ves
H.I
V.c
Ho
w f
req
uen
tly
are
est
ima
tes
up
da
ted
? ii
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E a
nn
ua
lly
up
da
tes
risk
sp
end
eff
icie
ncy
of
syst
em h
ard
enin
g i
nit
iati
ves
. T
his
freq
uen
cy w
ill
con
tin
ue
in t
he
futu
re.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
40
Pro
cess
fo
r
det
erm
inin
g r
isk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
of
syst
em
ha
rden
ing
init
iati
ves
H.I
V.d
Wh
at
gri
d h
ard
enin
g i
nit
iati
ves
are
incl
ud
ed i
n t
he
uti
lity
ris
k s
pen
d
effi
cien
cy a
na
lysi
s?
iiiv
Init
iati
ve
lev
el r
efer
s to
a m
itig
ati
on
pro
gra
mP
G&
E's
gri
d h
ard
enin
g i
nit
iati
ves
are
cu
rren
tly
gro
up
ed b
y u
nd
erg
rou
nd
, o
ver
hea
d,
an
d a
sset
rem
ov
al.
So
me
gri
d h
ard
enin
g i
nit
iati
ves
ha
ve
risk
sp
end
eff
icie
ncy
an
aly
sis
at
the
ind
ivid
ua
l in
itia
tiv
e su
ch a
s sy
stem
ha
rden
ing
(w
hic
h i
ncl
ud
es c
ov
ered
con
du
cto
r, p
ole
rep
lace
men
t, o
pen
wir
e se
con
da
ry,
an
d n
on
-ex
emp
t eq
uip
men
t
rep
lace
men
t) a
nd
lig
htn
ing
/su
rge
arr
esto
rs.
In t
he
futu
re s
tate
, P
G&
E i
nte
nd
s to
co
nd
uct
ris
k s
pen
d e
ffic
ien
cy a
na
lysi
s fo
r ea
ch
mit
iga
tio
n p
rog
ram
.H
Res
ou
rce
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
40
Pro
cess
fo
r
det
erm
inin
g r
isk
spen
d e
ffic
ien
cy
of
syst
em
ha
rden
ing
init
iati
ves
H.I
V.e
Ca
n t
he
uti
lity
ev
alu
ate
ris
k r
edu
ctio
n
effe
cts
fro
m t
he
com
bin
ati
on
of
va
rio
us
init
iati
ves
?
iii
Init
iati
ve
lev
el r
efer
s to
a m
itig
ati
on
pro
gra
mP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y d
oes
no
t ta
ke
a s
yn
erg
isti
c v
iew
of
its
po
rtfo
lio
of
syst
em h
ard
enin
g
init
iati
ves
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E p
lan
s to
do
so
th
rou
gh
im
pro
vem
ents
to
its
mo
del
ing
cap
ab
ilit
ies
an
d a
dd
itio
na
l d
ata
on
new
er p
rog
ram
s, s
uch
as
the
effe
ctiv
enes
s o
f
syst
em h
ard
enin
g.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
41
Po
rtfo
lio
-wid
e
inn
ov
ati
on
in
new
wil
dfi
re
init
iati
ves
H.V
.aT
o w
ha
t ex
ten
t d
oes
th
e u
tili
ty a
llo
cate
cap
ita
l to
in
itia
tiv
es b
ase
d o
n r
isk
-sp
end
effi
cien
cy (
RS
E)?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
use
s th
e R
IBA
2.0
pro
cess
to
all
oca
te b
ud
get
acr
oss
in
itia
tiv
es,
wh
ich
do
es n
ot
ali
gn
wit
h h
ow
ris
k s
pen
d e
ffic
ien
cy i
s u
sed
to
ass
ess
init
iati
ves
. P
G&
E s
ees
the
ben
efit
to e
stim
ate
of
risk
sp
end
eff
icie
ncy
wh
en a
llo
cati
ng
ca
pit
al
an
d w
ill
con
sid
er t
hes
e
esti
ma
tes
mo
vin
g f
orw
ard
.H
Res
ou
rce
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
41
Po
rtfo
lio
-wid
e
inn
ov
ati
on
in
new
wil
dfi
re
init
iati
ves
H.V
.bW
ha
t in
form
ati
on
do
es t
he
uti
lity
ta
ke
into
acc
ou
nt
wh
en g
ener
ati
ng
RS
E
esti
ma
tes?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
ta
kes
in
to a
cco
un
t th
e a
ver
ag
e es
tim
ate
by
in
itia
tiv
e ca
teg
ory
. P
G&
E
pla
ns
to g
et t
o t
he
circ
uit
lev
el,
so e
stim
ate
s in
th
e fu
ture
, sh
ou
ld p
rov
ide
spec
ific
info
rma
tio
n,
incl
ud
ing
sta
te o
f eq
uip
men
t a
nd
lo
cati
on
wh
ere
init
iati
ve
wil
l b
e
imp
lem
ente
d.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
41
Po
rtfo
lio
-wid
e
inn
ov
ati
on
in
new
wil
dfi
re
init
iati
ves
H.V
.cH
ow
do
es t
he
uti
lity
ver
ify
RS
E
esti
ma
tes?
ii
Ver
ify
ing
is
a m
ore
su
bst
an
tia
l p
roce
ss t
ha
n
chec
kin
g/b
rief
ly r
evie
win
g e
stim
ate
s
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
ver
ify
RS
E e
stim
ate
s fo
r p
ort
foli
o-w
ide
inn
ov
ati
on
in
new
wil
dfi
re
init
iati
ves
. P
G&
E d
oes
ch
eck
th
em,
bu
t v
erif
yin
g i
s m
ore
su
bst
an
tia
l. P
G&
E i
s st
ill
in
the
beg
inn
ing
sta
ges
of
det
erm
inin
g r
oo
t ca
use
s fo
r so
me
fail
ure
s. T
his
ma
kes
it
cha
llen
gin
g t
o v
erif
y R
SE
est
ima
tes
ho
list
ica
lly
. P
G&
E i
s w
ork
ing
to
wa
rds
RS
E
esti
ma
tes
bei
ng
ver
ifie
d w
ith
his
tori
cal
da
ta,
bu
t m
ay
no
t b
e a
ble
to
ach
iev
e th
is i
n t
he
nex
t th
ree
yea
rs.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
41
Po
rtfo
lio
-wid
e
inn
ov
ati
on
in
new
wil
dfi
re
init
iati
ves
H.V
.dD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty t
ak
e in
to c
on
sid
era
tio
n
imp
act
on
sa
fety
, re
lia
bil
ity
, a
nd
oth
er
pri
ori
ties
wh
en m
ak
ing
sp
end
ing
dec
isio
ns?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
use
s th
e R
IBA
2.0
pro
cess
ma
na
ged
by
En
terp
rise
Ris
k M
an
ag
emen
t
to s
core
pro
ject
s a
ga
inst
sa
fety
, re
lia
bil
ity
an
d o
ther
pri
ori
ties
wh
en m
ak
ing
dec
isio
ns.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to c
on
tin
ue
to s
core
acr
oss
sa
fety
, re
lia
bil
ity
, a
nd
oth
er
att
rib
ute
s co
nsi
sten
t w
ith
S-M
AP
dec
isio
ns.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
41
Po
rtfo
lio
-wid
e
inn
ov
ati
on
in
new
wil
dfi
re
init
iati
ves
H.V
.eA
re t
he
risk
sp
end
eff
icie
ncy
est
ima
tes
ver
ifie
d b
y e
xp
erim
enta
l d
ata
co
nfi
rmed
by
ex
per
ts a
nd
oth
er u
tili
ties
in
Ca
lifo
rnia
or
ab
roa
d?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
see
risk
sp
end
eff
icie
ncy
est
ima
tes
ver
ifie
d b
y e
xp
erim
enta
l d
ata
bei
ng
con
firm
ed b
y e
xp
erts
or
oth
er u
tili
ties
no
w o
r in
th
e im
med
iate
fu
ture
. T
his
is
larg
ely
du
e to
lo
gis
tica
l b
arr
iers
su
ch a
s a
n a
lig
nm
ent
in d
efin
itio
ns
of
ap
pro
pri
ate
ris
k.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
42
Po
rtfo
lio
-wid
e
inn
ov
ati
on
in
new
wil
dfi
re
init
iati
ves
H.V
I.a
Ho
w d
oes
th
e u
tili
ty d
evel
op
an
d
eva
lua
te t
he
effi
cacy
of
new
wil
dfi
re
init
iati
ves
?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y u
ses
pil
ots
an
d m
easu
res
red
uct
ion
in
ig
nit
ion
ev
ents
wh
en a
sses
sin
g
the
effi
cacy
of
new
wil
dfi
re i
nit
iati
ves
. R
ecen
t ef
fort
s re
late
d t
o P
G&
E's
re-
clo
ser
red
uct
ion
in
itia
tiv
e il
lust
rate
th
is p
ract
ice.
Sim
ila
rly
, fu
ture
eff
ort
s re
late
d t
o t
he
RE
FC
L i
nit
iati
ve
wil
l m
easu
re d
irec
t re
du
ctio
n i
gn
itio
n e
ven
ts.
Ho
wev
er,
PG
&E
do
es
no
t cu
rren
tly
mea
sure
nea
r-m
isse
s in
a d
elib
era
te m
an
ner
(se
e ex
pla
na
tio
n f
or
G.I
II.b
). C
on
sist
ent
wit
h o
ther
go
als
ou
tlin
ed i
n t
his
su
rvey
, P
G&
E a
ims
to d
evel
op
mo
re d
elib
era
te m
easu
rem
ent
of
nea
r-m
iss
even
ts a
nd
wil
l in
corp
ora
te s
uch
da
ta i
n
futu
re a
sses
smen
ts o
f w
ild
fire
in
itia
tiv
e ef
fica
cy.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
42
Po
rtfo
lio
-wid
e
inn
ov
ati
on
in
new
wil
dfi
re
init
iati
ves
H.V
I.b
Ho
w d
oes
th
e u
tili
ty d
evel
op
an
d
eva
lua
te t
he
risk
sp
end
eff
icie
ncy
of
new
wil
dfi
re i
nit
iati
ves
?
ii
"New
wil
dfi
re i
nit
iati
ves
" m
ean
s p
ilo
t p
rog
ram
sP
G&
E d
oes
no
t ev
alu
ate
ris
k s
pen
d e
ffic
ien
cy o
f n
ew w
ild
fire
in
itia
tiv
es,
sin
ce P
G&
E i
s
stil
l in
th
e p
ilo
t st
ag
e. U
tili
ties
in
Ca
lifo
rnia
are
ex
per
imen
tin
g w
ith
new
tec
hn
olo
gy
an
d a
s su
ch,
it i
s d
iffi
cult
to
est
ima
te c
ost
s w
ith
ou
t o
per
ati
on
al
his
tory
.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
42
Po
rtfo
lio
-wid
e
inn
ov
ati
on
in
new
wil
dfi
re
init
iati
ves
H.V
I.c
At
wh
at
lev
el o
f g
ran
ula
rity
do
es t
he
uti
lity
mea
sure
th
e ef
fica
cy o
f n
ew
wil
dfi
re i
nit
iati
ves
?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E's
lev
el o
f g
ran
ula
rity
to
mea
sure
th
e ef
fica
cy o
f n
ew w
ild
fire
in
itia
tiv
es i
s d
on
e a
t
the
pro
gra
m l
evel
fo
r th
e en
tire
ter
rito
ry.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to m
easu
re t
he
effi
cacy
of
new
wil
dfi
re i
nit
iati
ves
at
the
circ
uit
lev
el.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
42
Po
rtfo
lio
-wid
e
inn
ov
ati
on
in
new
wil
dfi
re
init
iati
ves
H.V
I.d
Are
th
e re
vie
ws
of
inn
ov
ati
ve
init
iati
ves
au
dit
ed b
y i
nd
epen
den
t p
art
ies?
ii
Ind
epen
den
t ca
n r
efer
to
in
tern
al
(e.g
., i
nte
rna
l
au
dit
) o
r ex
tern
al
enti
ties
PG
&E
's r
evie
ws
of
inn
ov
ati
ve
init
iati
ves
are
usu
all
y a
ud
ited
by
in
dep
end
ent
pa
rtie
s,
bu
t th
is i
s n
ot
alw
ay
s th
e ca
se f
or
ever
y r
evie
w.
PG
&E
wil
l co
nti
nu
e o
n t
his
ca
se-b
y-
case
ba
sis.
HR
eso
urc
e
all
oca
tio
n
met
ho
do
log
y
42
Po
rtfo
lio
-wid
e
inn
ov
ati
on
in
new
wil
dfi
re
init
iati
ves
H.V
I.e
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
sh
are
th
e fi
nd
ing
s o
f it
s
eva
lua
tio
n o
f in
no
va
tiv
e in
itia
tiv
es w
ith
oth
er u
tili
ties
, a
cad
emia
, a
nd
th
e g
ener
al
pu
bli
c?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
wil
l co
nti
nu
e to
sh
are
fin
din
gs
of
new
wil
dfi
re i
nit
iati
ves
. P
G&
E s
ha
res
fin
din
gs
in d
iffe
ren
t fo
rum
s in
clu
din
g t
hro
ug
h E
PIC
an
d r
ela
ted
an
nu
al
rep
ort
s, o
ng
oin
g
ben
chm
ark
ing
ca
lls,
an
d v
ari
ou
s m
eeti
ng
s.
Atch5-21
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
43
Wil
dfi
re p
lan
inte
gra
ted
wit
h
ov
era
ll d
isa
ster
/
emer
gen
cy p
lan
I.I.
aIs
th
e w
ild
fire
pla
n i
nte
gra
ted
wit
h
ov
era
ll d
isa
ster
an
d e
mer
gen
cy p
lan
s?
iii
iii
"Wil
dfi
re p
lan
" m
ean
s w
ild
fire
res
po
nse
pla
n,
no
t
Wil
dfi
re M
itig
ati
on
Pla
n.
PG
&E
's C
om
pa
ny
Em
erg
ency
Res
po
nse
Pla
n (
CE
RP
) is
co
nsi
der
ed a
n “
all
-ha
zard
s”
pla
n,
wh
ich
is
sup
ple
men
ted
by
nu
mer
ou
s “A
nn
exes
” th
at
inte
gra
te h
aza
rd-s
pec
ific
con
tin
gen
cies
(e.
g.,
Wil
dfi
re,
Cy
ber
In
cid
ents
, E
art
hq
ua
kes
, et
c.).
Ea
ch o
f th
ese
do
cum
ents
is
rev
iew
ed a
nd
up
da
ted
an
nu
all
y i
n a
cco
rda
nce
wit
h t
he
Gen
era
l O
rder
.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
43
Wil
dfi
re p
lan
inte
gra
ted
wit
h
ov
era
ll d
isa
ster
/
emer
gen
cy p
lan
I.I.
bD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty r
un
dri
lls
to a
ud
it t
he
via
bil
ity
an
d e
xec
uti
on
of
its
wil
dfi
re
pla
ns?
iii
"Wil
dfi
re p
lan
" m
ean
s w
ild
fire
res
po
nse
pla
n,
no
t
Wil
dfi
re M
itig
ati
on
Pla
n.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
run
co
mp
an
y-w
ide
wil
dfi
re s
imu
lati
on
s (l
ike
it d
oes
fo
r ea
rth
qu
ak
es
PS
PS
tra
inin
g).
PG
&E
wil
l h
old
dri
lls
for
wil
dfi
re s
imu
lati
on
s in
th
e fu
ture
bec
au
se i
t
reco
gn
izes
th
e im
po
rta
nce
of
a v
iab
le w
ild
fire
res
po
nse
pla
n.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
43
Wil
dfi
re p
lan
inte
gra
ted
wit
h
ov
era
ll d
isa
ster
/
emer
gen
cy p
lan
I.I.
cIs
th
e im
pa
ct o
f co
nfo
un
din
g e
ven
ts o
r
mu
ltip
le s
imu
lta
neo
us
dis
ast
ers
con
sid
ered
in
th
e p
lan
nin
g p
roce
ss?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
com
pre
hen
siv
ely
co
nsi
der
th
e im
pa
ct o
f co
nfo
un
din
g e
ven
ts o
r
mu
ltip
le s
imu
lta
neo
us
dis
ast
ers
in i
ts p
lan
nin
g p
roce
ss.
PG
&E
is
ded
ica
ted
to
foll
ow
ing
an
d t
rain
ing
on
IC
S,
an
d a
s su
ch,
wil
l fo
llo
w I
CS
gu
idel
ines
on
th
e p
lan
nin
g
for
mu
ltip
le,
sim
ult
an
eou
s d
isa
ster
s. I
n t
he
futu
re,
such
sce
na
rio
s w
ill
be
con
sid
ered
cru
cia
l si
nce
mu
ltip
le e
ven
ts d
o h
ap
pen
(a
s w
as
the
case
wit
h P
SP
S a
nd
Kin
cad
e).
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
43
Wil
dfi
re p
lan
inte
gra
ted
wit
h
ov
era
ll d
isa
ster
/
emer
gen
cy p
lan
I.I.
dIs
th
e p
lan
in
teg
rate
d w
ith
dis
ast
er a
nd
emer
gen
cy p
rep
are
dn
ess
pla
ns
of
oth
er
rele
va
nt
sta
keh
old
ers
(e.g
., C
AL
FIR
E,
Fir
e S
afe
Co
un
cils
, et
c.)?
iii
"Wil
dfi
re p
lan
" m
ean
s w
ild
fire
res
po
nse
pla
n,
no
t
Wil
dfi
re M
itig
ati
on
Pla
n.
PG
&E
's w
ild
fire
pla
n d
oes
no
t in
teg
rate
th
e d
isa
ster
an
d e
mer
gen
cy p
rep
are
dn
ess
pla
ns
of
all
rel
eva
nt
sta
keh
old
ers.
PG
&E
's p
lan
do
es i
ncl
ud
e m
an
y a
spec
ts o
f th
e
Ca
lifo
rnia
Sta
te E
mer
gen
cy P
lan
, a
nd
fo
llo
ws
the
sam
e a
pp
lica
tio
n o
f th
e IC
S
sta
nd
ard
. P
G&
E w
ill
be
inte
gra
tin
g a
dd
itio
na
l st
ak
eho
lder
s' e
mer
gen
cy p
rep
are
dn
ess
pla
ns
in t
he
futu
re.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
43
Wil
dfi
re p
lan
inte
gra
ted
wit
h
ov
era
ll d
isa
ster
/
emer
gen
cy p
lan
I.I.
eD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty t
ak
e a
lea
din
g r
ole
in
pla
nn
ing
, co
ord
ina
tin
g,
an
d i
nte
gra
tin
g
pla
ns
acr
oss
sta
keh
old
ers?
iii
"Wil
dfi
re p
lan
" m
ean
s w
ild
fire
res
po
nse
pla
n,
no
t
Wil
dfi
re M
itig
ati
on
Pla
n.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
tak
e a
lea
din
g r
ole
in
pla
nn
ing
, co
ord
ina
tin
g,
an
d i
nte
gra
tin
g p
lan
s
acr
oss
sta
keh
old
ers.
In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E p
lan
s o
n t
ak
ing
a m
ore
lea
din
g r
ole
wit
h
pla
nn
ing
, co
ord
ina
tin
g,
an
d i
nte
gra
tin
g w
ild
fire
pla
ns
acr
oss
sta
keh
old
ers.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
44
Pla
n t
o r
esto
re
serv
ice
aft
er
wil
dfi
re r
ela
ted
ou
tag
e
I.II
.aA
re t
her
e d
eta
iled
an
d a
ctio
na
ble
pro
ced
ure
s in
pla
ce t
o r
esto
re s
erv
ice
aft
er a
wil
dfi
re r
ela
ted
ou
tag
e?
iiii
PG
&E
ass
um
es t
ha
t th
e g
uid
elin
es l
aid
ou
t in
its
CE
RP
(C
om
pa
ny
Em
erg
ency
Res
po
nse
Pla
n)
an
d t
he
Ele
ctri
c A
nn
ex t
ha
t in
form
th
e In
cid
ent
Co
mm
an
d
Cen
ter
are
det
ail
ed e
no
ug
h t
o l
ead
to
act
ion
ab
le
pla
ns
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
wo
rks
wit
h e
ng
inee
rs t
o a
sses
s d
am
ag
e a
fter
wil
dfi
re o
uta
ges
an
d
foll
ow
s IC
S w
hen
fa
cili
tati
ng
th
e re
sto
rati
on
pro
cess
es.
Th
ese
pro
cess
es a
re b
uil
t
thro
ug
h t
he
crea
tio
n o
f d
ail
y I
nci
den
t A
ctio
n P
lan
s th
at
are
cre
ate
d e
ver
y d
ay
du
rin
g
an
in
cid
ent.
Th
ese
pla
ns
pro
vid
e cu
sto
miz
ed d
irec
tio
n t
ha
t ta
kes
in
to a
cco
un
t
veg
eta
tio
n,
top
og
rap
hy
an
d l
oca
l n
eed
s (e
.g.,
pri
ori
tizi
ng
ele
ctri
city
to
ho
spit
al)
an
d
als
o a
dd
ress
wh
eth
er t
o r
epa
ir o
r re
pla
ce a
sset
sI
Em
erg
ency
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
44
Pla
n t
o r
esto
re
serv
ice
aft
er
wil
dfi
re r
ela
ted
ou
tag
e
I.II
.bA
re e
mp
loy
ee a
nd
su
bco
ntr
act
or
crew
s
tra
ined
in
, a
nd
aw
are
of,
pla
ns?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
pro
vid
es a
sta
nd
ard
on
bo
ard
ing
do
cum
ent
to a
ll e
mp
loy
ees
wo
rkin
g a
rest
ora
tio
n t
ha
t co
ver
s to
pic
s su
ch a
s co
nta
ct a
nd
rep
ort
ing
in
form
ati
on
, ca
mp
loca
tio
n,
an
d w
her
e to
pic
k u
p d
ail
y I
nci
den
t A
ctio
n P
lan
s. T
he
IAP
s a
re t
he
da
ily
pla
n
tha
t p
rov
ide
spec
ific
dir
ecti
on
on
ho
w t
o o
bta
in o
ver
all
rec
ov
ery
ob
ject
ives
.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
44
Pla
n t
o r
esto
re
serv
ice
aft
er
wil
dfi
re r
ela
ted
ou
tag
e
I.II
.cT
o w
ha
t le
vel
are
pro
ced
ure
s to
res
tore
serv
ice
aft
er a
wil
dfi
re-r
ela
ted
ou
tag
e
cust
om
ized
?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
res
tora
tio
n p
roce
du
res
po
int
ba
ck t
o t
he
CE
RP
pla
n w
hic
h i
s te
rrit
ory
wid
e.
PG
&E
's r
esto
rati
on
pla
ns
are
ma
na
ged
th
rou
gh
th
e IC
S p
roce
ss w
hic
h i
s le
ver
ag
ed
fro
m o
ne
reg
ion
to
an
oth
er.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
44
Pla
n t
o r
esto
re
serv
ice
aft
er
wil
dfi
re r
ela
ted
ou
tag
e
I.II
.dIs
th
e cu
sto
miz
ed p
roce
du
re t
o r
esto
re
serv
ice
ba
sed
on
to
po
gra
ph
y,
veg
eta
tio
n,
an
d
com
mu
nit
y n
eed
s?
iiii
Inci
den
t a
ctio
n p
lan
s a
re c
ust
om
ized
to
a s
pec
ific
inci
den
t a
nd
bu
ilt
on
a d
ail
y b
asi
s
PG
&E
cu
sto
miz
es i
ts i
nci
den
t a
ctio
n p
lan
s to
th
e sp
ecif
ic n
eed
s, p
rio
riti
es,
an
d
ob
ject
ives
of
a r
esto
rati
on
on
a d
ail
y b
asi
s in
clu
din
g t
ak
ing
in
to a
cco
un
t to
po
gra
ph
y,
veg
eta
tio
n,
an
d c
om
mu
nit
y n
eed
s. W
hil
e th
e o
per
ati
ng
pro
ced
ure
s th
emse
lves
are
no
t
cust
om
ized
, ea
ch i
nci
den
t's
resp
on
se i
s cu
sto
miz
ed v
ia t
he
inci
den
t a
ctio
n p
lan
.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
44
Pla
n t
o r
esto
re
serv
ice
aft
er
wil
dfi
re r
ela
ted
ou
tag
e
I.II
.eIs
th
ere
an
in
ven
tory
of
hig
h r
isk
sp
end
effi
cien
cy r
eso
urc
es a
va
ila
ble
fo
r
rep
air
s?
iii
Ris
k s
pen
d e
ffic
ien
cy i
s d
efin
ed a
s th
e ca
lcu
late
d r
isk
red
uct
ion
fo
r ea
ch m
itig
ati
on
per
do
lla
r sp
ent
on
an
init
iati
ve,
an
d c
on
sid
ers
the
mo
st c
ost
eff
ecti
ve
an
d
mo
st q
ua
lifi
ed i
nit
iati
ves
.
PG
&E
ha
s n
ot
iden
tifi
ed a
ny
ris
k s
pen
d e
ffic
ien
cies
at
this
tim
e. I
n t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
wil
l id
enti
fy w
hic
h r
eso
urc
es (
bet
wee
n m
utu
al
aid
, co
ntr
act
ors
, em
plo
yee
s) a
re t
he
mo
st e
ffec
tiv
e in
ter
ms
of
qu
ali
ty,
safe
ty,
an
d t
imel
ines
s co
mp
are
d t
o t
hei
r co
st.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
45
Em
erg
ency
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
du
rin
g a
nd
aft
er
wil
dfi
re
I.II
I.a
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
pro
vid
e cl
ear
an
d
sub
sta
nti
all
y c
om
ple
te c
om
mu
nic
ati
on
of
av
ail
ab
le i
nfo
rma
tio
n r
elev
an
t to
aff
ecte
d c
ust
om
ers?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
pro
vid
es c
lea
r a
nd
co
mp
lete
co
mm
un
ica
tio
n o
f a
va
ila
ble
in
form
ati
on
rel
eva
nt
to a
ffec
ted
cu
sto
mer
s. F
or
exa
mp
le,
in a
n e
ven
t w
her
e E
OC
is
act
iva
ted
, th
ere
are
inst
an
ces
wh
en c
ust
om
ers
are
no
tifi
ed o
f a
n o
uta
ge,
esp
ecia
lly
in
th
e ca
se o
f a
la
rge
even
t (C
am
p F
ire)
. T
his
no
tifi
cati
on
in
clu
des
ref
eren
ce t
o a
co
nsu
mer
pro
tect
ion
web
site
an
d a
n a
dv
ice
lett
er i
n r
ela
tio
n t
o c
on
sum
er p
rote
ctio
ns.
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
pro
vid
e cu
sto
mer
s w
ith
ref
erra
ls t
o o
ther
ag
enci
es f
or
PS
PS
ev
ents
.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
45
Em
erg
ency
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
du
rin
g a
nd
aft
er
wil
dfi
re
I.II
I.b
Wh
at
per
cen
t o
f a
ffec
ted
cu
sto
mer
s
rece
ive
com
ple
te d
eta
ils
of
av
ail
ab
le
info
rma
tio
n?
iiiv
"Cu
sto
mer
s" m
ean
s P
G&
E c
ust
om
ers
aff
ecte
d b
y a
wil
dfi
re,
wit
h u
p-t
o-d
ate
cu
sto
mer
acc
ou
nts
.
Gre
ate
r th
an
95
% o
f a
ffec
ted
cu
sto
mer
s re
ceiv
e co
mp
lete
det
ail
s o
f a
va
ila
ble
info
rma
tio
n d
uri
ng
an
d a
fter
a w
ild
fire
. In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E p
lan
to
ob
tain
mo
re
com
ple
te a
nd
up
da
ted
da
ta,
an
d w
ill
enh
an
ce p
ub
lic
mes
sag
ing
, so
th
is p
erce
nta
ge
sho
uld
su
rpa
ss 9
9%
by
20
23
.
Atch5-22
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
45
Em
erg
ency
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
du
rin
g a
nd
aft
er
wil
dfi
re
I.II
I.c
Wh
at
per
cen
t o
f a
ffec
ted
med
ica
l
ba
seli
ne
cust
om
ers
rece
ive
com
ple
te
det
ail
s o
f a
va
ila
ble
in
form
ati
on
?
iiv
"Cu
sto
mer
s" m
ean
s P
G&
E c
ust
om
er w
ith
up
-to
-da
te
cust
om
er a
cco
un
ts.
Les
s th
an
99
% o
f a
ffec
ted
med
ica
l b
ase
lin
e cu
sto
mer
s re
ceiv
e co
mp
lete
det
ail
s o
f
av
ail
ab
le i
nfo
rma
tio
n d
uri
ng
an
d a
fter
a w
ild
fire
. T
he
per
cen
tag
e is
ba
sed
on
th
e
kn
ow
n p
op
ula
tio
n o
f m
edic
al
ba
seli
ne
cust
om
ers
in P
G&
E's
cu
sto
mer
sy
stem
. T
o
calc
ula
te t
his
per
cen
tag
e, P
G&
E u
sed
PS
PS
da
ta f
or
med
ica
l b
ase
lin
e n
oti
fica
tio
n
succ
ess
rate
s. T
his
is
the
sam
e d
ata
th
at
is u
sed
fo
r w
ild
fire
no
tifi
cati
on
s. I
n t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
ex
pec
ts t
his
per
cen
tag
e w
ill
incr
ease
to
ov
er 9
9.9
%,
as
som
e o
f th
e re
po
rted
mis
sed
no
tifi
cati
on
s w
ere
inco
rrec
tly
ta
gg
ed a
s 'm
isse
d'.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
45
Em
erg
ency
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
du
rin
g a
nd
aft
er
wil
dfi
re
I.II
I.d
Ho
w d
oes
th
e u
tili
ty a
ssis
t w
her
e h
elp
ful
wit
h c
om
mu
nic
ati
on
of
info
rma
tio
n
rela
ted
to
po
wer
ou
tag
es t
o c
ust
om
ers?
iii
iiN
on
eC
urr
entl
y,
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
pro
vid
e ev
acu
ati
on
in
form
ati
on
to
cu
sto
mer
s re
ga
rdin
g a
wil
dfi
re.
Go
ing
fo
rwa
rd,
PG
&E
see
s th
e v
alu
e o
f im
pro
vin
g c
om
mu
nic
ati
on
eff
ort
s b
y
sha
rin
g h
elp
ful,
rel
eva
nt
eva
cua
tio
n i
nfo
rma
tio
n a
nd
wil
l b
e a
dd
ing
lin
ks
on
PG
&E
's
web
site
an
d p
rov
idin
g a
to
ll-f
ree
tele
ph
on
e n
um
ber
du
rin
g a
nd
aft
er a
wil
dfi
re.
PG
&E
wil
l a
lso
co
nti
nu
e a
ssis
tin
g d
isa
ster
res
po
nse
pro
fess
ion
als
as
req
ues
ted
.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
45
Em
erg
ency
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
du
rin
g a
nd
aft
er
wil
dfi
re
I.II
I.e
Ho
w d
oes
th
e u
tili
ty e
ng
ag
e w
ith
oth
er
emer
gen
cy m
an
ag
emen
t a
gen
cies
du
rin
g
emer
gen
cy s
itu
ati
on
s?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E d
oes
ha
ve
som
e p
roto
cols
in
pla
ce t
o e
ng
ag
e w
ith
ag
enci
es d
uri
ng
an
emer
gen
cy,
bu
t in
gen
era
l, e
ng
ag
es w
ith
ag
enci
es i
n a
n a
d h
oc
ma
nn
er (
as
wa
s d
on
e
du
rin
g P
SP
S e
ven
ts w
hen
an
in
vit
ati
on
wa
s ex
ten
ded
to
oth
er e
mer
gen
cy m
an
ag
emen
t
ag
enci
es l
ike
Ca
l F
ire)
. F
or
exa
mp
le,
ther
e is
a p
roto
col
to e
mb
ed o
ne
of
PG
&E
's l
ead
s
in C
al
Fir
e's
EO
C.
In t
he
futu
re,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to e
xp
an
d a
nd
id
enti
fy a
dd
itio
na
l
eng
ag
emen
t p
roto
cols
wit
h o
ther
id
enti
fied
em
erg
ency
ma
na
gem
ent
org
an
iza
tio
ns.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
45
Em
erg
ency
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
du
rin
g a
nd
aft
er
wil
dfi
re
I.II
I.f
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
co
mm
un
ica
te a
nd
coo
rdin
ate
res
ou
rces
to
co
mm
un
itie
s
du
rin
g e
mer
gen
cies
(e.
g.,
sh
elte
rs,
sup
pli
es,
tra
nsp
ort
ati
on
etc
.)?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
co
mm
un
ica
tes
an
d c
oo
rdin
ate
s re
sou
rces
to
co
mm
un
itie
s d
uri
ng
em
erg
enci
es.
Fo
r ex
am
ple
, P
G&
E c
oo
rdin
ate
s w
ith
co
un
ty o
ffic
ials
to
set
up
Co
mm
un
ity
Res
ou
rce
Cen
ters
(C
RC
). O
nce
a C
RC
is
ag
reed
to
, co
mm
un
ica
tio
n g
oes
ou
t to
th
e p
ub
lic
incl
ud
ing
a l
ist
of
serv
ices
pro
vid
ed,
such
as
wa
ter,
ele
ctri
city
, b
lan
ket
s (u
po
n
req
ues
t),
an
d i
ce.
Th
is i
nfo
rma
tio
n i
s sh
are
d o
nli
ne
an
d i
n t
he
new
s.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
46
Pro
toco
ls i
n p
lace
to l
earn
fro
m
wil
dfi
re e
ven
ts
I.IV
.aIs
th
ere
a p
roto
col
in p
lace
to
rec
ord
th
e
ou
tco
me
of
emer
gen
cy e
ven
ts a
nd
to
clea
rly
an
d a
ctio
na
bly
do
cum
ent
lea
rnin
gs
an
d p
ote
nti
al
pro
cess
imp
rov
emen
ts?
iiii
No
ne
Aft
er e
ven
ts t
ha
t le
ad
to
an
act
iva
tio
n o
f P
G&
E's
Em
erg
ency
Op
era
tio
ns
Cen
ter
(EO
C),
for
all
ha
zard
s (i
ncl
ud
ing
ma
jor
wil
dfi
re i
nci
den
ts a
nd
PS
PS
ev
ents
), P
G&
E’s
ro
uti
nel
y
con
du
cts
Aft
er A
ctio
n R
evie
ws
(AA
Rs)
to
id
enti
fy,
coll
ect
an
d a
dd
ress
(w
her
e
ap
pli
cab
le)
less
on
s le
arn
ed f
rom
su
ch i
nci
den
ts a
nd
ev
ents
.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
46
Pro
toco
ls i
n p
lace
to l
earn
fro
m
wil
dfi
re e
ven
ts
I.IV
.bIs
th
ere
a d
efin
ed p
roce
ss a
nd
sta
ff
resp
on
sib
le f
or
inco
rpo
rati
ng
lea
rnin
gs
into
em
erg
ency
pla
n?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
's E
mer
gen
cy P
rep
are
dn
ess
an
d R
esp
on
se t
eam
is
resp
on
sib
le f
or
inco
rpo
rati
ng
less
on
s le
arn
ed i
nto
th
e em
erg
ency
pla
n w
ork
stre
am
s. P
G&
E a
pro
cess
to
pri
ori
tize
the
lea
rnin
gs,
ho
wev
er,
ther
e is
no
t a
ro
bu
st a
nd
rig
oro
us
pro
cess
to
in
corp
ora
te
less
on
s le
arn
ed i
nto
op
era
tio
ns.
PG
&E
wil
l fo
rma
lize
a p
roce
ss i
n t
he
futu
re.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
46
Pro
toco
ls i
n p
lace
to l
earn
fro
m
wil
dfi
re e
ven
ts
I.IV
.cO
nce
up
da
ted
ba
sed
on
lea
rnin
gs
an
d
imp
rov
emen
ts,
is t
he
up
da
ted
pla
n
test
ed u
sin
g "
dry
ru
ns"
to
co
nfi
rm i
ts
effe
ctiv
enes
s?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
co
nd
uct
s m
eeti
ng
s w
ith
va
rio
us
lin
es o
f b
usi
nes
ses
to t
ho
rou
gh
ly d
iscu
ss n
ew
pro
cess
es.
Fo
r ex
am
ple
, st
aff
in
vo
lved
wit
h w
ild
fire
s (s
uch
as
EP
&R
an
d W
SO
C)
ha
ve
met
to
co
lla
bo
rate
on
th
e n
ew p
lan
(i.
e.,
the
wil
dfi
re k
ick
off
mee
tin
gs)
. A
dd
itio
na
l
dri
lls
an
d t
rain
ing
s w
ere
iden
tifi
ed a
s a
n a
rea
of
imp
rov
emen
t th
at
cam
e o
ut
of
po
st-
PS
PS
res
tora
tio
n d
iscu
ssio
ns.
In
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E w
ill
pla
n t
o c
on
sist
entl
y h
old
va
rio
us
dry
ru
ns
an
d e
xer
cise
s.I
Em
erg
ency
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
46
Pro
toco
ls i
n p
lace
to l
earn
fro
m
wil
dfi
re e
ven
ts
I.IV
.dIs
th
ere
a d
efin
ed p
roce
ss t
o s
oli
cit
inp
ut
fro
m a
va
riet
y o
f o
ther
sta
keh
old
ers
an
d
inco
rpo
rate
lea
rnin
gs
fro
m o
ther
sta
keh
old
ers
into
th
e em
erg
ency
pla
n?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
ha
ve
a d
efin
ed p
roce
ss t
o i
nco
rpo
rate
a v
ari
ety
of
sta
keh
old
ers'
lea
rnin
gs
into
its
em
erg
ency
pla
n.
PG
&E
do
es t
his
th
rou
gh
an
Aft
er A
ctio
n R
evie
w
pro
cess
an
d r
egu
lar
pla
nn
ing
pro
cess
fo
r P
SP
S.
PG
&E
in
vit
es e
xte
rna
l st
ak
eho
lder
s to
its
kic
ko
ff o
f C
ER
P (
as
it r
ela
tes
to P
SP
S),
an
d t
hei
r fe
edb
ack
is
inco
rpo
rate
d i
nto
th
e
CE
RP
. P
G&
E p
lan
s to
ex
pa
nd
its
wil
dfi
re A
fter
Act
ion
Rev
iew
pro
cess
to
in
clu
de
a
va
riet
y o
f st
ak
eho
lder
s a
nd
in
corp
ora
te a
ny
fee
db
ack
rec
eiv
ed.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
47
Pro
cess
es f
or
con
tin
uo
us
imp
rov
emen
t
aft
er w
ild
fire
an
d
PS
PS
I.V
.aD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty c
on
du
ct a
n e
va
lua
tio
n o
r
deb
rief
pro
cess
aft
er a
wil
dfi
re?
iiii
"Wil
dfi
re"
incl
ud
es w
ild
fire
an
d P
SP
S,
as
ind
ica
ted
in t
he
cap
ab
ilit
y t
itle
.
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
co
nd
uct
s, a
nd
wil
l co
nti
nu
e to
co
nd
uct
, a
n A
fter
Act
ion
Rep
ort
fo
r
eva
lua
tio
n a
nd
in
tern
all
y h
old
deb
rief
s a
fter
a w
ild
fire
.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
47
Pro
cess
es f
or
con
tin
uo
us
imp
rov
emen
t
aft
er w
ild
fire
an
d
PS
PS
I.V
.bD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty c
on
du
ct a
cu
sto
mer
surv
ey a
nd
uti
lize
pa
rtn
ers
to
dis
sem
ina
te r
equ
ests
fo
r st
ak
eho
lder
eng
ag
emen
t?
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E i
s cu
rren
tly
co
nd
uct
ing
fo
rma
l P
SP
S l
iste
nin
g s
essi
on
s w
ith
co
mm
un
itie
s.
PG
&E
wil
l co
nti
nu
e to
co
nd
uct
lis
ten
ing
ses
sio
ns
wit
h c
om
mu
nit
y l
ead
ers
an
d p
lan
s to
imp
lem
ent
ad
dit
ion
al
pu
bli
c li
sten
ing
ses
sio
ns
aft
er w
ild
fire
ev
ents
. P
G&
E p
lan
s to
dev
elo
p a
fo
cuse
d p
lan
fo
r en
ga
gin
g t
he
rep
rese
nta
tiv
e fe
edb
ack
fro
m c
ust
om
ers
an
d
uti
lize
su
rvey
s in
th
e fu
ture
.I
Em
erg
ency
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
47
Pro
cess
es f
or
con
tin
uo
us
imp
rov
emen
t
aft
er w
ild
fire
an
d
PS
PS
I.V
.cIn
wh
at
oth
er a
ctiv
itie
s d
oes
th
e u
tili
ty
eng
ag
e?
iii
ivN
on
eP
G&
E h
old
s d
ebri
efs
wit
h p
art
ner
s to
dis
cuss
co
nti
nu
ou
s im
pro
vem
ent
aft
er w
ild
fire
s
an
d P
SP
S e
ven
ts.
Fo
r ex
am
ple
, a
fter
PS
PS
ev
ents
, p
art
ner
s a
re i
nv
ited
to
jo
in a
deb
rief
sess
ion
. P
art
ner
s h
av
e in
clu
ded
th
e C
PU
C,
Ca
l F
ire,
Ca
l O
ES
, a
nd
co
un
ty
rep
rese
nta
tiv
es.
PG
&E
rec
og
niz
es a
n o
pp
ort
un
ity
to
fo
rma
lize
an
d b
e m
ore
pro
act
ive
in h
old
ing
th
ese
the
on
go
ing
lis
ten
ing
ses
sio
ns.
PG
&E
lo
ok
s fo
rwa
rd t
o i
mp
lem
enti
ng
bo
th o
utr
each
met
ho
ds
in a
mo
re f
luid
ma
nn
er i
n t
he
futu
re.
Atch5-23
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
47
Pro
cess
es f
or
con
tin
uo
us
imp
rov
emen
t
aft
er w
ild
fire
an
d
PS
PS
I.V
.dD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty s
ha
re w
ith
pa
rtn
ers
fin
din
gs
ab
ou
t w
ha
t ca
n b
e im
pro
ved
?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
sh
are
s fi
nd
ing
s a
bo
ut
wh
at
can
be
imp
rov
ed w
ith
so
me
pa
rtn
ers
(e.g
.CP
UC
).
Fo
r ex
am
ple
, P
G&
E h
as
a l
esso
ns
lea
rned
sec
tio
n i
n t
he
10-d
ay
rep
ort
th
at
is
pu
bli
shed
on
th
e P
G&
E w
ebsi
te.
Ho
wev
er,
PG
&E
see
s a
n o
pp
ort
un
ity
to
sh
are
th
ese
less
on
s w
ith
a b
roa
der
au
die
nce
, fu
rth
er s
oci
ali
ze t
hes
e le
sso
ns
lea
rned
, a
nd
fo
llo
w-u
p
wit
h c
om
mu
nic
ati
on
s o
n a
ctio
ns
bei
ng
ta
ken
ba
sed
on
th
e id
enti
fied
les
son
s le
arn
ed.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
47
Pro
cess
es f
or
con
tin
uo
us
imp
rov
emen
t
aft
er w
ild
fire
an
d
PS
PS
I.V
.eA
re f
eed
ba
ck a
nd
rec
om
men
da
tio
ns
on
po
ten
tia
l im
pro
vem
ents
ma
de
pu
bli
c?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
sh
are
s fi
nd
ing
s a
bo
ut
wh
at
can
be
imp
rov
ed w
ith
so
me
pa
rtn
ers
(e.g
.CP
UC
).
Fo
r ex
am
ple
, P
G&
E h
as
a l
esso
ns
lea
rned
sec
tio
n i
n t
he
10-d
ay
rep
ort
th
at
is
pu
bli
shed
on
th
e P
G&
E w
ebsi
te.
Ho
wev
er,
PG
&E
see
s a
n o
pp
ort
un
ity
to
sh
are
th
ese
less
on
s w
ith
a b
roa
der
au
die
nce
, fu
rth
er s
oci
ali
ze t
hes
e le
sso
ns
lea
rned
, a
nd
fo
llo
w-u
p
wit
h c
om
mu
nic
ati
on
s o
n a
ctio
ns
bei
ng
ta
ken
ba
sed
on
th
e id
enti
fied
les
son
s le
arn
ed.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
47
Pro
cess
es f
or
con
tin
uo
us
imp
rov
emen
t
aft
er w
ild
fire
an
d
PS
PS
I.V
.fD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty c
on
du
ct p
roa
ctiv
e
ou
trea
ch t
o l
oca
l a
gen
cies
an
d
org
an
iza
tio
ns
to s
oli
cit
ad
dit
ion
al
feed
ba
ck o
n w
ha
t ca
n b
e im
pro
ved
?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
co
nd
uct
s p
roa
ctiv
e o
utr
each
to
lo
cal
ag
enci
es a
nd
org
an
iza
tio
ns
to s
oli
cit
ad
dit
ion
al
feed
ba
ck.
Pro
act
ive
ou
trea
ch t
o r
ecei
ve
feed
ba
ck f
rom
th
e cu
sto
mer
s ca
n b
e
furt
her
dev
elo
ped
fo
r b
oth
PS
PS
an
d w
ild
fire
s. P
G&
E's
pla
ns
to o
rga
niz
e a
nd
co
nd
uct
com
mu
nit
y o
utr
each
mo
re p
roa
ctiv
ely
in
th
e fu
ture
.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
47
Pro
cess
es f
or
con
tin
uo
us
imp
rov
emen
t
aft
er w
ild
fire
an
d
PS
PS
I.V
.gD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty h
av
e a
cle
ar
pla
n f
or
po
st-
even
t li
sten
ing
an
d i
nco
rpo
rati
ng
less
on
s le
arn
ed f
rom
all
sta
keh
old
ers?
iii
No
ne
Po
st-e
ven
t, P
G&
E e
ng
ag
es i
n p
ub
lic
list
enin
g s
essi
on
s to
rec
eiv
e fe
edb
ack
. T
his
feed
ba
ck,
alo
ng
wit
h f
eed
ba
ck r
ecei
ved
fro
m o
ther
fo
rum
s, b
eco
me
inco
rpo
rate
d i
n a
s
less
on
s le
arn
ed i
n d
ocu
men
ts s
uch
as
the
Aft
er A
ctio
n R
epo
rts.
Ho
wev
er,
ther
e is
roo
m f
or
PG
&E
to
im
pro
ve
its
list
enin
g s
essi
on
s to
su
pp
ort
mo
re o
f a
tw
o-w
ay
dia
log
ue
an
d g
ain
mo
re c
ust
om
er e
ng
ag
emen
t. P
G&
E p
lan
s to
dev
elo
p a
cle
ar
an
d
effe
ctiv
e p
lan
fo
r p
ost
-ev
ent
list
enin
g.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
47
Pro
cess
es f
or
con
tin
uo
us
imp
rov
emen
t
aft
er w
ild
fire
an
d
PS
PS
I.V
.hD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty t
rack
th
e
imp
lem
enta
tio
n o
f re
com
men
da
tio
ns
an
d r
epo
rt u
po
n t
hei
r im
pa
ct?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
tra
cks
an
d r
epo
rts
on
th
e im
pa
cts
of
imp
lem
ente
d w
ild
fire
rec
om
men
da
tio
ns.
PG
&E
do
esn
't c
urr
entl
y t
rack
th
e im
ple
men
tati
on
of
reco
mm
end
ati
on
s n
or
rep
ort
up
on
th
eir
imp
act
s fo
r P
SP
S.
Ho
wev
er,
PG
&E
wil
l b
e a
ble
to
do
so
in
th
e fu
ture
,
bec
au
se i
t is
set
tin
g u
p m
etri
cs t
o r
epo
rt o
ut
pro
gre
ss.
IE
mer
gen
cy
pla
nn
ing
an
d
pre
pa
red
nes
s
47
Pro
cess
es f
or
con
tin
uo
us
imp
rov
emen
t
aft
er w
ild
fire
an
d
PS
PS
I.V
.iD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty h
av
e a
pro
cess
to
con
du
ct r
evie
ws
aft
er w
ild
fire
s in
oth
er
the
terr
ito
ry o
f o
ther
uti
liti
es a
nd
sta
tes
to i
den
tify
an
d a
dd
ress
are
as
of
imp
rov
emen
t?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
do
es n
ot
con
du
ct r
evie
ws
aft
er w
ild
fire
s in
oth
er t
erri
tory
of
oth
er
uti
liti
es t
o i
den
tify
an
d a
dd
ress
are
as
of
imp
rov
emen
t. H
ow
ever
, in
th
e fu
ture
, P
G&
E
sees
th
e im
per
ati
ve
ben
efit
of
con
du
ctin
g s
uch
rev
iew
s. T
her
e a
re a
lso
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
to
furt
her
en
ga
ge
wit
h o
ther
uti
liti
es o
n w
ild
fire
s a
nd
PS
PS
po
st e
ven
ts.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
48
Co
op
era
tio
n a
nd
bes
t p
ract
ice
sha
rin
g w
ith
oth
er u
tili
ties
J.I
.aD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty a
ctiv
ely
wo
rk t
o i
den
tify
bes
t p
ract
ices
fro
m o
ther
uti
liti
es
thro
ug
h a
cle
arl
y
def
ined
op
era
tio
na
l p
roce
ss?
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y c
oll
ab
ora
tes
wit
h o
ther
Ca
lifo
rnia
uti
liti
es a
nd
sh
are
s b
est
pra
ctic
es,
bu
t d
oes
no
t co
nsi
der
th
e ex
isti
ng
lev
el o
f en
ga
gem
ent
to b
e a
"cl
earl
y d
efin
ed
op
era
tio
na
l p
roce
ss"
at
this
tim
e. P
G&
E p
lan
s to
fo
rma
lize
th
e ex
isti
ng
co
lla
bo
rati
on
an
d i
ncl
ud
e o
ther
glo
ba
l u
tili
ties
(e.
g.,
Au
stra
lia
) in
th
e fu
ture
.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
48
Co
op
era
tio
n a
nd
bes
t p
ract
ice
sha
rin
g w
ith
oth
er u
tili
ties
J.I
.bD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty s
ucc
essf
ull
y a
do
pt
an
d
imp
lem
ent
bes
t p
ract
ices
id
enti
fied
fro
m
oth
er u
tili
ties
?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
ha
s su
cces
sfu
lly
ad
op
ted
an
d i
mp
lem
ente
d b
est
pra
ctic
es i
den
tifi
ed f
rom
oth
er
uti
liti
es (
i.e.
, P
G&
E u
ses
the
PS
PS
pro
cess
, h
igh
-def
init
ion
ca
mer
as,
a w
eath
er s
tati
on
net
wo
rk a
nd
Tec
hn
osy
lva
pra
ctic
es t
ha
t w
ere
sha
red
by
SD
G&
E).
PG
&E
wil
l co
nti
nu
e
to a
do
pt
an
d i
mp
lem
ent
bes
t p
ract
ices
in
th
e fu
ture
.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
48
Co
op
era
tio
n a
nd
bes
t p
ract
ice
sha
rin
g w
ith
oth
er u
tili
ties
J.I
.cD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty s
eek
to
sh
are
bes
t
pra
ctic
es a
nd
les
son
s le
arn
ed i
n a
con
sist
ent
form
at?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
fo
llo
ws
the
ES
RB
-8 r
equ
irem
ent,
wh
ich
is
a c
on
sist
ent
form
at
for
sha
rin
g
less
on
s le
arn
ed.
PG
&E
als
o h
as
a f
oru
m t
o s
ha
re b
est
pra
ctic
es,
bu
t d
oes
no
t fo
llo
w a
con
sist
ent
form
at.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
48
Co
op
era
tio
n a
nd
bes
t p
ract
ice
sha
rin
g w
ith
oth
er u
tili
ties
J.I
.dD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty s
ha
re b
est
pra
ctic
es a
nd
less
on
s v
ia a
co
nsi
sten
t a
nd
pre
dic
tab
le
set
of
ven
ues
/med
ia?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
fo
llo
ws
the
ES
RB
-8 r
equ
irem
ent,
wh
ich
is
a c
on
sist
ent
an
d p
red
icta
ble
set
of
ven
ues
/med
ia f
or
sha
rin
g l
esso
ns
lea
rned
. P
G&
E h
as
a f
oru
m t
o s
ha
re b
est
pra
ctic
es,
bu
t d
oes
no
t co
nsi
der
th
at
to b
e a
co
nsi
sten
t n
or
pre
dic
tab
le s
et o
f v
enu
es /
med
ia.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
48
Co
op
era
tio
n a
nd
bes
t p
ract
ice
sha
rin
g w
ith
oth
er u
tili
ties
J.I
.eD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty p
art
icip
ate
in
an
nu
al
ben
chm
ark
ing
ex
erci
ses
wit
h o
ther
uti
liti
es t
o f
ind
are
as
for
imp
rov
emen
t?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
pa
rtic
ipa
tes
in b
ench
ma
rkin
g e
xer
cise
s w
ith
oth
er u
tili
ties
to
fin
d a
rea
s fo
r
imp
rov
emen
t m
ore
fre
qu
entl
y t
ha
n a
nn
ua
lly
, a
nd
wil
l co
nti
nu
e to
do
so
in
th
e fu
ture
.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
48
Co
op
era
tio
n a
nd
bes
t p
ract
ice
sha
rin
g w
ith
oth
er u
tili
ties
J.I
.fH
as
the
uti
lity
im
ple
men
ted
a d
efin
ed
pro
cess
fo
r te
stin
g l
esso
ns
lea
rned
fro
m
oth
er
uti
liti
es t
o e
nsu
re l
oca
l a
pp
lica
bil
ity
?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
in
form
all
y t
ests
les
son
s le
arn
ed f
rom
oth
er u
tili
ties
fo
r lo
cal
ap
pli
cab
ilit
y,
bu
t
do
es n
ot
ha
ve
a "
def
ined
pro
cess
" to
do
so
at
this
tim
e. P
G&
E w
ill
form
ali
ze t
his
pro
cess
in
th
e fu
ture
.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
49
En
ga
gem
ent
wit
h
com
mu
nit
ies
on
uti
lity
wil
dfi
re
mit
iga
tio
n
init
iati
ves
J.I
I.a
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
ha
ve
a c
lea
r a
nd
act
ion
ab
le p
lan
to
dev
elo
p o
r m
ain
tain
a
coll
ab
ora
tiv
e
rela
tio
nsh
ip w
ith
lo
cal
com
mu
nit
ies?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
ha
s a
lrea
dy
ex
ecu
ted
ma
ny
lo
cal
com
mu
nit
y "
PS
PS
Lis
ten
ing
Ses
sio
ns"
to
con
tin
ue
to b
uil
d a
co
lla
bo
rati
ve
rela
tio
nsh
ip w
ith
th
e lo
cal
com
mu
nit
ies
imp
act
ed b
y
the
20
19 P
SP
S s
easo
n.
PG
&E
is
in t
he
pro
cess
of
evo
lvin
g i
ts e
xis
tin
g c
om
mu
nit
y
ou
trea
ch p
lan
to
in
clu
de
mo
re t
wo
-wa
y c
om
mu
nic
ati
on
op
po
rtu
nit
ies.
PG
&E
wil
l
con
tin
ue
to f
urt
her
fo
rma
lize
an
d m
atu
re t
his
pla
n i
n t
he
com
ing
yea
rs.
Atch5-24
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
49
En
ga
gem
ent
wit
h
com
mu
nit
ies
on
uti
lity
wil
dfi
re
mit
iga
tio
n
init
iati
ves
J.I
I.b
Are
th
ere
com
mu
nit
ies
in H
FT
D a
rea
s
wh
ere
mea
nin
gfu
l re
sist
an
ce i
s ex
pec
ted
in r
esp
on
se t
o e
ffo
rts
to m
itig
ate
fir
e ri
sk
(e.g
. v
eget
ati
on
cle
ara
nce
)?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es w
ork
clo
sely
wit
h c
om
mu
nit
ies
on
ma
ny
of
its
wil
dfi
re m
itig
ati
on
eff
ort
s.
Th
ere
are
co
mm
un
itie
s (i
n H
FT
D a
rea
s) w
her
e re
sist
an
ce h
as
bee
n e
xp
erie
nce
d (
i.e.
,
reg
ula
tio
ns
in S
an
ta C
ruz
pro
hib
it P
G&
E f
rom
per
form
ing
ro
uti
ne
veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent)
in
res
po
nse
to
eff
ort
s to
mit
iga
te f
ire
risk
. P
G&
E w
ill
con
tin
ue
to w
ork
wit
h c
om
mu
nit
ies
bu
t d
oes
n't
fo
rese
e th
is c
ha
ng
ing
in
th
e fu
ture
.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
49
En
ga
gem
ent
wit
h
com
mu
nit
ies
on
uti
lity
wil
dfi
re
mit
iga
tio
n
init
iati
ves
J.I
I.c
Wh
at
per
cen
t o
f la
nd
ow
ner
s a
re n
on
-
com
pli
an
t w
ith
uti
lity
in
itia
tiv
es (
e.g
.,
veg
eta
tio
n m
an
ag
emen
t)?
vv
La
nd
ow
ner
is
def
ined
as
un
iqu
e cu
sto
mer
sL
ess
tha
t 0
.5%
of
lan
do
wn
ers
are
cu
rren
tly
no
n-c
om
pli
an
t w
ith
PG
&E
's i
nit
iati
ves
. In
ord
er t
o a
nsw
er t
his
qu
esti
on
, P
G&
E u
sed
its
its
to
tal
nu
mb
er o
f cu
sto
mer
ref
usa
ls i
n
20
19 (
~2
2,0
00
) a
s th
e n
um
era
tor
an
d i
ts t
ota
l n
um
ber
of
un
iqu
e cu
sto
mer
s (~
5.2
mil
lio
n)
as
the
den
om
ina
tor
to e
qu
al
a n
um
ber
th
at
is l
ess
tha
n 0
.5%
.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
49
En
ga
gem
ent
wit
h
com
mu
nit
ies
on
uti
lity
wil
dfi
re
mit
iga
tio
n
init
iati
ves
J.I
I.d
Wh
at
per
cen
t o
f la
nd
ow
ner
s co
mp
lain
ab
ou
t u
tili
ty i
nit
iati
ves
(e.
g.,
veg
eta
tio
n
ma
na
gem
ent)
?
iviv
A "
com
pla
int"
is
a f
orm
al
com
pla
int
file
d b
y a
cust
om
er w
ith
th
e C
PU
C.
La
nd
ow
ner
is
def
ined
as
un
iqu
e cu
sto
mer
acc
ou
nts
Cu
rren
tly
, le
ss t
ha
n 1
% o
f la
nd
ow
ner
s co
mp
lain
ab
ou
t u
tili
ty i
nit
iati
ves
. In
fu
ture
,
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
exp
ect
this
nu
mb
er t
o c
ha
ng
e
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
49
En
ga
gem
ent
wit
h
com
mu
nit
ies
on
uti
lity
wil
dfi
re
mit
iga
tio
n
init
iati
ves
J.I
I.e
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
ha
ve
a d
emo
nst
rati
vel
y
coo
per
ati
ve
rela
tio
nsh
ip w
ith
com
mu
nit
ies
con
tain
ing
>9
0%
of
the
po
pu
lati
on
in
HF
TD
are
as
(e.g
. b
y b
ein
g
reco
gn
ized
by
oth
er a
gen
cies
as
ha
vin
g a
coo
per
ati
ve
rela
tio
nsh
ip w
ith
th
ose
com
mu
nit
ies
in H
FT
D a
rea
s)?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
is
evo
lvin
g i
ts e
xis
tin
g c
om
mu
nit
y o
utr
each
pla
n t
o b
e m
ore
co
lla
bo
rati
ve
in
na
ture
, b
ut
curr
entl
y d
oes
no
t co
nsi
der
its
elf
to h
av
e a
dem
on
stra
tiv
ely
co
op
era
tiv
e
rela
tio
nsh
ip w
ith
all
co
mm
un
itie
s a
t th
is t
ime.
PG
&E
rec
og
niz
es t
he
va
lue
an
d
imp
ort
an
ce o
f th
ese
rela
tio
nsh
ips
an
d h
as
an
act
ion
pla
n t
o c
on
tin
ue
to i
mp
rov
e it
s
ou
trea
ch,
pa
rtn
ersh
ip a
nd
co
lla
bo
rati
on
act
ivit
ies
wit
h i
ts l
oca
l co
mm
un
itie
s.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
49
En
ga
gem
ent
wit
h
com
mu
nit
ies
on
uti
lity
wil
dfi
re
mit
iga
tio
n
init
iati
ves
J.I
I.f
Do
es u
tili
ty h
av
e re
cord
s o
f la
nd
ow
ner
s
thro
ug
ho
ut
com
mu
nit
ies
con
tain
ing
>9
0%
of
the
po
pu
lati
on
in
HF
TD
are
as
rea
chin
g o
ut
to n
oti
fy o
f ri
sks,
da
ng
ers
or
issu
es i
n t
he
pa
st y
ear?
iiii
"Ris
ks,
da
ng
ers"
are
th
ose
ste
mm
ing
fro
m u
tili
ty
ow
ned
ass
ets,
no
t p
rop
erty
ow
ner
ass
ets.
PG
&E
ha
s re
cord
s o
f o
ver
90
% o
f it
s la
nd
ow
ner
s re
ach
ing
ou
t to
PG
&E
to
no
tify
of
risk
s, d
an
ger
s o
r is
sues
, b
ut
do
es n
ot
ha
ve
a "
con
sist
ent,
rep
eata
ble
" p
roce
ss t
o
ad
dre
ss t
he
no
tifi
cati
on
s.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
50
En
ga
gem
ent
wit
h
LE
P a
nd
AF
N
po
pu
lati
on
s
J.I
II.a
Ca
n t
he
uti
lity
pro
vid
e a
pla
n t
o p
art
ner
wit
h o
rga
niz
ati
on
s re
pre
sen
tin
g L
imit
ed
En
gli
sh
Pro
fici
ency
(L
EP
) a
nd
Acc
ess
&
Fu
nct
ion
al
Nee
ds
(AF
N)
com
mu
nit
ies?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
pa
rtn
ers
wit
h o
rga
niz
ati
on
s re
pre
sen
tin
g L
imit
ed E
ng
lish
Pro
fici
ency
(L
EP
)
an
d A
cces
s &
Fu
nct
ion
al
Nee
ds
(AF
N)
com
mu
nit
ies.
No
tab
ly,
PG
&E
ha
s a
n a
gre
emen
t
in p
lace
wit
h t
he
Ca
lifo
rnia
Fo
un
da
tio
n f
or
Ind
epen
den
t L
ivin
g C
ente
rs (
CF
ILC
) to
spec
ific
all
y e
ng
ag
e w
ith
th
e A
FN
co
mm
un
ity
. P
G&
E w
ill
con
tin
ue
to p
ut
fort
h
con
sid
era
ble
eff
ort
to
wa
rds
stre
am
lin
ing
its
co
mm
un
ica
tio
ns
to s
imp
lify
co
ord
ina
tio
n
go
ing
fo
rwa
rd,
esp
ecia
lly
fo
r th
e L
EP
gro
up
s.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
50
En
ga
gem
ent
wit
h
LE
P a
nd
AF
N
po
pu
lati
on
s
J.I
II.b
Ca
n t
he
uti
lity
ou
tlin
e h
ow
th
ese
pa
rtn
ersh
ips
crea
te p
ath
wa
ys
for
imp
lem
enti
ng
su
gg
este
d a
ctiv
itie
s to
ad
dre
ss t
he
nee
ds
of
thes
e co
mm
un
itie
s?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
's p
art
ner
ship
s w
ith
th
e L
EP
an
d A
FN
co
mm
un
itie
s cr
eate
pa
thw
ay
s fo
r
imp
lem
enti
ng
su
gg
este
d a
ctiv
itie
s to
ad
dre
ss t
he
nee
ds
of
thes
e co
mm
un
itie
s. P
G&
E
ha
s p
rov
ided
fu
nd
ing
to
CF
ILC
to
pro
vid
e re
vel
an
t su
pp
ort
to
th
e co
mm
un
itie
s th
ey
serv
e. P
G&
E i
s im
ple
men
tin
g a
n A
FN
ad
vis
ory
co
un
cil,
or
sim
ila
r in
pu
t p
roce
ss,
to g
et
dir
ecti
on
an
d g
uid
an
ce f
rom
co
mm
un
itie
s m
emb
ers
on
ho
w t
o b
est
sup
po
rt a
nd
ser
ve
thes
e co
mm
un
itie
s.J
Sta
keh
old
er
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
50
En
ga
gem
ent
wit
h
LE
P a
nd
AF
N
po
pu
lati
on
s
J.I
II.c
Ca
n t
he
uti
lity
po
int
to c
lea
r ex
am
ple
s o
f
ho
w t
ho
se r
ela
tio
nsh
ips
ha
ve
dri
ven
th
e
uti
lity
’s
ab
ilit
y t
o i
nte
ract
wit
h a
nd
pre
pa
re L
EP
& A
FN
co
mm
un
itie
s fo
r w
ild
fire
mit
iga
tio
n
act
ivit
ies?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
ha
s m
an
y e
xa
mp
les
of
inte
ract
ion
s w
ith
th
e L
EP
an
d A
FN
co
mm
un
itie
s in
reg
ard
s to
wil
dfi
re m
itig
ati
on
act
ivit
ies
(see
sec
tio
n 5
.3.9
.4 L
an
gu
ag
e A
cces
s a
nd
Tra
nsl
ati
on
s S
tra
teg
y o
f th
e 2
02
0 W
MP
). P
G&
E r
eco
gn
izes
th
at
it c
an
ap
ply
mo
re
rig
or
an
d f
orm
ali
ty a
rou
nd
its
in
tera
ctio
ns
to s
oli
cit
feed
ba
ck f
rom
th
ose
co
mm
un
itie
s
at
this
tim
e. A
s su
ch,
PG
&E
pla
ns
to c
on
tin
ue
to s
tren
gth
en i
ts r
ela
tio
nsh
ips
wit
h t
he
LE
P a
nd
AF
N c
om
mu
nit
ies
to b
e a
ble
to
mo
re e
ffec
tiv
ely
pre
pa
re L
EP
& A
FN
com
mu
nit
ies
for
wil
dfi
re m
itig
ati
on
act
ivit
ies
in t
he
futu
re.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
50
En
ga
gem
ent
wit
h
LE
P a
nd
AF
N
po
pu
lati
on
s
J.I
II.d
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
ha
ve
a s
pec
ific
an
nu
all
y-
up
da
ted
act
ion
pla
n f
urt
her
red
uce
wil
dfi
re a
nd
PS
PS
ris
k t
o L
EP
& A
FN
co
mm
un
itie
s?
iii
No
ne
Th
e u
tili
ty h
as
an
nu
all
y-u
pd
ate
d a
ctio
n p
lan
s to
fu
rth
er r
edu
ce w
ild
fire
an
d P
SP
S
risk
s to
AL
L c
om
mu
nit
ies.
Wit
h r
ega
rd t
o P
SP
S t
his
is
pa
rtic
ula
rly
fo
cuse
d o
n t
he
com
mu
nit
ies
mo
st l
ikel
y t
o b
e fr
equ
entl
y i
mp
act
ed.
PG
&E
wil
l co
nti
nu
e to
ex
pa
nd
an
d
evo
lve
thes
e a
nn
ua
lly
-up
da
ted
aci
ton
pla
ns
to i
nco
rpo
rate
sp
ecif
ic a
ctio
ns
to s
up
po
rt
the
LE
P &
AF
N c
om
mu
nit
ies
as
no
ted
in
th
e tw
o q
ues
tio
ns
ab
ov
e.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
51
Co
lla
bo
rati
on
wit
h e
mer
gen
cy
resp
on
se
ag
enci
es
J.I
V.a
Wh
at
is t
he
coo
per
ati
ve
mo
del
bet
wee
n
the
uti
lity
an
d s
up
pre
ssio
n a
gen
cies
?
iiii
iN
on
eP
G&
E c
urr
entl
y w
ork
s w
ith
su
pp
ress
ion
ag
enci
es a
nd
no
tifi
es t
hem
of
ign
itio
ns.
PG
&E
als
o s
ha
res
its
GO
ES
16
/17
sa
tell
ite
cap
ab
ilit
y w
ith
lo
cal
ag
enci
es,
wh
en r
equ
este
d.
PG
&E
wil
l co
nti
nu
e to
ev
olv
e th
is r
ela
tio
nsh
ip a
nd
, w
her
e a
pp
rop
ria
te,
wil
l en
ga
ge
wit
h d
iffe
ren
t en
titi
es t
o h
elp
th
em b
ette
r d
etec
t ig
nit
ion
s.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
51
Co
lla
bo
rati
on
wit
h e
mer
gen
cy
resp
on
se
ag
enci
es
J.I
V.b
In w
ha
t a
rea
s is
th
e u
tili
ty c
oo
per
ati
ng
wit
h s
up
pre
ssio
n a
gen
cies
iii
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
co
op
era
tes
wit
h s
up
pre
ssio
n a
gen
cies
th
rou
gh
ou
t it
s se
rvic
e a
rea
s a
nd
wil
l co
nti
nu
e d
oin
g s
o g
oin
g f
orw
ard
.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
51
Co
lla
bo
rati
on
wit
h e
mer
gen
cy
resp
on
se
ag
enci
es
J.I
V.c
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
acc
ura
tely
pre
dic
t a
nd
com
mu
nic
ate
th
e fo
reca
sted
fir
e
pro
pa
ga
tio
n p
ath
usi
ng
av
ail
ab
le a
na
lyti
cs r
eso
urc
es a
nd
wea
ther
da
ta?
iii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
pre
dic
t a
nd
co
mm
un
ica
te f
ore
cast
ed f
ire
pro
pa
ga
tio
n p
ath
usi
ng
av
ail
ab
le a
na
lyti
cs r
eso
urc
es a
nd
wea
ther
da
ta,
ho
wev
er w
e a
nti
cip
ate
ha
vin
g t
he
cap
ab
ilit
y t
o d
o t
his
in
th
e fu
ture
(th
rou
gh
th
e T
ech
no
sylv
a t
ech
no
log
y p
latf
orm
).
Atch5-25
Ca
teg
or
y
Le
tte
rC
ate
go
ry
Na
me
Ca
pa
bil
ity
#C
ap
ab
ilit
y
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
n
Na
me
Qu
es
tio
nC
ur
re
nt
Sta
te
Sc
or
eF
utu
re
Sta
te S
co
re
As
su
mp
tio
nE
xp
lan
ati
on
Ca
teg
or
y/C
ap
ab
ilit
y I
nfo
Sc
or
es
Fin
al
De
liv
er
ab
leQ
ue
sti
on
In
fo
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
51
Co
lla
bo
rati
on
wit
h e
mer
gen
cy
resp
on
se
ag
enci
es
J.I
V.d
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
co
mm
un
ica
te f
ire
pa
ths
to t
he
com
mu
nit
y a
s re
qu
este
d?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
pre
dic
t a
nd
co
mm
un
ica
te f
ore
cast
ed f
ire
pro
pa
ga
tio
n p
ath
usi
ng
av
ail
ab
le a
na
lyti
cs r
eso
urc
es a
nd
wea
ther
da
ta,
ho
wev
er m
ay
be
ab
le t
o d
o t
his
in
th
e
futu
re w
ith
its
Tec
hn
osy
lva
tec
hn
olo
gy
.
PG
&E
bel
iev
es i
t is
cri
tica
l to
un
der
sta
nd
wh
o s
ho
uld
pro
vid
e co
mm
un
ity
-wid
e
no
tifi
cati
on
of
po
ten
tia
l fi
re p
ath
s (a
nd
ho
w);
th
en,
this
pro
cess
wo
uld
nee
d t
o b
e
tho
rou
gh
ly d
iscu
ssed
an
d a
lig
ned
bet
wee
n P
G&
E,
fire
su
pp
ress
ion
ag
enci
es,
com
mu
nit
y O
ES
an
d o
ther
sta
keh
old
ers.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
51
Co
lla
bo
rati
on
wit
h e
mer
gen
cy
resp
on
se
ag
enci
es
J.I
V.e
Do
es t
he
uti
lity
wo
rk t
o a
ssis
t
sup
pre
ssio
n c
rew
s lo
gis
tica
lly
, w
her
e
po
ssib
le?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
cu
rren
tly
ass
ists
su
pp
ress
ion
cre
ws
log
isti
call
y (
wh
ere
po
ssib
le)
an
d w
ill
con
tin
ue
do
ing
so
in
th
e fo
rese
eab
le f
utu
re.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
52
Co
lla
bo
rati
on
on
wil
dfi
re
mit
iga
tio
n
pla
nn
ing
wit
h
sta
keh
old
ers
J.V
.aW
her
e d
oes
th
e u
tili
ty c
on
du
ct
sub
sta
nti
al
fuel
ma
na
gem
ent?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
gen
era
lly
on
ly c
on
du
cts
fuel
ma
na
gem
ent
in a
rea
s w
her
e re
late
d r
egu
lati
on
s
ap
ply
, n
am
ely
PR
C 4
29
2.
PG
&E
pla
ns
to a
llo
cate
fu
nd
ing
fo
r a
ta
rget
ed,
risk
-ba
sed
fuel
ma
na
gem
ent
effo
rt i
n t
he
futu
re,
bu
t su
ch e
ffo
rts
ma
y n
ot
qu
ali
fy a
s a
dd
ress
ing
"su
bst
an
tia
l fu
el m
an
ag
emen
t" w
ork
acc
ross
rig
hts
of
wa
y.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
52
Co
lla
bo
rati
on
on
wil
dfi
re
mit
iga
tio
n
pla
nn
ing
wit
h
sta
keh
old
ers
J.V
.bD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty e
ng
ag
e w
ith
oth
er
sta
keh
old
ers
as
pa
rt o
f it
s fu
el
ma
na
gem
ent
effo
rts?
iii
iN
on
eP
G&
E e
ng
ag
es w
ith
sta
keh
old
ers
reg
ard
ing
fu
el m
an
ag
emen
t in
an
ad
ho
c m
an
ner
,
an
d d
oes
no
t sh
are
in
form
ati
on
in
a c
on
sist
ent
wa
y.
PG
&E
pla
ns
to i
mp
lem
ent
a f
uel
ma
na
gem
ent
pla
n /
pro
gra
m t
ha
t w
ill
all
ow
fo
r ef
fect
ive
eng
ag
emen
t a
nd
co
ord
ina
tio
n
wit
h s
tak
eho
lder
s o
n f
uel
ma
na
gem
ent
act
ivit
ies.
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
52
Co
lla
bo
rati
on
on
wil
dfi
re
mit
iga
tio
n
pla
nn
ing
wit
h
sta
keh
old
ers
J.V
.cD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty c
ult
iva
te a
na
tiv
e
veg
eta
tio
n e
cosy
stem
acr
oss
ter
rito
ry
tha
t is
co
nsi
sten
t
wit
h l
ow
er f
ire
risk
?
ii
No
ne
PG
&E
do
es n
ot
curr
entl
y c
ult
iva
te a
na
tiv
e v
eget
ati
on
eco
syst
em a
cro
ss t
erri
tory
con
sist
ent
wit
h l
ow
er f
ire
risk
bec
au
se P
G&
E b
elie
ves
th
ere
are
mo
re e
ffec
tiv
e w
ay
s to
red
uce
th
is r
isk
(e.
g.,
fu
el m
an
ag
emen
t).
JS
tak
eho
lder
coo
per
ati
on
an
d
com
mu
nit
y
eng
ag
emen
t
52
Co
lla
bo
rati
on
on
wil
dfi
re
mit
iga
tio
n
pla
nn
ing
wit
h
sta
keh
old
ers
J.V
.dD
oes
th
e u
tili
ty f
un
d l
oca
l g
rou
ps
(e.g
.,
fire
sa
fe c
ou
nci
ls)
to s
up
po
rt f
uel
ma
na
gem
ent?
iiii
No
ne
PG
&E
fu
nd
s, a
nd
wil
l co
nti
nu
e to
fu
nd
, lo
cal
gro
up
s to
su
pp
ort
fu
el m
an
ag
emen
t.
Atch5-26