panagiotis papapetrou, george kollios, stan sclaroff, dimitrios gunopulos

49
Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos Department of Computer Science Boston University University of California, Riverside Discovering Frequent Arrangements of Temporal Intervals

Upload: toril

Post on 19-Jan-2016

38 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Discovering Frequent Arrangements of Temporal Intervals. Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos Department of Computer Science Boston University University of California, Riverside. Introduction and Motivation. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios GunopulosDepartment of Computer Science

Boston University University of California, Riverside

Discovering Frequent Arrangements of Temporal Intervals

Page 2: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Introduction and Motivation Sequential pattern mining has received particular attention in the last decade:

Database of sequences: ordered lists of instantaneous events.

Extract frequent sequential patterns.

In many applications events occur over time intervals.

Extracting frequent arrangements of these temporally correlated labeled

intervals may lead to useful observations.

So far, algorithms concentrate on the case where events occur

instantaneously.

The idea of mining temporal patterns of interval-based events introduced in [1].

However, the extracted patterns are restricted to certain forms.

1. P. Kam and A. W. Fu. “Discovering temporal patterns of Interval-based Events”. In Proc. of the DaWak, pages 317–326, London, UK, 2000. Springer-Verlag.

Page 3: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Applications (1/4)Linguistics

(Eye-brow Lower)

(WH-Question)

(WH-Word)

time

ASL Database Collections of utterances.

Utterance:

Associates a segment of video with a detailed transcription.

Contains a number of ASL gestural and grammatical fields

each one occurring over a time interval. (WH-Word)

(Rapid head-shake)

Page 4: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Applications (2/4)Linguistics (An example)

> Who drove the car, who?

Page 5: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Applications (3/4)Networks

Router 1 Router 2IPs IPs

A B

(D, C)(D, B)

(A, B)

D

C

time

Page 6: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Applications (4/4)Biology

Human Gene

Region ofNucleodite A

Region ofNucleodite G

Region ofNucleodite C

(Nucleodite C)

(Nucleodite G)

(Nucleodite A)

Position in the Gene

Page 7: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Main Contributions

Formal definition of the problem of mining frequent temporal

arrangements of intervals in an interval database.

Development of two efficient mining algorithms that use

breadth first and depth search techniques in an enumeration

tree of temporal arrangements.

Extensive experimental evaluation and comparison with a

standard sequential pattern mining method both on real and

synthetic datasets.

Page 8: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Outline

Preliminaries Problem Formulation Proposed Algorithms

BFS-based DFS-based Hybrid-DFS

Experimental Evaluation Related Work Conclusions Future Work

Page 9: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Preliminaries (1/6) There can be many types of relations between two event intervals2. We consider five of them:

2. J. F. Allen and G. Ferguson. “Actions and events in interval temporal logic”. Technical Report 521, The University of Rochester, July 1994”.

A[tstart, tend] B[tstart, tend]

(a)

A[tstart, tend]

B[tstart, tend]

(b)

A[tstart, tend]

B[tstart, tend]

(c)Meet of A and B, denoted as: AB

Match of A and B, denoted as: A || B

Overlap of A and B, denoted as: A | B

A[tstart, tend]

B[tstart, tend]

(d)

A[tstart, tend] B[tstart, tend]

(e)

Contain of A and B, denoted as: A > B

Follow of A and B, denoted as: A → B

+/- e

+/- e+/- e

Page 10: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Preliminaries (2/6)

Let SS = { = {EE11, , EE22, …, , …, EEmm} be an ordered set of event intervals, called } be an ordered set of event intervals, called

event interval sequenceevent interval sequence, or, or e-sequence e-sequence..

Each Each EEii is a triple (eis a triple (eii, t, tiistartstart, t, tii

endend))

eeii: an event label.: an event label.

ttiistart:start:: the event start time.: the event start time.

ttiiend:end:: the event end time.: the event end time.

Note: Note: SS is ordered by t is ordered by tiistartstart..

k-e-sequencek-e-sequence: an e-sequence of size k.

e-sequence databasee-sequence database D: D: a set of e-sequences.

Page 11: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Preliminaries (3/6)

Example of a 5-e-sequence:

SS = { (A,1,7), (B,3,19), (D,4,30), (C,7,15), C,23,42) }= { (A,1,7), (B,3,19), (D,4,30), (C,7,15), C,23,42) }

A

B

CC

31 4 7 15 19 23 30 42

D

Page 12: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Preliminaries (4/6) k-Arrangement:k-Arrangement: a set of kk temporally correlated events in an

e-sequence, denoted as A = {EE , R}, where: E E : the set of labels of the event intervals in the arrangement.

R R : the set of temporal relations between the events in E.

)}E ,(Er ... ),E ,(Er ..., ),E ,(Er ),E ,(Er ..., ),E ,(Er ),E ,(E{r R n1-nn232n13121

}, |, ||, { )E ,(Er ji A

B

C

} }|, |, { C},B,{A, {

E1 Ei Ei+1 EnEi+3Ei+2Ei-1

where is the temporal relation between EEii and EEjj.

Page 13: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Preliminaries (5/6)

Given an e-sequence SS and an arrangement AA = {EE , RR}:

SS contains AA, if all the events in EE appear in SS, with the

relations defined in RR.

Given an e-sequence database DD and a minimum support

threshold min_supmin_sup:

An arrangement AA is frequent, if it is contained in at least

min_supmin_sup e-sequences (i.e. records) of DD.

Page 14: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Preliminaries (6/6)

A

B

C

A

B

CC

31 4 7 15 19 23 30 42

D

SS = {(A,1,7), (B,3,19), (D,4,30), (C,7,15), C,23,42)}= {(A,1,7), (B,3,19), (D,4,30), (C,7,15), C,23,42)}

Example of an arrangement AA, contained in an e-sequence SS:

} }, |, { C},B,{A, {

Page 15: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Problem Formulation

Our Goal:

Find the complete set of frequent arrangements given:

A e-sequence database D.D.

A minimum support threshold min_sup.min_sup.

Page 16: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Apply a sequential pattern mining algorithm?

Consider start and end points of an interval as two instantaneous events.

Convert each e-sequence into a regular sequence. Apply an efficient sequential pattern mining algorithm + post-

processing. Basic drawbacks:

k-arrangement = sequence of 2k events. May produce 22k patterns. Can we reduce it to 2k?

Extracted patterns will carry lots of redundant information.A

B

{Astart, Bstart, Aend, Bend},

but also: {Astart, Bstart},…

Sequential Pattern MiningAlgorithm will produce

Page 17: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Frequent Arrangement Mining Algorithms

Use a logical Tree-like structure to enumerate the

arrangements3.

Traverse the Tree using:

BFS

DFS

Hybrid DFS

BFS for the first two levels.

DFS for the rest of the mining process.

3. R. J. Bayardo. “Efficiently mining long patterns from databases”. In Proc. of ACM SIGMOD, pages 85–93, 1998.

Page 18: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

The Arrangement Enumeration Tree

NULL

{A, B} {A, C} {B, A} {B, C} {C, A} {C, B}{A, A} {B, B} {C, C}

A->A A>B A->B AC A|C A||C A>C A->C

{A} {B} {C}

{A, A, A} {A, A, B} {A, B, A} {A, B, B} {A, B, C}{A, A, C}

AB*A|C*B||CAB*AC*B|C A||B*A->C*BC ...

AA A|A A||A A >A A||BAB A|B

Let },,{ CBAE

LEVEL3

LEVEL2

LEVEL1

Intermediate

Intermediate

Page 19: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

BFS-based Approach (1/2) Traverses Tree in BFS order.

2 database scans.

On each step k:

Build candidate k-arrangements based on (k-1)-arrangements.

Find 2-relations by scanning the second level of the Tree.

Determine frequency: min_supmin_sup threshold must be satisfied.

If a node is not frequent, do not expand sub-tree (Apriori Principle)4.

Stop at step k, where no frequent arrangements are found.

4. R. Agrawal and R. Srikant. “Fast algorithms for mining association rules”. In Proc. of VLDB, pages 487-499, 1994.

Page 20: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

BFS-based Approach (2/2)An Example

{A, B} {A, C} {B, A} {B, C} {C, A} {C, B}{A, A} {B, B} {C, C}

A->A A>B A->B AC A|C A||C A>C A->C

{A, A, B} {A, B, A} {A, B, B}{A, A, C}

AA, A|C, A||C

AA A|A A||A A >A A||BAB A|B

… …

{A, B, C}{A, A, A}

Page 21: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

DFS-based Approach Candidate generation in DFS order.

Leads to frequent large arrangements faster.

Skips expansions of nodes that are definitely going to lead to frequent

arrangements.

DFS is inappropriate:

For each node we would have to scan the database multiple times to

detect the 2-relations among the items in the node.

Hybrid-DFS

Generates the first two levels of the Tree using BFS, then uses DFS.

Eliminates multiple database scans, 2-relations are available.

Page 22: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Experimental Setup (1/4)Real Datasets SignStream Database

Created by the National Center for Sign Language and

Gesture Resources at Boston University.

Collection of 884 utterances.

Some types of event labels: Grammatical or syntactic structures:

WH-Question.

Negation.

Yes/No Question.

Gestural Fields: Head-shake.

Eye-brow raise/lower.

Page 23: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Experimental Setup (2/4)Real Datasets Network Data

Sampled from flow data.

Two routers with high communication rate:

ATLA: router in Atlanta.

LOSA: router in LA.

Monitored communication for 10 days, between 200 IPs.

An e-sequence is a set of IP connections for every 15 minutes:

An event label is the two IPs (source-destination).

The interval corresponds to the duration of this communication.

Size of dataset: 960 e-sequences.

Page 24: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Experimental Setup (3/4)Synthetic Datasets

Generated considering the following factors: Number of e-sequences in the Database.

Average e-sequence size.

Number of distinct items.

Density of frequent patterns.

Page 25: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Experimental Setup (4/4)Algorithms

Compared:

BFS.

Hybrid-DFS.

SPAM5, modified as follows:

Considered the start and end points of each interval as

two instantaneous events.

Post-processed the extracted sequential patterns to

convert them into arrangements.

5. J. Ayres, J. Gehrke, T. Yiu, and J. Flannick. Sequential pattern mining using a bitmap representation. In Proc. of ACM SIGKDD, pages 429–435, 2002.

Page 26: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Performance Analysis

BFS outperforms SPAM in large database sizes

and small supports.

Hybrid-DFS outperforms both SPAM and BFS.

In low supports Hybrid-DFS is twice as fast as

BFS.

Page 27: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Sample Results (1/4) SignStream Database

Page 28: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Head: tilt side

Negation

Eye-brow raise

Negation

72 % 87 %

Head: tilt side

Yes/No Word

Eye-brow raise

Yes/No Word

68 % 87 %

Eye-brow lower

Yes/No Word

76 %

Head: tilt side

Eye-brow lower

Yes/No Word

74 %

Negations:

YES/NO Questions:

Sample Results (2/4) SignStream Database

Page 29: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Sample Results (3/4) SignStream Database

WH-questions:

For more detailed results visit the following web page:http://cs-people.bu.edu/panagpap/Research/asl_mining.htm

Eye-brow lower

Wh-word

Head: jut forward

Wh-word

Eye-aperture: squint

Wh-word

Head: rapid shake

Wh-word85 %

56 %

51 %

85 %

Page 30: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Sample Results (4/4)Network Dataset

Page 31: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Related Work Problem of mining frequent itemsets and association rules was first

introduced by R. Agrawal and R. Srikant, 1994.

An extension to episodes (i.e. combinations of events with a partially

specified order) was proposed in [H. Mannila et. al. 1995].

Some efficient sequential pattern mining algorithms have been proposed

in [M. Zaki. et. al. 2001] and [J. Ayres et. al. 2002].

Closed sequential pattern mining algorithms presented in [X. Yan. et. al.

2003] and [J.Wang et. al. 2004].

Interval-based events introduced in [P. Kam et. Al. 2000], however

restricted to certain forms + apriori-based.

Page 32: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Conclusions The problem of mining frequent arrangements of temporal

intervals has been formally defined. Two efficient methods for solving the problem have been

discussed. Both methods use an arrangement enumeration tree to

discover the set of frequent arrangements. The DFS-based approach further improves performance over

BFS:

Longer arrangements are reached faster. The need to examine smaller subsets of these

arrangements is eliminated.

Page 33: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Future Work

Push additional constraints into the mining process:

Gap constraints.

Regular expression constraints.

Mine top-k frequent arrangements.

Mine frequent closed arrangements.

Apply other interestingness measures.

Page 34: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

EXTRA SLIDES

Page 35: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Applications American Sign Language databases

Extract frequent correlations between grammatical and syntactic structures + manual and gestural fields.

Network Monitoring: Analyze packet and router logs. Detect temporal relations of events occurring over time

periods. Patterns can be used for prediction and intrusion detection.

Biology: Find frequent overlapping regions of nucleotides in the

human gene.

Page 36: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Apply a closed sequential pattern mining algorithm*?

Noise again…

A

B

A

B

A

B

{Astart, Bstart, Aend, Bend}: 2/3

But also:

{Astart, Aend, Bend}: 3/3

Closed Sequential PatternMining Algorithm

*. J.Wang and J. Han. “Bide: Efficient mining of frequent closed sequences”. In Proc. of IEEE ICDE, pages 79–90, 2004.

Page 37: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

The ISIdList Structure (1/2) An ISIdList is defined for every arrangement generated

throughout the mining process. The ISIdList for an arrangement AA = { , R} in an e-

sequence database DD, has the following structure: Head: Arrangement representation using and R. A record for each e-sequence in the database that supports AA. Each record is of type (idid, intv-Listintv-List), where:

idid is the id of the e-sequence in DD. intv-List:intv-List:

set of intervals where AA occurs in the e-sequence A (for | | ≤ 2). set of pointers to records of ISIdLists of the second level (for | | > 2).

E

E

EE

Page 38: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

The ISIdList Structure (2/2) (Example)

Database D

id e-sequence

1

2

4

3

A [1, 3], B [1, 3], A [6, 12], B [8, 11], C [ 9, 10]

A [1, 2], B [2, 6], A [10, 12], B [11, 15], C [14, 17]

B [1, 3], A [4, 7], A [9, 11], B [11, 12] , C [12, 14]

B [1, 5], A [6, 14], B [7, 10], C [8, 9]

A

esid Intv-List

1

1

2

2

3

3

4

[1, 3]

[6, 12]

[1, 2]

[10, 12]

[4, 7]

[9, 11]

[6, 14]

B

esid

1

1

2

2

3

3

4

[1, 3]

[8, 11]

[2, 6]

[11, 15]

[1, 3]

[11, 12]

[1, 5]

Intv-List

4 [7, 10]

C

esid

1

2

3

4

[9, 10]

[14, 17]

[12, 14]

[8, 9]

Intv-List

Let DD consist of a set or e-sequences of event intervals with labels A, B, C.

The set of frequent 1 arrangements is {A, B, C}, with the following ISIdLists:

Page 39: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

BFS-based Approach

At each Step k: Use Tree to generate candidate arrangements:

Build N(k) from N(k-1). Construct IMk. For every 2-relation, point to the

second level of the Tree. Check support. If it satisfies min_sup, then add to

Fk. Continue with the rest of the Tree in a BFS order. If a node is found not to be frequent, do not expand

its sub-tree (Apriori Principle)3. Stop at step k, where Fk = empty.

3. R. Agrawal and R. Srikant. “Fast algorithms for mining association rules”. In Proc. of VLDB, pages 487-499, 1994.

Page 40: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

BFS-based Approach (1/4) DD: an input e-sequence database. FF: the complete set of frequent

arrangements. FFkk: the complete set of frequent k-

arrangements. CCkk: the current set of candidate k-

arrangements. min_supmin_sup: the minimum support threshold. ISIdList (A)ISIdList (A): the ISIdList of arrangement A.

Page 41: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

BFS-based Approach (2/4)

BFS:STEP 1: Find F1

Use Tree to generate C1

Build N(1). For each ni

1 in N(1): Build ISIdList (Ai), where Ai is the arrangement that

corresponds to ni1.

If the number of records in ISIdList (Ai) is at least min_sup,min_sup, then A is inserted into F1.

Page 42: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

BFS-based Approach (3/4)

BFS:STEP k: Find Fk

Use Tree to generate Ck

Build N(k) from N(k-1). Construct IMk.

For each node in IMk: Build ISIdList. If the number of records in the ISIdList is at least

min_sup,min_sup, insert arrangement into F1.

Continue with the rest of the Tree in a BFS order.

Page 43: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

BFS-based Approach (4/4)

Continue with the rest of the Tree in a BFS order.

If a node is found not to be frequent, do not expand its sub-tree (Apriori Principle)1.

Stop at step k, where Fk = empty.

1. R. Agrawal and R. Srikant. Fast algorithms for mining association rules. In proc. of VLDB, pages 487-499, 1994.

Page 44: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Hybrid DFS-based Approach

DFS is inappropriate:

For each node we would have to scan the database multiple

times to detect the 2-relations among the items in the node.

Though in BFS these relations are already available.

Generate the first two levels of the Tree using BFS.

Then use DFS.

Eliminates multiple database scans, since now the 2-relations are

available.

Page 45: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

BFS-based Approach (1/2) Creating a 2-arrangement (Example)

A

esid Intv-List

1

1

2

2

3

3

4

[1, 3]

[6, 12]

[1, 2]

[10, 12]

[4, 7]

[9, 11]

[6, 14]

B

esid

1

1

2

2

3

3

4

[1, 3]

[8, 11]

[2, 6]

[11, 15]

[1, 3]

[11, 12]

[1, 5]

Intv-List

4 [7, 10]

Meet (A, B)

esid

2

3

[1, 2] , [2, 6]

Intv-List

[9, 11] , [11, 12]

Follow (A, B)

esid

1

2

[1, 3] , [8, 11]

Intv-List

[1, 2] , [11, 15]

3 [4, 7] , [11, 12]

{A, B}

Contain (A, B)

esid

1 [6, 12] , [8, 11]

Intv-List

4 [6, 14] , [7, 10]

Page 46: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

BFS-based Approach (2/2)Creating a 3-arrangement (Example)

{A, B, C}

Contain (A, B) * Contain (A, C) * Contain (B, C)

esid

1

4

Intv-List

Contain (A, B)

esid

1 [6, 12] , [8, 11]

Intv-List

4 [6, 14] , [7, 10]

Contain (B, C)

esid

1

4

[8, 11] , [9, 10]

Intv-List

[7, 10] , [8, 9]

Contain (A, C)

esid

1

4

[6, 12] , [9, 10]

Intv-List

[6, 14] , [8, 9]

Page 47: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Experimental SetupReal Datasets

Dataset 1: Utterances of WH-Questions.

Size: 73 e-sequences.

# of labels: 400.

Dataset 2: SignStream Database.

Size: 884 e-sequences.

# of labels: 400.

Page 48: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Related Work (1/2) Problem of frequent itemset mining first introduced in:

R. Agrawal and R. Srikant. Fast algorithms for mining association rules. In proc. of VLDB, pages 487-499, 1994.

An extension to episodes (i.e. combinations of events with a partially specified order) was proposed in: H. Mannila, H. Toivonen, and A. Verkamo. Discovering Frequent episodes in

sequences. In Proc. of ACM SIGKDD, pages 210–215, 1995.

The Itemset Enumeration Tree was described in: R. J. Bayardo. Efficiently mining long patterns from

databases. In Proc. of ACM SIGMOD, pages 85–93, 1998.

Some efficient sequential pattern mining algorithms have been proposed in: M. Zaki. Spade: An efficient algorithm for mining sequences. Machine Learning,

40:31–60, 2001. J. Ayres, J. Gehrke, T. Yiu, and J. Flannick. Sequential pattern mining using a bitmap

representation. In Proc. of ACM SIGKDD, pages 429–435, 2002.

Page 49: Panagiotis Papapetrou, George Kollios, Stan Sclaroff, Dimitrios Gunopulos

Related Work (2/2) Closed frequent itemset mining algorithms:

J. Pei, J. Han, and R.Mao. Closet: An efficient algorithm form ining frequent closed itemsets. In Proc. of DMKD, pages 11–20, 2000.

M. Zaki and C. Hsiao. Charm: An efficient algorithm for closed itemset mining. In Proc. of SIAM, pages 457–473, 2002.

Closed sequential pattern mining: X. Yan, J. Han, and R. Afshar. Clospan: Mining closed sequential patterns in large

databases. In Proc. of SDM, 2003. J.Wang and J. Han. Bide: Efficient mining of frequent closed sequences. In Proc. of

IEEE ICDE, pages 79–90, 2004. Mining association rules in temporal and spatio-temporal databases:

T. Abraham and J. F. Roddick. Incremental meta-mining from large temporal data sets. In ER ’98: Proceedings of the Workshops on Data Warehousing and Data Mining , pages 41–54, 1999.

X. Chen and I. Petrounias. Mining temporal features in association rules. In Proc. of PKDD, pages 295–300, London, UK, 1999. Springer-Verlag.

I. Tsoukatos and D. Gunopulos. Efficient mining of spatiotemporal patterns. In Proc. of the SSTD, pages 425–442, 2001.

Discovering temporal patterns of Interval-based Events: P. Kam and A. W. Fu. Discovering temporal patterns of Interval-based Events. In Proc.

of the DaWak, pages 317–326, London, UK, 2000. Springer-Verlag.