part i. the emergence of degree-granting biomedical ... · pdf filethe emergence of...
TRANSCRIPT
Part I. The Emergence of Degree-Granting Biomedical Engineering
Programs in Sub-Saharan Africa
INTRODUCTION
The disability-adjusted life-year (DALY) is definedas the overall health and life expectancy of differentcountries expressed as the number of years of life lostdue to ill health, disability or early death. An excellentinteractive 2012 world map of each country’s DALYexpressed in years lost per 100,000 population isavailable from the World Health Organization(WHO).7 Canada, the U.S. and Mexico, respectively,had DALYs in 2012 of 18,838 (15th), 22,775 (33rd)and 26,763 (50th) years lost. The global average in2012 was 38,780, essentially the same as Iraq (108th)and Bangladesh (109th). In contrast, not one countryin continental Sub-Saharan Africa had a DALY in2012 of less than the global average, and all of thecountries that had DALYs of greater than60,000 years lost were Sub-Saharan except for Afgha-nistan and Haiti. While there has been a reduction ofthe relative Sub-Saharan DALY numbers and someshifting in the rankings since the original 2000 WHOcensus,7 the overall global DALY picture for Sub-Saharan Africa remains the most challenging.
Characteristic of Sub-Saharan medical clinics is theaccumulation of mostly routine instrumentation thatlies unused or in disrepair due to a lack of a skilledworkforce and/or readily available spare parts.2,4
Correcting this situation is largely the role of thebiomedical engineer (BME). According to the 2016WHO comprehensive report Human Resources forMedical Devices: The Role of Biomedical Engineers,again the U.S., Mexico and Canada, respectively,have 49, 24 and 18 BMEs per 1 M people; whereasBotswana is the only Sub-Saharan country withgreater than 10 BMEs per 1 M people.9 In fact, 68%of Sub-Saharan countries have one or less BMEs per1 M people, and many countries have none at all.9 Ina promising trend, several Sub-Saharan universitieshave responded to this disparity by starting BMEprograms and coalescing into professional BMEsocieties.
The above referenced 2016 WHO report, a mustread for those interested in increasing BME capacity inlow- and middle-income countries (LMICs),9 is acomprehensive description of the BME context in thesix WHO global regions. Appendix 2 of the report lists
52 Sub-Saharan institutions that have self-reported asoffering BME programs starting in the early 2000s.Seventeen of these programs list bachelor’s degrees inBME, and six list graduate BME degrees. Another 24programs only listed ‘‘other’’, which is commonly atwo-year or less biomedical technology degree pro-gram, similar to an associates degree or certificate inthe U.S. However, verifying the existence of theseprograms and learning about their curriculum can befrustrating to an individual or institution interested inestablishing a partnership with a Sub-Saharan BMEprogram.
This manuscript is the first of two editorials thatapprises the U.S. biomedical engineering (BME)community of the growing presence of BME programsin Sub-Saharan Africa (Part I) by providing verifiedreferencing of viable BME programs. The second edi-torial (Part II) encourages U.S. BME programs to getinvolved in their emergence through collaborativeeducational partnering.
SUB-SAHARAN BME PROGRAMS
The WHO Global BME Survey lists all self-re-ported BME educational programs in 2015.8 Twenty-two of these programs were housed in Sub-Saharanuniversities that use English as the language ofinstruction. Generic Internet searches were conductedto learn more about the characteristics of these pro-grams. Table 1 lists the bachelor’s and graduate de-gree granting BME programs that could be verifiedthrough this search. Programs without Internet evi-dence of existence were not included. Note: Five ofthe BME programs in Table 1 did not self-report forthe WHO survey, but were included as they becameknown to the authors. Note: the composition of website addresses can be quite fluid; this table designatesthem as of 2017.
PROFESSIONAL SUB-SAHARAN BME
SOCIETIES
The need for regular equipment procurement,management and repair (EPMR) of medical equip-
Annals of Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 45, No. 10, October 2017 (� 2017) pp. 2265–2268
DOI: 10.1007/s10439-017-1897-2
0090-6964/17/1000-2265/0 � 2017 Biomedical Engineering Society
2265
TABLE1.
BachelorLevelandGraduate-D
egreegrantingBMEProgramsin
Sub-SaharanAfrica(M
ain
Source:WHO
GlobalBMESurvey8).
Institution
Location
BMEdegreesoffered
BMEWebsite
asof2017
Addis
AbabaInstitute
ofTechnology
Addis
Ababa,Ethiopia
BS,MS
http://www.aau.edu.et/aait/academics/center-of-
biomedical-engineering/
Jim
maUniversity
Jim
ma,Ethiopia
BS
http://www.ju.edu.et/beco/node/72?q=node/78
AllNationsUniversity
Koforidua,Ghana
BS
http://www.anuc.edu.gh/home/academics/15/27/
academics.htm
l
KwameNkrumahUniversityofScience
andTechnology
Kumasi,Ghana
BS
https://www.archive.knust.edu.gh/pages/
index.php?site
id=
admissions&page=co
urse_detail&
progtype=ugd&id=471
UniversityofGhana
Accra,Ghana
BS,ME,MP,PhD
http://www.ug.edu.gh/biomed-eng/
ValleyView
University
Adentan,Ghana
C,D,BS
https://www.vvu.edu.gh/in
dex.php/biomedical-engineering
TechnicalUniversityMombasa
Mombasa
,Kenya
C,D,BS,BT
http://www.tum.ac.ke/departments/m
edical-engineering
Kenya
ttaUniversity
Nairobi,Kenya
BS
http://www.ku.ac.ke/schools/engineering/programmes/
undergraduate-programmes/91-programmes/285-
bachelor-of-science-biomedical-engineering.htm
l
MalawiUniversity
ofScience
andTechnology
Thyolo,Malawi
BS
http://www.m
ust.ac.m
w/department/engineering
UniversityofMalawi,ThePolytechnic
Blantyre,Malawi
D,BS
http://www.poly.ac.mw/faculty/engineering/
Bells
UniversityofTechnology
Ota,Nigeria
BE
http://www.bellsuniversity.edu.ng/admissions/
undergraduates/index.php?page=AvailableProgrammes
FederalUniversityofTechnology,Owerri
Owerri,Nigeria
BT,MS,PhD
http://www.futo.edu.ng/Schools/Health
/Biomedical.php
UniversityofLagos
Lagos,Nigeria
BS,MS
http://www.basmed.unilag.edu.ng/index.php/biomedical-
engineering-unit/
UniversityofPretoria
Pretoria,Republic
ofSouth
Africa
MS,PhD
http://www.up.ac.za/bioengineering
UniversityofCapeTown
CapeTown,Republic
ofSouth
Africa
MS,PhD
http://www.bme.uct.ac.za/bme/bme-programmes
UniversityofWitw
atersrand
Johannesburg,Republic
ofSouth
Africa
BS
https://www.wits.ac.za/course-finder/undergraduate/ebe/
biomedical-engineering/
Make
rere
University
Kampala,Uganda
BS
https://www.courses.m
ak.ac.ug/programmes/bachelor-
science-biomedical-engineering-0
Mbarara
University
ofScienceandTechnology
Mbarara,Uganda
BS
http://www.fast.must.ac.ug/about/
department/
department-of-biomedical-sciences-and-engineering
DDiploma,CCertificate,BEBachelorofEngineering,BSBachelorofScience
,BTBachelorofTechnology,
MSMasters
ofScience
,MEMasters
ofEngineering,MPMasters
ofPhilosophy,
PhD
Doctoraldegree.
B. PLOSS AND W. REICHERT2266
ment in a clinical setting is substantial in Sub-SaharanAfrica, and thus the current and primary emphasis ofmost Sub-Saharan BME programs. Consequently,many Sub-Saharan undergraduates pursuing a bache-lors degree in BME see EPMR as their likely careerpath.5,6 However, focusing solely on EPMR and justincreasing the pool of Sub-Saharan BMEs alone willnot necessary lead to increased employment opportu-nity without proper in-country vision and leadership.
Another encouraging trend is the growth of Sub-Saharan BME societies that connect professionals andstudents of mutual interests. Table 2 lists the BMEsocieties in Sub-Saharan Africa according to the WHOGlobal BME Survey for which viable web sites wereidentified. Also included are two Pan-Africa collabo-ratives and some additional societies known to theauthors, but not listed by the WHO BME survey.8
Like the Biomedical Engineering Society (BMES) andthe American Institute for Medical and BiologicalEngineering (AIMBE) in the U.S., Sub-Saharan BMEsocieties are able to advocate for curricular priorities,funding, regulation, and intellectual property policiesthat foster modern training and health technologyinnovation. The existence of BME student organiza-tions is also an important professional leveragingactivity, such as the Makerere University BiomedicalStudent Association and Engineering World Health(EWH) chapters at Makerere University and theUniversity of Ghana.1,3
CONCLUSION
The current manuscript, Part I, provides a verifiedlisting of degree granting Sub-Saharan BME programsthat is also limited to English-speaking institutions tomatch the U.S. language of instruction. These pro-grams and the associated societies provide an oppor-tunity for U.S. BME programs to partner with BMEprograms in Sub-Saharan Africa, thus broadeningcurricular capabilities and professional expectations.BME institutions in resource-limited environments areoften seeking opportunities for more up to date con-tent, expansion of course coverage, and obtainingcollaborations that lead to additional training andresearch support. These are opportunities that U.S.BME programs are well positioned to provide.
Part II presents illustrative examples of U.S. BMEprograms that have established collaborative partner-ships mainly in Malawi, Nigeria, Ghana and Uganda,as well as specific recommendations to consider whenplanning an education partnership with a Sub-SaharanBME program.
TABLE2.
Sub-SaharanBME
Societies(M
ain
Source:WHO
GlobalBMESurvey8).
Country
Society
name
Website
Ethiopia
EthiopianBiomedicalEngineeringAssociatio
nhttps://www.facebook.com/EthioBMES/
Gambia
Gambia
BiomedicalEngineeringTechnologists
Association
http://www.abetgambia.blogspot.com/2011/08/association-of-
biomedical-engineering.htm
l
Ghana
GhanaSociety
ofBiomedicalEngineers
http://www.ghanabiomedicalengineers.org
Cote
D’Ivoire
Syn
dicatNationaldesBiomedicauxdeCote
D’Ivoire
https://www.facebook.com/282225361904170/photos/pcb.7918
25117610856/791825070944194/?type=3
Kenya
Associatio
nofMedicalEngineeringofKenya
http://www.amek.or.ke/in
dex.php
Nigeria
NigerianInstitute
forBiomedicalEngineering
http://www.nigerianbme.org
PanAfrica
AfricanUnionofBiomedicalEngineeringandSciences
http://www.africanbmes.org
PanAfrica
AfricanBiomedicalEngineeringConsortium
http://www.abec-africa.org
Republic
ofSouth
Africa
South
AfricaChapter,IEEEEngineeringin
Medicine
andBiologySociety
http://www.embs.org/m
ember-communities/chapters/
Republic
ofSouth
Africa
ClinicalEngineeringAssociatio
nSouth
Africa
http://www.ceasa-national.org.za
Uganda
UgandaNationalAssociationforMedicalandHospital
Engineering
http://www.unamhe.org
Part I. The Emergence of Degree-Granting Biomedical Engineering Program 2267
REFERENCES
1 EWH. Overview & Locations: List of Active Chapters.Engineering World Health, 2017. (http://www.ewh.org/university-chapters/chp-overview).2Howitt, P., A. Darzi, G. Z. Yang, H. Ashrafian, R. Atun, J.Barlow, A. Blakemore, A. M. Bull, J. Car, L. Conteh, G. S.Cooke, N. Ford, S. A. Gregson, K. Kerr, D. King, M.Kulendran, R. A. Malkin, A. Majeed, S. Matlin, R. Mer-rifield, H. A. Penfold, S. D. Reid, P. C. Smith, M. M. Ste-vens, M. R. Templeton, C. Vincent, and E. Wilson.Technologies for global health. Lancet 380:507–535, 2012.3Makerere University Biomedical Engineering Students’Association - mubesa. Facebook (https://www.facebook.com/mubesamuk/).4Malkin, R. A. Design of health care technologies for thedeveloping world. Annu Rev Biomed Eng 9:567–587, 2007.5Mohedas, I., E. E. Kaufmann, S. R. Daly, and K. H.Sienko. Ghanaian undergraduate biomedical engineeringstudents’ perceptions of their discipline and career oppor-tunities. Glob J Eng Educ 17:34–41, 2015.6Mullally, S., and M. Frize. Survey of clinical engineeringeffectiveness in developing world hospitals: equipment re-sources, procurement and donations. Conf Proc IEEE EngMed Biol Soc 4499–4502:2008, 2008.
7WHO. Age-standardized disability adjusted life year:DALY: rates (per 100,000 population), 2012. World HealthOrganization, 2014 (http://www.who.int/gho/mortality_burden_disease/countries/situation_trends_dalys/en/).8WHO. BME Global Survey. 2015 (http://www.who.int/medical_devices/support/en/).9WHO. Human resources for medical devices: the role ofbiomedical engineers. In: WHO Medical device technicalseries. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2017(http://www.who.int/medical_devices/publications/hr_med_dev_bio-engineers/en/).
William Reichert
Department of Biomedical Engineering,Duke University, Durham NC U.S.Electronic mail: [email protected]
Brittany Ploss
Department of Biomedical Engineering,Duke University, Durham NC U.S.
B. PLOSS AND W. REICHERT2268