participatory rural appraisal report of khandali village ... filetrend analysis matrix ranking venn...
TRANSCRIPT
For office use only
Participatory Rural Appraisal Report of
Khandali Village, Tal. Mohol, Dist. Solapur
Summarized by Krishi Vigyan Kendra, Mohol
Solapur – 413213, M.S.
2012-13
KRISHI VIGYAN KENDRA, MOHOL
CONTENTS
Sr. No. Content
1 Introduction
2 Bench mark survey
Climate and Land Holding Pattern
Soil Type and Soil and water conservation structures
Irrigation/ water Source
Natural Vegetation
Cropping Pattern
3 PRA
Village map
Social map
Soil Map and Village Transect
Time line
Trend analysis
Matrix ranking
Venn diagram
List Of Participated Farmers in PRA
4 SWOT and POIN Analysis
5 Seasonability
6 Major Cropping Pattern
7 Major problems identified
8 Problem Cause Diagram
9 Farmers – Scientist interaction for action plan development
10 PRA photo
1
Mahatma Phule Krishi Vidyapeeth Krishi Vigyan Kendra, Mohol
Tal. Mohol, Dist. Solapur Participatory Rural Appraisal (PRA) - 2012
Village Khandali 1. Introduction:
Krishi Vigyan Kendra, Mohol established in year, 2011 for technology
dissemination though various agricultural extension activities. Participatory Rural
Appraisal survey is an important mean to identify the problem constraints and need of the
farmers through their own involvement. Though this Krishi Vigyan Kendra comes under
scarcity zone of Maharashtra and mainly work for dryland agriculture, the village
Khandali Tal. Mohol has maximum irrigation potential. Hence Krishi Vigyan Kendra has
to focus on both dryland and irrigated technologies.
Village Khandali comes in Mohol tahsil situated near Pune- Solapur National
Highway- 9 with approach road of 8 Km and it is 25 Km away from this Krishi Vigyan
Kendra, Mohol. The village Khandali popularly grown of Banana and pomegranate along
with cash crop Sugarcane and cereals like Maize, Sorghum, Wheat etc. pulses and oilseeds
are grown to some extent. There is opportunity for enhancing crop production with fruit
and vegetable processing.
Facilitators: 1 Dr. D. R. Nandre. 2 Dr. P. G. Chavan 3 Mr. D. N. Kshirsagar 4 Dr. N.S. Deshmukh 5 Mr. A. G. Dighe 6 Ms. S. B. Kakade
2
2. Bench mark survey of Khandali 2.1 Climate:
The climate of the area is semi-arid tropical. Generally, South-West monsoon starts
from June and peak rainfall occurs in July and August. Usually there are short and long
dry spells occurs between the outset and station of rain.
Annual Rainfall Approximate 537 mm
Period June to Oct
Temperature Maximum 40.40c
Minimum 120c
Distribution:
Month Temperature
(OC) Humidity
(%) Rainfall (mm)
Maxi Min Morning Evening
Jan 30.8 12.32 59.2 28.2 0.0
Feb 35 14.42 54.75 30.25 0.0
Mar 38.2 16.22 33.8 17.85 0.0
Apr 40.26 23.5 53.64 28.28 8.2
May 40.42 23.4 71.5 38 7.6
Jun 36.8 78.625 77.5 46.5 65.3
July 33.36 22.88 79.4 53.6 55.8
Aug 33.62 21.82 79 53.5 39.0
Sept 33 21.9 75.25 51 35.8
Oct 32.32 19.42 72.6 47.2 148.4
Nov 31.57 15.1 61.25 37.5 3.4
Dec 31.7 13.175 58.25 34.5 0.0
Reference: Agril. Research Station, Mohol , year:2012
2.2 Land Holding Pattern:
Sr. No. Holding (ha) No. of cultivators
1 Small (<1 Ha) 286
2 Marginal(1- 2 Ha) 840
3 Large(>2 Ha) 170
3
2.3 Soil Types:
Soil of Khandali village varies from light to medium and medium to deep with
light soil- 40 %, Medium type of soil- 35 % and deep soil of 25 %.
Light soil : < 30 cm depth (40%)
Medium soil : 30-45 cm depth (35%)
Heavy/ Deep soil : > 45 cm (25%)
2.4 Soil and Water conservation structures:
1. Vegetative bund
2. Compartment bunding
3. Nala Bund
4. Earthen Bund
5. Percolation tank
6. Cement plug
7. Check dam
2.5 Irrigation/water source/facilities:
Hand pump 28
Well : 600
Bore well : 1150
Farm Pond
Nala Bunding
Cement Plug
:
:
:
02
1200 ha.
02
2.6 Natural vegetation:
Forest Species : Babool, Tamarind etc.
Trees : Acacia spp., Ber
Shrubs : Euphorbia spp., Cassia etc.
Weeds /floara : Harali, syprus, Congress, Chikta, Kena, tansad
4
2.7 Cropping pattern:
3. PRA at Bitale, Tal Mohol, Dist. Solapur
The different tools used for PRA Village Map Social Map Soil map Transect walk Time line Trend analysis Venn diagram Matrix ranking
3.1 Village map
The cadastral map of the village Khandali Tal. Mohol was collected from Talathi
Office,Khandali
.
Season Cereals Pulses Oilseeds Fruits Vegetables Fodder crop
Kharif Maize, sugarcane
Pigeon Pea, Moth bean, green gram
-- Pomegranate Anola, Grapes, Banana, Mango, citrus, custard apple, watermelon, muskmelon
Tomato, flower, Brinjal, pumpkin, Methi, Coriander, onion
Maize,
Rabi Wheat, maize, sorghum, Sugarcane
Gram Groundnut Ghas
Summer Maize - Groundnut
5
3.2 Social map
The village Khandali is located near national highway -9. In the center of the
village, the houses of villagers are located. There are common well for drinking water in
the village. The temple of goddess ‘Yamai Mata’ of Hemand Panthi type is located at the
center of the village.
1. Population : 4542 (male 2380, female 2162)
2.Educational facilities
Nursery/ Anganwadi : 04
Primary School : 04
Secondary School : 01
Higher Secondary : Modnimb (12 km.), Pandharpur (28 km.)
Senior College : Modnimb (12 km.), Pandharpur (28 km.)
3. Drinking water availability : Pipe line(01), Well (01), Boar (42),Hand
pump etc.
4. Temple : 08, Hanuman, Sonamai
5. Material availability in the village
a. Grocery : In Village- 07
b. Dal mill : 10
6
c. Seeds/ Fertilizers
Krishi Seva Kendra : 04
d. Insecticides and fungicides
Krishi Seva Kendra : 04
6.Farm implements
1.Tractor : 50 2.Seed Drill : 01
3.Rotavator : 25 4.Sprayer
(Manual / Engine )
: 500
5. Thresher : 10 Power tiller : 10
7.Medical facilities
Name of institute /organization In Village Nearby Village Dist. from Village
a.Primary Health Center: -- : patkul 15 km
b. b.Veterinary Health Center: 01 : -- --
8.Marketing facility
a. In Village/ Nearby Village -- : Modnimb 12 km
b. Tehsil/District -- : APMC, Solapur 60 km
9.Availability of technology/ knowledge source
a. Information regarding agricultural
practices
: Krishi Vigyan Kendra, Mohol
News Paper, Agrowan
10.Industries
Dairy : 06
11. Self Help Group 05
3.3 Soil Map of village Khandali:
The Soil map indicating type of soils available on cultivable land in village.
7
3.3 Transect of village:
The transect walk was carried out with the villagers from North to South and East
to West direction. The various item viz, topography, irrigation source, crops and cropping
system, trees and fruits trees etc. were identified by observatory method during walk. The
details given below
Topography Leveled Slope 1 to 2 % Slope 2 to 4 % Slightly sloppy 2 to 3 %
Soil type Medium to deep
Medium Heavy Soil shallow Soil
Irrigation source
Well, Borewell
Well, Percolation tank, Borewell
Well, Borewell, farm pond
Well, Borewell, cement bund , Nala bund
Crops and Cropping system
Sugarcane, Onion, Maize, Sorghum, Watermelon.
Maize, Tomato, Wheat, Gram
Sugarcane Onion, Maize
Jowar, Gram
Trees
Neem, Babul, Acacia sp.
Neem, Nilgiri, Rain tree ,
Acacia sp. Hiwar
Neem, Babul
Fruit trees Banana, Mango, Ber
Pomegranate, Turmarind, Ber, Mango, Lime
Mango, Banana Ber, Pomegranate
Weeds
Harali, Parthenium
Parthenium, Pathri, Cockscomb, Kena
Ekdandi, Parthenium , Lawala,
Harali. Aghada, Kunda.
Fodder crop Lucerne, berseem
Lucerne, Maize, Fodder Sorghum
Maize, Sugarcane
Pasture land
Pest and diseases
Wooly aphids & Thrips, Red nut, wilt, Shoot Fly
Rust, Pod boron Wilt, Aphid
Thrips, Rust, Stem borer
Pod borer, Shoot fly, Chikta
Animals Cow Khillar, Jerssey, HF, Local Buffalo Pandharpuri Goat Osmanabadi, Local Poultry Local
8
3.4 Time line:-
The major events remembered by the villagers was drawn with the help of key
informants.
Year Major events 1920 Bicycle 1950 Radio 1950 Motorcycle
1950,2011 Nala Bund 1950 Z. P. Primary School 1956 Establishment of Grampanchyat. 1960 Chemical Fertilizer 1972 Electricity 1972 Drinking Water Well and Pipeline
1972,2003,2012,1998,2007 Famine 1975 Hand Pump 1975 Thresher 1980 Crossbreed Cow 1985 Farm Pond 1985 Television 1992 Drip irrigation
1992,2003 Percolation Tank 1993 Earth Quake 1994 Tractor
1997-98 Telephone 1998 Bio-Gas 1998 Use of Improved seed 2000 Mobiles 2000 Agril. Service Center 2000 Cement Plug 2005 SHG 2009 Pest Occurrence
9
3.5 Trend analysis: The trend analysis in respect of rainfall, water table, cropping pattern, area of various crops grown during the year, livestock etc. was done with the help of the farmer participants involved in PRA.
Particulars 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010
Rainfall * * - * * * -
Kharif cropping area - - - - 00 000 000
Rabi cropping area ### ### ### ### ## ### ###
Horticultural Crops
Banana - - - - - - -
Pomegranate Vv vvv vvv Vvv vvv vvv vvv
Onion OOO OOO OOO - - - -
Ber >>> >>> >>> - - - -
Area under various crops
Sugarcane $ $$ $$ $$$ $$$ $$$$ $$$$$
Rabi Sorghum @@@@ @@@@ @@@ @@@ @@ @@ @
Maize X XX XX XXX XXX XXXX XXXX
Tomato - - - - II II III
Attack of Insect Pest ! ! ! ! !!!! !! !!
Livestock
Cow
Desi AAA AAA AAA AAA AAA A A
Crossbreed - < < < < <<< <<<<
Buffalo
Local BBB BBB BBB BB BB B B
3.6 Matrix ranking:
The Matrix ranking was completed with the help of the participatory farmers in
respect of various crops, varieties, sheep and goat and the information is given below.
1. Matrix ranking of crops:
Sr. No.
Particulars/ Crop
cereals pulses Oilseed Vegetable Cash crop Fruit crop
1 Food 5 3 3 4 2 3 2 Fodder 5 4 3 2 5 2 3 Expenditure
on fertilizers 3 3 3 3 5 5
4 Market price 3 4 4 4 4 4 5 Income 3 4 5 4 5 5 Rank II III III IV I II
It is observed that Cash crop is major crop followed by Cereals and fruit crop.
2. Matrix ranking of Sugarcane:
Sr. No. Particulars / Varieties 86032 671 94005
1 Availability of planting material
4 3 2
2 Crop duration 4 4 3
3 Expenditure on fertilizers
4 4 4
4 Ratoon yield 5 4 3 5 Higher Yield 5 3 3 Rank I II III
3. Matrix ranking of maize:
Sr.No. Particulars / Varieties Parmeshwar Pinecle Dicalb 1 Grain yield 4 4 4 2 Fodder yield 5 4 3 3 Drought resistant 4 4 4 4 Fodder quality 5 3 3 5 Market price 5 4 4 Rank I II III
4. Matrix ranking of Tomato.
Sr.No. Particulars / Varieties Abhinav Shaktiman 955
50/ Namdhari Us- 3383
1 Plant growth 3 3 4 2 Fruit size 4 3 4 3 Pest and disease resistance 3 3 4 4 Yield 4 4 5 Rank I III II
5. Matrix ranking of Onion
Sr.No. Particulars / Varieties Abhinav Shaktiman 955
50/ Namdhari Us- 3383
1 Duration 3 3 4 2 Expenditure 3 3 4 3 Yield 4 3 3 4 Water 4 4 3 5 Quality 5 3 4 6 Storage 4 3 3 Rank I III II
3.7 Venn diagram:
The institutional relationship diagram indicating, how close the contact and
cooperation between those organizations and groups is prepared with the help of farmers.
This indicates the importance of the various individuals and the institutions in and outside
the village with regard to a phenomenon related to agriculture. The importance of various
organizations/ individuals for a phenomenon is indicated in terms of size of the circles and
distance from the centre.
VENN DIAGRAM OF VILLAGE, Bitale , Tal. Mohol , Dist. Solapur
Village Khandali Tal. Mohol
Veternary Clinic
,
APMC Modnimb
Krishi SevaKendra
PHC
GramPanchayt
KVK, ARS
Mohol
Sugarcane factory
25km
15km
12km
km
Sugar FactoryLoknete
15km
3.8 Farmers participated in PRA:
Shri.Uttam Kashinath Mane Shri. Jaywant Sambhaji Vyavhare Shri. Arun Hanumant Mule Shri. Rahul Subhash Patane Shri. Dhanaji Babru Dongare Shri. Shivaji Datta Mule Shri. Maruti Datta Shrikhande Shri. Manik Maruti Shrikhande Shri. Hanumant Maruti Shrikhande Shri. Shrimant Bajrang Srikhande Shri. Krishna Dagdu Darphalkar Shri. Ankush Ramchandra Shrikhande Shri. Pralhad Mule Shri. Janardhan Shivaji Bhosale Shri. Arvind Balkrishna Patil Shri. Bhalchandra Bhagvant Tarate Shri. Ganesh Dattatray Mule Shri. Bharat Sadashiv Bhosale Shri. Kiran Parameshwar Mule Shri. Vishnu Maruti Mule Shri. Brahmadev Maruti Mule Shri. Nitin C. Mule Shri. Mahadev Dattray Bhange Shri. Shahu Datttray Bhosale Shri. Vikram Datttray Bhosale Shri. Dipak hari Mane Shri. Nandkumar Ananda Mule Shri. Samadhan Hanumant Asade Shri. Suryakant Narayan Joshi Shri. Kantilal Manik Dongare Shri. Anurat Shivaji More Shri. Maruti Mule Shri. Suresh Laxshman Mule Shri. Satyavan Mule Shri. Shivaji Govind Mule
4 .1 SWOT analysis of village: S- Strength, W- Weaknesses, O- Opportunity, T- Threats Strength:
1. Use of drip irrigation system on large scale. 2. Positive attitude towards fruit crop. 3. Availability use of farm implements. 4. Diversified agro climatic situation. 5. Diversified farming system. 6. Greater participation in social activities. 7. Positive attitude towards dairy enterprise. 8. Adoption of improved technology and post harvest management. 9. Soil suitable for all type of crops.
Weaknesses: 1. Unawareness about IPM, IDM.. 2. Lack of knowledge about INM. 3. Lack of knowledge about scientific feeding management to livestock. 4. Unskilled marketing. 5. Less important to expenditure incurred on labour and other inputs..
Opportunities:
1. Scope for increasing efficiency of fertilizer use. 2. Scope for developing fertigation techniques. 3. Scope for increasing area under pulses and oilseeds crops. 4. Scope for developing agro base enterprises, value addition. 5. Scope for enterprunrship development.
Threats: 1. Uncertainty of rainfall 2. Discontinuity in electricity 3. Indiscriminate use of fertilizers lead to soil degradation. 4. Unavailability of storage facility.
4.2 POIN analysis
Sr.No. Problem Opportunity Issues Needs 1 Lack of Knowledge about
integrated approach Regarding integrated approach of dryland and irrigation technology
Water conservation devices, proper tools and techniques for farming
Gatcharcha Demonstration Exposure visit
2 Communication gap among farmers for adopting new technology
Formation of cluster approach and farmers club
Limited approach , less initiative
Exposure visit Group discussion Gatcharcha
3 Less participation of farm woman in decision making
Increasing participation of farm woman in decision making
Less education, Male dominant society
Formation of SHG Extension programme
4 Marginal productivity enhancing crop yield through adoption of new technology
Traditional Farming practices, Lack of knowledge about IPM, INM
Training Exposure visit Kisan mela
5 Minimum use of quality fodder for milch animal
Introduction of improved variety of fodder crop
Traditional feeding approach, open grazing, low milk yield, low fat percentage
Demonstration Training Gatcharcha Campaigning
6 Lack of knowledge about processing of value addition of agricultural produce
Promotion of agro base processing enterprise
Post harvest losses, low risk ability towards Capital Investment economic status
Training Exposure visits Gatcharcha Exhibition
5.1 Seasonability of weather:
Month Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
Rainfall - - - - - - - - *** **** - -
Temperature * *** **** **** **** ** ** ** * * * *
Humidity ** ** * * * ** ** ** **** *** *** **
5.2 Seasonability of crop:
Crop Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
Sugarcane 80 % 20%
Maize
Tomato
Banana
Onion
Pomegranate
5.3 Seasonability of animal diseases:
Particular Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
H.S
B. Q.
FMD
Diarshea
5.4Seasonability of pest and disease:
Crop Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
Sugarcane
Sorghum
Pomegranate
Onion
Tomato
Banana (June- July planting)
6. Major cropping pattern:
1. Banana based production system 2. Pomegranate based production system 3. Sugarcane based cropping system 4. Maize based cropping system 5. Dairy based production system
Wooly Aphid
Top Shoot Borer
Red rot
Shoot fly
Chikta
Oily spot
Thrips
Fruit borer
Leaf curl
Fruit borer
Leaf curl
Steam borer
7. Major problems identified:
1. Agronomy
1. Fertilizers unavailability at proper time.
2. Indiscriminate use of fertilizers.
3. Less use of biofertilizers
4. Unawareness about INM practices.
5. No proper irrigation management.
6. Improper management practices for agronomical crops.
7. Traditional method of sowing and planting followed
2. Horticulture
1. Improper Disease management
2. Unawareness about INM.
3. Improper use of insecticide, pesticide.
4. Unawareness about bahar management.
5. Lack of knowledge about pruning.
3. Livestock
1. Unawareness about mineral mixture feeding.
2. Low milk yield.
3. Lack of knowledge about improved varieties of green fodder.
4. Lack of knowledge about animal disease and their remedies.
4. Soil Science
1. Less use of soil and water conservation practices.
2. Unawareness about soil testing.
3. Unawareness about reclamation of problematic soils.
5. Food science and technology
1. Lack of knowledge about post harvest handling
2. No value addition.
3. Scope for food and V processing
6. Agriculture Extension
1. Less participation in technology adoption.
2. Technical gap among farmers.
8. Problem cause diagram: a. Problem cause diagram for low yield in sugarcane:
Less use of modern Technologies
Unawareness
Lack of knowledge
Lack of INM
Practices
b. Problem cause diagram for low yield in Maize:
Unawareness about Diversified approach
Lack of knowledge
Improper plant spacing
Lack of knowledge
Lack of soil testing
Low yield in
sugarcane
Traditional irrigation management
Indiscriminate use of biofertilizers
Lack of set treatment
Low yield in ratoon
Low yield in Maize
No proper crop rotation
Uneven plant population
Imbalance nutrient supply
Monoculture
c. Problem cause diagram for low yield in Tomato:
Unawareness
Lack of plant protection
Measures/ seed treatment
Lack of knowledge
Unawareness about
IWM practices
Less use of
micronutrients
d. Problem Cause Diagram for low yield in Onion:
Less use of plant
protection measures Lack of knowledge
Lack of knowledge
about INM
Lack of knowledge
Low Yield in Tomato
Occurrence of pest and disease
Imbalance use of fertilizer
Improper irrigation
Use of local variety
Micronutrient deficiency
Low Yield in Onion
Improper nursery management
Less seedling treatment
Imbalance use of fertilizers
Occurrence of sucking pest
e. Problem cause diagram for low yield in pomegranate:
No proper spacing
Use of disease infected
material
Lack of knowledge
Unawareness
Lack of Knowledge
Lack of knowledge/
Poor economic status
f. Problem cause diagram for low yield in Banana:
Unawareness
Lack of pest and
Disease management
Lack of knowledge
Lack of IWM practice
Lack of knowledge
Low Yield in
Pomegranate
Incidence of pest and disease
Improper bahar management
No proper pruning techniques
Uneven plant population
Indiscriminate use of fertilizer/micronutrients
Low yield in
Banana
Occurrence of pest and diseases
Imbalance use of fertilizer
Improper use of irrigation water
Use of local snckers
Lack use of seed treatment
Indiscriminate use of irrigation water
9. Farmers – scientist’s interaction for action plan development:
An interactive session was conducted with the farmers of Khandali village during
the survey. The farmers with distinguished farming approach viz. crop component, Animal
Component, Horticulture and emerging entrepreneur. Participated actively for identifying
the constraints and need of farmers and the problems raised by them are given below-
Points raised by the farmers:-
Lack of seed treatment. Less use of biofertilizers. Improper method of planting. Availability of planting material/ use of local cultivar. Unawareness about dryland technologies. Unawareness about pruning techniques in orchards. Unavailability of quality fodder material. Unawareness about vaccination in animal. Lack of knowledge grading, packaging and processing of fruit and vegetables. Lack of knowledge about scientific feeding management. Unavailability of skilled labour. Lack of knowledge about fertigation techniques.
.