performing arts medicine msc”ιαλέξεις 2019/ht...development of a specific exercise...

92
PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC DIVISION OF SURGERY & INTERVENTIONAL SCIENCE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON www.ucl.ac.uk/surgery/courses/msc-performing-arts-medicine

Upload: others

Post on 25-Jul-2020

14 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE

MSCDIVISION OF SURGERY amp

INTERVENTIONAL SCIENCEUNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON

wwwuclacuksurgerycoursesmsc-performing-arts-medicine

Collaborations

bull Institute of Sport

Exercise and Health

bull British Association for Performing Arts Medicine

bull Royal National

Nose Ear amp Throat Hospital

Collaborations

bull English National Opera

bull Royal College of Music

bull National Centre

for Circus Arts

Collaborations

bull Royal Ballet

bull English National Ballet

bull British Institute

of Modern Music

Structure

bull Postgraduate Certificate (PG Cert) ndash 4 modules ndash 60 credits

bull Postgraduate Diploma (PG Dip) - 8 modules ndash 120 credits

bull Masters (MSc) ndash 8+1 modules ndash 180 credits

bull Full-time 1 year

bull Part-time 2 years

bull September start

bull Distance Learning

bull Short Courses

Κατηγοριες Μουσικων Οργανων και Μυοσκελετικες Αναφορες

bull Συντομη περιγραφη των κυριων μουσικων οργανων και των απαιτησεων τους

bull Οι μουσικοι της ορχηστρας η τοποθετηση τους και ο μαεστρος

bull Οι ιδιαιτεροτητες των μουσικων ποπ και ροκ

bull Αναφορα στις εργονομικες και φυσιολογικες διαδικασιες που επηρεαζουν και διαμορφωνουν τις μυοσκελετικες προσαρμογες των μουσικων

bull REFERENCES

bull BIRD HA (2016) Performing Arts Medicine in Clinical Practice 1st ed London Springer International Publishing

bull RAMELLA M et al (2014) Postural Disorders in Conservatory Students The Diesis Project Medical Problems of Performing Artists 29(1) pp 19

Ergonomics

bull Instrumentalists come in all sorts of shapes and sizes

bull Instruments come in specific shapes and sizes

bull So instrumentalists have to adapt to their instruments often playing them for long periods in un-ergonomic positions

SYMMETRY

bull SYMMETRICAL - WoodwindPICCOLO FLUTE OBOE CLARINET BASSOON

- Keyboards PIANO ORGAN KEYBOARDS

bull PARTIAL SYMMETRY - Brass CORNET TRUMPET TROMBONE TUBASAXOPHONE

bull ASYMMETRIC - Strings

VIOLIN VIOLA CELLO DOUBLE BASS GUITAR HARP

- FLUTE

BODY ADJUSTMENTSThe Clarinettist

Technical problems (Mcilwain 2010)

1Excessive pressure on finger pads

2Poor wrist alignment

3Shoulder tension

4Excessive movement whilst playing

5Tense and locked fingers Long Keys

Short Keys

Thumb of Right Hand

Posture

bull Sitting or standing

bull Carrying

bull Important factorsbull Muscle strength

bull Flexibility

bull Stamina and endurance

bull Body Awareness

Violin Hold

Contact points

1 Jawchin

2 ClavicleShoulder

3 Base of first finger

4 Thumb

The support muscles tire out first

Posture suffers

Compensatory postures amp movement lead to injury

Violin injuries

Asymmetrical posture = muscular imbalances

Posture-Related Injuries

Guitar size shape weight

Asymmetric

Sitting or Standing positions

Strap

Hand Size

Grip

The Harp

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 2: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Collaborations

bull Institute of Sport

Exercise and Health

bull British Association for Performing Arts Medicine

bull Royal National

Nose Ear amp Throat Hospital

Collaborations

bull English National Opera

bull Royal College of Music

bull National Centre

for Circus Arts

Collaborations

bull Royal Ballet

bull English National Ballet

bull British Institute

of Modern Music

Structure

bull Postgraduate Certificate (PG Cert) ndash 4 modules ndash 60 credits

bull Postgraduate Diploma (PG Dip) - 8 modules ndash 120 credits

bull Masters (MSc) ndash 8+1 modules ndash 180 credits

bull Full-time 1 year

bull Part-time 2 years

bull September start

bull Distance Learning

bull Short Courses

Κατηγοριες Μουσικων Οργανων και Μυοσκελετικες Αναφορες

bull Συντομη περιγραφη των κυριων μουσικων οργανων και των απαιτησεων τους

bull Οι μουσικοι της ορχηστρας η τοποθετηση τους και ο μαεστρος

bull Οι ιδιαιτεροτητες των μουσικων ποπ και ροκ

bull Αναφορα στις εργονομικες και φυσιολογικες διαδικασιες που επηρεαζουν και διαμορφωνουν τις μυοσκελετικες προσαρμογες των μουσικων

bull REFERENCES

bull BIRD HA (2016) Performing Arts Medicine in Clinical Practice 1st ed London Springer International Publishing

bull RAMELLA M et al (2014) Postural Disorders in Conservatory Students The Diesis Project Medical Problems of Performing Artists 29(1) pp 19

Ergonomics

bull Instrumentalists come in all sorts of shapes and sizes

bull Instruments come in specific shapes and sizes

bull So instrumentalists have to adapt to their instruments often playing them for long periods in un-ergonomic positions

SYMMETRY

bull SYMMETRICAL - WoodwindPICCOLO FLUTE OBOE CLARINET BASSOON

- Keyboards PIANO ORGAN KEYBOARDS

bull PARTIAL SYMMETRY - Brass CORNET TRUMPET TROMBONE TUBASAXOPHONE

bull ASYMMETRIC - Strings

VIOLIN VIOLA CELLO DOUBLE BASS GUITAR HARP

- FLUTE

BODY ADJUSTMENTSThe Clarinettist

Technical problems (Mcilwain 2010)

1Excessive pressure on finger pads

2Poor wrist alignment

3Shoulder tension

4Excessive movement whilst playing

5Tense and locked fingers Long Keys

Short Keys

Thumb of Right Hand

Posture

bull Sitting or standing

bull Carrying

bull Important factorsbull Muscle strength

bull Flexibility

bull Stamina and endurance

bull Body Awareness

Violin Hold

Contact points

1 Jawchin

2 ClavicleShoulder

3 Base of first finger

4 Thumb

The support muscles tire out first

Posture suffers

Compensatory postures amp movement lead to injury

Violin injuries

Asymmetrical posture = muscular imbalances

Posture-Related Injuries

Guitar size shape weight

Asymmetric

Sitting or Standing positions

Strap

Hand Size

Grip

The Harp

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 3: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Collaborations

bull English National Opera

bull Royal College of Music

bull National Centre

for Circus Arts

Collaborations

bull Royal Ballet

bull English National Ballet

bull British Institute

of Modern Music

Structure

bull Postgraduate Certificate (PG Cert) ndash 4 modules ndash 60 credits

bull Postgraduate Diploma (PG Dip) - 8 modules ndash 120 credits

bull Masters (MSc) ndash 8+1 modules ndash 180 credits

bull Full-time 1 year

bull Part-time 2 years

bull September start

bull Distance Learning

bull Short Courses

Κατηγοριες Μουσικων Οργανων και Μυοσκελετικες Αναφορες

bull Συντομη περιγραφη των κυριων μουσικων οργανων και των απαιτησεων τους

bull Οι μουσικοι της ορχηστρας η τοποθετηση τους και ο μαεστρος

bull Οι ιδιαιτεροτητες των μουσικων ποπ και ροκ

bull Αναφορα στις εργονομικες και φυσιολογικες διαδικασιες που επηρεαζουν και διαμορφωνουν τις μυοσκελετικες προσαρμογες των μουσικων

bull REFERENCES

bull BIRD HA (2016) Performing Arts Medicine in Clinical Practice 1st ed London Springer International Publishing

bull RAMELLA M et al (2014) Postural Disorders in Conservatory Students The Diesis Project Medical Problems of Performing Artists 29(1) pp 19

Ergonomics

bull Instrumentalists come in all sorts of shapes and sizes

bull Instruments come in specific shapes and sizes

bull So instrumentalists have to adapt to their instruments often playing them for long periods in un-ergonomic positions

SYMMETRY

bull SYMMETRICAL - WoodwindPICCOLO FLUTE OBOE CLARINET BASSOON

- Keyboards PIANO ORGAN KEYBOARDS

bull PARTIAL SYMMETRY - Brass CORNET TRUMPET TROMBONE TUBASAXOPHONE

bull ASYMMETRIC - Strings

VIOLIN VIOLA CELLO DOUBLE BASS GUITAR HARP

- FLUTE

BODY ADJUSTMENTSThe Clarinettist

Technical problems (Mcilwain 2010)

1Excessive pressure on finger pads

2Poor wrist alignment

3Shoulder tension

4Excessive movement whilst playing

5Tense and locked fingers Long Keys

Short Keys

Thumb of Right Hand

Posture

bull Sitting or standing

bull Carrying

bull Important factorsbull Muscle strength

bull Flexibility

bull Stamina and endurance

bull Body Awareness

Violin Hold

Contact points

1 Jawchin

2 ClavicleShoulder

3 Base of first finger

4 Thumb

The support muscles tire out first

Posture suffers

Compensatory postures amp movement lead to injury

Violin injuries

Asymmetrical posture = muscular imbalances

Posture-Related Injuries

Guitar size shape weight

Asymmetric

Sitting or Standing positions

Strap

Hand Size

Grip

The Harp

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 4: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Collaborations

bull Royal Ballet

bull English National Ballet

bull British Institute

of Modern Music

Structure

bull Postgraduate Certificate (PG Cert) ndash 4 modules ndash 60 credits

bull Postgraduate Diploma (PG Dip) - 8 modules ndash 120 credits

bull Masters (MSc) ndash 8+1 modules ndash 180 credits

bull Full-time 1 year

bull Part-time 2 years

bull September start

bull Distance Learning

bull Short Courses

Κατηγοριες Μουσικων Οργανων και Μυοσκελετικες Αναφορες

bull Συντομη περιγραφη των κυριων μουσικων οργανων και των απαιτησεων τους

bull Οι μουσικοι της ορχηστρας η τοποθετηση τους και ο μαεστρος

bull Οι ιδιαιτεροτητες των μουσικων ποπ και ροκ

bull Αναφορα στις εργονομικες και φυσιολογικες διαδικασιες που επηρεαζουν και διαμορφωνουν τις μυοσκελετικες προσαρμογες των μουσικων

bull REFERENCES

bull BIRD HA (2016) Performing Arts Medicine in Clinical Practice 1st ed London Springer International Publishing

bull RAMELLA M et al (2014) Postural Disorders in Conservatory Students The Diesis Project Medical Problems of Performing Artists 29(1) pp 19

Ergonomics

bull Instrumentalists come in all sorts of shapes and sizes

bull Instruments come in specific shapes and sizes

bull So instrumentalists have to adapt to their instruments often playing them for long periods in un-ergonomic positions

SYMMETRY

bull SYMMETRICAL - WoodwindPICCOLO FLUTE OBOE CLARINET BASSOON

- Keyboards PIANO ORGAN KEYBOARDS

bull PARTIAL SYMMETRY - Brass CORNET TRUMPET TROMBONE TUBASAXOPHONE

bull ASYMMETRIC - Strings

VIOLIN VIOLA CELLO DOUBLE BASS GUITAR HARP

- FLUTE

BODY ADJUSTMENTSThe Clarinettist

Technical problems (Mcilwain 2010)

1Excessive pressure on finger pads

2Poor wrist alignment

3Shoulder tension

4Excessive movement whilst playing

5Tense and locked fingers Long Keys

Short Keys

Thumb of Right Hand

Posture

bull Sitting or standing

bull Carrying

bull Important factorsbull Muscle strength

bull Flexibility

bull Stamina and endurance

bull Body Awareness

Violin Hold

Contact points

1 Jawchin

2 ClavicleShoulder

3 Base of first finger

4 Thumb

The support muscles tire out first

Posture suffers

Compensatory postures amp movement lead to injury

Violin injuries

Asymmetrical posture = muscular imbalances

Posture-Related Injuries

Guitar size shape weight

Asymmetric

Sitting or Standing positions

Strap

Hand Size

Grip

The Harp

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 5: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Structure

bull Postgraduate Certificate (PG Cert) ndash 4 modules ndash 60 credits

bull Postgraduate Diploma (PG Dip) - 8 modules ndash 120 credits

bull Masters (MSc) ndash 8+1 modules ndash 180 credits

bull Full-time 1 year

bull Part-time 2 years

bull September start

bull Distance Learning

bull Short Courses

Κατηγοριες Μουσικων Οργανων και Μυοσκελετικες Αναφορες

bull Συντομη περιγραφη των κυριων μουσικων οργανων και των απαιτησεων τους

bull Οι μουσικοι της ορχηστρας η τοποθετηση τους και ο μαεστρος

bull Οι ιδιαιτεροτητες των μουσικων ποπ και ροκ

bull Αναφορα στις εργονομικες και φυσιολογικες διαδικασιες που επηρεαζουν και διαμορφωνουν τις μυοσκελετικες προσαρμογες των μουσικων

bull REFERENCES

bull BIRD HA (2016) Performing Arts Medicine in Clinical Practice 1st ed London Springer International Publishing

bull RAMELLA M et al (2014) Postural Disorders in Conservatory Students The Diesis Project Medical Problems of Performing Artists 29(1) pp 19

Ergonomics

bull Instrumentalists come in all sorts of shapes and sizes

bull Instruments come in specific shapes and sizes

bull So instrumentalists have to adapt to their instruments often playing them for long periods in un-ergonomic positions

SYMMETRY

bull SYMMETRICAL - WoodwindPICCOLO FLUTE OBOE CLARINET BASSOON

- Keyboards PIANO ORGAN KEYBOARDS

bull PARTIAL SYMMETRY - Brass CORNET TRUMPET TROMBONE TUBASAXOPHONE

bull ASYMMETRIC - Strings

VIOLIN VIOLA CELLO DOUBLE BASS GUITAR HARP

- FLUTE

BODY ADJUSTMENTSThe Clarinettist

Technical problems (Mcilwain 2010)

1Excessive pressure on finger pads

2Poor wrist alignment

3Shoulder tension

4Excessive movement whilst playing

5Tense and locked fingers Long Keys

Short Keys

Thumb of Right Hand

Posture

bull Sitting or standing

bull Carrying

bull Important factorsbull Muscle strength

bull Flexibility

bull Stamina and endurance

bull Body Awareness

Violin Hold

Contact points

1 Jawchin

2 ClavicleShoulder

3 Base of first finger

4 Thumb

The support muscles tire out first

Posture suffers

Compensatory postures amp movement lead to injury

Violin injuries

Asymmetrical posture = muscular imbalances

Posture-Related Injuries

Guitar size shape weight

Asymmetric

Sitting or Standing positions

Strap

Hand Size

Grip

The Harp

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 6: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Κατηγοριες Μουσικων Οργανων και Μυοσκελετικες Αναφορες

bull Συντομη περιγραφη των κυριων μουσικων οργανων και των απαιτησεων τους

bull Οι μουσικοι της ορχηστρας η τοποθετηση τους και ο μαεστρος

bull Οι ιδιαιτεροτητες των μουσικων ποπ και ροκ

bull Αναφορα στις εργονομικες και φυσιολογικες διαδικασιες που επηρεαζουν και διαμορφωνουν τις μυοσκελετικες προσαρμογες των μουσικων

bull REFERENCES

bull BIRD HA (2016) Performing Arts Medicine in Clinical Practice 1st ed London Springer International Publishing

bull RAMELLA M et al (2014) Postural Disorders in Conservatory Students The Diesis Project Medical Problems of Performing Artists 29(1) pp 19

Ergonomics

bull Instrumentalists come in all sorts of shapes and sizes

bull Instruments come in specific shapes and sizes

bull So instrumentalists have to adapt to their instruments often playing them for long periods in un-ergonomic positions

SYMMETRY

bull SYMMETRICAL - WoodwindPICCOLO FLUTE OBOE CLARINET BASSOON

- Keyboards PIANO ORGAN KEYBOARDS

bull PARTIAL SYMMETRY - Brass CORNET TRUMPET TROMBONE TUBASAXOPHONE

bull ASYMMETRIC - Strings

VIOLIN VIOLA CELLO DOUBLE BASS GUITAR HARP

- FLUTE

BODY ADJUSTMENTSThe Clarinettist

Technical problems (Mcilwain 2010)

1Excessive pressure on finger pads

2Poor wrist alignment

3Shoulder tension

4Excessive movement whilst playing

5Tense and locked fingers Long Keys

Short Keys

Thumb of Right Hand

Posture

bull Sitting or standing

bull Carrying

bull Important factorsbull Muscle strength

bull Flexibility

bull Stamina and endurance

bull Body Awareness

Violin Hold

Contact points

1 Jawchin

2 ClavicleShoulder

3 Base of first finger

4 Thumb

The support muscles tire out first

Posture suffers

Compensatory postures amp movement lead to injury

Violin injuries

Asymmetrical posture = muscular imbalances

Posture-Related Injuries

Guitar size shape weight

Asymmetric

Sitting or Standing positions

Strap

Hand Size

Grip

The Harp

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 7: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Ergonomics

bull Instrumentalists come in all sorts of shapes and sizes

bull Instruments come in specific shapes and sizes

bull So instrumentalists have to adapt to their instruments often playing them for long periods in un-ergonomic positions

SYMMETRY

bull SYMMETRICAL - WoodwindPICCOLO FLUTE OBOE CLARINET BASSOON

- Keyboards PIANO ORGAN KEYBOARDS

bull PARTIAL SYMMETRY - Brass CORNET TRUMPET TROMBONE TUBASAXOPHONE

bull ASYMMETRIC - Strings

VIOLIN VIOLA CELLO DOUBLE BASS GUITAR HARP

- FLUTE

BODY ADJUSTMENTSThe Clarinettist

Technical problems (Mcilwain 2010)

1Excessive pressure on finger pads

2Poor wrist alignment

3Shoulder tension

4Excessive movement whilst playing

5Tense and locked fingers Long Keys

Short Keys

Thumb of Right Hand

Posture

bull Sitting or standing

bull Carrying

bull Important factorsbull Muscle strength

bull Flexibility

bull Stamina and endurance

bull Body Awareness

Violin Hold

Contact points

1 Jawchin

2 ClavicleShoulder

3 Base of first finger

4 Thumb

The support muscles tire out first

Posture suffers

Compensatory postures amp movement lead to injury

Violin injuries

Asymmetrical posture = muscular imbalances

Posture-Related Injuries

Guitar size shape weight

Asymmetric

Sitting or Standing positions

Strap

Hand Size

Grip

The Harp

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 8: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

SYMMETRY

bull SYMMETRICAL - WoodwindPICCOLO FLUTE OBOE CLARINET BASSOON

- Keyboards PIANO ORGAN KEYBOARDS

bull PARTIAL SYMMETRY - Brass CORNET TRUMPET TROMBONE TUBASAXOPHONE

bull ASYMMETRIC - Strings

VIOLIN VIOLA CELLO DOUBLE BASS GUITAR HARP

- FLUTE

BODY ADJUSTMENTSThe Clarinettist

Technical problems (Mcilwain 2010)

1Excessive pressure on finger pads

2Poor wrist alignment

3Shoulder tension

4Excessive movement whilst playing

5Tense and locked fingers Long Keys

Short Keys

Thumb of Right Hand

Posture

bull Sitting or standing

bull Carrying

bull Important factorsbull Muscle strength

bull Flexibility

bull Stamina and endurance

bull Body Awareness

Violin Hold

Contact points

1 Jawchin

2 ClavicleShoulder

3 Base of first finger

4 Thumb

The support muscles tire out first

Posture suffers

Compensatory postures amp movement lead to injury

Violin injuries

Asymmetrical posture = muscular imbalances

Posture-Related Injuries

Guitar size shape weight

Asymmetric

Sitting or Standing positions

Strap

Hand Size

Grip

The Harp

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 9: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

BODY ADJUSTMENTSThe Clarinettist

Technical problems (Mcilwain 2010)

1Excessive pressure on finger pads

2Poor wrist alignment

3Shoulder tension

4Excessive movement whilst playing

5Tense and locked fingers Long Keys

Short Keys

Thumb of Right Hand

Posture

bull Sitting or standing

bull Carrying

bull Important factorsbull Muscle strength

bull Flexibility

bull Stamina and endurance

bull Body Awareness

Violin Hold

Contact points

1 Jawchin

2 ClavicleShoulder

3 Base of first finger

4 Thumb

The support muscles tire out first

Posture suffers

Compensatory postures amp movement lead to injury

Violin injuries

Asymmetrical posture = muscular imbalances

Posture-Related Injuries

Guitar size shape weight

Asymmetric

Sitting or Standing positions

Strap

Hand Size

Grip

The Harp

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 10: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Posture

bull Sitting or standing

bull Carrying

bull Important factorsbull Muscle strength

bull Flexibility

bull Stamina and endurance

bull Body Awareness

Violin Hold

Contact points

1 Jawchin

2 ClavicleShoulder

3 Base of first finger

4 Thumb

The support muscles tire out first

Posture suffers

Compensatory postures amp movement lead to injury

Violin injuries

Asymmetrical posture = muscular imbalances

Posture-Related Injuries

Guitar size shape weight

Asymmetric

Sitting or Standing positions

Strap

Hand Size

Grip

The Harp

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 11: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Violin Hold

Contact points

1 Jawchin

2 ClavicleShoulder

3 Base of first finger

4 Thumb

The support muscles tire out first

Posture suffers

Compensatory postures amp movement lead to injury

Violin injuries

Asymmetrical posture = muscular imbalances

Posture-Related Injuries

Guitar size shape weight

Asymmetric

Sitting or Standing positions

Strap

Hand Size

Grip

The Harp

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 12: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Violin injuries

Asymmetrical posture = muscular imbalances

Posture-Related Injuries

Guitar size shape weight

Asymmetric

Sitting or Standing positions

Strap

Hand Size

Grip

The Harp

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 13: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Posture-Related Injuries

Guitar size shape weight

Asymmetric

Sitting or Standing positions

Strap

Hand Size

Grip

The Harp

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 14: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

The Harp

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 15: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

brass instruments

bull Shape size and weight

bull Trombone

bull Chest and diaphragm

bull Embouchure mouth and cheeks

bull Fine control of the tongue

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 16: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

PERCUSSION

bull Orchestral

bull Jazz and Pop

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 17: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

keyboards

bull Action ndash FINGER WORK amp MUSCLE BALANCE

bull Regulation - CONTROL

bull Height of Piano Stool - POSTURE

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 18: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

bull Heavy workload on upper limbsbull Brain activated to control

complex motion

Piano demands

superhuman technique

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 19: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Ideal posture

times Left seated too close- Neck flexion- shoulder - elbow bending

Right correct

times Left seated too low- elbow bending

- too low wrist

Right correct

times

(Guptill C and Zaza C 2010)

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 20: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

REPERTOIRE

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 21: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

THE ROCKERSLow back

Right wrist and shoulder

Finger trauma Pronation injury

Lateralmedial epidondylitis

Headneckthorax

Knee Ankle

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 22: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

bull Wrist problems

bull Tendinopathies

bull Shoulder Tension

bull Low back amp Neck

bull Kneeankle

Keyboard ndash Keyboards

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 23: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

The bass and guitar players

bull Strap

bull Instrument position

bull Mic position

bull Size and weight of instrument

bull Cables ndash risk of falling

bull Stage size

bull + everything else

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 24: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

ldquoHead and neck injury risks in heavy metal head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bassrdquo BMJ (2008)

ldquo To minimize the risk of head and neck injury head bangers should

bull decrease their range of head and neck motion

bull head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock

bull only head bang to every second beat

bull use personal protective equipment ldquo

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 25: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

lsquoΜυοσκελετικες Διαταραχες του Ανω Ακρου

των Μουσικωνrsquo

bull Το ανω ακρο και η εννοια της κινητικης και νευρομυικης αλυσιδας απο τον κορμο μεχρι

τα δακτυλα

bull Οι διαταραχες που παρουσιαζονται στο ανω ακρο του μουσικου και πως προσεγγιζουμε

την δαγνωση τους

REFERENCES

TUBIANA R and CHAMAGNE P (1988) Functional Anatomy of the Hand Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(3)

pp 83

TUBIANA R (1988) Movements of the Fingers Medical Problems of Performing Artists 3(4) pp 123

TUBIANA R et al (1989) Fundamental Positions for Instrumental Musicians Medical Problems of Performing Artists4(2)

pp 73

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 26: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

What pain

medical condition social psychological issues posture technique practice repertoire habits

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 27: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Where is the painHow does the pain behave

Back

Neck

Hand

Wrist

Elbow

Shoulder

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 28: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

WHEN WE KNOW THE MEDICAL CONDITION

SPECIFIC PAIN

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 29: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 30: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

De Quervainrsquos Tenosynovitis

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 31: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Dupuytrenrsquos Disease

NO PAINnodulesrarr thickeningrarr contracture

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 32: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Trigger Finger Thumbmaybe painlsquotriggeringrsquo

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 33: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Ganglion Cystpain amp size vary and exacerbated by repetitive movements

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 34: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Osteo-arthritis

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 35: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

WHEN WE CANNOT FIND A MEDICAL

CONDITIONNON-SPECIFIC PAIN

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 36: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Letrsquos see how you playhellip

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 37: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Technique

WE NEED

bull Flexible bow-hand fingers

bull Refine large movements

bull Enough energy on string

Tension in the right hand is impeding bowing ability

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 38: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Healthy Bow HoldbullNo gripping

bullFingers curved

bullRelaxed manner

bullNo stiff joints

bullSoft palm

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 39: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

POSTURE

bull Position of least strain

bull Balance

Risky postures

NeckTorso

Shoulders

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 40: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Chin rest amp Shoulder pad

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 41: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Shoulder down

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 42: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

bull Keep head level

bull Look directly forward

bull Adjust whole body

Music StandampThe Conductor

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 43: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

POSTURE

bull Keep natural curves

bull Shoulders down

The Lower Back

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 44: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Holding the Instrument

bull Hold with ease

bull Natural mechanics

bull Stability from Scapula

Tension

Biomechanics

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 45: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Wrist amp Hand

bull Watch them play

Tension

Biomechanics

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 46: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

BOWING

bull Movement starts in Upper Back

bull Shoulder joint is the pivot

bull Elbow wrist and fingers passive motions

bull Free to move

bull Minimum energy

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 47: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Can Physical Tension cause PainYES

bullCo-Contraction of muscles

bullExcess Contraction of muscles

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 48: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Excess Contraction

bull Muscles need blood

bull If contracted too much or for too long darr blood supply

bull darr blood supply = cramp fatigue injury

Muscles need to relax to uarr blood supply

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 49: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Just the hands

or the whole body

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 50: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Muscles are made up of cells (fibres)

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 51: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Cells need O2 to work

They take O2 from the bloodWhen the work is done they release CO2 to the blood

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 52: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Blood supply of the arm

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 53: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

The muscles that move the forearm are in the upper armagonist ne antagonisttension ne release

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 54: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

The muscles that move the fingers and the wrist are in the forearm

agonist ne antagonisttension ne release

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 55: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Lumbricals rarr bend the knuckles with straight fingers

Interossei rarr spread out the fingers

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 56: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

How can we help

bull Relaxation Methods

bull Breathing Exercises

bull Psychological Support

bull Muscle Activity Monitoring amp Biofeedback

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 57: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Muscle Relaxation

All muscle groups have to learn to relax

bull Hand

bull Forearm

bull Arm

bull Neck amp Head

bull Lower Back

bull Pelvis amp Legs

DURING PRACTICEDURING PERFORMANCE

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 58: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Breathing

bullBreathing rhythm and pattern has to be learned

practiced and incorporated

in the performance

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 59: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Shoulder Bladebull The scapula is in the correct position and fixed by supporting muscles

bull The rotation of the inferior corner of the scapula is essential for the natural movement of the shoulder joint

bull If the scapula wings off andor tilts forward the rotating movement is not possible the shoulder joint and the TOS close up and the muscles in the upper arm and the neck and shoulder area are overloaded

bull Incorrect position of the scapula may cause problems such as

Diffuse Pain Fatigue Shaking Numbness Weakness Poor Control

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 60: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Pianistsrsquo hands or pianistsrsquo shoulders

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 61: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

You have two shoulder blades

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 62: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Scapula motion and fixation

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 63: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Scapula and Clavicle Motion and Fixation

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 64: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Kinematic Chaina biomechanically efficient pattern of motion

Sequence of Muscular Events ndash XL L M S XS

The musician needs to know

which muscles to engage

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 65: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Stretch

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 66: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Strengthen

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 67: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Discipline of Biomedical Science Sydney Medical School

bull Inj Prev 201319257-263

bullDevelopment of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians

bull Cliffton Chan1 Tim Driscoll2 Bronwen Ackermann1

bull Using available evidence on exercise prescription in collaboration with clinical consensus and current best practice a specific exercise programme was developed to prevent andor reduce occupational injuries in professional orchestral musicians

bull Shoulder series

bull A progressive series of scapular stability and rotator cuff exercises were included focusing on restoring shoulder muscle balance and movement control This progressed to stages that added resistance and increased the functional context of the exercises into instrumental performance biomechanical patterning

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 68: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

College of the Arts University of South Florida

bull Med Probl Perform Art 2012 Jun27(2)85-94

bull Intervention program in college instrumental musicians with kinematics analysis of cello and flute playing a combined program of yogic breathing and muscle strengthening-flexibility exercises

bull Lee SH1 Carey S Dubey R Matz R

bull College musicians encounter health risks not dissimilar to those of professional musicians Fifteen collegiate instrumental musicians participated in the intervention program of yogic-breathing and muscle-strengthening and flexibility exercises for 8 weeks Pre- and post-intervention data from the Health-Pain-Injury Inventory (HPI) and the Physical amp Musical-Performance Efficacy Assessment Survey (PME) were analyzed for the effects of the program on the musicians physical and musical-performance efficacy HPI results showed that the majority of our sample had healthy lifestyles and minimal pain and injuries but irregular eating and exercise habits The pre-intervention PME data showed a high level of musical efficacy (ie awareness of music technique tone and flow) but a low-level of physical efficacy (ie awareness of posture tension and movement flexibility) Post-intervention data showed that the program improved physical efficacy by increased awareness of posture and tension In 2 volunteer musicians kinematics motion analysis was conducted for exploratory purposes Our cellist played the scale using a larger range of motion (ROM) in rightshoulder flexion and abduction and slightly increased rotation while keeping decreased right elbow ROM after the intervention program The flutist shifted the body weight from one foot to the other more in the second playing post-intervention These changes can be attributed to the increased physical efficacy that allowed freedom to express musicality Findings from these case scenarios provide empirically based hypotheses for further study We share our experience so that others may use our model and instruments to develop studies with larger samples

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 69: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Cardiffbull Work 201140(3)317-24 doi 103233WOR-2011-1238

bullPostural problems of the left shoulder in an orchestral trombonist

bull Price K1 Watson AH

bull Professional musicians require a disciplined and balanced regime of practise and performance to enable them to cope with the physical challenges of their chosen instrument and to reduce the risk of work- related injury If practise or performance strategies are suddenly changed permanent damage may occur even in a player with a mature well-established technique The trombone presents unique physical challenges which are heightened by recent developments in instrumental design as well as by orchestral working conditions This study presents the experiences of a professional orchestral trombonist who worked as a principal player in a UK orchestra until his performing career was cut short by a performance related injury His personal approach to practise is discussed in the context of the physical and professional challenges associated with contemporary orchestral practices The case study demonstrates the importance of considering the interplay between psychological and physical factors in the development and treatment of injury in musicians

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 70: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 71: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Bio Psycho Social

Wrong technique

darrFatiguecrampinjury

darrPain

darrPoor performance quality

darrPerformance Anxiety Career issues etc

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 72: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Musicianrsquos Focal DystonialdquoMuscular incoordination

or loss of voluntary motor control

of extensively trained movements

while a musician is playing the instrumentrdquo

(Altenmuller 2010)

bull NO PAIN

bull DYSTONIC POSTURE

bull TASK SPECIFIC

bull Career ending

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 73: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Rapid repetitive highly stereotypic movement can degrade corticalrepresentations of sensory information guiding fine motor hand movements (Byl et al 2005)

Musical practice in musicianrsquos dystonia leads to changes in cortical organisation that progress too far and begin to interfere with movement rather than assist (Rosenkranz et al 2005)

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 74: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Difficulty performing

Loss of control in fast passages

Slow movement of fingers

Weakness of the hand

Finger curling

Lack of precision

Irregularity

Past injuriesPsychological factors

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 75: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Neuroplasticity

Biofeedback Re-Training with sEMG(Neuroplastics)

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you

Page 76: PERFORMING ARTS MEDICINE MSC”ιαλέξεις 2019/HT...Development of a specific exercise programme for professional orchestral musicians • Cliffton Chan. 1, Tim Driscoll. 2,

Contact

bull wwwharatroulicom

bull haratrouligmailcom

bull haratrouliuclacuk

Thank you