personal information giuseppe notarbartolo …pew fellows in marine conservation 2001 – present...
TRANSCRIPT
Date:26February2018
CURRICULUMVITAE
PERSONALINFORMATION GiuseppeNotarbartolodiSciara
address viaBenedettoMarcello43,20124Milano,Italytelephone +390229402867mobile +393356376035email [email protected] http://www.disciara.orggender malebornon 27November1948nationality ItalianORCIDID https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0353-617XWikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giuseppe_Notarbartolo_di_Sciara
JOB Marineconservationecologist
WORKEXPERIENCE 2016–present
1986-1997,2010-2016HonoraryPresidentandVicePresidentPresidentTethysResearchInstitute,VialeG.B.Gadio2,20121Milano,Italywww.tethys.orgSector:marineconservationscienceandpolicy
2014–present COP-appointedCouncillorforaquaticmammals
U.N.ConventionontheConservationofMigratorySpecieofWildAnimals(CMS)
2017 MemberoftheReviewPanel,2ndPerformanceReviewAppointedbytheConventionontheConservationofAntarcticMarineLivingResources(CCAMLR),asan“internationallyrecognisedexpertwhoseexpertisecoverstherelevantareasofenvironmentalmanagement,fisheriesscienceandlegalmatters,includingcomplianceandenforcementissuesandthefightagainstIUUfishing"(COMMCIRC17/25andSC-CIRC17/19)
2012–present Co-chair
JointIUCNWCPA/SSCTaskForceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
2012–present MemberoftheBoardofGovernorsTheSocietyofMarineMammalogy
2003–present Member
IUCNSSCSharkSpecialistGroup
2003–present MemberoftheBoardofAdvisorsPewFellowsinMarineConservation
2001–present
1992-1994CoordinatorCIESMTaskForceonMarineMammals
2000–present RegionalCoordinator,MediterraneanandBlackSea
IUCNWorldCommissiononProtectedAreas–Marine
2
1991–present DeputyChair
IUCNSSCCetaceanSpecialistGroup
2006-2016 ContractProfessorUniversity“Statale”ofMilanoCourseonscienceandpolicyofmarinebiodiversityconservation
2002–2010 Chair
ScientificCommitteeofACCOBAMS
1999-2003 Commissioner/AlternateCommissionerforItalyInternationalWhalingCommission
1996–2003 President
IstitutoCentraleperlaRicercaApplicataalMare(ICRAM)
EDUCATION 1980-1985 PhDinMarineBiology
UniversityofCaliforniaatSanDiego,ScrippsInstitutionofOceanography,LaJolla,California,USA
1975-1976 Laureainnaturalsciences,cumlaude
UniversityofParma,Italy
1969-1974 LaureainbiologicalsciencesUniversityofParma,Italy
PERSONALSKILLS-LANGUAGES Mothertongue Italian
Otherlanguages UNDERSTANDING SPEAKING WRITING
Listening Reading Spokeninteraction Spokenproduction
English C C C C CFrench C C C C CSpanish C C C B B
SELECTEDPUBLICATIONS h-indexScopus:21-h-indexGoogleScholar:40 SchweitzerJ.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.1986.Theretemirabilecranicainthegenus
Mobula:acomparativestudy.JournalofMorphology188:167-178.
WatkinsW.A.,TyackP.,MooreK.E.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.1987.StenobredanensisintheMediterraneanSea.MarineMammalScience3(1):78-82.
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.1987.ArevisionarystudyofthegenusMobulaRafinesque,
1810(Chondrichthyes:Mobulidae),withthedescriptionofanewspecies.ZoologicalJournaloftheLinneanSociety,London91:1-91.
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.1987.Killerwhale,Orcinusorca,intheMediterranean
3
Sea.MarineMammalScience3(4):356-360.
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.1988.NaturalhistoryoftheraysofthegenusMobulaintheGulfofCalifornia.FisheryBulletin86(1):45-66.
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,HillyerE.V.1989.MobulidraysoffEastern
Venezuela.Copeia1989(3):607-614.
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.1990.AnoteonthecetaceanincidentalcatchintheItaliandriftnetswordfishfishery,1986-1988.ReportsoftheInternationalWhalingCommission40:459-460.
FossiM.C.,MarsiliL.,LeonzioC.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,ZanardelliM.1992.Theuseofnon-destructivebiomarkerinMediterraneancetaceans:preliminarydataonMFOactivityinskinbiopsy.MarinePollutionBulletin24(9):459-461.
NotarbartoloG.,AusendaF.,OrsiReliniL.,ReliniG.1992.Unapropostadigestionedell’ambientepelagico:laRiservadellaBiosferanelBacinocorso-ligureprovenzale.AttiXXIICongressodellaSocietàItalianadiBiologiaMarina,Cagliari,SantaMargheritadiPula,20-24May1991.Oebalia,Supplemento17:517-521.
WatkinsW.A.,DaherM.A.,FristrupK.M.,HowaldT.J.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.1993.Spermwhalestaggedwithtranspondersandtrackedunderwaterbysonar.MarineMammalScience9(1):55-67.
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,VenturinoM.C.,ZanardelliM.,BearziG.,BorsaniJ.F.,CavalloniB.1993.CetaceansinthecentralMediterraneanSea:distributionandsightingfrequencies.ItalianJournalofZoology60:131-138.
ForcadaJ.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,FabbriF.1995.AbundanceoffinwhalesandstripeddolphinssummeringintheCorso-LigurianBasin.Mammalia59(1):127-140.
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,BarbacciaG.,AzzellinoA.1997.Birthatseaofafalsekillerwhale,Pseudorcacrassidens.MarineMammalScience13(3):508-511.
BearziG.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,PolitiE.1997.SocialecologyofbottlenosedolphinsintheKvarneric’(northernAdriaticSea).MarineMammalScience13(4):650-668.
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,GordonJ.1997.Bioacoustics:atoolfortheconservationofcetaceansintheMediterraneanSea.MarineandFreshwaterBehaviourandPhysiology30:125-146.
BerubéM.,AguilarA.,DendantoD.,LarsenF.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,SearsR.,SigurjònssonJ.,Urban-RamirezJ.,PalsbøllP.J.1998.PopulationgeneticstructureofNorthAtlantic,MediterraneanSeaandSeaofCortezfinwhales,Balaenopteraphysalus(Linnaeus,1758):analysisofmitochondrialandnuclearloci.MolecularEcology7(5):585-599.
BearziG.,PolitiE.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.1999.Diurnalbehavioroffree-rangingbottlenosedolphinsintheKvarneric(northernAdriaticSea).MarineMammalScience15(4):1065-1097.
BrownellR.L.,Jr.,TillmanM.F.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,BerggrenP.,ReadA.J.2000.Furtherscrutinyofscientificwhaling.Science290:1696.
FossiM.C.,CasiniS.,MarsiliL.,AusiliA.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.2001.AretheMediterraneantoppredatorsexposedtotoxicologicalrisksduetoendocrinedisrupters?AnnalsoftheNewYorkAcademyofScience948:67-74.
FossiM.C.,CasiniS.,AncoraS.,MoscatelliA.,AusiliA.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.2001.DoendocrinedisruptingchemicalsthreatenMediterraneanswordfish?PreliminaryresultsofvitellogeninandzonaradiataproteinsinXiphiasgladius.MarineEnvironmental
4
Research52:477-483.
ClarkC.W.,BorsaniJ.F.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.2002.Vocalactivityoffinwhales,Balaenopteraphysalus,intheLigurianSea.MarineMammalScience18(1):286-295.
JahodaM.,LafortunaC.L.,BiassoniN.,AlmiranteC.,AzzellinoA.,PanigadaS.,ZanardelliM.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.2003.Mediterraneanfinwhale’s(Balaenopteraphysalus)responsetosmallvesselsandbiopsysamplingassessedthroughpassivetrackingandtimingofrespiration.MarineMammalScience19(1):96-110.
ClaphamP.J.,BerggrenP.ChilderhouseS.,FridayN.A.,KasuyaT.,KellL.,KockK.-H.,Manzanilla-NaimS.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,PerrinW.F.,ReadA.J.,ReevesR.R.,RoganE.,Rojas-BrachoL.,SmithT.D.,StachowitschM.,TaylorB.L.,WadeP.R.,BrownellR.L.,Jr.2003.Whalingasscience.Bioscience53(3):210-212.
OriansG.,BriandF.,DiamondJ.,ColbornT.,GomezE.,GuilleminR.,KlugA.,KonishiM.,LubchencoJ.,MeeL.,NorseE.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,PayneR.,SafinaC.,SuzukiD.,WilsonE.O.,WoodwellG.2003.“ScientistsversusWhaling”:whoseerrorsofjudgment?Bioscience53(3):200-203.
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,ZanardelliM.,PanigadaS.,JahodaM.,AiroldiS.2003.Finwhale,Balaenopteraphysalus(L.,1758),intheMediterraneanSea.MammalReview33(2):105-150.
ReevesR.R.,SmithB.D.,CrespoE.A.NotarbartolodiSciaraG.2003.Dolphins,whalesandporpoises:2002-2010ConservationActionPlanfortheWorld’sCetaceans.IUCN/SSCCetaceanSpecialistGroup.IUCN,Gland,SwitzerlandandCambridge,UK.ix+139p.
BearziG.,ReevesR.R.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,PolitiE.,CañadasA.,FrantzisA.,MussiB.2003.Ecology,statusandconservationofshort-beakedcommondolphins(Delphinusdelphis)intheMediterraneanSea.MammalReview33(34):224-252.
PalsbøllP.J.,BérubéM.,AguilarA.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,NielsenR.2004.Discerningbetweenrecurrentgeneflowandrecentdivergenceunderafinite-sitemutationmodelappliedtoNorthAtlanticandMediterraneanSeafinwhale(Balaenopteraphysalus)populations.Evolution58(3):670-675.
NotarbartolodiSciara,G.,Serena,F.&Mancusi,C.2006.Mobulamobular.In:IUCN2009.IUCNRedListofThreatenedSpecies.Version2009.2.
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,AgardyT.,HyrenbachD.,ScovazziT.,VanKlaverenP.2008.ThePelagossanctuaryforMediterraneanmarinemammals.AquaticConservation:MarineandFreshwaterEcosystems18:367-391.doi:10.1002/aqc.855.
GuidettiP.,MilazzoM.,BussottiS.,MolinariA.,MurenuM.,PaisA.,SpanòN.,BalzanoR.,AgardyT.,BoeroF.,CarradaG.,Cattaneo-ViettiR.,CauA.,ChemelloR.,GrecoS.,ManganaroA.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,RussoG.F.,TunesiL.2008.Italianmarinereserveeffectiveness:doesenforcementmatter?BiologicalConservation141:699-709.doi:10.1016/j.biocon.2007.12.013
AbdullaA.,GomeiM.,HyrenbachD.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,AgardyT.2008.ChallengesfacinganetworkofrepresentativemarineprotectedareasintheMediterranean:prioritizingtheprotectionofunderrepresentedhabitats.ICESJournalofMarineScience,66.doi:10.1093/icesjms/fsn164
AusterP.J.,FujitaR.,KellertS.R.,AviseJ.,CampagnaC.,CukerB.,DaytonP.,HenemanB.,KenchingtonR.,StoneG.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,GlynnP.2009.Developinganoceanethic:science,utility,aesthetics,self-interestanddifferentwaysofknowing.ConservationBiology23(1):233-235.doi:10.1111/j.1523-1739.2008.01057.x
DolmanS.J.,EvansP.G.H.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,FrischH.2010.Activesonar,beakedwhales&Europeanregionalpolicy.MarinePollutionBulletin63:27-
5
34.doi:10.1016/j.marpolbul.2010.03.034
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,BirkunA.,Jr.2010.Conservingwhales,dolphinsandporpoisesintheMediterraneanandBlackSeas:anACCOBAMSstatusreport,2010.ACCOBAMS,Monaco.212p.
AgardyT.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,ChristieP.2011.Mindthegap:addressingtheshortcomingsofmarineprotectedareasthroughlargescalemarinespatialplanning.MarinePolicy35:226-232.
FossiM.C.,CasiniS.,CalianiI.,PantiC.,MarsiliL.,ViarengoA.,GiangrecoR.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,SerenaF.,OuerghiA.,DepledgeM.H.2012.Theroleoflargemarinevertebratesintheassessmentofthequalityofpelagicmarineecosystems.MarineEnvironmentalResearch77:156-158.doi:10.1016/j.marenvres.2012.03.003
AzzellinoA.,PanigadaS.,LanfrediC.,ZanardelliM.,AiroldiS.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.2012.Predictivehabitatmodelsformanagingmarineareas:spatialandtemporaldistributionofmarinemammalswithinthePelagosSanctuary(NorthwesternMediterraneansea).Ocean&CoastalManagement67:63-74.
AdnetS.,CappettaH.,GuinotG.,Notarbartolo-di-SciaraG.2012.Evolutionaryhistoryofthedevilrays(Chondrichthyes:Myliobatiformes)fromfossilandmorphologicalinference.ZoologicalJournaloftheLinneanSociety,London166:132-159.doi:10.1111/j.1096-3642.2012.00844.x
GuidettiP.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,AgardyT.2012.IntegratingpelagicandcoastalMPAsintolarge-scaleecosystem-widemanagement.AquaticConservation:MarineandFreshwaterEcosystemsDOI:10.1002/aqc.2314
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.2012.Ancientwaves,recentconcerns:thebuddingofmarinemammalconservationscienceinItaly.AquaticMammals38(4):441-455.DOI10.1578/AM.38.4.2012.441
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.2013.Spermwhales,Physetermacrocephalus,intheMediterraneanSea:asummaryofstatus,threats,andconservationrecommendations.AquaticConservation:MarineandFreshwaterEcosystemsDOI:10.1002/aqc.2409
PortmanM.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,AgardyT.,KatsanevakisS.,PossinghamH.,DiCarloG.2013.Hewhohesitatesislost:whyconservationintheMediterraneanSeaisnecessaryandpossiblenow.MarinePolicy42:270-279.http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2013.03.004
LascellesB.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,AgardyT.,CuttelodA.,EckertS.,GlowkaL.,HoytE.,LlewellynF.,LouzaoM.,RidouxV.,TetleyM.J.2014.Migratorymarinespecies:theirstatus,threatsandconservationmanagementneeds.AquaticConservation:MarineandFreshwaterEcosystems24(Suppl.2):111-127.DOI:10.1002/aqc.2512
CorriganC.M.,ArdronJ.A.,Comeros-RaynalM.T.,HoytE.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,CarpenterK.E.2014.Developingimportantmarinemammalareacriteria:learningfromecologicallyorbiologicallysignificantareasandkeybiodiversityareas.AquaticConservation:MarineandFreshwaterEcosystems24(Suppl.2):166-183.DOI:10.1002/aqc.2513
DeBoerM.N.,SaulinoJ.T.,LewisT.P.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.2015.Newrecordsofwhaleshark(Rhincodontypus),giantmantaray(Mantabirostris)andChileandevilray(Mobulatarapacana)forSuriname.MarineBiodiversityRecordsVol.8;e10;doi:10.1017/S1755267214001432
CagnolaroL.,CozziB.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,PodestàM.(Editors).2015.Faunad’Italia.MammaliaIV.Cetacea.Calderini–Edagricole,Milano.375p.
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.2015.Marineconservation.Pages145-156in:H.D.Smith,J.L.
6
SuarezdeVivero,T.S.Agardy(editors),RoutledgeHandbookofoceanresourcesandmanagement.EarthscanfromRoutledge,LondonandNewYork.612p.
CrollD.A.,DewarH.,DulvyN.K.,FernandoD.,FrancisM.P.,Galván-MagañaF.,HallM.,HeinrichsS.,MarshallA.,McCauleyD.,NewtonK.M.,Notarbartolo-di-SciaraG.,O’MalleyM.,O’SullivanJ.,PoortvietM.,RomanM.,StevensG.,TershyB.R.,WhiteW.T.2015.Vulnerabilitiesandfisheriesimpacts:theuncertainfutureofmantaanddevilrays.AquaticConservation:MarineandFreshwaterEcosystemsDOI:10.1002/aqc.2591
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,LaurianoG.,PierantonioN.,CañadasA.,DonovanG.,PanigadaS.2015.Thedevilwedon’tknow:investigatinghabitatandabundanceofendangeredgiantdevilraysintheNorth-WesternMediterraneanSea.PLOSONE10(11):e0141189.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0141189
GeijerC.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,PanigadaS.2016.Mysticetemigrationrevisited:areMediterraneanfinwhalesananomaly?MammalReview.DOI:10.1111/mam.12069
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,FernandoG.,AdnetS.,CappettaH.,JabadoR.W.2016.Devilrays(Chondrichthyes:Mobula)oftheArabianSeas,witharedescriptionofMobulakuhlii(ValenciennesinMüllerandHenle,1841).AquaticConservation:MarineandFreshwaterEcosystems.DOI:10.1002/aqc.2635
CoomberF.G.,D’IncàM.,RossoM.,TepsichP.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,MoulinsA.2016.DescriptionofthevesseltrafficwithinthenorthPelagosSanctuary:inputsforMarineSpatialPlanningandmanagementimplicationswithinanexistinginternationalMarineProtectedArea.MarinePolicy69:102-113.doi:10.1016/j.marpol.2016.04.013
LawsonJ.M.,WallsR.H.,FordhamS.V.,O’MalleyM.P.,HeupelM.R.,StevensG.,FernandoD.,BudziakA.,SimpfendorferC.A.,DavidsonL.N.,EnderI.,FrancisM.P.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,DulvyN.K.2016.Sympathyforthedevil:aconservationstrategyfordevilandmantarays.PeerJPrePrints4:e1731v1https://doi.org/10.7287/peerj.preprints.1731v1
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,AgardyT.2016.BuildingonthePelagosSanctuaryforMediterraneanmarinemammals.Pp.162-179in:P.Mackelworth(editor),Marinetransboundaryconservationandprotectedareas.EarthscanfromRoutledge,OxfordandNewYork,313p.
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,HoytE.,ReevesR.,ArdronJ.,MarshH.,VongravenD.,BarrB.Inpress.Place-basedapproachestomarinemammalconservation.AquaticConservation:MarineandFreshwaterEcosystems.DOI:10.1002/aqc.2642
NotarbartolodiSciara,G.,Podestà,M.,Curry,B.E.(Eds.),2016.Mediterraneanmarinemammalsecologyandconservation.AdvancesinMarineBiology75.
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.2016.MarinemammalsintheMediterranean:anoverview.In:NotarbartolodiSciara,G.,Podestà,M.,Curry,B.E.(Eds.),Mediterraneanmarinemammalsecologyandconservation.AdvancesinMarineBiology75:1-36http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/bs.amb.2016.08.005
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,CastelloteM.,DruonJ.-N.,PanigadaS.2016.Finwhales(Balaenopteraphysalus):athomeinachangingMediterraneanSea?In:NotarbartolodiSciara,G.,Podestà,M.,Curry,B.E.(Eds.),Mediterraneanmarinemammalsecologyandconservation.AdvancesinMarineBiology75:75-101http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/bs.amb.2016.08.002
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,KotomatasS.2016.AreMediterraneanmonkseals(Monachusmonachus)beinglefttosavethemselvesfromextinction?In:NotarbartolodiSciara,G.,Podestà,M.,Curry,B.E.(Eds.),Mediterraneanmarinemammalsecologyandconservation.AdvancesinMarineBiology75:361-388http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/bs.amb.2016.08.004
PanigadaS.,DonovanG.P.,DruonJ.N.,LaurianoG.,PierantonioN.,PirottaE.,ZanardelliM.,ZerbiniA.N.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.2017.SatellitetaggingofMediterraneanfinwhales:workingtowardstheidentificationofcriticalhabitatsandthefocussingofmitigationmeasures.ScientificReports7:3365DOI:10.1038/s41598-017-03560-9
7
AbudayaM.,UlmanA.,SalahJ.,FernandoD.,WorC.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.2017.Speakofthe
devilray(Mobulamobular)fisheryinGaza.ReviewsinFishBiologyandFisheriesDOI10.1007/s11160-017-9491-0
CañadasA.,AguilardeSotoN.,AissiM.,ArcangeliA.,AzzolinM.,B-NagyA.,BearziG.,CampanaI.,ChicoteC.,CotteC.,CrostiR.,DavidL.,DiNataleA.,FortunaC.,FrantzisA.,GarciaP.,GazoM.,Gutierrez-XarxaR.,HolcerD.,LaranS.,LaurianoG.,LewisT.,MoulinsA.,MussiB.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,PanigadaS.,PastorX.,PolitiE.,PulciniM.,RagaJ.A.,RendellL.,RossoM.,TepsichP.,TomásJ.,TringaliM.,RogerT.2017.Thechallengeofhabitatmodellingforthreatenedlowdensityspeciesusingheterogeneousdata:thecaseofCuvier’sbeakedwhalesintheMediterranean.EcologicalIndicators85:128-136.http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolind.2017.10.021
NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,KeremD.,SmeenkC.,RudolphP.,CesarioA.,CostaM.,ElasarM.,FeingoldD.,FumagalliM.,GoffmanO.,HadarN.,MebrathuY.T.,ScheininA.2017.CetaceansoftheRedSea.CMSTechnicalSeries33.86p.
MannocciL.,RobertsJ.J.,HalpinP.N.,AuthierM.,BoisseauO.,BradaiM.N.,CañadasA.,ChicoteC.,DavidL.,Di-MéglioN.,FortunaC.M.,FrantzisA.,GazoM.,GenovT.,HammondP.S.,HolcerD.,KaschnerK.,KeremD.,LaurianoG.,LewisT.,NotarbartolodiSciaraG.,PanigadaS.,RagaJ.A.,ScheininA.,RidouxV.,VellaA.,VellaJ.2018.AssessingcetaceansurveysthroughouttheMediterraneanSea:agapanalysisinenvironmentalspace.ScientificReports8:3126DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-19842-9
HONOURSANDAWARDS KnighthoodintheOrderofSt.Charles,receivedfromH.S.H.thePrinceAlbertIIofMonacoon17November2009,forservicesrenderedtothePrincipalityinmyqualityofChairoftheScientificCommitteeofthe“AgreementontheConservationofCetaceansoftheBlackSea,MediterraneanSeaandContiguousAtlanticArea”.
Prize“Tridented’Oro”awardedbytheInternationalAcademyofUnderwaterSciencesandTechnologieson11September1993,ontheislandofUstica(Italy),foractivitiesinthefieldofmarinescience.
Careerprize“Unavitaperilmare”(“Alifeforthesea”),10thedition,awardedin2006bytheCityAquariumofMilanoandVerdeacqua.
EuropeanCetaceanSociety2015ConservationPrize“MandyMcMathConservationAward”.