04/12/2015

1

Noise protection in the home

A fresh look at Approved Document E

Peter Turner NHBC Principal Acoustic Consultant

Noise protection in the home Approved Document E

(2003) BS 8233:2014

Noise protection outside the home NPSE / NPPF BS 4142:2014

PPG24

Noise protection in the home

Approved Document E (2003)

How effective is ADE for

protecting the welfare

(health and wellbeing)

of homeowners?

Approved Document E: Requirements

•  E1: Reasonable resistance to airborne and impact sound insulation between dwellings and from other parts of the same building or other attached buildings.

•  E2: Reasonable resistance to airborne sound insulation within the same dwelling:

ü  all floors ü  walls between bedrooms and adjacent rooms not containing a door ü  walls between a room containing a WC an adjacent room

•  E3: Reasonable control of reverberation in common areas which flats open directly onto.

Requirement E1

04/12/2015

2

Requirement E1

Provides “reasonable” resistance to sound between dwellings

Requirement E1

Examples plant rooms, lifts, gyms, community rooms and circulation spaces

Requirement E1

BS 8233:2014

Sufficient guidance?

Requirement E2

Provides “reasonable” resistance to sound within a dwelling

Requirement E3

Provides “reasonable” control of reverberation in common areas

Further Guidance in ADE

Entrance doors

Pipe enclosures

Internal services (reference to BS8233)

04/12/2015

3

Perceived sound and homeowner response

•  Characteristics of the noise source (e.g. loudness, spectra, periodicity, force) •  Transference of the noise into structure (direct or indirect) •  Conductivity or resistance to sound/vibration within the structure •  Re-radiation of sound by structure into the air •  Reverberation in the occupied room •  Level of background (masking) noise (e.g. road traffic, mechanical ventilation) •  Activity of occupant (Sleeping, resting, conversation, housework, exercise) •  Health of occupant (including stress and anxiety, or disabilities) •  Expectations and past experience in dwellings •  Sensitivity of the occupant

Depends on the following :

Perceived sound and homeowner response

•  E1 target values are objective measures between dwellings. •  Background noise levels, subjective response, noise characteristics are not

considered.

•  Homeowner expects that the sound insulation provided by a wall or floor helps to provide sufficient rest and sleep.

•  What is a “reasonable” resistance to sound, if a homeowner is dissatisfied?

Case 1: Direct airborne transmission

Bedroom Bedroom

Part

y W

all

Speech distinguishable

through wall

Very low background

levels

Case 1 : Direct airborne transmission

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

100 160 250 400 630 1000 1600 2500 4000

dB

ThirdOctaveBandFrequency(Hz)

Soundinsulationcurveandspeechspectra

DnT

Measuredspeechspectrum

SpeechSpectrummeasuredthroughwall

BackgroundNoise

Case 2: Airborne Flanking Transmission

Living Room

Party Floor

Speech distinguishable through floor

Very low background

levels

Living Room

DnTw(Ctr) = 49(-3) = 46dB DnT,w + Ctr

Linings not to BS8212

Structure-borne noise

Case 2: Airborne Flanking Transmission

Living Room

Party Floor

Living Room

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

50 63 80 100 125 160 200 250 315 400 500 630 800 1000 1250 1600 2000 2500 3150 4000 5000

Standardized Level Difference, DnT(dB)

Third Octave Frequency Band (Hz)

Triline added : 58 (-5)

Drylining removed : 52 (-4)

Original condition : 49 (-3)

Flanking Transmission

Lined wall = 58(-5) = 53dB DnT,w + Ctr

04/12/2015

4

Case 3: Water pipes

WC

Living

Party/Internal Floor

Water noise

Case 3: Water pipes

WC

Living

Party/Internal Floor

Water noise

Rigid contact

Other types of noise

•  Structure borne sound e.g. banging doors, light switches, extractor fans, WCs •  Horizontal impact transmission (e.g. stairs against party walls) •  Impact sound insulation within the home •  Structure induced noise such as creaking floors •  Re-radiated noise from vibrations (e.g. water pipes in contact with enclosure) •  Low frequency noise (e.g. deep thuds from footfall) •  Vibrations from washing machines •  External noise

•  Noises not covered by ADE but sometimes reported by some homeowners separate from or in addition to E1 or E2 enquiries include:

Case 4: Structure-borne / flanking transmission Flat 2 Flat 1

WC Living Living

Bedroom

Case 4: Structure-borne / flanking transmission Flat 2 Flat 1

WC Living Living

Bedroom

Case 4: Structure-borne / flanking transmission Flat 2 Flat 1

WC Living Living

Bedroom

Screed Cut

04/12/2015

5

Case 4: Structure-borne WC Noise 47(-3) = 44dB DnT,w + Ctr

Before Cut After Cut

59(-4) = 55dB DnT,w + Ctr

Case 5: Structure-borne from Pump Room

Pump room Flat

Cor

ridor

E1 Compliant

New Noise Criteria for Lift noise

25dB LAMax

Lift Noise Only

Case 6: Structure-borne noise from commercial premises

Case 7: Bridged Wall Cavity

54dB DnT,w + Ctr

63dB LnT,w

Other Impact Noise

•  Timber floors <100Hz •  Tiled floors

•  Roof terraces

•  Internal Floors

04/12/2015

6

Mechanical ventilation systems

•  BS8233:2014 – Hotels guidance only

•  Comfort cooling systems < NR25 (30dB LAeq)

•  Minimum air ventilation systems < NR20 25dB LAeq

•  Extend to residential dwellings?

•  Helps to raise background noise, hence mask other noises

Case 8: External Noise

Case 9: Communal Area / Entrance Doors

Other Issues

•  Reverberation within dwellings •  Under-croft car parks •  Roof top plant •  Internal flanking transmission

NHBC Foundation : Sound Progress

NHBC Foundation : Sound Progress

04/12/2015

7

NHBC Foundation : Sound Progress

Consider: •  expectations (cost,

location, tranquillity) •  The lower background

noise (quieter location) •  No disturbance from

neighbours

NHBC Foundation : Sound Progress

Future

•  Holistic Approach – consider all factors: (spectra, external noise, background etc)

•  Whole dwelling protection (Like Parts C, F & L)

•  Time for an updated NIS/NAS style survey? •  Classification system?

(may help to manage expectation)

COST Action TU0901 & ISO/TC43/SC2

•  TU0901: to “harmonise the descriptors for airborne and impact sound insulation between dwellings and for airborne sound insulation of facades as well as to prepare a European classification scheme with a number of quality classes”

•  Classes A-F (analogous to energy rating)

COST Action TU0901 & ISO/TC43/SC2

•  Airborne sound insulation between dwellings including from non-residential

•  Impact sound insulation between dwellings including from non-residential

•  Façade Insulation of dwelling

•  Noise from Building Services and equipment

•  Reverberation in common areas (TBC)

QUESTIONS