phillip killicoat, credit suisse: finance in the global iron ore industry
TRANSCRIPT
2
Finance in the Global Iron Ore Industry
Financing for iron ore producers
Then and now
Capital
markets
Mitigating
risks
Hedging in mine financing
Iron ore market developments
3
Trade-offs in raising capital for mining projects
Equity
Cost of capital
Mezz
Bank loan
Bonds
Flexibility
What
motivates
each type
of mining
investor?
4
Equity investors and mining
Then
Growth focus
Bubble charts
Blue sky optionality
„Leverage to the cycle‟
Now
„Cash is king‟, capex discipline
Investor demands for yield
Pressure for project curtailments, concerns of excess
supply
Credit ratings matter
5
Fixed income investors and mining
Then
Small equity buffers
Demand for higher yielding instruments
High prices masked production/construction
underperformance
Active bank loan market
Now
50% equity buffers
Basel III reg cap restrictions
Volatile prices expose
7
The rise of China has increased real price levels and volatility
Historic iron ore prices (Real terms 2010 USD)
Source: IMF, Credit Suisse
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
8
Why hedge?
A modest hedge protects profit margins for the volume hedged
Improves loan-carrying capacity by withstanding market shocks
Provides a cash flow buffer to achieve target run rate
production plans in all market conditions
Protecting [25]% of 2 year cash flows meaningfully reduces equity
dilution risk if prices were to fall again
If prices never fall, equity investors still have full upside exposure
on [75]% of production over the hedged period
If prices fall at any point you have the option to unwind the swaps
and monetise the hedge mark-to-market as cash
9
Iron ore hedging process
Set up Execution Settlement Scenarios
Security
ISDA
Unmargined
Select strategy
Volume
Price
Tenor
Low case
Mid case
High case
Monthly
Cash settled
Hedge settlement – separate physical and financial flows
* Swap level determined at time of execution
Settlement Diagram
If realised price <$125*
CS pays Miner $125
minus realised price
Financial
swap
Off-taker pays
market price
(net of freight,
quality and
agency
adjustments)
Physical
IO
delivered
to off-taker
Physical
If realised price >$125
Miner pays CS the
realised price minus $125
Miner
Customer
10
or
11
Payoff scenarios – the hedge pays the miner needs it most
0
50
100
150
200
250
Physical Financial Net
High realised price = $150/t
Operating profit
US$mm
0
50
100
150
200
250
Physical Financial Net
Low realised price = $90/t
Operating profit
US$mm
0
50
100
150
200
250
Physical Financial Net
Par realised price = $125/t
Operating profit
US$mm
12
Iron ore swaps and options volume averaged >360Mt since April
Source: SGX; LCH; CME, SMX, Credit Suisse
Iron ore swaps volume (Mt annualised)
Annualised Mt
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
abr/09 out/09 abr/10 out/10 abr/11 out/11 abr/12 out/12 abr/13 out/13
OTC SGX LCH CME SMX
Oct 2013:
* 30 Mt
* 1.4 Mt/day
* 361 Mtpa
13
Iron ore swaps and options volume averaged >360Mt since April
Source: SGX; LCH; CME, SMX, Credit Suisse
Iron ore swaps volume (Mt annualised)
Annualised Mt
Oct 2013:
* 30 Mt
* 1.4 Mt/day
* 361 Mtpa
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
abr/09 out/09 abr/10 out/10 abr/11 out/11 abr/12 out/12 abr/13 out/13
OTC SGX LCH CME SMX Dalian
Adding Dalian
* 67Mt
* 6.7 Mt/day
* 808Mtpa
Sources of liquidity across the ferrous market
Share of swaps activity by industry segment (% total volume)
Merchants,
30%
Miners,
30%
Mills, 5%
Investors,
25%
Consumer,
10%
More frequent price adjustment is passed down the value chain
Raw materials
Steel mills
Steel consumers
Iron ore
Coking coal
Alloys
Now indexed Monthly or Quarterly
From: Arbitrary adjustments in steel list price
To: raw material formula steel sales contracts
Autos / machinery
Appliances
Construction
Steel pricing basis:
Fixed conversion margin with floating IO+CC formula
16
Disclaimer
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS PROVIDED FOR INFORMATIONAL AND DISCUSSION PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT, AND MAY NOT BE RELIED ON IN ANY
MANNER AS, LEGAL, TAX OR INVESTMENT ADVICE OR AS AN OFFER TO SELL OR A SOLICITATION OF AN OFFER TO BUY AN INTEREST IN ANY FUND (A “FUND”) MANAGED
OR SPONSORED BY CREDIT SUISSE ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENTS (“CSAI”). A PRIVATE OFFERING OF INTERESTS IN A FUND WILL ONLY BE MADE PURSUANT TO A
CONFIDENTIAL PRIVATE PLACEMENT MEMORANDUM (AN “OFFERING MEMORANDUM”) AND SUCH FUND‟S SUBSCRIPTION DOCUMENTS, WHICH WILL BE FURNISHED TO
QUALIFIED INVESTORS ON A CONFIDENTIAL BASIS AT THEIR REQUEST FOR THEIR CONSIDERATION IN CONNECTION WITH SUCH OFFERING. THE INFORMATION
CONTAINED HEREIN WILL BE QUALIFIED IN ITS ENTIRETY BY REFERENCE TO SUCH OFFERING MEMORANDUM, WHICH WILL CONTAIN ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ABOUT
THE INVESTMENT OBJECTIVE, TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF AN INVESTMENT IN A FUND AND WILL ALSO CONTAIN TAX INFORMATION AND RISK DISCLOSURES THAT ARE
IMPORTANT TO ANY INVESTMENT DECISION REGARDING A FUND. NO PERSON HAS BEEN AUTHORIZED TO MAKE ANY STATEMENT CONCERNING ANY FUND OTHER
THAN AS SET FORTH IN THE RELEVANT OFFERING MEMORANDUM AND ANY SUCH STATEMENTS, IF MADE, MAY NOT BE RELIED UPON. THE INFORMATION CONTAINED
HEREIN MUST BE KEPT STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL AND MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED OR REDISTRIBUTED IN ANY FORMAT WITHOUT THE APPROVAL OF CSAI. WHEN ISSUED
IN AUSTRALIA, THE OFFER OF THESE INVESTMENTS MAY ONLY BE MADE BY WAY OF AN OFFERING MEMORANDUM ONLY TO WHOLESALE CLIENTS, AS DEFINED IN
CHAPTER 7 OF THE CORPORATIONS ACT. NOTHING IN THIS DOCUMENT PURPORTS TO BE AN OFFER OF ANY INTERESTS OR INVESTMENTS. IN ADDITION, NONE OF THE
INTERESTS ARE A REGISTERED SCHEME, AS DEFINED IN THE CORPORATIONS ACT, AND NO OFFERING MEMORANDUM WILL NOT BE LODGED WITH THE AUSTRALIAN
SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION (ASIC).
WHEN ISSUED IN THE UNITED KINGDOM, THIS DOCUMENT IS ISSUED BY CREDIT SUISSE ASSET MANAGEDMENT (LIMITED) WHICH IS AUTHORIZED AND REGULATED BY
THE FINANCIAL SERVICES AUTHORITY. THIS DOCUMENT IS DIRECTED AT PROFESSIONAL CLIENTS ONLY. IT SHOULD NOT BE DISTRIBUTED TO OR RELIED UPON BY
RETAIL CLIENTS.
WHEN ISSUED IN SWITZERLAND, THESE INVESTMENTS QUALIFY AS UNITS OF A FOREIGN COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEME IN THE SENSE OF ART. 119 OF THE SWISS
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEMES ACT (CISA). NO ACTION HAS BEEN TAKEN OR APPLICATION HAS BEEN MADE TO THE SWISS FEDERAL BANKING COMMISSION
(SFBC) FOR AUTHORIZATION OF PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION OF THESE UNITS IN OR FROM SWITZERLAND. ACCORDINGLY, THESE UNITS ARE NOT REGISTERED WITH THE
SFBC UNDER THE CISA. AS A RESULT, AN INVESTOR DOES NOT BENEFIT FROM THE SPECIFIC INVESTOR PROTECTION AND/OR SUPERVISION BY THE SFBC AFFORDED
UNDER THE CISA AND ITS IMPLEMENTING ORDINANCES. ANY OFFER OR SALE MUST THEREFORE BE IN STRICT COMPLIANCE WITH SWISS LAW AND IN PARTICULAR
WITH THE RULES OF THE CISA, ITS IMPLEMENTING ORDNANCES AND THE CIRCULAR 03/1 OF THE SFBC ON PUBLIC SOLICITATION. ACCORDINGLY, THE UNITS MAY NOT
BE OFFERED, PROMOTED, SOLD OR DISTRIBUTED TO THE PUBLIC IN OR FROM SWITZERLAND, BUT ONLY TO QUALIFIED INVESTORS IN ACCORDANCEWITH THE CISA
AND ITS IMPLEMENTING ORDINANCES. IN CONNECTION WITH THIS INVESTMENT, CREDIT SUISSE MAY PAY TO THIRD PARTIES, OR RECEIVE FROM THIRD PARTIES AS
PART OF THEIR COMPENSATION OR OTHERWISE, ONE-TIME OR RECURRING REMUNERATIONS (E.G. PLACEMENT OR HOLDING FEES). IN RECEIVING PAYMENTS BY
THIRD PARTIES CREDIT SUISSE‟S INTERESTS MAY BE ADVERSE TO THOSE OF THE HOLDERS OF THIS INVESTMENT PRODUCT AND SUCH PAYMENTS CAN AFFECT THE
INVESTORS RETURN. FURTHER INFORMATION MAY BE REQUESTED FROM YOUR RELATIONSHIP MANAGER. THIS DOCUMENT CONSTITUTES MARKETING MATERIAL AND
IS NOT THE RESULT OF A FINANCIAL ANALYSIS AND, THEREFORE, NOT SUBJECT TO THE DIRECTIVES ON THE INDEPENCE OF FINANCIAL RESEARCH (SWISS BANKERS
ASSOCIATION).
WHEN ISSUED IN HONG KONG, THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS PRESENATION HAS NOT BEEN APPROVED BY THE SECURITIES AND FUTURES COMMISSION IN
HONG KONG. ACCORDINGLY (A) INTERESTS IN A FUND MAY NOT BE OFFERED OR SOLD AND HAVE NOT BEEN OFFERED OR SOLD IN HONG KONG, BY MEANS OF ANY
DOCUMENT OTHE THAN TO (I) “PROFESSIONAL INVESTORS” AS DEFINED IN THE SECURITIES AND FUTURES ORDINANCE (CAP.571) OF HONG KONG AND ANY RULES
MADE UNDER THAT ORDINANCE; OR (II) IN OTHER CIRMCUMSTANCES WHICH DO NOT RESULT IN THE DOCUMENT BEING A “PROSPECTUS” AS DEFINED IN THE
COMPANIES ORDINANCE (CAP. 32) OF HONG KONG OR WHICH DO NOT CONSTITUTE AN OFFER TO THE PUBLIC WITHIN THE MEANING OF THAT ORDINANCE; AND (B) NO
PERSON HAS ISSUED OR HAD IN ITS POSSESSION FOR THE PURPOSES OF ISSUE, AND WILL NOT ISSUE OR HAVE IN ITS POSSESSION FOR THE PURPOSES ISSUE,
WHETHER IN HONG KONG OR ELSEWHERE, ANY ADVERTISEMENT, INVITATION OR DOCUMENT RELATING TO ANY INTEREST IN A FUND, WHICH IS DIRECTED AT, OR THE
CONTENTS OF WHICH ARE OR ARE LIKELY TO BE ACCESSED OR READ BY , THE PUBLIC IN HONG KONG (EXCEPT IF PERMITTED TO DO SO UNDER SECURITIES LAWS OF
HONG KONG) OTHER THAN WITH RESPECT TO INTERESTS IN A FUND THAT ARE OR ARE INTENDED TO BE DISPOSED OF ONLY TO PERSONS OUTSIDE HONG KONG OR
ONLY TO “PROFESSIONAL INVESTORS” WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE SECURITIES AND FUTURES ORDINANCE (CAP. 571) OF HONG KONG AND ANY RULES MADE UNDER
THAT ORDINANCE.