plane stress vs strain

Upload: wondwosen-a-lakew

Post on 04-Apr-2018

228 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    1/53

    Chapter 5

    PLANE STRESS AND PLANE STRAIN

    Many problems in theory of elasticity are two dimensional in nature and they can be modeled

    as plane stress and plane strain. On the other hand the solution of three-dimensional elaticity

    problems are generaly very difficult. If the structure enables some necessary conditions, it can

    be analyzed using a two-dimensional mathematical model.

    i. Plane Stress : A thin plate subjected to in-plane loading acting in its own plane, the

    state of stress and deformation within the plate is called plane stress, Fig. 5.1. In this

    case only two dimensions (in the plane of plate) are required for the analysis.

    ii. Plane Stress: If a long body is subjected to transverse loading and its cross section and

    loading do not vary significantly in the longitudinal direction, a small thickness in the

    loaded area can be treated as subjected to plane strain, Fig. 5.2.

    Now, strain-displacement and stress-strain relationships will be developed.

    5.1 BASIC EQUATIONS

    5.1.1 Strain-Displacement Relationships

    The displacement vector has two components for two dimensional problems.

    { }

    =v

    u(5.1)

    The strain-displacement relationships are given as follows. For a two dimensional problem,

    there will be only three independent strain components (x, y, xy) and the strain-displacementrelations, Eqs. (2.1), reduced to

    +

    =

    0xy

    0y

    0x

    xy

    y

    x

    v

    u

    xy

    y0

    0x

    (5.2)

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    2/53

    68

    Figure 5.1 A thin plate under inplane loading.

    Figure 5.2 A long cylinder under internal pressure.

    z

    yz

    x

    y

    x

    y

    z

    x

    y

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    3/53

    69

    Here the second term at the right hand side is the initial strains vector, such as thermal strains.

    The first two types, x and y, are normal strains in the x and y directions, and xy is shearingstrain. As before, they may be written in matrix form as:

    { } [ ]{ } { }= + 0 d (5.3)

    where

    [ ]

    0

    0

    x

    y

    y x

    =

    d (5.4)

    and in the case of thermal strains

    { }

    =

    =0

    1

    1

    T

    0xy

    0y

    0x

    0 (5.5)

    for plane stress problems and

    { } ( )0

    0 0

    0

    1

    1 1

    0

    x

    y

    xy

    T

    = = +

    (5.6)

    for the plane strain problems.

    5.1.2 Stress-Strain Relationships

    Assuming an isotropic material, we shall develop relationships between stresses and strains

    for both plane stress and plane strain.

    (i) Plane Stress

    0yzzxz === 0zxyz ==

    If the thermal strains are taken into the account, the 3-D strain-stress relations, given by Eq.

    (2.8), reduced to

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    4/53

    70

    ( )

    +

    +

    =

    0xy

    0y

    0x

    xy

    y

    x

    xy

    y

    x

    1200

    01

    01

    E

    1(5.7)

    In the case of plane stress, the component of strain in the z direction will be nonzero and isgiven by

    ( ) TE

    yxz ++=

    (5.8)

    Solving for stresses in terms of the strains, we find:

    ( )

    =

    0xy

    0y

    0x

    xy

    y

    x

    2

    xy

    y

    x

    2

    100

    01

    01

    1

    E(5.9)

    We can write the constitutive relations as the matrix expressions:

    { } [ ]{ } { }0C += { } [ ] { } { }( )0E = (5.10)

    where

    [ ]( )

    + =

    1200

    0101

    E

    1C and [ ]

    ( )

    =

    2

    100

    0101

    1

    EE

    2(5.11)

    For a material that is orthotropic in the x and y directions, the case of plane stress gives the

    following strain-stress and stress-strain operators:

    [ ]

    =

    xy

    yx

    xy

    y

    xy

    x

    G

    100

    0E

    1

    E

    0EE

    1

    C [ ]( )

    =

    xyyxxy

    yyyx

    xxyx

    G100

    0EE

    0EE

    E (5.12)

    Here the symbol xy denotes the strain in the x direction due to strain in the y direction. If weuse for an approximation shear modulus as

    y

    xy

    x

    yx

    xy E

    1

    E

    1

    G

    1 ++

    + (5.13)

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    5/53

    71

    we need only three independent constants.

    From the reciprocal theorem, we have

    yx

    xy

    x

    y

    E

    E

    = (5.14)

    (ii) Plane Strain

    The case of plane strain is based on the assumptions that:

    w = 0 and 0z

    w=

    at every cross section. Here the independent variables are assumed to be

    functions of only the x and y coordinates provided we consider a cross section of the body

    away from the ends.

    0zxyz == 0yzzxz ===

    If the thermal strains are taken into the account, the 3-D strain-stress relations, given by Eq.

    (2.3), reduced to

    +

    +=

    0xy

    0y

    0x

    xy

    y

    x

    xy

    y

    x

    200

    01

    01

    E

    1(5.15)

    Here, in the case of thermal strains

    { } ( )

    +=

    =0

    1

    1

    T1

    0xy

    0y

    0x

    0 (5.16)

    As before we can solve for the stresses in terms of the corresponding strains to obtain:

    ( )( )

    +

    =

    0xy

    0y

    0x

    xy

    y

    x

    xy

    y

    x

    2

    2100

    0101

    211

    E(5.17)

    The component of stress in the z-direction will be nonzero and is given by

    ( )z x y = + (5.18)

    The strain-stress operator [C] is found as

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    6/53

    72

    [ ]

    +

    =200

    01

    01

    E

    1C (5.19)

    In addition, the stress-strain operator [E] is seen from above equation to be:

    [ ]( )( )

    +=

    2

    2100

    01

    01

    211

    EE (5.20)

    On the other hand, the case of plane strain in an orthotropic material has the following strain-

    stress and stress-strain operators:

    [ ]

    0

    0

    10 0

    x y

    x y

    xy

    d b

    E E

    c a

    E E

    G

    =

    C [ ]( )

    01

    0

    0 0

    x x

    y y

    xy

    aE bE

    cE dE ad bc

    ad bc G

    =

    E (5.21)

    where

    zxxzzxyzyx

    zyxzxyzyyz

    1dc

    b1a

    =+=

    +==

    From the reciprocal theorem we find

    c

    b

    E

    E

    x

    y =

    5.2 STRESS TRANSFORMATION

    Also of interest to us are inclined stresses. For this purpose Figure shows stresses in the

    directions of axes x and y, which are inclined at the angle with axes x and y. The stressesin the inclined axes can be obtained as follows:

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    7/53

    73

    Figure 5.3 Stress transformations between the inclined axis.

    cos 2 sin 22 2

    x y x yx xy

    + = + + (5.22)

    cos 2 sin 22 2

    x y x yy xy

    + = (5.23)

    sin 2 cos 22

    x yxy xy = + (5.24)

    It is possible to find the directions of principal stresses by differentiating this equation with

    respect to q and setting the results equal to zero.

    0d

    d x =

    Hence, we obtain

    x

    x

    yy

    x

    y

    y

    xxy

    yx

    xy

    yx

    xxyyx

    y

    xxy yx y

    xxy

    y

    yx

    x

    xy

    yx

    y

    y

    yx

    x

    xy

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    8/53

    74

    yx

    xy

    P

    22tan

    = (5.25)

    Principle normal stresses and the accompanying shear stress can be obtained by substitution.

    0

    22

    22

    xy

    min

    2

    xy

    2

    yxyx

    2P

    max

    2

    xy

    2

    yxyx

    1P

    =

    =+

    +=

    =+

    +

    +=

    (5.26)

    Thus, the shearing stress is zero when the normal stresses have principal values (maximum

    and minimum)

    On the other hand, the maximum shearing stress max occurs at an angle that can be found bydifferentiating Eq. (5.24) with respect to and setting the results equal to zero, as follows:

    0d

    d yx =

    Hence,

    xy

    yxS

    22tan

    = (5.27)

    where S = P /4 is the value of for which the shearing stress is maximum. The followingexpression can be found for maximum shear stress:

    2

    xy

    2

    yx

    max2

    +

    = (5.28)

    The accompanying normal stresses as:

    2

    yx

    yx

    +== (5.29)

    5.3 TRIANGULAR ELEMENTS

    Finite elements with a triangular shape prove to be quite versatile for the purpose of

    discretizing any two dimensional continuum. One of the earliest and best-known elements is

    the constant strain triangle described by the Turner et al. In the present section stiffnesses and

    equivalent nodal loads will be developed in detail for this triangle. In addition, a brief

    description will be given for the linear strain triangle of Fraejis de Veubeke.

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    9/53

    75

    x

    y

    node i

    Q2i-1

    Q2i

    Figure 5.4 Plane problem and finite element model.

    5.3.1 Constant Strain Triangles

    Figure shows a constant strain triangle of thickness t, having the following generic

    displacements (translations) in the x-y plane:

    { }

    Tu v=

    (5.30)

    x

    y

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    10/53

    76

    Its three corners, points 1, 2, and 3, serve as nodes that are numbered in a counterclockwise

    sequence. At each node there are two nodal translations in the directions of x and y, with the

    former preceding the latter. We denote the element displacement vector as,

    { } T654321 qqqqqqq = (5.31)

    A triangular element of area A appears in the Figure and any point P(x,y) on the triangle may

    be located by dividing it into sub triangles having areas A1, A2, and A3. Dimensionless area

    coordinates for the triangle are defined as

    A

    A

    A

    A

    A

    A 221 === (5.32)

    By inspection, we see that:

    AAAA 321 =++

    Thus,

    1=++ (5.33)

    which shows that , , and are interdependent. Figure indicates that = 1 at point 1 and =0 along edge 2-3. Also indicated is a linear variation of from point 1 to the opposite edge,and similarly for and .

    The displacements inside the element are now written using the shape functions and the nodalvalues of the unknown displacement field.

    1 1 2 3 3 5

    1 2 2 4 3 6

    u N q N q N q

    v N q N q N q

    = + +

    = + +(5.34)

    Figure 5.5 Constant strain triangles.

    (x3, y3)q5

    q6

    3

    (x1, y1)q1

    q2

    1

    (x2, y2)q3

    q4

    2

    x

    (x, y)e

    u

    v

    te

    Ae

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    11/53

    77

    N3 = 1- = 1

    1

    N3

    2

    3

    x

    Figure 5.6 Natural coordinates.

    Figure 5.7 Shape functions of CST.

    3

    = 01

    2

    x

    (x, y)

    = 1

    = 0

    = 1A1

    A2

    A3

    N1 = = 1

    1

    N1

    2

    3

    x

    N2 = = 1

    1

    N2

    2

    3

    x

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    12/53

    78

    The independent shape functions are conveniently represented by the pair, , as follows

    === 1NNN 321 (5.35)

    The relations can be expressed in a matrix format

    { } [ ]{ }= N q (5.36)

    where [N] is the shape function matrix, given by

    [ ] 1 2 31 2 3

    0 0 0

    0 0 0

    N N N

    N N N

    =

    N (5.37)

    If we substitute Eq. (5.36) into the strain-displacement relations, we obtain

    { } [ ][ ] [ ][ ]{ } [ ]{ }

    0

    0

    x

    u

    vy

    y x

    = = = =

    N q B q (5.38)

    The strain-displacement matrix [B] can be written as

    { } [ ]{ } 1 2 31 2 3

    31 2

    31 2

    3 31 1 2 2

    0

    0 0 00

    0 0 0

    0 0 0

    0 0 0

    x

    N N N

    N N Ny

    y x

    NN N

    x x x

    NN N

    y y y

    N NN N N N

    y x y x y x

    = =

    =

    B N

    (5.39)

    A finite element is said to be isoparametric if the same interpolation formulas define both the

    geometric and the displacement shape functions. Such elements satisfy both geometric and

    displacement compatibility conditions. If the geometric interpolation functions are of lower

    than the displacement shape functions, the element is called subparametric. If the reverse istrue, the element is referred to as superparametric.

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    13/53

    79

    Because isoparametric elements are usually curved, they tend to be more suitable than

    subparametric elements for modeling geometric boundary conditions. However, strain-

    displacement relationships are complicated by the fact that generic displacements are

    expressed in terms of local coordinates, whereas differentiations with respect to the global

    coordinates are required. Also, it becomes necessary to employ numerical integration

    whenever explicit integrations are impossible.

    For the triangular element, the coordinates x, y can also be represented in terms of nodal

    coordinates using the same shape functions, as follows

    1 1 2 2 3 3

    1 1 2 2 3 3

    x N x N x N x

    y N y N y N y

    = + +

    = + +(5.40)

    In matrix form we may write

    =

    3

    3

    2

    2

    1

    1

    321

    321

    y

    x

    y

    x

    yx

    N0N0N0

    0N0N0N

    y

    x(5.41)

    Using the notation, xij = xi xj and yij = yi yj we can write Eq. (5.40) as

    13 23 3

    13 23 3

    x x x x

    y y y y

    = + += + +

    (5.42)

    This equation relates x and y coordinates to the and coordinates.

    Using the chain rule for partial derivatives of shape functions, we have

    i i i

    i i i

    N N Nx y

    x y

    N N N y

    x y

    = +

    = +

    i = 1,2,3 (5.43)

    which can be written in matrix notation as

    i i

    ii

    N x y N

    x

    NN x y

    y

    =

    i = 1,2,3 (5.44)

    where the (2 x 2) square matrix is denoted as the Jacobian of the transformation, [ J]:

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    14/53

    80

    [ ] 13 1323 23

    x y

    y

    x yx y

    = =

    J (5.45)

    Also, from Eq. (5.44),

    11 12

    21 22

    ii

    i i

    NN

    x

    N N

    y

    =

    i = 1,2,3 (5.46)

    where [ ] is the inverse of the Jacobian [J], given by

    [ ] [ ][ ]

    1 23 13

    23 13

    1

    det

    y y

    x x

    = = J

    J(5.47)

    det[J] = x13y23 x23y13

    From the knowledge of the area of the triangle, it can be seen that the magnitude of det [J] is

    twice the area of the triangle. If the points 1, 2, and 3 are ordered in a counterclockwise

    manner, det [J] is positive sign. We have

    [ ]1 det2A = J (5.48)

    where represents the magnitude. Most computer codes use a counterclockwise order for

    the nodes and use det [J] for evaluating the area.

    Let us write Eq. (5.46) in following expanded form,

    [ ] [ ]

    31 231 2

    11 12

    31 2 21 22 31 2

    G L

    NN NNN N

    x x x

    NN N NN N

    y y y

    = D D

    144424443 144424443

    (5.49)

    where [DG] and [DL] are the matrices of global and local derivatives of shape functions,

    respectively. Substitution of Eqs.(5.35) and (5.47) into Eq. (5.49) yields

    [ ] 23 13 23 13 13 2323 13 23 13 23 13

    1 0 11 1

    0 1 1G

    y y y y y y

    x x x x x

    = =

    DJ J

    Considering xij = xji and xi,j xkj = xik, we obtain the global derivatives as follows

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    15/53

    81

    [ ] 23 31 1232 13 21

    1G

    y y y

    x x

    ==

    D

    J

    The matrix [B] given by Eq. (5.39) can be written in terms of the global derivatives.

    [ ]11 12 13

    21 22 23

    21 11 22 12 23 13

    0 0 0

    0 0 0

    G G G

    G G G

    G G G G G G

    D D D

    D D D

    D D D D D D

    =

    B (5.50)

    After the multiplication we obtain element strain-displacement matrix,

    [ ]23 31 12

    32 13 2132 23 13 31 21 12

    0 0 01

    0 0 0

    y y y

    x x

    y x y x y

    =

    BJ

    (5.51)

    Here [B] is a (3 x 6) matrix relating the three strains to the six nodal displacements. It may benoted that all the elements of the [B] matrix are constants expressed in terms of the nodal

    coordinates. The element stiffness matrix given by

    [ ] [ ] [ ][ ] [ ] [ ][ ]e e

    T T

    V V

    dV dV = = k B E B B E B

    Considering eeV

    AtdVe

    = we obtain the stiffness matrix as

    [ ] [ ] [ ][ ]Te et A=k B E B (5.52)

    Equivalent Nodal Forces

    Now, the equivalent nodal loads due to the body forces and surface tractions will becalculated using the finite element formulations.

    The vector of body forces is

    { } [ ] { }dVbNf TV

    be

    =

    where

    { }

    =y

    x

    b

    bb and dV = tedA

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    16/53

    82

    Figure 5.8 Body forces and equivalent nodal forces on a CST.

    { } dA

    bN

    bN

    bN

    bN

    bN

    bN

    tdAb

    b

    N0

    0N

    N0

    0N

    N0

    0N

    tfee A

    y3

    x3

    y2

    x2

    y1

    x1

    e

    y

    x

    T

    A

    3

    3

    2

    2

    1

    1

    eb

    =

    = (5.53)

    The force components, bx and by, can be expressed in terms of and using the isoparametricformulation.

    Integrals of polynomial terms in the area coordinates and can be obtained as follows [2]:

    ( ) ec

    A

    ba A2!2cba

    !c!b!adA

    e+++

    =

    If c = 0, it becomes

    ( ) eA

    ba A2!2ba

    !b!adA

    e++

    =

    If the body force is constant, we need the integrations of dAN

    eA

    i . For N1 = , we calculate the

    integral as follows:

    ( ) eeA

    1 A3

    1A2

    !201

    !0!1dA

    e

    =++

    =

    Similarly, eA

    3

    A

    2 A3

    1dANdAN

    ee

    == . Hence, the body force vector is given as,

    1

    2

    3

    fb1

    fb2

    fb3

    fb4

    fb5

    fb6

    b(x,y)

    x

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    17/53

    83

    { } Tyxyxyxeeb bbbbbb3

    tAf = (5.54)

    A traction force is distributed load acting on the surface of the body. We can integrate the

    traction force to obtain a distributed load on the midline of the surface.

    et = (5.55)

    Consider an edge 2 3 acted on by traction ,x y , shown in Fig. 5.7. We have

    { } [ ] { }2 3

    T

    s

    l

    f N dl

    = (5.56)

    where

    { } xy

    = (5.57)

    Substituting Eqs. (5.37) and (5.57) into Eq. (5.56) we obtain

    Figure 5.9 Surface tractions and equivalent nodal forces on a CST.

    1

    2

    3

    fs1

    fs2

    fs3

    fs4

    fs5

    fs6

    x,

    x

    y

    x

    y ( ),x y

    x

    y

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    18/53

    84

    { } 2 3 2 3

    11

    11

    22

    22

    3 3

    3 3

    0

    0

    0

    0

    0

    0

    Tx

    y

    x x

    s y yl l

    x

    y

    NN

    NN

    NNf dl dl

    NN

    N N

    N N

    = =

    (5.58)

    If the traction force is constant, we need the integrations of ll

    j-i

    dN i . We note here that N1 = 0

    along the edge 2 - 3 and 0l

    3-l

    =2

    dN1

    On the other hand, for N2 = and li-j = l2-3 we calculate the integral as follows:

    ( ) 3-23-2l

    lll

    3-2

    2

    1

    !1010

    !0!1!0d010 =

    +++=

    Similarly,( ) 3-23-2

    ll

    llll

    3-23-2

    2

    1

    !1100

    !1!0!0ddN3 =+++

    = . Hence, the vector of surface forces is given

    as,

    { } 2 3 0 02T

    x y x yl = sf (5.59)

    We may designate the element temperature load as

    { } [ ] [ ]{ }e

    T

    V

    dV= T 0f B E

    where {0} is initial strain vector due to the temperature change, T. From the theory ofelasticity, {0} can be represented by

    { }0

    0

    0

    1

    1

    0

    x

    y

    xy

    T

    = =

    0 (5.60)

    for plane stress and

    { } ( )

    0

    0

    0

    1

    1 10

    x

    y

    xy

    T

    = = + 0

    (5.61)

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    19/53

    85

    for plane strain.

    If the temperature change is constant on the element the integration may be performed as

    { } [ ] [ ]{ } [ ] [ ]{ }e

    T Te e

    V

    dV A t = =T 0 0f B E B E (5.62)

    The stresses in an element are then obtained by using following equation:

    { } [ ] { } { }( ) [ ] [ ]{ } { }( )= = 0 0 E E B q (5.63)

    Finally, we may use the constant strain triangles in order to model a thin plate subjected to

    inplane loads, given in Fig. 5.4. We need to arrange two tables for nodal coordinates andelement connectivity.

    Table 5.1 Element connectivity for the FE model given in Fig. 5.4.

    Elements Nodes

    1 11 12 13

    2 14 11 13

    3 13 4 14

    4 12 7 13

    5 11 1 12

    6 2 11 14

    7 5 2 14

    8 6 5 14

    9 4 6 14

    10 8 4 13

    11 7 8 13

    12 9 7 12

    13 10 9 12

    14 1 10 12

    15 3 1 11

    16 2 3 11

    Table 5.2 Nodal coordinates for the FE model given in Fig. 5.4.

    NODE X Y Z

    1 0.15 -0.4 0

    2 -0.3 -0.2 0

    3 -9.77E-02 -0.351 0

    4 5.00E-02 0.4 0

    5 -0.39993 9.50E-02 0

    6 -0.25379 0.36834 0

    7 0.4 0.1 0

    8 0.25992 0.2914 0

    9 0.44994 -0.11375 0

    10 0.34652 -0.3001 0

    11 -1.91E-04 -0.15168 0

    12 0.2518 -0.13182 0

    13 0.14752 0.10795 014 -0.12607 0.10327 0

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    20/53

    86

    500 N/mm

    40 kN

    200 mm

    300 mm

    The nodal coordinates are stored in a two-dimensional array represented by the total number

    of nodes and the two coordinates per node. The connectivity may be clearly seen by isolatinga typical element, as shown in Fig. 5.5. For the three nodes designated locally as 1,2, and 3,

    the corresponding global node numbers are defined in Fig. 5.4. This element connectivityinformation becomes an array of the size of number of elements and three nodes per element.

    A typical connectivity representation is shown in Table 5.2. Most standard finite elementcodes use the convention of going around the element in a counterclockwise direction toavoid calculating a negative area.

    Example 5.1 For the two-dimensional loaded plate shown in Figure E5.1, determine the

    displacements of points A and B and the element stresses using plane stress conditions. Body

    force may be neglected in comparison to the external forces. The thickness of plate is 5 mm,the Young modulus is 70 GPa and, the Poisson ratio is 0.3.

    A

    Figure E5.1-a

    Solution:

    Finite element model is depicted in Fig. E5.1-b.

    Figure E5.1-b

    Q6

    1

    Q7

    3

    2

    1Q8

    Q1

    Q2

    Q3

    Q4

    Q52

    4

    y

    x

    B

    A

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    21/53

    87

    3

    1

    1

    2

    4

    2

    3

    1

    2

    3

    For the plane stress conditions, the material property matrix is given by

    [ ] ( )

    =

    =69.200069.731.2

    031.269.7

    10

    2

    100

    01

    01

    1

    E

    E4

    2

    Figure E5.1-c

    In Fig. E5.1-c, the bold numbers are the global ones and the others are the local numbers.

    Then, we establish the connectivity as follows

    Element Number Nodes

    1 2 3

    1 1 2 4

    2 3 4 2

    The table of nodal coordinates for the coordinate system depicted in Fig. E5.1-b, is given in

    the following table

    Node

    Number

    x

    (mm)

    y

    (mm)

    1 300 0

    2 300 200

    3 0 200

    4 0 0

    We found first Jacobian matrices for the elements:

    [ ]

    =

    =

    200300

    0300

    yx

    yxJ

    2323

    13131 and [ ] 241 mm10x6200300

    0300Jdet ==

    [ ]

    =

    =

    200300

    0300

    yx

    yxJ

    2323

    13132 and [ ] 242 mm10x6200300

    0300Jdet =

    =

    The strain-nodal displacement matrices [Be] can be determined as

    Local numbers

    Global numbers

    2

    1

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    22/53

    88

    [ ]

    =

    200323

    003030

    020002

    10x6

    1B

    2

    1

    [ ]

    =

    200323

    003030

    020002

    10x6

    1B

    2

    2

    On performing the matrix multiplication [E][B]e , we get

    [ ] 1 427.69 2.31 0 2 0 0 0 2 0

    110 2.31 7.69 0 0 3 0 3 0 0

    6 100 0 2.69 3 2 3 0 0 2

    256 115.5 0 115.5 256 0

    77 384.5 0 384.5 77 0

    134.5 89.7 134.5 0 0 89.7

    E Bx

    =

    =

    [ ][ ]

    =

    7.89005.1347.895.134

    0775.38405.38477

    02565.11505.115256

    BE2

    The stiffness matrices can be calculated as

    [ ]1 1 11 1 2

    3

    2 0 3

    0 3 2256 115.5 0 115.5 256 0

    0 0 330000 577 384.5 0 384.5 77 0

    0 3 06 10134.5 89.7 134.5 0 0 89.7

    2 0 0

    0 0 2

    229 125 101 57.8 128.2 67.2

    125 333 67.2 288.4 57.8 4

    10

    T xk A t B E B

    x

    = =

    =

    4.8

    101 67.2 101 0 0 67.2

    57.8 288.4 0 288.4 57.8 0

    128.2 57.8 0 57.8 128.2 0

    67.2 44.8 67.2 0 0 44.8

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    23/53

    89

    [ ] [ ] [ ][ ]

    ==

    8.44002.678.442.67

    02.1288.5708.572.128

    08.574.28804.2888.57

    2.67001012.67101

    8.448.574.2882.67333125

    2.672.1288.57101125229

    10BEBtAk32T2

    22

    2

    In the above matrices, the global dof association is shown on top. In the problem under

    consideration, Q2, Q5, Q6, Q7, and Q8 are all zero. Using the elimination approach, it is now

    sufficient to consider the stiffness associated with the degrees of freedom Q1, Q3, Q4. Theforce vector due to the distributed load on the 3-1 edge of element 2 can be calculated as:

    { } 3 1300

    0 0 0 500 0 0 0 5002 2

    T Tx y x y

    l = = 2sf

    The forces are neglected. A concentrated load of 40 kN is applied in the direction of Q1.

    The set of equations is given by the matrix representation

    =

    75

    0

    40

    10

    Q

    Q

    Q

    33308.57

    0229101

    8.57101229

    10 3

    4

    3

    1

    3

    Solving for Q1, Q

    3and Q

    4, we get

    Q1 = 0.30326 mm, Q3 = 0.13361 mm, Q4 = -0.27749 mm

    For element 1, the element nodal displacement vector is given by

    { } T1 0027749.013361.00030326.0q =

    The element stresses 1 are calculated from [E][B] 1{q}1 as

    { } MPa839.22398.83742.45

    T1 =

    Similarly

    { } T2 27749.013361.00000q =

    The element stresses 2 are calculated from [E][B] 2{q}2 as

    { } MPa903.24277.10258.34 T2 =

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    24/53

    90

    5.3.2 Linear Strain Triangles

    The linear strain triangles in the Figure 5.10 have a constant thickness t and the followinggeneric displacements.

    { } Tvu=

    In addition to the three corner nodes (numbered 1, 2, and 3), there are also three mid-edgenodes (numbered 4, 5, and 6). The linear strain triangle is shown in Fig. 5.12(a) with its

    natural coordinates, and its isoparametric counterpart element appears in Fig. 5.12(b). We willapproach this isoparametric element by first examining its straight-sided parent. Nodal

    displacements for either element are:

    Figure 5.10 Element T6. (a) Triangular parent (LST) (b) Isoparametric counterpart.

    = 03

    vi

    i

    1

    q22

    x

    y

    (x, y)

    uv

    ui

    q14

    5

    6

    = = 1

    = 0

    = 1

    = 0 = 1

    =

    =

    = 03

    vi

    i

    1

    q22

    x

    y

    (x, y)

    u

    v

    ui

    q14

    5

    6

    =

    = 1

    = 0

    = 1

    = 0 = 1

    = =

    (a)

    (b)

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    25/53

    91

    { } T611T

    1221 v,...,vuq,...,qq == (5.64)

    Geometric interpolation functions for the parent element are linear, as is the case for any

    triangle with straight sides. Quadratic displacement shape functions may be written in naturalcoordinates as:

    ==

    ==6

    1i

    ii

    6

    1i

    ii vNvuNu (5.65)

    where

    4N)12(N

    4N)12(N

    4N)12(N

    63

    52

    41

    ======

    (5.66)

    The strain-displacement matrix can be written as follows

    { } [ ]{ } 1 2 61 2 6

    61 2

    61 2

    6 61 1 2 2

    0

    0 0 00

    0 0 0

    0 0 0

    0 0 0

    x

    N N N

    N N Ny

    y x

    NN N

    x x x

    NN N

    y y y

    N NN N N N

    y x y x y x

    = =

    =

    ...B d N

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    (5.67)

    Eq. (5.67) can be written in the format

    { } [ ] [ ] [ ]{ }{ }

    { }

    1

    21 2 6

    6

    =

    q

    qB B ... B

    q

    (5.68)

    and hence it can be concisely expressed as:

    { } [ ] { }iii qB= (i = 1,2,3,4) (5.69)

    where

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    26/53

    92

    [ ] [ ][ ]

    =

    ==

    x

    N

    y

    N

    y

    N0

    0x

    N

    N0

    0N

    xy

    y0

    0x

    NB

    ii

    i

    i

    i

    i

    ii (5.70)

    (i) Subparametric Triangles: The derivatives in the strain-displacement relationships are

    found by using the linear interpolations for the geometry given by Eqs. (5.40) through (5.42).The global derivatives can be obtained the same relation given with Eq. (5.46) on condition

    with the upper index 3 changed to 6.

    11 12

    21 22

    ii

    i i

    NN

    x

    N Ny

    =

    i = 1,2,,6

    where the shape functions are the ones given in Eq. (5.66).

    (ii) Isoparametric Triangles: For the isoparametric triangle T6 in Fig 3.12(b), we take thegeometric interpolation functions to be:

    ==

    ==6

    1i

    ii

    6

    1i

    ii yNyxNx (5.71)

    where Ni are given by Eqs. (5.5-7). Thus, the edges of the element become quadratic curves,as indicated in the figure. Because the natural coordinates are curvilinear, the Jacobian matrix

    is required. Thus,

    [ ]

    6 6

    1 1

    6 6

    1 1

    i ii i

    i i

    i ii i

    i i

    N Nx yx y

    x y N Nx y

    = =

    = =

    = =

    J (5.72)

    For the T6 element, the Jacobian matrix is

    [ ]

    [ ]

    [ ]

    1 1

    2 23 5 61 2 4

    3 3

    4 43 5 61 2 4

    5 5

    6 6L

    N

    x y

    x yN N NN N N

    y

    x yN N NN N N

    x y

    x y

    =

    D

    C

    J

    14444444244444443

    14243

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    27/53

    93

    Here, [DL] matrix can be evaluated using the shape functions given by Eq. (5.66).

    [ ] ( )( )4 1 0 4 4 3 4 4 4 1 3

    0 4 1 4 4 3 4 4 1 3 4L

    + = +

    D

    The inverse of the Jacobian matrix, [], has already given by Eq. (5.47), and is repeated here.

    [ ] [ ][ ]

    ==

    1121

    12221

    JJ

    JJ

    Jdet

    1J

    The matrix of global derivatives is given as follows

    [ ] [ ][ ]G L=D D

    The terms of this matrix can be determined as

    ( ) ( )

    ( ) ( )

    ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

    [ ] [ ]

    ( ) ( )

    ( )

    11 22 21 21

    12 12 22 11

    13 22 12 23 11 21

    14 22 12 24 21 11

    15 22 12 25 21 11

    16 22

    1 14 1 4 1

    1 14 1 4 1

    1 14 4 3 4 4 3

    4 4

    4 41 3 1 3

    41 3

    G G

    G G

    G G

    G G

    G G

    G

    D J D J

    D J D J

    D J J D J J

    D J J D J J

    D J J D J J

    D J

    = =

    = =

    = + = +

    = = +

    = = +

    =

    J J

    J J

    J J

    J J

    J J

    J( )12 26 21 11

    41 3GJ D J J + = J

    (5.73)

    Referring to Eqs. (5.73), we see that the submatrix [B]i may also be written as follows:

    [ ]1

    2

    2 1

    0

    0

    0 0

    i

    G ii

    G ii

    G i G ii i

    N

    x DN

    Dy

    D DN N

    y x

    = =

    B i = 1,2,3,4 (5.74)

    The matrix [B] is a (3 x 12) element strain-displacement matrix relating the three strains to the

    twelve nodal displacements.

    Then the stiffness matrix for the element is obtained from:

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    28/53

    94

    [ ] [ ] [ ][ ]e

    T

    e

    A

    t dA= k B E B

    Hence, the element stiffness matrix given by

    [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ]12 3 3 3 3 12 12 3 3 3 3 12

    ee

    T T

    ex x x x x x

    AV

    dV t dA= = k B E B B E B (5.75)

    Integration in the Natural Coordinates:

    In order to obtain any term of the stiffness matrix, the type of integration to be performed as:

    ( )dxdy,fI = (5.76)

    However, the integral in Eq. (5.76) is more easily evaluated if it is first transformed to the

    natural coordinates and . In addition the limits of each integration must be changed tobecome 1 to 1; and the infinitesimal area dA = dxdy must be replaced by an appropriate

    expression in terms of d and d. For this purpose Fig. 5.11 shows an infinitesimal area dA inthe natural coordinates. Vector r locates a generic point in the Cartesian coordinates x and y as

    follows:

    jiyxr yx +=+= (5.77)

    The rate of change of r with respect to is:

    Figure 5.11 Infinitesimal area in naturel coordinates.

    y

    y

    r

    dA

    dr

    r

    +

    dy

    dx

    dy

    dx

    d

    r

    dr

    i

    k

    dr

    r

    +

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    29/53

    95

    jir

    +

    = yx

    (5.78)

    Also, the rate of change of r with respect to is:

    jir

    +

    = yx

    (5.79)

    When multiplied by d and d, the derivatives in Eqs. (5.78) and (5.79) form two adjacentsides of the infinitesimal parallelogram of area dA in the figure. This area may be determined

    from the following vector triple product:

    krr

    =

    dxddA (5.80)

    Substitution of Eqs. (5.78) and (5.79) into Eq. (5.80) gives:

    ddyxyx

    dA

    = (5.81)

    The expression in the parentheses of Eq. (5.81) may be written as a determinant. That is,

    x y

    dA d d d d x y

    = =

    J (5.82)

    in which [J] is the Jacobian matrix and det[J] is its determinant. Thus, the new form of the

    integral in Eq. (5.77) becomes:

    ( ) ddJ,fI1

    1

    1

    1

    = (5.83)

    Gaussian quadrature procedure will be applied for the numerical integration. For triangles in

    natural coordinates the numerical integration formula is [4]:

    ( )=

    =n

    1j

    jj,fWAI (5.84)

    in which Wj is the weighting factor for the jth sampling point. Integration points for n = 1, 3,

    and 4 appear in Fig 5.12, and their locations and weighting factors are given in Table 5.3.

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    30/53

    96

    Figure 5.12 Integration points for n = 1,3, and 4.

    Table 5.3 The locations of integration points and weighting factors.

    N Order Points Wj1 Linear a

    31

    31 1

    3 Quadratic

    a2

    1 2

    1 3

    1

    b 0 21

    31

    c21 0 3

    1

    4 Cubic

    a31

    31

    4827

    b 0.6 0.2 4825

    c 0.2 0.6 4825

    d 0.2 0.2 4825

    5.4 QUADRILATERAL ELEMENTS

    5.4.1 Bilinear Displacement Rectangle

    In two-dimensional problems the isoparametric quadrilaterals serve a useful purpose. This

    element is the isoparametric parent of the bilinear displacement rectangle, developed by

    Melosh [6]. The elements depicted in Fig. 5.13. The generic displacements indicated in the

    figure are:

    { } Tv,u=

    An x and a y translation are shown at each node. Thus, the nodal displacement vector is:

    { } T411T

    821 v,...,v,u,q,...,q,qq == (5.85)

    Now let us assume the following displacement functions

    =

    =

    =+++=

    =+++=

    6

    1iii44332211

    6

    1i

    ii44332211

    vNuNuNuNuNv

    uNuNuNuNuNu

    (5.86)

    1

    2

    3

    1

    2

    3

    1

    2

    3

    a

    a

    a

    b

    b

    cc

    d

    Linear Quadratic Cubic

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    31/53

    97

    in which N1, N2, N3, and N4 are the interpolation functions and they are given as follows:

    ( )( ) ( )( )( )( ) ( )( )

    +=++=

    +==

    11N11N

    11N11N

    41

    441

    3

    41

    241

    1(5.87)

    We may write in the matrix form:

    { }

    =

    =

    8

    2

    1

    4321

    4321

    q

    q

    q

    N0N0N0N0

    0N0N0N0N

    v

    u

    M (5.88)

    Figure 5.13 Bilinear displacement rectangle and its isoparametric quadrilateral.

    x

    y

    =-1

    q7

    q2

    q1

    q4

    q3

    q5

    q6

    v u

    q8

    = - =

    = -

    =

    =0

    = 0 = -1

    = 1

    = 1

    1

    2

    3

    4

    q1q2

    q4q3

    q5

    q6q

    8

    q7

    = y/b

    = y/bu

    v

    2a

    2b

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    32/53

    98

    Eq. (5.88) can be arranged as follows

    { } [ ]{ } [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ]

    { }{ }{ }{ }

    1

    2

    1 2 3 43

    4

    = =

    q

    qN q N N N N

    q

    q

    (5.89)

    or it may be written in a concise form as

    { } [ ] { }iii qN= (i = 1,2,3,4) (5.90)

    For example, for node 1 we may write following equations:

    { } [ ] { }111 qN= (5.91)

    1 1 11

    1 2 21

    0 1 0

    0 0 1

    N q quN

    N q qv

    = =

    (5.92)

    The generic displacements {}i in Eq. (5.91) represent the translations at any point due to thedisplacements {q}i at node i. As a further efficiency of notation, we can write the functions N i

    as

    ( )( )00i 114

    1N ++= (5.93)

    where

    0 = 0 = (i = 1,2,3,4) (5.94)

    [B] matrix can be expressed as:

    { } [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ]{ }{ }{ }{ }

    1

    2

    1 2 3 43

    4

    =

    qq

    B B B Bq

    q

    (5.95)

    This relation can be concisely expressed as:

    { } [ ] { }i i i

    = B q (i = 1,2,3,4) (5.96)

    where

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    33/53

    99

    [ ] [ ][ ]

    00

    00 0

    0

    i

    i i

    i ii

    i i

    N

    xx

    N N

    Ny y

    N N

    y x y x

    = = =

    B N (5.97)

    In the isoparametric formulation, we use the same shape functions N i to also express the

    coordinates of a point within the element in terms of nodal coordinates. Thus,

    1 1 2 2 3 3 4 4

    1 1 2 2 3 3 4 4

    x N x N x N x N x

    y N y N y N y N y

    = + + += + + +

    (5.98)

    In matrix form we may write

    =

    4

    4

    3

    3

    2

    2

    1

    1

    4321

    4321

    y

    x

    y

    x

    y

    x

    y

    x

    N0N0N0N0

    0N0N0N0N

    y

    x(5.99)

    The Jacobian matrix, [J], is given as follows:,

    [ ]

    =

    =

    ==

    ==4

    1i

    ii

    4

    1i

    ii

    4

    1i

    ii

    4

    1i

    ii

    yN

    xN

    yN

    xN

    yx

    yx

    J

    (5.100)

    From Eqs. 6.2.1 and 6.2.2, for the special case of four-node plane element

    [ ] [ ]{ }L N=J D C (5.101)

    The matrix [DL] given by this expression consists of derivatives of N i with respect to local

    coordinates. That is,

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    34/53

    100

    [ ] ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

    31 2 4

    31 2 4

    1 1 1 11

    1 1 1 14L

    NN N N

    NN N N

    + +

    = = + +

    D (5.102)

    [CN] is the matrix of nodal coordinates as follows

    [ ]

    1 1

    2 2

    3 3

    4 4

    N

    x y

    y

    x y

    y

    =

    C

    The matrix [DG] given by this expression consists of derivatives of Ni with respect to globalcoordinates. It can be written in terms of local derivatives of shape functions using the inverse

    of the Jacobian matrix, [ ].

    [ ] [ ][ ]

    31 2 4

    31 2 4

    G L

    NN N N

    x x xx

    NN N N

    y y y y

    = =

    D D (5.103)

    Evaulating terms in [DG] yields:

    ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

    ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

    ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

    ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

    11 22 12 21 21 11

    12 22 12 22 21 11

    13 22 12 23 21 11

    14 22 12 24 21 11

    1 11 1 1 1

    4 4

    1 11 1 1 1

    4 4

    1 11 1 1 1

    4 4

    1 11 1 1 14 4

    G G

    G G

    G G

    G G

    D J J D J J

    D J J D J J

    D J J D J J

    D J J D J J

    = + =

    = + + = +

    = + + = + + +

    = + = + +

    J J

    J J

    J J

    J J

    (5.104)

    By this approach we can find all the terms in [DG] numerically.

    Because of the appearance of the determinant of [J] in denominator positions, we usually

    cannot integrate explicitly to obtain stiffnesses and equivalent nodal loads. Instead, it becomes

    necessary to use numerical integration.

    Then, we can obtain the submatrix [B]i using Eqs. (5.104) as follows

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    35/53

    101

    [ ]1

    2

    2 1

    0

    0

    G i

    G ii

    G i G i

    D

    D

    D D

    =

    B i = 1,2,3,4 (5.105)

    After determining the [B] matrix, we express the stiffness matrix for Q4 element (withconstant thickness t) in Cartesian coordinates. Thus,

    [ ] ( ) [ ] ( ) ( )1 1

    3 38 3 3 81 1

    , , ,T

    e xx xt d d

    = k B E B J (5.106)

    Similarly, equivalent nodal loads due to body forces may be written in natural coordinates as:

    [ ] ( ) ( ) ( )1 1

    8 2 2 11 1

    , , ,T

    b e x xt d d

    = f N b J (5.107)

    In addition, equivalent nodal loads due to initial strains in natural coordinates are:

    [ ] ( ) [ ] ( ) ( )1 1

    0 3 38 3 3 11 1

    , , ,T

    e xx xt d d

    = 0f B E J (5.108)

    Except in special cases, the integrals in Eqs. (5.107) and (5.108) must be performed by

    numerical integration. However, if the element is rectangular, direct explicit integration may

    be used. Also, line loadings with or constant may be handled by explicit line integrations.Of course, if the body forces consist of point loads, no integration is required at all.

    Furthermore, note that the determinant of the Jacobian matrix appears in the denominators of

    all the terms in matrix [B]. Therefore, the determinant J in Eq. (5.108) cancels throughout;so the equivalent loads for initial strains may be integrated either explicitly or numerically. If

    a temperature change T varies bilinearly, it is defined as:

    =

    =4

    1i

    ii TNT

    Numerical Integration

    For quadrilaterals in natural coordinates, the type of integration to be performed as

    ( ) ddJ,fI1

    1

    1

    1

    =

    Two successive applications of Gaussian quadrature produce:

    ( ) ( )kjkjn

    1k

    n

    1j

    kj ,J,fRRI = = =

    (5.109)

    where Rj and Rkare weighting factors for the point (j, k). Integration points for n = 1,2,3each way on a quadrilateral are shown in Fig. 5.5.

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    36/53

    102

    x

    y

    (7,1)

    1

    2

    3

    4

    (20,5)

    (14,14)

    (5,10)

    G1

    G2

    G3

    G4

    Figure 5.14 Integration points for n = 1,3, and 4.

    Table 5.4 The locations of integration points and weighting factors for quadrilaterals.

    n k Rj Rk1 0 0 2 2

    2 3

    1 3

    1 1 1

    3

    0.7745966692 0.7745966692 0.5555555556 0.5555555556

    0.0 0.0 0.8888888889 0.8888888889

    Example:

    Derive numerically the stiffness term k12

    for the isoparametric Q4 element in the

    figure, using Gaussian integration with n = 2

    each way. Assume that thickness t is

    constant .The coordinates of nodes are given

    in the figure.

    Solution:

    The formula for numerical integration of

    terms in [k] is:

    [ ] ( ) [ ] ( ) ( )3 38 3 3 81 1

    , , ,n n T

    e j k j k j k j k xx xk j

    t R R = =

    = k B E B J

    Matrices [B] and [J] in this expression are functions of the coordinates j and kfor theintegration points (or Gauss points) G1, G2, G3, and G4 shown in the figure. In particular, for

    k12 with n = 2, Rj = Rk= 1 so that

    [ ] [ ] [ ]12 1,1 3 3 1,2

    1 1

    n nT

    e xk j

    k t = == B E B J

    1

    2

    3

    4

    1

    2

    3

    4

    1

    2

    3

    4

    n = 1 n = 2 n = 3

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    37/53

    103

    In this formula the symbol [B]1,1 denotes the first column of submatrix [B]1 and [B]1,2 is the

    second column. Substituting these columns in above equation, we obtain:

    ( )12 12 33 11 211 1

    n n

    e G G

    k j

    k t E E D D= =

    = + J

    in which the terms E12 and E33 are left in unspecified form.

    To evaluate this equation, we first calculate Jacobian matrix as:

    [ ] [ ][ ] ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

    7 1

    1 1 1 1 20 5 11 2 41 1

    1 1 1 1 14 14 4 2 94 2

    5 10

    L N

    + + = = = + +

    J D C

    Then the determinant of J is:

    ( )1 115 18 84

    = +J

    Terms required from DG are:

    ( ) ( )( )

    ( ) ( )( )

    ( )

    11 22 12

    21 21 11

    1 5 9 41 1

    4 2 115 18 8

    3 5 2 31

    1 14 2 115 18 8

    G

    G

    D J J

    D J J

    + = + = +

    + +

    = = +

    J

    J

    Evaluating the product DG11DG21| J | at each of the four integration points and summing the

    results can be obtained as:

    ( )3312e12 EEt1578.0k +=

    which can be finalized using numerical values of t, E12, and E33.

    5.4.2 Isoparametric Quadrilateral

    Figure 5.15(a) shows the rectangular parent of the isoparametric quadrilateral (Q8) element,

    which appears in Fig. 5.15(b). In order to understand this higher-order isoparametric element,

    it is helpful to study first its rectangular parent. Nodal displacements for either element consist

    of x and y translations at each node. Thus,

    { } TT vvuqqqq 8111621 ,...,,,...,, == (5.110)

    Now let us assume the following displacement functions

    ==

    ==8

    1

    8

    1 i

    ii

    i

    ii vNvuNu (5.111)

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    38/53

    104

    Figure 5.15 (a) Parent rectangular element (b) Isoparmetric quadrilateral (Q8) element.

    in which N1, N2, , N8 are the interpolation functions and they are given as follows:

    ( )( )( )

    ( )( )

    ( )( ) )8,6(112

    1

    )7,5(112

    1

    )4,3,2,1(1114

    1

    2

    0

    0

    2

    0000

    =+=

    =+=

    =+++=

    iN

    iN

    iN

    i

    i

    i

    (5.112)

    where

    ii == 00

    q1q2

    q4q3

    q5q6q8

    q7

    = y/b

    = y/bu

    v

    2a

    2b

    q9 q10

    q12

    q11

    q14q13

    q16

    q15

    x

    q7

    q2

    q1

    q4

    q3

    q5

    q6

    v u

    q8

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    8

    q10

    q9

    q11

    q12q13

    q14

    q16

    q15

    (b)

    (a)

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    39/53

    105

    This rectangle is called a Serendipity element [1] because nodes appear only on its edges.

    If we take the geometric interpolation functions to be the same as the displacement shape

    functions in Eqs. (5.112), we formulate the isoparametric (Q8) element. Physically, this

    means that the natural coordinates and are curvilinear, and all sides of the element becomequadratic curves [6]. Thus,

    ==

    ==8

    1

    8

    1 i

    ii

    i

    ii yNyxNx

    The formulation of stiffnesses and equivalent nodal loads for element Q8 is very similar to

    that for Q4 element given earlier. Numerical integration also follows the same pattern as

    before, even though the local coordinates are curved.

    When higher-order elements are available, it is not always clear whether to use them or torefine network of lower-order elements to achieve the same accuracy. Figure 5.16 depicts a

    two-dimensional continuum discretized into Q4 elements and a smaller number of Q8

    elements. In this case it seems clear that using Q8 elements instead of tour times as many Q4

    elements has advantages. First, we see that the number of nodes is smaller when Q8 elements

    are used. Second, this type of element is able to model the curved boundary with superior

    accuracy. Third, we can expect greater numerical accuracy in the results because of quadratic

    displacement functions in place of linear functions. Of course, the validity of these predictions

    can only be verified by numerical experimentation with practical applications.

    Figure 5.16 Discretization with Q4 and Q8 elements.

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    40/53

    106

    PROBLEMS

    Problem 1. The element shown in the figure is taken from a finite element model of a thin

    aluminum plate with 5 mm thickness. The calculated nodal displacements are given below.

    Determine (a) the natural coordinates (,) of point P, (b) the nodal displacement at the pointP, and (c) element stresses.

    u1 = 0.05 mm

    v1 = 0.02 mm

    u2 = 0.04 mm

    v2 = 0.0 mm

    u3 = 0.03 mm

    v3 = 0.0 mm

    Problem 2. A cantilevered beam is made of an aluminum alloy and is subjected a

    concentrated load of 10 kN on the free end. The dimensions of the beam are shown in the

    Figure.

    (a) Model the portion of the beam, shown in the Figure, with two CST elements.

    (b) Apply the loads due to the bending and shear. Use simple calculations of beam theory

    to obtain the loads.

    (c) Apply the appropriate boundary conditions.

    (d) Obtain the nodal displacements and element stresses.

    (e)

    Model the entire beam using FE software. Obtain converged solutions and comparethe results with yours. (E = 70 GPa, = 0.3)

    Problem 3. The aluminum disc shown in the figure has a radius of 50 mm and a

    thickness of 5 mm. A linearly varying pressure load is applied to right and left hand sides

    of the disc and its maximum value is 800 MPa.

    a. model the disc with two constant strain triangles (use the symmetry of geometry and

    loads)

    b. determine the nodal displacements and draw the deformed and undeformed shapesc. calculate the element stresses.

    u1

    v1

    u2

    v2

    u3

    v3

    (5,6)

    (10,5)

    (9,8)

    1

    2

    3

    P(8,6)

    Coordinates are in mm.

    Thickness = 10100

    1200 mm100

    200

    10 kN

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    41/53

    107

    2

    34 =

    =

    uv

    2a

    2b

    TT

    2

    34 =

    =

    uv

    2a

    2b

    T

    d. model the disc using FE software. Obtain converged solutions and compare the results

    with yours. (E = 70 GPa, = 0.3)

    Problem 4. Suppose that a bilinear displacement rectangle is subjected to a temperature

    change that varies linearly from edge 1-4 to edge 2-3, as indicated in the figure. Develop

    equivalent nodal loads for node 2 due to such temperature variation, assuming isotropic

    material in plane stress.

    Problem 5. For the bilinear displacement rectangle is subjected to a temperature change that

    varies linearly from edge 1-4 to edge 2-3, as indicated in the figure. Develop equivalent nodal

    loads for node 2 due to such temperature variation, assuming isotropic material in plane

    stress.

    (Weaver & Johnston, prob. 2.3-6, answer:( ) ( )3 4

    2,2 1 3 1

    t tE T E Tf tb f ta

    = =

    )

    x

    y

    Pmax =800 MPa45

    50 mm

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    42/53

    108

    Problem 6. Derive numerically the stiffness term k66 for the isoparametric Q4 element in the

    figure using Gaussian numerical integration with n=2 each way. Assume that the thickness t is

    constant and the material is isotropic. The coordinates for 1,2,3, and 4 are (2,1), (8,1), (7,6)

    and (1,5), respectively. Give the numerical results to four significant figures (Weaver &

    Johnston, prob. 3.4-5, answer: k55 = (0.5312E22 + 0.1929E33)t

    Problem 7. Derive numerically the stiffness term k55 for the isoparametric Q4 element in the

    figure using Gaussian numerical integration with n=2 each way. Assume that the thickness t is

    constant and the material is isotropic. The coordinates for 1,2,3, and 4 are (2,1), (8,1), (7,6)

    and (1,5), respectively. Give the numerical results to four significant figures.

    Problem 8. Derive numerically the stiffness term k56 for the isoparametric Q4 element in the

    figure using Gaussian numerical integration with n=2 each way. Assume that the thickness t is

    constant and the material is isotropic. The coordinates for 1,2,3, and 4 are (2,1), (8,1), (7,6)

    and (1,5), respectively. Give the numerical results to four significant figures

    Problem 9. Derive numerically the stiffness term k33 for the isoparametric Q4 element in the

    figure using Gaussian numerical integration with n = 2 each way. Assume that the thickness t

    is constant and the material is isotropic. The coordinates for 1,2,3, and 4 are (2,1), (8,1), (7,6)

    and (1,5), respectively. four significant figures.

    Problem 10. The aluminum plate is subjected the distributed and concentrated loads. The

    dimensions of plate are given in the figure. E = 70 GPa, = 0.3 and thickness of the plate 5mm.

    (a)Model the plate with two finite elements

    (b)Solve the nodal displacements

    (c)Obtain the element stresses

    (d)Calculate the support reactions.

    (e)Optional: Solve the problem using a FE software and compare the results.

    You may use MATLAB software to solve the linear algebraic equations and to perform other

    matrix operations.

    3

    x

    y

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    43/53

    109

    Problem 11. A linearly varying load (force per unit length) is aplied on the 2-3 edge of Q4

    element shown in the Figure.. Obtain the equivalent nodal loads due to the distributed load.For this purpose, express bx in terms of. The length of edge is l23 and = 1 on this edge. Thecoordinates for 1,2,3, and 4 are (2,1), (8,1), (7,6) and (1,5), respectively.

    Problem 12. The cross-section of a long steel axle shown in the figure has a radius of 50 mm.

    A linearly varying pressure load is applied to right and left sides of the axleand its maximum

    value is 800 MPa.

    a) model the disc with two constant strain triangles (use the symmetry of geometry and

    loads)

    b) determine the nodal displacements and draw the deformed and undeformed shapes

    c) calculate the element stresses.

    600 mm

    800 mm

    40 kN

    90

    50 kN/m

    500 mm

    500 mm

    y

    4

    3bx3

    bx221

    x

    y

    Pmax =800 MPa45

    50 mm

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    44/53

    110

    1

    2

    34

    = y/b

    = x/a

    uv

    2a

    2b

    by0by

    Problem 13. For the bilinear displacement rectangle, derive the equivalent nodal loads due to

    the parabolically distributed force by = by0(1-x2) per unit length, apllied in the h direction

    along edge 1-2 in the figure.

    Problem 14. Derive numerically the stiffness term k36 for the isoparametric Q4 element in the

    figure using Gaussian numerical integration with n = 2 each way. Assume that the thickness t

    is constant and the material is isotropic. The coordinates for 1,2,3, and 4 are (4,2), (10,2),

    (8,8) and (2,6), respectively. Give the numerical results to four significant figures.

    Problem 15. The geometry and loading of a plate which is made from A-36 steel are shown

    in the figure. The thickness of plate is 10 mm. (a) model the plate with two constant strain

    triangles (b) determine the nodal displacements and draw the deformed and undeformed

    shapes (c) calculate the element stresses.

    x

    y

    4

    12

    3

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    45/53

    111

    1

    2

    34

    = y/b

    = x/a

    u

    v

    2a

    2b

    T

    -T

    x

    4

    1

    2

    3

    Problem 16. Suppose that a bilinear displacement rectangle is subjected to a temperaturechange that varies linearly from edge 1-2 to edge 3-4, as indicated in the figure. Develop

    equivalent nodal loads at node 4 due to such a temperature variation, assuming isotropic

    material in plane stress.

    Problem 17. Derive numerically the stiffness term k34 for the isoparametric Q4 element in the

    figure using Gaussian numerical integration with n = 2 each way. Assume that the thickness t

    is constant and the material is isotropic. The coordinates for 1,2,3, and 4 are (4,4), (10,6),

    (10,12) and (2,8), respectively. Give the numerical results to four significant figures.

    20 N/mm

    200 mm

    400 mm

    400 mm

    40 N/mm

    y

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    46/53

    112

    Problem 18. For the Q4 element shown in the figure, the element displacement vector {q} is

    given as { } 0 0 0.20 0 0.15 0.10 0 0.05 T= q (a)Find the x, y coordinates of a point whose location in the natural coordinates is given

    by = 0.5, = 0.5.

    (b)Find the u, v displacements of the point P.

    Problem 19.

    (a) Sketch a four-node plane element for which J is a function of but not of.(b) Use Gauss quadrature to evaluate the integral

    1 1 2

    21 1

    3

    2I d d

    +=

    +

    Use (i) one point, (ii) four points. Determine the percentage of error of each result.

    Problem 20. Natural coordinates other than the , system may be chosen. One alternativeis the r,s system shown. Write shape functions of the bilinear element in terms of r and s.

    Problem 21. The figure shows a linearly varying force bx (force per unit length) applied in

    the x direction along side 2-3 of the Q4 element. By explicit integration derive the equivalent

    nodal loads due to such an edge loading. For this purpose, let L23 be the length of edge 2-3

    (where =1), and express the intensity of bx in terms of before integration.(a) Determine the displacement components,

    (b) Obtain the strain components

    (c) Figure 2b shows a four-node quadrilateral. The (x,y) coordinates of each node are given

    in the figure. Find the x,y coordinates of a point P whose location is given by = 0.5, =0.5.

    4

    1 2

    y3

    x

    bx3

    4

    1 2

    y3

    x

    r

    s

    r = 1

    s = 1

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    47/53

    113

    Problem 23. Figure 2a shows that a four-node element shown was initially a square. Nodal

    displacement components, each of magnitude c in both x and y directions, create the

    displaced shape indicated by dashed lines. For the point x = y = a/2,

    (a) Determine the displacement components,

    (b) Obtain the strain components

    (c) Figure 2b shows a four-node quadrilateral. The (x,y) coordinates of each node aregiven in the figure. Find the x,y coordinates of a point P whose location is given by =0.5, = 0.5.

    Figure 2a Figure 2b

    Problem 24. The Q8 element in the figure has a parabolicaly distributed force bx (per unit

    length) applied in the x direction on edge 2-6-3. Find the eqivalent loads at node 6 due to this

    influence.

    Problem 25. For the aluminum square plate shown in the figure, (i) model by two CST

    elements (ii) model by one bilinear displacement rectangle. Take Poissons ratio of 0. The

    dimension a = 100 mm and the thickness of plate is 1 mm. The distributed load b y is 100

    N/mm.

    (a)Obtain the nodal displacements

    (b) Calculate the element stresses. Compare and comment on the results of two solutions.

    (c)Find the strain energy of rectangular element.

    =x/a

    =x/a

    2a

    2a

    4

    1

    (1,4)

    (1,1) 2(5,1)

    (8,8)

    y

    3

    x

    x

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    8

    bx0

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    48/53

    114

    Problem 26. The Q8 element in the figure has a linearly distributed force by (per unit length)

    applied in the y direction on edge 1-5-2. Find the eqivalent loads at node 5 due to this

    influence.

    Problem 27.

    (a) Write shape functions of the plane stress element in terms of and .(b) Explain the isoparametric approach in the element formulations.(c) Obtain the J11 term of the Jacobian matrix.

    a

    a

    b

    x

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    8

    by1

    by2

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    49/53

    115

    Problem 28. For the bilinear displacement rectangle, derive the equivalent nodal loads

    due to parabolically distributed force bx = bx0(1-2)per unit length, applied in

    the direction along edge 2-3 in the figure.

    Problem 29. Figure shows that a four-node element shown was initially a square. Nodal

    displacement components, each of magnitude c in both x and y directions, create the displaced

    shape indicated by dashed lines. Write the displacement functions using the bilinear shape

    functions for the Q4 element.

    (a) Determine the displacement components for the point x = y = a/2,

    (b) Obtain the strain components at this point.

    Problem 30. Figure shows a four-node quadrilateral. The (x,y) coordinates of each node are

    given in the figure. Assume that the thickness t is constant and the material is isotropic.

    (a) Derive the stiffness term k46 for the isoparametric Q4 element until the application of

    numerical integration.(b) Explain the application of Gaussian numerical integration with n=2 each way.

    =x/a

    =x/a

    2a

    2a

    4

    1

    2

    3

    = x/a

    = y/b

    bx0

    2a

    2b

    4

    1 2

    y3

    x

    6

    5

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    50/53

    116

    Problem 30. Write the shape functions of the triangular plane-stress element given in the

    figure. The node 4 is at the centroid of triangle. Use the non-dimensional area coordinates and .

    Problem 31. The nodal coordinates and displacements of a quadrilateral plane-stress element aregiven in the figure.

    (a)Calculate the displacement components at the point P(12.0, 13.4). The corresponding

    natural coordinates are = 0.25 and = 0.60 at the point P.(b)Obtain the Jacobian matrix of the element.

    (c)Calculate the normal strains and normal stresses at the centroid of the element.

    E = 200 GPa, = 0.3, element thickness t = 4 mm.

    1

    2

    3

    4

    x, u

    y, v

    4

    1

    (8,16)

    (8,8)

    2 (16,8)

    (14,14)y

    3

    x

    Coordinates in mm.

    P

    4

    1

    (1,4)

    (1,1) 2(5,1)

    (8,8)

    y

    3

    x

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    51/53

    117

    6 5

    4a a

    b

    b

    =x/a

    =y/2b

    1

    2

    3

    Problem 32. A special plane stress element in a shape of right triangle is shown in the figure.

    The element has three corner nodes and hence it is a constant strain triangle.

    (a)Write the linear shape functions of element. Notice that the shape function must be

    zero at the edge across the related node.

    (b)Obtain the [B] matrix. Why this element has the constant strains? Which type of

    triangular element provides the linear strain variation within the element? Pleaseexplain.

    (c)Calculate the k12 term of stiffness matrix.

    Problem 33. The linear strain triangle (LST) element shown in the figure is a plane-stress

    element.

    (a) Determine shape functions N3 and N4 in terms of non-dimensional coordinates and.

    (b) Sketch their variations on the element.

    (c) Let u3, v3, u4, and v4 be the only nonzero d.o.f. In terms of these d.o.f., , , a, and b,what is the element strain field?

    Problem 34. The figure shows a linearly varying load bx (force per unit length) applied in the

    x direction along side 2-3 of the Q4 element. By explicit integration derive the equivalent

    nodal loads due to such an edge loading. For this purpose, let L23 be the length of edge 2-3(where = 1), and express the intensity of bx in terms of before integrating.

    =x/a

    =y/b

    a

    b

    1 2

    3

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    52/53

    118

    Problem 35. A CST element with three nodes is taken from a FE mesh. The nodalcoordinates are shown in the figure and the nodal displacements under the applied loads

    and 60C temperature increase are given in the table. The material of element is steel withE = 70 GPa, = 0.32, and = 23(10-6)/ C. Recover the element stresses.

    Coordinates are in mm.

    Problem 36. (a) Write the shape functions in terms of non-dimensional coordinates for

    the rectangular element shown in figure.

    (b) If the nodal displacements of a rectangular element a = b = 2 are u1 = 0.215, u2 =

    0.180, u3 = u4 = 0.125, compute u andu

    x

    at the point x = y = 1.5.

    Node No. u (mm) v (mm)

    13 0.020 -0.015

    17 0.025 0.010

    19 0.015 0.0

    1

    2

    3

    4

    bx2

    bx3

    x

    y

    x, = x/a

    y, = y/b

    a

    b

    1 2

    34

    (20,10)

    (60,20)

    (40,40)

    17

    13

    19

    x

    y

  • 7/30/2019 Plane Stress vs Strain

    53/53

    119

    Problem 37. A distributed loading is normal to side 2-3 of the Q4 element. Derive explicit

    expression for the equivalent nodal load at node 2.

    Problem 38. Natural coordinates other than the , system may be chosen. One alternativeis the r,s system shown. Write the shape function N1 in terms of r and s. Plot the shape

    function.

    4

    1 2

    y3

    x

    r

    s

    r = 1

    5

    6

    8

    s = 1

    l

    (2,1)(9,1)

    (6,6)

    1 2

    4

    x

    y (1,5)3

    4 N/mm

    2 N/mm