Policy Proposal 2006-3Policy Proposal 2006-3

Capturing Originations in Capturing Originations in TemplatesTemplates

Montréal, Québec

ARIN XVII

Policy Proposal 2006-3Policy Proposal 2006-3DescriptionDescription

ARIN would, in all IPv4 and IPv6 ARIN would, in all IPv4 and IPv6 number transactions, collect and number transactions, collect and display the ASN(s) which are permitted display the ASN(s) which are permitted to originate a prefix.to originate a prefix.

********************************************************************************AC ShepherdsAC Shepherds

Mark KostersMark Kosters Suzanne WoolfSuzanne Woolf

Montréal, Québec

ARIN XVII

Policy Proposal 2006-3Policy Proposal 2006-3HistoryHistory

Introduced on PPMLIntroduced on PPML 9 FEB 069 FEB 06

Designated Formal ProposalDesignated Formal Proposal 17 FEB 0617 FEB 06

First PPM DiscussionFirst PPM Discussion ARIN XVIIARIN XVIISubsequent PPM DiscussionSubsequent PPM Discussion

Last RevisionLast Revision

Proposal TextProposal TextIn Meeting PacketIn Meeting Packethttp://www.arin.net/policy/2006_3.html

Montréal, Québec

ARIN XVII

Resource Impact: SignificantResource Impact: Significant

Implementation Requirements:Implementation Requirements: Template ChangeTemplate Change Registration Software ChangeRegistration Software Change Directory Services ChangeDirectory Services Change Guidelines ChangeGuidelines Change Staff TrainingStaff Training

Policy Proposal 2006-3Policy Proposal 2006-3Implementation Assessment – March 2006Implementation Assessment – March 2006

Montréal, Québec

ARIN XVII

Legal Risks: None* Legal Risks: None* *However, the third staff comment *However, the third staff comment indicates a potential issue by increasing indicates a potential issue by increasing ARIN legal responsibility> As ARIN agrees ARIN legal responsibility> As ARIN agrees to “verify” anything it may create a legal to “verify” anything it may create a legal liability if it is done badly… liability if it is done badly…

Policy Proposal 2006-3Policy Proposal 2006-3Legal Assessment – March 2006Legal Assessment – March 2006

Montréal, Québec

ARIN XVII

Comments: Comments: Could be addressed by alternatively Could be addressed by alternatively

enhancing the ARIN Internet Routing enhancing the ARIN Internet Routing Registry.Registry.

Network Modification template omitted from Network Modification template omitted from proposal.proposal.

Reminder: ARIN can verify that the request Reminder: ARIN can verify that the request was submitted by an authorized POC was submitted by an authorized POC representing a vetted organization. ARIN can representing a vetted organization. ARIN can not verify specifically “the list of the ASes not verify specifically “the list of the ASes that the user permits to originate address that the user permits to originate address prefixes within the address block”.prefixes within the address block”.

Policy Proposal 2006-3Policy Proposal 2006-3Staff CommentStaff Comment

Montréal, Québec

ARIN XVII

2 for, 1 for as long as info is 2 for, 1 for as long as info is also put in IRR, 2 said to use also put in IRR, 2 said to use the IRR, 1 said use RPSLthe IRR, 1 said use RPSL

Comments:Comments: "…effort would be better spent "…effort would be better spent

in revitalizing the RR…"in revitalizing the RR…" ““This [is] a simple method to This [is] a simple method to

allow folks doing prefix-list allow folks doing prefix-list building to verify that sprint building to verify that sprint (sic) has the block owners (sic) has the block owners authority to originate said authority to originate said block."block."

PostsPosts PeoplePeople3333 1010

Policy Proposal 2006-3Policy Proposal 2006-3PPML DiscussionPPML Discussion

Montréal, Québec

ARIN XVII

Policy Proposal 2006-3Policy Proposal 2006-3

http://www.arin.net/policy/2006_3.htmlhttp://www.arin.net/policy/2006_3.html