poster #m106 the clinical overlap between autism and psychosis
TRANSCRIPT
S228 Abstracts of the 4th Biennial Schizophrenia International Research Conference / Schizophrenia Research 153, Supplement 1 (2014) S1–S384
Poster #M105
SCHIZOTAXIA REDUX
Vaughan J. Carr1, Jessica Bowen1, Melissa J. Green1,2
1University of New South Wales; 2School of Psychiatry
Background: In 1962 Paul Meehl introduced the term schizotaxia to re-
fer to a genetically determined neural integrative defect predisposing to
schizophrenia. On interaction with the social environment and “polygenic
potentiators”, schizotaxia was proposed to lead to a pattern of psycholog-
ical organisation called schizotypy, as a necessary precondition for “true”
schizophrenia (as opposed to phenocopies emerging via alternative means).
Meehl’s schizotype was characterised by “cognitive slippage”, interpersonal
aversiveness, anhedonia, and ambivalence, with neurological soft signs
thought to be caused by the core neural integrative defect. The concept
of schizotaxia is difficult to define, and its manifestations in the form
of schizotypy similarly difficult to operationalize (but it is not equivalent
to DSM schizotypal personality, nor conceptualizations based on positive
psychotic-like experiences). Using Meehl’s descriptions and attempts by
others to measure schizotaxia, we sought to identify individuals with these
characteristics and determine the utility of this concept for future study in
a large sample of healthy individuals and schizophrenia patients from the
Australian Schizophrenia Research Bank (ASRB).
Methods: Participants were 659 healthy controls and 617 schizophrenia
or schizoaffective disorder cases in the ASRB. A series of Grade of Mem-
bership (GoM) analyses were conducted separately for healthy control and
case samples, using putative indicators of schizotaxia including specific
neurocognitive measures (attention, immediate memory, executive func-
tion), self-reported asociality and constricted affect (from the Schizotypal
Personality Questionnaire), and neurological soft signs (NSS). The emergent
“pure types” were compared in terms of other cognitive, personality, and
socio-demographic features, as well as illness-related variables for cases.
Results: Each GoM analysis produced similar three-type solutions: the
first subtype was relatively unimpaired on all variables, the second was
characterised by predominant NSS and mild executive dysfunction. The
third subtype, arguably reflecting “schizotaxia”, was characterised by sig-
nificantly impaired cognitive functioning, asociality, constricted affect (in
controls), and poor NSS sensory integration (in controls) or motor control
(in SZ). Post-GoM comparison of resulting subtypes reported high levels
of social anxiety, suspiciousness, cognitive-perceptual schizotypal features,
and a greater level of childhood adversity in schizotaxic controls (5.7% of
the sample). In contrast, SZ cases belonging to the putative schizotaxic type
(29.8% of cases) were characterized by more severe negative symptoms,
and a lower level of childhood adversity.
Discussion: These findings provide preliminary evidence supporting a pu-
tative “schizotaxic” profile evident in both clinical and non-clinical groups,
in accord with a population base-rate predicted by Meehl’s model. Future
study of potential neurobiological differentiation of the schizotaxic subtype
is warranted.
Poster #M106
THE CLINICAL OVERLAP BETWEEN AUTISM AND PSYCHOSIS
Katie E. Chisholm1, Stephen Wood1, Renate L. Reniers1, Matthew Broome2,
Ashleigh Lin1
1University of Birmingham; 2University of Oxford
Background: Schizophrenia spectrum disorders (SSD) and autism spectrum
disorders (ASD), currently conceptualised as separate, have been reported to
co-occur at elevated rates. Additionally, the diagnostic criteria of each dis-
order have areas of overlap and recent research suggests that the disorders
share multiple phenotypic similarities. As SSD and ASD are both thought
to exist on extended phenotypic continua, it is important to consider not
only co-occurrence at the diagnostic level, but also to investigate evidence
of overlap in traits. Research of this type is underrepresented in the field.
Investigation at the trait level will aid the development of a fundamental
understanding of the disorders and their joint impact on quality of life and
functioning.
Methods: Young people presenting with a first episode of psychosis to
Early Intervention Services in Birmingham were invited to take part in the
research. The positive and negative symptom scale (PANSS) was used to
measure positive, negative, and general symptoms of psychosis, and the
schizotypal personality questionnaire (SPQ) used to measure underlying
schizotypal traits. The Autism Quotient (AQ) was used to measure traits of
ASD. The authors of the AQ suggest that scores of above 32, although not
diagnostic, may indicate that ASD is present, and that an individual with
ASD is unlikely to score less than 26.
Results: Preliminary results from 32 participants suggest that traits of ASD
are found at elevated rates in individuals experiencing a first episode of
psychosis. Participants (24 male) were aged between 18 and 36 (mean
age 26). Of these initial 32 participants, 4 participants scored higher than
26 on the AQ, including 3 scoring higher than 32. Associations between
current psychotic symptoms, schizotypal personality, and autism traits
were examined. ASD traits were found to have a moderate to strong
positive correlation with both state (PANSS) and trait (SPQ) measures of
SSD. In particular, strong positive correlations were found between the SPQ
subscale of interpersonal deficit and AQ subscales, and between general
current symptoms and AQ subscales. Traits of ASD and SSD, as well as
current symptoms of psychosis, also had significant negative correlations
with participants’ quality of life and current levels of functioning. In par-
ticular, current general symptoms of psychosis were highly correlated with
overall quality of life and functioning, as well as the quality of life subscale
of engagement with life. Similarly current negative symptoms of psychosis
showed strong correlations with overall quality of life and engagement in
life. In addition, current positive symptoms of psychosis, total AQ score,
and the schizotypal subscale of interpersonal deficits were negatively cor-
related with quality of life and functioning. Data will be collected from 100
participants with first episode psychosis. With the full dataset, we will also
discuss the association between traits of ASD and childhood trauma, as well
as premorbid adjustment.
Discussion: This remains an important topic for investigation to improve
understanding of areas of dissociation and overlap between the disorders.
We will present a more definitive conclusion with a larger data set.
Poster #M107
CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS OF SCREENING FOR NMDA ENCEPHALITIS IN
FIRST EPISODE PSYCHOSIS
Eric Kelleher1,2, Colin Doherty3, Aiden Corvin1
1Trinity College Dublin; 2St James’ Hospital, Dublin; 3Department of
Neurology, St James’ Hospital, Dublin
Background: The diagnosis of Schizophrenia is based clinically on charac-
teristic positive symptoms (e.g. delusions, hallucinations), negative symp-
toms and social deterioration. Identifying particular aetiologies in specific
patient groups may be important in advancing diagnostics and therapeu-
tics. Anti-N-Methyl-D-Aspartate (NMDA) encephalitis is associated with
auto-antibodies to the NR1 hetromere of the NMDA Receptor. Based on
recent literature, Anti-NMDA receptor encephalitis could be implicated in
approximately 10% of psychotic presentations. Patients with florid NMDA
encephalitis e.g. those with initial psychotic symptoms followed by subse-
quent catatonia, seizures and autonomic dysfunction are usually referred
for treatment with immunotherapy. However mild or incomplete forms of
the disorder could potentially occur with psychiatric features in isolation.
Electroencephalogram (EEG) and Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) of
the brain can aid diagnosis. The aim of this ongoing study is to screen a
prospective sample of patients with a first episode of psychosis presenting
to our service for NMDA antibodies to establish the prevalence in this
group. For identified cases, we aim to collaborate with neurology colleagues
on treatment decisions and clinical care pathways. We report findings of
the first 9 months of the study.
Methods: Following ethical approval, we invited psychiatry teams within
the defined catchment area of our service to refer all patients with a first
episode psychosis who met entry criteria from January 2013. Recruitment
involved a structured clinical interview for DSM-IV (SCID) diagnosis which
incorporated the Scale for the Assessment of Positive Symptoms (SAPS)
and Scale for the Assessment of Negative Symptoms (SANS). Phlebotomy
for a serum sample for NMDA antibodies was also taken and sent to John
Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford, a tertiary referral centre for the diagnosis of
immunological disorders.
Results: 4/31 (13%) samples were identified as being NMDA positive. Av-
erage age of NMDA-positive cases was older than other first-episode cases