powerpoint presentationwaterinstitute.ufl.edu/symposium2014/downloads/presentations/hodges... ·...
TRANSCRIPT
• Bonn, M. A. and F. W. Bell. Economic impact of selected Florida springs on surrounding local areas. Florida
Department of Environmental Protection, 2003 (Ichetucknee, Wakulla, Homosassa, Blue springs).
• Bonn, M.A. Visitor profiles, economic impacts, and recreational aesthetic values associated with eight priority
Florida springs located in the St. Johns River Water Management District. St. Johns River Water Management
District, Palatka, FL, 2004 (Silver Glen, Silver, Alexander, Apopka, Bugg, Ponce de Leon, Gemini, Green
springs).
• Foster, C. Valuing preferences for water quality improvement in the Ichetucknee Springs System: A Case Study
from Columbia County, FL. Master Thesis, University of Florida, 2008.
• Huth, W.L. and O.A. Morgan. Measuring the willingness to pay for cave diving. Marine Resource Economics vol.
26, pp 151-166,2011 (Wakulla Springs).
• Morgan, O.A. and W.L. Huth. Using revealed and stated preference data to estimate the scope and access
benefits associated with cave diving. Resource and Energy Economics vol. 33, pp. 107-118, 2011 (Blue Spring,
Jackson County, Florida).
• Knight, R. Ichetucknee Springs & River: A Restoration Action Plan. Howard T. Odum Florida Springs Institute,
2012.
• Shrestha R.L., Alavalapati, J.R.R., Stein T.V., Carter, D.R., and C.B. Denny. Visitor Preferences and Values for
Water-Based Recreation: A Case Study of the Ocala National Forest. Journal of Agricultural and Applied
Economics, 34(3), 547 – 559, 2002 (Sweetwater, Silver Glen, Juniper, Salt Springs).
Credit: map is copied from http://www.saveoursuwannee.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/florida-spreings1.jpg
Expenditure Item(s) IMPLAN Sector Output
(Revenue)
Employment
(jobs/M$)
Labor
Income
Value Added
(GDP)
Indirect
Business
Taxes
Food & beverages
324. Retail Stores - Food and
beverage 2.17 31.4 0.93 1.42 0.22
413. Food services and
drinking places 1.98 28.6 0.68 1.13 0.13
Transportation (gasoline) 326. Retail Stores - Gasoline
stations 2.15 21.8 0.85 1.48 0.20
Diving training 393. Other private
educational services 2.06 30.9 0.76 1.27 .007
Private springs entry fees,
diving gear rentals
410. Other amusement and
recreation industries 2.08 32.0 0.73 1.31 0.18
Lodging
411. Hotels and motels,
including casino hotels 2.11 21.5 0.66 1.20 0.16
412. Other accommodations 2.12 25.3 0.68 1.14 0.11
Public springs entry fees 432. Other state and local
government enterprises 2.03 15.1 0.63 1.07 0.05
Multipliers for the North-Central Florida Study Area
Multipliers denominated in dollars per dollar output, except employment is jobs per million dollars output.
Spending in retail trade sectors is margined.
Site / Activity
Number
visitors
annually
Number
diving
visitors
annually
Share of
customers
from outside
local area
Total
Spending
Manatee Springs State Park 142,641 2,573 70% $10,626,084
Fanning Springs State Park 293,303 10% $21,029,839
Ichetucknee Springs State Park 177,543 108 70% $13,096,587
Lafayette Blue Springs State Park 33,684 6 70% $2,416,044
Peacock Springs State Park 13,887 11,804 70% $2,825,392
Troy Spring State Park 11,293 8,470 70% $2,122,519
Little River Spring County Park 11,025 4,380 70% $1,469,393
Hart Springs 35,000 200 40% $2,540,500
Ginnie Springs 190,000 15,000 70% $17,313,000
Blue Springs 41,000 70% $3,185,700
Hornsby Springs 20,000 50% $1,554,000
Blue Grotto 13,000 13,000 90% $3,415,100
Devil's Den 5,000 1,665 75% $739,955
Santa Fe River Canoing (outfitters) 8,380 60% $730,526
Total All Springs 995,756 57,206 $83,064,639
Expense Item Amount (Million $)
Private spring entry fees $3.40
Public park entry fees $2.87
Transportation (fuel) $23.30
Hotels / motels $11.25
Other accommodations $11.25
Restaurants $10.80
Food & beverage stores $10.80
Gear rental and diving gasses $7.66
Diver training $1.72
Total $83.06
Total Spending by Non-Local Visitors $45.10
Activity / Business Employment
(jobs)
Output
($1000)
Value added
($1000)
Labor
Income
($1000)
Indirect
Business
Taxes
($1000)
Manatee Springs State Park 143 $11,696 $6,633 $3,889 $821
Fanning Springs State Park 185 $14,265 $7,533 $4,392 $1,158
Ichetucknee Springs State Park 174 $14,332 $8,116 $4,759 $1,011
Lafayette Blue Springs State Park 31 $2,598 $1,464 $861 $181
Peacock Springs State Park 65 $4,282 $2,604 $1,473 $336
Troy Spring State Park 48 $3,175 $1,926 $1,091 $248
Little River Spring County Park 29 $2,042 $1,221 $697 $156
Hart Springs 28 $2,245 $1,237 $724 $167
Ginnie Springs 293 $21,155 $12,458 $7,158 $1,672
Blue Springs 48 $3,599 $2,086 $1,209 $281
Hornsby Springs 21 $1,539 $882 $508 $126
Blue Grotto 90 $6,024 $3,712 $2,099 $474
Devil's Den 16 $1,089 $660 $374 $88
Santa Fe River Canoing 11 $821 $480 $275 $68
Total All Springs 1,183 $88,861 $51,011 $29,508 $6,786
Source: Partially based on Huth B. and A. Morgan. Diving Demand and Economic Impact for Public Resources. Presentation for Jackson Blue Spring Basin Working Group, Marianna, FL 2010
*Indexed to 2013 dollars using Implicit Price Deflator for Gross Domestic Product (U.S. Department of Commerce , 2014)
Silver Glen Spring
Orlando Sentinel / May 23, 1997
www.orlandosentinel.com
Source: Shrestha et al. 2002. Visitor Preferences and Values for Water-Based Recreation: A
Case Study of the Ocala National Forest. Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics,
34(3), 547 – 559
*Indexed from to 2013 dollars using Implicit Price Deflator for Gross Domestic Product (U.S. Department of Commerce , 2014)
Credit: http://cojodiving.wordpress.com/2011/05/10/cojo-goes-to-florida-cave-diving/
Jackson Blue Spring
Site
Number of Visitors (annually) Total Consumer
Surplus
($1000)** Total Diving Extended /
Overnight* Day
Manatee Springs State Park 142,641 2,573 14,007 126,061 $1,399
Fanning Springs State Park 293,303 29,330 263,973 $2,036
Ichetucknee Springs State Park 177,543 108 17,744 159,692 $1,250
Lafayette Blue Springs State Park 33,684 6 3,368 30,310 $235
Peacock Springs State Park 13,887 11,804 208 1,875 $1,974
Troy Spring State Park 11,293 8,470 282 2,541 $1,426
Little River Spring County Park 11,025 4,380 665 5,981 $773
Hart Springs 35,000 200 3,480 31,320 $275
Ginnie Springs 190,000 15,000 17,500 157,500 $3,705
Blue Springs 41,000 4,100 36,900 $285
Hornsby Springs 20,000 2,000 18,000 $139
Blue Grotto 13,000 13,000 0 0 $2,158
Devil's Den 5,000 1,665 334 3,002 $300
Santa Fe River Canoeing 8,380 838 7,542 $58
Total All Springs 995,756 57,206 93,855 844,695 $16,011
* 10% of visitors (excluding divers); ** Consumer surplus per person per trip: $166 for divers (Shrestha et al. 2002); $12.17 for extended visitors; $6.36 for day visitors (Morgan and Huth 2011)
Activity / Business Output Impact
($1000)
Consumer
Surplus
($1000)
Total Economic
Value
($1000)
Manatee Springs State Park $11,696 $1,399 $13,095
Fanning Springs State Park $14,265 $2,036 $16,301
Ichetucknee Springs State Park $14,332 $1,250 $15,582
Lafayette Blue Springs State Park $2,598 $235 $2,833
Peacock Springs State Park $4,282 $1,974 $6,256
Troy Spring State Park $3,175 $1,426 $4,601
Little River Spring County Park $2,042 $773 $2,815
Hart Springs $2,245 $275 $2,520
Ginnie Springs $21,155 $3,705 $24,860
Blue Springs $3,599 $285 $3,884
Hornsby Springs $1,539 $139 $1,678
Blue Grotto $6,024 $2,158 $8,182
Devil's Den $1,089 $300 $1,389
Santa Fe River Canoing $821 $58 $879
Total All Springs $88,861 $16,011 $104,872
Source: based on Casey et al., 2008. A Preliminary Assessment of the Economic Benefits of Land Conservation Areas in Florida. Defenders of Wildlife.
Category Benefit
Use values
Direct use values Recreation (e.g., scenery viewing, canoeing / kayaking)
Social, religious, and spiritual events
Education and research
Nature-related art, crafts, and publications (e.g., calendars, books, TV shows, etc.)
Consumptive non-recreation use: water bottling
Indirect use values Hydrological services Nitrogen cycle Biodiversity maintenance (including rare, threatened, and endangered species) Habitat provision
Option value Possibility to engage in direct use of the resource in the future
Passive use values (Non-use values)
Existence value Appreciation of the scenic beauty of the springs
Stewardship value Appreciation of the fact that this scenic beauty and natural systems are actively managed and are…
Bequest value … passed to future generations
Head Springs, Ichetucknee
http://www.springsrus.com/water_places.aspx
*Indexed from to 2013 dollars using Implicit Price Deflator for Gross Domestic Product (U.S. Department of Commerce , 2014)
Source: Foster C. 2008. Valuing preferences for water quality improvement in the Ichetucknee Springs System: A Case Study from Columbia County, FL. Master Thesis, University of Florida.
Credit: David Doubilet, Ginnie Springs Florida (1992). (http://www.phaidon.com/agenda/photography/picture-galleries/2011/december/13/into-the-deep-blue-yonder/?idx=10)