preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · preclinical proof of concept and other...

27
International Regulatory Forum of Human Cell Therapy and Gene Therapy Products Ian Harris, Ph.D. 16 March 2016 Cell Therapy, Janssen R&D Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues Jennifer Jacobs, Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist living with Type 1 diabetes.

Upload: others

Post on 07-Jan-2020

12 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

International Regulatory Forum of Human Cell Therapy and Gene Therapy Products

Ian Harris, Ph.D. 16 March 2016 Cell Therapy, Janssen R&D

Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues

Jennifer Jacobs, Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

living with Type 1 diabetes.

Page 2: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

Proof of concept (POC)

Scientific Rational for clinical Biologically active dose levels Dosing regimens (single, repeated) Appropriate route of administration Duration of response Mechanism of action

– Protection/prevention – Regeneration

Timing of administration relative to disease/injury Potential patient population Monitoring efficacy and safety

Page 3: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

3

Umbilical Tissue Derived Cells (palucorcel, CNTO 2476, hUTC) for the treatment of Geographic Atrophy

• Why Geographic Atrophy?

• Why Umbilical Tissue Derived Cells (palucorcel) ?

Page 4: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

Age-Related Macular Degeneration (AMD) is the leading cause of irreversible vision loss in the world

Other AMD affects 1 in 2000 people in the U.S. and other developed countries*

Normal Vision Vision with AMD

The macula is required for reading, driving and recognizing faces

Page 5: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

The macula comprises only ~4% of the retina, but provides 50% of visual information reaching the brain

Macula o 6 mm diameter o 6,000 cones/mm2

Foveola o 0.35 mm diameter

at center of fovea o Only cones and

Mueller cells

Fovea o 1.5 mm diameter o 165,000 cones/mm2

o Origin of ½ of optic nerve fibers

Rod density ranges from ~35,000 rods/mm2 at the periphery to ~150,000 rods/mm at about 3-5 mm from the foveola

Neuroscience, 2nd ed., Purves D, Augustine GJ, Fitzpatrick D, et al., eds., Sunderland (MA): Sinauer Associates; 2001

Page 6: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

Approximately 15% of the 15 M AMD patients in the US progress to an advanced form and lose central vision

Page 7: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

Lesion progression rates vary significantly in GA, as does position relative to the fovea

o Differences in progression rate do not correlate with visual acuity decline

o Foveal sparing enables a patient to see 20/20 while a smaller lesion encompassing the fovea impairs visual acuity significantly (<20/400)

o Diagnosis and onset of symptoms is associated with loss of autonomy, depression, and overall reduced quality of life

Rates of Progression

Page 8: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

8

A model of AMD pathogenesis

Modified from: Ambati et al., 2013; Fritsche et al., 2014

Page 9: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

Why Human Umbilical Tissue Derived Cells?

Microarrays RNA Seq Secretome analysis

Neurotrophic factors TSP1, TSP2, TSP4, SPARC, Hevin, BDNF, GDNF, LIF, IL-6, Neurotrophin 3, LEDGF, PDGF-DD, HGF

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 801

1.0×1007

1.0×1014

1.0×1021

Umbilical

Fibroblast

Omentum

MSC

Placenta

Days in culture

Cell n

umbe

r

Page 10: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

10

Palucorcel (Umbilical tissue derived cells) are not comparable to mesenchymal stem cells (MSC)

• sVEGFr1 may be important to prevent GA patients from converting to wet AMD

PCR for Differentially Expressed Genes

Fibroblast MSC Placenta Umbilical

Umbilical tissue derived cells

Placenta

Fibroblast

Bone marrow MSC

Ileac crest derived cells

Primary Component Analysis of Gene Microarrays

RPE Fibroblast MSC Umbilical

Page 11: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

11

Selection of animal model

Scientific rational • Appropriate species

• To characterize physical, mechanical, biological properties

• Relevant to demonstrate proof of concept • Immune tolerated and biologically active • Genetic background

• Number of animals for statistical and scientific

interpretation • Animal model, test species, delivery system

Page 12: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

12

Other preclinical studies

Identify potential risks and guide clinical monitoring • Local & Systemic toxicity

• Ectopic tissue or transformation

• Biodistribution/ retention • Distribution, persistence, clearance

• Tumorgenicity • Immunogenicity • Safety of delivery

ICH S6(R1) Preclinical Safety Evaluation of Biotechnology-Derived Pharmaceuticals FDA Guidance for Industry: Preclinical Assessment of Investigational Cellular and Gene Therapy Products (November 2013)

Page 13: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

Royal College of Surgeons (RCS) rat

• The RCS rat is a widely studied animal model of retinal degeneration due to a genetic defect in the retinal pigmented epithelium (RPE), i.e., a null mutation of the gene encoding Mertk.

• Cell culture studies demonstrate that Mertk-deficient primary RCS RPE cells have normal levels of outer segments binding, but are defective in the ingestion phase of phagocytosis.

• Delivery of a recombinant Mertk to RCS RPE completely corrected the phagocytic defect of the cells, resulting in photoreceptor rescue.

Page 14: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

Palucorcel (hUTC) preserves retinal architecture

Untreated Untreated

CNTO 2476 CNTO 2476

Postnatal d30 Postnatal d90

Sham Sham

• Single injection of 20,000 human cells at Postnatal day 21 in RCS rat preserves photoreceptors to postnatal day 90

Lund RD, et al., Cells isolated from umbilical cord tissue rescue photoreceptors and visual functions in a rodent model of retinal disease. Stem Cells. 2007 Mar;25(3):602-11.

Page 15: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

15

Area of Photoreceptor Preservation in the RCS rat

Injection site

Superior Inferior

Outer nuclear layer

Area preserved >30% rat retina

Photoreceptors are preserved beyond where CNTO 2476 is injected

Page 16: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

Palucorcel (hUTC) Improves Optomoter Response over 180 d

Optomotor response (head tracking) is used to measure the elicitation of a consecutive motor response, enabling assessment of all components of visual integration. Animals placed in a rotating drum covered with vertical black and white stripes at various spatial frequencies follow the movement of the drum by moving the eye/head whereas animals with altered vision cannot track the stripes

Optomotor Response (6 mo)

Days Postnatal V

isua

l Acu

ity (c

/d)

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

Untreated (n=26)

Sham (n=12)

Subretinal (n=13)

Injection P21

Functionally Blind

Normal

* (p<0.001) CNTO 2476 sham untreated

Normal

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

Days Postnatal

Vis

ual A

cuity

(c/d

)

Optomotor Response (3 mo)

Functionally Blind

(n=7) (n=5) (n=3)

Page 17: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

Correlation of luminescence with anatomical preservation

Luminance threshold is used to measure spatial vision as single and multiunit activity in the superficial layers of the superior colliculus

Log Candela Units/m2 Subretinal

No sham response

CNTO 2476

Postnatal day 200

0

20

40

60

80

100

0.7 1.2 1.7 2.2 2.6 3.1 3.6 4.1

CNTO 2476 sham untreated

*

* * *

% A

rea

Postnatal day 100

Log Candela Units/m2 Subretinal

Larger area of retina is sensitive to lower levels of light with treatment

Page 18: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

0.10.150.2

0.250.3

0.350.4

0.450.5

0.550.6

P20 P30 P60 P75 P90

thre

shol

d (c

/d)

WT

Dys UNT

Sham

4K hUTC

20K hUTC

100KhUTC

Optomoter does not show a dose response

P21 Injection

Confidential

4,000 hUTC 20,000 hUTC 100,000 hUTC

Sham Untreated

Wild Type

Page 19: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

19

hUTC was detected in the RCS rat eyes 60 days post subretinal injection

• In order to understand cell fate after subretinal injection, biodistribution studies were performed based on an indirect measurement of human gene expression in animal tissue using Q-RT-PCR

• Biodistribution studies demonstrated long-term cell retention of hUTC in eyes

• hUTC were detected in nontarget organs (peripheral blood, kidney and liver) in nude rats 2 weeks following subretinal delivery, but there was no evidence for long term survival of cells in non-target organs

Page 20: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

Human cell retention in the rat eye and visual function

0 25 50 75 100 125 150 1750

1

2

3

4

5

Log cell numberoptomotor threshold recording

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

Slope -0.01909 ± 0.003782

Slope -0.002198 ± 0.0003982

day

Log

cell

num

ber

optomotor threshold recording

• Similar rate of change are observed in cell number and Optomoter • Optomoter response starts to decline when estimated ~500 cells remain

Page 21: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

21

Administration

• Intravitreal • Choroid • Subretinal

Photoreceptors

targeted layer for cell delivery Retinal Pigment Epithelium

Bruch’s Membrane

Choroid

X X

Sclera Choroid

Retina

Page 22: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

22

Development of surgical procedure & devices

Transvitreal Suprachoroidal

Page 23: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

RCS-RPE

hUTC

In vitro Assay Trophic Factor RCS Rat Model

(RCS phagocytosis studies performed in collaboration with Dr. George Inana, Bascom Palmer Eye Institute)

020406080

100120140160

Normal Dystrophic Dystrophic + hUTC

Rel

ative

pha

gocy

tosi

s *

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

N+control M D+control M D+hUTC CM

Rel

ativ

e ph

agoc

ytos

is

*

RCS-RPE

hUTC CM

From preclinical proof of concept to potency assay

Page 24: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

24

Hypothesis: Palucorcel rescues phagocytosis in RCS RPE through the secretion of Receptor tyrosine kinase (RTK) ligands

Page 25: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

Receptor tyrosine kinase ligands can compensate for loss of Mertk function

BDNF HGF GDNF

Cao, Jet al., (2015) Human umbilical tissue-derived cells rescue retinal pigment epithelium dysfunction in retinal degeneration Stem Cells. doi: 10.1002/stem.2239. [Epub ahead of print]

Page 26: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

Receptor kinase ligands secreted by umbilical tissue derived cells are required for bioactivity

Cao, Jet al., (2015) Human umbilical tissue-derived cells rescue retinal pigment epithelium dysfunction in retinal degeneration Stem Cells. doi: 10.1002/stem.2239. [Epub ahead of print]

Page 27: Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues · Preclinical proof of concept and other preclinical issues . Jennifer Jacobs,Stowaway Jennifer is a New York based artist

Thank you