preliminary thoughts on scuss 1. scientific perspectives 2. suggestions for next steps 李 成 scuss...

17
Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

Upload: gerald-holbrook

Post on 15-Jan-2016

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS1. Scientific perspectives

2. Suggestions for next steps

李 成

SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

Page 2: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

Virtues of the u-band for galaxies

• Star formation: – sensitive to young stellar populations

• Cold gas– Indicator of cold gas fraction in galaxies

Page 3: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

1. Estimating cold gas fraction in galaxies

u-r, u-k as indicators

Wei Zhang et al. 2009

Page 4: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

1. Estimating cold gas fraction in galaxies color plus surface brightness

Wei Zhang et al. 2009

Page 5: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

HyperLeda + SCUSS

• >100 HI galaxies from HyperLeda falling in the current SCUSS region

• Expect to have >1000 eventually

Page 6: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

2. Star formation in BCGs• Some brightest cluster galaxies show star

formation in their center• How do they get the cold gas: cooling flow or

minor mergers

Jing Wang et al. 2010

Page 7: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

2. Star formation in BCGs• Some brightest cluster galaxies show star

formation in their center• How do they get the cold gas: cooling flow or

minor mergers• Cooling flow: a “blue core”– Better to have X-ray image to determine the

thermodynamic state of the gas in the halo center• Minor mergers: more extended u-r color– Estimate the available cold gas in satellite galaxies

• This idea also applies for general early-type galaxies

Page 8: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

3. Direct measurements of HOD parameters for different types of galaxies

• Take BCGs as dark matter halo centers• Stellar population synthesis: Identifying

different types of satellite galaxies (SF, AGN, …) and estimating their physical properties

• Measuring the halo occupation number as functions of halo mass and galaxy properties

• Need to carefully subtract contributions from foreground/background galaxies

• Need other bands for better determining the physical properties

Page 9: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

Need more bands: UV, IR

• photo-z• Stellar populations, SFH, SFR, stellar mass, …• Identification and classification of different

types of objects• Available data– GALEX, 2MASS, WISE, AKARI, …

Page 10: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

WISE preliminary release (Apr 14) Overlapping area: 30<RA<50, 0<Dec<4

SCUSS Year 1

Page 11: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

WISE preliminary release (Apr 14) Overlapping area: 30<RA<50, 0<Dec<4

SCUSS Year 1

Wright et al. (2010)

Page 12: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

4. Lyman break galaxies magnified by galaxy clusters (?)

• LBG: star-forming galaxies at z~3, R*=24.54, ~1 / arcmin^2 at R=24.5 (Adelberger & Steidel 2000)

• MS 1512-cB58: R=20.4, magnified by ~30 by a foreground cluster (Yee et al. 1996, Seitz et al. 1998)

• Bentz et al. (2004): 6 candidates from SDSS/DR1 QSO sample

• Bentz et al. (2008): HST imaging, all unresolved point sources, 5 quasars, 1 with a companion at 0.8”

• Can we do the same, taking advantage of the much better quality in u-band?

Page 13: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

SCUSS Value-added galaxy catalogue (SCUSS-VAGC)

• Collecting data from literature– Previous redshift surveys: CfA, 2dF, SDSS, BOSS– Galaxy clusters: Abell, Zwicky, MaxBCG, GMBCG,

Wen et al., …– HI: HyperLeda, ALFALFA – UV: GALEX– NIR: 2MASS– MIR: WISE– FIR: AKARI

Page 14: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

Selection effects for LSS studies

• Survey geometry– Gap between CCDs– Cutout at CCD edges– Bright stars– Bad pixels

• Completeness map– Limiting magnitude varies across the survey region

Page 15: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

Color-color diagram for star/galaxy separation

图片来自 SCUSS 项目书

Page 16: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

Star/galaxy separation

• 需要仔细比较现有方法,确定最佳方案,尤其是在暗端– SCUSS: DAO sharpness, Bertin g/s– SDSS: m(psf) - m(model) > 0.145 for galaxies– Color-color diagram: u-g vs. g-r

• 需要与已有的更深的图像数据比对– SDSS 使用 COMBO-17 的一块天区: – COMBO-17, S 11: 11h 42m 58s-01 42' 50"

Page 17: Preliminary thoughts on SCUSS 1. Scientific perspectives 2. Suggestions for next steps 李 成 SCUSS team meeting, 2011.6.11, Beijing

Can we trust SDSS star/galaxy separation for faint sources?

• SDSS: COMBO S11 field as a standard• 100% correct for r<19.5

图片来自 SDSS/DR5 网站

star galaxy