PREVALENCE, PREDICTABILITY, AND INTERVENTIONS: A CASE STUDY OF BULLYING

K E L L I B O U R N E , H E A LT H & S C I E N C E E D U C AT O RL A K E S I D E M I D D L E S C H O O L , I R V I N E , C A L I F O R N I AR E S E A R C H C O N D U C T E D AT C A L I F O R N I A S TAT E U N I V E R S I T Y , F U L L E RT O N ( M A S T E R ’ S O F S C I E N C E I N S E C O N D A RY E D U C AT I O N )C O N TA C T: K E L L I B O U R N E @ I U S D . O R G

RESEARCHER INTERESTS•Found a gap in research that focused on middle school student perceptions of bullying interventions•Found a gap in research on predictability of bullying (versus just physical violence) •Was curious to see if the school’s trends regarding the prevalence of bullying were similar to those at the state and national level•Wanted to contribute to the creation of a more positive climate for students at school

RESEARCH QUESTIONS1. What is the prevalence of bullying at

Lakeside Middle School?2. Is the time and place of bullying

predictable?3. What do students perceive are the most

effective bullying prevention strategies?

My hypotheses…

SCHOOL PROFILE• Located in Irvine, California (231,117

population)• 7th and 8th grade student body• 693 total students (2012/2013)• 32 certificated positions; 18 classified

positions• Student/family population:• Very ethnically diverse (~ 50 languages)• Middle to upper socioeconomic status majority• Title 1 School: 15% on free or reduced lunch

SURVEY DETAILS• Data from 643 7th & 8th grade

students• Balance between grades and

gender• 45 questions about bullying•From the beginning of 2012/2013 school year•Definitions & privacy given to support accurate responses

• 4 demographic questions

PREVALENCE OF BULLYING: • 38.3% of students report being bullied one or

more times• 65.6% have witnessed/seen bullying• 95.7% of teachers reported a perception that

there is more bullying than they are aware of• 86.2% teachers reported a moderate to severe

concern regarding bullying• Forms: verbal emotional physical (from most

to least common)• Most common places: lunch areas, snack areas,

classrooms • Most common times: lunch, break, classrooms,

after school

I hav

e no

t bee

n bu

llied

.

On th

e wa

y to

scho

ol

On th

e wa

y ho

me

from

scho

ol

Hallw

ays b

efor

e/af

ter s

choo

l

Hallw

ays d

urin

g pa

ssin

g pe

riod

Bath

room

Cafe

teria

Clas

sroo

m (w

hen

the

teac

her w

as in

th...

Clas

sroo

m (w

hen

the

teac

her w

as n

ot in

...

Medi

a Ce

nter

Whe

re I

go d

urin

g br

eak

Whe

re I

go d

urin

g lu

nch

Bike

rack

P.E.

lock

er ro

om (i

nsid

e)

P.E.

lock

ers (

outs

ide)

Othe

r (pl

ease

spec

ify)0.0%

10.0%

20.0%

30.0%

40.0%

50.0%

60.0%

70.0% Question: If you have been bullied, WHERE has it taken place?

Campus Locations

Perc

enta

ge o

f St

uden

ts

I hav

e no

t witn

esse

d bu

llyin

g.

On m

y wa

y to

scho

ol

On m

y wa

y ho

me

from

scho

ol

Hallw

ays

Bath

room

Cafe

teria

Clas

sroo

m (w

hen

the

teac

her w

as in

the

room

)

Clas

sroo

m (w

hen

the

teac

her w

as n

ot in

the

room

)

Medi

a Ce

nter

Whe

re I

go fo

r sna

ck

Whe

re I

go fo

r lun

ch

Bike

rack

P.E.

lock

er ro

om (i

nsid

e)

P.E.

lock

ers (

outs

ide)

Othe

r (pl

ease

spec

ify)0.0%

5.0%10.0%15.0%20.0%25.0%30.0%35.0%

Question: If you have witnessed bullying, WHERE has it taken place?

Campus Locations

Perc

enta

ge o

f St

uden

ts

I hav

e no

t bee

n bu

ll...

On th

e wa

y to

scho

olOn

the

way

hom

e fr.

..Ha

llway

s bef

ore/

aft..

.Ha

llway

s dur

ing

pas..

.Ba

thro

omCa

fete

riaCl

assr

oom

(whe

n th

e...

Clas

sroo

m (w

hen

the.

..Me

dia

Cent

erW

here

I go

dur

ing

b...

Whe

re I

go d

urin

g l..

.Bi

ke ra

ckP.

E. lo

cker

room

(ins

...P.

E. lo

cker

s (ou

tsid

e)Ot

her (

plea

se sp

ecify

)0.0%

10.0%

20.0%

30.0%

40.0%

50.0%

60.0%

70.0%

Q: If you have been bullied, WHERE has it

taken place?

I hav

e no

t witn

ess..

.On

my

way

to sc

...On

my

way

hom

e ...

Hallw

ays

Bath

room

Cafe

teria

Clas

sroo

m (w

hen

t...

Clas

sroo

m (w

hen

t...

Medi

a Ce

nter

Whe

re I

go fo

r sna

ckW

here

I go

for l

unch

Bike

rack

P.E.

lock

er ro

om (i

...P.

E. lo

cker

s (ou

ts...

Othe

r (pl

ease

spec

...

0.0%

5.0%

10.0%

15.0%

20.0%

25.0%

30.0%

35.0%

Q: If you have wit-nessed bullying,

WHERE has it taken place?

Lang

uage

/acc

cent

Mone

y

Appe

aran

ce

Cultu

re

Sexu

al p

refe

renc

e

Race

/etn

icity

/skin

colo

r

Frie

nds/w

ho th

ey h

ang

out w

ith

Disa

bilit

y

Socia

l awk

ward

ness

/act

diff

eren

t

Relig

ion

New

to th

e sc

hool

Athl

etic

abili

ty

Heig

ht

Gend

er

Bein

g ov

erwe

ight

Clot

hing

/how

they

exp

ress

them

selv

es

Hobb

ies/i

nter

ests

Othe

r (pl

ease

spec

ify)

36.1%

10.9%

59.9%

23.1%19.3%

31.3%36.3%

23.5%

51.8%

16.1% 13.8%

28.5%21.9%

7.3%

53.5%

40.4%

22.3%

11.9%

Reasons Students are Bullied

PREDICTABILITY OF BULLYING• Common theme: unstructured,

unsupervised times and places• Students who have been bullied:•Time: 66% report it is random, 34% report some degree of predictability•Place: 55% report it is random, 45% report some degree of predictability•Form: 25% report it is random, 75% report some degree of predictability

PREDICTABILITY OF BULLYING• Common theme: unstructured, unsupervised times and places

• Students who have witnessed bullying report:•Time: 48.8% report random, 25.2% report some degree of predictability•Place: 46.5% report random, 26% report some degree of predictability•Form: didn’t ask

STUDENT PERCEPTIONS: SOLUTIONS• Vast majority (96%) feel it is their duty to help someone being bullied

• However, when students are being bullied…• They are walking away (21%) • They are telling someone (15.4%)• They are standing up for themselves (14.5%)• But 20% aren’t doing anything about it…

STUDENT PERCEPTIONS: SOLUTIONS• Students are more likely to tell the

following people, in the following order:• Friend• Parent• Teacher/school counselor

• However, students want independence with preventing and coping with bullying

STUDENT SUGGESTIONS• How bullying can be prevented:

•Anonymous reporting (68.7%)•Train students to help each other (47.9%)•Get help from an adult (44.2%)•Train students to help themselves (42.7%)•Offer activities that encourage student connectedness (37.9%)

More

stud

ents

get

ting

hel

p fro

m a

n ad

ult a

t sch

ool

More

stud

ents

get

ting

help

from

a p

aren

t

More

adu

lt su

perv

ision

An a

nony

mou

s way

to re

port

bully

ing

Trai

n st

uden

ts to

hel

p ea

ch o

ther

Trai

n st

uden

ts to

hel

p th

emse

lves

Have

act

iviti

es th

at e

ncou

rage

stud

ent c

onne

cted

ness

&

belo

ngin

g

Have

scho

ol-w

ide

asse

mbl

ies

Have

mor

e di

scus

sions

in cl

ass

Othe

r (pl

ease

spec

ify)

44.2%32.7% 35.5%

68.7%

47.9%42.7% 37.9%

29.1%35.8%

7.8%

Student Perceptions of Effective Bullying Intervention Strategies

STUDENT SUGGESTIONS• Lakeside school wide connectedness can

improve by:•Consequences should be more clear (48.1%)•Teachers should create a more positive classroom atmosphere (46.8%)•Offer more student training (46.4%)•More clubs and lunchtime activities (45.5%)•Make school rules more clear (40.8%)•More education on the consequences of bullying (40.8%)

Allo

w st

uden

ts to

be

mor

e in

volv

ed w

ith se

tting

beh

av-

ior r

ules

and

stan

dard

s

More

club

s and

oth

er lu

ncht

ime

activ

ities

Make

mor

e cle

ar th

e sc

hool

's ru

les o

n bu

llyin

g

More

edu

catio

n on

the

effec

ts a

nd co

nseq

uenc

es o

f bul-

lyin

g

More

stud

ent t

rain

ing

on h

ow to

dea

l with

bul

lyin

g if/

when

it h

appe

ns

An o

ngoi

ng a

nti-b

ully

ing

prog

ram

at s

choo

l

Prov

ide

a fo

rum

for s

tude

nts t

o ta

lk o

penl

y ab

out w

hat's

go

ing

on a

t the

ir sc

hool

Allo

w st

uden

ts to

exp

ress

them

selv

es a

nd e

duca

te

othe

rs a

bout

thei

r rel

igio

ns, c

ultu

res,

sexu

al id

entit

es,

etc.

More

scho

ol-w

ide

asse

mbl

ies t

hat c

orre

ct in

accu

rate

pe

rcep

tions

and

cove

r top

ics li

ke ra

cism

, cul

ture

, re-

ligio

n, se

xism

, etc

.

Prov

ide

mor

e op

portu

nitie

s for

peo

ple

to m

eet o

ther

s ou

tsid

e of

thei

r reg

ular

gro

up o

f frie

nds

Teac

hers

shou

ld cr

eate

a m

ore

posit

ive

envi

ornm

ent i

n th

eir c

lass

room

s

The

cons

eque

nces

for b

ully

ing

shou

ld b

e m

ore

clear

and

co

nsist

ent Ot

her (

plea

se sp

ecify

)

40.6%45.5%

40.8% 40.8%46.4%

33.2% 33.7%38.3%

31.9%40.0%

46.8% 48.1%

8.6%

Student Perspectives on Improving School Wide Culture

STUDY IMPLICATIONS• One study has found that targets of bullying are

more likely to seek help if the bullying is chronic versus it being a short-term or one-time occurrence (Unnever & Cornell, 2004)

• Recent headlines inform us of students ending their lives or the lives of others (as a result of bullying)

• Research documents the known negative health consequences for both targets and bullies

• In response, schools cannot play a passive role and wait for targeted students and bullies to come forward seeking their assistance

STUDY IMPLICATIONS• Schools must be proactive in knowing the needs of

their students and having an awareness of their schools’ trends about bullying so that they can appropriately address them

• Schools must also do a fair job of educating their staff to recognize and intervene with bullying when they see it, and must provide training and encouragement in the establishment of positive and sensitive climates in their classrooms

• Lastly, teachers’ and students’ perspectives, perceptions, and ideas should be included and supported when planning and implementing a bullying prevention program, as they play a primary role in the establishment of acceptable versus unacceptable behavior within the culture and context of their school and within the classroom

STUDY IMPLICATIONS• On a larger level, bullying should not be viewed as an

isolated issue for schools alone to deal with – appropriate community and family involvement should be put in place. According to Pack et. al (2011), bullying is rooted in “social-ecological theory” in that this type of aggressive behavior is influenced by the “interaction of individual, family, peer, and community factors” (p. 128).

• Resources, funding, and professional guidance to help schools establish effective prevention and intervention programs that meet the needs of their varying student populations are significant elements, as well.

• Greater funding should be allocated to schools to reduce class sizes and student body sizes so that a greater relationships can be built between students, teachers, and their schools.

LAKESIDE’S CURRENT EFFORTS…• School-wide bullying awareness campaign

• Student-created slogans “Be Nice to People” and “Bullying. Just. Don’t. Do. It.”

• “Starting a Movement” for Kindness Campaign from Ted Talk (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V74AxCqOTvg)

• Assemblies on tolerance and coping strategies• “Lunch Bunch” to promote social inclusion

• Bullying curriculum in 7th grade health class• “Let’s Get Real” Documentary• Building empathy and intervention strategies

• PBIS (Positive Behavior Intervention System)• Nationally-recognized, research-based framework for student

social/emotional development• Comprehensive in nature: school, classroom, parent

components• School-wide and classroom plans in development phases for

Fall 2014 rollout

“LET’S GET REAL” – HUMAN RELATIONS MEDIA

STUDY LIMITATIONS & A CALL FOR MORE RESEARCHResearch Limitations• Not possible to confirm accuracy of reported claims regarding the

prevalence of bullying as survey was anonymous• Students may have a skewed or inaccurate perception of the

definition of bullying, possibly invalidating some of their responses • Findings from the study emphasize descriptive statistics, describe

trends in attitudes and behaviors, are based upon percentile ranking, and do not demonstrate actual correlations or relationships

• Difficulty in predicting accuracy students’ actual behavior regarding bullying reporting and intervention due to hypothetical situation findings

Research Needs• Predictability of form of bullying (to assist with intervention

strategies development)• Effectiveness of anonymous reporting as a student-centered

intervention and prevention strategy (virtual vs. paper)• Effectiveness of student-recommended interventions (does

student buy-in and ownership increase the likelihood of a school wide cultural shift?)

THANK YO

U FOR YO

UR

TIME!

Kelli Bournekellibourne@ius

d.org