[preview] challenges in procurement, design and

1
https://doi.org/10.24904/footbridge2022.061 Distributed by Contact author: Gerhard du Plessis, [email protected] CHALLENGES IN PROCUREMENT, DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION OF THE ERASMUSRAND PEDESTRIAN BRIDGE Authors: Gerhard DU PLESSIS 1 , Edwin KRUGER 2 , Alan AGAIENZ 2 Affiliation: 1 Superstructures Consulting Engineers, Pretoria, South Africa 2 South African National Roads Agency SOC Ltd , Pretoria, South Africa Keywords: pedestrian bridge; arch; steel composite; dynamics; vibration, damping, buckling; non-linear analysis The new Erasmusrand Pedestrian bridge replaced the previously impact-damaged pedestrian bridge spanning across the National Route 1 Freeway in Pretoria, South Africa for the South African National Roads Agency SOC Ltd (SANRAL). The structure consists of a steel arch supporting a composite steel/concrete deck with inclined square hollow steel struts. The bridge spans 73m across a 10-lane dual carriageway freeway providing access to a local school from the suburbs. Several challenges were presented in the project with procurement, design and construction. An initial assessment report explored the possibility of saving the badly twisted portals on the old steel bridge. Although the costs were slightly cheaper than a new construction, there were inherent risks with the approach and the decision was therefore taken to demolish. However, in terms of the procurement rules of SANRAL, the design of the new structure had to be put out to tender but not as a design competition. Once appointed the new design consultant had to put at least 3 different proposals on the table about costs and aesthetics. The inclined sides of the road cutting profile at the site favoured an arch or frame type of solution. However, the road cut formation was relatively shallow resulting in a low rise to span ratio. With the low rise to span ratio a number of design challenges were presented such as susceptibility to buckling, susceptibility to vibrations under dynamic footfall forces and sensitivity to variation in temperature and support conditions. Construction challenges included fabrication of plate elements with complex geometry, handling and transport of massive assemblies and stability during erection. The paper discusses the procurement, design development and construction challenges and how these were overcome. Fig. 1. Elevation View of Erasmusrand Pedestrian Bridge

Upload: others

Post on 03-Apr-2022

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

https://doi.org/10.24904/footbridge2022.061

Distributed by

Contact author: Gerhard du Plessis, [email protected]

CHALLENGES IN PROCUREMENT, DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION OFTHE ERASMUSRAND PEDESTRIAN BRIDGEAuthors: Gerhard DU PLESSIS1, Edwin KRUGER2, Alan AGAIENZ2

Affiliation: 1 Superstructures Consulting Engineers, Pretoria, South Africa2 South African National Roads Agency SOC Ltd , Pretoria, South Africa

Keywords: pedestrian bridge; arch; steel composite; dynamics; vibration, damping, buckling; non-linearanalysis

The new Erasmusrand Pedestrian bridge replaced the previously impact-damaged pedestrian bridgespanning across the National Route 1 Freeway in Pretoria, South Africa for the South African National RoadsAgency SOC Ltd (SANRAL). The structure consists of a steel arch supporting a composite steel/concretedeck with inclined square hollow steel struts. The bridge spans 73m across a 10-lane dual carriagewayfreeway providing access to a local school from the suburbs. Several challenges were presented in theproject with procurement, design and construction.

An initial assessment report explored the possibility of saving the badly twisted portals on the old steel bridge.Although the costs were slightly cheaper than a new construction, there were inherent risks with theapproach and the decision was therefore taken to demolish. However, in terms of the procurement rules ofSANRAL, the design of the new structure had to be put out to tender but not as a design competition. Onceappointed the new design consultant had to put at least 3 different proposals on the table about costs andaesthetics.

The inclined sides of the road cutting profile at the site favoured an arch or frame type of solution. However,the road cut formation was relatively shallow resulting in a low rise to span ratio. With the low rise to spanratio a number of design challenges were presented such as susceptibility to buckling, susceptibility tovibrations under dynamic footfall forces and sensitivity to variation in temperature and support conditions.

Construction challenges included fabrication of plate elements with complex geometry, handling andtransport of massive assemblies and stability during erection.

The paper discusses the procurement, design development and construction challenges and how thesewere overcome.

Fig. 1. Elevation View of Erasmusrand Pedestrian Bridge