probing the character of the pygmy dipole...

43
V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments Investigation of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance in particle- coincidence experiments V. Derya 1* , J. Endres 1 , M. N. Harakeh 2,3 , D. Savran 4,5 , M. Spieker 1* , H. J. Wörtche 2 , and A. Zilges 1 1 Institute for Nuclear Physics, University of Cologne, Germany 2 KVI, Rijksuniversiteit Groningen, The Netherlands 3 GANIL, CEA/DSM-CNRS/IN2P3, Caen, France 4 ExtreMe Matter Institute EMMI and Research Division, GSI, Darmstadt, Germany 5 Frankfurt Institute for Advanced Studies FIAS, Frankfurt a.M., Germany 4th Workshop on Nuclear Level Density and Gamma Strength Oslo, May 27 31, 2013 Supported by the DFG (ZI 510/4-2 and SFB 634), by the EU under EURONS Contract No. RII3-CT-2004-506065 in the 6th framework programme, and by the Alliance Program of the Helmholtz Association (HA216/EMMI) *Supported by the Bonn-Cologne Graduate School of Physics and Astronomy

Upload: others

Post on 02-Nov-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Investigation of the Pygmy Dipole Resonance

    in particle- coincidence experiments

    V. Derya1*, J. Endres1, M. N. Harakeh2,3, D. Savran4,5,

    M. Spieker1*, H. J. Wörtche2, and A. Zilges1

    1Institute for Nuclear Physics, University of Cologne, Germany 2KVI, Rijksuniversiteit Groningen, The Netherlands

    3GANIL, CEA/DSM-CNRS/IN2P3, Caen, France4ExtreMe Matter Institute EMMI and Research Division, GSI, Darmstadt, Germany

    5Frankfurt Institute for Advanced Studies FIAS, Frankfurt a.M., Germany

    4th Workshop on Nuclear Level Density and Gamma Strength

    Oslo, May 27 – 31, 2013

    Supported by the DFG (ZI 510/4-2 and SFB 634), by the EU under EURONS Contract No. RII3-CT-2004-506065

    in the 6th framework programme, and by the Alliance Program of the Helmholtz Association (HA216/EMMI)

    *Supported by the Bonn-Cologne Graduate School of Physics and Astronomy

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Introduction

    The particle- coincidence method

    Systematic study in (,) and (,)

    First results 140Ce(p,p)

    Summary

    Outlook

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Introduction

    Isovectorial electric Giant

    Dipole Resonance

    Low-lying E1 strength

    2-Phonon (2+3-)1-

    Pygmy Dipole

    Resonance (PDR)

    (,) (,Xn)A. Leprêtre et al., Nucl.

    Phys. A258 (1976) 350

    A. Zilges et al., Phys.

    Lett. B 542 (2002) 43

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Relevance of the PDR

    Symmetry energy of the

    equation of state (EOS)

    neutron-skin thickness

    E1 strength

    Nucleosynthesis

    neutron-capture rates

    -ray strength function

    photo-absorption cross section

    S. G

    orie

    ly, Ph

    ys. L

    ett. B

    43

    6 (1

    99

    8) 1

    0

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    PDR studied with (,) in N=82 isotones

    Real-photon scattering for stable nuclei

    below the particle thresholds

    Strongly fragmented E1 strength

    Accessible quantities:

    transition energy E

    multipole character

    reduced transition strength B(E1)

    fragmentation

    integrated strength

    A. Zilges et al., Phys. Lett. B 542 (2002) 43

    S. Volz et al., Nucl. Phys. A779 (2006) 1

    D. Savran et al., Phys. Rev. Lett 100 (2008) 232501

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    ProbeInteraction

    (dominant)

    Location of

    interaction

    Character of

    interaction

    (dominant)

    photon Electromagnetic whole nucleus isovector

    particle* hadronic surface isoscalar

    proton* hadronic surfaceisoscalar and

    isovector

    Probes for scattering experiments

    Insight into the structure of the (dipole) excitations

    •at medium particle energies

    (≈ 50-150 MeV)

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    The particle- coincidence method

    Reaction: inelastic particle scattering

    Coincident detection of particles and rays

    Performed with particles at Kernfysisch

    Versneller Instituut in Groningen, The Netherlands

    beam at E = 136 MeV

    – AGOR cyclotron

    – Cyclotron frequency: 28 MHz

    – Particle current: 0.4-1 pnA

    particle

    particle

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    HPGe-detector array

    beam

    BBS

    20 cm

    Photo by S.G.Pickstone

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Big-Bite Spectrometer

    QQD-type spectrometer

    Two quadrupole magnets

    One dipole magnet

    Maximum solid angle: 9.2 msr

    Ph

    oto

    by

    S.G

    . Pic

    ksto

    ne

    50 cm

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Big-Bite Spectrometer

    EUROSUPERNOVA System

    for particle detection

    – Focal Plane Detector System

    2 Vertical Drift Chambers

    energy and particle

    trajectories

    – scintillator layer trigger

    Ph

    oto

    by

    S.G

    . Pic

    ksto

    ne

    50 cm

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    12

    2,4,31

    PDR region

    Sn

    Excitation spectrum in coincidence

    94Mo (,)

    Typical energy resolution: ≈ 300 keV

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    The - coincidence matrix

    EX E-E [MeV]

    Inte

    nsity

    48Ca(,)

    E[M

    eV

    ]

    Excited states

    Detector response

    Decay branching

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    The - coincidence matrix

    EX E-E [MeV]

    Inte

    nsity

    48Ca(,)

    Energy spectra through projection

    Selecting transitions by setting gates

    E[M

    eV

    ]

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Selecting transitions – Projected spectra

    Gate on EX≈E +1Gate on EX≈E+E2

    12

    10

    48Ca(,)

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    - angular correlation from DWBA

    spin sequence BBS @ 3.5°

    beam

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Experimental method: (,’)

    Selective excitation

    – Isoscalar probe

    – Mainly low spin from ground state

    – Natural parities

    Powerful data analysis

    – HPGe detectors with high energy resolution

    – Selection of transitions

    – Cross sections

    – Branching ratios

    – Angular distributions Spin assignments

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    PDR in 140Ce

    D. Savran et al.,

    Phys. Rev. Lett. 97 (2006) 172502

    Splitting:

    low-energy part

    (,) and (,)

    high-energy part

    (,) only

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Systematic study in (,) and (,) experiments

    J. Endres et al.,

    Phys. Rev. C 80 (2009) 034302

    D. Savran et al.,

    Phys. Rev. Lett. 97 (2006) 172502

    J. Endres, E. Litvinova et al.,

    Phys. Rev. Lett. 105 (2010) 212503

    Neutron magic (N=82) isotones 140Ce and 138Ba

    Proton magic (Z=50) isotope 124Sn

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Systematic study in (,) and (,) experiments

    J. Endres et al.,

    Phys. Rev. C 80 (2009) 034302

    D. Savran et al.,

    Phys. Rev. Lett. 97 (2006) 172502

    J. Endres, E. Litvinova et al.,

    Phys. Rev. Lett. 105 (2010) 212503

    Neutron magic (N=82) isotones 140Ce and 138Ba

    Proton magic (Z=50) isotope 124Sn

    Splitting is a common feature of the low-lying dipole

    response in semi-magic heavy neutron-rich nuclei

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Transition densities for two RQTBA states in 124Sn

    Low-lying state: Typical PDR state

    High-lying state: Transitional region towards the GDR

    Interpretation of the splitting

    J. Endres et al., Phys. Rev. C 85 (2012) 064331

    - In phase

    - Large neutron

    contribution at the

    surface

    - Slightly out of phase

    - Enhanced proton

    contribution

    Similar conclusions in N. Tsoneva et al., Phys. Rev. C 77 (2008) 024321

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    (,) and (,) in 94Mo

    C. Romig,

    private communication

    Non-magic (N=52, Z=42) isotope 94Mo

    Near to (sub) shell closure

    V. Derya et al.,

    Nucl. Phys. A906 (2013) 94

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Systematic study in (,) and (,) experiments

    J. Endres et al.,

    Phys. Rev. C 80 (2009) 034302

    D. Savran et al.,

    Phys. Rev. Lett. 97 (2006) 172502

    J. Endres, E. Litvinova et al.,

    Phys. Rev. Lett. 105 (2010) 212503

    Neutron magic (N=82) isotones 140Ce and 138Ba

    Proton magic (Z=50) isotope 124Sn

    Splitting is a common feature of the low-lying dipole

    response in semi-magic heavy neutron-rich nuclei

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Light-mass nuclei: halo nuclei, single-particle

    character excitations

    Medium-mass nuclei: development of a more

    collective electric-dipole excitation mode?

    Dependence on N/Z ratio in the calcium chain

    Low-lying dipole strength in lighter nuclei

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Low-lying dipole strength in lighter nuclei

    T.D. Poelhekken et al., Phys. Lett. B 278 (1992) 423

    T. Hartmann et al., Phys. Rev. C 65 (2002) 034301

    V. Derya et al., to be published

    T. Hartmann et al., Phys. Rev. C 65 (2002) 034301

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    J=1- states in (,) and (,)

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Strongest state in (,) at 7.3 MeV is missing in (,)

    J=1- states in (,) and (,)

    ?

    d/d < 0.15 mb/sr

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Strongest state in (,) at 7.3 MeV is missing in (,)

    Strongest state in (,) at 7.6 MeV is weak in (,)

    J=1- states in (,) and (,)

    ?

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    High Intensity -Ray Source

    (HIS) at the Duke Free Electron

    Laser Laboratory (DFELL)

    100% linear polarized and nearly

    mono-energetic intense -ray

    beam (I ~ 107 photons/sec)

    6 HPGe detectors:

    – One for beam monitoring

    – One at backward angle

    – Four at = 90° in the horizontal and

    vertical plane Parity assignment

    Target: 48Ca

    – Amount: 1 g

    (≈$250,000)

    Parity Measurement at HIS

    direction of polarization 2 c

    m

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    The State at 7.298 MeV

    -ray beam energy of 7.3 MeV

    Measured for 1.5 h

    Experimental asymmetry:

    SE

    DE

    spectrum of the vertical detectors spectrum of the horizontal detectors

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    9 dipole excitations were observed

    The excited dipole states do have negative parity

    Parity assignments in 48Ca

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    QRPA calculations:

    strong IS LED states present in all even-even

    Ca isotopes (N=14-40)P. Papakonstantinou et al. PLB 709 (2012) 270

    Character changes

    proton-skin oscillation

    pure IS oscillation

    neutron-skin oscillation

    Experimental results on 48Ca:

    – separated strong IS LED state at 7.6 MeV

    – weak in IV channel pure IS oscillation

    character changes at N > 28

    Comparison with theoretical results for 48Ca

    Nat N=30

    (Gogny interaction)

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    ProbeInteraction

    (dominant)

    Location of

    interaction

    Character of

    interaction

    (dominant)

    photon Electromagnetic whole nucleus isovector

    particle* hadronic surface isoscalar

    proton* hadronic surfaceisoscalar and

    isovector

    Probes for scattering experiments

    Insight into the structure of the (dipole) excitations

    •at medium particle energies

    (≈ 50-150 MeV)

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    performed at KVI

    beam energy: 80 MeV

    central BBS angle: 6°

    8 HPGe detectors

    target enrichment: 99.72 %

    First results 140Ce(p,p)

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Excitation spectrum in coincidence

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    spectrum with gate on Ex=E

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Comparison of the probes

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Comparison of the probes

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Systematic study of E1 excitations in (,) and

    (,) experiments in stable and spherical nuclei

    – A = 48-140

    – N/Z = 1.23-1.48

    – semi-, doubly-, and non-magic

    (,) method is appropriate tool for identifying

    the contribution of the PDR to the total E1

    strength and strength function

    First results of 140Ce(p,p) show qualitatively

    different behavior for the proton probe

    Summary

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Outlook: iThemba LABS

    K600 spectrometer at 0°

    Continuation of particle- coincidence experiments

    at medium particle (p, , …) energies

    First feasibility test in December 2012

    – Performed by R. Neveling et al.

    – beam of 160 MeV energy

    – 2 Clover detectors, 1 big NaI detector

    R. Neveling et al., Progress Report: PR194 (2013)

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Outlook: &HORUS in Cologne

    HORUS: spectrometer

    14 HPGe detectors

    6 BGO shields

    Photopeak efficiencywith SONIC: 2% at 1332 keV

    Energy resolutionwith digital DAQ: ≤2.5 keV at 1332 keV, 6 kcps

    SONIC: particle spectrometer

    Silicon Identification Chamber

    8 E-E detector tubes

    Solid angle coverage ≈ 4%

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Combining and particle spectroscopy

    various probes (p, d, , …)

    particle- coincidence

    Outlook: &HORUS in Cologne

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    Combining and particle spectroscopy

    various probes (p, d, , …)

    particle- coincidence

    Excitation-energy spectrum from

    a very recent experiment:92Mo(p,p‘) at 10.5 MeV

    Si detector at 131°

    E = 79 keV @ 10.5 MeV

    Outlook: &HORUS in Cologne

  • V. Derya, University of Cologne, AG Zilges The PDR in particle- coincidence experiments

    University of Cologne (Cologne, Germany)

    V. Derya, J. Endres, A. Hennig, J. Mayer, L. Netterdon,

    S. G. Pickstone, P. Scholz, M. Spieker, T.-M. Streit,

    M. Weinert, and A. Zilges

    Kernfysisch VersnelIer Instituut (Groningen, The Netherlands)

    S. Bagchi, M. N. Harakeh, N. Kalantar, A. Najafi, C. Rigollet,

    and H. J. Wörtche

    ExtreMe Matter Institute (Darmstadt, Germany)

    E. Fiori, J. Isaak, B. Löher, D. Savran, and J. Silva

    TU Darmstadt (Darmstadt, Germany)

    N. Pietralla, C. Romig, and M. Scheck

    Supported by: