Program Chairs’ Report

David EvansUniversity of Virginia

Giovanni VignaUC Santa Barbara

Agenda

Review Process

Some Statistics on the Papers

Awards

Giuseppe Ateniese, Johns Hopkins UniversityMichael Backes, Saarland University / Max Planck ISSAdam Barth, University of California, Berkeley Nikita Borisov, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign David Brumley, Carnegie Mellon University Cristian Cadar, Imperial College London Shuo Chen, Microsoft Research Redmond Anupam Datta, Carnegie Mellon University Nick Feamster, Georgia Institute of Technology Debin Gao, Singapore Management University Jon Giffin, Georgia Institute of TechnologyVirgil Gligor, Carnegie Mellon University Michael Goodrich, University of California, Irvine J. Alex Halderman, University of Michigan Somesh Jha, University of Wisconsin Rob Johnson, Stony Brook University Engin Kirda, Eurecom, France Yoshi Kohno, University of Washington Shriram Krishnamurthi, Brown University Christopher Kruegel, University of California, Santa Barbara Ruby Lee, Princeton University Michael Locasto, George Mason University Sergio Maffeis, Imperial College London Z. Morley Mao, University of Michigan Jonathan McCune, Carnegie Mellon University David Molnar, Microsoft Research Redmond Cristina Nita-Rotaru, Purdue University Vern Paxson, University of California, Berkeley Mike Reiter, University of North Carolina Andrei Sabelfeld, Chalmers University Stuart Schechter, Microsoft Research Redmond Hovav Shacham, University of California, San Diego Vitaly Shmatikov, University of Texas at Austin Radu Sion, Stony Brook University Sean Smith, Dartmouth College Adam Smith, Pennsylvania State University Dawn Song, University of California, Berkeley Angelos Stavrou, George Mason UniversityEd Suh, Cornell University Patrick Traynor, Georgia Institute of Technology V. N. (“Venkat”) Venkatakrishnan, University of Illinois at Chicago Dan Wallach, Rice University Brent Waters, University of Texas at Austin Westley Weimer, University of Virginia XiaoFeng Wang, Indiana University Felix Wu, University of California, Davis Dongyan Xu, Purdue University Haifeng Yu, National University of Singapore Sencun Zhu, Pennsylvania State University

Giuseppe Ateniese, Johns Hopkins UniversityMichael Backes, Saarland University / Max Planck ISSAdam Barth, University of California, Berkeley Nikita Borisov, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign David Brumley, Carnegie Mellon University Cristian Cadar, Imperial College London Shuo Chen, Microsoft Research Redmond Anupam Datta, Carnegie Mellon University Nick Feamster, Georgia Institute of Technology Debin Gao, Singapore Management University Jon Giffin, Georgia Institute of TechnologyVirgil Gligor, Carnegie Mellon University Michael Goodrich, University of California, Irvine J. Alex Halderman, University of Michigan Somesh Jha, University of Wisconsin Rob Johnson, Stony Brook University Engin Kirda, Eurecom, France Yoshi Kohno, University of Washington Shriram Krishnamurthi, Brown University Christopher Kruegel, University of California, Santa Barbara Ruby Lee, Princeton University Michael Locasto, George Mason University Sergio Maffeis, Imperial College London Z. Morley Mao, University of Michigan Jonathan McCune, Carnegie Mellon University David Molnar, Microsoft Research Redmond Cristina Nita-Rotaru, Purdue University Vern Paxson, University of California, Berkeley Mike Reiter, University of North Carolina Andrei Sabelfeld, Chalmers University Stuart Schechter, Microsoft Research Redmond Hovav Shacham, University of California, San Diego Vitaly Shmatikov, University of Texas at Austin Radu Sion, Stony Brook University Sean Smith, Dartmouth College Adam Smith, Pennsylvania State University Dawn Song, University of California, Berkeley Angelos Stavrou, George Mason UniversityEd Suh, Cornell University Patrick Traynor, Georgia Institute of Technology V. N. (“Venkat”) Venkatakrishnan, University of Illinois at Chicago Dan Wallach, Rice University Brent Waters, University of Texas at Austin Westley Weimer, University of Virginia XiaoFeng Wang, Indiana University Felix Wu, University of California, Davis Dongyan Xu, Purdue University Haifeng Yu, National University of Singapore Sencun Zhu, Pennsylvania State University

Program Committee

External ReviewersAditya AkellaAslan AskarovThanassis AvgerinosLucas BallardMatthias BergKarthikeyan BhargavanLeyla BilgeArnar BirgissonPrithvi BishtRaymond BuseJuan CaballeroStephen CheckowayJoe CooleyScott CrosbyDeepak D’SouzaPierre Malo DanielouMatthew DavisManuel EgeleJason FranklinMatt FredriksonDeepak GargPaolo Gasti

Sebastian GerlingSteven GianvecchioKalpana GondiXun GongBill HarrisPieter HooimeijerAmir HoumansadrSonia JahidLimin JiaAaron JohnsonDeborah JohnsonJoshua JuenBoris Koepf Louis KrugerAndrea LanziClaire Le GouesJongHyup LeePeng LiZhou LiZhuowei LiZhiqiang LinMike Ter Louw

Matteo MaffeiStephen McCamantKazuhiro MinamiPrateek MittalEsfandiar MohammadiMadan MusuvathiChitra MuthukrishnanShishir NagarajaArvind NarayananGiang NguyenKim PecinaAdrian PerrigMichael PiatekWillard RafnssonRaphael ReischukEric RescorlaJunghwan RheeAlejandro RussoBrian SchulteEdward SchwartzHendrik SchweppeDan Simon

Yingbo SongMiroslava SotakovaAhren StuderChristopher SzilagyiAnkur TalyMichael TschantzDominique UnruhDanny WalkerQiyan WangRui WangXinran WangBogdan WarinschiNicholas WeaverDinghao WuTing-Fang YenKehuan ZhangMichelle Zhou

Nov 18

237

170

9670 62

26

30

24

22

14 10

5

Round 1:2 reviews

Round 2:1-2 more reviews

Round 3:1-2 more reviews

Online discussion,

more reviews

PC MeetingDeadline

SoK

26-27 Jan

Charlottesville, VA

Dec 18 Jan 11 Jan 23

Review Process

PC Meeting

59

289

268

155

51

3

All Research Reviews 1: Hopeless2: Strong Reject3: Weak Reject4: Weak Accept5: Accept6: Strong Accept

4

40

22

22

18

1All SoK Reviews

9

34

58

32

3

2: Strong Reject3: Weak Reject4: Weak Accept5: Accept6: Strong Accept

Accepted Research Papers

3

Papers by Country

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

Number of submissions

# accepted 1/(acceptance rate)

counting each contact author / number of authors

Luxe

mbo

urg

Switz

erla

nd

Cana

da

Aust

ria

Ger

man

y

Nor

way

Om

an

Fran

ce

Italy

Kore

a

Slov

ak R

epub

lic

Taiw

an Iran

Paki

stan

Chile

Indi

a0.00.51.01.52.02.53.03.54.04.55.0

Submissions per Million (shared by authors)

Aust

ria

Israe

l

Switz

erla

nd

Belg

ium

USA

Net

herla

nds

UK

Fran

ce

Italy

Chin

a0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

Accepts per million (shared by authors)

Syste

m secu

rity

Attacks

and defe

nses

Cryptogra

phy

Secu

rity a

rchite

ctures

Intrusio

n detecti

on

Form

al Meth

ods

Web

secu

rity

Secu

re inform

ation flow

Secu

rity a

nd privac

y polic

ies

Hardware

secu

rity

Usabilit

y and se

curit

y

Embed

ded sy

stems s

ecurit

y

Recove

ry

Censo

rship-re

sistan

ce0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

SubmittedAccepted (Scaled)

Submits/Accepts by Topic

Lang

uage

-bas

ed se

curit

yW

eb se

curit

ySe

cure

info

rmati

on fl

owSy

stem

secu

rity

Form

al M

etho

dsEm

bedd

ed sy

stem

s sec

urity

Appl

icati

on se

curit

yAtt

acks

and

def

ense

sH

ardw

are

secu

rity

Aver

age

Mal

war

eSe

curit

y ar

chite

ctur

esN

etw

ork

secu

rity

Auth

entic

ation

Secu

rity

and

priv

acy

polic

ies

Anon

ymity

Met

rics

Fore

nsic

sIn

trus

ion

dete

ction

Acce

ss c

ontr

olU

sabi

lity

and

secu

rity

Prot

ocol

secu

rity

Cryp

togr

aphy

Priv

acy-

pres

ervi

ng sy

stem

sD

istr

ibut

ed sy

stem

s sec

urity

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%Acceptance Rate by Topic

Language-based security AND Web security: 100% (3/3)

Best Paper Awards

Paper Awards CommitteeDavid Evans, University of Virginia

Somesh Jha, University of Wisconsin Yoshi Kohno*, University of Washington Mike Reiter, University of North Carolina

Giovanni Vigna, UC Santa Barbara

* Not for Best Practical Paper Award

Best Practical Paper

Presented by IEEE Security & Privacy Magazine to the “paper most likely to immediately improve the security of current environments and systems.”

Best Practical PaperChip and PIN is Broken

Steven J. MurdochSaar DrimerRoss AndersonMike Bond

University of Cambridge

Best Student Paper

TaintScope: A Checksum-Aware Directed Fuzzing Tool for Automatic Software

Vulnerability DetectionTielei Wang, Peking UniversityTao Wei, Peking UniversityGuofei Gu, Texas A & M UniversityWei Zou, Peking University

Best Paper

SCiFI - A System for Secure Face Identification

Margarita OsadchyBenny PinkasAyman JarrousBoaz Moskovich

Univesity of Haifa

Thanks!

Giovanni VignaProgram Committee

membersExternal reviewersAuthors

OrganizersUlf Lindqvist (General Chair)Deb Frincke (Registration)Al Shaffer (Treasurer)Jenny McNeill (Publications chair)Carrie Gates (Poster and workshops chair)Adrienne Felt (Web/design chair)Angelos Stavrou (Short talks chair)Peter Neumann (30th Anniversary papers)Technical Committee: Hilarie Orman, Terry Benzel, Sven Dietrich, Cynthia Irvine