puerto rico insurance summit - cmara de comercio de
TRANSCRIPT
PUERTO RICO INSURANCE SUMMIT
Observations of the Bermuda
Insurance and Reinsurance Market
April 25, 2012
Agenda
Bermuda Market: Key Facts & Statistics
History of the Bermuda Insurance and Reinsurance Market
Regulation
– Role of the Bermuda Monetary Authority
– The Multi-License System
Captives
Collateralized Market Sector
Keys to Bermuda’s success
2
Bermuda Market: Key Facts
The Bermuda insurance and reinsurance market comprises
– total assets of $525B
– capital of $185B
– gross premium of $108B
Employee count of 32,000 worldwide with 1,700 located in Bermuda
– most companies have significant global infrastructure
24 Global & independent brokers have offices on island
US-Bermuda Tax Convention Act: provides tax relief for Bermuda’s International
Business sector
3
Bermuda Market: Key Facts
All lines of insurance & reinsurance are transacted in Bermuda, with large
amounts of capacity available
Bermuda carriers write 40% of the US property cat capacity
– 60% of the hurricane reinsurance in Florida and Texas
– 30% of US crop reinsurance
25% of the US medical liability insurance and reinsurance market
For International business, it is estimated that Bermuda reinsurers have:
– 37% of reported claims from Europe’s 2010 Windstorm Xynthia
– 38% of reported claims from Chile’s 2010 earthquake
– 51% of reported claims from New Zealand’s 2010 earthquake
– 14% of reported claims from the Japan 2011 earthquake and tsunami
4
Bermuda Market: Key Facts
2011 has seen an increased number of ‘sidecars’ & Special Purpose Insurers,
including Cat Bonds
– Special Purpose Vehicles offer reinsurance for a limited timeframe
– Largely funded by hedge funds
– Sidecars assume ‘side-by-side’ position with traditional reinsurer in risk
selection
– 23 SPI’s registered in 2011 versus 8 in 2010
– Some examples of new and re-issued sidecars include:
New Point IV (Alterra) - $200M capitalization
Accordion Re (Lancashire) - $250M capitalization
Alpha Cat 2011 (Validus) - $130M capitalization
DaVinci Re (Ren Re) – additional $100M capital
5
6
How does Bermuda compare?
Bermuda Total GWP Munich Re GWP
$107,7m $31,280m
Bermuda 2010 GWP Europe 2010 GWP
$107,7m $96,606m
Bermudian Top Three Lloyd's Total
GWP GWP
$13,215m $12,977m
Bermuda Market: History
1947: AIG founder CV Starr selects Bermuda as the location for American
International
1960’s: Fred Reiss creates the concept of a captive insurer and chooses
Bermuda as the most suitable domicile
1985/6: Ace & XL formed during the US Liability insurance crisis
1988: Centre Re (now Centre Solutions) formed with $250M of capital,
provided mainly by Zurich Insurance Group
– made Bermuda the focus for structured products
1992: following Hurricane Andrew the Bermuda reinsurance market was
formed
– 7 property cat reinsurers founded following influx of $4B of capital
including Mid Ocean, Tempest Re and Ren Re
7
Bermuda Market: History
Late 1990’s: Arrow Re and Lehman Re were formed to be transformer
companies as insurance and financial markets converged
2001: $10B+ of capital raised post 9/11
– S&P reported 50% of capital raised post 9/11 came to Bermuda
– new carriers included Arch Re, Allied World, Axis, Endurance and
Montpelier Re
2005: $18B of capital raised following damage from Hurricanes Katrina, Rita &
Wilma
– new carriers included Ariel Re, Flagstone Re, Harbor Point Re,
Lancashire and Validus Re
– sidecars created by Arch Re, Montpelier Re, Ren Re, XL Re and others
2011: Bermuda largely withstands the test of $115B of insured natural
catastrophe losses. Recent start-ups include Third Point Re and Pac Re
which highlights the continued convergence with the capital markets 8
Regulation: Bermuda Monetary Authority (BMA)
Established under the Bermuda Monetary Authority Act 1969
– supervises, regulates and inspects financial institutions operating in or from
within its jurisdiction
– issues national currency
– assists with detection and prevention of financial crime
– advises the government on banking and other financial matters
It has regulatory responsibility for a market that comprises of:
– banking sector with total assets of $23B
– the Bermuda Stock Exchange with total market capitalization of over $319B
– 1,200 companies in the Insurance market and total assets in excess of $525B
9
Regulation: The Multi-License System
Class 1
– Single Parent Captive insuring the risks of its owner
– Minimum capital & surplus of $120K
Class 2
– Multi Owner Captive insuring the risks of its owners
– Also applies to a single parent or multi owner captive writing less than 20% of net
premium from risks not related to the business of their owners
– Minimum capital & surplus of $250K
Class 3
– Includes structured reinsurers writing 3rd party business or insurers writing direct
policies with 3rd party individuals
– Also applies to a single parent group, association or agency where more than 20%
and less than 50% of net premium is from risks unrelated to the business of their
owners
– Minimum capital and surplus of $1M
10
Regulation: The Multi-License System (cont.)
Class 4
– Insurers and reinsurers writing direct excess liability insurance and/or property Cat
reinsurance risks
– Minimum capital and surplus of $100M
Special Purpose Insurers
– Carrying on business in the area of insurance-linked securitizations
– Insurer is established to enter a single transaction or a single set of transactions
– Their obligations are fully collateralized
Long Term
– Insurers writing life business
Composite / Dual License
– Insurers and reinsurers who carry on both general and long-term business
– Composite companies are required to maintain minimum capital and surplus the sum of
both general and the long-term business class
Intermediaries
– Insurance managers, brokers and agents
11
Captives
12
Bermuda is viewed as a global leader in the Captives market worldwide
Captive premiums currently estimated at $20B
Largest proportion of Bermuda’s captives are US owned entities
Classes of business include:
– General Liability
– Auto Liability
– Workers Compensation
– Property
– Marine
– Healthcare / Medical Malpractice
Global Captive Domiciles
Bermuda 845
Cayman 738
Vermont 572
Guernsey 341
Anguilla 252
Luxembourg 244
Barbados 242
BVI 219
Turks & Caicos 211
13
Captives contd.
Rent-a-Captive (RAC)
– An insurance or reinsurance company organized to insure / reinsure risks of
unrelated shareholders
– Participants pay a fee to ‘rent’ the insurance company license to insured’s
– Each insured’s results and funds are kept separate and the RAC retains no risk
– Bermuda is the leading domicile for RAC’s
– 25 current providers on island for RAC’s including:
ACE Bermuda
Alternative Re
American Physicians Capital
Capital Management Services
Cedar Management Limited
Insurance Company of the West
Liberty Mutual Management
16
17
Bermuda Collateralized Markets
Significant market presence in Bermuda with $10B+ of capital offering a non-
traditional collateral product
Collateral posted by way of Trust Agreement or Letter of Credit
Strengths
No credit risk rather than a promise to pay
Able to provide meaningful capacity with some offering lines of $100M+
Willing to look at products that some rated markets are reluctant to provide, eg. Cat
Bonds, Retro, Multi-Line
Weaknesses
Many funds need to generate high teens ROL to ensure they meet their requisite
ROE targets
Cannot provide a reinstatement, with the occasional exception
Focused on short tail Cat business only
Some carriers have concerns about final commutation of collateral, particularly on
high layers which can be effected by loss development
What’s So Special About Bermuda?
18
‘Bermuda holds a position
within the global reinsurance
and insurance industry that is
the envy of domiciles such as
Zurich and Singapore and I do
not see that changing in the
next 10 years’
David Cash, CEO Endurance
Specialty
Source: Bermuda Insurance Update Vol. 3&4, 2011, Bermuda Gazette, GR Market Report Feb 2012
‘I really don’t think many of
us fully appreciated the
power of the brand until we
saw how well it withstood
the economic setbacks
that have rocked the world’
Paula Cox, Premier of
Bermuda
‘One thing I can say for
certain is that as long as
Bermuda remains an
important center for
insurance and reinsurance,
we intend to play a leading
role’
Mike McGavick, CEO XL Group
‘Bermuda's been very good
for us, we moved here for
strategic, regulatory and
tax reasons and all have
worked out fine for us’
Bronek Masojada, CEO Hiscox
‘This is all about taking a
long-term view and again,
nobody does that better
than Bermuda’
Joe Plumeri, Chairman Willis
Keys to Bermuda’s Success
Reputation: ‘Blue chip offshore financial center’ with a critical mass of capacity
Competitive Prices: Contrary to belief, Bermuda is no more expensive for the establishment
and management of a company than any other major offshore jurisdiction
Regulatory Flexibility: Sound but flexible regulation – sufficient oversight to ensure probity
and solvency, but willingness to embrace new capital
Tax Assurance: No income or capital taxes until at least 2016
– lack of personal income tax an additional factor for non-US employees
Privacy: Maintain confidentiality regarding sponsors of commercial transactions
Speed: Due to the partnership of Government and industry, commercial objectives can be
achieved quickly
Professional Expertise: A core of excellent professionals wok and live in Bermuda
Cutting-Edge Telecoms: The island is fully Web-wired with first rate satellite and fixed-link
communications
Quality of Living: a domicile with a high standard of living including schools, transport, and
access to the US and Europe
19
Summary
20
Significant financial and intellectual capital, with a track record of success
in the US and International insurance and reinsurance markets
Last decade has cemented position as a major market player
Bermuda has shown its resilience in the face of a number of major events
2011 catastrophe losses were an income event rather than a balance
sheet event
Bermuda continues to diversify its capacity, with the capital markets and
special purpose vehicles increasing their presence
The threat of other low tax jurisdictions are being addressed by the
Bermudian government
Quality of living is a key factor to the continued success of Bermuda
Bermuda Insurance Markets
ACE LIMITED ANEMOS INSURANCE MANAGEMENT IRON-STARR
ALLIED WORLD ASSURANCE CAT EXCESS LIABILITY
LANCASHIRE INSURANCE
ALTERRA CAPITAL CHARTIS LEXINGTON INSURANCE
ARCH INSURANCE (BERMUDA) CHUBB ATLANTIC INDEMNITY MONTPELIER
ARGO COLONIAL OIL
ARIEL RE CORPORATE OFFICERS & DIRECTORS
ASSURANCE (CODA)
OCIL
ASPEN INSURANCE ENDURANCE SPECIALTY SOVEREIGN RISK
AXIS INSURNACE EVEREST STEAMSHIP MUTUAL
BF&M HARDY BERMUDA TORUS
CANOPIUS
HISCOX INSURANCE XL INSURANCE
ATTORNEY LIABILITY
ASSURANCE SOCIETY (ALAS)
IRONSHORE INSURANCE ZURICH INTERNATIONAL
22
Bermuda Reinsurance Markets
Bold = Traditional Rated Markets
Non-Bold = Non-Traditional and/or Collateralized Markets
ACE TEMPEST RE AXIS IAT RE PLATINUM RE
AQR Re CANOPIUS IRIS RE RENAISSANCE RE
AEOLUS RE CATLIN JRG RE SIRIUS AMERICA
ALLIANZ RISK TRANSFER CATCO JUNIPERUS RE THIRD POINT RE
ALLIED WORLD DAVINCI RE LANCASHIRE TOKIO MILLENNIUM RE
ALPHA CAT RE DE SHAW MERCURY CAPITAL TOP LAYER RE
ALTERRA RE ELEMENTUM MONTPELIER RE TRANSATLANTIC RE
AMERICAN SAFETY RE ENDURANCE MS FRONTIER RE VALIDUS RE
AMLIN EVEREST RE NEON WIND RIVER RE
ARCH RE FLAGSTONE RE NEPHILA XL RE
ARGO RE HANNOVER RE NEW POINT RE
ARIEL RE HARDY PARTNER RE
ASPEN HISCOX PENTELIA
23
24
Company 2011 Capital
(estimated)
Lead Investors
Advent Re $48m Advent Syndicate
Aeolus Re $1,500m Multiple Investors
Alpha Cat $130m Validus
Arrow Capital $100m Goldman Sachs
Catco $500m QIC
DE Shaw Re $1,000m Shaw Capital
Elementum $500m Elementum, Stark
Iris Re $100m Cartesian, Aspen
Juniperus Re $300m Aquiline Capital
Nephila $6,000m Multiple Investors
Neon TBA TBA
New Point Re $200m Alterra, Stone Point Capital
Pentelia Capital $150m Natixis, Mitsubishi
2011 Collateralized Markets