putting out the fire: when a crisis occurs
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
Pamela J. Ritz, ARM, SPHR, CRM, HACCPPresidentSpecialty Risk Management, Inc.®
May 16, 2008
Crisis Crisis Management Management in the World in the World
of Food of Food Borne Borne
IllnessIllness
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
SRM has created a closely integrated team with expertise in the areas of:
– Food Law– Public Health Law– Communicable
Disease/Pathology– Product Recall– Media– Marketing Response– Customer Response– Employment Practices– Business Recovery– Contracts– Insurance
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
•• 100%100% of our prevented cases happen within a matter of hours of the first Health Department contact
• However, 5% slip through to “public/media events” … TIME ISTIME IS
OF THE OF THE ESSENCE!ESSENCE!
Prevention
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Presently 11,000 to 12,000 Interactions per Year on “Media”-Based Events
Food Borne Illness
1997 - 2008
Interactions73,937
Summary
• 41% Customers• 38% Company Crisis
Management• 6% Insurance Carriers• 4% Health Department• 5% Media• 3% Medical• 2% Law Firms• 1% Lab
Recall Manufacturers
2002 - 2008
Interactions4,328
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Food Borne Crisis – “Plug In”
MarketingInternal orExternal
PublicRelations
HumanResources
RiskManagement/
Insurance Carrier(s)
CorporateManagement
RestaurantManagement
Quality Assurance/
HealthDepartment
Increase EffectivenessIncrease Effectiveness
Goals• Integrate• Take on
character of company
• Uniquely mold to each event
• Be invisible• Earn our
place
1.1. Current Trends Current Trends –– WhatWhat’’s Hot Now s Hot Now
2.2. Prevention / ControlPrevention / Control3.3. Controversial Controversial ––
““PammiePammie DearestDearest’’ss”” Future PredictionsFuture Predictions
Current Trends Current Trends --WhatWhat’’s Hot Nows Hot Now
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Even If You Are Doing Everything You Can to Monitor your Employee’s Health and Exclude any Symptomatic Employees …
Scenario:A “Regular” customer (retiree) walks into your restaurant and seats himself at his usual table. On his way, he stops to grab his own silverware accidentally touching other pieces of silverware. Little does he know he is a carrier of Norwalk virus …
He visits with his favorite wait staff. She has been an acquaintance and server for almost two years. He finished his meal and she clear the dishes while serving his final cup of coffee…
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Illness is Building … HD - Slow to Respond …
• Week 1 (total of 9 ill guests, 1 ill employee)– Sunday: - Customer infected with Norovirus eats at restaurant– Wednesday: - Server calls in sick– Thursday: - Server returns to work– Saturday: - 8 guests eat – sick within 48 hours (Server working)
• Week 2 (total of 45 ill guests, 13 ill employees)– Sunday: - 14 guests eat – sick within 48 hours (Server working)– Monday: - 3 employees call in sick
- 3 guests eat – sick within 48 hours– Tuesday: - 6 employees call in sick
- 6 guests eat – sick within 48 hours– Wednesday: - 2 employees call in sick– Thursday: - 9 guests eat – sick within 48 hours– Friday: - Employee calls in sick
- First inspection related to customer complaints – HD gets involved
– Saturday: - Employee calls in sick- 13 guests eat - sick within 48 hours
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Warning Signs are often missed…
• Week 3 (total of 24 ill guests, 2 ill employees)– Sunday: - 9 guests eat - sick within 24 hours– Monday: - SRM receives call from restaurant for help
- 1 employee calls in sick- 4 guests eat – sick within 24 hours
– Tuesday: - 1 employee calls in sick- 3 guests eat – sick within 24 hours
– Wednesday: - 4 guests eat – sick within 24 hours– Thursday: - 1 guest eats – sick within 24 hours– Friday: - 3 guests eat – sick within 24 hours
- Confirmed death from complications- Restaurant closes
– Saturday: - Media circus begins- Intense cleaning
• Week 4– Sunday: - Intense cleaning– Monday: - Re-inspection– Tuesday: - Re-opened restaurant
100 sick 8 hospitalized 1 death
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Scenario:Employee travels internationally –
unknowingly exposed to Hep A
• Friday, 5 p.m.: Health Department Press Release– “The County Health Department has
learned that a worker with confirmed infectious Hepatitis A worked while ill at “our” restaurant.
– People who dined at this restaurant between March 14 and March 25 contact their local Health Department or healthcare provider for assessment and vaccination.
– A vaccination clinic will be set up next week. It is strongly recommended all over 12 months obtain the vaccine.
– Symptoms for Hep A are …
“Laissez Faire” (hands off) Health Department – Hep A
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
• Week 1– Friday afternoon
• 5:00 - Press Release – Health Department goes home• 5:30 - 60 phone calls to restaurant• 6:00 - Local news continues• 7:00 - Calls from weekend reporters• 8:00 - Cameras rolling in parking lot• 10:00 - Return calls to local media complete
– Saturday• Customer hotline running• Customers (eating 14th, 15th, want testing and shots)• Health Department available for one (1) call Saturday with
company – vaccine / IG harder to find than realized, maybe no clinic or maybe Wednesday
• More cameras rolling out front• No private physician has vaccine / IG• All employees inoculated/tested
Media Nightmare Cycle & Upset Customer Eruption
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
The rest of the
story…
– Sunday – Private clinics established by restaurant for testing/shots
– Monday (within 48 hrs)• By 8:30 a.m. 2300 customer calls over
weekend• Media stories Monday
– Tuesday• Starting arrangements for >155 customers
shots from California, Canada, Florida – 22 states total
• Media stories Tuesday– Wednesday
• H.D. slates one day for shots – only 1000 shots available – run out in a matter of hours
• Stampede of customers as they rush to private clinics for shots – only to wait for hours due to long lines – “standing room only” – “wall to wall” people
• Media (big) – “not enough shots”– Thursday - Customer calls – follow up– Friday – Customer calls – follow up
• Week 2– Saturday
• Health Department gives another 250 shots• Customers also want testing
9,700 Total Interactions
No restaurant closure!
85% in revenue
1 employee illNo other employees (ill)
No ill customers
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
HD / Media Problems We Currently See…• Customers hear “Hepatitis” or
“Norovirus” – demand treatment• “Fecal/oral” route stalls business• Workers with Hep A “worked
while ill” (customer anger)• “Contact your local Health
Department or Healthcare Provider – You’re Exposed”
• Delayed response after press announcements – 5 to 7 days even in a pro-active HD setting
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
Crisis Management Environment• Friday night press releases – weekend
catastrophes• Coordination of nationwide needs• Availability of “serum”• Testing/treating your own employees –
pre-requisite for restaurant re-opening• “Cash strapped” Health Departments are
charging for services
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
Dollar Costs to the Community…or will it be you?
• Scenario: Patrons wait 3 hours for Hep A inoculations– **“One elderly woman fainted in
line and was taken to a hospital”– **“’They expected several
thousand people, but it looks like half of Arlington is here’, said Wayne Springer, the deputy fire chief.”
• Total InoculationsGiven (2 wks customers): 38003800
• Cost per Inoculation: x $35-$75• Total Cost of
Inoculations: $133,000$133,000--$285,000$285,000
** As reported by The Boston Globe, 6/19/04
• Customers expect treatment
• Insurance carriers may not covermay not cover
• “Tax Dollar Expenditure” outrage
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
Health Departments may Regulate our Restaurants but …
Public Health Law mission statement:
… The board shall exercise its power in matters relating to protecting the public health to prevent the introduction of disease into the state… including anything necessary or expedient to promote health or suppress disease…
No thought for revenue/expense impactNo after-hours/weekend support
Law allows unlimited use of media
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
Public Health Varies by State - Will Impact Your Event
TennesseeTennessee GeorgiaGeorgia CaliforniaCalifornia New JerseyNew Jersey
3 Regions Single Strong Coordination
– not a “Monolithic”
Force
Cities + Overlapping “Agencies” Divided by
County
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
American’s Demand Healthcare Increasing Phenomenon
• Most don’t know personal vaccine history• Want to be tested or treated• Internet tells them about disease / treatment• Customers want a place to go for help –
immediately• “High end” customers – demanding• “Inoculations / vaccine” not on hand at
treating physicians• What are you going to do?
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
Our First Hurdle Towards Rebuilding Business Traffic
Customers want:AttentionTreatment
Business Recovery Efforts
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
After the Initial Shock of Media Events the Issues of “Liability” and BI Intertwine
BusinessIncome recovery requires “getting out”of the public consciousness
The longer an Insured
remains as a source of
“public contempt” the
longer the BI event
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Sick EmployeeTreatment
HealthDepartmentDoctor
Report
Restaurant
Restaurants and hospitality are uniquely vulnerable to any one of the 35 reportable
diseases
It’s Simply Enough…
Cycle is Defined by Law
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
HealthDepartment
CommonRestaurant
Sick CustomerTreatment
Sick CustomerTreatment
Sick CustomerTreatment
DoctorReport
DoctorReport
DoctorReport
Commonality is Enough to Generate a Health Department Investigation
Restaurants are vulnerable to special risks
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The 1999 Federal Food Code Transferred all Responsibility to the Restaurant Manager
• Managers are expected to know:– Any employees diagnosed– Any employees with symptoms– Any employees previously ill– Any employees with sick family members or who
have recently traveled outside U.S.
Hepatitis, Salmonella, E-Coli, Shigella were the focus (Employees as ‘Carriers’)
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The Big “5”
20052005• Federal Food Code changed• Laboratories upgraded• New abilities to diagnose• “Old Disease” will look like a “new”
problem• Most common Media events
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
Public Health Science v. Traditional Product Testing
• Expectation – “food is long gone” – illness onset time periods
• No actual contaminated food is required to complete investigations
• Food testing advances may not even address (especially virus)
• Food Code changed in 1999 & 2005you should be thereyou should be there
Public Health
Food Borne Illness
assumes:
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
PFGE Patterning / RNA Sequencing Technology is Catching Up
• Health authorities using science of “victims” and statistics– Homeland Security money
has dramatically improved state labs
– “Pulse Net” now tracking all pathogens - E. Coli, Shigella, Salmonella, Hep A
– States now ID Norovirus
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
Complications – Compressed Operating Environments for Restaurants
• Enjoying recent abilities to negotiate insurance premiums
• Property/casualty coverage must be “tested” for “restaurant” industry readiness
• Lawsuits – sick customers don’t help – media impact
• Standard carriers don’t have to pay for your business losses
“Send Money”
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
Smack Down (pleeeeaase)
• “I cannot comment on matters involving litigation” – COME ON!
• Give American people some credit
• “We have given individualized attention to each and every customer – there has never been a need to file a lawsuit.”
Copyright © 2008 SRM®, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
Radical Legal Principles in Food Borne Illness Events - Product Liability
• Customers are entitled to “actual damages” under strict liability law
• You can “render aid” during ongoing investigations without “admitting liability”
• There will always be a “written report” by Health Department
• Enough science to rule out most “fakers”
Prevention / ControlPrevention / Control
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Prevention: (Actual Event) The Phone Rings
“We have taken samples from your ice machine along
with other restaurants in the
city. We found coliforum counts. Do
you have any comments?”
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Creating the “Ick” Factor Thru “Junk Science”
• Making news on a slow day…– Health Department is not
involved– No customers have
complained– Now what?
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Can the media just say anything they want to?
You still can’t yell fire in a crowded theater
No!!No!!No!!No!!
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
There are Laws that Govern the Publication of Information
• “Libel law” - basics still apply
• “Truth” is the media’s only defense
• “Privacy” is another barrier
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Reporters Think About the Factors that “Ping” the Ear of the Public
• Am I affected?• Unknown effects• Caused by employees• Caused by restaurant• Companies we know• Children, elderly, pregnant
women (death or injury)
Media reaction / consumer fear
angles
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Media Prevention Work Means Playing a Game of “Brinksmanship”
• Don’t drop into media training here
• Dialogue – chat only• Stay in touch (you’ll have
another opportunity …)• Do the science (internally)• If you comment - it becomes
the “truth”© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Return Call to Reporter…”Let’s Test Your Science…Buddy”
• So I know that there are natural coliforum counts in public water supplies – how does ours compare?
• “We will want to test, too. Let me compare processes – water testing requires sterile containers obtained from labs with time periods strictly maintained for submission.”
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Goal: Prevent our Brand Name from Being Mentioned – or Article Published
OUTCOMEOUTCOME
NO MEDIA EVENTNO MEDIA EVENT
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
The Weight of “Truth” – Prevention Strategy for “Brand Impact” Protection
Be prepared - 2008 Junk Science Trend
• Coliform Bacteria• Fecal Coliform • “Aerobic Plate Counts”
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
We Slip into “Media” Training Sometimes too Quickly
• There is a natural “surface tension” in any news story called “truth”
• If you break it with volunteered information – “game’s on”
• Don’t remove the “burden” of truth in how you interact
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
“Privacy” has Some Strength as a Tool in Brand Protection
• Customer calls the media with a report of a food borne illness
• Reporter calls – “Would your restaurant like to comment?”
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Truth – In the “Food Borne Illness” World it means Health Department Involvement
• Discipline– “I’d love to talk with you
… have you talked with the Health Department? Who (name)?”
– “What did they say?”– “Can I call you back?”
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Switching Gears: Basic Truths During any Food Borne Illness Event – Public Events
• Must know / understand the Health Department message first
• If there is a message – they must know your plan
• Health Departments now have PR spokesman – you have to seek them out during events
• If there is no ongoing investigation, then there is NO validated illness© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
The Majority of Your Time is Spent on Advertising and Branding
• For our brands – it’s “reflex” now– Reach– Spread– Surveys and analysis– Who “we” are, what “we” serve, who
buys our “stuff” (inside Brand Loyalty)
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
We Know Who and What we are (Reacting to “Pain” or “Reality”)
• It’s just painful to hear / see:– “Popular local eatery sickens
hundreds”– “Tune in at 6 – eating at the most
popular place in town could just be your last meal”
• Your officers are mad• Your largest investors are
shocked• Your founder wants to fight back
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
.
Internal Communication is also Important
• Food borne illness media events will impact our sales
• “Responding” is a long term commitment = day/week/months
• Measure financial impact in context
• Yes - It will cost us money
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
How to Handle the Media – Books are Written about it• There is no magic “structure”• Too often we think:
– Being “open” or “available”– Get our “media trained staff” out
there– Interviews at the restaurant– Get the press releases
out far and wide
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Non-Traditional Marketing / PR
• PR’s role is shaped everyday by the crisis management meeting
• You will be learning “technical” knowledge during an event
• “Get in” and “get out” of the press for a reason
• Control your “reach” and “spread”• Prevent it if you can, of course
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Technology in U.S. gives us some natural limitations on “who hears story”
Broadcast Bands License for a “Fixed” Distance
Impact restricted to “need to know area” for mandated action
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Financial Results - Not Brand Surveys
$0
$10,000
$20,000
$30,000
$40,000
$50,000
$60,000
$0
$10,000
$20,000
$30,000
$40,000
$50,000
$60,000
Affected Location Nearby Location
$0
$10,000
$20,000
$30,000
$40,000
$50,000
$60,000
Other Location$0
$10,000
$20,000
$30,000
$40,000
$50,000
$60,000
Other Location
Year to Year Revenue of Location Tells us How to Rebuild Business
Copyright © 2008 SRMSM, Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.
It is Always a Shock – But Success in Crisis Management is Measurable
• Minimizing the financial drop• Limiting the spread• Focusing on how fast we recover
ActionsAffect
Recovery
Success is…
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Crisis Management is About Continuously Affecting/Reducing Loss – Mentally Prepare Yourselves
Integrated Effort/Expertise
Food Borne Illness Event
Reduce Media
Business Response Plans - Integrating
Marketing Concepts to Increase
Business Flow
Immediate1-800 Customer
Response
Gov’t Control /Pathology Dialogue
Gov’t Control /Pathology Dialogue
ControversialControversial““PammiePammie DearestDearest’’ss””
Future PredictionsFuture Predictions
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
History: CDC Data 1996-2006 10 YEARS
“Supplier Events”
66 Events
8,520Customer Illnesses
“RestaurantCaused Events”
6,000 Events
258,168Customer Illnesses
Current Pre-Occupation with “Supply Chain” Issues
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
There are Often 2 Waves of Media Events
Health Department Press
Events –Media Reactions
Plaintiff Attorney Special Interest
Stories –Media Reactions
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2004
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
“E-Coli Lawyer Cleans Up, Makes Good Money from Bad Food” (article from Associated Press 2/5/08)
Highest Plaintiff Attraction -
Restaurant Events+
Supplier Issues
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Science is tightening the noose
Salmonella Reduction Initiative2008 FSIS / FDA Initiative
Salmonella Reduction Initiative2008 FSIS / FDA Initiative
CDC PostingPulseNet Comparisons
PFGE PFGE
FactoryProduct Sampling
Human Illness /Outbreak Sampling
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
We have to think about more seamless approaches to “worst case”
• Collision course:– (BI) Insurance agents pushing for risk transfer
for financial loss– (GL) Insurance agents pushing for risk
transfer for liability loss– Corporation is pushing coverage and low cost
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Think About the Worst Case Death – Disability – Customer Injury
We want our suppliers sitting beside us at the Defense Table
What if we are suing them for recovery at the same time?
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Any Loss Transferred to Insurance will Mean Lawsuit
Recovery / Subrogation
Any Supplier Loss
InsuranceCarrier
Transferred
SubrogationLawsuit
YourCompany
Supplier
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
100% of all Food Borne Illness Restaurant Outbreaks Result in Inspections
• Health Department Inspection
Critical ViolationCritical ViolationCritical Violation
• Public Information– How much are you at
fault?– What ammunition will be
in Health Department investigation?
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Media Nightmare – Disclosure and Managing conflict in the media eye.
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
We Know How Product Liability Law Works – Lock Attorneys in a Room
DecideHow do we
want to defend?
ContractsWork
Backwards
© Copyright All Rights Reserved SRM, Inc. © 2008
Back to Basics - Contracts
• How do we want to do business anticipating liability?
• Car companies went through the same cycles• What media agreements are integrated into
contracts?• Some suppliers are our only source• How do we both survive?• QA, Purchasing, Risk Management & Public
Relations – joint project
Pamela J. Ritz, ARM, SPHR, CRM, HACCPPresidentSpecialty Risk Management, Inc.®
May 16, 2008
THANK YOU!THANK YOU!