quantum optical lever sensing on a sin string

1
<P|Q|I> Pittsburgh Quantum Institute www.pqi.org <P|Q|I> Pittsburgh Quantum Institute www.pqi.org <P|Q|I> <P|Q|I> Pittsburgh Quantum Institute www.pqi.org <P|Q|I> Pittsburgh Quantum Institute www.pqi.org <P|Q|I> Characterization of the intrinsic laser noise using balanced detection. The intrinsic laser noise is found to be governed by the Poissonian statistics. Noise floor = 4.626 × 10 −9 V Measurement in quantum mechanics necessarily entails back action, where the measurement process perturbs the system being measured. The precision of a measurement is limited by this back action in a fashion governed by a Heisenberg uncertainty relation. In this project, we explore the quantum limits of optical lever angular displacement sensing and will attempt to harness correlations in the quantum noise of our system to evade the effects of quantum back action. Our optical lever detection scheme is similar to the standard AFM cantilever where light reflecting off the surface of a bending or tilting mechanical resonator is used to measure the angular derivation Δ . A back action torque, Δ , occurs when photons recoiling off of different locations of the mechanical resonator provide random angular momentum kicks. Introduction 1. Yutaro Enomoto et al., Physical Review A 94, 012115 (2016) 2. T. P. Purdy et al., Science 339, 801 (2013) 3. D. Mason, et al., Nature Physics 15, 745 (2019). 4. Ghadimi et al., Science 360, 764–768 (2018) References Reactive Ion Etching to define the strings, and wet KOH etching to release the SiN strings from the substrates. We made the lengths of the strings 1mm, 2mm or 5mm with different shape modulations in order to find the optimal design with highest quality factor in the subsequent experiments. Noise Characterization of laser To characterize the intrinsic laser noise, we performed the balanced detection to cancel its intensity noise of the laser. We found that there is an approximately linear relation between the laser noise and the optical power, indicating the intrinsic noise is governed by the shot noise obeying Poissonian statistics. We are working on a software based auto-balancing system to better cancel the laser intensity noise dynamically and its optical diagram is shown below. Acknowledgement We acknowledge the support from the Department of Physics and Astronomy at the University of Pittsburgh, the Charles E. Kaufman Foundation, JQI and NIST. Jing-Chen Zhang 1 , Shan Hao 1 , Robinjeet Singh 3,4 , Thomas Purdy 1,2 Quantum optical lever sensing on a SiN string 1 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pittsburgh. 2 Pittsburgh Quantum Institute. 3 Joint Quantum Institute, University of Maryland, College Park. 4 National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, Maryland Nanomechanical resonators use multiple design strategies to reduce mechanical dissipation: Dissipation Dilution High tensile stress increases mechanical resonance frequency by many orders of magnitude. Mechanical Band Structure Engineering Periodic modulation of string width produces a band gap. Localized defect modes in the gap are protected from clamping and radiation losses. Simulation Next steps We plan to further reduce the thermal and laser noise to approach a measurement at the standard quantum limit. By adding a lens to our measurement setup we will cause destructive interference between the shot noise induced angular deviation and the back action torque induced to angular deviation. We hope this measurement scheme will lower the noise below the standard quantum limit therefore realizing the quantum back action evasion. In order to access the quantum regime where quantum back action becomes important, we are working to reduce the noise in our experiment: Nano-fabrication of SiN string mechanical resonators with high quality factor, which minimizes the thermal noise Developing laser source with low intrinsic noise Implementation of actively balanced detection methods to reduce the effects of laser intensity noise Fabrication Device characterization We performed “ring-down” measurements to obtain the quality factor of our samples by measuring the time constant of the exponential decay of mechanical energy, after driving the sample with a specific frequency. Right figure shows our ring-down measurement result as an example. The driving frequency is 0.554 Mhz and the obtained quality factor is 1.03×10 6 . The best quality factor to date ~10 7 . The “ring-down” experiments we have performed so far indicates that our SiN string samples indeed have very low thermal noise. Yet more efforts should be made to lower the noise to the level where quantum back action becomes important. COMSOL simulation of a localized mode of the modulated SiN string Optical microscope image of SiN strings Optical diagram of the noise characterization using auto-balanced detection(work in progress) 1 : shot noise of the angular deviation : shot noise of the back action torque 0 : Thermal motion Band structure simulation of a modulated SiN string Schematics of the “ring-down” measurement Schematic plot of quantum optical lever experiment Optical diagram of the noise characterization using balanced detection 0.5mm SiN strings with ultra-high quality factor 2 mm Ring-down measurement of a SiN string Time(s) 0 2 4 6 8 10 -20 -40 -60 -80 -100 -120

Upload: others

Post on 28-Oct-2021

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Quantum optical lever sensing on a SiN string

<P|Q|I> Pittsburgh Quantum Institute www.pqi.org <P|Q|I> Pittsburgh Quantum Institute www.pqi.org <P|Q|I>

<P|Q|I> Pittsburgh Quantum Institute www.pqi.org <P|Q|I> Pittsburgh Quantum Institute www.pqi.org <P|Q|I>

Characterization of the intrinsic laser noise using balanced detection. The intrinsic laser noise is found to be governed by the Poissonian statistics.

Noise floor 𝑆𝑆𝑓𝑓 = 4.626 × 10−9 V

Measurement in quantum mechanics necessarily entails back action, where themeasurement process perturbs the system being measured. The precision of a measurementis limited by this back action in a fashion governed by a Heisenberg uncertainty relation.In this project, we explore the quantum limits of optical lever angular displacement sensingand will attempt to harness correlations in the quantum noise of our system to evade theeffects of quantum back action.

Our optical lever detection scheme is similar to the standard AFM cantilever where lightreflecting off the surface of a bending or tilting mechanical resonator is used to measure theangular derivation Δ𝜃𝜃. A back action torque, Δ𝑇𝑇, occurs when photons recoiling off ofdifferent locations of the mechanical resonator provide random angular momentum kicks.

Introduction

1. Yutaro Enomoto et al., Physical Review A 94, 012115 (2016)

2. T. P. Purdy et al., Science 339, 801 (2013)

3. D. Mason, et al., Nature Physics 15, 745 (2019).

4. Ghadimi et al., Science 360, 764–768 (2018)

References

Reactive Ion Etching todefine the strings, and wetKOH etching to releasethe SiN strings from thesubstrates.

We made the lengths ofthe strings 1mm, 2mm or5mm with different shapemodulations in order tofind the optimal designwith highest quality factorin the subsequentexperiments.

Noise Characterization of laser

To characterize the intrinsiclaser noise, we performed thebalanced detection to cancelits intensity noise of the laser.

We found that there is anapproximately linear relationbetween the laser noise andthe optical power, indicatingthe intrinsic noise is governedby the shot noise obeyingPoissonian statistics.

We are working on a softwarebased auto-balancing systemto better cancel the laserintensity noise dynamicallyand its optical diagram isshown below.

AcknowledgementWe acknowledge the support from the Department of Physics and Astronomy at the University of Pittsburgh, the Charles E. Kaufman Foundation, JQI and NIST.

Jing-Chen Zhang1, Shan Hao1, Robinjeet Singh3,4, Thomas Purdy1,2

Quantum optical lever sensing on a SiN string

1Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pittsburgh. 2Pittsburgh Quantum Institute. 3Joint Quantum Institute, University of Maryland, College Park. 4National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, Maryland

Nanomechanical resonators use multiple designstrategies to reduce mechanical dissipation: Dissipation Dilution High tensile stress

increases mechanical resonance frequency bymany orders of magnitude.

Mechanical Band Structure EngineeringPeriodic modulation of string width produces aband gap. Localized defect modes in the gap areprotected from clamping and radiation losses.

Simulation

Next steps

We plan to further reduce thethermal and laser noise toapproach a measurement at thestandard quantum limit.

By adding a lens to ourmeasurement setup we will causedestructive interference betweenthe shot noise induced angulardeviation and the back actiontorque induced to angulardeviation. We hope thismeasurement scheme will lowerthe noise below the standardquantum limit therefore realizingthe quantum back action evasion.

In order to access the quantum regime where quantum back action becomes important,we are working to reduce the noise in our experiment: Nano-fabrication of SiN string mechanical resonators with high quality factor, which

minimizes the thermal noise Developing laser source with low intrinsic noise Implementation of actively balanced detection methods to reduce the effects of laser

intensity noise

Fabrication

Device characterization

We performed “ring-down” measurements to obtain the quality factor of our samples by measuring the time constant of the exponential decay of mechanical energy, after driving the sample with a specific frequency.

Right figure shows our ring-down measurement result as an example. The driving frequency is 0.554 Mhz and the obtained quality factor is 1.03×106.

The best quality factor to date ~107. The “ring-down” experiments we have

performed so far indicates that our SiNstring samples indeed have very low thermal noise. Yet more efforts should be made to lower the noise to the level where quantum back action becomes important.

COMSOL simulation of a localized mode of the modulated SiN string

Optical microscope image of SiN strings

Optical diagram of the noise characterization using auto-balanced detection(work in progress)

𝑆𝑆𝜃𝜃𝑖𝑖𝑖𝑖𝑖𝑖 𝜔𝜔 ∝ ⁄1 𝑃𝑃 : shot noise of the angular deviation𝑆𝑆𝜃𝜃𝑏𝑏𝑏𝑏 𝜔𝜔 ∝ 𝑃𝑃 : shot noise of the back action torque𝑆𝑆𝜃𝜃𝑡𝑡𝑡 𝜔𝜔 ∝ 𝑃𝑃0: Thermal motion

Band structure simulation of a modulated SiN string

Schematics of the “ring-down” measurement

Schematic plot of quantum optical lever experiment

Optical diagram of the noise characterization using balanced detection

0.5mm

SiN strings with ultra-high quality factor

2 mm

Ring-down measurement of a SiN string

Time(s)0 2 4 6 8 10

-20

-40

-60

-80

-100

-120