r - home - fdr presidential library & museum · roooovolt olons wlth tho book...
TRANSCRIPT
hAiaa.IJt D. •-•a.,., JL r.n N..,.,..__,. M•- A._ NKW You; 22, N.,. You;
~/
S.ptoaber 1e, l i,7,
Dear Klaa ~paons
I .. oncloeill8 • letter ancl oo .. clocu.. nto g1Yon to Mr. RoooeYolt b7 Georce-Benrl llort1n, who ukecl h1a to unci thea to Mro, Roooovolt olons wlth tho book •co•tb&slnlon Peace• (which I aa ooncl1ll8 rou unclor oeparate coYer). I bol1oYe 1t lo all oelt oxplonatorr.
S~nc."ral7 rouro,
~---~ S•crotol')'.
l re
..
71.,_/IC .,., ... ; ... o.c~ lo
PI .. 0 0 • ·'!- eJ .• ·. • L.-1..;.~ i l.w.
:- ,.(_,. 0 11... 0 .tl.
cl--. l...-1-., ""- ~c .. £/ C..: c.- I..J "f' c-;L--_L;:; (1.. 1-. a.l- /t. /.-...· -·~ f ~c..4. . .
/(o< f-11.. ~~ l....a-.h ... ,. I
lp Ra4& .sc.:<i"'- ' ?.......;. ~-';' ,._
f.(. ~ 1 «-.b-. tu/-., ct....... .... -J .(.?.! ~·
H. ... "'·-- ... ~~.a. ....... ~-·-~ l'f-:-·). -.d ,_ II.~ ,.. ~--« "c- t-L. ·e • . ~ .. ' f-J' ;L:..J f 'it ..... ~
__ ..... ' _ ... .....}..
~ • ..J. _., ......... ,, ~ . o) ~ l
t .. , .. ~.. 1 ·" j
:.-- - ),. ..
I
lxtracta rroa latter• to r.otaaaor Faul .. ntouz.
Froa the R1f5ht Hoa. Hy.sh Dalt.op. Qbapotllgr or t.he 'MWW •
AU6Uat 9th , l9116
ll'our a on ' a book ..• 11 nry wall writ tan, varr well arpe&, and 'fWJ wall atre"6thal>&4 bft&pt quotation. Broa41)' , • • I ba'ta no 4oa~ that ,_ aon b&a .. tabl1aha4 b1a oaaa. llo other vr1tar, to .y ltncnrla._•~ bU -
·~~~~~;;~i_a~n4:_•~•;.•tteot1vely preaae4 baa. an attaok OD ~ leers:' • tha sraat 1ntluanoa or &.C.P, on tbOQiht &DI 'f1aw,-but not t1U 119''· I oontaaa, - that til»
a graat ey11 , you ..,. paraonal expar1anoa to abow bow, bJ a 41tt
ent and lonsar rout&, throUSh traota ot error tro4dan bJ tbe teet ot IUllta tudaa or &nsl1ah a nd Aaar1oaM, I caae 1n tha laat 1..,.. ~tore tha war W tha •••• v1awa a• thoaa ao ada1rabl7 aat torth 1n your aon a book. Tha t1n&l 4aaonatrat1on ot our d&lU810D rao ha d .. or1bea OD pp,l65-6) ... tha trluapb&l urcn or Oa raan ll'outh aorou &uropa 1n 19"<l - tha youth who. aecor41ns to Kern .. , anould b&va bean a ripple& and atarva4 bJ the Paaoa Traatlaa, An ia4aad, raa be pointe out on p,l85), dataata4 and 418ll'llPted Oaraaey aay have won tba aacond World war • aoonoa1call:y and b1olcs1oallJ 1n t he long run•,
. . • Oaraany - not Soviet Rualia, ao ooao ballaYa,- 11 otill the sraatt& aan&ea t o all that Franca and Br1 taln oar a tor and otand tor 1n the world. It wa 111.11 ll&ndll the thins, 1t will ba tha aanaca ot oaraan:r, beolta4 bJ Soviet Ruaoia , asalnot the Wa&t
Froa Prot . p l tor y . Sttyvt . Inati t.ut.t tor A4yaMts) Stu4y . Pr1Mtt.ep
AI you know, I oaw tho bool in •nuaar1pt. an4 I b&Ya now re- rM4 1\ with sr .. t ada1at1on. In OtJl• and ccsanor 1t a .... toM ouparb. It oontlrao a:y tael1D6 that Lord Kayn .. , in h1a aconealo th1nlt1DS and propoaalo, undar-elt1aata4 the pol1t1oal conaaquano .. or 1\18 rao .... Diat10Dio
Froa Fror. Barnadotta Sohal tt, State Departaent , waab1nston,~.
I read recently your aon ' • book lD reply to J , II, !Coyn .. and thoUSh\ 1\ a aaaterly pertor8enoe.
gfNg'JI l'ftCII - ,
JO!JRHAL Of JIORQI HI8__NU - ProCeteqr J.yrre
; l ;Mantoux aay not -.-w when he attr1butea great 1apor tanoe to U book) in date1"111ning ~ah and A .. rioan a ttitudea t""ard ~raan;r, r e Da:ratti and the Tr .. ty or Varaa1llea troa 1919 to tile advent ot H1tler. n remark4ble that ao i aportant a booll: a bould 1\!.ve bad to Vllit tor a quarw:r-•~f cen t ury before 1t waa aubJeo\ed to a tull- aoal.e aoapet&Dt eoono.lo any quarter •••• I am oha111ed to aay that I •bared to the full lteynM "a•..,,. ,~lu wlth the plight ot the Geraana 1r the7 did p&J0 and bia lapatienoe wi French 1no1atence that tlle1r own eoonoodo and pol1tioale plisht, in tile ev that Gel'lllBny ware let art lightl;r , bad e ven greater ola1u to ay~t.h;r • •• ,Man t oux waa a ble t o ahow that lteynaa 1pol1tioal viewa were unaoun4 . He l y ahowa a lso that there were oerioua err ore or bi a l and 1Doono1etenc1 1n fina ncial a r 1tb#et1c , which , I tear, aoet or ua took on !alta, , •• The r;u1lt-complex toward Geraany, and t~r4 tile Treaty or Ver aaiUH Keynaa helped to eetabl1ah in England and A .. r1oa1 t he groaal;r unfai r oari·OO or the pareonality, the character, and the 1ntelleot or WOOdrow t he moat widely remembered part or hie booll: on tile Peaoe1 bia axage;ara coun t ot the greed , the 1ntrenaigenoe and tile obaM a ion with a aeourU;r t he French; 'theae had long before cont ributed their weight to ... ing the ·•or ld-hegemony 8fr a resurgent and repara tiona-tree Nazi Cle,....nJ1• ••
' an !OJ Ifiqtt, I QIIICII •••• - Prgftteor •• "'ward
• • ••• Both ae n penetrating interpretation ot the tragic event& peat and ae a thought-provoking guide tor the arohlteote ot :=·:~:~~~: it should find a vary wide audienoe. It ahould 1nterett the le88 than lntelllgent publio i a te, .. n or artaira and a tatee .. n ca reful reade r will ran to deteot. , benea t h the uno..,.on br1ll1enoy a product Of the IIOit palnetaldng IOient1t1C CI'BStaMn&bip and or a DO.U'LLC eagacity for whloh many elder .. n .ay well envy ita youthfUl author,
AMERICAN ECQNOKIO RiVIiW - M1A. Htilper1A•
•••• • The pol1 t1oal and 11aral oone equenoM or llr lteyn .. are aleo t.raoed by &tienne Kantaux in lome of the !lOSt penetrating p&f381 or thi8 1nezorablJ al and pa1nata11:1ngly ta1r 4iaouuion ••• • linoe reoent bit tory aha .. \bat was Jreynea•, ••baa1a \bat waa wrong and not that ot tile peao-ll:erl of Mantoux'• boCik bringa t hat taotor out with oryetal olar1ty - there ia i n our preaent outlook. Let ue hopa that the llloolt under review will read, not onl y in un1Yere1ti .. but alao 1n govern.ental burea .. , _not aoholnra but a leo b:y otatea .. n. It oarriM • -•s• wbiob aho\U4 pr09e helpful ln the work of the conte~ary paao..all:ere,
e ther articl e• i n "Chicago Tri bune"(27,l0. 46) - "Obioago au.• (2._11,46) "Oour11r J ournal" (LouiaviUe, 24.11 . 46)~ "Loa .lngel.ea ,,._. (1},10,46) ' "Boaton Traveler " (2),10 .46) -••uon"(a .11.46) - Pll1la4e,lpU& IDqll1rel' Not.loeo ln " FORTUNE" (January 1947, p . a6 , "BoH-ot-f.ba-llontb Club -·(
ZXtr&ota troa Artlolea 1n the llr 1tleb PreN
on "'l'ho Clr tha81n1an Peaoe• b7 .Stlenne llantoux.
' 1'Hi SPJqteroa, June 14 1946 - HARm n tJIMtA<W.
I have been r...Uns thla week a brull1ent bMk by ltlenne llant.ou ••• 111& M1n t h .. u 11 that Xeyn .. 1 1 book on 3tna loonaaJ.o Oonaequanoaa or tbo ,..._. cu auoh to aro~&&o and fort ify the ~~nra&&oning su1lt• oonaoioul-l or tile Br1tll$ and Aaarioan peopb a. 'l'll&'t tho prec11ot.ione i n wb1oh 1teyne1 then 1••1p4, aat! whloh were 1o re&c11ly accepted aa ra~elation by op1n1on in th1a oouatr7 &D4i:£ the Dnited 8tataa, were c1oaonatrably i noorreo t . And that thla U.. we abould wllo to reoogni81 0 ao the 11118a1ana have already reotenhed, that 8ectW'1\J not dlll)end upon eoon0111o rorDIUlu , but 18 oond1tione4 by hard )lal1t1o&l an4 graphloal raota.
s lm pA X TIW . June 23 ~946 - o . L. Sghvartz
.• . The work 11 eo opportune that 1t auat be aet down tor iamediate pr .. or1be4~ preaor lbed reading •.• '!'he Xeyneaian ••••Y 1• aubJaotad to a ayat ... t1o axaa1na and checked aso1nlt the Treaty end ltl aubeequent oparetion, partiolllarly i n fleld of reparatlona. But before t hi a, thoro io a penetrating aeot1on on tbe conf'trenoe i toalr, wh1oh goee tar to reaove the gl1 tter and apart le t roa t.11e ~eynea1Bn vero1on . . . Wbat waa perhapa moat banetul waa tbe guying or Pree1f-Dt W1laon ..• America wao happy to replld1ate tho "blind and dear Don Quie..,. .. , ~ "bo mbootlad old P,.e ebyter1sn" and to diaown 5\lropo along with h1.11 •• 'thoro are aure lndloat1one tnat young Mttntoux could have greatly served in the eooooaio t1elc1, t hat he would have been a toreaoo t adv1oer or h1e oo110try at tb1a Ju.o ure and played an iaportant part 1n ebap1ng the eooaoa1o oonlequenoea or thill J)Noe . Hla looo 11 ·• traeedy, but he baa hrt b1a aark.
NJW'8 QHRONICl.l . Augu.at 20 19~ - A .J.Q'••1 AS'
It 11 & pity that Keyn .. io not alive to anewezht., 11noe it 1a by tar the ~ tora1dob1e oh&lhnge, on botll the poUtloal and eooaoa1o Ude , that h&e .,_. boon d1reote~ at the Kayne• tneo1a on tho Veraa~ll .. tre&tJ .
LIVEBPOQL QAlLX POSTa J upe 19 1946 - &.H •
.. . Ita nl1~1ty 1a not arr eow b7 tho taot that. L' II!.,.PtlT ...... , ... .., ... ..,.l1.,e to lf enawer lt. It ooul4 no' be a~ • ••.
I NYJST!f!l! RIVIR (London) - July 6 1946.
'!'here are numer ous 1eeeone to be learnt rroe th1a book whlob ooulc1 be or ~1 to uo l n tho tr• ml ng ot the traolng ot Peace T'reat1 .. now.
l!ULX T"l!'ll!API! - J uly 12 19 116.
'!'he au t hor ' • PW'P"" 11 no • ere aoe~o ezero1 .. 1n debo'*'nsl 1t u to varq agelnat tho ropetltlon• or tho aame errore 1n the .-t ~rt:;•· The book exh1b11 q .. uu .. or a1nd ooap&Nble • · n n e,.., .. · as o 111.
B. B. C, Al!!tr1tn 8an1gt, August 4 1946 - R.W1ener.
'1'1\tl't 11 DO do\lb\ ""''- :r:::=~~·~ bP - or 1ta - t br11UUit II alii& ,__ PII'MPI - '--J•• •••••••• •• Ul
I
Art1olo paru d&Da •t. Moa4e0
(Journal quot141on, l'arU, 14 JU1llet 19"6)
(Apr•• uno arwlJao 4la l1Yro 4o J ,M, ll:oJ-, "!be &o-o Oonaeq...or tho Peace•, at 4o - ,,.,l._.110aur 1 'op1111oa, 1 1au\ew' oonUnOMI)
Le prooti~o doe cPP'fauJfi'" lppfJ:tP~ no t1on4ra1t-11 paa au talt qu• oe livre n ava1t Ja .. 1e d1aou ~D4 &van~ aujour4 1hu1? AYeo l'avantaga du raoul dono lo toapa , un Jouno Franoa1a Tiont 4 1 antrepran4ra cotta 41aoueo1on dono un travai l 1nt1tul4 : "Tho C&rtb&g1n1on Paaoa, orr tho Economic Conoaquenooa ot Mr leynoo (Ozford Univoroit7 Pr .. a), Dlaparu lui ouaai, hdlao ! au teMilo 4 1uno guorro l loquollo 1l &Ye1t pr1a uno part gloriouoo, et fila de Paul ~ntouz, l 1n1ator1on blon oonnu, &t1anno xantOUJC a n1a a u service de oa r.!tutaUon 1 .. quaUUa qUi avo1ftt. aaaur6 le auoo~o de oon pred4coaoeur: la connaloaonco do 1 1h1ato1ro at 4o l'6oon~ pol1 t1que , l ' appol aux aantiaonta g4n4roux, uno vaate oulturo 11tt6ra1ra, untatyla angloia race, v1goureux at br1llant , uno 1ron1o parouuha paroa qu ollo invite la sympathio, ot convainoanto poroo qu 0ollo 44r1vo doo tal& at de l e logique, uno haute aptitu&o A la deduot1on at l 1 1fnonoe 4oo 1-d6oo generaloa. Qua l 1 on coaporo loa deux 11vroo: dopu1o 1 1 ontr6o on .. -t1~ro Juoqu'A l a dernl .ro phraoo, &.Mantoux a calque oon oxpoo4 eur colu1 do son afne. "Il y a vlngt-clnq ana, ccnolut-il, M. [oynoo d44ia1t aon uvro ~ la g6nerat1on l vonlr. La repona o qu'on a luo viont do ootto gen'ratlon , " una generation appeleo A oublr lao cone4quonooo do tautoa dobt ella n'<ltalt pao rooponoablo, ot 111lr1e par uno eprouvo aaW.. Qui o'honnoralt que l o r~ponao eolt donn6o our un ton •olont1ora aordlnt' La bonn o ro1 6o l 1adv•rta1re eat reconnua (11 eat expreaalaent 4~ren4u aontre 1 1aoouaat1an de gormanophll1o). Kala il eot eulvl pao l pae ot aux JOW< d 1un lootour comme ao1, ignorant do l'~conomlo pollt1que, no oort pea du d4bat laonavsntoCel lmpraeolon oontirato par le Jugeoent quo le protoaaour onslaia & Ensor, opeoislleto de 1 1h1ato1re pol1t1quo, expr1ae dona aon ovont-propOI. L' .!di fioo de J .M. Keynes apparalt cooproc1a par dee 1noxeot1tudoa~ 4ea om1B l 1one , des vices de raiaonnement, des 1nooh4renoe• , perto11 .... une er reur de doouaentation,sur del pointe de pre•1~r• 1apor~coe: on n. Yo1t. gu~ro comment 6chapper A pare1llo oonclua1on qu&Ad on au1t aotto d1oauae1o aerr~•• o~ lee textea aont oppo•'- aux att1raat1ona, lee ohiftrel auz ohif free, at o~ lee pointe que pourralt aaequor 1°a4voroa1ro aont toujouro 616 gaament relov'• · Dlra-t-cn quai alae el loa 0 prophtt1aa• du .. g1o1on ont ete de•entloo par l eo talta, 1 oat a1af do Jugor apr•• l 'ev~ ... nt? Il n 1 on roeteralt paa moine que coo proph4t1oa <!talent tauaaoa. Dt plua, l~ guaentet1cn d 'E. lantouz repooo sur doo doouaento at aur doa atat1at1quee d 0or1glno oouvent allemande, ot acc .. a1bloa on e&Jouro partie aux h ..... do 1919 . Il 6talt grand tftpl do d4aontror, proo~a-verbaux on •1n, qiM Cleaencaau n ' et< 1>48 un Bb1look d'raUonnabla n1 Wllaon un pontin 44bU.a at chlaeriquo, at quo loa auteura du Traltf , n1 dana lao buta, n1 dana loa aoyona, n'avolont en vuo la rUino 4oonoa1qvo ot pol1t1quo du pauplo allaaan4. L •.,.. ture 4conoa1quo du Tral \f parart a voir 4tl! aoUdo ot •-4ol l oa t a1bl .. • •• on aurolont 4t4 plutlt pol1t1qu .. : ll-4oeaua aon 4araior or1t1quo roJo1ndro1t Jac~uoa 8a1nv1llo.
Il eat ~ooe1blo d oxpooer dana le d~tall le tb••• do notre Jaune coapatrloto. L oooontiol pout a 'on ru ... er on qiiAilq .... aoto I 1 1a6ouU• I
I
4U o1ou .. o '•ono.iqu• ot t1.nane1~ .. de V-1U.. ne 44pa .. a1._. pal
1., rorcoo 4o 1 'Ul+pe ot. 1111 le1a.ait. le oapa11W de Y1YN ~ 1111 n1-rort. h""*1nl 4u po1Jit. 4e .,,.. t.eobnlq• (por •MP'• .., " qa1 ........ lei t rllnotort.o), . .. oleuM• 4ta1ent a .. utablee l ou talro .. OIIa.J.q-nt. W.C auz Ya1nqueur•.
L'1.nUrit. 4u livre n' .. t pao •lll&lo•nt r•t.roe,..ur.•n r - •••••• bl o b. toue, 41\ lo prot•o...,. IPIIor, une -••o 4e fa1t.e, 4o obitfi"H, 4o If o ono1d~rat1ono qu.1 • o rapportont d1root.eoent aua pre~ .. 4o le pa1x ~ -. n1r . Lo pl4p&rt • •. n4ont Ja.,1o ''' rfun1o auaol o ..... faont.•
O'oat on ponunt ~ oott o f!1X quo l'outeur o r441&4 1011 4ern1er oh&pa. tr·o . Il .. t oxoopt l a toll 4 1llua1- ot. 4e 4•eupolr our 1o o-.p\.9 4e ••• ooababloo, ot paraft • •o1r une • -clonae pW. -oto 491 r4al1W. 1» aa1n .. quo J .IC.l:OJnel reprocb&nt. •Oll"1rr4allt.4•t-1 ... o \ l'S..~t. 4e 1919 . Un n o t a r o ton\11-ont oot 411 l •on t.ranll. Il 1 aura ou •1• .... not.ro p&JI, qll1 no oaural t trop 44ploror le 411par1t.1.., 4'un •pr1\ 4e •• t o troopo.
Jaoquoo Vallotto.
_j
from .Tames T.
Dea r J rofeeeor Mantoux,
EXtract f r om a let~r IH~tJ, Director, O&rnegie
ernational Peaoe. !"l
J
indow .. nt tor
. .. When the book arri ·u4, I aet. aaicle ot.her.;~~~ read lt wlth great inter est. t! nd a growing IMD8e or bow eplen41cl an 1 t. ia ••• I reel th& t i n it &t.1enne hu unooneoiouely rai•e4 • •n~t. that ·will mean a uoh for under at.and11'16 peo~ tor 101115 1•r• t.o o ...
The ae t tlement at the end of the tl.rlt VOrlcl •r ha8 a\lOh t.o et'fer ot precept and example now, both ln the • •o1clanoe or bl~re an4 1n IUE5l)8ta' of poeitive policy . Thie book show• now aa41J not. onl3 pu~o op1n1on fir at-rank econ01111eta •Y be llliabad wbeD t he probl• l• 10 .a1\ aacl OOIIIP;U~ ae t hat whloh followa/,:IQI-~)1 on worlcl revolut.1on• l1ke t.hoee through wru•on and I have been l1v1ng •••• ••
- ...
LIVERPOOL DAILY POST (June 19 , 1946.)
The Book Shelt
WAnNI NG TO PROPHITS• K. Etienne Mantoux co.~leted "The Carthaginian Peace
-or The Economic Consequences ot Kr Ieynea (Oxford Univer sity Preaa,laa. 64) a tew months before he waa killed in the last atage ct the war. It S. a book t ha t waa well worth writing, and ita validity ia not attected by ~ the fact that Lord Keynes ia not alive to anawerit. It could not be a na~ered. Lord Keynea'a aervioea to economic theory were i .. eaaurable, but the harm cauaed by hi• Juvenile •1cona.ic Conaequencea ot the Peace Trea ty•oould be ruefully ... aured sa the inter-war period drew to ita ... close. M.Mantoux cr1ticallJ exa mines that lamentable effort at propheOJ, indicate• ita entirely a1ataken eat1aatea ot Ge~ny•a powers of r ecover, under · t he Versaill es Treat y" traces the unha ppy ettect ot the book in buildi ng up a "guilt - complex among the victor-nation&, and s hows how t he Keynesian ca ricature of Wils on -elpe4 to turn --. Aaerioan public opin1an against Europe. The "Soono.ic cenaequeno .. •,ao taaoua in ita own daJ, il thus f i na lly- and most instruc t ively- •debunked•. Jlow that we are 1111k1ng another peace, M. Ms ntoux's book shoul d be a warning to ,prophets- and a warning to t he public to be on its gua rd sgainat thea.
K.H.
I SAID THE PROPHET-Thf Corthotrlnfa.rt /'~ae~---01 Ch.c l"conomfc C01UtQ1141ftU O/ llr.
Ktli!Ut. B'¥ tttniW: ltlon.toeu. (Orford. 121. &f.)
Tl..a O l.>lrvar lh THOMAS JON&S
.P•ul
TilE
LITERARY ~o"','"'r• -_ ... _... , .....
..... f •• ,_.. •tu .... . ..... ~ '"
I I SH ER~lAN NATU RALIST
A~"'-~
""'····· ... , ... ~thl ,_,..,~- .. 1<1 ............. . ,_ __ ...... _ .... ~ .. ..,.,.,. ..... --................... _ ... ...._ .... _, ... ... ·---- ....
COLLINS
SUPPLEMENT -·=: Plii.ICt,. Jp
The House or H u t c Ia i n so 11
fJ UI'OIL,SO'f • c.. ............. ....
t-.......... ~
'" PE<;CY
WINDSOR ond
THE AMERICAN SOLDIER f',..A Tobit)
........ ,.., .. ..... "¥ ·""'_,."'_, --···"~ ;:.::~:...~-=7. ... , ..... "ft.'l!..m'..#',;;.... ..... u...,.,.,..._,.. --- ... _. .. ........ ... -., ... .. , ...... ,_., .... *
~~ -R-LifE COMES
TO SEA THORPE
Xril & ll ... .... -ANNA
COLLETT &ukl• I.Mu ......... --, .... ~ .... ..._ ...... ..,.. .. .._ .. _ ............ .. -......... .... ........ .~-....... -........ _ .... . .....,_
..... - .... ... -. - -- ·--····--~-.... - ·-"""" .. " ......... ~ "' --.. ,...., """ .. - .. --,-:.,,._,... ,_~ .,_ ... '""""
~-
HAil; ~ . DEPARTMENT
CAT . !("'7 '-'
•Oooo~ool~-;=:.::
............ "'-~· _...,_.., ......... . _... ...,,. ,~,...,
"11 ··--··· _ ., __ .. , .. _ .......... .
n. Fa. Uti- f/ BEDEUA •• v'!"~·
-~ .... .._,._, ~=-":J ·~~
. • - ..... r~ ... ::l ......... ,.,,,..._ ... _ ~
THE LllTLE TRAIN
nw.t.b O.'zj4 .. -....... •4-..- ...... ................. , .. ,_ -.:~-~#.!;
Ep.CSp.~ti,.._
••• """·"'" ..,. ,._., ,....,, ........ ~ I.TVliDAY IUL Y ......
• -• :
.
.-
... 11!1 -.. _ ,~ O'Tli'('IIJ/M
:::='i:"o-::--:.......,..·-= ........ .., ... .:..= n-~-:;; _-.::;:: ___ --;r:;;;-- . -·- ~· =---=-:.:'::' _iloo_.._..., .... ::.·o·:....... "'S =-~~~ -·
ane U"k'"'" TNt .,1}((1 Olf nu: , ... --~-·------............ --~·-~:"C
~~~ - ~~
*** ·trc_.. _. _. ... . .. .. _,.·-n..-- . .._.,c..., oa UArU .t/IO
"''"'"" L
JIAC MI4.1..AI'f o no.o,,. ,.._ . &Ufti.II.DT
oOtiA&.O Cl.ltlc. ....,.. ........ ~ C":O: =-..=:, : ... ----.,...,... - ...... . ........ ___ _,
__, .... , -~· ..... ·-· ~, ... .=_ ::...._-c.~
~-- ··--,..,... w. .. .,.. •
i~-==·~-~ ~~-&.
~ ... - ··--lrUIIUft
'
. I -;
' THI SP&CTATO &, JU Jrf ll J 4 , ., . ,
MARGINAL COMMENT
I HAYS olem a.tod mytdf whf dM •irub p;~Wk, wbo .W.. die war .Mwcd tbm'l..:JYU ldl~ 10 "'"' lana d JW ..
polptldJ, lboulcl bcfwt.'dll 1919 fOd 19)1 t' ... ¥1 abtottlfd without I tnOIMI)I'I rdl«don th: German nnlon ollll• Tr•rr « Venaliia. n~n locAl)' there • tc ti\Mf people "' ttll.t CINOUl wbo remain OMYII'II«d ll\11 the 1k:lo:c 84d«r!etM. ol1919 ... _,OtiC d lb.IDOIIipt«am Mid INquiiiOUl "" tnmcd; )'ft tiMw ,...,... ..,..,.... .. w it ddlti&JJ 110 N:atc • kt&Kr l.bdt ~ "~• IMMel upaa. 1M bet ._, dM Trcary ._ .o bud or toO Mil\. .._ a diU tlf1IIIP 1t wftiOD ., be-~} Jc _, "" • liM _......, s· .... ,.,an ..... btaJ ., decud ., . .... P'UmM ndiliae .. dlorJ ..... wDouc twirlc .-ate ot ... . ........ .......,. .. Tilt lila .._ *" ~ a • new CIDIII,_,. • ..._ ,_.... *- Ulf 'J'II- .t ctlllcal tbouPs ra.kn .._ • • '*-"' ~ ~....ncsc.. 1"'aoo. ...... k ....... for lorftp ,..._ ~ .. JDducr the: Britit.h peapk ........... ~ ...., dtory ...... ~ to tba it ;. _, 10 pcnudt theft .. l•tl - .., t...c~ wrc'lQI. u ODe .._. • w. Ole commoa MOM ol t1w &t:Ji"'- OIX'I bat mahod Is 10 ~J YpciO cbdt _,.,__... MDiK d &\lAic. No f.oclhbmeo et.o be lltdt.)Oid 10 btJKft thlt IL1t OWD Oomnnwm hne aa.ed with ~ h\ltMftity MIS fofftlaha l but wbt:ll f'OII Idl an Enpishmt.n th&s bU ctto.m Nlcn bton "awddlc'""a • Of "l~Nl~dtttd,.'" bJt *Xq)W'IICIC ftl tbU IOCUIIIdoo II ~e, \&IINII«dnc and piA!U'Lttable.. This t. '* lht ooly reuoo wbJ -ICCrptifd wid! tuda rad.ioa1 tbc ~ \tnioo ol YcnaiDn.. 'Tllc lrl'fti.th ~ bd.icnd dM GctDant becnM .., ~ • bdin'c .a.-: lad "" «<iit ctwy ..._ • br:~c ~} OeufJ beauM ..t. - lhr kNt WIIC!Xd'CII'abk bt fll w.t If. u .-.: pcopk ...,.'"'-me (k,... -· da:fnliMII • • • ..... dlotir........... i:apoK W!OQP - IMkn. ... lilorriWc c6rD ... ~ ..... be~; - ... 1'0011., tt. ~., .. dM tnicS;a cl a c:c:ru!:D Tn.:J, thea Me W .-b' "cual dloK ~ ill order to ~ aaiq, rillll_. .ad ,_.. Httt' .-u me liat o1 COIIlfortlllc ~. lk h o1 a- ,......~
I en uoe mwx~& lMK •bo CIOtlttnd that lbt TTnt, ot VU'Uillet and lu let~ ~ ~led • muttrpkc"c ol pa.:ifia~ don, "Jlle MTUal ttftlkt oondudll'd ln 191P WUII' tulfic:icot.IJ brit~t.o._, to pcrpmutc rumtmmt whbout britlt lotdbk coouah to rmdet cbt.t r~ iotlfccdft. The hb«al pdoclpkt wtskh &bq ~ cbq wwe cJeao and .u.-wu. obtcwecl -t n"tiatcd .,. dM b~ formiiJM dorNcd .. OOIDCftl\IM fnqlkDt ~ .. __ .......... ..- ........ d .............. dll; ,.-M ill nalll' lot Ill peci6orioo lk ~ ot 19t9 ..ac ..,..... •lc:acn tbc: ~ ~ 'lrild ~ ....... tin 1R '*-0 " a:ecilc ~ lk ... ,...._ fll-. Ye~ dill' ,.., ~edf ., the PaD Pan s.cn-.. ..., ...... - Dn'd umed-..; W 1bc Trada a.c. ......... Ia «cr~ ,.,....,, dMo dl!t ....W -w ana liiPe '-" ~ • 11M~ ttl 1 toCIODIId au- .,., : w dw ...,. Oo." retililoif ... .., ..,. _,...,. """"ot"" or-." v--·.., ~ el the l.aflx cl N~ ...,,.. itt .,... ~ anidel. dilc:e 1k wbok T"*J covJd...,.. .._ ....- • ~ CICIDitltlonl bJ ~ meua. Yn. ltnl!l n Iii ........ dill' P..,. .smse.em d 1919 Kmtt prdttabk. botb lo priacfph Mid pncricll'o to I Df Wflkrnll'tlt wfiJcb Wt Itt IJkdf 10 acbl«"¥1 tJ!II• tlmf. . . .
M. 0 r •tid Mt, LJord Oecw,e • • IMl dort to ldll* U.. Mcmscn """""Met arl~1 ao- Ufft kaowt • rNidt M 1M dod ~ l.bc IMtf WIIIOrtY cl dlolc rutbWtftt lOll an.dot.l1 dl7 .. Hh IOD IWcMC wu • Pl.fd. •indout, ~ Mel hmk J'O'*I\I G'IUl. Hit f"''tfJ Sdlllfl ~ U1CrJ1, .tva:w.n, lftt 1 bl.e WIN .. lfttll t)'tt .,..,Ute~ wl&h W•Dileacc 1M CftlrrpriM ; bh o:prcMkln WH OM oi•Wn atonnty,fJI~ f~.t~ f•dl. Ht fiCIIped tr~:~m Prwc ahu dH ...,.. .• '*" aad it -.. " ~ iD s .... JttMT • .- 1M pt~ 0. •cctW (~ .W. booL He \~Me riCII!VMd 10 lwopc. ,__ die Fru FraQ; f.erc:C't Md W * ~ • pmoMII't tllfthrllr& • a:n:ack:r d ... a.m.... ~ .......... ~....._ ........... fl .. o-.1 D"'rt;tJ. "' .... ~ ia 8nwit • ,_ .,.. ...,. ~ .. ~ -. ......_ •tc --.· 1w .nu.., ·to tk ~ IC8l""' doa tM MI. X..,......,_ W.. boot rwc.:J~'It )'Clift .... ~ J. •....., wbidl C01Mt t... .. .-.-, .. Wtdl ~ ...._ ~- ... ~·r WOUld Maytwd KC'1tlft brtt .... dtit bril1lul ~I How ..,...WC W'OQW hiYC -- dll COO.. bowdoo of tJlot ""CrM wkh die apprmdcc ~ Nwtcn Lbt IIIP(iow, 1t*1t. rwt~INlblt cr~ ol Ml,...,-d Kcrott lftlll tlrle I!Mhl .. , nri1td tf" d 8dtnAc Mt.n~ousl luc CKb « tbeallt ct.cl.
The n.lll .a.r.. ol EtMaoe MaotOW: · Q. cbJt Kcyott' book oa Tlol ~ C..W4W1'1"• ol lAw , .,.. dW much • .,..... aod omty w wv--... ~ c1 tiM: ..W. uti
jAo~~ ~ nac tM prllllllcdoc. aa .w.:. ~e..,... ._ ........ aN .wet. .. .,. It .-tay ~ .. tt"f'ddO..., ... • ~ CIDWIUf _.a. dM J'anal Sucn.,""" ~ol7 ..,.. •
AM ... .U ~ '" tbociW bt -- " ...,...... • diM: ....... ~lllrcfldJ ~ ... aariydoa.- ...... .... ......:nk ............. ,...,bJ_,,.... .. ... .,.._. floCl" He ,-. ogc "* ia dM • ran ~ ''" KiliJ« 11PMC ..,C. .,..,.._, • ... whidt WM W'l'h ..; • W timn ar-ct tii.M due oftdl 1teynd .... ~ .. be: .,.... Gcnot.Q(I ..,.d'7 • p117 1o ~ Kcyoa bid pttdla:td dw dM CIGIIMf!ql.ttOCC'J ol tht pcKC -at be .. . ........ ....,, ~ ot tbc Malldatd& « life and CICICQfon" 1 t ta )'fV1 .t1cr VtNillo 8woprlt1 t~ r:l U'ri.Da Mel IW'tU bcf.o hilbtt, Kqna Mel Pfcdkttd tl»t the iroo output W'OI.ald (aU 1 to '"'- h inaaMd by tO pet ~.... K.yDa bad f(Cdiac:d &hi~ dw Otn'IV.A ICed OUQM would didnitall io feq, ic iaaeued bJ )I fi'Ct Clm'Kc w ,...un,d .. ~ co.) output -ouW ~Atop 1 k IKr•IM!CI lly 1110tC diM .)0 ,., «e1: KC11k* ~ ._. a.-(• ....a ......, wwJd • ;.a ..., fll wlla dMy wen bdort• l ~ __., ......... GcnnM ............ ~ tOM "' t,U • 1110 ..... I(--... G<ftooo-- .. -.... ; • t.a. .... ,.,.. _, u IBiilliwdt .. ,.,.,... Gc:ntuay ,.,....,. bcftoc• )j ..t Jl ............. ....... Jt.,.... pctdicted a. ea:_, ...ad ........ __.. Prlllft ; .. ,......._., ...,. .a. .......... It - be ......... "~t ._. II .,..:W ,.,..... o be Clfteo CMUCP~ftrt N 1M ft ...._ ...tu, tiJt .... t.u:lt It Chill be 4oft DOC CMik k "*'-dJ dew dille dM ,..,..,...... plu wlaL.il Kcyan ~ nt M'm', --. ru~.aJr .. thlt ~ pur iato ~
1ki111 • I(IOd Pttft(Mwl. Be:'- Mulcous bdlcw. lft 1b1 toe~ ol r..._, 1. witt I,_. ,_ tuda «kkusloa.. Hil boc* .......,.10 r-'ad \It 1b1!t Hftlc:t •• aoi tt•llld br die T~Wr1 o1 Vcn.Wca, "-t by die J*lk CI~Md 1ft a-, br dJ,t dtad 011 I "'"*' ......... h .... nmiodJ to» that. f"I'CO • the ~"' lftf WldcrncSINI..: .. ~.fl~··-rdw~-·,.. mluwilMI the ........., wWI:tl ~ ....,.... W ..,....._. ICaoff'dM _,.. &1M ......._ .. 1114 .... ol -
THI SPICTATO&,
dw Jtouw fll. I ............. -. 0rat 8rioia ... ,.. ,., .. ~ ol ........ ., c.-c.. " ...... ,_ ~ • ..,., om:. ww ~ ol ......, Mq )len:
INm ,,....ted irMJ Frmdl: .ad ,c:HraM, I~ ... ........,.. . ... Sp;n..th_ &lid pn'lu,pt • link .,..nu.,ly, ......... and told atl o .. , ctlc worid: die pcnmt tiOIU~N wW .. ,, a:naiftl7 prortnu •• h.r. Sir Gilbcn c;.mpbl it llw W.tt4 ti 1 1o1:11 11M ol O«b ol tilt IIOU"f, He WOUio:l bJ 1h.t l t"'"'l Mrtlcll:t hot Mt tmdcnd
hJ'+'e hdd in •nr a.c &n boaowcd pi-c• Jn '"' 81 thb l*ticll.lat wr ... ~ hf bu rc,atucd a hlt h daim oo 1M IJitil\ldt noc only ol poUdc:i• .n• but ol ~ wrioln 1tuckm ol Pllbllc tlllr\o
THE BALEFUL BEETLE a,. JOIL"" "ILTO.H
THAT • cnut becdt ...., br tala ._ N1i11NtJ \, 1k polb;. ... dkfuhu ~....,. allc1 -*r ~ • a pbcir fll
..._nope:-. tcaftlo • ~ 1100 eutrlll-a, faorcbl C"Wa. far u h..r. h.lmonv. nit pt«<M ~ liM ftC'UiltJ '*-~ • .... ,~ and iu iNuN aPPQ1 .. tlt.t .... ol dw: ridialloln tiiCMilld tw rnUced., fot tllc •.nntcd INca bat bcm tollft.tmcd by OPtttJ Gf tiX Mmiwy of~ .. tn ~btcd 1~ d the Color• 8«tk.. A crm ol if111Kft (rom tloll.uld .,. the ¥tl'lklt c:hotfn by lbc WfpJ immlarana. Wl»1 nn 1\qpc:tl oou an luppct~ t..,Un, t.nd 11 Is very llltdy t:h.IC Ot.bm ot !.be tpeclu mlf !Oiktw, 01 wont niU h1vc preceded. cht tlll< dtt(O\'utd culprit.
Pot lllmo.c • cmtury 1M Coklndo 8ttdt b&.t b«n ftlttd whttt'YCI' lht potJolO ll.l) bed:! nlb:i.,..ttd. hi home $ U.Ie of (:olondo lsu C.llntd YNCiftWI.I~t notOrlct)' hom iu. 'fCI'1 AIIIM. for it •u &hac ia lhc UJI)' lliO't IJm it dncmckd f,_ w'Jd obtcuril;r !n chc loodllilll ol •M ltoc:t.kt. • dc'¥OUI tht pcuo J*(lln fl dw Ani wu.kn. It ..,. -~ twallf JU" .. .,.... ... ..7' riPe: IC'ftiM die' Uo.ltc4 SCutt • dw ~ ~ .....-.. .-b ........_dna """""''" precl.c•ud die-~ cl* ,... at • ~ ol--..c: .. potl~Wk'c. ~. ~a--tutn WU1: ~ ftldl. ~ t:Jl'Cfl'llwt, cW mllbk C'IIIIIMueo 1110 --._
Etubidkd from Qac:b.."C 10 New VA lht knk ..., dally all ,. ,_ the Adt.ndc ~ • ~ ...... tbt lf'OWm; ol t!u10pc oanuaDr rcprdcd wiUI nv-. *ft>fcbtN.ioa. "lllclf't wu ,Jrftldy o~ ai!Ou;Jb ol Nlrlilar impocu doN from the New Wodd.. A1 ~c nry momr.~1 the ~tJox"" ~ to bnc dw:royed
"'" lmmorul • ina ol Pranu and wu t pttMII'II K rc•.s Europe.. Oddl·y tnou&.h, lllb 1pbf1-llltc: ernuwc, wb.kh ••• Mkl to hue COM PrtMt clout* the 1moun1 of tbt tockmflity Plkl 10 PruwU io 1t"71, wn abo tuppo)Kd to N ve ori,iMtcd ill c:.ndo, Wlw:rt h puut. ti.Wd wiW YIMt.. Suc:h an ·~ c.atiOOC .,_.,. INCic tbc b«tJc I'I'Oftl lbt WliV Star.t ~ any kt-1 •btmiftt. The Alnt.rioA Downy ,\ot.IWtw ol the rinot cl daiRy J'CU' cwtlu wu ..,. kqocun "*"" So Co ua n•• ,.... to "'- aad dac Coklndo lkdk ........ IlK di~ ol ,....... ., ..... ~~~ ......... DIM' ~00. m tl'ta C'C'en• , oehc ~ I.~!~~Mttt Mid hsa
An ••tn AJlhcu,. It cW eoc WC~Cc(d' ia u.-.. tiM AdMidt a. fcwu -a ''''· rtw Colondo B«tk p~ • P'IWit---., '-Elllbed _... II Jp1 llit¥n -- Tbr kantcd liullorlaa fll tt I C, Or. lwr, lu.1 rccord.ed • ~ wich lhc ' cklldc: &"''IUf .t fb PMOd ~ .,., hu.rd in tb: ~~ ps.n..-.:.rn.imft ot 1U7 Tbc Ormon Kiot. .. hnMd hi •P'Pf'09f;.tc <OM\Imt ol bl.ck mel ytllow ttriP"'t una:
.. Til.c on ol ywrllu lc poucon, to,• I And Ill )'OUt 1tny ·~t. lutt ~.lcll )'01.11 lully aullllowtn 1 Aod all row ructu.M bud• I You•d btcut hldc ,ow lite~ Nld cbHW. ANI ~~ ,.,:.'rt toe. for \be Coiondo !lftdc't C1011W
T • coll:u du joey "" I • Aa4 ..... - ....... •lhe 03dl of W'ffl'tl ,....., \"UM"' of ........ fill ...... WICb dlonr:1 u. M.
'ne I*U"IIt cl tk.~ dnpcnu ....,.._ __. a.qu ... Ut _,
JUI<I 1 4 , I t46 6o)
............ ct ............... .... ~...,... ~ '*-' • ,_., r-. ., .. c-, ,... ........... o...u, cWdral - _.,. ........ l .... Ia-......... ~-., tllbJea .......... "' ... ..,... A.pirukunll Sode.orJ .. ..rly u It); ; ... -. cJtco .. ~ '-It AM beN -...d • t ...._ c1 pM:Udty, t.U, itUediW t)' Itt dauunl"" ,...,.., Oltibenlt L.. I ICCICIO iuo tt.tl COIIMrJ .,. &A ldn ol lloitb obotiol.u tppa.l 10 LM Nul mcDtiltlJ, 11141 Ill 1hcof1 tO ~. du.1 t11 Mo.ukd poMct-ca.mpalao condnlk'd ~~ lllt war. ToUJ, wllb iftl.et4aOon tericM.I.t 11:1 dcTucaiACI ~ owltrol 40 ~Wtltn ot Clllun~twd c:.uwcl by W ot I'Mit"""'l' ll*tflall1 puWidiJ h w.Nr ~ Tk CtJ~CWt o1 • ma u.. ~ -.. the " ""'.........,_ ktUICa :. • nwud, ""' " lone ... ,_, lor dM ~t w1Wdl •we. "'""" btCII ~tid.. ft Cltf\tJIIIy would • aw.. ~ wi&bou.J a1 1M -': 6aec .. --.cc eM ~ Mart.ct~ '" _,. p!IOfllt. tad ........ ...... ~ .. ~ tftMIQ-. • ....-.. ... ....... -.if ............. . n.t 11M~ ........... .., JI.U5IUUd ~ .... MWtuJ
ol ~-*hi" rtllllr:4 CI"U' UK Jdtt .. • ,_,. ..,.. of ...-.. ..... C...lf#N • 1t.ida wue ~ -. ~ 8«tlc:t wW 110C !w'ft ~ the o*Ld; ,._ ........ tt ~ lb.4hu 'lril tbq .._,.. rcjokcd, knowinc tM t ._!WI .,.,., .,.. «< &1M looll«<t, thai • Krioaa ial~ COI.ll4 awdty OCCIIJ
W'llhcul bt~l Jiofltlf4. for, l.bc pnl GnCC' utehtilihcd 1e I ~· lf'O'W(nJ ., .. , lu n te of multlplk:adoo I• cnonnout. WiiJilG dahtttn tnOCith.i of lbt Pl'*bk diiCt' of ft.rN imporu1lon ~It Bontdu.c th~ •h~Soo Gftf a wide ..,,. of Sot.Jtb-W'tKt-1'11 Franc• wu Olo't of oor.uo&, wtdl OJ:IUU ~ camplecc mdiudoe tt impoMibk. Dnpb MtiAI:Uil ~ mtt.M.Ittl, tht ketJc tw4
fCICIItd Oc:M., "' lf24. aod - .w.-.Dy redVC*I .. ,wet oiiM ~ ,... aop ntt .aacc. 0. ClftC oc::a.icle ....... • foodtoW ................ Ddt ~ ~ ....-..rn wut .... ..... ... .. ......_ _ _ ,.,.., .... . .
nwk. ... ieMQ ... ........ . Stamo.y Orrda .. ..... .. c::oa.n.. ._. 0... ~ A~~~p~~ :a)fd.. •9Jl. n.e ~ ....,_ rioe "' ...... ~ ... IIMd .. a... . ........... ~ .............. w.-t ttal. "1lrrh ,... .. .,. cleeied • euUa. , .... Jawy btavM dull ualldJ h&aecl h lC
prantW.ud,.
nu pouto Ill 111 ~ pJant So formJcA.blc h • 10c ot d.iMUa to ~ it 5I -.~~ita tbat II miiba wdl bl worldtftd ~ lli)"'M cM.rtt to ltoW l.h.la ~'1 "'!:J'"ble • aU. Ap111 ff'O(ft lllc u lcbnted t.nd cklldl7 JUPI lo.tt towl0 wMch drpopullltd lrtltnd 1 CtfiNI'1 ..,0 chb ya.~, rberc ue die Sa'"- Powclcfr, Cammon t.nd ~ : dw kot .. ~ Piok aftd WIJIII«, Md t.he .u.bttt toe lcttowft .. lbd ..... Jl .- _,. - t:ftCIUCb (,wl die a~ It -..plctc), thac vc ~ ......_ l1w ~ dqitnrnd" 6nM\, ~ Mil CIC =otntio cdokv, die .....,....
.......... o~ ... a- ... LafOW..,.I""' ..... -OHaM.. * --r.ckn.t.b~-·---~------ nw,...,... 5 r ,., .... --. .... ~- · ~.,..... . ...., .._..,_.... ................... ~ ..... ...., be .. lniluat. T1M ....t ., .., .... ,._ Yhl ~ Sorioa.., Or. St-....~ .... . -~ -.:~ ,_, ,.,.. 8rid4 fuma" • ~ - 1M ... -... .. COftCdl4 -'"' dM: prirM 1m«~ dnuoJu ol .... ~ !:Itt • Colondo ...,, t ftd GA ~ ~ tJrUI lfl ~ ..... at
t., , MaJ i l be .... tN4 \be ~ ol • a1Qfk Colondo '"'"' In lhh COUIIIIJ WIN ai'!U MWIPI,I)U hddlloa.
' THI SPI.CTATOa , JU .. I I 4 • I, • •
MARGINAL COMMENT ~ KAilOLD NIOOtAOH
I ItA VB flild nttd ar)'KW wh'l l.bt Ilk~ puWk, Wbo dwillll M. ~ MIS Mt . ...,.._ G.cqc: e a 1-' ,._. .. .....,_ die ~ wu WMed th<mol.d'l'tl ilnpnTiow to rt~ lone d pro- dilcttoe:u whidl h.t "*'•: oo ..,. d'ft ...,_ • fllliiiCb • 1M
ptpftdl, •hould bnwc-m 1919 an6 19)1 t.ave: t btotbcocl withou1 I dortt ~ tJw liWMt" hlMOt)' r:tl eo.t twbvlcot Md -.bit .,.. ~~·, rr"(l(tlon l.h: CknmA vtnlon ol thl T rtarr « Vuwi:Ua. llh 10n Btknfte ... • tilted. ~ bLlinpal and bcr(llc. )'CWirl Rvtn tod-11 cbtte IJC 11\MJ pcopjt ln tl'llt <0U1M1Y Who rcm.t.in OXI- -. Hb f'ff:l'/ ltttlaffl IUIIftMd coaf)', ~ l:tM I hJt ~ vl.n«d dw 1hc Dbct SrnlemoHM o( 1919 wtt Mt ol1.hoe 1110111 lpotuq ~~""" tfb tp&rll.kd wid! iftldJitcocc: find e:ntttSM'IM J bit n pn.-lon Mid WqUilOW rver fnmed; )'ft \hac pc!OC)Ic ~ 00W 6nd it ftt 00C ol fkn llontlfy, (ll ......... f~ fll thWnc ftith. tit d~t to w.tc wlldbn \heir con'l'icdoll wu t..Md vpor11 du rae~ c:~Q~pc4 from PfU)(c at\" die aopltulation, IDd h ... Ill PritltctoA. lhaa dl. 'J"ru:ry wu toO lwd at toO tolt. .... k di» atra1iJC iG NlrW' Jri'N7, diiM )M pttptttd tbr aatm.ltor IlL! boOL H1 liM• pbc~ to be ~~ It N J b1 ~ 1k A.,..S•_. rctumal to E~ .. ~ dM: Ft« FH:aldl hrta ... W 1M peoplr• lMn \McD to d ecttd by 1 .... ,.._ ~ dllll rlwJ ~ ol ~ ~ U. ~ ot• Gt...... ... ~ Wllhc.JI bcba ""-"' al .. . .............. "'"bc ba ....... w ~~ill die .... ~ fll .. ... tku ~ U I Tq:vor ~ ltcMtlc ~ dAD .:If Qllllil)"'()ryJ. Kr _. ..... iD ...... I fc..,.. -*J ...... dM .,._ fll cdlbl cbolaPt rallltcn illaa ...... \!«aM ~ ~ -. ........ • II -., • k .,m""' • • dl.t co.ilre ICM,... 4 n • nche "flM. ~ it Ia 46.wb for lamp ...-- ca. .a.. Mt. K.,... ,..._. llit boot ......,.4•t ,_. .... Thr.1 podUu 10 iDctlucc: the: 8ririlb people • ..._. Ill dw ..., *' Willi • 1111 ....,. wllldt _.,. '"- dllc a-nQo1L • 'C"M .._ •llcM. ~ to lii:.:IM. it U asJ 10 pcr.wrdr I:).G to/1-11 We. dw7 haw ¥P 'lion 1M ....-.r ...W 1tbJ-d X.q.a hlv« ...S d*" ~ ""f'fftf. U oac •uta 10 bhw * ~ ~CDK d. t!K ~ ID6icuMotl Hor .-we- would bl<rc bCICO 1k oooEn&U.t., Olio«'• beM ~ h to pllly ypo. eMU ~ ~· ff'O!Ndoa ol tlw: ......... wkb cbc apprmdcc ~ ~ 4lif 1\illt. No &c:Ushmm caD be: incttatld co btlfcvt dLet bil owu 1M .._.aou., tcftlk, Nllliuti;ac «7ft ol M8,.-,d KfJDI't Utd th« ~tttunmt haft .cud witll wbdbm, bl.nualq aod lorftit,bt ; but IS.hiftt, C'lehccl cyn d IWmac Mamoua! Bul eecb c1 then"~. wl'ltft J'O'IIdi iiO Etla;fu.hmM lhllt bb Chalim I\IJfA blft '"ID~" « '"blund«td, • hit scc.epcll'l« ol ...U ICQaldon ill ialmcdiatt, wuc lkQinc &nd plcuunblt.. 'J"ttU It tiOC die -.ly ~ wby we t«ept«l wilb wda rod.incss die: Oa.an \cnloQ d Vcnaiiia. Tbc ftriru. ~ tK.Ikwd dk Oc:tm:Mt btcii\IM .., ... d co ~ ~: -.:1 wby clld 1ky ""* 110 bcticor« dial~ c::tr.d7' bocw:K .-cit wu ., leut UDCCIIClllc:nabk liDt ol bdltf, If. u ICIIDt pcopk MMIW4, dw Gc:ma:. -u dc:tmDiDM: ooc ..,. to mhM 1ku 011'0
,.,._, - • bc:row ..,.... - «kn. .. ....,..,. ..., Uld ..ai~cu -... bt -euilcd ; 1:u1 r • I(IOt fl .,. 6cPa .., m \be N1lda .t. • caua TrucJ. ttac:a ... w ..t:r " c::MUl drll»e lll"tkk. .. <wdtt to ~ ...;.,, ttlil~ Md pao&. 8cu -~ d'K .... d oomlotciac ~. the: ._ fl kMl mimnc.c:.
I 1m DOC amonc thOM •bo conu~ dwot lhl T'"'f cf VUMiUn and ill •uend.ma iluuummu rcprtM:Ottd 11 mutc-rpk.ct ol p11Ci6c::t· tbl. Tbc K'ftfal untk • contl\lekd Ill 1919 wu« tu~ly tn'ltalll'l& to JI«'P"UIIt rtttl'ltmftlt wilb.ouc bdt.ll tordbk ~ to rtftdtt that tttaumcm iDdfll'ctin, Tbe llbut.l ptloclp~ whkb ~hey .mbodi«::-Md tb.c:y wc:rc dew!. -nd .u.,.....wac- obenu-ed -.d Yitiattd ..,. dtt b )'PO(ddcal foc!Miu ckwcd to ClOfiCftl lk l.reca- 9'ioiltdoaa d dloM ~ Alld ill Md:irl& to lad 16 .. Mit~~dw: ~ ruk few tD r- ·e · 11M ~ fll 1919 .a"t -.ed. ipcft tbt ~ ~ ~ .....-- ...ca.tdn ~ bovad 10 acrdlc .,._ die ..,... cf --. Yet elM: raJ ~ cf tile PW Pelc.t ~ ... M It - IICWI' cam.d «a ; W «br Trarin .,_ _...., .. ~II'J puuc:a!a", dlft dM wor1d. woaW ana !uoft btcn ~ • ... ~ cl • teODIId Gmraao War: W the......., Oo•=•••• ,_,_..a. m. n ~ IIRidet d * T...,. tA v..-... ~. dM: ~ ol the: l..apt ol N.-., ._..,. i"-~' ardda. dlco die .t:dc Tn:wy mUd ... btc-o ......., to ~ CODdilioM bf 1)d(CI\ll mCSDt. Y ~ CWD u .It M*Odto. th« Puce Stttlaoco& d 1919 '""'' prdaabk, bodt Ia prlodpM ud ptiClCia, co t oy tenlcmcnl wtUcb w.c: •a liktly co lldl.ln'• thl• lime. . . .
.s..;rt .... :Is .y..., 'zt" ,
I Y,rl.Jma Defended
"" ' ;' .. !:: ----.......,~- ...... ...., .. .. &. . .. ..,
ttn.:=..•
eoae Yea~r• 14eat RDo d,.,., tea Jran•, aa4 o t monUJIIental wo personal letter.
"The Fo rgot t en Jtan• i e one o! aeTe11t7;.two po ems in THE TORCH'S J'L.AKll, and the late Prof. Charles Phi llips of Notre Dame UniTeraity wbo shared my wann admiration for J'ranklin Delano Rooseyelt, included in hie introduction a gracef ul tribute t o him.
• I think, Judging from your own writina• and progreesiTe liberal conTictiona, that you mi ght be interested in my book, and accordingly take the liberty o! enclosing tor your kind cons i deration the publisher's circular. In the ~oeeTelt library I belieTe you haTe a copy of a preTioua volume of mine--• Voices at Daybreak•, with a foreword by Dr. Richard Burton.
Of the first edi tion o f '1'IDI 'l'ORCli'S J'LA1Ill lese than a do zen co p ies remain. Theee are autographed . Not that I attach any importance to ~Y autograph, but it doee make a book ~ore intimately personal .
With beet wiahea I am AppreoiaUnly 7oura, ~·"-"ll <;"~
f
I
--~~~-===~-====·~·~·~----------------------_]