radio constraints on the volume filling factors of agn...

16
Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN winds and Andy Fabian (IoA) STFC Postdoctoral Fellow Institute of Astronomy, University of Cambridge

Upload: doandang

Post on 10-Feb-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

Alexander Blustin

JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09

Radio constraints on the

volume filling factors of AGN winds

and Andy Fabian (IoA)

STFC Postdoctoral FellowInstitute of Astronomy, University of Cambridge

Page 2: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

ionised wind

X-ray absorption – more ionised

Blustin et al. 2007, A&A, 466, 107

UV absorption – less ionised

Kriss et al. 2003, A&A 403, 473Artist’s impression of ionised wind in nuclear region of a galaxy

The winds are studied through X-ray and UV spectroscopy.

They contain gas at a range of velocities and ionisation levels.

Multiple origins: torus/NLR, accretion disc?

Observing AGN winds

Page 3: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

How much mass and energy is carried by AGN winds?

What are their volume filling factors?

What role do AGN winds play in feedback?

Probably small (see Blustin et al. 2005, A&A 431 111), but direct observational evidence lacking

Page 4: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

Need a new observational window: radio free-free (bremsstrahlung) emission from wind?

Well-known diagnostic of stellar windse.g. Wright & Barlow 1975, Panagia & Felli 1975

Recently suggested for AGN: Blundell & Kuncic 2007

We have now applied this to winds in a group of nearby AGN

Page 5: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

Stellar: uniform spherical wind AGN wind: partially covering, clumpy

Page 6: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

Sν,4π

M4π

4/3.

Stellar: uniform spherical wind AGN wind: partially covering, clumpy

Radio flux density

Mass outflow rateWright & Barlow 1975Panagia & Felli 1975

Page 7: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

Sν,4π

M4π

4/3.

Stellar: uniform spherical wind AGN wind: partially covering, clumpy

Radio flux density

Mass outflow rate

M Cv Ω

. Covering factor

Volume filling factor

Wright & Barlow 1975Panagia & Felli 1975

Page 8: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

Sν,4π

M4π

4/3.

Stellar: uniform spherical wind AGN wind: partially covering, clumpy

Radio flux density

Mass outflow rate

M Cv Ω

.

Sν,obs

( Cv Ω )4/3 M

4π4/3

.

Covering factor

Volume filling factor

Wright & Barlow 1975Panagia & Felli 1975

Page 9: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

Sν,4π

Observed AGN 1.4 GHz radio flux density

Cv Ω =

Sν,obs

Covering factor

Volume filling factor

3

4

AGN 1.4 GHz radio flux density predicted for a spherical uniform wind

Page 10: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

What is the value of global covering factor Ω?

50% of nearby Seyferts have warm absorbers, so could be 4π/2 = 2π

BUT

if the winds are related to the (base of) the NLR, it has to be smaller than this: 2π x (solid angle of torus hole=proportion of unobscured AGN=25%) = 1.6

Page 11: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

Calculating the radio flux density Sν,4π

Can we just integrate over bremstrahlung emission?i.e. optically thin?

No (τ >> 1).

Instead use modified expressions for optically-thick stellar wind emission (Wright & Barlow 1975):

Sν ~ ∫ [blackbody flux x bremsstrahlung absorption] dr

Page 12: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

Full expression for Sν:

radio flux density, Sν,4π

= 23.2 M4π

ν γ gff Z d (1+z) Jy

µ v

4 2 2 2 4 3 3 3 3 3

based on Wright & Barlow 1975

. -2 -1

average ionic charge

gaunt factor

distance to source

ne/n

i

rest-frame frequency

mass outflow rate

outflow speed

mean atomic weight of gas

flux conversion

Page 13: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

Mass outflow rate for a uniform wind:

(For non-outflowing ionised absorber, use substitution:

M4π

µ v

.

= 4 π mp L

ion

ξ

assuming n r-2 and ξ is constant)

ionising luminosity

ionisation parameter

= ξ

4 π Lion

µ mp v

M4π

.

proton mass

Page 14: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

The AGN sample

Requirements: point-like radio source in NVSS image (no host contamination) Sufficiently well-spectroscopically-studied X-ray absorbing wind

NGC 3516

MR 2251-178

IRAS 13349+2438

NGC 3783(a bit extended?)

Also MCG-6-30-15 (no NVSS image, but unresolved in VLA; Ulvestad & Wilson 1984)

Page 15: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

Upper limits for volume filling factors

(Not all phases predicted to produce sufficient flux to obtain an upper limit to Cv)

NGC 3516

MR 2251-178

IRAS 13349+2438

NGC 3783

MCG-6-30-15

0.0002 - 0.3

0.04 - 0.1

0.01 - 0.5

(none; predicted radio flux lowerthan observed; host galaxy emission from extended source?)

0.006 - 0.02

Assuming Ω is in range 1.6 - 2π:

Cv upper limit

Page 16: Radio constraints on the volume filling factors of AGN windsstar.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessO/blustin.pdf · Alexander Blustin JENAM, University of Hertfordshire, 20/04/09 Radio

Conclusion

When calculating the mass outflow rate of an AGN wind, we can't safely assume a volume filling factor of unity;

This will cause us to overestimate the wind's contribution to feedback.

For more details, see:

Blustin & Fabian 2009, MNRAS in press, arXiv/0904.0209