rao bahadur judgment

21
&% 6:;,0399,943 3/,8 %&#%#$ 0./0/3 550,398 #,4,,/:7!/,'03,9,.,,5,9 '8 #08543/039 %0:39:749943:90,3/!,507849/,3/37 550,398 %0:39:749943:90,3/!,507849/ '8 #08543/039 3,2,:7,2,.,3/7,#,4,3/37 43-0 :/08 ,,.0,3/$73;,8,,3,7 ,80 490 425,3 08 .9' 41 $0.9 43 4397,.98 9 425 ,3 43 /8.48:70413907089-411.0741425,3340/04170.94780110.941 %7,38,.9430907;4/11.07;493147.4397,.93.0839070890/ ,-9147/,2,08,3/80.709574198 &% ,,.0 %88,.4330.90/807084114:7,550,8,7834:941 ,8:9 -90:39:749943 : 90 ,3/ !, 50 7 8 4 25 ,3 290/ , , 38 9 90 9 4 /0 10 3/ ,398 9 0 7 14 7207 80.709,708,3/970,8:7078147 ,/0.,7,9439,99080/0103/,398.0,80/944/411.0 1742 89 ,7. 147 ,3 3 :3.9 43 70897,3 3 902 174 23907107 3 9 90 2,3, 0 2039 4190 425,3 147 .4770.9,..4:398 ,3/ /,2, 08 147904888:89, 30/ - 9 0 4 25 ,3 - 70,843 41 90 7 80;0 7, ,.98 41 17,:/ ,3/ 2 8,557 45 7 ,9 43 57023,7:/2039390.,80,85,880/43957,3/9013,:/2039 439570103/,39 4 ,8349,550,0/-:90,80,7/ 3843.,80 43 90 ,550,8 - 5 , 39 118 0103/,394 ,8 57 01 0770/550 , 4 41 ,,3899057023,7/0.700,3/550,441,,3899013,/0.700%0 425,3 ,8 57 01 077 0/550, 4 41 ,, 389 90 570 23,7 /0.700 ,3/ 550,441,,3899013,/0.700 ',74:82,990781,94-0/0,9939080,550,890/0.8433.,8390 473, 97, ,8 349 -003 ,88 890/ -:9 .438/07,- ,25070 / - 90 ,.9 43 41 90 5,391183349.0,770,83-0147090.,203944:79,3/349.0,7809934:93 90750,/38,9907.,:80841,.943070,3/,97020/08,9,070450394

Upload: lakshmimenon39

Post on 06-Apr-2018

229 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 1/21

&%

6:;,0399,9433/,8

%&#%#$

0./0/3

550,398#,4,,/:7!/,'03,9,.,,5,9'8

#08543/039%0:39:749943:90,3/!,507849/,3/37

550,398%0:39:749943:90,3/!,507849/'8

#08543/0393,2,:7,2,.,3/7,#,4,3/37

43-0 :/08,,.0,3/$73;,8,,3,7

,80 490425,308 .9 ' 41 $0.943 4397,.98 9 425,343/8.48:70413907089-411.0741425,3340/04170.94780110.941%7,38,.9430907;4/11.07;493147.4397,.93.0839070890/,-9147/,2,08,3/80.709574198

&%

,,.0

%88,.4330.90/807084114:7,550,8,7834:941 ,8:9-90:39:749943:90 ,3/ !,507 8 425,3 290/ ,,389 90 94 /0103/,398 907 14720780.709,708,3/970,8:7078147,/0.,7,9439,99080/0103/,398.0,80/944/411.01742 89 ,7. 147 ,3 3:3.943 70897,33 902 1742 39071073 9 902,3,020394190425,3147 .4770.9,..4:398 ,3/ /,2,08 147904888:89,30/- 90 425,3 - 70,843 41 907 80;07, ,.98 41 17,:/ ,3/ 28,557457,943 57023,7:/2039390.,80,85,880/43957,3/9013,:/2039439570103/,394 ,8349,550,0/-:90,80,7/3843.,8043 90 ,550,8- 5,39118 0103/,39 4 ,8 57010770/ 550, 4 41 ,,3899057023,7/0.700,3/550,441,,3899013,/0.700%0425,3 ,8 57010770/ 550, 4 41 ,,389 90 57023,7 /0.700 ,3/550,441,,3899013,/0.700

',74:82,990781,94-0/0,9939080,550,890/0.8433.,8390473, 97, ,8 349 -003 ,88890/ -:9 .438/07,- ,25070/- 90 ,.943 41 905,391183349.0,770,83-0147090.,203944:79,3/349.0,7809934:9390750,/38,9907.,:80841,.943070,3/,97020/08,9,070450394

Page 2: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 2/21

902 43 9080.,:808 41 ,.943 9 -0 .43;03039 94144 90 47/07 9,03-904074:793/0,399080;07,2,99078388:03989,943,3/,8/0,9-49,550,8,,3899057023,7/0.700,9908,20920

%0 1789,3/ 248925479,392,990770,90894,2479,041#84;07902574507931,;4:741901041903//0103/,39%8,89,03433/,3:,7

3.4393:,94341,3/-,4180.:79147;,74:84,389,03,9;,74:89208-90425,3174207%04074:79,80/43982,99079,994:903//0103/,39 ,/ ,3 3907089 3 98 2479,0 . .431.90/ 9 8 /:9 94 90425,3 ,3/ 90701470 ,3 3907089 .0 84:/ ,;0 /8.480/ ,3/ 94: 0,8,-090701470,8,039147905741980,/,30/,3/,8,97:8900147,3488. 90 425,3 2, ,;0 8:11070/ 09 83.0 34 574198 070 ,30/ ,3/ 34 4883.:770/3//0103/,398170041,3.;,-93988:9%8/0.8438902,374:3/41,99,.3905,39118,550,

889,90/902479,0,89,033.4393:,94341,8070841570;4:84,3889490804,38904389,9020393905,39835,7,.9,9/0103/,3988:8503/0/97,38,.9438 9 ,38 ,3/ ,00 9,9 ,70 /0-98 070 -47740/ ,9 , 7,90 4139070891742907;08%08,704/078/85:90/9003:303088,3/44/1,941

948097,38,.9438,3/5,880/,850.,7084:943433/0.02-07.:79,390-47743 54078 41 90 /0103/,398 . ,8 .431720/ 43 9 0.02-07 %080 97,38,.9438 ,70 .4:8;0 ,3/ 17,:/:039 ,3/ 070 3903/0/ 94 -03019 90/0103/,398,9 90.4898 4190 5,3911425,3 ,3/,7090701470 ;4/%0897.9:/0,8.438/070/902479,0,9039-:934070/8.:8808904,380.05994.42094.079,3.43.:84389070431,;4:7,-09490/0103/,398%:80543984:935,7, 9,9 90 2430 147 9080 4,38 ,8 70.0;0/ 1742 90 03/078 ,3/ 5,/ 147;,:0,3/0,834/4:-99,990,24:398,00/,/-00370.0;0/1742903//0103/,39810,3/,/-0038503914790092,905:7548041902013/8,849,9 0,7 3 90 8947 41 90 425,3 43 3/ ::89 90 ,3 41 ,/7,8701:80/94,/;,3.024702430-043/#8-47740/4394;02-07,9507 .039,3/9,99 ,89039,990/0103/,398,3/907;08 -0,394,/;,3.0

24309490425,3%070834,990259-905,3911894574;09,990425,3.4:/,;049 243043 0,80790728 39045032,709 479,9:3.,0/.,59,,8,;,,-098.0,79,990425,3,8,;370,9/11.:90830993908,704/078 94 2009 .,8 147 1:7907 .,59, ;03 ,80,7 ,8 9070.9478 ,/ 94-03138:9894.42508,704/078945,:5,3/84209308:9807010/,2349907014705705,70/9414490897.9:/034/3,80/40835,7,9,9902479,0/4.:2039,3/9814707:330789,98905742884734908147904,3807000.:90/349390390708984190425,3-:917,:/:039-90/0103/,39894,/;,3.090390708941903//0103/,39810%0897.9:/0/408349,8,;08,/.438/0790804,38-90280;0802070,7:08-,.1742902479,0 9490 4,38,3/ -0.,:80 013/8 90 14720717,:/:039 04/890 ,99072:89,;0-0035,7941908,2017,:/:99,98-3420,38,092,90.43.:84347, 574507 2094/ 41,77;3,9, .43.:8435,79.:,7 ,890 :/02801 4/8

9,9,9178990/0103/,39807003:3057480.:9390 390708984190425,39,94,3807030.088,7,3/9,9901:24304-9,30/ 43 9480,88503939039070898 41 90 425,3 4 49 90 1: ;,:0 147 907 2430 9 90 920 41,7:2039 970/ 94,8.079,3 0907 ,9 ,3 920 90 8,704/078 ,/,9 ,3 41 903:2074:8,33:,0307,2009380;07.,030/904,3898/11.:93902,88410;/03.090708398.,8094-0,-84:90.079,341,35439-:90,;0349-00354390/ 94,3 0;/03.04394 3/.,909,990 8,704/0780;07.,030/ 90804,38%05,39118/4349,880799,9904,38070:330.088,747,9,3:3/:7,90 413907089 47 9,9 90 425,3//349091:;,:0 147 90 2430%05,39

Page 3: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 3/21

20394380307,20093433/0.02-07..:79,0/90-47743540784190/0103/,3989/408349,550,70;0317429023:908419,9200939,9 903 9080 4,38 47 90 7,90 41 3907089 43 902 070 /034:3.0/ %0701470-043/901,.99,9904,38070-47740/174290;0841903//0103/,39,3/89 /0103/,39 9070 8 34 .,:80 147 310773 17,:/ ,3/ 90 1,.98 9,9 4,38 07030.088,79,9907,904139070898349574;0/4714:3/94-0:3/:,3/9,9

90425,3491:;,:0147907243080029420945:99088:04117,:/4:941906:08943,870,7/8904,3890280;08

4.42094902479,0%05,39.,7082070,0307,4309,99,8.4:8;017,:/:039,3/:3,:94780/09:8800178919,830.088,7 90425,38 13,3., 548943 ,8 ,5574,.3, .788'07 0,73 90 8947 41 90425,3 9070.9478 ,/ 94 -4774 2430 3 47/07 94 47 90 2 9 1789 90-47740/ 1742 90 ,3 41 ,/7,8 1742 94 -:9 90 ,3 701:80/ 1:79074,383!7;,9084:7.0890701470,/94-09,550/%080.019024304190/0103/,398,3/907;08.,770/4390425,39:73949070,8,44//0,4117.943,3/2,30:;073147548943-0900390/0103/,398,3/908,704/078%0-,,3.0800941,897434:9-:990-,,3.08009413.904,3880990/ -982479,0070039070/,85,880/

/,90/ 3/ 57 9 8 4-;4:8 9,9 90 89,0 ,8 -03 70,.0/ 03 1:790724304:/349-003994:980.:79%0 70.9478903/0./0/94,/;079801474,38439080.:7941902/;0798020398070380790/3944.,3085,5078,3/,,703:2-0741,38,8,5574,.0/1474,38%080,701:80/80080708%0708348:089439,9,3419080574.00/38070349-43,1/0%:89070.9478,/.4209490.43.:8439,92430.4:/349-0574;/0/94:980.:7943 5745079 ,3/ ,/ 2,/0, 03:30 011479 84 94 7,80 2430 4:98/0 - , 412479,0 ,3/ ,/ 1,0/ 3 9080 .7.:289,3.08 9 80028 94 20 507.79., 94/034:3.0 90 ;3 41 90 2479,0 4;07 2 5745079 9480.:70 90 4,38 .903/ /0103/,398 10 ,/,70,/ ;03 4794 4/ 9,9 90 2479,02:89,;0 -0039,390/- 17,:/ 825 -0.,:80 90 2479,00,8 903/ /0103/,398 10 90.7.:289,3.0894223/543994901,.99,9190.70/947,/-003,3430080,3

4:98/07 90 708:9 4:/ ,;0 -003 90 8,20 3,20 90 2479,0 4;07 90 25745079 %070 ,8 3 90 .7.:289,3.08 34 4907 ,9073,9;0 %8 .43.:843 8897039030/- 90 .43/:.9 41 90 8,70 4/078 3 90 2,9907 3 9 4;02-078420419028039,349.0949070.9478.,870,/,9907200934394;02-078005,0419057390/5,507857490893,,38990;341 90 2479,0 %070.9478 30;0790088 - , ;490 41 94 7084;0/ 43 902479,0 %0 57490893 8,704/078 ,3/ 90 /880393 70.9478 ,/ :39 3/,3:,703902479,0,8,.9:,00.:90/920949,00110.9;08905894570;0399,3///0,.93493,9,986:90.0,79,990//349.438/079,990739070898070-035:93,370,045,7/-9097,38,.943%0;,/9,3/-3/3.,7,.90741902479,0834388:03,805,7,908:9-902479,009403147.09,3/-0:/.,/0./0/9070-:9147905:7548084198.,80800348:11.03970,8431474/39,99,8 ,97,38,.94317,:/:039039070/394990

390394341.0,9390425,3

%03096:0894380907903//0103/,394,84304190.70/9478,/,339070893982479,0.84:/,;0-003/8.480/949070.9478-0147090/0./0/ 948,3.9439,3/1:79071 840907903//0103/,39890701470,-09490425,34390.4397,.9%017895439147.438/07,943890/0103/,398.43903943 9,9 98 4-0.943 94 90 2479,0 ,8 30;07 7,80/ 3 90 5,39 47 9050,/38479088:08,3/,8437,80/,99092041,7:20393904074:79,3/ 9,9 3 .43806:03.0 34 0;/03.0 ,8 850.1., /70.90/ 94 98 5439 %0 43

Page 4: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 4/21

0;/03.0 43 90 5439 8 .439,30/ 3 .079,3 ,38078 - .079,3 9308808 94 906:0894309079070.9478309,9903//0103/,390/,0307,540741,994730 3 1,;4:7 41 8 10 %0 5,39 8 .:5,- ;,:0 ,3/ 2070 850,8 41 902479,097,38,.943-03:3,:94780/,3/9047//8.48:70830;072039430/3905,394739088:0843904907,3/38,550,5099433//0103/,39,83492,/09,74:3/41,550,9,90,89,03-8:757803904074:794398

2,9907-:9,8207050,/0/9,9904074:794:994,;00/9,99070,8,8:11.039 /8.48:70 41 83907089 890 3/ /0103/,39 ,8 9,03 889,3/ 439,974:3/90318 3907089,88:.,84:93,94,;0-003/8.480/90436:0894389,9,;094-0.438/070/,704342//9043:841574410,3/090798574;0/9,99070,847,8349,/8.48:7093907014709,9907083498:-89,3.0 3 98 90.3., 4-0.943- 90 /0103/,398 ,94: ,8 8, 5439 4:9,90743905,39118,939050,/381,89038439029043:8415744141 343/8.48:70

98 349 /85:90/9,93/ /0103/,39,.90/,8 ,039418103902,9907 41982479,0,3/0,8:3/4:-90/,990920 ,70.947,3/;490/147902479,0,990200934170.94784/0./0/947,399%04074:79,814:3/,3/983498074:8 .,030/ -01470 :8 9,9 90 8,3.943 41 9070.9478 ,8, -4/ ,8 349

30.088,7 147 98 2479,0 %0 80.709,708 ,/ 503,7 5407 94 03907 394 8:.2479,08 1 90 94:9 9 ,/;8,-0 9 ,8 349 90701470 30.088,7 9,9 982479,084:/4-014709070.9478,9,-:9981,.94198014:/349,-84;0903//0103/,39190/0103/,39894:99,/;8,-094,;090/70.98,3.943419070.9478 9039 ,83.:2-03943902945,.0.,3//,901,.98-014709070.9478,3/1903//0103/,39,/,339070893902479,0.,88:.,33907089 ,80 4:93, 94 /8.480 ,3/ .0 // 349/8.4800 .,33499,0809073901,.99,90.4:/2801,;08,3.9430/902479,094:943949070.9478,9,

8,;07-701/8.:88900,6:08943,7:0/,903943-498/083,2009073 90 5708039 .,80343/8.48:7041 39070893, .4397,.9 47;493 43,

.4397,.93.0839070890/703/079041103/370.947,-03,34889490425,3.92,,;08:11070/3.43806:03.047703/0790.4397,.9;4/47 ;4/,-0 %0 573.508 . 98 425,3 706:70/ 9870.9478 94 144 3 902,990741.4397,.983.902990280;08,;0,33907089,70,//43379.0 41 90 79.08 41 884.,943 %8 ,79.0 94 2 23/ 2508 9,9 90425,3,/344-0.943949870.9478-0339070890/3.4397,.982,/0990425,3 47 94 907 2,3 574198 438:. -:9 90 3,9:70 41 90 3907089 2:89-0/8.480/,3/9039070890/70.9478,349;4903 902,990741 90.4397,.94710 /408 8;490 8, 349.4:39%8 ,79.0 ,8 ,/4590/ 43 9 $05902-07 :3/0790 :3,203/0/ 3/,3425,308 .93 .90 5708039 $0.943 ,94///349,550,73 -.941908080.9438070380790/4,907,94340;07,82,/039079.0841884.,9433.43806:03.04198,907,9434190, 4 -:83088203 2:89 -0 8:55480/ 94 34 907 43 3907089 ,3/ 90

-:830882034198425,3070.43903934994574-99870.94781742,;3,339070893.4397,.98990425,3574;/0/9,990 3907089,8/8.480/,3/9,91,70.947;49088;4908,349-0.4:390/9/408349,550,794209,9$0.943,47-,//8,3939490897.9308841909072894.9070.9478,/,70,/-003-4:3/- 90 425,398010.0599,9902,0,-70,.419090728 5:38,-0 - , 503,9 9,9 8 94 8, 90 90728 90280;08 ,70 349 247043074:8 -:9 90 4-807;,3.0 41 902 8 94 -0 03147.0/ 9 2470 80;079 ,2 3495705,70/ 94 4/9,9 ,1907905,883 41.9 41 79.0 41 90 79.08 41884.,943 -0.,20 :97, ;708 -0.,:80 41 90 ,203/20398 41 90.9 %080 80.9438

Page 5: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 5/21

82525480/,503,9147-70,.41,34-,943,70,/,//43-79.0

40898254894341,503,9147343/8.48:7047147;493.,77993,90 .43806:03.08 1789 ,8 70,7/8 90 425,3 9,9 90 .4397,.9 039070/ 394 98:., -70,. 41 4-,943 8 ;4/ ,- 394 47 ;4/,-0 ,3/ 80.43/ ,8 70,7/8 9041103/370.94780,-0147/,2,089490425,3190708,348894943

90.4397,.94780,-094,..4:39147,380.7095741982,/0 -2

870,7/8902,990741;4934390.4397,.998002894206:90.0,79,9902070;493.,3349419801,;0,30110.94390.4397,.9$0.943-.079,3/408349 8, 84 ,3/ 3 2 ;0 .,3349 -0 0/ 94 25 84 %0 0110.9 41 90 80.943 820709,990;4901;038,349-0.4:390/%0708344-0.938,39,9900110.9 41 90 ;490 8 94 703/07 90 .4397,.9 0, 47 ;4/,-0 &3088 90701470 90.4397,.9 4:/ 349 ,;0 -003 ,..0590/ 1 90 ;490 ,/ 349 -003 ;03 90 .4397,.9702,38 :3,110.90/ 50793039 .,80 43 98 5439 8 %7,38;,, 4 ; 0 0:2%7,38;,, ,3/ ,3/ 0;04520394 $ %# 3.,.4397,.9,80/94-0;4/,-0349-0.,:8090;490,8;03-:9-0.,:801 9,/ 349-003 .4:390/90704:/ 349,;0-003, 6:47:2 6:,10/ 94.4397,.9%02,9907,894-0440/,91742,-:83088543941;0,3/194:990;49090

425,34:/89,;0.,770/974:90.4397,.990425,3,834.,294,;090.4397,.93:10/470,25032507,07.,39070/9884.,943;402,3%#,9078,89,0 9 9,9 0;03 ;493 4:/ 349 0.:/0 90 ,7002039 ;493 9,9 8 ,1907/8.48:70470390 4,7/81:,,7041903907089419039070890/70.9478 94 0907 ;493 4:/ 2,0 ,3 39070890/70.947 ,-0 94 ,..4:39 147 80.7095741983489,#.,#49/;4744/# % %# ,3843 #- ,550,78 94.438/079,994:/10,88:. 3907089802:89349;490,3/9,099,910//;49004:/-0-4:3/- 90 0307, 06:9. .,708,1/:.,7,0399 90 .43.0,0/ 5741989,9 0 2,08 3 90 5708039 .,80 40;07 9 ,8 -00314:3/9,99070070349,3.43.0,0/57419843902479,0849,9300/3494

1:790743985439

870,7/8902,990741343/8.48:709.$0.943,/0,890,-4;0.438/07,943 41 $0.9433/.,908 9,9 90 2070 1,.9 9,9 90 80.943 254808,503,9 8 34 74:3/ 147 310773 9,9 90 80.943 574-98 90 .4397,.9 47 2,08 90, 9 8 831.,39 9,9 94: $0.943 / 3 90728 /893.9 8,8 9,9 90-70,. 907041 703/078 90 .4397,.9 ;4/ ,9 90 45943 41 90 425,3 0 ;4/,-0$0.9438,-,3/./43498,84:7907$0.943,.439025,9089,99039070892,-0,.6:70/,190790.4397,.9,8-0035,880/-90425,338:., .,80 9 80028,-8:7/94 .43903/9,9 ,30 54891,.9442884394 /8.480 ,33907089,.6:70/8:-806:0399490.4397,.9,;0900,0110.941703/07390.4397,.9;4/,-39447;4/,-0%8800289420943/.,909,9,90;0790,2,-033,3/33/,90,89,9,-70,.41$0.943,-47./408349

584 1,.94 703/07, .4397,.9 ;4/ 47;4/,-03 390757093 80.9438 41 98 3/ 98088039, 94 800 0907 90 4-0.9 41 90 80.943 8 9,9 90 .4397,.9 .439025,90/84:/ -0 147-//03 ,3/ ,3 80.943 700/ 43 3 ,3 5,79.:,7 .,80 ,;0 94 -0.438/070/ 43 98 43 47/3 ,3/ 20,33 3 47/07 94 800 0907, -70,. 41 903-943.439,30/39254798 ,574-9434190.4397,.998019:89,8-0030/33,3/9,9$0.943 4190!:-.0,9 .9$0.943419043003/078 .9 ,3/ $0.943 41 90 02039,7 /:.,943.9 84:/ -0390757090/ ,8574-93 .4397,.982,/0 3/01,3.0 419080574;8438800 08;$704.,4,7/""%#

Page 6: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 6/21

!900;,70""%#'.947,3,08147/$3/.,90;499%#%433,7/;499%%#,3/,73,.0;,7""!#%%080.,80840;07,70.0,7.,8083.90.4397,.935,798905,79,-09490503,925480/ -9080.943,3/

90/083419080.94390701470894147-/90.4397,.9,2349,-014770,8438,70,/;03948504:99008903.041,38:./08317429047/341$0.943,47-

0,;0 9070147094 .420 -,.94 9079.08 41 884.,943 ,3/90 ,903,55.,-09498425,34794425,308.,;0,379.041884.,9438:.,879.04:/8002942094-098 43/8.48:7041,3390708934950780703/07 90 .4397,.9 ;4/ 47 ;4/,-0 ,9 90 45943 41 90 425,3 '493 - ,339070890/70.94734950780703/0790.4397,.90907;4/47;4/,-0:9343/8.48:70 47 ;493 070 -:9 147 90 ;490 90 .4397,.9 4:/ 349 ,;0 -0038,3.9430/ 3, .,808 703/079039070890/70.947,-094,..4:3914780.709574198

,99038903,9:704190390708941.90,.4250/8.48:70%8,8-003, 2,99074117:91:/8.:8843,3/,8-003/0130/ 32,3.,8083;,74:8,83489,#.,#49/;4744/# % %# ,3843 900307, 573.508 .90/1742,.6:0038005,0,3/2,0307,-08:220/:53907:04106:99,990 3907089.,70.94741,425,3489,3/83,1/:.,770,9439490.425,38-4:3/94/8.4808,3 3907089..431.9898/:99490425,309079039070898418:.,3,9:70473492:89-0,6:08943411,.930,. .,80 ,3/ /0./0/ 43, 7010703.094 90 47/3 410,. $9,9:90 100,25082, -0 .90/ 9 ,8 -003 0/ 3 ,72,3 ; :3.5, 47547,943 41 42-,&#429,93907089939020,3341$0.94341 90 42-, :3.5, .9 8, 349 -0 2070, 5,7039, 3907089 .,

1,9072,9,038843801,70-:99,99039070892:893;4;0842070,843,-0050.9,943 4150.:3,7 ,/;,39,0472:89,9 0,89 -02,907, 9,985708:2,--733 8420 8:-89,39, ,/;,39,0 94 90 5,79 $:. ,/;,39,0 ,8 -003 0/ 94,..7:019944908,5041,3,/;07980203941905,79844/8800370,99035,79030""#47704,341243094.,774:9,.4397,.99904,7/1479080.:7941.90.4397,.9,8,8830/8.0,7,.,8041.431.933907089800:3338;,2843" " % # ! ,8 ,8402542039-,172.,/,.4397,.99904,7/800:9943;843""#!0307,90390573.508989,907090 390708988:.9,99809431:03.090 70.947,,38990425,383907089094574/:.0,.431.9-090038/:99490425,3,3/8/:99447390708939049075,799490.4397,.908-4:3/94/8.4809

043/9840;0798.0,79,919040-4/4170.9478,8,70,/,,7041901,.981472,/8.48:70834930.088,7:947994980110.92,-06:490/17422507,07.,39070/9884.,943;402,3%#,3/489,#.,#49/;4744/#%%#,3843070',:,3 ,28 702,78 9 80028 94 20 9,9 90 425,3 974: 9870.9478,850710.90,,709,9$74744/,8-0301.,39070890/3,.4397,.9%,9-039089,9041340/04190425,3,3/9870.9478,2.0,741453439,99070,83493398.,8094703/07$74744/8:-0.9

Page 7: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 7/21

94 ,3 ,-9 ,8,70.947 41 9,9 425,3 94 ,..4:39 3 70850.9 41 ,9 8479.,80.709574198

,;007034/4:-99,9903//0103/,39,8,8,03941810-4:3/3/:994 09 ,8 1,;4:7,-0 90728 147 07 ,8 5488-0 870.947 41 90 425,3 0 ,8-4:3/9409,81,;4:7,-0907281479,85488-0%094/:908,703.425,9-0,3/

.,3349-0007.80/9409079.,3349-0/4:-90/9,9903//0103/,398/:99490425,3,894/8.4808,03.1478101349,70,/343949070.9478,3/947017,31742;49343902479,0,3/9,904:/,;0.422990/ ,.0,7-70,.4180,/:908,870.947183907089,8349343949070.947847194:9/8.48390;490/,3/8;490,8300/0/94.,7790.4397,.93904907,3/9,990-4/4170.9478309,9905745480/2479,00,8903//0103/,398109070.,3-0 347442147/4:-9%030902479,0,8207080.:7914790570;4:84,38,3/9,990.70/947,8903//0103/,39810,3/98 ;07 /11.:9 94-00;0 9,9 ,341 902 070 347,39 9,9 90 3//0103/,39,8,.93 1478 10 3 98 2,9907 :7907 4394 90 ,, 3 .90 50,/38,;0-003/7,3:5907083488:043985439,3/03905,391188:-806:0392,/0 98343/8.48:70, 2,9907 41 .,70 90 43:8 41 574;3 9.0,7 , :543902%0.,3349,49040.,80944974:,3/-0.480/94:9,388:0

4398 5439,3/ 903 ,7:0 9,9 90/0103/,3982:89 8:1107 :/2039 -0.,:80 90,;01,0/94/8.,709043:8415744143,543941.90,;034349.09490/0103/,3983 907 50,/3 ,3/ 43 . 90 /0103/,398 070 349.,0/94 574/:.00;/03.0!,39118.,3349-0,40/8494850,94,203/9075,39,3/14:3/907.,:8041,.94343,6:08943415:701,.9349,00/3905,391,:94798,390/147 98 4-;4:8 574548943 4:/ .90 2507, 07.,390 70/9 884.,943 ;402,3%#070900,730/47/,3.047702,78!,391180706:90,,70419030.0889412,34:9,.,8041.43.0,2039,3/489,#.,#49/;4744/#%%#,3843070#-89,9084,990259,8-0032,/094849,9$7 4744/0;07//,9,8.4397,79490#,,425,3879.0841884.,943

,2 .0,7 9,9 90 43:8 , :543 90 5,39118 94 574;0343/8.48:70 ,21:7907 .0,7 9,9 90 ,;0 349 /8.,70/ 9 !,39118 93088 4 4 ,8 ,70.947 ,9 90 20093 .8,3.9430/902479,0 ,3/ 90 4370.947,99820093 4 ,8 -003 0,230/- 90 5,39118 ,8 349 0;03 ,80/ 10 ,8 903347,3941,393.90/0103/,3984:994,;0/8.480/020708,89,90//349349,9903//0103/,390/, 0307, 540741,9947301478 10-:998899094905439%05,39118,8,70,/54390/4:9,;030;07390750,/38,880790/9,99070.9478070349,,7041903//0103/,398,03.,3/,;03490,230/,370.9479489,909,90,8349,,704190390708340;/03.0 9,99070.9478 070 349 ,,70 4190 ,03. ,3/ 9,9907014701472,/8.48:70,99020093 ,830.088,798349450394 90 5,3911894.43903/9,99070 ,8 8:. ,3 ,-803.0 41 /8.48:70 ,8 ,24:39 94 , -70,. 41 90 , 8

70,7/8903//0103/,398;4934390.4397,.9,9870,574-90/03904,7/,8,,704190390708941903//0103/,39890.4:3934190;490-:90;031903//0103/,398;49043982479,0-0349.4:390/90708:94:/,;0-003908,2083.090;49343902479,0,8-,2,47941,,389

2:89070/0,9,3,9902593984:79-!441945:931708 0;/03.0 41 ,3 :3/8.480/ 3907089- 90 3/ /0103/,39 3,20 9,9 9 ,8-003/8.4;070/-905,39118,19079090723,943419097,3904074:799,90,8,990920418;4904398.4397,.990:3;078,0,90041810.,3349

Page 8: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 8/21

8004 98 897039038 905,39118 .,80 9 8/4:-91:1, 8508 8:..0884388 ,33907089 . 2:89 -0/8.480/ -:9 0;03 1 9 0709070 8 ,,3349 90 8908901147994,8807947574;09,99070.9478,99020093070347,39419,91,.93901,.98903,2:3,-0944/9574;0/9,99070,8,3 343/8.48:70-903/ /0103/,39 41 ,3 3907089 . 0 4:9 3 , 94 ,;0 /8.480/ 4 6:0894390701470,7808418,..4:39,-914780.709574198-:9,8,70,/54390/4:990

4074:79,80/9,902,/03430

1:79075439,8-0037,80/-5,391183 .4330.9439982479,0 98.43903/0/9,9-907084:9434190425,3/,90/903/0.02-075,03.47547,90/379.0419079.0841884.,94390/0103/,398907241411.0 ,8 80.709,708 .,20 94 ,3 03/ 43 89 ,7. $:-806:039 94 9,9 /,9040;07 90 .4393:0/94 /8.,7090/:9084180.709,708 ,3/ 970,8:7078 ,3/5,/4:9 94,7/8 90 /8.,70 41 90 2479,0, :2 41 #8 /09,8 41 . ,70;03,95,0419057390//4.:20398!,39118.43903/9,990/0103/,398,/.0,80/ 43 89 ,7.94,;0 ,3,:9479 945, 4:9 90 425,3824308,3/ 90701470 ,70 -4:3/ 94 701:3/ 94 90 425,3 #8 5,/ 4:9 94:9,:94794390 17895,.0988340702,/0,2,990741.,703905,39347/4089800294,;0-0037,80/3904074:7988:04.94:.0898

2,9907 ,8 7,80/ 349 43 90 5,39118 50,/3 -:9 43 90 /0103/,398 50,9,9 907084:943 41 3/ 0.02-07 ,8 3;,/ %8 3 9801 8 034: 94 7050 905,39118.4390394383.097089843 ,5439411,.943.90/0103/,39807030;07.,0/:54394,//:.00;/03.03,20090790/0103/,398//.4393:0990.438039 ,3/ ,:9479 41 90 8,704/078 ,8 80.709,708 ,3/ 970,8:7078 ,1907 89,7.3 903095,.098.0,7 0;03174290570803970.47/89,9 ,190789,7. 90 /0103/,398 // 349 .0,80 94 -0 80.709,708 ,3/ 970,8:7078 %07084:943413/0.02-07,81440/-,34907,9908,2020093..439025,90/ 9,9 9030 80.709,708 ,3/970,8:7078 4:/ -0 ,554390/ -01470 89,7.949,04;07907411.0174290/0103/,398$:.,20093,83490/,94:9,89390.4250903.041908,704/078944/9,3/3/00/907437084:943.439025,90/9074/3919080.709,7084770.9478701:8094.,

9 %0 8,704/078 90701470 944 34 89058 94 ,55439 411.078 94 9,0 4;07 .,701742 ,3/ 8:..00/ 90 /0103/,398 3 907 411.0 ,3/ 9 8 6:90 .0,7 1742 8:-806:039574.00/38 41 90 8,704/078 9,9 90 .4393:0/ 90 /0103/,398 ,8 /0 1,.9480.709,708 ,3/ 970,8:7078 :39 13, ,9 , 20093 3 0.02-07 90 3080.709,708,3/970,8:7078070,554390/8005,0%023:90841902009384189:5,0413/.94-075,0,9.,0,80147 43 . 90 5,39118 70 ,8 ;,/ ,3/ ,:94780/ ,8 0397:890/ 94 908080.709,708,3/970,8:7078,3/4190.02-075,0/0243897,909831,.9907084:943,990,893,20/2009389,984,3/84-043980.709,708,3/970,8:7078174298/,90147,7/35,.0419094/0103/,398,3/9,984,3/84,70,:94780/949,05488088434190209.17429014720780.709,708%05,39118.,3349 84,90 430 ,.9 41 9480 /0 1,.94 80.709,708 ,3/ 970,8:7078 ,3/ 8, 9 8:3,:94780/%02:8914.,.43903/9,9,,.98/430-902,190789,7.

3.:/3900,8041,70:3,:94780/,3/949,909039,8:3/0789,3/907.,80,9 90 -,790 070349 5705,70/94440390/0103/,39807031,.9 ,:94780/ 94 .4393:0 ,1907 89 ,7. 90 /:908 41 80.709,708 ,3/970,8:7078 0;03 94: 90 79.08 41 884.,943 ,/ /43 9,9 90 070 94 /029411.04389,7.904:79349-084.94:89413/9,9,90,.98/430-902,190789,7.0703;,/%007031,.97,910/-90425,394:90.43806:039,,203/2039,83493.47547,90/39079.0841884.,943%85,7941905,39118.,809070147080028942094,;0348:-89,3.0!,39118

Page 9: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 9/21

,550,4390402,990741902479,01,8

%0309543994.438/078,.,702,/0-905,39118,,38990/0103/,3983902,990741.079,30,808%03,9:704190800,8088,81448%008800,8948:55, 10/3:2-0741 5:990841 7, :901472,3:1,.9:70394 -,8,3/94 5,,10/ 8:2 507 5:99 147 473 0503808 94 90 2 %0 08800 944 4;07 90

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

9080.439039438,;0-00357,.9.,;03:5-01470:8,3/3090714:3/1,;4:79904:79-04%0897.9:/0,84374:3/8349,00/3905,3914:3/90/0103/,398,-0 147/,2,08 013/89,9090 /0103/,398 070 349 574;0/ 94,;0,/,8,703900,8090,/8:.,3390708939,890070-4:3/94/8.480 ,3/ . 90 // 349 /8.480 0 13/8 1,7907- , 574.088 41 70,8433/11.:9941449,994:90708340;/03.09,990/0103/,39890280;082,/0,380.7095741984;07900,80900,80,8439490717,:/43;07:31,;4:7,-0907289490425,3,3/9,990425,3 -9,917,:/489,8:241#8,3/09070147013/890/0103/,398,-039,98:2%01789543994-0/0,993.4330.9439980,80894809901907070,8,3574419,9900,8089,390/-17,:/%,99,85:-.,/;07980/0;03/0,/;07980/,..47/394!428018005,041900;/03.0,3/9,9903/07807045033;90/8.0,71742

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

4390805,7,90,77,302039%%%-090039008800,3/84735,79307890 574198 94 902 4-9,30/ - 8,0 41 90 2,3:1,.9:70/ :33 -,8 ,8 94 -0.,.:,90/ ,8 1 90 070 5,3 #8 507 5:99 94 90 2 03.0 90 :/0.43.:/089,9,343089088004:/,3/4:994,;0903/070/#85075:99,3/9,9-0.,:800//349900,8089,390/917,:/,24:3,-0941449870,8433

08800 8 41 .4:780 03990/ ,8, -:83088 2,3 94 09 8 0,80 43 90 40895488-090728.902,..059,3/102,08,,705741990704347039078

Page 10: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 10/21

3945,7930785984204300804390574850.9410993,70757419814728019,9834990-:8308841902%02,19075:-..,3147903/078,..0590/90089-/,3/902489:5794170.9478.4://4342470%01,.99,990088002,/0,705741984794:99,90.4:/2,0 ,,7057419834574419,990900,80,817,:/:039980,894-080,1907900;039,3//0./09,9900,80,9,071:704:/,;0;03247057419894902:998,/2990/ -905,39118

,3/ ,..0590/- 90 897.9 :/0 9,9 :5 9 903 90 2 . ,/ -003 473/05,792039,,/-003473,9,488,3/3.43806:03.09088902410,83,83974/:.0/800%:834430,9909204190903/078.4:/-0,9,.079,30907 90 30 88902 4:/ -0 -0301., 47 349 &3088 90 5,39118 ,70 ,-0 94089,-8,3/574;09,9902.4:/,;04-9,30/900,8017428420430080,9,1:70 ,-4;0 #8 47 9,9 ,,2 $:-7,2,3,2 .4:/ ,;0 -003 147.0/ :5 94 90071:70,3/9070834,990259-905,3911894/498907083245343,-84:903474:3/1474/39,9900,804:994,;0-003147,071:70,3/9,9901,:709409,071:70,8/:09484202,,1/084717,:/43905,794190/0103/,398%8.43.:843-0.4208897430703070202-079,98:. ,.,80 41 2,,1/08 47 17,:/,8 30;075:9147,7/ 3905,39,9 , ,2:3,-094,700 9 90 407 4:79 9,9 98 0,80 ,8 -003 843 94 ,;0 -003 3 ,3 ,9,390/- 17,:/ 3,3 .,80 90 20,8:70 41/,2,088743 %0 :/0108 9,9

9,98903:2-07415:99082:950/-#89084.,0/80.709574198-:9 43 8 43 843 5,7, 43 5:9908 070 470/ 84 9,990 5745071:704:994,;0-0032:950/-#8

%030954398090790/0103/,398,/3980,808:.,3 3907089,8904:93,94,;0/8.480/$:.,3 390708985072990/94,70.947-79.041 90 79.08 41 884.,943 -:9 903,9:70 41 83907089 2:89 -0 /8.480/ %05,39/408349,00,3,-803.041/8.48:7098349,54399,033905,3947390 88:08 347 .,3 13/ 9,9 ,3 0;/03.0 ,8 -003 0/ ,-4:9 9 47 90 70,8438,70,/;034/9,99043:80843905,3911894574;0343/8.48:70,3/1,9413/,30;/03.0,9,,290701470:3,-0944/9,99070,8,3 343/8.48:70 0;03 8:55483 9,9 /8.48:70 ,8 25480/- , 3 ,3 .,80 ,2

1:7907349 .43;3.0/9,990 /0103/,398,/,3 3907089.90070-4:3/94/8.480%008800,890-749073,41$,9,3,7,,3,2:799084341903//0103/,39$,9,3,7,,3,2:790/,540741,99473017429008800370850.9419 3,..4:39 419080 70,94385,3/ 84043 ,..4:39 41 9080 90 897.9 :/04/89,9903//0103/,39,8.0,739070890/390.4397,.9410,80,3/574.00/81:7907944/9089/0103/,39.;,-0-0.,:8094:9805904-0.9.4:/349,;0 -003 ,.0;0/ 1,94 14498 ,3/90 5,39118 ', /408 349 8:554799080 13/38 -;4:8 90 897.9 :/0 ,8 34914:3/ 90 89 /0103/,39 ,/ ,33907089390.4397,.9.0,8-4:3/94/8.480,3/0,814:3/9349574;0/9,9 90 89 /0103/,39 ,8 50.:3,7 39070890/ 3 90 ,11,7 ,9 , 8 94 90 3//0103/,39-043/870,943859070834939484,33907089.04:994,;0/8.480/08,/2990//;/0/17428843$,9,3,7,,3,2:79,3/90,70349 4344/ 90728$0.43/ /0103/,3910/ 8,..4:3983 4:79,3/ 90 5,39118

,/ 90 455479:39 41 3850.93 902 0907 90 // 84 47 349 90 ,;0 349.48039410902!708:2,-90/43498:55479905,39118.,80%0,..4:39841$,9,3,7,,3,2:790703498:22430/-905,39118390.;8:9-9008800,,38990 425,3 94 .90 5,39 ,:/08 90 40 2,9907,8 -003 430394,3/9,80/90709,9/0103/,398,/34 3907089398.4397,.9%070834,550,4720247,3/:2414-0.943843985439800 $441%08:089439,9903//0103/,3949,380.709574198174247,/,339070893980,80,83495:994,3930883490;0394!42801;03!448:550/1:3/8 147 90 .4397,.9 800 %%% ,3/ 4 8 0,230/ 43 -0,1 41 90 5,39118

Page 11: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 11/21

2,08348:.8:08943!,391183905,39/01390.,70/9,990/0103/,398430/, 8,70 3,3/70,80/ 5741981742 98 0,80 -:9 90 407 4:79 3 5,7, /01390 89,908 9070 8 34 0;/03.0 3 90 .,80 9,9 90/0103/,398 ,.9:, ,30/507843,,35,79.:,7,24:3998,84349089,-80/9,9902,/0507843,,50.:3,7,390280;08,3/35,7,98,89,990/0103/,39890280;08430/,8,708349089,-80/-70,-00;/03.0

3984:79905,39118,;05:93,50994394,/29.079,3,3,..4:39810/39,90,808:9.,..4:39807010/,839,98:9347/0794574;09,99089,3/3//0103/,39813,3.0/980,80;0310,/2990/9080,99889,097000,78,19079007010/39,98:9,3/3484:3/70,8438,/;,3.0/90.4:/349,;0-0035:930,707/4349.438/079,9900;0384 ,572,1,.0.,80 9,9 90 /0103/,398 ,/;,3.0/ 90 24308 .,3349 8:55479 90 897.9 :/08

 :/2039,3//0.700,,389903//0103/,3943980,800907439074:3/8;03- 2 47 43 90 74:3/ 9,9 90 3/ /0103/,39 // ,8, 2,9907 411,.9 2,0 ,380.709574198

4,7:2039,8-003,//70880/ 94:843900,8041894900,8041/0,99390 :/20393 5,7,894 98,8 5:-.,:.9430/,3/

,34.0//4331,;4:741',7,/,7,,;,-74907419089/0103/,39%05,39.,80,89,990/0103/,398,/8,708398:8:,905,391182,/034,99025994574;0 907 5,39 .,80 ,3/ 809 :5 4907 .4:398 1789 9,9 90 ,:.943 ,8 349 1,7.43/:.90/,3/80.43/9,99089/0103/,39,/,3 390708939.0//349/8.480%04074:79,870500/-495439801470:8901789543983499,03-:990 80.43/ 8 570880/ 4390 74:3/ 9,9 90 08800 ,3/90 89 /0103/,39 070:3/;/0/202-078 41,4391,2%:83454398570880/070,8,,389903//0103/,39479089/0103/,3998.43903/0/9,90,8/;/0/17428-749074390/,9041900,80-0.,:80,5,799438:9,/-00310/3,,3892801,3/9,9 -74907- ,34907 -74907 %0 0;/03.0,8 8 3,9:7, 03 90 2,9907,8 349850.1.,5:9 388:08 20,70 ,3/ 398 89,90 4190 .,80 ,2349 5705,70/94/1107 1742 90 407 4:79 3 98 13/3 9,9 9 ,8 349 -003 574;0/ 9,9 90 89

/0103/,39 ,/,3 3907089 3900,80 . 0,8 -4:3/ 94/8.480 0 2:893490,8,;0,70,/3490/4349072,990789,9905,39118,/2,/034,99025994574;0-0;/03.0901,.941343/8.48:708:554799013/341904074:7943980,80

%00,80418 /0,99-90:/035,7,894%05,39.,80,89,9900,80,834.0//439490088003859041 ,07-/-!4 ,3/ 9,9 90 425,3 90701470 489 9070- 3 98 6:08943 41 1,.9 90 4074:79,814:3/,,389905,39118,3/.,38003470,843147/110738,,389900;/03.0 41 ! 4 . 80028 94 -0 0,78, ,3/ 9,9 41 ! 4 90:38:..0881:.,2,3990708 90 0;/03.0 41! 4 90 425,38..4:39,39800 4 8,8 9,9 9070 ,8 34 07 -/ 9,3 9,9 41 90 08800 90701470,7009904074:7939813/38,-4:9980,80

%00,8041%80,80,85:9:5945:-.,:.943,3/34.0//4394',7,/,7,,;,90-74907419089/0103/,39%05,39.,80,89,990,:.943,8 349 1,7 0/ ,3/ 9,9 90 425,3 9070- 8:89,30/ , 488 ,3/ 9,9 90/0103/,398,/8,7083 90 .4397,.9 ,3/ 2:892,044/9490 425,3 ,574198.90088002,/0%,990,:.943,8:31,70/,8349-003574;0/9,8,8,2,9907411,.90/:3/0790,:85.084190897.9:38184:799801,3/,8.431720/-904:7999092041.43172,94390425,3,/90455479:39415:993147,7/,34-0.94390,/9490.43172,943430,550,7894,;0-003

Page 12: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 12/21

5:9 147,7/ ,700 9 90 407 4:79 9,9 98 ,0,943 41 ,3 :31,7 ,:.943 8:314:3/0/8 9490 ,0,9439,9 /0103/,398 ,/8,708 390.4397,.990 2,9907,8 14:9 4:9 3 $ 4 4143 90 1041 90 897.9 4:79%0 407 4:797008 43 90 /0.7003 9,9 8:9 -:9 9070 84-;4:8 8420 .431:843 39,9 /0.700%0:/203939,98:904307,908-49905708039/0103/,3989.4898,890070:330.088,72,/05,7908,3/0/9,99057080393//0103/,39,8

8:-5,793074143041908,7078%,998,890/0.8438.0,7,841742,34902,/0-908,20:/045,880/90/0.8433900;/03.041!4398.,80,95,0419057390/0;/03.0%0/0.70039,98:940;078,89,9908,704190/0103/,399,989057080393//0103/,398,-094,33,8390 7:500 94: 9 ,84 04307,908 90 9 /0103/,39 %0 289,0 8 3 90 /0.70083.090:/20398.0,79,99057080393//0103/,39,/348,70-:9,843,8:-5,79307 9, 8,707 $:. 8:-5,7930785 40;07 4:/ :3/4:-90/ -0 ,33907089 390.4397,.9 %0 407 4:798 90701470793 4/39,9 9,8 349-003574;0/9,99089/0103/,39,/,3 3907089390.4397,.9-:99,998574;0/9,93//0103/,39,/

403905,39,/.,70/3//0103/,399,;3 ,8,703980,800 // 349 38 79903 89,902039 /03 99 8 831.,39 9,9 009070/030/

,;3,/,38,7039057419841900,808147900,78,3/07017,30/1742,382,7/03,370850.941980,80%,9,88:11.03994223/,;370,7/9490907284179.0419079.0841884.,9439497443239097,9043:841574;3/8.48:70,3/0,82,/034,99025994/4840,890701470,..47/3949090728419,9,79.07914:3/ -904074:79,-094,..4:3914785741988,550,4398902#82:891,

%0 309 5439 70,908 94 ,3 4;0789, - 430 #,2,3:,, 3 90 4/ 25702808,99005038041905,3911425,3%00,730/:/08/8.:884343982,9907 8 3 5,7, 41 8 :/2039 ,3/ 8 .43130/ 94 90 5,79 5,0/- 90 89/0103/,39 %03 8://03 0 4/8 -49 90 /0103/,398 ,-0 94:9 8,3 04/8 3/ /0103/,39 ,84 ,-0 40;07 98 4..:5,943 41 90 5702808 7,98 ,8

.0,7,2,9907.903//0103/,394:9390 390708984190425,394,;0440/394,3/5:979,3/0.,3349-0,-84;0/413003.0.0/94,4889490425,339040904074:798/0.700439854392,-08:554790/

%0309543980307,.4228843%0897.9:/0,847/070/90/0103/,39894 147109 :3/07 $0.943 41 90 3/,3 4397,.9 .9 907 0307, .4228843 147,3/-0.,:804190728.43/:.9390800,78070,,3904074:79 ,8 430 03970 4:98/0 90 5,39 %0 43 .,2 3 90 5,39 70,7/394/3 41 .4228843 8 3 5,7, 3 . 98 .,20/ 9,9 90/0103/,398.,3349.,2.4228843,190789,7.-0.,:809079072841411.0903.,2094 ,3 03/ %070 8 34.,2 ,90;07 14790709:73 4190 .42288430,730/3 900,7857479489,7./4349800490/0.84341904074:7943982,9907 .,3 -0 8:554790/ 5,79 1742 98 90.3., 74:3/ ,;0 349 14:3/ 9,9 90

/0103/,398,;0-003574;0/94,;0-003:941,328.43/:.9394,8.,70/,3/90701470907083474:3/1479094/34190907.4228843

%030954398907024;,4190/0103/,3981742907411.0,880.709,708%0/0103/,398/43494-0.99498574;843390/0.700,3/99070147089,3/9,3 ,907,943 4190 /,90 0703,1907 94 -0 .438/070/ %0 574;84394 /0;07 :5 ,425,37089078,3/5,50781448

$420 ,7:2039 ,8 5:9 147,7/ 70,9;0 94 90 :/08 ,;3 /8,40/ 90

Page 13: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 13/21

5,39118.,29,990/0103/,3982,/080.70957419843,34.4397,.9988:11.03994702,743989,990.,283498:554790/-,3,..4:399,8349/11.:914790 5,39118 94 ,;0 .,0/ 147 90 ,..4:398 41 90 4 425,3 $0.43/ /0103/,39574/:.0/ 8 4 .4228843 ,..4:39 -44 -01470 90 4:79 -:9 90 5,39118 // 349.4480 9470 :543 9 -;4:8 34 .,80 147 /11073 1742 90 407 4:79 ,8 -0032,/04:943985439

.,2,8,845:9147,7/-5,3911870,7/3904889490425,3-90/0103/,398 349 ,;3 8:0/ ,,2 $:-7,2,3,2 90 08800 147 147 3498:553 5:9908 %8 ,8, .,803495:9147,7/ 3 90 5,39 347 ,8 9-0032,/0,74:3/41.,23904074:79,3/.,3349,4994-09,03070%8/8548084190,550,8,,3899057023,7/0.700

550,8 48 41 ,3/ 41 ,70 ,,389 90 13, /0.700 3 9057023,7/0.700, 422884307,8,554390/949,0 ,..4:3981742940.:/30944,..4:398:59495790/,9043. ,#0.0;07,8,554390/949,0.,704190425,38,11,78381:70890897.9:/0,88:7.,70/90/0103/,3989,8:241#8,83907089434,38.90/0103/,398 3049,90/ 147 90 425,3 349 43 90 74:3/ 9,9 9080 4,38 070

17,:/:039,3/3903/0/14790743-03019479,94190770,9438.,890.,803905,39-:9439074:3/9,990/0103/,398//349/8.480903907089.90,/390804,38%81:703.:/08390708943904,38.708:90/3902479,0 ,70,/ /0,9 9 ,3/ 3907089 43 4907 4,38 349 84 80.:70/ 070 904-0.943,70,/9,03,870,7/8902479,02:89,,3-0570880/%070834393905,394198.,7041343/8.48:70,3/90708340;/03.0,90;07,-4:99%043.,703905,3970,7/398835,7,.9,9,70/0-98-47740/-90/0103/,398,9 ,7,90413907089174290/0103/,398;08070.4:8;0,3/17,:/:039,3/3903/0/94-0301990/0103/,398%8.,70,8-00370500/-90 407 4:79 ,3/ 79 ,8 90 4,38 070 :80/ 147 90 425,38 092,90-:83088,3/ 90708 340;/03.0,90;079,9904,3807034930.088,714790425,38-:83088479,9902430.4:/,;0-00349,9,4077,90413907089

8,;0,70,/702,70/3902,990741902479,0/0103/,39807030;075:994905744141343/8.48:70,3/905,39118.,33499:7374:3/,3/8,9,990,;0349574;0/,990070349.,0/:54394574;0,241453439,9988:7.,70.,3349-08:89,30/984-;4:83,3.,809,990,.9:,1:70413907089.4:/349-0/0907230/-904074:79,99,989,01902479,0814:3/-3/34390425,3 3 90 8:9 :543 90 2479,0 90 3907089 43 9 4:/ -0 5,,-0- 90425,3 ,3/ 90701470 90 1:70 41 #8 4:/ ,;0 94 -0 70/:.0/- 902479,0 3907089 9,9 90 407 4:79 .4:/ ,;0 /430 ,8 94 ,;0 ;03 ,870,7/8 90 2479,0 3907089 , /0.,7,947 /0.700 9,9 90 /0103/,398 84:/ -08:7.,70/147842:.3907089,82,0;039:,-014:3/-3/34390425,3

%0 43 4907 902 8 90 2,9907 41 920-,770/ /0-98 . ,70 8,/ 94 ,;0-0.420770.4;07,-04394903003.04190/0103/,398%0897.9:/0408

974:90 89 1:7380/- 90 422884307 ,3/13,8:7.,708 90/0103/,3989,3,24:3941#843980,/070,,39894-03490/9,9905,39.,80 43 982,9907 ,834943041 3003.0 ,3/,-994 ,..4:39 %0 .,70,85,7, 9,9 90/0103/,398 .4:/0/9 90/0-9478,3/ 0907// 349 .40.9 90/0-9847.42574280/1474078:28147507843,70,8438%0708340;/03.00.05990 1,.9 9,9 .079,3 /0-98 070 -,770/ - 920 34 0;/03.0 9,9 ,3 488 94 90425,3 .4:/ ,;0 -003 570;0390/ 003.0 ,8 30907 ,;0770/ 347 3 245343574;0/%06:089430907,5,79.:,7/0-984795:78:3 -8:947300.:9438,70,2,990741/8.70943390,3/841-:83088203,3/94:/-0

Page 14: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 14/21

,-8:7/ 147, 4:79 94 4/ 2,3,078 7085438-0 147 0;07 :370.4;070/ /0-9 2070-0.,:80 89058- , 41 00.:943 47- , 41 8:9 070349 9,03 %0 79.08 41884.,9434;0890,3,370.9478,-84:90/8.709433902,9907419070.4;0741/0-98%0897.9:/08970,9203941985,794190.,808907014701,71742 8,981,.947 %4 .420 94 5,79.:,7 9028 9028 48 ,3/ 070 349.4390890/-90/0103/,398,3/90248349.4390890/94900903941#8

.40.90/ 9028 48 ,3/ ,;0 -003 8:7.,70/2070-0.,:8090/0103/,398//3499,0890589470.4;079021742905,7908471742 907 !0,/078 4 17,:/ 47 .4:843 8 574;0/ 3 ,3 389,3.0 %080 .,33495488--02,/02,99078418:7.,70

%8.43.:/0890/8.:8843439013,/0.700,550,

$73;,8,,3,7

%080 14:7 .4330.90/ ,550,8 ,;0 ,7803 4:9 41, 8:9 3899:90/-, 425,37089070/ :3/0790 3/,3 425,308.9 :3/07903,204190:39:749943:90,3/!,507849/:39:7%44190,550,8,7017429057023,7:/2039,3/-905,39118,3/903//0103/,3970850.9;0,3/909449078,70-90

8,205,7908370850.9419013,:/2039

%0 :31479:3,90 9,94394 . 9080,550,870,90 8,95.,389,3.041902,33073.5078438.4330.90/9902,3,0203941290/,-9425,308398.4:39793,3/-0,;00,/330;9,-94/8:89,3//897:8939023/841905:-.970,7/94,8:.3899:9438

%089474198425,38:11.089484.0,748443,890425,38349 574507 47,380/ ,3/ 89,790/ 10 50450 9,0 ,3 70, 3907089 3 9 ,3/ 902420399-03894843/.,94384147357419,-4907507843803/0,;4:794.,59:70 9- 90 2,35:,9438 41 8,708 ,3/ ;4908 ,3/ 03 90 /,307 41 8:.03/0,;4:78.420894 -070,80/- 90 473, 574249078 90 39079:73 -0.420:38.7:5:4:8,3/7084790;03946:08943,-02094/84180.:7339490743,3/89054072,3,02039,3/,880984190425,39890701470.0,79,9:30889070 8 , /0./0/ 2574;02039 3 90 247,0 41 , 9480 .4330.90/ 9 8:.3899:943890574850.9418:.425,308,9,37,90398.4:397830.088,7442

,;0,/90,/;,39,041507:83-01470,3/90:/2039:8934/0;070/-20,730/-7490739080,550,88,;00307,,700/92970,7/94248941902,9907870,7/9:330.088,794790,805,7,90:/20394124370,7/3,902,990783.43974;078398;0574548094/0,850.,439946:0894381789,870,7/8902479,0,3/80.43/,870,7/89017890,8031,;4:741$:-7,2,3,2

870,7/8902479,0901789543994-04-807;0/89,9902479,00,83492,/0,5,7994908:9,3/90039706:08943,89070147094-0/8.:880/43,8-0900390425,343904305,79,3//0103/,39848,3/439049075,79190.,:8041,.943,/3905,3984:/-070,7/0/,8-03147/,2,08,,389/0103/,39848,3/1472810,8,3.0,3/-70,.4197:89,3/4390-,8843.90 0,730/ 897.9 :/0 390 4:79 -04 574.00/0/ 9 80028 94 -0 .0,7 9,9 34/,2,08 ,90;07 ,;0 -003 574;0/ %0 407 4:79 ,8 14:3/ ,8 , 1,.9 43 900;/03.0,//:.0/9,9,90243089,9070,/;,3.0/ -$,9,7,:901041903/ /0103/,39 070 ,.9:, ,/;,3.0/- 07 1742 07 43 24308 ,3/ 90 949, 41

Page 15: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 15/21

8:.24308,8#8%04074:79,8,84,77;0/,990.43.:8439,9988:241 #8 ,90,89 8 705,,-0- 90 425,3 9490 3/ /0103/,398 10,3/90701470841,7,890/0103/,398,70.43.0730/3424709,3#8.80889,3#8,;3-00314:3/94,;0-0035,/94902479,0092:89-00/9,934488,/-003574;0/94,;0-0038:89,30/-905,3911425,3,;034 089,943 3,..0593 908013/38 41 1,.9- 90 0,730/ 897.9 :/03

1,.9348074:8,990259,8-0032,/094,88,948013/381849054894389,9370850.941,2479,043-0,14190425,3-74:9,-4:9-/0103/,39848,3/ 90 ,;0 -003 .,70/ 9 2810,8,3.0,3/ -70,. 41 97:89 ,3/ 34 /,2,08,;0 -003 574;0/ 94 ,;0 -0038:89,30/- 90425,31 905,39118 .,80 ,/-0039,93;041908:943902479,0-902479,0034909/0./0/9070,8 , 70,843,-0 78 41 90 5,3911 425,3 -03 2,/0 ,-0 7431: 147 ,708:28412430147.92,349-0,-0,3/,9,9905,39118,390/:3/079057023,7 /0.700 3 98 8:9 ,8 90 /0.,7,943 41 ,3 4-,943 43 90 5,79 41/0103/,39848,3/943/0231,3/0053/02310/905,3911425,31742,-9370850.9418:.,24:39890.,8029,;0-003/1107039

84:/,;0-0035705,70/94/0,990.,80439,914493,/9349-003147901,.99,93859041908:089432,/0-20900,730/',84,550,70/147

90425,3//349,550,794,70094,38:.;047.4:780%0425,3,834/4:-9,;370,7/949050,/38398.,8000.90/94/8,1172902479,0,3//034-,94389070:3/07:9,;370,7/94901,.99,99,98:9,834909-003/85480/419825488-034948,090790/0103.04190425,339,98:94:/474:/349-08:..0881:1984:/-08:..0881:903,88:232,10,8,3.0,3/-70,.4197:8943905,794190/0103/,39898/11.:994800490.4:/-084:994-02,/0,-0147,3,24:39890,-9370850.941.90425,38,-08:..0881:9470889

398;0934/4:-9-0.4208:330.088,7948,,3931:790770,7/390.,2-,80/43902479,0-:9,8906:08943,8-0037,80/,3//0-,90/-01470:8,9.438/07,-003998002894209,929,808094:9-7012;09

70,7/9490.43903943839013/3841904074:79.,;0-003,..0590/-:89070,83417,:/2810,8,3.047-70,.4197:89370850.941904,389,0314790 425,3 1742 $,9,7,: %0 40 ,24:39 ,8 -003 .70/90/ 3 90 425,38-448 ,3/ 14:3/ 94 ,;0 -003 :980/ 147 90 5:754808 41 90 425,3 %0 436:08943 9:8 702,33 9 70,7/ 94 9080 ,24:398 8 ,8 94 90 7,90 41 3907089.70/90/31,;4:741$,9,7,:390,..4:39-4484190425,39825488-094,7003982,9907990;09,03-900,730/897.9:/035,8839013,/0.700 3 90 8:9 0 ,550,78 94 93 9,9 -0.,:80 9080 ,24:398 413907089,;0-003 .70/90/ 5074/., 3 90 3,20 41 $,9,7,: 488 ,8 -003 8:89,30/ 94 9,909039- 90 425,3 %0 .43903943 43 -0,1 41 90 5,39118 ,8 349 9,99080,24:398 070 ,.9:, 5,20398 347 .4:/ 90 .43903943 ,;3 70,7/ 94 90.7.:289,3.08-09,990425,38147842070,843-4:3/-9080.70/9838:., 2,3307 ,8 94 570;039 902 1742 708893 90 ,00/ ,-9 41 90 425,3 9

70,7/ 94 902 8, ,907 43 /0, 9 90 ,850.9 41 98 6:08943 -0,73 43 90390708939097,38,.9434190/0103/,398,3/90343/8.48:70418:.39070894790570803940;07,3/,5,791742,38:.6:08943904374:3/43.0;039,39080.70/98413907089,85,20398,.9:,2,/090.,3-0.,0/3946:0894389,9907,90413907089895:,90/147,8:370,843,-0470.088;0

9,84144817429013/3841 90 4074:799,99,8.0,730.088,714790 425,3 94 -4774 24308 147 89,793 90 47 41 90 425,3 1 903 9 ,830.088,7 147 90 425,394-4774,3/9080.709,708,;093907798 -003

Page 16: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 16/21

-47743,8,70,/14:3/-904074:79903,317,:/2810,8,3.047-70,.4197:89.4:/70,904394907,9041 3907089,3/970,7/94990708,-84:9034,0,94347574419,99,85488-09070,3/9031479080.709,70894-4774,3243084390.70/94190425,3,99889,0,9,4077,90413907089%0708349, 8.39,410;/03.094.4:7,9903943,8 -003/7,394849,939024302,70994:/,;0-0035488-0947,80243043895:,9438,8943907089

/110703994948043.904,380709,03%097:940;074:/:3/4:-90/,550,794-09,98443,9,37,90,890425,3//34989,7947,.9:,9050784389,9070248939070890/390425,3070/0103/,39848,3/,3/98-0.,:8090070,34:88420447490794574249090425,3,3/89,79473990944907841,/;,3.3902430890280;08475078:,/3907;0894/484147,439200;0394:9,380.:790898349897,309,9903//0103/,39810//349388943,380.:7908147070;03-,4157428847349088443,89,8.0,79,9/0103/,39848,3/070303970470.:8;02,3,020394190425,38 .43.07383/ 9 8 ,84 349 8:757839,9 03 9 ,814:3/9,9 , 41,8://030390425,3,857428394-0347,3/490750450.,20147,7/943907107038:.2,3,020398084:/,;070,7/0/9,8088039,948,10:,7/0743390708994895:,90147,3/4-9,380.:7908

90701470,700920,730/-749079,990/0.7005,880/,,389903//0103/,3939013,/0.700970,7/9498,24:3941 3907089,80774304:8,3/84:/-0/0090/

8 70,7/8 90 ,.9:,2479,0 9801 ,;0 ,84 /11.:908 3 :3/0789,3/3 90,.9:,.,8041905,391189334990.,809,9-70,84341;3419080.:7908390,412479,0,35,79.:,7088,8-0038:89,30/-90425,3184/4349004906:089434190-3/33,9:7041902479,0.8388:03902479,08:9.,3,9,-070,7/0/,8-03700;,39147905:75480841905708039.,80 3 /0.,7,943 ,8 ,,389 /0103/,398 48 ,3/ ,8 80.709,708 9,9 902479,08349-3/34:/-04134,;,%06:08943,89070147094-070,7/0/43174290543941;041902479,0.4397,.9,3/970,7/9490895:,9438

90703070,,390436:089437,80/47..4:/-07,80/,870,943439490574;8438,894 39070893/070,,3,8490708,-84:90348:.0;/03.043-0,141905,39118,8,70,/,/;0790/94

09,870,7/8906:089434190,00/17,:/2810,8,3.047-70,.4197:89-90/0103/,3983.4330.9439902479,0,3/,5,791742906:0894341,3 343/8.48:704139070899.8,/0,5708039,23498,9810/90708,30;/03.0 . 4:/ :891 4:7 4/3 9,9 9097,38,.943 ,8 2574507 1 4;07,,417:5008,8574507/:09490,/,99092041902479,0,3/,814:3/ -900,730/:/03904:79-0490,/,83,9:7,57088314707-03;0380.:79907014709.,33495488--08,/9,990/0103/,3983;38:.80.:79070,.932574507%08:757804:/7,907-09,9842:.,24:3984:/,;0-003039-90,/570;4:894:9,380.:79-:9,;034/4:-99,9,884

2070-0.,:804190.431/03.080,/3/0103/,39848,3/480-00;0/070,9,37,90,99,99202,89078419089:,943:9038443,19079-0.,20.0,79,99054894341/0103/,398$,3/970,7/9490425,3,8349,880.:70,8507,5880,/2,30/9,8433,9:7,1470794895:,909,9842080.:7984:/-0;03

%0436:08943.,8/8.:880/,970,9039-01470,834943970,7/94982479,0-:9,84970,7/94905742884734908.-0.,202070/390 2479,0 ,8 9,9 :3/07 $0.943 , 41 90 3/,3 425,308 .9 . ,8

Page 17: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 17/21

3974/:.0/394 90 .9-90,203/3.941,34-,9438,/430;0770.947 /70.9 47 3/70.9 .43.0730/ 47 39070890/3 ,3 .4397,.9 47 ,77,302039039070/ 394 43 -0,1 41 90 425,3 94 /8.480 90 3,9:70 41 8 3907089 ,9 9020093419070.9478,9.90.4397,.947,77,3020398/0907230/431839070899030898473,34907.,80,990178920093419070.9478,190790,.6:8943418390708947902,34190.4397,.947,77,302039%0503,98

,84 574;/0/ - ,:80 41 90 8,20 80.943 41 , 130 43 ,3 70.947 4.4397,;030890574;84310034/4:-93223/9,9905,8834198,203/3574;8432:89,;0-00370,4;07440/ -905,7908-0.,:809894-0349.0/9,90;033905,39.,70-,80/4398574;843,8-003,/970,7/94,341902,9907892,507,58-005,30/439074:3/9,998574;843.,2094-05,880/84209030,784784,190790425,39801,87089070/,3/574-,-90 ,9903943 41 90 70.9478 ,8 349 850.1., /7,3 94 9 ,3/ 90 4-,943825480/ 9070- :9 ,9 90 8,20 920 9070 8 3 90 79.08 41 884.,943 41 90425,379.0

4 70.947 8, -0 /86:,10/ - 8 411.0 1742 .4397,.93 9 90 425,30907,8 ;03/47 5:7.,807 47490780347 8, ,3 8:..4397,.9 47,77,30203947,3 .4397,.9 47 ,77,302039 039070/ 394 - 47 03 -0,1 41 90 425,3 9 ,3

425,3 47 5,7930785 41 47 3 . ,370.947 8, -0 , 202-07 47 49078039070890/-0,;4/0/3478,,3 70.94784 .4397,.9347-038:.202-07478439070890/-0,-094,..4:399490425,3147,35741970,80/-,38:..4397,.947 ,77,302039-70,843418:.70.947 4/39,9411.047 41901/:.,770,9439070-089,-80/-:9903,9:70418 39070892:89-0/8.480/-2,9902009341 9070.9478 ,9 . 90 .4397,.9 47 ,77,302039 8 /0907230/ 431 839070899030898473,34907.,80,9901789200934190 70.9478,190790,.6:894341 8 3907089 574;/0/ 30;0790088 9,9 34 70.947 8, ;490 3 70850.9 41 ,3.4397,.93.088439070890/,3/10/4;4908;4908,349-0.4:390/

970,7/94908,/80.943,3/908,/,79.0946:089438,;0,7803%01789 8 0907 3 90 .4397,.98 43 -0,1 41 90 425,3 9 $,9,7,: 90 3//0103/,39 ,/ 8:. 3907089 47 .43.073 ,8 -73 9 93 90 20,33 41 9480

47/83908,/80.94347,79.03/80.43/090710,/8:.3907089908,20,8,8,1,.9/8.480/

01470 574.00/340;0794 3/.,902 ;0 9 70,7/94 90806:08943892:89-04-807;0/9,9905,39118,;0340702,/0,.,7041343/8.48:70,8,5,7941907.,708,8,,389903//0103/,3947,85,794190.,:8041,.943%0 .,70 3 8:. .,808 -03 70, 9,9 90 70.947 -03 :3/07 , 89,9:9474-,943 94 /8.480 8 3907089 // 349 /4 84 90 ,;072039 2:89 349 43 3.:/0,0,943 41 08903.0 41 8:. 3907089 -:9 ,84 90 1,.9 47 ,0,943 41 343/8.48:70473490747/890-70,.41904-,9430,730/-74907,8-0033.30/949,090;09,9390,-803.041,38:.,0,943906:08943/408349,78094-0.438/070/&3/4:-90/94:/-08410,/4394/49$0.943, :9 9070 8 ,84 79.0 ,-4;0 7010770/ 94 ,3/ 9 80028 94 20 9,9 ,;370,7/9490,3:,0419,9,79.00390.,7041,70.947-0339070890/3,.4397,.98 2,/0,,389290-:7/038 0,89432 418439,90.4250/9 90 574;84 - /8.483 8 3907089 ,3/ 90701470 -0.,20 03990/ 94 9022:39;03-90,79.0

3:2-07 41 .,808 ,;0 -003 6:490/ -01470 :8 9 70,7/ 94 ,9 .43899:9083907089939020,33418:.,7:092,0307,-08,/,3/.438/079:330.088,7947010794,90.,808439054399,990384:798,;0843,/893.9;0903/03.9470,7/,350.:3,7 3907089,8.423939020,3341

Page 18: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 18/21

9005708843390708939080.94319028.0194-0574;/0/,,389 -8:.,7:0 -0 9,9 3470.947 4 8 3, 1/:.,7 548943 9 70,7/ 94 90 425,384:/-70,8434183907089349-03,54894394-7394-0,743,/0.843970,7/94,6:089439,9.4208:5-01470904,7/,1700,3/1,723/94:9,3-,847570:/.090398002894209,70850.99490023039:/089,90;0370,94385 8:. ,8 9,9 41 1,907 ,3/ 843 47 :8-,3/ ,3/ 10 47 ,3 82,7 -43/

84:/-070,7/0/,8.4257003/-9005708843892,-09,9,;370,7/9490 38 .43/9438 90 39075709,943 41 90 05708843- 38 4:798 2, -079-:914725,79,;370,7/94900307,,3:,002540/390$9,9:90,3/90 4-;4:8 28.01 9 83903/0/ 94!74;/0 ,,389 ,;0;07 990089,943 3.43.:/3 9,9 , 70,94385 ,8 9,9 41 , :8-,3/ ,3/ 10 2:89 -0 70,7/0/ ,83907089190.7.:289,3.080708:.9,992,70,843,--070,7/0/,8.,5,-041,110.939070.9478/0.843 14725,79,2:3,-09470,7/903907089,2,3,839013,3.,574850794188434710,8088.,5,-04131:03.38

 :/20399,3854880883507,58,82,8,703,34907425,341.08,70.947,2,,709,998;0412302,-070,7/0/,8-03390900941842,3:/20398410,730/:/083384:798-:9,840;07905439,8349-00330.088,7147/090723,9431092,-0,9-07994;005708843942;02,,844-807;09,9,8,2,9907412070050703.084:/,;0;07990

089,943389,939,9841,7,85,7908398.4:397,70.43.0730/94:/2,034/110703.09490247907543941;00907 ,2,3,85:7547939403907394,.4397,.943843-0,14743-0,141810

,;090701470.4209490.43.:843398.,809,943906:089430907903//0103/,39,/47,/349,3 3907089398.4397,.93.:/3902479,00,/8:.3907089

:9,;3.4209498.43.:84334/4:-9904-,943144897010703.09479.0418-03-4:3/94/8.4808:. 3907089

870,7/840;07906:0894309079070,847,83498:./8.48:70

,206:,8,9810/9,99070,834300/1478:./8.48:70-0.,:80,;370,7/9490.7.:289,3.08,;034/4:-99,98:. 3907089,80,/390.4397,.9,8034394,9070.9478,3/9070147090.7.:289,3.08//349.,147,34;079,.941/8.48:7043905,7941903//0103/,39398.4330.943906:089437,80/,3/ .438/070/- 90407 4:792,-0 7010770/ 94 0907 14790 5:75480 41902479,0 9 ,8 30.088,7 94 4-9,3 90 8,3.943 41 9070.9478 ,3/ 0907 9080.709,70890280;08,/9079947,398:.,2479,088:23,89,8-00314:3/ 90 80.709,708 ,/ 8:. 5407 ,5,79 1742 9070.9478 ,2 .0,7 41 90453439,913,2,99073.9080.709,708,/9054079030;0790088494 9070.9478 147 90 5:75480 41 897039033 90280;08- 4-9,33 8,3.94390.42093904507,94341$0.943 ,,3/,8479.0%08094574;8438,70349.43130/43942,990783.908,3.943419070.9478830.088,7:99843706:70/9,99020093419070.9478,9.90/8.48:708706:70/94

-02,/084:/-0430,9.90.4397,.947,77,3020398/0907230/43,3/9,98:3/4:-90/98.,80-:9989,3/894.4224380380,3/9,8-0030/390.,8041489,#.,#49/;4744/# % %# ,3843 9,9 070 90 70, 3,9:70 41903907089834394,9070.9478907083430.0889942,0,1472,/8.48:70,;370,7/9490.7.:289,3.0810034/4:-99,9,9070.94785708039,9902009370,7/0/9089:,943,8-0333480380/11070391742,.4397,.9-903//0103/,39 2801 49 43 ,8$,9,7,: 8 10-:9 0907 90540741,994730,8343473499,8.0,79,90,8,.93,807,039370850.941902,9907

Page 19: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 19/21

100 34 /4:-9 3 223/ 9,99070.9478 2:89 ,;0 70,7/0/ 90 .4397,.9 3908,209,819070,.4397,.9-903//0103/,392801

79.0 ,4870.9478 90280;08 94 03907 394 .4397,.98 9 90 425,3,3/9070147090708346:089434190;,/9418:..4397,.98574;/0/90574;848.,770/4:9,3/90/8.48:7082,/0%0 343/8.48:708349.,70/,3/0;03

94:,8.438/0790-:7/0341574414190/8.48:70418:..7.:289,3.084:/-0439070.947 .43.0730/89390.7.:289,3.084190.,80 ,28,9810/9,98:. 3907089 ,8 90 3/ /0103/,39 ,/ ,8 343 ,3/ 8:11.039 /8.480/ 94 9070.947814725,79,25493.30/94.438/070;03901,.99,9 ,834,00/94,;0-0032,/0-$,9,7,:,990920;3,07089,90,3/574507994903//0103/,394:/2,0,3/110703.0:/2039-0394900110.99,9903049,9438970,7/9490.4397,.92:89,;0-003.,770/43,3/90.4397,.99801039070/ 394 ,81 9 ,8, .4397,.9- 90 /0103/,39 2801 9 80028 9420 9,9 346:08943,780847.,3,78043,374:3/8:.,89,990/0103/,39//349/8.48083907089

2,398.4330.943,847010794,3//8548041,3490754399,9,87,80/,3/ ,7:0/ 9 70,7/ 94 9 9 ,8 ,7:0/ 9,9 ,1907 90 89 41 ,7.

/0103/,398 48 ,3/ .0,80/ 94 -0 80.709,708 0, ,3/ 9,9 90701470 , 905,20398 2,/0 - 902 94,7/8 90 2479,0 8:-806:039 94 9,9 /,90 84:/ -047/070/94-0705,/-9029490425,3390 -,8843.904074:79,8/0,9990406:08943985439/408349,780-0.,:801439040345,2039,8-0032,/094$,9,7,:24709,380,803990/94174290425,39070.4:/,;0-0033448847/,2,09490425,35,79174298,94090798 .0,7 1742 90 0;/03.0 9,9 ,/ -003 ,//:.0/ 47, ,3/ /4.:2039,7 9,9 900307, -4/ 41 8,704/078 90280;08 7,910/ 90 .4393:,3.0 3 90 411.0 41/0103/,398 48 ,3/ ,8 80.709,708 %0 6:08943 8 349 84 2:. 430 41 90/0103/,398,;347349,;3-00380.709,708-:9190,/5:754790/94,.9,890,03984190425,3,3/,88:.,0398/0,9990243084190425,39,83.:2-0394390425,33499470.43808:./0,3847947,91907.4393:,3.0

3 411.0 9 80028 94 20 ,;3 70,7/ 94 90 7024903088 41 98 6:08943 9 8:330.088,7 94 0,230 3 /09,90 0;/03.0 3 90 .,80 1 90701470 ,3 6:0894384:/,780970,7/9490805,20398,;3-0032,/0 -90/0103/,39894:9574507,:9479 ,8 ,0398 90 43 13/3 3 .43843,3.0 9 90 0;/03.0 4:/ -09,990070;79:,349430/4:9-90425,3-:9,40/-90425,394.4393:094,.9,880.709,708

90701470 ,7003 90.43.:8439,9970,7/ 94902479,047 90 /0-98. -0.,20 2070/ 394 9 9070 8 34 ,-9 94 90 425,3 43 90 5,79 41 90/0103/,398

345,88439490.438/07,9434190.,70970850.9949017890,809,831,;4:741430,,2$:-7,2,3,2,;070,9/11.:93:3/0789,3/3900,.9

13/3841904074:79970,7/94982,9907,3/,8490.43.:843:92,90,77;0/,9%04074:79,82,/0/0103/,39848,3/,-0370850.941980,80147,949,8:241%074:3/43.9842,/0,-04:/,550,794-0,81448%00,730/897.9:/013/89,9903//0103/,39,/3450.:3,7390708939097,38,.943,3/09.42089490.43.:8439,90,/8:. 3907089,80,8-4:3/94/8.4809,90//349/4849,9084:/907014702,044/904888:89,30/-90425,3,3/9,98:.48884:/-020,8:70/-907,9041#8 . ,8 ,77,30/ - 90 3/ /0103/,39 2801 9 70,7/ 94 905,7930785 9,9944 4;07 900,80 ,8-03 90 70,843,-0 7,90 507 5:99 41.49943

Page 20: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 20/21

,2:3,-094,700990.43.:843,77;0/,9-900,730/897.9:/03904:79 -049,9903/ /0103/,39 ,/3413,3.,39070893902,990798.0,71742900;/03.09,93905,79307859,9,8-74:939408903.0147905:7548041 90 0,80 , 3:2-07 41 5078438 070 8 43 .70,9:708 %0 ,77,302039 41 905,79307858574;0/94,;0-0032,/03904:8041903//0103/,392801,3/:3/078/70.9438,3/8438438,/2990/94,;04-9,30/540741,9947301742

903423,08800:94;07,3/,-4;0,9898.0,71742900;/03.09,9147985,79307859057419807094-0.,.:,90/434390-,8841#8-0370,7/0/,890.,7085,,-09490425,3&3/07900,8090,24:39,700/94-05,/9490425,3,843#8%0-,,3.041#88349,..4:390/147,9,,3/907083447/4105,3,943,8944,8949,098/110703.041#84749-0.,2094-010/ ,;034/4:-93223/,9988:241#8 5075:9970570803989,9,8,700/ 9443949054.0941903//0103/,391 ,8,8-0038:0890/ ,9 90 -,7 98 8:2 41 #8 ,8 ,84 94 -0 , 9,03 - ,,2$:-7,2,3,29070,83470,84388,7039057419884:/,;0-00310/,98:.,41:70,3/905745078,7084:/349,;0-00310/3.:8;041908:241#85075:99,849908,20920,2349:3,,7041901,.99,990708 34 /70.9 0;/03.0 9 70,7/ 94 90 3/ /0103/,39 ,;3 9,03 98 57419 9 840;07,;370,7/9490.7.:289,3.0825488-094050.9905,391189497,.0

,3/ 574;0 8:. 574198 %0 ;07 08803.0 41 2,3 8:. 574198 8 98 80.70. ,3/8:-903088

&3/0779.094:,70.9478,40/94,;0,339070893,3.4397,8947,77,302039099843.43/943418/8.483903,9:70418390708918490-:7/03 41 ,;3 8,9810/ 90 .43/943 08 :3/4:-90/ 43 9070.947 03 43013/8 90 3/ /0103/,39 9,3 8:. 097,47/3,7 3907089 3 2,3 , 90,77,3020398,-4:9900,8038434:802,38843902,475,7930798,33,88,70,3/9008800,,2$:-7,2,3,2,5,7930743914:7,3/,,1,33,88,70,3/34970,,..4:393 14790/110703.041 #89 825488-0947088990 .43.:8439,99070 ,8, .4397,.9 3 .0,/, 8:-89,39, 3907089939020,33419080.9434790,79.0,3/9,994::3/07,34-,94394

/8.480908,200//349/48490701470,7009,994:4374:3/8/110703994 9480 9,9 ,550,0/ 94 90 0,730/ 897.9 :/0 3 90 4:79 -04 90 3//0103/,39,85745072,/0,-09490425,3

:9,870,7/890,24:399.,343-0147908:22,/0:5 -.,.:,93,9#85075:99370850.941905:9908,.9:,470/3902043147#8%0/0.70041904074:7984:/90701470-024/10/-8:-899:93#8147#8

9 70,7/ 94 , 90 4907 2,99078 3 , 90 ,550,8 ,700 03970 9 90.43.:84384120,730/-74907

39490/110703.04145343-09003:843900,804190/0.70041

904074:79439,92,9907570;,0.0599,990,24:3941#8-070/:.0/94#894:89/0103/,39,8349,550,0/98.0,79,990/0.7008 41 90 407 4:79 ,,389 2 3 90 2,9907 41 90 3907089 43 4,38 #8,3/3902,990784190/8,4,3.041.4228843,3/908:7.,734190 920-,770/ /0-98 0.059 90 9028 850.10/ 3 90 570.0/3 5,7,7,5 ,88:7.,70,-0 433/ /0103/,39.,3349 43 90 13/38 -02,39,30/ %0 ,24:394190/0.70043900,8041 ,843 8.,80-070/:.0/1742#894#8 %0 309 708:9 8 9,9 90 57023,7 /0.700 41 90 407 4:79 824/10/,-3807939$05902-073890,/4189,7.3,:80

Page 21: Rao Bahadur Judgment

8/3/2019 Rao Bahadur Judgment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rao-bahadur-judgment 21/21

-,9073,:80,81448147#838079#8,3/4291742,3/#899003/4190.,:80,3/9,99013,/0.700824/10/,42993,:80-89734:9842:.41,:80,870,908949090241#8,3/.-8:-899:93147901:70#8,3,:80908:24190284,3/39042288430788941770.4;07,-090285:8#8870,7/8.489890/0.700857023,7,3/13,41904074:79,70

24/10/,814483-49/0.70089847/070/0,.5,795,843.4898

870,7/890,550,8$48,3/,70/82880/,3/5,391185,/0103/,398.489839080,550,8870,7/83//0103/,398,550,890,7024/10/,83490/,-4;0,3/5,39118708543/03985,,19,0/.4,9894,550,393-49

,3:5,97,31472,943$4:9438!;99/

494945