ravi satulo laicer, a096 675 284 (bia jan. 15, 2014)

8/13/2019 Ravi Satulo Laicer, A096 675 284 (BIA Jan. 15, 2014)

1/13

LAICER, RV SATULOA096-675284BUTLER COUNTY JAIL701 SE TONE ROADEL DORDO, KS 6704

Name: LAICER, RAV ATULO

Executive Oce r Immgraton Reew

Bord of Imigrtion AppelsOce of he Clerk

507 Leeb Pke Ste 2000Falls Chuc, Vrgina 0530

HSCE Oice of Chef Counsel - KAN2345 Grad lvd., uite 500Kansas Ci, MO 64108

A 096675284

Date o ths otce /10

cosed is a cpy of the Bar's decso a order n the aboe-reerence case.

ncosure

P b:M Hh G

Sincerel,

D cDona Carr

Che Cerk

g k

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished

Cite as: Ravi Satulo Laicer, A096 675 284 (BIA Jan. 15, 2014)


2/13

US. Depamen of JusceExecutive Oce r Immiaton Revew

Deiso of the Bord of mmto Appel

F Curh, Vg 0530

e A096 67 284 Knsa Cy, MO 1

In re: RV SAL LCERIN REMOVAL PROCEEDINGS

APPEAL

ON BEHA OF ESPONDENT Pro se

ON BEHA OF DS:

CHARGE:

Jefer . MayAsssan Ce Conse

Dae: JAN 1 a 204

Noce Sec 237(a)(2)(A)), &N Ac [8 .S.C 227(a)(2)()()] -Convced of aavaed felony

APPLICATON Removably connance reef om reoal

The resoen, a nave of Inda and czen o Tanzana, apeas om he Aus , 203,decson of he Imgrao de, whch und he responde reovable a chared, und hmnebe r reef o remova eed hs reques r a conance, d orere h removed

he respondes appea ll be ssseWe reew r cear eor e ns of c, ncludn e eenaon of credbly,

made by he mraon Jue. 8 C.F 003(d)(3)(). We reew e novo a oer sses,ncln wheher he pes have me he relean brden of proof, nd ssues o dscreon8 C.FR 003 {d)(3)()

We f he Imraon Juesdecson. he mraon Jude properly und heresponen reovabe as chaed uder secon 237(a)(2)(A)() of he mmraon and

Naonay Ac (c) 8 .S.C. 227(a)(2)(A)(), as a aen convced of an aravaelony under secon (a)(43)(F) o he Ac, 8 SC 0(a)(43)(F) (.. a 2, 6-7 Exh. ).

We aree ha he respondens March 9, 202, convco r e oense of aravaed baeryn volaon o 2344(a)(2)(A) of he ansa Saes (S.A) r whch he was senenced o3 monhs of mprsonen, s caeorcal a crme o olence under 8 SC. 6(a) and (b(. a 1-2 6-7 xh 2 f a 2; Tr. a 48)

nder S.C 6(a), oense s a crme of volence "ha an eeen he se,atemped use, or heaened use of physca rce aans he erson or propery of anoher. Seealso Maer of Velasquez, &N Dec. 278, 283 (BA 200) (hysca rce s be he

e proceedns bere he Iaon ude n i aer ere coeed n Kn CityMssor oh vdeo conferece san o seco 240(b)(2)(A)() o he Ac, 8 SC.

229a(b)(2)()() Cite as: Ravi Satulo Laicer, A096 675 284 (BIA Jan. 15, 2014)


3/13

0 284

intentiona use of voent rce at is capable of causing pysica pain or injury to anotherperson). The language o K.S.A. 1-3414(a)(2)() denes he oense o aggravated batery aseckessy casng ea bodiy h to another person or dsgement of other person (.J. at6). Bodiy h has been dened as any touching of the victm aganst he victim's will with

physica rce in an intentional ostile and aggavated m er. State v. Dbish 675 d 877,715 (984) The word "eat distinguishes the body hm necessary om slight, rivial, mnoo oderate ha, and as such it does no incude mere bruises whch are liely to be sstainedin simpe bate. Id Fher the ter disguement is a ctua circumstance that proves"great bodiy h ae v. Uleas 95 P3d 1020, 1035-36 (013) ecause e stauteunder which e respondent was convicted requires he use of volent rce that s capabe ofcasing physical pan or injry to anohe we a he Imation Judges deteination ata vioaton of KSA 21-3414(a)(2)(A) is a crme of volence uder 8 U.S.. 16(a).

Similarly we agree wth te mmgration Judge that a violation of .S.A 2 344(a)(2)(A)is aso a crime o vioence nde 18 U.SC 16) whic incles y oher oense that s a

ony d at by its naure, nvoves a sbsantia is that pysica rce against the person orpropery of anoter may be used in the cose o commiig the oense (.J. at ). Thesbstantial risk efeed to in 16(b) "relates not to he gener condct or to e possibilty thath wl resut om a person's conduct, but to the rs hat the se of physical rce againstanother might be required in commiting a crime. Leca v Asc 53 U.S. I 0 (00).As noted above an oense nde KS.A. 34(a)(2)(A) which s a ony under Kansas anddera law reques he intent o use volent physical rce against the victim (J at 6-7Therere the respondent's convicon r aggravated baery der K.S.A. 2-344(a)()(A) is acategorca crime of violence under 8 US.C 16() d e is removabe as carged.

We dsagree with the respondent's contention that the Immigration Judge should have

anted him a contnuce because he ed a moton to wtdaw s plea with the criminal courwhic is pending (J. a 4 7 Exh. 5 Tr. at 47) A Immigration Judge may grant a continuance good cause shown. 8 C.F.R. 1003.29 1240 A decision o deny a moton rcontnance wi no e revesed uness the alen estabshes that he denial cased hm acuaprejudice and h and materay aected the outcome o his case Mae f llaealZniga3 l&N Dec. 88 (B 006); Mate fSibn 8 &N Dec. 35 356-57 (BIA 1983); Mae fPeez-Andade 9 I&N Dec. 433 (BIA 987).

Even if e respondent is seekng post-convction reief this Board has held that heavaiability of post-convction motions do no serve to negate he naity of eciina convicion or the charge o emovabliy uness and unt te conviction has beenovered pursuant to sch a moton (Tr. at 49, 53). See Mate f Onyid 22 &N Dec. 55555 (BI 1999); Mate f Madigal-Calv 1 &N Dec. 323 (BIA 99) Moreove e ot go behnd the udcal recd to deterine the gul or iocence o an alien See NS vLpezMendza 8 U.S 03 1039 (198) ( mmgraton dge canno addcae guMatte f - 1 &N Dec. 90 904 (IA 997); Madigalalv spa Theee, heIgration Judge appopriaey und tha the resondent did not demonstrate good cause towaant a continuance (J. at 7-8).

The respondent also arges hat he, an alege religios preache ars reng to Ta(Tr. at 58) The Immigraton udge nd however tha he espondent does no qual r



4/13

0 784

wioig of remova d proeco uer he Coveo gas Toe becuse heesed h he had o o pesecuio o oure by e govee Tai (J 7 Tra 3 8 Furer e aee he mmgraio Juge ha he respoes er s oogeezed o cosue reasobe e of e of persecio or oure (Tr a 8 Seeed v Goles 437 F3 70 73 (8 Ci 200 (a shoig o eso d coicbeee Musms Csas i doesi oe s iscie o show persecuo Whiehe respode aso cms h az nd wada e o he bri of r hrm sg omgee codos such as cy cv wr or mob voece o ordy uppor cmof pesecio See ohmed v sco 3 F.3d , 003 (8h C 200 ccordigy, heowg orde be eere

RDE The respoes appe is dsissed

THE BD

3



5/13

UNITED STATS DPARTMT OF JSTC

EXECUTIVE OFFIC OR IMMGRAT RVIWUNITD STTS MMGRATO COURT

SAS CIY, MSO

File: A096-675-284

In th Mater of

ugust 15 3

VI SATULO LAICER)))

)

MOL ROC

RESPONDT

CHARES Scio 23()(2)()(iii) of the mmigrtio nd atioi ct (ct)at ay tie er admissio aie convicted o n ggrvtd lonas efied i ectio 01(a)(3)(F) of the Act cri o vioenc(s efied i ection 16 of Tite 1 itd ttes Cd but otcudig purey poitica oese) r which ter oiprisoet orderd is t east oe yr.

LCTO otion for a cotiuce

O BELF OF RESPODT PRO S

O BEHAF OF HS JF Y3 Grd Bouevrd uite 500Ksas City isouri 610

ORAL CSO OF TH MMGTO JGTh eoe i a 0-yer-od divorced mae ntiv of di d citiz

of Tzai who is a a peraet residt o the Untd Sttes O y 1

th respodet as covcted i the district cou o edgwick Couty Knss or h

oy oense aggrte ery i ioatio of K Scion -3 or which a


6/13

eece of 31 mont wa mpoe

O Je 9 201 te Depamen of Homea ecurty H or

Depatmet) persoally see a Noce to Apea cha responent wth remoal

une ecto 2a2)A of the ato a Natoay Ac Act) a ote

aboe The Notce to Appear wa fle wt the Kaa Cty Immraton Co tatn

emoa poceen o une 24 203 ee xbt 1

At a mate calear earn on Je 27 2013 te espoent

acknowlede proper sece of te oce to Appea H h were explae to m

a wel a te cae of remoa. The repoent equeted a contnance for

atonal tme to obtan repreentato by a aoney and h wa rane by te

Cou At the mate eet earn on Jly 8 2013 the reponent aeared befre

te Co wtou an aoey a cae e d ot ae an attorney to epeent

m Te repoent admted factal alleaton tro 4 contaned n te Notce to

ppear non n aleaton 2 a e a nae of Ina Te repondent d eny

alleaton 5 contane n te otce to Apea tat e a been concted of anaraated batey une Kana law becae he beee e wa no oery

conced of tat oense Te reondent ao dene tat he ad been concted of a

crme of oence araaed felony a chared n te otce o Appear.

Becase te reonent a been amted to te Unte tate frt a a

en and en alo beqently ajte tat to hat of a afl ermanent

esdent te Depaent of Homelan ecrty m poe by cea and conncn

eence tat te espondet ubjec to emoal a chae No econ on

epoablty al be ald nle t bae pon reaonabe sbtatal an

probate eence ecto 240c)(3)(A) of e Act The Depament preented

docmenta eence ppo of the ene alleaton an chae of emoal

A096-675-284 August 15, 03


7/13

Tese documes ncludethe cefedcovcon record cudig he

omplaifrmato, te respodent'sappcato to adjust status on Form 1-485 whc

was approved Augs 8, 2008 ad he responden's documets from the respodes

Tanzana passpo ncludng hs stdet vsa and other dentfng inmaton. See

xhbi ab A og C, page og 8. Te Depame ao le

ppemea ocmen clung he Kaa aue une wch he epoen wa

convce fo agavae baey pua o Kaa ae aoae eco -

3 xhb 3 ab D pae 9 The eponen objece a he fnal heag ohe Depame' uppemea ocmen a ab D becae e wa o popely

covce Tha i becae e beeve he wa o popey conce of agaae

baey The Co oe fin e Depame' ocme maeal a eeva o e

e bee e Co, a, eeoe amible The ocmen wil heefoe be

amie no he eco.

The epamen ao fe a econ ppemena packe of ocmen

icling he epoen wae o h an acknoweemen ha he a bee

avie pan o Paia ha h cmna cae may impac h Immaon aThe packe ao ncle he ancip of he epoe' gy plea, a e a he

acp of enencin Te Depame fle eco elaing he epoe'

appeal an eqe fo pocovicion elie, a a ana cae ae v Loe

bme fo he popoio a valag ava e n eck Coy, aa

wie plea ageeme ae cie o a ala ee xhibi 4, a oh I

page 0 hough 73 e epoen ao obece o xhbi e ackowege e

ocmen eae o hm an ha he i e peon ame i he ocmen H

objecon eae o e way he wa covce coue neecie aace on

behalf of h cimial cone The Co ao fn hee ocmen maeal an

A665-284 3 Augu 5 23


8/13

reeva o e ssues a mus be decdd b e Cour and as admed e

docuens no record as Exb

An alen convced of an aggravaed felon a an me aer admsso s

oa. Te agaa eo s d o a4 o

To deermne weer a acular convcon s an aggravaed felon e Cou frs

appes he "caegorca aproac ookng onl o e sauo defnon of e oense.

If e sauor defnon of e oense of convcon s broader an e dfnon of he

relea removal oense e Cou aples a "modfed caegorcal aroac n an

aem o dermn e conduc for wch he defendan was acual coved

Under e modfd caegorca aroac e Cour ooks eond e langua of e

saue o a narrow se of documes a are par of he recor of convcon orer o

deermneweher e conduc r wc e alen was convced consues an

aggravae felony. ee g n raly S pard v Une tat s 5 U 3 005.The erm convon means w resec o an alen a forma uen

of gul of e alen enered by a cour or f aucaon of gu ha een whel

were a uge or ur as found e alen ul or e alen as nere a lea of uly

or noo coener or has amed sucen fas o warran a fng of u a he

uge as ordere some form of enalty unshmen or resran on e alen's lery o

be mosed Any referece o a erm of mrsomn of a seence w resec o an

oense s deemed o clue e erod of narcerao or conmen ordere y e

Cour regardless of an susenson of he moso or execuon of a mrsonmen

of senence n wole or n a ee econ a8.

n s case e resonden as fled wh e Dsrc Cour of Sedgwc

Coun ansas a "moo o wdraw lea fed o Jul 7 03 n case numer

3CV3 In e resondens moon o wdraw e lea n s case e argues

A09665-284 4 August 5 203


9/13

e was no a prop actual bass o th pa The spondent also conends s

counsel was eeciv because e was o adised hat his convicto could constte

an aggavated felo hs counsel gnored is desie to plea o a misdemeanor and go

to al, and ms e esonen as o he bl o e t as am

othe clams. H povded e Cour w a 59 page ax o his motion. ee Exibt 5

Th rspodet ndicates ta thee has no yet been a hearng set in he Sedgwick

County Distc Co elaing o his moo to withdaw is plea The esponde does

ot know the me fram, but believes he Dsct Cour judge canno make a decsion

on the moto wthout havng fst a hearing o te post-convction moo convicto

is fnal or Immgation prposes unless a unl h espondets convction s vacated

or he moion o wthdaw the plea is ganed s the respondent's convcto sands

eoe he Court toda hs covcton s ial fr Immgraton prposes pursuant to

Section 0(a)(48) o the ct

crime of volence aggravated felony s defi in 8 US C Secton 6

to ncude: () a oese that has as a eemet te use atempte use or treatene

use o physcal ce against a person o propey of aothe o (2) any other oense

tat s a elo a that by ts nature nvolves a substantal rsk that physcal orce

aganst te pso or popty o anoter may use n te cous o comtn te

onse. The Supreme Cou of the United States has held that a "crme ofvolnce

requies a higher mns reathan erelyaccidental or nelent conduct. L ocal vAshcof, 54 US 1 (204).

Te epamnt has sente the statue aggavated battey uner

whic th esponet was convicted The crminal convction ecords contaed at

Exhibt 2 page 1 do ndcate hat th espondent as covcted uner sbsecton 21-

344(a)(1)() r intentionally causing great oily harm to another peson or

A096675-284 5 Augus 5 203


10/13

dsurmet o oth so owev th sodts rmet s wl

s udmt t o Exhbit 2 do dict tht cout 1 th count the

esod ws cnvced o ws mendd om rvtd bry sevey v 4

ony to v bte eey eve 5 eony n oon t the e e

or sctio or th Cout to vw is 21414)2)A) eckssy cusin rat

body h o nhe erson or disume o other rso dto, th

ckss mes r ws mto n th trnscrit o he ui Th Cou dos

ind t the ckss mes is sucint o de cme o voenc rvatd

eony ht t rsonns ons dos hve n eemnt o te use o hysc

oc inst s w, M Lc or h sondn to be convc o his oense h

hd to cus rt bodily hm. Dmt s resented he e rmet s

we s th sencin documt n Exib 4 tb whch dscb th hysc ce

t was use

Even the esoden's oens s ot cm o vioence s escibe

n Scon 6 o he Act t is so n oens ta s eony n y s ne nvoesh susni s o ysca orce st erson or ory o noh my b

use n e cours o comm e oense For Seion 6b) t s ecessa o

exmn he cma conuc equrd convcton rer an he conseqe o e

crim o n the oens by i nu voves e sustn rs t hysc orce

my be used n couse o commtn te oense Te resonen n e e

nce he os conto o hs t n hi his ie n t is y he s u o

body h. The trnscrt o he so ndices tht rsonden kc hs

ie, d so h some so o ss which sousy cut er y Troe e

Court dos t resodnts crmi covcon consiutes rved

eony cme o volenc rviewn th documens subm by h Dement

A066584 6 Augs 15, 201


11/13

inluing he covction ecods as wel as he ote oues n his ase, he

espone ws sentene o 1 onts iaeain, and heefre, he erm of

ipisne ipose is a eas e yea as eque Theefe he Cut oes

ssain aego and he hage o emova unde Setin (a(iii

he esonden has esigae Tazaia an iiae tha he ha o

fear o any peseuion o toue if he eus hee weve he espnden oes

have wo Ued ates izen aughers e wats o have the oppouiy to emain

in he Uite ates as thei fate Te aughtes at oe tie were i state stdy

but ae now apaenly i the usoy f his wife fom whm he beleves he is ivored

Te espondet was senene o 1 months in a and dd se a leas 1 mohs of

that seened ipse the Kansas Deaent Cretins he resnent

es have his moher and bohe in Tazania bu hs faer aparely is eease

Te respondet is a awful ermanen resen f the Unte taes oever beause

he has been ne f an aggaate ey he s nt elgie eqes anelan

remal a eanent resident rsuan Sen 240a f te Te esonden equess a fuer nnane f his emal reeding

in rer f he Distrt Cu f edgik Couny t nsier is min hdra his

plea ased n ineeie assistane f unsel and the lak a rper faal

fndatin fr is plea The Deamen is psed a her onnane as the

resnden is detained and does no ave any ele r ema. The itin s

final r mgra rses n mgain Jdge may grant a fuher nnane

f go ase shown 8 C. FR Section 10029 In his ase, the Cou oes n find

god ause for a futher inuane The espnen does t ye have any hearig

dae on he ostonvition oion set n Sedgik Cn. n addtn e Depame

has e a nube f dumes with he Cou shw that he resondent was

A9665284 August 15 203


12/13

avse of he Imgao cosequeces of is gul lea See Exhibi 4 age 24

Te resone aes ssue wi ha a of cose e Cou oes no now wha wil

ae in he Dsic Cour of Segwick Cou on hs ssue However ae reviewg

a o he umes e eamet e e o s ssue a ag no time frame

o know whe e cimil cou will make a ecisio he Cou oes o f goo

ause f a fue coiuance

Ae conseig e eco oai he onl ore he Cou a ee

oa s a ode o remova o Tazan e Cout w eseve aeal r e

esonen o all e issues in his ase

ODES

ORDER The esoen's moi fo coniuace ene

FURTER ODER Te esonen is oee emove frm e Une Saes o

Tazana o he age onane he Noice o Aear

A096675-284

PALA V DAVISmmigraon ue

8 August 15, 203


13/13

CERTIFCAE PAGE

I ereb cetfy tat he atached proceeg bere JUG PAULA V. DAVS

e ate o:

RAV SALO LACER

A096-675284

KANSAS CY MISSO URI

as e as erei aeas, and tat ts s te rgna ranscrp ereo r e le f

e xecuve Ofce r migraon Review

SACY A SOBE (Transcibe)

POSO SRVS ln2

SETEBR 5 2013

(Compeon ae)

ravi satulo laicer, a096 675 284 (bia jan. 15, 2014)

Documents