real-world examples: perimeter protection documents/standards...real-world examples: federal and dod...

17

Upload: others

Post on 13-Jul-2020

15 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter
Page 2: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

Real-World Examples:Federal and DoD

Perimeter Protection

Basil J. SteeleSandia National Laboratories

A Summit on Perimeter SecurityAmerican National Standards Institute

Homeland Security Standards Panel

May 17, 2005

Page 3: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

3Perimeter Protection

What is a PIDAS?

P - Perimeter

I - Intrusion

D - Detection and

A - Assessment

S - System

Page 4: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

4Perimeter Protection

PIDAS

A mutually supporting combination of barriers, clear zones, lighting, and electronic intrusion detection, assessment and access control systems constituting the perimeter of a Protected Area and designed to detect, impede, control or deny access to the Protected Area (PA).

Page 5: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

5Perimeter Protection

“Hard” PIDAS Requirements

PA will be protected by a system using Protective Forces, barriers, and intrusion detection

Page 6: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

6Perimeter Protection

“Soft” PIDAS Requirements

Number of Sensors

Sensor types

Sensor layout

Zone width

Lighting type

Lighting placement

Camera types

Camera layout

Complimentary

Broad dynamic range, light limiting, 5 vertical scan lines

Page 7: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

7Perimeter Protection

User’s Performance Requirements Requirement Threat R N Comments

Unarmed Personnel X Do not want to detect unarmed personnel

Personnel with Weapons

X Can we discriminate between armed adversaries and workers with tools?

Personnel with Explosives

Personnel with Radioactive Materials

“Light” vehicles “Heavy” vehicles Trojan Horse vehicles

Early Detection/Assessment of Ground-Bourne Threats

Explosive vehicles Unarmed Personnel Personnel with Weapons

Detection/Assessment of Ground-Bourne Threats

Personnel with Explosives

Page 8: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

8Perimeter Protection

Performance

Sensor Characteristics

– Probability of Detection, Pd

– Nuisance Alarm Rate (NAR)

– Vulnerability to Defeat

Page 9: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

9Perimeter Protection

Exterior Sensor Technologies

Microwave

Ultrasonic

Active Infrared

Passive Infrared

Capacitance

Sonic

Vibration

Fiber Optics

Video Motion Detectors

Page 10: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

10Perimeter Protection

Features of a Good Barrier System

Provides delay after detection

Exhibits balanced design; no weak links

Uses delay-in-depth

Designed for maximum credible threat

Page 11: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

11Perimeter Protection

Schematic of Typical System

Sector Length Approx 75 m.

High PressureSodium Lights

CCTV

Protected Area

CADBox

PowerCabinetTaut WireMW

MWMW

IR

IR

IRIR

IRMW

Limited Area

Page 12: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

12Perimeter Protection

Soft Requirements

Sensor layout

Topography

Lighting layout

Camera layout

Design

Sensor types

Page 13: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

13Perimeter Protection

Exterior CBRN Detection Technologies

Chemical

Biological

Radiation

Medical Surveillance

Intrusion Detection

Etc.

Page 14: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

14Perimeter Protection

PSRS M-Star QUPID

LaserGuard CEDAR

SPIDER

Early Warning Detection

AES

Page 15: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

15Perimeter Protection

PSRS M-Star QUPID

LaserGuard CEDAR

SPIDER

AES

Page 16: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

16Perimeter Protection

PSRS M-Star QUPID

LaserGuard CEDAR

SPIDER

AESINTENT?

Page 17: Real-World Examples: Perimeter Protection documents/Standards...Real-World Examples: Federal and DoD Perimeter Protection Basil J. Steele Sandia National Laboratories A Summit on Perimeter

17Perimeter Protection

Summary

Questions and Answers

SN

L

ASIS

DOE UL

DoD

EquipmentPeople

Procedures

?

Basil J. Steele(505) [email protected] 0768Sandia National LaboratoriesP.O. Box 5800Albuquerque, NM 87185-0768