recent advances to the syntectonic model and its applicability to opal exploration along the...
TRANSCRIPT
Pan Gem Resources (Aust) Pty Ltd 2011
Copyright Dr. Simon R. Pecover, July 2011 Page 1
Pan Gem Resources (Aust) Pty Ltd Gemstone Exploration Across Australia
Recent Advances to the Syntectonic Model and its Applicability to
Opal Exploration along the Collarenebri Antiform
By
Dr. Simon R. Pecover
Managing Director
Pan Gem Resources (Aust) Pty Ltd
Abstract
Recent advances to the Syntectonic Model of opal deposit formation within the Great Australian Basin (GAB) have resulted
from a detailed study of micro-structural features evident in opal veins within gently warped interbedded sandstones and
claystones of the Angledool Antiform. This study has revealed opal vein textures that preserve repeated episodes of fluid flow
injection by viscous Non Newtonian fluids, hyper-saturated with amorphous silica.
The preserved textures within these opal veins also show evidence of repeated episodes of opal hardening and brittle fracture
deformation of earlier injected viscous fluids. These textures are interpreted to have been formed by multiple viscous opal fluid
injection and hydraulic extension fracturing depositional events, resulting from opalising fluid flows under pressure, moving
along progressively developing and evolving opal vein array systems.
Given the generally horizontal nature of the vein opal deposits studied, and their juxtaposition to facies change boundaries that
have been subjected to faulting, generating relay-zone ―flats‖ and ―ramps‖ fault architectures, then these deposits could be
classified as stratabound fault-controlled vein-type ore depositional systems.
From a regional perspective, the vein systems studied were found to mainly coincide with areas of high intensity faulting within
very specific parts of mapped antiformal and domal structures, where compressional dewatering of silica-rich clay facies
reservoir rocks appears to have provided highly localised sources of opalising fluid flows into nearby structural (i.e. both
tectonic and sedimentary) trap sites and vein systems.
The Syntectonic structural opal formational analogue and paradigm provided by the opal depositional environment of the
Angledool Antiform, has been applied to exploring the adjacent Collarenebri Antiform. Numerous structural targets have been
identified along the Collarenebri Antiform, where high intensity faulting, suitable opalising fluid-source reservoir rocks and
extensive silicification has been identified.
Introduction
Regolith genesis researchers have long advocated simple gravity-driven vertically-downward-moving
meteoric groundwater flows, as the principal mechanism for carrying dissolved amorphous silica to
depth across near-surface Great Australian Basin (GAB) sedimentary lithologies, with the resulting
opal deposits said to have been formed by the evaporation of silica-rich waters, passively residing for
millions of years in pre-existing open cavities. Additionally, some workers have even claimed a
dominant role for microbes in the precipitation of opalising silica, co-genetic with the deposition of
Cretaceous sediments across the GAB.
However, a new study of micro-structural geological features, preserved in opal veins formed after the
deposition of the Cretaceous sediments of the GAB, has revealed a complex range of textures that
preserve dynamic fluid flow and kinematic relationships that are interpreted to be indicative of multiple
episodes of viscous Non-Newtonian opalising fluid flows at relatively high pore pressures. Complex
patterns of intermixed potch and precious opal have been observed in some of the vein systems
studied, which suggests once vigorous, dynamic and turbulent fluid flows through vein networks,
flowing from areas of higher pore pressure to areas of lower pore pressure.
Pan Gem Resources (Aust) Pty Ltd 2011
Copyright Dr. Simon R. Pecover, July 2011 Page 2
Multiple episodes of opalising fluid injection, opal hardening and brittle fracture deformation, forming
complex in-vein opal breccias, is considered indicative of multiple generations of opal formation,
within a seismically active and vigorous fluid-flow-driven, hydraulic-extension-fracturing, Syntectonic
environment.
The vein systems studied, were found to be located in areas of high intensity faulting and fracture-
mesh development, within discrete lateral and vertical parts of the Angledool Antiform. The geological
setting of these vein opal deposits within the Angledool Antiform has now provided a suitable
analogue and paradigm for Pan Gem Resources and its joint venture partners, to progress opal
exploration across the nearby Collarenebri Antiform, and is considered to have applicability across the
entire opal prospective area of the GAB.
Core Tenants of the Syntectonic Model of Opal Formation in the Great Australian Basin
The ―Syntectonic Model‖ of Pecover (1996), advocates a core process in which the vein opal deposits
of the GAB were formed rapidly through a process of fault controlled, seismic-fluid-pumping and
hydraulic extension fracturing of host rocks, by silica-rich fluids derived from the compressional
overpressuring and dewatering/silica-stripping of silica-laden claystones, during antiformal buckling of
interbedded Cretaceous sandstones and claystones. The precipitation of opal from these silica-
super-saturated fluids is thought to have occurred through the polymerisation of dissolved silica,
which then formed viscous gelatinous silica/water mixtures hyper-supersaturated with colloidal silica
spheres.
The potential contribution of fluids to the sedimentary pile of the GAB, from other sources, including
hot artesian waters, is not excluded from the Syntectonic Model, and is supported by zirconium
mobilisation research work carried out at Macquarie University (Liddicoat 2003).
At its core, the Syntectonic Model conforms to the well understood processes by which most mineral
veins are thought to have been formed in nature. These processes typically involve hydraulic
extension of fractures that become filled with mineralising fluids which move along pressure gradients
within the structural architecture of the geologic system, with relatively rapid precipitation of minerals
occurring within these fractures, during periods of depressurisation, leading to mineral vein formation.
As processes of this type are commonly multi-cyclic, then it is not surprising that several generations
of mineralisation can occur within a given vein system.
Thus, the core geologic and structural tenants of the ―Syntectonic Model‖ of opal genesis in the GAB
(Figure 1), may be summarised as:-
Kinematic
In-Veins
Stress Controlled
Syntectonic
Geotectonic Setting of Opal Deposits along the Angledool Antiform
Opal mined across the Angledool Antiform commonly occurs as potch and much rarer precious opal,
in horizontal to sub-horizontal veins, interstitial infillings between mineral grains in some sedimentary
lithologies, isolated nodules, ironstone concretion cavity infill’s, and as pseudomorphic replacements
of fossil remains in generally clay-rich facies rocks.
At many widely-spaced locations along the Angledool Antiform, within the Narran-Warrambool Opal
Mining Reserve (Figure 2), potch and precious opal occurs in highly faulted and fractured Cretaceous
claystones and clayey sandstones. Fault and fracture-controlled deformation bands (known locally as
Pan Gem Resources (Aust) Pty Ltd 2011
Copyright Dr. Simon R. Pecover, July 2011 Page 3
―biscuit band‖) have also been found to be an important source of minable opal, at or close to the
surface.
Within the Reserve, the opal-bearing Cretaceous sediments have been gently warped into low,
generally NE-SW trending, ridges, forming low-amplitude antiformal and domal tectonic structures. In
many areas, opal-bearing country is commonly overlain by hard caps of silicified Tertiary sands and
gravels, which crop out as silcretes. In these extensively silicified areas, distinctive and discrete
mounds of silcrete rubble, are interpreted by experienced prospectors, to be the surface expression of
―blows‖, and are considered valuable surface indications of opal prospective country (Aracic 1996).
It is well known by experienced opal miners’ across the GAB, that there is an absolute and intimate
association between the location of faults and sites of opal deposition. Opal typically occurs close to
the hanging wall and foot wall sides of these faults.
Faulting observed in open-cut and underground exposures across the Angledool Antiform, exhibits
complex mixtures of fault types, including normal, reverse and oblique-slip faults, commonly arranged
in conjugate sets, resembling wedge-like structures that severely disrupt the "level". Faults cross-
cutting claystone "levels", may flatten appreciably, forming layer-parallel slip surfaces concordant to
bedding, particularly at the contact between sandstone and claystone. These layer-parallel slip
surfaces may be related to complex linkages within fault relay-zones, comprising horizontal fault
―flats‖ connected to nearby inclined fault ―ramps‖, forming discrete fault damage zones, in which
dilational and hydraulic extension fractures within the ―flats‖ host opal vein arrays. Such vein arrays
would be expected where slip surfaces show significant undulation, and a high degree of roughness.
When multiple fault relay-zones are arranged en-echelon to one another in areas of intense fault
clustering, opal veins may occur over considerable lateral distances, in a stepwise vein-array fashion.
In these sub-horizontal fault damage zones, complex layering and intermixing of bedding-parallel
brecciation, fault gouge and networks of opal veins collectively define the ―opal horizon‖. These
damage zones may also show significant horizontal to sub-horizontal slicken-sided surfaces,
indicative of prolonged fault movement. In some areas, the opal horizon may also be developed at the
base of a claystone unit immediately overlying a sandstone unit. This development of "top" and
"bottom" opal-bearing horizons may also be accompanied by the stacked succession of several opal
levels, each hosting opal mineralization at repetitive sandstone/claystone interfaces.
The fault and bedding-controlled vein systems within the Angledool Antiform, commonly exhibit
complex meshwork patterns of branching and anatomising veinlets, similar to those seen in fault-
controlled net-vein fracturing geological environments. The opal veins typically show pinch and swell
morphologies when viewed in cross-section. Lateral extent, like thickness, is highly variable and
ranges from small centimetre-scale pods to undulating vein arrays that can be traced over tens of
metres.
In all the opal fields occurring across the Angledool Antiform, extensive vertical fracturing of both
sandstones and claystones is evident. These vertical fracture sets resemble Hill-Type fracture
meshes, commonly developed in many parts of the world, where fluid flow, induced by seismic-fluid
pumping processes, has occurred in horizontally bedded sandstones and shales (Sibson 1987, 1989
& 1994).
Across the Angledool Antiform, these fracture meshes may be associated with normal and reverse
faults, which may also host brecciated stockworks and vertical pipe-like ―chimneys‖ of brecciation
(known locally as ―blows‖). These conduits provide evidence that fluids have travelled vertically
upwards under pressure through the sedimentary pile. This process has given rise to a variety of
geological structures, ranging from simple net vein fracturing of host rock lithologies, to angular clast-
supported jig-saw-fit breccias, to matrix-supported breccias with rounded clasts; with the latter
resulting from the prolonged fluidisation of the breccia column. While not all such breccia bodies have
Pan Gem Resources (Aust) Pty Ltd 2011
Copyright Dr. Simon R. Pecover, July 2011 Page 4
provided conduits for opalising fluids (as clearly, many breccias in GAB rocks are not silicified), those
that are indurated and hardened by significant amounts of amorphous silica, are more likely (in the
authors view) to be associated with areas of significant opal vein mineralization (Pecover 1996, 1999,
2003, 2005, 2007 & 2010).
The close association of those breccia pipes that display intense opal silicification and kaolinisation
with nearby opal vein arrays, suggests an important genetic link between breccia formation, fault and
fracture development, and significant lateral and vertically-ascending, opalising fluid flows.
Thus, given the generally horizontal nature of the vein opal deposits studied, and their juxtaposition to
facies change boundaries, that have been subjected to faulting that has generated significant ―flats‖
and ―ramps‖ relay-zones, then the opal deposits within the ―flats‖ could be classified as stratabound
fault-controlled vein-type ore depositional systems (Pecover 2010).
Recent Advances to the Syntectonic Model through the Study of Opal Vein Textures
To investigate the processes of opal vein formation in the GAB at the micro-scale level, samples of
opal veins comprising multiple generations of potch, as well as mixtures of potch and precious opal,
have been studied in detail.
This research has revealed a range of textures and features that demonstrate the dynamic processes
by which opalising fluids have deposited multiple generations of potch and precious opal into evolving
vein systems. This investigation also provides the basis for new lines of research into how viscous
opalising fluids have behaved to produce the myriad of opal patterns and textures encountered in opal
mines all across the GAB.
This research also supports the proposition, that the opal deposits of the GAB were primarily formed
during the Tertiary Period, by tectonically-driven near-surface fluid flow processes associated with the
antiformal warping, faulting and fracturing of water-saturated overpressured silica-rich clayey reservoir
rocks, within the upper sedimentary sequence of Cretaceous rocks making-up the GAB, as advocated
by the ―Syntectonic Model‖ of Pecover (1996).
Pan Gem Resources Opal Vein Research in the GAB
The following discusses the opal vein textural features identified during current opal genesis research
carried out by the Author, with the financial support of Pan Gem Resources (Aust) Pty Ltd.
Potch Opal Vein Textures
The opal vein textures studied, record histories of incremental and multiple episodes of opal
deposition via the injection of viscous opalising fluids. Earlier formed generations of opal in the veins
studied show evidence of hardening and subsequent brittle fracture deformation. Parallel and cross-
cutting relationships to previously formed veins were also found to be common, while fragments,
slivers and blocks of rotated wall rock clasts, incorporated into the composite structure of the veins,
resulted in complex wall rock and opal vein brecciation textures (Figure 3).
Complex patterns of cross-cutting, and vein-wall-parallel brittle-fracture micro-faulting, was also found
to be common in the veins studied. Small-scale dyke-like intrusions of opal, comprising fluidised
mixtures of both viscous and previously hardened opal clasts were found to occur along fractures in
previously hardened opal (Figure 4). Some of these micro intrusions show evidence of dissolution
and erosion/corrosion along the walls of the dykes, suggesting a vigorous and chemically corrosive
siliceous fluid flow environment, even at the micro level.
Pan Gem Resources (Aust) Pty Ltd 2011
Copyright Dr. Simon R. Pecover, July 2011 Page 5
Clear textural evidence for the viscous nature and Non Newtonian fluid flow behaviour of the opalising
fluids that formed the veins examined, can be seen where injecting fluids (now frozen) display
distinctive curved fluid-flow-front patterns of movement, resulting from fluid drag along vein and
internally intrusive micro-dyke walls (Figures 3, 4 & 5). Compelling textural evidence for turbulent
viscous fluid flow of once liquid opal, which has become hardened and then fractured in a brittle
manner through hydraulic extension fracturing, leading to new opal vein formation, can be seen in
Figure 6.
Composite Potch and Precious Opal Vein Textures
Evidence of complex and dynamic processes in the formation of opal in GAB rocks, can be seen in
opal veins displaying vein-wall-parallel stratification of both potch and precious opal. Particularly
intriguing are those veins that show ―colour bars‖ sandwiched between layers of potch (Figures 7 &
8).
In some of the veins studied, the colour bars were found to be composed of precious opal comprising
distinctive close-packed fibrous crystalline structures (Pecover 1996), consistent with the formation of
colloidal photonic crystals (Colvin 2001). These crystals were found to have grown as closely-
packed, sub-parallel crystal aggregates, with individual crystals displaying extreme length to width
ratios, and orientated at right angles to vein stratification (Figure 7). In contrast, the potch layers in
these veins, on either side of the ―colour bars‖, showed both laminar and turbulent viscous fluid flow
textures.
In many of the stratified potch/precious opal veins examined, bands of potch and precious opal
display simple to very complex interlayer laminar and turbulent viscous fluid flow relationships,
involving the fluid mixing, diffusion and intrusion of multiple generations of potch and precious opal.
In these types of veins, the distinctive, undisturbed close-packed parallel aggregates of photonic
colloidal crystals of precious opal, orientated normal to vein walls, is lacking, with laminar and
turbulent fluid flows having generated a flowing "crystal mush" of broken and re-distributed photonic
colloidal crystals, creating intriguing patterns of liquid-crystal-fire (Figure 8).
Why Precious Opal is so Rare in GAB Rocks
As the growth of photonic colloidal crystals of precious opal, presumably requires relatively
stable and quiescent conditions to form (e.g. Figure 7, Specimen A.), then the textures evident in
specimens B, C & D of Figure 7, indicate that these conditions can be severely disrupted by later
invading fluid flows of viscous liquid potch opal. Furthermore, the laminar and turbulent liquid-opal-
fluid-flow conditions affecting silica gels containing disordered accumulations of generally non-
equidimensional sized silica spheres, within dynamically evolving Syntectonic opal vein arrays, would
tend to work against the orderly arrangement of close-packed silica spheres to form photonic colloidal
crystals, and accordingly, the creation of effective light diffraction gratings; so necessary for the
formation of precious opal.
Thus, in a dynamically forming and evolving Syntectonic opal vein depositional system,
channelized flowing "rivers" of viscous siliceous fluids, carrying a jumbled mass of silica spheres, from
areas of high pore pressure to areas of low pore pressure, in response to fault-controlled seismic fluid
pumping processes, would greatly favour the formation of potch opal over precious opal (i.e. because
the silica spheres in such a dynamic fluid-flow environment would have virtually no opportunity to
arrange themselves into orderly close-packed light-diffracting arrays).
In contrast, precious opal would likely only form in those "quiet" parts of the opal depositional system
(e.g. within sealed fluid-filled compartments), that allowed for the stable and orderly assembladge of
Pan Gem Resources (Aust) Pty Ltd 2011
Copyright Dr. Simon R. Pecover, July 2011 Page 6
close-packed equidimensional-sized silica spheres, and the subsequent growth of photonic colloidal
crystals.
Therefore, in such a dynamic liquid-opal-fluid-flow geological environment, the formation of precious
opal would be rare and the formation of potch opal would be very common.
Opal Vein Formation
The textural features described above, together with the inclusion of comminuted wall rock clasts
within the veins examined, strongly suggests a tectonically-driven multi-cyclic process of opal vein
formation in the GAB. Such a process would likely involve cyclic fracture-induced permeability,
coupled with multiple fluid injection events associated with elevated pore pressures.
The Non Newtonian fluid flow textures preserved in the veins studied, also show the apparent mixing
of different types of viscous fluids, with some veins preserving liquid flow patterns of precious opal
intermixed with various types of potch opal. These features also suggest a cyclic formational process,
involving episodically induced fracture permeability coupled with self-sealing along dynamically
evolving fluid migration pathways (i.e. the vein arrays), and are thus unlikely to be the result of
weathering and microbial formational processes.
Given that precious opal is likely to require quiescent conditions to achieve orderly packing of silica
spheres to form a light diffracting array, then the stratification described above and the turbulent
intermixing of potch and precious opal in the veins examined, points to a far more complex and
dynamic fluid flow environment of opal deposition than has previously been contemplated by those
advocating simple passive weathering and microbe geo-formational process models.
The opal vein textures described above, clearly show that passive rock weathering processes and the
activity of so-called microbes (assuming of course that such filamentous structures reported from
Australian opal, are indeed the fossil remains of real microbes, and not simply colloidal ligands and
microbe-like silica nanoparticles, associated with colloidal chemistry processes) could not have
formed the opal veins studied, and that complex textures preserving both viscous fluid flow and brittle
fracture deformation are more likely to have been formed by fluids under pressure, associated with
tectonic processes during opal vein formation, that were imposed on the near-surface Cretaceous
sedimentary rocks of the GAB, after they were laid down.
Pan Gem Resources Opal Vein Formation Research
Applicable to Exploration along the Collarenebri Antiform
The knowledge gained from the study of opal vein textures described above, has been used by Pan
Gem Resources to better predict the depositional environments for opal deposition within GAB
antiformal structures. Those areas which display stratigraphic and structural geometries favouring the
formation of trap sites for opalising fluid accumulation, particularly within the ―flats‖ component of fault
relay-zones, are considered by the author to be high priority opal exploration targets.
A number of such prospective sites associated with high concentrations of faults and surficial deposits
of silcrete have now been identified during opal exploration along the Collarenebri Antiform. These
sites also show many of the surface indications described by Aracic (1996) that are associated with
known opal deposits across the Angledool Antiform.
Structural Setting of the Collarenebri Antiform
Structurally, the Cretaceous sediments of the Collarenebri Antiform (Figure 9) are part of the Byrock
Lightning Ridge Composite Block (Figures 10 & 11). This structural block is bounded by large
Pan Gem Resources (Aust) Pty Ltd 2011
Copyright Dr. Simon R. Pecover, July 2011 Page 7
regional scale lineaments, which separate the block from the Boomi Trough in the east, the
Coonamble Embayment in the south, and the Cunnamulla Shelf to the west. The block also coincides
with the southerly extension of the Dirranbandi Syncline (Exon and Den Hertog 1972). The
Cretaceous ridge country at Collarenebri is bounded by two very large continental-scale ENE - WSW
trending lineament fracture systems. These are the Darling River Lineament to the west, which
controls the drainage of the Darling River to the south-west and the Culgoa River to the north-east,
and the Cobar-Inglewood Lineament, which controls the drainage of the Barwon River from Walgett,
north-east to where it joins the Macintyre River, west of Goondiwindi. The Darling River Lineament
and the Cobar-Inglewood Lineament are also broadly conformable to a pervasive ENE-WSW
structural trend that is evident across most of NSW (Scheibner 1973 and 1979).
At Collarenebri, the regional structural setting is dominated by the Weemelah Block and the Cobar-
Inglewood Kink Zone, with much of the area covered by opal Exploration Licences 6738 and 7650,
occurring between the south-eastern edge of the Cobar-Inglewood Kink Zone, and the north-western
edge of the Weemelah Block (Figures 10 & 11).
Opal prospective WNW-ESE-trending structures, comprising joints and fractures lie within ENE-WSW-
trending structural corridors across outcropping Cretaceous sediments of the Collarenebri Antiform.
As at Lightning Ridge, these structures appear to be prospective for the location of opal fields.
However, the aeromagnetic mapping over the Collarenebri Antiform does not support the existence of
a so-called ―Opal Corridor‖, such as the one proposed for the Angledool Antiform (which curiously
does not seem to include the opal fields of Lightning Ridge proper).
Opal Exploration Targets Across the Collarenebri Antiform
Geological interpretation of Landsat and aerial photo imagery, coupled with ground-based geological
mapping, has identified a large number of highly prospective structural and litho-stratigraphic targets
for more detailed opal exploration across the Collarenebri Antiform. In particular, faults and fractures,
striking at 0o to 10o, 30o to 45o, 60o to 90o and 325o to 355o respectively across the Collarenebri
Antiform are considered highly prospective structural targets for opal mineralisation (Figure 12).
Within this structural architecture, current exploration has located a number of areas of intense fault
clustering associated with zones of brecciation, and argillic/silicic alteration of Cretaceous sediments,
which are considered prospective for opal mineralisation at depth (Figure 13).
The most interesting of the prospective areas identified to-date, is Opal Prospect A, located in the
northern part of the Collarenebri Antiform, where both potch and precious opal have been identified
from drill hole samples. The prospect contains a number of brecciated silcrete outcrops associated
with areas of significant argillic alteration located within a fault-cluster-complex that includes both
normal and reverse faults. Prospective claystone reservoir rocks overlain by sandstone beds occur
within the prospect area; with the stratigraphy displaying Hill-Type fracture sets containing vertical
zones of brecciation and pervasive silicification (Figure 14).
Future exploration will concentrate on better defining the structural and stratigraphic architecture of
the prospective areas identified along the Collarenebri Antiform, as well as characterising the
mineralogy of the opal depositional system, and in particular, the nature and distribution of opal-
bearing dilatational jogs and vein systems within fault relay-zone ramp and flat structural settings.
Concluding Remarks
During the last 15 years, since the Syntectonic Model of opal formation in the GAB was first proposed
(Pecover 1996), considerable complimentary evidence has been presented by a number of
researchers (Glass - van der Beek 2003; Liddicoat 2003, Verberne 2004; Rey, Verberne and Glass-
van der Beck 2005; Rey & Dutkiewicz 2010).
Pan Gem Resources (Aust) Pty Ltd 2011
Copyright Dr. Simon R. Pecover, July 2011 Page 8
Much of this evidence is consistent with the fault-valve tectonic processes of mineralising fluid flow
formation, proposed by Sibson (1987, 1989, 1990, 1994, 1996 & 2000), associated with fault-fracture
mesh development, and the seismic pumping of geo-fluids in ore deposit settings across the planet.
Importantly, such processes are known to be applicable to the formation of fault-controlled vein-type
ore deposits in a variety of geological settings (Micklethwaite and Cox 2004).
However, many ―old-school‖ proponents of traditional weathering and biological processes still
advocate opal forming mechanisms which do not adequately explain the formation of opal veins in the
GAB.
As the head of a successful, privately funded, gemstone exploration and mining company, that has
been in business for over 15 years, I for one would not invest in opal exploration and resource
development projects, based on the formational mechanisms advocated by both the deep weathering
and microbe models of opal deposit genesis in the GAB.
From a practical gemstone explorationist perspective, I believe that geo-formational models that
provide little predictive value for targeting drill holes to discover new opal deposits are of no
commercial value to the Opal Industry going forward.
Rather (and in deference to the on-going debate), in the absence of the application of any particularly
agreed geological model to aid in the search for opal deposits across the GAB, newcomers need only
to initially acquaint themselves with the published works of long-time opal miner, Mr. Stephen Aracic
(1996), to understand and appreciate the most important and practical indications to observe when
exploring for and mining opal deposits throughout the Great Australian Basin.
Bibliography
Aracic, S., 1996. DISCOVER OPALS, LIMITED EDITION. BEFORE & BEYOND 2000, WITH
SURFACE INDICATIONS, p 352. Stephen Aracic, Lightning Ridge NSW.
Bourke, D.J., 1973. A geological interpretation of the composite log of the Lightning Ridge town water
supply bore. New South Wales Geological Survey ——— Report GS 1973/027 (unpubl.).
Colvin, V.L., 2001. From opals to optics: Colloidal photonic crystals. Materials Research Society
Bulletin, 26 (8), 637-64.
Cram, L., 1990. BEAUTIFUL AUSTRALIAN OPALS, p 24. Len Cram, Lightning Ridge NSW.
Cram, L., 1998. A Journey with Colour. A History of Queensland Opal, pp 1- 368. Len Cram,
Lightning Ridge NSW.
Exon, N.F., and Den Hertog, J.G.A., 1972. Geology of the Northern Part of the Surat Basin. Sheet
A, 1:1,000,000. Australian Bureau of Mineral Resources, Canberra.
Glass - van der Beek, I., 2003. Structural and lithological relationships to opal deposition at Lightning
Ridge, NSW. B.Sc. (Hons) thesis, University of Sydney, Sydney, 92 pp.
Hawke, J.M., and Bourke, D.J.., 1984. Stratigraphy, in Contributions to the geology of the Great
Australian Basin in New South Wales. New South Wales Geological Survey ——— Bulletin 31,
23-124.
Hawke, J.M., and Cramsie, J.N., 1984. Structural Subdivision of the Great Australian Basin in New
South Wales, in Contributions to the geology of the Great Australian Basin in New South
Wales. New South Wales Geological Survey ——— Bulletin 31, 1-22.
Pan Gem Resources (Aust) Pty Ltd 2011
Copyright Dr. Simon R. Pecover, July 2011 Page 9
Henricus Prematilleke 2007. Australia Gemstone Report. Jewellery News Asia Magazine, pp45-62,
January 2007. Published by CMP Asia Ltd, Hong Kong.
Holmes, G.G., and Senior, B.R., 1976. Lightning Ridge Opal Field. International Geological
Congress, 25th, Sydney ——— Excursion Guide 7B. 13pp.
Liddicoat, K.M., 2003. Geology and geochemistry of the Lightning Ridge black opal deposits. B.Sc.
(Hons) thesis, Macquarie University, Sydney, 166 pp.
Micklethwaite, S., and Cox, S.F., 2004. Fault-segment rupture, aftershock-zone fluid flow and
mineralisation. Geological Society of America, Geology; v. 32; no. 9; p. 813–816.
Oliver, J.G and Townsend I.J., 1993. Gemstones in Australia. A review of the industry and the first
national assessment of gemstone resources. Australian Gemstone Industry Council pp.1-72.
Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra.
Paradis, S. Townsend, J. and Simandl, G.J. (1999): Sedimentary-hosted Opal; in Geological
Fieldwork 1998, B.C. Ministry of Energy and Mines, Paper 1999-1.
Pecover, S.R., 1996. A new genetic model for the origin of opal in the Great Australian Basin.
Mesozoic Geology of the Eastern Australian Plate Conference. Geological Society of Australia,
Extended Abstracts 43, pp 450-454.
Pecover, S.R., 1999. The new syntectonic model of origin to explain the formation of opal veins
(―seams‖ and ―nobbies‖), breccia pipes (―blows‖) and faults (―slides‖) at Lightning Ridge. 1st
National Opal Symposium, Lightning Ridge, Extended Abstracts, pp 1-8.
Pecover, S.R., 2003. Structures related to opal deposits at Lightning Ridge. Opal Exploration
Symposium, Earth Resources Foundation, The University of Sydney, Extended Abstracts, pp 1-
5.
Pecover, S.R., 2005. Breccia Pipes – Fluid pathways of the opal gods. 4th National Opal Symposium,
Lightning Ridge, Extended Abstracts, pp 1-31.
Pecover, S.R., 2007. Australian Opal Resources, Outback Spectral Fire. Rocks and Minerals, 82(2)
102-115.
Pecover, S.R., 2010. Fluid flow and brittle fracture textures in opal veins: Clues to the origin of opal in
the Great Australian Basin. 13th Quadrennial IAGOD Symposium, Adelaide, Extended
Abstracts, pp 420.
Redfire Resources N.L., 1992. Prospectus to raise $AUD 2.5 million for the development of opal
resources in NSW and Queensland.
Redfire Resources NL., 1991. Exploration Reports, ELs 3573 & 3574, Collarenebri, Lightning Ridge
area. First annual exploration report, period ending Jul 1991. Unpublished report. GS1991/235
(R00000700).
Redfire Resources NL., 1992. Exploration Reports, ELs 3573 & 3574, Collarenebri, Lightning Ridge area.
Second annual exploration report, period ending Jul 1992. Unpublished report. GS1991/235
(R00000701).
Redfire Resources NL., 1993. Exploration reports, ELs 3573 & 3574, Collarenebri, Lightning Ridge area.
Third annual explor. report, period ending July 93. Unpublished report GS1993/228 (R00003130).
Pan Gem Resources (Aust) Pty Ltd 2011
Copyright Dr. Simon R. Pecover, July 2011 Page 10
Redfire Resources NL. 1994. Final report, ELs 3573 & 3574, Collarenebri, Lightning Ridge area. Fifth
annual & final explor. report, period ending Nov 93. Unpublished report .GS1994/169 (R00000317).
Rey, P.F., Verberne, R.T., and Glass-van der Beck, I., 2005. Some remarks about the formation of
Boulder opal. 4th National Opal Symposium, Lightning Ridge, Extended Abstracts, p 4.
Rey, P.F., and Dutkiewicz, A., 2010. The formation of seam opals at Lightning Ridge. 13th
Quadrennial IAGOD Symposium, Adelaide, Extended Abstracts, p 424-425.
Scheibner, E., 1973. Tectonic Map of New South Wales, scale 1:1,000,000. Geological Survey of
NSW, Sydney.
Scheibner, E., 1974. Fossil fracture zones, segmentation and correlation problems in the Tasman
Fold Belt system. Reprint from The Tasman Geosyncline Symposium, Geological Society of
Australia, Queensland Division, Brisbane.
Scheibner, E., 1979. Geological significance of some lineaments in New South Wales. The First
Australian Landsat Conference - Proceedings LANDSAT 79, 318-332.
Sibson, R.H., 1987. Earthquake rupturing as a mineralizing agent in hydrothermal systems. Geology,
Vol 15, pp 701-704.
Sibson, R.H., 1989. Structure and mechanics of fault zones in relation to fault-hosted mineralization.
AMF Special Publication, p 66.
Sibson, R. H. 1990. Conditions for fault-valve behaviour. In: Deformation Mechanisms, Rheology and
Tectonics (edited by Knipe. R. J. & Rutter, E. H.). Spec. Publ. geol. Sot. Lond. 54, 15-28.
Sibson, R.H., 1994. Crustal stress, faulting and fluid flow. In Geofluids: Origin, Migration and Evolution of
Fluids in Sedimentary Basins, Ed Parnell, J., Geological Society Special Publication No 78, pp 69-
84.
Sibson, R. H. 1996. Structural permeability of fluid-driven fault-fracture meshes. Journal of Structural
Geology, Vol. 18, No. 8, pp. 1031 to 1042.
Sibson, R.H., 2000. Tectonic controls on maximum sustainable overpressure: fluid redistribution from
stress transitions. Journal of Geochemical Exploration 69–70 (2000) 471–475.
Townsend I.J., 2007. Perfect conditions, perfect spheres: Opal formation in Australia In Opal The
Phenomenal Gemstone, pp18-21. Publisher, Lithographic, LLC, East Hampton, Connecticut,
USA, 1-112.
Verberne, R.T., 2004. Formation of opal deposits at Lightning Ridge, New South Wales, Australia. A
descriptive study into the mode of opal deposition. Utrecht University, the Netherlands and The
University of Sydney. Post doctoral study pp 1-23 (unpubl).
Watkins, J.J., 1985. Future prospects for opal mining in the Lightning Ridge Region. New South
Wales Geological Survey Report GS 1985/119.
Diagram Modified After Micklethwaite & Cox 2004
Figure 1. Geological characteristics consistent with the Syntectonic Modelof opal formation in the Great Australian Basin.
Opalising fluids derived from
overpressured reservoir rocks,
such as compressed claystones
Dr. Simon R. Pecover, 2011
Figure 2. Angledool Antiform, within the Narran-Warrambool Opal Mining Reserve.Modified after NSW Mineral Resources opal fields Landsat imagery.
Figure 3. A. Horizontally laminated vein of potch opal, cross-cut by multiple fracturesthat have been in-filled by later generations of opal, all showing viscous fluid flow andbrittle fracture deformation textures. B. Complex vein of intermixed potch and preciousopal, showing curved viscous fluid flow fronts around brittle-fractured wall rock clasts.
A
B
Micro faults, fractures and opalveins cross-cutting earlier
formed potch layers
Layer-parallel fracturesin-filled by later a
generation of potch
Anastomosing fracturein-filled by a possible
4th generation of potch Micro potchbreccias
Multiple generations of potchshowing viscous fluid flow textures
Potch vein containingfragments of earlier-formed opal
Curved viscous preciousopal fluid-flow-fronts
Sandy claystone clastsripped from vein wallsand carried along in
a viscous liquidopal fluid flow
Opal veinletshowing sense of
hydraulic extension
Mixing of potchand precious opal
viscous fluids
Brecciated wallrock clasts
Curved viscous opalfluid-flow-fronts
Sandy claystone wallrock host to opal veins
Fluid mixingfront
Fluid mixingfront
Dr. Simon R. Pecover, 2011
Dr. S. R. Pecover Specimen & Photo
Dr. S. R. Pecover Specimen & Photo
Figure 4. A. & B. Composite veins of potch showing numerous complex relationshipsbetween multiple generations of opal, showing a variety of viscous fluid-flow behaviors.Dyke-like intrusions are clearly evident in both specimens, as are well developed curvedviscous fluid-flow-fronts of once liquid opal. Rheological differences between opalgenerations, ranging from plastic to brittle fracture deformation, are also clearly evidentin these veins.
A
B
Curved viscous fluid flow-frontsof once liquid opal
Intrusiveopaldyke
Sandy claystone wall rock
Wall rock brecciation
Intrusiveopal dyke
Patterns ofturbulent viscous
fluid-flowBrecciated
opal
Curved viscousfluid-flow-fronts
of once liquid opal
Intrusiveopaldyke
Laminar viscousfluid flow
Laminar viscousfluid-flow
Laminar viscousfluid-flow
Fluid mixingfronts
Dr. Simon R. Pecover, 2011
Dr. S. R. Pecover Specimen & Photo
Dr. S. R. Pecover Specimen & Photo
Figure 5. A. & B. Composite veins of potch showing numerous complex relationshipsbetween multiple generations of opal, showing a variety of viscous fluid-flow behaviors.Dyke-like intrusions are clearly evident in both specimens, as are well developed curvedviscous fluid-flow-fronts of once liquid opal. Rheological differences between opalgenerations, ranging from plastic to brittle fracture deformation, are also clearly evidentin these veins.
A
B
Curved viscousfluid-flow-fronts
of once liquid opal
Sandy claystone wall rock
Large clast of earlier-formed potchshowing laminar & turbulentviscous fluid-flow patterns
Patterns ofturbulent viscousfluid-flow within
laminar flow
Brecciated opal & sandy claystone wall rock clasts
Brittle-fracturedclasts of potch
Fractured opal veins& sandy claystone wall rock
Micro normal fault
En echelon micro reversefaults with intrusive
potch dykes
En echelon microreverse faults
Fractured opal veins& sandy claystone wall rock
Rotated potchclast
Patterns ofturbulent viscous
fluid-flowFluid mixing
fronts
Dr. Simon R. Pecover, 2011
Dr. S. R. Pecover Specimen & Photo
Dr. S. R. Pecover Specimen & Photo
Figure 6. Turbulent and laminar viscous fluid-flow of potch opal, cross-cut by hydraulic extension fractures in-filled bya later generation of potch opal. The turbulent fluid flow patterns evident in this specimen, record classic Non Newtonianviscous flow behavior. While ever these processes are at work within a developing and evolving Syntectonic opal veindepositional system, precious opal is prevented from forming (which is why precious opal is so rare).
Laminar viscous fluid-flowof liquid potch opal
Turbulent viscous fluid-flowof liquid potch opal
Hydraulic extension fracturesin-filled with a later generationof viscous liquid potch opal,forming a younger opal vein
within an older opal vein
Dr. Simon R. Pecover, 2011
Dr. S. R. Pecover Specimen & Photo
A B
C D
Figure 7. A. Colour bar within translucent potch, comprising parallel photonic colloidalcrystals of precious opal that have grown at right angles to the prevailing opalising fluidlamination. B. Colour bars of precious opal within wavy viscous fluid flow layers of potch.C. Colour bars of precious opal being invaded, corroded and disaggregated by viscousfluid flow layers of potch. D. Photonic colloidal crystals of precious opal breaking apartand moving within laminar and wavy viscous fluid flows of potch opal.
Len Cram Photo
Potch
Potch
Photonic colloidalcrystals of precious opal
Potch
Potch
Potch
Potch
Potch
Photonic colloidal crystalsof precious opal breaking-up
in laminar & viscous fluid flowingpotch opal
Laminar & wavy viscous fluid
flowing potch opal
Corrosion & disaggregationof precious opal layer by
potch opal fluid flow
As the growth of photonic colloidal crystals of precious opal presumably requiresrelatively stable and quiescent conditions to form, then the textures evident in samplesB, C & D suggest that these conditions can be disrupted by later invading fluid flows ofviscous liquid opal. Furthermore, the laminar and turbulent conditions of liquid opal fluidflow within dynamically evolving Syntectonic opal veins would tend to prevent the orderlyclose-packing of silica spheres and the creation of light diffraction gratings.
Thus, in a dynamically forming and evolving Syntectonic opal vein depositional system,containing flowing "rivers" of viscous liquid opal, moving from areas of high pore pressureto areas of low pore pressure, in response to fault-controlled seismic fluid pumpingprocesses, potch opal formation would be greatly favoured over the formation of preciousopal, with precious opal only being able to form in those "quiet" parts of the opaldepositional system that allowed for the stable and orderly assembly of close-packedequidimensional sized silica spheres, and the subsequent progressive growth of photoniccolloidal crystals.
Therefore, in such a geological environment, the formation of precious opal would be rareand the formation of potch opal would be very common.
Dr. Simon R. Pecover, 2011
A B
C D
Figure 8. A.-D. Laminar and turbulent viscous fluid-flow patterns of multiple generationsof potch and precious opal.
Horizontal layers ofpotch and precious opal.
Curved viscous fluid-flow-frontsof once liquid precious opal
Fluid-flow direction
Len Cram Photo
Laminar to turbulentviscous fluid flowsof precious opal,
comprisingbroken
fragmentsof photonic
colloidal
crystals
Laminar to turbulentviscous fluid flows
of potch opal,intruding
"crystal mush"of precious
opalPrecious opal"crystal mush"
Precious opal"crystal mush"
Fluid flow patternsin potch opal
Precious opal"crystal mush"
Precious opal"crystal mush"
Fluid flow patterns
in potch opal
Fluid-flow-frontsbetween potch
andprecious opal
Fluid-flow-frontsbetween potch
andprecious opal
In all of the above samples, complex patterns of intrusion and mixing of different generations of viscous liquidpotch and precious opal are evident. Distinctive, undisturbed close-packed parallel clusters of photoniccolloidal crystals of precious opal, orientated normal to vein walls, are lacking in these specimens, with
laminar and turbulent fluid flows having generated flowing "crystal mushes" of broken andre-distributed photonic colloidal crystals, creating intriguing patterns of liquid-crystal-fire.
Dr. Simon R. Pecover, 2011
Figure 9. Landsat image of the Collarenebri Antiform covered by opalExploration Licence 6738.
Dr. Simon R. Pecover, 2011
Figure 10. Structural settings of the Angledool and CollarenebriAntiforms.
Figure 11. Structural and magnetic settings of the Angledool andCollarenebri Antiforms.
Dr. Simon R. Pecover, 2011
Figure 12. Structural architecture of the Collarenebri Antiform, showingmajor interpreted lineaments and faults.
Dr. Simon R. Pecover, 2011
Figure 13. Opal exploration targets across the Collarenebri Antiform,located in areas of high intensity faulting (Note: Many more targets havebeen identified than just the ones shown here).
Dr. Simon R. Pecover, 2011
Figure 14. Stratigraphy of Opal Prospect A, showing vertical Hill-Typefractures containing breccia pipes in the NE sector of the prospect.A high degree of silicification and argillic alteration of the fault damagezones are evident in this sector, which are overlain by thick deposits ofsurficial silcrete. Both potch and precious opal have been recorded fromthis Prospect.
Dr. Simon R. Pecover, 2011