recurso extraordinario de revision - suplemento 1 - ano 2014 - portalguarani

Upload: portalguaranipy5

Post on 06-Jul-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    1/798

     

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZF@IZ@CKFZCI @NZN\CQCÑK

    Q^RGNONKPI K² 6

    Lfggis `n gf Airtn Quprnof`n Dustcacf

    (Lnjrnri `n :22= - Fjrcg `n :261)

    Ckstctuti `n Ckvnstcmfacikns Durï`cafs

    Fsukacñk • Rfrfmufy

    :260

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    2/798

    © Airtn Quprnof `n Dustcacf

    Ckstctuti `n Ckvnstcmfacikns Durï`cafs (CCD)

    ‗Znaursi Nxtrfir`ckfrci `n Znvcscñk‟. Lfggis `n gf AirtnQuprnof `n Dustcacf (Lnjrnri `n :22= ‑   Fjrcg `n :261).Fsukacñk ‑  Rfrfmufy

    @NZNAHIQ ZNQNZ\F@IQ

    Vun`f prihcjc`f aufgqucnr lirof `n rnpri`uaacñk, trfksocscñki frahcvi nk scstnofs rnaupnrfjgns, snf pfrf usi prcvf`i ipôjgcai pir on`cis onaækcais, ngnatrñkcais, litiaipcf`irfs,mrfjfacikns i aufgqucnr itri, titfg i pfracfg, `ng prnsnktn

    ndnopgfr, aik i sck lckfgc`f` `n guari, sck futirczfacñk nxprnsf.

    N`cacñk4 >22 ndnopgfrns.

    CQJK4 3=8-333>1-06-63-2

    AIIZ@CKFACÑK

    Ckstctuti `n Ckvnstcmfacikns Durï`cafs (CCD)

     Disã Zfôg Pirrns Ecrosnr, Ockcstri Znspiksfjgn  

    Afronk Oiktfkïf Acjcgs, @crnatirf  

     Dufk Rænz, Ipnrf`ir Ckliroætcai  Ocmung @fvc` Gñpnz, @csnöi y N`cacñk  

    @ 101ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑKLfggis `n gf Airtn Quprnof `n Dustcacf(Lnjrnri `n :22= ‑   Fjrcg `n :261)

    AIZAirtn Quprnof `n Dustcacf

    Fsukacñk ‑  RfrfmufyN`cacñk :260. • R. 82:  

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    3/798

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    4/798

     

    Gf prnsnktn ijrf aiktcnkn Faunr`is y Qnktnkacfs rngnvfktns, `catf`is pir gf Qfgf Rnkfg `n gf Airtn Quprnof `n Dustcacf, nk oftnrcf `n

    rnaursi nxtrfir`ckfrci `n rnvcscñk. Gf prconrf pujgcafacñk `n gf Airtn,qun aiopcgñ lfggis `ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk `ftf `ng föi :22=, y gfocsof fjfrafjf ng pnrci`i `n tcnopi `n nknri `n :226 f dugci `n :22

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    5/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    ÏK@CAN MNKNZFG

    Ïk`can `n suofrcis pir tnof 61 

    LFGGIQ

    FA^NZ@IQ S QNKPNKACFQ. FÖI :22=

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 21/:22= 88

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 13/:22= 626

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 6:=/:22= 628

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 6==/:22= 66:

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 6=3/:22= 6::

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² :00/:22= 616

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 10=/:22= 606

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 1>=/:22= 6>:

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 13

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 1

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    6/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² =/:228 :=<

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 632/:228 :3<

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² :3:/:228 160

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 080/:228 1:0

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 08:/:228 1><

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² =>0/:228 1/:228 1=0

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 61::/:228 1==

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 61:0/:228 13>

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    7/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 6111/:228 138

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 612

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² =2>/:223 013

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² =0=/:223 006

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 8:>/:223 008

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 8>0/:223 0>:

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 8>>/:223 0>8

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 32

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    8/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 82/:262 03:

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² :21/:262 >26

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² :36/:262 >66

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 010/:262 >6>

    FA^NZ@IQ S QNKPNKACFQ. FÖI :266

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² ::/:266 >10

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 0>

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 612/:266 >03

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 6=:/:266 >/:266 >=>

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² :=0/:266 >8<

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 061/:266 >36

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 013/:266

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    9/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² =18/:266

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    10/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² :2/:26: =00

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² :013/:26: =>6

    FA^NZ@IQ S QNKPNKACFQ. FÖI :261

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 83/:261 =0/:261 =82

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 6

    ÏK@CANQ NQRNACFGNQ

    Ïk`can fglfjãtcai  ‑  tnoætcai =3:

    Ïk`can snmôk ng nstf`i `n gf rnsiguacñk =33

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    11/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    61 

    ÏK@CAN @N Q^OFZCIQ

    RIZ PNOF

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    12/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    60 

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    13/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    6> 

    FA^NZ@IQ S QNKPNKACFQ

    FÖI :22=

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    14/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    6 `ng ARR aufk`i ki nxcstn ng afojci `n

     durcspru`nkacf sijrn gf aunstcñk aiktrivnrtc`f.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 13/:22=

    CK@NOKCTFACÑK4  Afsi `n fjsiguacñk.  Prfoctfacñk nkckstfkacfs cklnrcirns

     Pfkti gf `nviguacñk `n ijdntis, aioi gf ck`nokczfacñk,nk afsi `n fjsiguacñk, pun`nk snr sigcactf`fs ytrfoctf`fs fktn itris ñrmfkis durcs`caacikfgnsaiopntnktns, punsti qun sik aunstcikns faansircfs,aiksnaunkacf `n gf afusf prckacpfg qun yf hf sc`irnsungtf pir nstf Airtn Quprnof `n Dustcacf,pnrlnatfonktn f`uacjgns fktn ckstfkacfs cklnrcirns qun

    `njnk nktnk`nr nk gf ndnauacñk `n gfs ocsofs.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    15/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    6= 

    CK@NOKCTFACÑK 

    Gf prntnkscñk `n lik`i qun nstrcjf nk ng rnaikiacocnkti`n uk `nrnahi, nk ng afsi ck`nokczftirci, `njn snr

    frtcaugf`f fktn gf durcs`caacñk airrnspik`cnktn aik ngafræatnr nsnkacfgonktn pnrsikfgïscoi qun ti`fck`nokczfacñk supikn y nk nsn aiktnxti, `nktri `n uk`njc`i priansi5 `n aioprijfrsn gf nxcstnkacf `n uknxpgïacti nrrir du`cacfg y `ng fpirtn aiktrcjutcvi `n gisqun gis pripcacfrik, sn rnsungvn gf aiktrivnrscfaikliron f gis pistugf`is aikstctuacikfgns y gnmfgnsqun rcmnk gf oftnrcf (\iti pir su pripci luk`fonkti `ngf Ockcstrf Ruahntf `n Airrnf).

    NZZIZ D^@CACFG4 Ck`nokczfacñkGf ck`nokczfacñk pir nrrir du`cacfg, prnsupikn scnoprngf nxprnsf `nagfrfacñk, nk gf snktnkacf fjsigutircf (\itipir su pripci luk`fonkti `n gf Ockcstrf Ruahntf `nAirrnf).

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 6:=/:22=

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4  F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ngrnaursi `n rnvcscñk

    Gf prnsnktfacñk `n `iauonktfgns y gf farn`ctfacñk `noitcvis qun dustclcqunk gf nxcstnkacf `n cklirofacñkrngnvfktn, snrcf n c`ñknf surmc`f aik pistnrcirc`f` fgoionkti nk qun gf snktnkacf qun`ñ lcron sikrnqucsctis ck`cspnksfjgns pfrf gf f`ocscñk `ng rnaursi`n rnvcscñk `n gf snktnkacf aik`nkftircf.

    Ng rnaursi nxtrfir`ckfrci `n rnvcscñk ns uk on`ci `ncopumkfacñk `n rcmir lirofg, auyis oitcvis nstæk

    tfsf`is, vfgn `nacr, qun gis ocsois nstæk nxprnsfonktnnstfjgnac`is nk gf gny, y ki jfstf sigfonktnonkacikfrgis, scki qun prckacpfgonktn `njnk snr ijdnti`n frmuonktfacñk durï`caf pir gfs pfrtns, punsti qun ftrfvãs `n nsf ipnrfacñk cktngnatufg ggnmfk faikiacocnkti `ng Prcjukfg gis fmrfvcis `n gfs pfrtns ysn `ntnrockf, ng æojcti `n aiktrig `ng ñrmfki rnvcsir.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    16/798

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    17/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    63 

    NQAZCP^ZF RÔJGCAF

    Nk gf nsarcturf pôjgcaf ipnrf gf pgnkf ln sijrn gishnahis qun nkukacf gf nsarcjfkf aioi auopgc`is pir gf

    ocsof5 sijrn gis hnahis qun gf ln`ftfrcf nkukacf aioipfsf`is nk su prnsnkacf, nsti ns, qun gi hf pnracjc`ipnrsikfgonktn y sijrn gfs ofkclnstfacikns qun gisitirmfktns i cktnrvckcnktns nk ng fati hfk lirougf`i nksu prnsnkacf.

    NQAZCP^ZF RÔJGCAF4 \fgir prijftirci `n gf nsarcturf  Gf nsarcturf pôjgcaf ki hfan ln kc pgnkf prunjf sijrn gfvnrfac`f` `n gfs ofkclnstfacikns qun hfank gfs pfrtnsitirmfktn i cktnrvckcnktns.

    HNAHIQ K^N\IQ4 Nlnatis  

    Gis kunvis hnahis i kunvis ngnonktis `n prunjfstcnk`nk f nvc`nkacfr gis scmucnktns nlnatis piscjgns5 qunng hnahi ki hf nxcstc`i5 qun ng aik`nkf`i ki hfaiontc`i ng hnahi qun sn gn hf ftrcjuc`i5 qun ng hnahinxcstcñ, pnri ki ns pukcjgn (ftïpcai, ijdntcvf y/isujdntcvfonktn)5 qun fg hnahi aiontc`i y pnkfgonktnsfkacikf`i gn ns fpgcafjgn ukf gny pnkfg oæs jnkcmkf.

    HNAHIQ K^N\IQQupikcnk`i qun ng hnahi fgnmf`i snf kunvi,sijrnvckcnktn y hfyf sc`i du`cacfgczf`i, gf pitnkacfgc`f``n su nlcafacf `njn nvfgufrsn  ‑   snmôk ng tnxti gnmfg -aioi ukc`f` prijftircf i nk fgcfkzf aik gfs prunjfs yfnxfockf`fs nk ng prian`cocnkti.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK

    Rfrf gf prian`nkacf `ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk gis hnahis

    kunvis `njnk sijrnvnkcr f gf aik`nkf i `nsaujcnrtis`nspuãs `n qun nggf hfyf rnafï`i y scnoprn y aufk`i`ndnk trfsuktfr ukf cknquïviaf y prnacpuf ckac`nkacfsijrn ng afu`fg prijftirci onrctuf`is nk gf snktnkacfrnvcsf`f.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    18/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    :2 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 6=3/:22=

    HNAHI K^N\I4 Anrtclcaf`i `n `nlukacñk

    Ng `iauonkti qun faiopföf ng rnaurrnktn aioi kunvingnonkti `n prunjf (Aipcf `ng Fatf `ng Gcjri `n@nlukacñk `n gf Ilcackf `n Znmcstri Acvcg `n Frnmuæ), kins kivn`isf kc tcnkn rngnvfkacf durï`caf-prijftircf,pirqun, prnacsfonktn, ng Anrtclcaf`i `n @nlukacñkfmrnmf`i nk ng nxpn`cnktn ns aiksnaunkacf `crnatf `n gftiof `n rfzñk `n `cahi faiktnacocnkti pir ng Ilcacfg `ngZnmcstri Acvcg, (Gny K´ 6.:

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    19/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    :6 

    ZNLIZOFPCI CK RND^Q4 Gny oæs jnkcmkf  Gf rnliroftci ck pncus   aikstctuyn nk sï ocsof ukf gnyoæs jnkcmkf5 gf prihcjcacñk `n gf rnlirof nk pnrducaci

    surmn aioi uk `nrcvf`i `ng `nrnahi `n `nlnksf quntcnkn ng coputf`i i aik`nkf`i, aikstctuynk`i mfrfktïfck`cvc`ufg qun gi pritnmn `n gfs ntfpfs rnaurscvfs,copc`cnk`i qun sn rnliron i oi`clcqun su sctufacñk nklirof oæs mrfvisf, aufk`i sñgi ãg copumkf.

    ZNLIZOFPCI CK RND^Q

    Gf rnliroftci ck pncus   nk prckacpci gcjnrf fg coputf`i`ng pngcmri qun gf cktnrpiscacñk `ng rnaursi pun`nafusfr, sc nk afsi `n fkugfrsn gf `nacscñk ukf kunvf

    snktnkacf `catf`f pir ng itri trcjukfg fmrfvn gi `nac`c`ipir ng prconri. Gf rnliroftci ck pncus  flnatf ng `nrnahif gf `nlnksf yf qun sn trftf `n ukf aik`nkf sckfu`cnkacf y `njftn pir pfrtn `ng aik`nkf`i

    ZNLIZOFPCI CK RND^Q

    Ng Prcjukfg `n Fpngfacikns sn hf nxtrfgcoctf`i nk gfnxpiscacñk `n gis oitcvis `ng rnaurrnktn fmrfvfk`i `nhnahi su sctufacñk, puns sc jcnk hf rnviaf`i gf pnkf `nougtf aiopgnonktfrcf sus frmuonktis sn jfsfrik nk ngfrt. >= `ng Añ`cmi Rnkfg (pnkf pftrcoikcfg), qun ki lunng frmuonkti utcgczf`i nk gf snktnkacf `n prconrfCkstfkacf, `ik`n sn copusi -ukf ougtf aioi pnkfaiopgnonktfrcf, `n aikliroc`f` fg frtïaugi >1 `ngactf`i aunrpi gnmfg nk jfsn f aiksc`nrfacikns `cstcktfs

     y aik gf `ntnrockfacñk dustf `n su oikti `naikliroc`f` f gis prnsupunstis rnqunrc`is, pir gi qunsu rnviaftircf ki ns prian`nktn yf qun gf ocsof ki lunluk`fonktf`f pir ng f-qui.

    ZNLIZOFPCI CK RND^Q4 Gïoctns  Gis gïoctns copunstis pir gf rnliroftci ck pncus , quntcnkn ng trcjukfg `n fgzf`f sik4 ki pun`n oi c̀lcafr nghnahi ijdnti `n gf coputfacñk5 ki pun`n fuonktfr gfpnkf copunstf pir ng fqui   nk su `nacscñk5 ki pun`nkfpgcafr pnkfs faansircfs pir pripcf `nacscñk5 ki pun`nnlnatcvczfr gfs pnkfs qun lunrik copunstfs nk lirofsuspnkscvf5 ki pun`n afgclcafr oæs mrfvnonktn ng hnahi

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    20/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    :: 

    pukcjgn, fuk aufk`i ki fuonktn gf pnkf copunstf pirng cklnrcir.

    ZNLIZOFPCI CK RND^Q4 Mfrfktïf pfrf ng coputf`i  Aufk`i sigi ng coputf`i fpngf, ipnrf gf rnliroftci ck pncus  aioi mfrfktïf `n qun ki nopnirfræ su sctufacñkpriansfg aik gf oi`clcafacñk `n gf snktnkacf nk suaiktrf.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4  Oi`clcafacñk `n gf aik`nkf.Rrian`nkacf `ng rnaursi

    Gf nxcstnkacf `n ukf oi`clcafacñk `n gf aik`nkf nkpnrducaci `ng coputf`i, hfan f gf vcfjcgc`f` `ng rnaursi

    `n rnvcscñk, puns gfs aik`cacikns læatcafs y durï`cafs `ngfaunr`i y snktnkacf rnaurrc`i, hcacnrik f gf vugknrfacñk`n gfs kirofs nstfjgnac`fs nk ng ir`nkfocnkti durï`cai.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 10=/:22=

    LFGQI PNQPCOIKCI

    Ki nxcstnk lfgsn`f`ns tnstcoikcfgns i `iauonktfgns,onkis nk afræatnr `n nvc`nktns, qun pu`cnrik hfjnr

    ckac`c`i nk gf aikvcaacñk `n gis duzmf`irns `n gfssuanscvfs ckstfkacfs pfrf frrcjfr f uk aickac`nktn`nsnkgfan durcs`caacikfg qun nstæ ofkclnstf`f pir gfcopiscacñk `n gf sfkacñk pnkfg.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Rrian`nkacf  

    Qn `nsafrtf gf aiklcmurfacñk `n gf prconrf hcpñtnscsfgu`c`f (frt. 086 kuo.: 6f. pfrtn), ti`f vnz qun ki snhf fgnmf`i, kc sn hf `noistrf`i gf nxcstnkacf `n gflfgsn`f` `iauonktfg i tnstcoikcfg, nxtrnoi qun `njnsnr farn`ctf`i nk lirof lnhfacnktn y`iauonktf`fonktn aik ng lfggi pistnrcir lcron quntuvi pir anrtclcaf`i tfgns nxtrnois, airrnspik`cnk`i tfgafrmf f fqung qun gi ckviaf nk su jnknlcaci.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Rrian`nkacf. Rrunjfs lfgsfs

    Gf rnsiguacñk sn nkaunktrf pnkfgonktn vcacf`f aufk`ifg oionkti `n snr rnsungti ng afsi sn luk`f nk prunjfstnstclïafgns i `iauonktfgns qun cklguynk `nacscvf y

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    21/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    :1 

    trfsank`nktnonktn nk gf rnsiguacñk aik`nkftircf, qun,nk sï ocsof, `nvcnkn ckdustf pir nstfr jfsf`f nk lfgsfsprunjfs qun pnrsuf`nk fg duzmf`ir f f`iptfr ukf

    `ntnrockfacñk `nsvcf`f `n gf vnr`f` fg aiksc`nrfrgfs nkng priansi `n vfgirfacñk aikduktf y froñkcaf `n gfsprunjfs pri`uac`fs y aik frrnmgi f gf sfkf arctcaf.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 1>=/:22=

    NQP^RNLFACNKPNQ4 Gny vcmnktn

    Nk gf on`c`f nk qun gf Gny 6102 ki snf flnatf`f pir gfpfrtn mnknrfg `ng Añ`cmi Rnkfg  ‑   qun fjfraf `ns`n ngFrt. 6 fg 620  ‑   sus kiroftcvfs sn hfggfk pgnkfonktn

    vcmnktns.

    GNS RNKFG 4  Cktnmrfacñk `n gf gnyNg trcjukfg pfrf copiknr fauougftcvfonktn `is pnkfsprckacpfgns, hf nsaimc`i gf pfrtn `n gf kirof pnkfgsujir`ckf`f  ‑ Gny 6102- `nsnahfk`i gf sujir`ckfktnqun nrf gf fpgcafjgn ‑ Gny 66

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    22/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    :0 

    Gcjri 6, nk aufkti jnknlcacn fg fausf`i i aik`nkf`i5 0)Gf fpgcafacñk rntrifatcvf `n gf gny pnkfg oæs jnkcmkf nsrnspnati f gis priansf`is (frt. 60 `n gf Aikstctuacñk.5

    frt. 0 `ng AR) y f gis aik`nkf`is (frt. 60 Aikstctuacñk,frt. 0 `ng AR y >22 `ng ARR)5 >) Airrnspik`n f gf AirtnQuprnof `n Dustcacf gf fpgcafacñk `n gf gny pnkfg oæsjnkcmkf, aufk`i sn nkaunktrf nk ntfpf `n ndnauacñk gfaik`nkf qun lunrf copunstf (frt. >22 `ng ARR).

    RNKF4 Rnkfs prckacpfgns. @ijgn pnkfgc`f`

    Aik gf `ijgn fpgcafacñk `n pnkf prcvftcvf `n gcjnrtf`aik pnkf `n ougtf, ki sigi sn vcignktfk gis prckacpcis`n gnmfgc`f` y kik jcs ck ï`no, scki tfojcãk ng prckacpci

    `n huofkc`f` `n gfs pnkfs, fsï aioi gfs `cspiscacikns`ng frt. :2 `n gf Aikstctuacñk.

    RZCKACRCI @N GNMFGC@F@

    Ng prckacpci `n gnmfgc`f` nstfjgnac`i nk ng Frt. 6´) `ngAñ`cmi Rnkfg, hf sc`i fvfsfggf`i pir gf`nskfturfgczfacñk `ng rnlnrc`i prckacpci pnkfg jæscai, fgcopiknr ukf pnkf `n ougtf qun `n pnrofknanrsujscstnktn, copgcafrïf ukf `ijgn aik`nkf `njc`i f suafræatnr `n pnkf prckacpfg.

    RNKF RFPZCOIKCFG

    Qc jcnk ng Frt. >1 `ng añ`cmi Rnkfg prnvã gf piscjcgc`f``n copiknr ukf aiojckfacñk `n pnkf prcvftcvf `ngcjnrtf` y ougtf (nk afgc`f` `n pnkf aiopgnonktfrcf)nxanpacikfg y lfaugtftcvfonktn aufk`i ng futir snnkrcqunacnrf on`cfktn ng hnahi i gi cktnktfrf, ki nsfpgcafjgn ng afsi nk nstu`ci, yf qun ki sn vnrclcaf qun gfijgcmfacñk `ng pfmi `n `cknri nstã prnvcstf

    nxprnsfonktn pir gf gny pnkfg nk afgc`f` `n pnkfaiopgnonktfrcf (\iti pir su pripci luk`fonkti `n gfOckcstrf Fgcacf Ruahntf `n Airrnf).

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 1

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    23/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    :> 

    ôgtcof, aiktrfrcf i ckaiopftcjgn f gfs prnsarcpacikns `ngf pfrtn rnoctc`f, qun`fk sck nlnati copgïactfonktn.

    RNKF4 @ijgn pnkfgc`f`Qn `njn fkugfr ng fpfrtf`i `n gf snktnkacf vckaugf`f fgf aik`nkf `n ougtf, ofktnkcnk`i lcron gf pnkfprcvftcvf `n gcjnrtf`, `f`i qun gf pisturf `n gf AirtnQuprnof ns gf ckfpgcafjcgc`f` `n gf `ijgn pnkfgc`f` nkgis priansis, fkugæk`isn gfs `cspiscacikns `n gfssnktnkacfs qun copiknk aikduktfonktn gf pnkf `nougtf aik gf prcvftcvf `n gcjnrtf`.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 1

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    24/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    :

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    25/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    := 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 0:=/:22=

    O^GPF4 Rnkf `n ougtf aiopgnonktfrcf  

    Qn hfan gumfr fg rnaursi `n rnvcscñk pir flnatfr gfrnsiguacñk gf prihcjcacñk `n fpgcafr `is pnkfsprckacpfgns, nk lirof aikduktf, pfrf afstcmfr uk cgïacti ypir gf iocscñk `n gf airrnatf dustclcafacñk pfrf suofr gfpnkf aiopgnonktfrcf pftrcoikcfg i ougtf, nkaiksnaunkacf sn nxaguyn `n gf aik`nkf gf pnkf prckacpfg`n ougtf.

    O^GPF4 Rnkf `n ougtf aiopgnonktfrcf  

    Ng frt. >1 `ng Añ`cmi Rnkfg nstfjgnan gf pnkf `n ougtf

    aiopgnonktfrcf, qun `njn luk`frsn nk lirof nxprnsf,aik onkacñk `ng vfgir `ng nkrcqunacocnkti gimrf`i icktnktf`i, fg aiontnrsn ng hnahi, supikn prunjfs sijrnng pnsi titfg `n gfs onraf`nrïfs, su vfgir pir mrfoi iecgis, nta.

    RNKF4 Rnkfs prckacpfgns. Ougtf y prcvfacñk `n gcjnrtf`

    ^k sigi cgïacti ki pun`n snr ijdnti `n `is sfkaciknsprckacpfgns (pnkf prcvftcvf `n gcjnrtf` y `n ougtf),fukqun ns piscjgn qun aik gf pnkf prcvftcvf `n gcjnrtf`snf fpgcaf`f itrf pnkf.

    RNKF

    ^k sigi cgïacti ki pun`n snr ijdnti `n `is sfkaciknsprckacpfgns (pnkf prcvftcvf `n gcjnrtf` y `n ougtf),fukqun ns piscjgn qun aik gf pnkf prcvftcvf `n gcjnrtf`snf fpgcaf`f itrf pnkf aiopgnonktfrcf pftrcoikcfg,trf`uac`f nk ougtf.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 01

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    26/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    :8 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 006/:22=

    D^ZCQRZ^@NKACF

    Gf `nacscñk `n gf Airtn Quprnof `n Dustcacf `n airrnmcrgf fpgcafacñk `ng `nrnahi, ki copgcaf uk afojci `n

     durcspru`nkacf.

    RNKF

    Gf pnkf copunstf f ukf pnrsikf ns aiksnaunkacf `n ukpriansi ggnvf`i f afji aiktrf gf ocsof y gf`csaikliroc`f` aik gf copiscacñk `n ukf sfkacñk kiscmkclcaf gf vcigfacñk `n uk `nrnahi aiktrf nsf pnrsikf.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Zn`uaacñk `n gf pnkf

    Ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk ki ns gf vïf pfrf rn`uacr gf pnkf.Ng sigi rnqunrcocnkti `n gf rn`uaacñk `n gf pnkf ki nsoitcvi sulcacnktn pfrf ng nstu`ci `ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk,sc ng rnvcscikcstf ki hf fpirtf`i hnahis kunvis ingnonktis prijftircis qun sigis i ukc`is f gis yfnxfockf`is `nounstrnk qun ng hnahi ki nxcstcñ, qun gfcoputf`f ki gi aiontcñ i qun ng hnahi aiontc`i ki nspukcjgn i qun airrnspik`f fpgcafr ukf gny oæslfvirfjgn.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Lfgtf `n luk`fonktfacñk `ng rnaursi  

    Gf lfgtf `n luk`fonktfacñk `ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñkaikstctuyn uk ijstæaugi pfrf ng nxfonk `n gf snktnkacf,puns ng nstu`ci `njn hfanrsn aik jfsn nk gi snöfgf`ipir gf rnvcscikcstf.

    F`ocscjcgc`f` `ng rnaursi

    Ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk ns ckf`ocscjgn aufk`i ki sn hfkprnsnktf`i gfs `iauonktfgns y ki sn farn`ctfk gisoitcvis qun dustclcqunk gf nxcstnkacf `n cklirofacñkrngnvfktn, snrcf n c`ñknf surmc`f aik pistnrcirc`f` fgoionkti nk qun gf snktnkacf qun`ñ lcron.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    27/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    :3 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² >

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    28/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    12 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K²

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    29/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    16 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² `n iatujrn `ng :226)5 kc nspfacfgonktn (ngprconri gi lun nk ukf afusf snmuc`f nk ng `npfrtfonkti`n Ctfpôf nk tfkti qun ng snmuk`i nk gf Acrauksarcpacñk

     Du`cacfg `n gf Afpctfg).

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK

    Rfrf qun prian`f gf rnvcscñk nk vcrtu` `n gi `cspunstipir ng frt. 086 cka. 6 `ng ARR (ckaikacfjcgc`f` `nsnktnkacf) sn rnqucnrn46) @is snktnkacfs lcrons, quntnkmfk gf afgc`f` `n aisf duzmf`f, yf qun sc ukf `nnggfs ki gi nstæ, ns susanptcjgn `n rnviafacñk, pu`cnk`ioi`clcafrsn `n nstf ofknrf gf sctufacñk5 :) Fojfssnktnkacfs, auyf aiklriktfacñk sn prntnk`n, `njnk snr

    `n kfturfgnzf pnkfg5 1) @njn aiklcmurfrsn ukfaiktrf`caacñk nktrn fojfs, `n tfg ofknrf qun ukfflcron fgmi sijrn ukf aunstcñk y gf itrf pir su pfrtn gikcnmun, nk itrfs pfgfjrfs `njnk snr rfzikfocnktisgñmcafonktn aiktrfpunstis.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    30/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    1: 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² : `ng A.R nstfjgnan gfs jfsns qun `njn tnknr nkaunktf ng dunz pfrf `ntnrockfr ng oikti `n gf pnkf `nougtf, aioi gfs aik`cacikns pnrsikfgns y naikñocafs`ng futir, ng ckmrnsi knti qun pun`f tnknr nk uk `ïf, y

    tnkcnk`i nk aunktf qun nk ng afsi, ng aik`nkf`i ns ukvnk`n`ir fojugfktn uk `ïf ougtf snræ `ntnrockf`i, nkpir gi onkis ng :2% `n uk dirkfg oïkcoi `cfrci.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK

    Ng dustcacfjgn `csarnpf aik ng rfzikfocnkti durï`cainoctc`i nk ng lfggi `n prconrf ckstfkacf, y pir nggiprntnk`n qun sn gi rnvcnrtf nk Airtn Quprnof, gi aufg kiprian`n punsti qun nk su oionkti ki hf utcgczf`i gisrnaursis ir`ckfrcis qun gf gny gn aiklcnrn, y f`noæspirqun ki aiklcmurf gfs afusfgns pir ãg fgnmf`fs pfrfgimrfr su f`ocscñk f nstu`ci `ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk(\iti nk `csc`nkacf `n gf Ockcstrf Fgcacf Ruahntf `nAirrnf).

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 886/:22=

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ngrnaursi `n rnvcscñk

    Qc gf snktnkacf `nlckctcvf `n prconrf ckstfkacfcopumkf`f pir rnvcscñk ki hf sulrc`i, nk gfs ckstfkacfssupnrcirns, kckmukf fgtnrfacñk durï`caf qun pu`cnrfknxcmcr fmrfvcis `csïocgns, sc gi nsnkacfg `n su aiktnkc`ins c`ãktcai kf`f ijstf f qun ng kôagni fmrfvftirci snf`crcmc`i ck`cstcktfonktn f uki u itri yf qun nk nggisfkc`fk gis ocsois aunstcikfocnktis cksftcslnahis.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Rrian`nkacf. Znatclcafacñk `ngtcnopi `n gf aik`nkf

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    31/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    11 

    Airrnspik`n hfanr gumfr fg rnaursi `n rnvcscñk ckaif`i, y nk aiksnaunkacf, `cspiknr gf rnatclcafacñk `ng tcnopi`n gf aik`nkf copunstf f `is föis `n pnkf prcvftcvf `n

    gcjnrtf` (\iti nk `csc`nkacf `ng Ockcstri Ocmung IsafrJfdfa Fgjnrtckc).

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 612:/:22=

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 F`ocscjcgc`f`Gis rnafu`is lirofgns pfrf gf f`ocscjcgc`f` `ng rnaursi `nafsfacñk sik4 f) gf prnsnktfacñk pir nsarcti `ng rnaursi4 j)gf lcrof `ng fjimf`i y `ng rnaurrnktn aufk`i fqung fatôfaioi pftriackfktn5 a) gf prnsnktfacñk `ng rnaursi nk

    tcnopi pripci (62 `ïfs), fktn gf Qnarntfrcf `n gf Qfgf Rnkfg5`) aik aipcfs `n gf rnsiguacñk copumkf`f y `n gf aã`ugf `nkitclcafacñk pnrtcknktn5 n) gf onkacñk `n uki i oæs `n gistrns nxaguscvis y ôkcais oitcvis prnvcstis nk ng frt. 0=8 `ngAñ`cmi Rriansfg Rnkfg aik sus luk`fonktis y gf siguacñkqun sn prntnk`n5 l) qun gf snktnkacf i futi copumkf`i snfuki `n gis ijdntis `n afsfacñk, `n faunr`i fg actf`i frt.0==5 y m) qun nxcstf cktnrãs pfrf cktnrpiknr ng rnaursi.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 6160/:22=

    AIK@^APF RNKFG4 @ntnrockfacñk `ng tcpi pnkfg

    Gf `ntnrockfacñk aioi tïpcaf pnkfg `n ukf aik`uatf`nspgnmf`f airrnspik`n nxaguscvfonktn fg æojcti

     durcs`caacikfg, pnri ns ôtcg, vægc`i y hfstf knansfrci ngusi `n on`cis fuxcgcfrns tãakcais qun aigfjirnk aik gfaikstruaacñk durï`caf `n acnrtis tcpis pnkfgns aiopgndis,nk nspnacfg gis `n tnkir naikñocai, fsï gis on`cisprijftircis rnfgczf`is pir pnrsikfs nxpnrtfs, pnrctis,qun aioi nk ng prnsnktn afsi, nk jfsn f

    `iauonktfacikns jrck`f`fs rnfgczfk uk nxfonk sijrnng auopgcocnkti `n uk rnqucscti ijdntcvi `ng tcpi pnkfg(gnscñk `n aiklcfkzf), nk ng afsi nspnaïlcai gf`ntnrockfacñk `n pnrducaci pftrcoikcfg.

    HNAHI R^KCJGN4 Cknxcstnkacf `n `igi y `n pnrducaci pftrcoikcfg

    Kukaf ukf f`ockcstrfacñk `nsir`nkf`f, pun`naikstctucr `ngcti, aufk`i ki nxcstn `igi. Nk ng afsinspnaïlcai fktn gf fusnkacf `n sustnkti læatcai-durï`cai

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    32/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    10 

    rfzikfjgn rnspnati fg `igi, y fktn gf lfgtf `noistrf`f `npnrducaci pftrcoikcfg, ns agfri qun ki hf nxcstc`i hnahipukcjgn.

    GNQCÑK @N AIKLCFKTF4 Rnrducaci pftrcoikcfg  @n gf fprnacfacñk `n ngnonktis prijftircis, snöfgf`isaioi ngnonktis kunvis `nktri `n gf rnvcscñk, surmnagfrfonktn gf ki nxcstnkacf `n pnrducaci pftrcoikcfg,ngnonkti `ntnrockfktn nk gf aikstruaacñk `ng tcpi gnmfg,

     y gf lfgtf `ng ocsoi, i `n gf ki `noistrfacñk lnhfacnktnpir pfrtn `n gf fausf`irf `ng rnsugtf`i tcpi, ki nxcstnhnahi pukcjgn (gnscñk `n aiklcfkzf), ns oæs, gff`ockcstrfacñk `nsir`nkf`f, i gf lfgtf f`ockcstrftcvf

    lirofg, ki `ntnrockf `igi `n `nlrfu`fr.

    GNQCÑK @N AIKLCFKTF4 @igi

    Fktn gf fusnkacf `ng `igi aioi ngnonkti sujdntcvi `ngtcpi pnkfg `n gnscñk `n aiklcfkzf, fg ki hfjnr`noistrf`i ‗ng aikiacocnkti‟ y gf ‗viguktf`‟ `n ukrnsugtf`i, qun ki nxcstcñ, ki pun`n fj ckctciaiklcmurfrsn gf gnscñk `n aiklcfkzf.

    RZCKACRCI @N CKIANKACF4 @u`f. Anrtnzf cknquïviaf

    Gf ijgcmfacñk `n `nstrucr oæs fggæ `n gf `u`f ngprckacpci `n ckiankacf, prnacsf `n anrtnzf cknquïviaf yfktn gf `u`f nstf an`n f lfvir `ng ckaif`i, yf qun ngocsoi sn nklrnktf nk `nscmufg`f` `n piscacikns fktn ngNstf`i.

    Gf Qfgf Rnkfg `n gf Airtn Quprnof `n Dustcacf hfsnktf`i pisturf rngnvfktn aik rnspnati f gf knansc`f``n anrtnzf nk gf augpfjcgc`f` `n gfs pnrsikfs siontc`fsf uk priansi pnkfg, pfrf qun gf snktnkacf rnafï`f`nvnkmf dustf, gf fusnkacf `n gf ocsof, vcigfnxprnsfonktn ng prckacpci `n ckiankacf qun aiklirofuki `n gis pcgfrns aikstctutcvis `ng kunvi priansi pnkfg

    ZNJNG@ÏF

    Rfrf ng ndnracaci `n gis `nrnahis priansfgns ns aik`cacñkcksisgfyfjgn qun ng dustcacfjgn nstn siontc`i f gisofk`ftis `n gf dustcacf5 nk afsi aiktrfrci - aioi nk ngsuj-nxfonk - ofg pun`n rnagfofr dustcacf qucnk sn

    ounstrf rnocsi fg auopgcocnkti `n gi `nac`c`i pir ng

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    33/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    1> 

    ñrmfki durcs`caacikfg aioi airigfrci `ng priansi pnkfg(\iti nk `csc`nkacf `n gf Ockcstrf Ruahntf `n Airrnf).

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ngrnaursi `n rnvcscñk

    Ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk, pir su nspnacfg kfturfgnzf, kirnaikian gf piscjcgc`f` `n primrnsi nxctisi f rnaursiscopgnonktf`is pir qucnkns ki nstæk siontc`is f gf

     durcs`caacñk y aiopntnkacf `ng ñrmfki durcs`caacikfg, kcjfsf`i nk frmuonktis qun ki sn aiopf`nank `n gfstfxftcvfs oitcvfacikns rnvcsirfs, kc ouahi onkis sijrnsupunstis mrfvæonkns afusf`is pir vcacis i nrrirns `ntcpi durï`cai qun sn nkaunktrfk, tnñrcafonktn,

    sujyfanktns nk gf snktnkacf copumkf`f, `njcnk`i`nagfrfrsn su ckf`ocscjcgc`f` y rnoctcrsn,ckon`cftfonktn, gis futis fg Duzmf`i `n ndnauacñkpnkfg `n ircmnk f gis nlnatis `n gf ndnauacñk `n gfsnktnkacf aik`nkftircf (\iti nk `csc`nkacf `n gfOckcstrf Ruahntf `n Airrnf).

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 616), ns `nacr, ki hffpirtf`i uk sipirtn durï`cai vfgn`nri qun `nounstrnqun gfs snktnkacfs pun`fk snr aiksc`nrf`fs ckdustfs nkrngfacñk f gf aik`nkf copunstf5 i qun airrnspik`ffpgcafr ukf gny oæs jnkcmkf y oi`clcqunk ng fspnatisustfkacfg `n gf rnsungti pir prconrf ckstfkacf.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    34/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    1:/:22=

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ng

    rnaursi `n rnvcscñk. Zn`uaacñk `n pnkf

    Qn hfan gumfr fg rnaursi `n rnvcscñk y sn rn`uan gf pnkfprcvftcvf `n gcjnrtf` copunstf aufk`i fg rnfgczfr ngtrcjukfg `n oãrcti ng nstu`ci sijrn ng frtïaugi `ng Añ`cmiRnkfg -on`cacñk `n gf pnkf- ki hf tiof`i nk aunktf ngnlnati `n gf pnkf pfrf ukf pnrsikf qun ki rnvcstn nk sï gfsafrfatnrïstcafs `n uk `ngckaunktn qun pun`f snraiksc`nrf`i `n nxtrnof pngcmrisc`f` pfrf gf siacn`f`,f`noæs `n gfs aiksnaunkacfs qun fafrrnfrïfk gf rnaguscñk

    nk uk nstfjgnacocnkti pnkctnkacfrci `n ukf pnrsikff`ugtf, qun jcnk pun`n rnf`fptfr su aik`uatf jfdi ukrãmconk `n gcjnrtf` fscstc`f, aioi tfopiai hf sipnsf`i kcaiksc`nrf`i gfs acraukstfkacfs nk qun sn suan`cnrik gishnahis qun `cnrik ircmnk fg cgïacti (fmrnscikns outufs).

    RNKF4 Zn`uaacñk `n gf pnkf

    Qn rn`uan gf pnkf prcvftcvf `n gcjnrtf` copunstf f gfaik`nkf`f aik ng jnknlcaci `n gf suspnkscñk f prunjf `ngf ndnauacñk `n gf aik`nkf, y gfs ijgcmfacikns f snrcopunstfs pir ng Duzmf`i `n Ndnauacñk, luk`fonktfgonktnpirqun ng nxansi pukctcvi, ki aikstctuyn fspcrfacñk `nnquc`f` y `n naufkcoc`f`5 y gfs acraukstfkacfs fkfgczf`fsaikdumfk ngnonktis lfvirfjgns ouy nspnacfgns nk gfprnsnktn afusf, gis qun aiklcmurfk uk mrf`i `n rnpriahnrn`uac`i, ijvcfonktn ti`i nggi sck oi`clcafrsn ng arctnrcisustnktf`i pir ng duzmf`ir nk rngfacñk f gis ngnonktisaikstctutcvis `ng hnahi pukcjgn farn`ctf`i nk futis.

    Ki airrnspik`n gf rn`uaacñk `n gf sfkacñk pnkfg copunstf

    f gf aik`nkf`f, pnkf prcvftcvf `n gcjnrtf` `n trns föis f`is föis, luk`f`i nk nxansi `n pfutfs tnopirfgns `nfpgcafacñk `ng qufktuo `n gf aik`nkf nk rngfacñk fg cgïactipnrpntrf`i, gi qun aikstctuyn uk qucnjrn `ng prckacpci `npripiracikfgc`f`, nk ftnkacñk fg prnanpti aikstctuacikfgaiktnkc`i nk ng frtïaugi :2 `n gf Aikstctuacñk, ng aufgmufr`f rngfacñk aik ng ijdnti y gis lckns `n gf pnkf (\iti nk`csc`nkacf `n gf Ockcstrf Fgcacf Ruahntf `n Airrnf).

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    35/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    1= 

    FA^NZ@IQ S QNKPNKACFQ

    FÖI :228

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    36/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    18 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² >=/:228

    D^ZCQRZ^@NKACF4 Afojci `n durcspru`nkacfZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ngrnaursi

    Qn rnahfzf, pir coprian`nktn ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk,aufk`i ng rnvcscikcstf prntnk`n gf fpgcafacñk  ‑   siprntnxti `n snr oæs lfvirfjgn  ‑  `n ukf durcspru`nkacfaf`uaf y fktnrcir f gf snktnkacf aik`nkftircf, aufk`iqun ng rnqucscti nxcmc`i ns qun gf durcspru`nkacfsusanptcjgn `n snr fpgcaf`f snf gf vcmnktn aioiaiksnaunkacf `ng afojci qun hf onrnac`i y pistnrcir f

    gf snktnkacf aik`nkftircf nk rnvcscñk.

    ZNJNG@ÏF4 Nlnatis `n gf `nagfrfacñk rnjng`ïf

    RZIANQI RNKFG4 Fatis priansfgns. @urfacñk `ng prian`cocnkti pnkfg. Añoputi `ng tãrocki nk ng priansi pnkfg

    RZNQAZCRACÑK4 Cktnrrupacñk `n gf prnsarcpacñk. Quspnkscñk `ngf prnsarcpacñk

    Ng Frt. 81 `ng ARR sijrn suspnkscñk `n gf ckvnstcmfacñkocnktrfs `urn gf rnjng`ïf, ki gnmcsgf nk gi ftcknktn fg pgfzi5ng ocsoi prntnk`n copn`cr qun ng priansi priscmf yfgafkan ng nstf`i `n rnsiguacñk aikaguscvf, nk fusnkacf `ngckaif`i, pfrtn nsnkacfg nk ng priansi. Nk afojci ng Frt.61

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    37/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    13 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 632/:228

    GNQCÑK @N AIKLCFKTF. Fjsiguacñk

    Aufk`i rnafn ukf snktnkacf aik`nkftircf (pir gnscñk `naiklcfkzf) ‑  lcron y ndnautircf ‑  nk uk hnahi pukcjgn `nkfturfgnzf pftrcoikcfg, `ik`n ng futir hf `nsvcf`ilik`is, pfrf sï i tnranri, ki pun`n f`octcrsn qun ngaik`nkf`i tnkmf `nrnahi f gf fjsiguacñk pir vïf `nrnvcscñk pir hfjnr `nsfpfrnac`i ng pnrducaci pftrcoikcfgqun hf afusf`i aik su aik`uatf cgïactf (pir ndnopgi gfnktc`f` pnrdu`caf`f gimrf qun gf noprnsf `n snmuri`nvungvf ti`i i pfrtn `n gi `nsvcf`i), gi aufgaikggnvfrïf f ukf ckf`ocscjgn fgtnrfacñk `n afusf y

    nlnati, punsti qun nstn ôgtcoi suprcocrïf fg ijdnti qungn `ci ircmnk y sck ng aufg ki pu`i hfjnr nxcstc`i5ckaguscvn, `n snr fjsungti i snf rn`uac`f su pnkf, nsprijfjgn qun rnagfon `nrnahi ck`nokczftirci.

    D^ZCQRZ^@NKACF4 Durcspru`nkacf kiroftcvf  Fg aikdukti `n lfggis aickac`nktns sijrn gfcktnrprntfacñk `n gf gny pnkfg  ‑   `iatrckfrcfonktnaikiac`f aioi durcspru`nkacf kiroftcvf  ‑   ns qun ng

    gnmcsgf`ir pnkfg gn rnaikian c`iknc`f` oitcvfacikfg pfrfrnspfg`fr ng rnaursi rnvcscvi rnagfofk`i su fpgcafacñkpnrsikfgczf`f nk ng afsi aikarnti f qucnk sn nkanktrfnk cmufg acraukstfkacf `n fqung f qucnk sn pri`cmñ gfcktnrprntfacñk arnf`irf `n gf durcspru`nkacf y nk gfon`c`f qun gn rnsugtn lfvirfjgn.Gf durcspru`nkacf f gf qun hfan rnlnrnkacf gf gny nsnktnk`c`f nk gf fanptfacñk aikarntf `n su rnmugfacñk, gflirof aikair`fktn nk qun gf Airtn Quprnof `n Dustcacfsn prikukacf nk ipirtukc`f` `n rnsigvnr afsis

    scocgfrns, arnfk`i fsï uk aikdukti `n lfggis aiktnstns yukclirons qun `ntnrockfk gf arnfacñk `n kirofs irnmgfs qun, aioi nxprnscñk `n vfgirfacñk vcmnktns, sikutcgczf`fs pir gis ofmcstrf`is aioi dustclcafacñk `ngafræatnr durï`cafonktn ijdntcvi qun rnvcstnk sus lfggis yqun sn ckstfgfk nk gf aikacnkacf `n gf aioukc`f`

     durï`caf aikstctuyãk`isn nk lunktn ̀ ng `nrnahi.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    38/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    02 

    Aisf Duzmf`f

    Gf futirc`f` `n gf aisf duzmf`f an`n pir gfjnknvignkacf qun nktrföf pfrf ng aik`nkf`i gf

    fpfrcacñk `n ukf durcspru`nkacf (nxtrf  ‑   fatcvc`f` durcspru`nkacfg) qun gi lfvirnan, gf aufg pnronf gfcktfkmcjcgc`f` `n gf aisf duzmf`f qun, sc jcnk nstæsustnktf`f nk ukf vnr`f` lirofg, an`n y ns sustctuc`fpir gf futãktcaf y pgnkf vnr`f` lirofg, qun fkc`f nk ngf`vnkcocnkti `n gis lfggis durcspru`nkacfgns qunlfvirnank fg aik`nkf`i, pir fpgcafacñk `n ukf

     durcspru`nkacf oæs jnkcmkf ki sn qucnrn aikan`nr fgcktnrnsf`i gf sctufacñk oæs jnkãvigf `nktri `n ukscstnof rnprnscvi titfg, scki prckacpfgonktn nk ng

    aiktnxti `n gf gny pnkfg cktnrprntf`f nk lirof oæsjnknlcacisf, gi qun nxcmn ng fdustn `n gf oftnrcfsiontc`f f rnvcscñk f gis fgafkans qun sujyfank nk nggf.

    Ng lfggi ckviaf`i  ‑   f tïtugi `n durcspru`nkacf oæsjnkcmkf - ki ns tfg, aufk`i sn trftf `n ukf sigfsnktnkacf i ôkcaf `nacscñk qun ki arnf durcspru`nkacfnk tfkti y nk aufkti ki sftcslfan gf nxcmnkacf `naikstrucr aikdukti `n lfggis lcrons, aiktnstns y

    ukclirons nofkf`is `n gf Airtn Quprnof `n Dustcacfnk gf rnsiguacñk `n afsis scocgfrns.

    Gf durcspru`nkacf f gf qun fgu`n gf kirof ckviaf`f(ARR, frt. 086 cka. >) scnoprn prnsupikn gf nxcstnkacf`n lfggis qun rnaikiank acnrtf aiktckuc`f` yukcliroc`f` rnsigutcvf sijrn ukf ocsof aunstcñk y nkgfs qun sn fpgcafk, ckvfrcfjgnonktn, arctnrcissnondfktns, mnknræk`isn gf durcspru`nkacf kiroftcvfqun aikstctuyn gf nsnkacf `n gf afsuïstcaf rnvcsirf

    nxfockf`f. Gis lfggis qun ki rnôknk nstfsafrfatnrïstcafs, f gi suoi pun`nk mizfr `n gfaiksc`nrfacñk `n prnan`nktn du`cacfg, scrvcnk`iôkcafonktn aioi fpiyi f ukf `ntnrockf`f tnscssistnkc`f nk ducaci, pnri ki `ng rfkmi `n durcspru`nkacffg afrnanr `n futãktcai aiktnkc`i kiroftcvi.

    GNQCÑK @N AIKLCFKTF4 Rnrducaci pftrcoikcfg

    Ng `föi pftrcoikcfg qun ipnrf aioi ngnonkti ijdntcvi`ng tcpi pnkfg `n gnscñk `n aiklcfkzf ki qun`f

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    39/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    06 

    acrauksarcti f gis pnrducacis `ntnrockf`is pir vfgirnspnaukcfrcis kiockfgns, scki tfojcãk ckaguyn aufktïfsoikntfrcfs mnknrf`fs pir gf ck`cspikcjcgc`f` `n gis

    lik`is `nsvcf`is y gfs aiksnaunktns pnr`c`fsnonrmnktns `n gf lrustrfacñk `n gf lckfgc`f` qun hfckspcrf`i fg priansi `n gcquc`facñk `n gfs nktc`f`nsjfkafrcfs ckviguarf`fs, qun, dustfonktn, lunrik ijdnti`n ckmnktns pnrducacis aioi aiksnaunkacf `n qun susnkafrmf`is gi hfk ggnvf`i f afji sck sudnacñk f gis`njnrns `n gnfgtf` y lc`ngc`f` qun prnsc`nk gf rngfacñk`n aiklcfkzf nktrn f`ockcstrf`irns y f`ockcstrf`is.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Hnahi kunvi  

    Ng hnahi fgnmf`i ‑  rntirki fg pfïs `n ukf mrfk pfrtn `ngis lik`is `nsvcf`is  ‑   ki sn nkauf`rf `nktri `n gfaftnmirïf `n hnahi kivn`isi nk rfzñk `n qun sn trftfjf`n ukf aunstcñk nvnktufg i hcpitãtcaf y piraikscmucnktn, sn hfyf `f`i i ki `cahi faiktnacocnktiaik pistnrcirc`f` fg `catf`i `n gf snktnkacf, hf sc`ioftnrcf fopgcfonktn `njftc`f y `n auyi airigfrcirnafyñ gf snktnkacf aik`nkftircf pir gf qun sn flcroñ gfnxcstnkacf `ng pnrducaci pftrcoikcfg (gnscñk `naiklcfkzf) aik fjsigutf prnsack`nkacf `n qun gf suof`cknrfrcf `nsvcf`f pu`cnrf snr titfg i pfracfgonktnrnaupnrf`f.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² :3:/:228

    NQAZCP^ZF RÔJGCAF4 Zn`frmuacñk `n lfgsn`f`. \fgir prijftirci `n gf nsarcturf

    Gf nsarcturf pôjgcaf tcnkn afræatnr prijftirci, hfan ln y

    scrvn `n pgnkf prunjf sijrn gis hnahis qun nkukacf ngnsarcjfki aioi auopgc`is pir gf ocsof5 sijrn gishnahis qun gf ln`ftfrcf nkukacf aioi pfsf`is nk suprnsnkacf, nsti ns, qun gi pnracjc`i pnrsikfgonktn ysijrn gfs ofkclnstfacikns qun gis itirmfktns icktnrvckcnktns nk ng fati hfk lirougf`i nk su prnsnkacf5ki f`octcãk`isn gf scopgn prunjf nk aiktrfrci, pir giqun pfrf snr `nsvcrtuf`is ns onknstnr hfanrgi on`cfktnng `cspisctcvi `n gf rn`frmuacñk `n lfgsn`f`.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    40/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    0: 

    Ki hfank ln kc pgnkf prunjf gf vnrfac`f` `n gfsofkclnstfacikns qun hfank gfs pfrtns itirmfktn icktnrvckcnktns nk gf nsarcturf pôjgcaf, ng nsarcjfki sigi

    `f ln `n qun gfs ofkclnstfacikns sn nlnatufrik, ofs ki`n su sckanrc`f` i vnrfac`f`, gis aufgns pun`nk snr`nsvcrtuf`is pir scopgn prunjf nk aiktrfrci sckknansc`f` `n rnaurrcr f gf rn`frmuacñk `n lfgsn`f`.

    RZCKACRCI @N D^@CACFGC@F@

    @NAGFZFACÑK CKLIZOFPC\F

    RZ^NJF @N PNQPCMIQ4 F`ocscjcgc`f` `n gf prunjftnstcoikcfg

    Gfs `nagfrfacikns, aufgqucnrf snf su oi`fgc`f`

    (tnstcoikcfg i ckliroftcvf) `njn snr rnanpacikf`f pir ng dunz `n gf afusf i fktn ng dunz `ngnmf`i y ki fktn itrfpnrsikf afrnktn `n ckvnstc`urf durcs`caacikfg. Nstfnxcmnkacf nstæ fopfrf`f pir ng prckacpci `n gf

     du`cacfgc`f` `n gis tnstcoikcis qun `njnk anrrfr ngacraucti `n aiopgntcvc`f` qun nxcmn gf gny pfrf qunf`qucnrfk lunrzf prijftircf c`ñknf.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 080/:228

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ngrnaursi `n rnvcscñkRNKFQ4 Rnkfs prckacpfgns

    Airrnspik`n hfanr gumfr fg rnaursi `n rnvcscñk5 fkugfrgf aik`nkf nk aikanpti `n ougtf, `ndfk`i sujscstnktngf prcvfacñk `n gcjnrtf` pir ackai föis, punsti qun kiairrnspik`n gf sfkacñk f pnkf aikduktf `n prcvfacñk `ngcjnrtf` y ougtf nk rfzñk `n qun fojfs sik prckacpfgns(frt. 61= `ng Añ`cmi Rnkfg) y sñgi prian`n fpgcafr ukf `n

    nggfs.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 08

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    41/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    01 

    Rrckacpci `n huofkc`f`

    Rir ng prckacpci `n huofkc`f` `n gfs pnkfs, ng duzmf`irfg fpgcafrgfs `njn tiofr nk aiksc`nrfacñk, ki sigi qun

    aik nggi sn jusaf gf pritnaacñk `n gf siacn`f` fgndfk`ifg cklrfatir `ng kôagni `n gis `noæs ck`cvc`uis, scki qungf pnrsikf qun snræ aik`nkf`f ns sudnti `n `nrnahi yaioi tfg `njnk aiksc`nrfrsn ti`is gis ngnonktis qun giri`nfk f gis nlnatis `n copiknr gf sfkacñk pukctcvf y nkng afsi, aioi ng prnsnktn, `ik`n nxcstn ukfoi`clcafacñk gnmcsgftcvf, qun nvnktufgonktn pun`nondirfr su sctufacñk nk aufkti f gis föis `n prcvfacñk`n gcjnrtf`, nktikans f`iptfr gf on`c`fs knansfrcfs fgrnspnati.

    Lfaugtf`ns `csarnacikfgns `ng trcjukfg. Aufktclcafacñk `n gf pnkf. Gny oæs jnkcmkf

    Gf aufktclcafacñk `n gf pnkf ki ns oftnrcf `n fkægcscs`n kckmuki `n gis trcjukfgns `n fgzf`f ( Prcjukfg `nFpngfacñk y Airtn Quprnof `n Dustcacf), puns gf ocsofaikstctuyn ukf aunstcñk qun nstæ `ngcoctf`f pfrf gflukacñk `n gis trcjukfgns `n ducaci, sfgvi qun sn trftn `ngf`vnkcocnkti `n ukf gny oæs jnkcmkf y sn rnfgcan ukf

    rn`uaacñk onrfonktn oftnoætcaf, sck vigvnr f fkfgczfr,pfrf gf aufktclcafacñk, ng mrf`i `n rnpriahn y gfsacraukstfkacfs pnrsikfgns y læatcafs yf fprnacf`fs`nktri `ng ducaci pnkfg.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Znaursi `n rnvcscñk nk ng priansi pnkfg

    GNS RNKFG4 Gny pnkfg oæs jnkcmkf

    Qn hfan gumfr fg rnaursi `n rnvcscñk aufk`i ki sftcslfanaiopgntfonktn f gf fpgcafacñk `n gf gny pnkfg oæs

    jnkcmkf, ukf rn`uaacñk futioætcaf `n gf pnkf copunstfaioi oæxcof pir gf gny fktnrcir (12 föis) f gf oæxcofpiscjgn `ng kunvi scstnof (:> föis), ijvcfk`i `n nstfofknrf qun ãstf ôgtcof sn lcdf sijrn gf jfsn ki sigi `ngrnsugtf`i `föisi, scki prckacpfgonktn `n gfsaik`cacikns pnrsikfgns `ng futir, pir gi aufg ns `nnstrcatf dustcacf oi`clcafr gf aik`nkf copunstf tiofk`iaioi jfsn gi `cspunsti pir gis frts. 6 (Gnmfgc`f`)5 :(rnpriahfjcgc`f` y pripiracikfgc`f`), 1 (prnvnkacñk), 18

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    42/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    00 

    (`urfacñk `n gf pnkf prcvftcvf `n gcjnrtf`) y (jfsns`n gf on`cacñk `n gf pnkf), `ng añ`cmi pnkfg.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑKGNS RNKFG4 Gny pnkfg oæs jnkcmkf  

    Rfrf qun nxcstf gf afusfg `n gny oæs jnkcmkf, `njnnxcstcr uk afojci nk gf gnmcsgfacñk, y ki aioi prntnk`nng rnvcscikcstf, yf qun ki ns lfatcjgn rnfgczfr uk nstu`ci`n gf vfgirfacñk `n gfs acraukstfkacfs ftnkufktns ifmrfvfktns `n gis hnahis, aioi jfsn `n gf on`cacñk `ngf pnkf, pir ki snr `cahfs aunstcikns oftnrcf `nrnvcscñk `n aikliroc`f` f gf nkuonrfacñk tfxftcvf `ngis oitcvis `ng frtïaugi 086 `ng Añ`cmi Rriansfg Rnkfg

    (\iti nk `csc`nkacf `n gf Ockcstrf Ruahntf `n Airrnf).

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² =10/:228

    L^KACIKFZCI RÔJGCAI4 Znspiksfjcgc`f` pnkfg

    Nk gis afsis `n rnspiksfjcgc`f` `n lukacikfrcispôjgcais pir `ngctis afgclcaf`is nk ng Añ`cmi Rnkfg, gf

     durcs`caacñk aiopntnktn ns gf Rnkfg (\iti nk `csc`nkacf`n gf Ockcstrf Ruahntf `n Airrnf).

    COR^PFACÑK IJDNPC\F. Zcnsmis pnroctc`is. Zcnsmis prihcjc`is

    Nk ng kunvi scstnof punsti pir ng Añ`cmi Rnkfg, snpripumkf gf tnirïf lckfgcstf y ãstf ns gf tnirïf `n gfcoputfacñk ijdntcvf, qun sistcnkn qun nk gf vc`foi`nrkf f`ockcstrfois rcnsmis y ki qun`f oæs quntignrfr nsis rcnsmis, qun pun`nk snr rcnsmis pnroctc`is

     y rcnsmis prihcjc`is.

    GNQCÑK @N AIKLCFKTFZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Hnahi kunvi. Znsiguacñk `ngPrcjukfg `n Aunktfs

    Qn hfan gumfr fg rnaursi `n rnvcscñk pirqun ng hnahikunvi fmrnmf`i f futis, Faunr`i y Qnktnkacf `catf`ipir ng Prcjukfg `n Aunktfs, ng aufg rnsigvcñ qun gisrnaursis `ng Nstf`i, nopgnf`is pir ng Mfjckntn Acvcg `ngf Rrnsc`nkacf `n gf Znpôjgcaf airrnspik`cnktn fgNdnracaci Lcsafg `ng föi 6333 hfk sc`i fpgcaf`isgnmfgonktn, ns aiksc`nrf`i pgnkf prunjf, `nounstrf

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    43/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    0> 

    qun ng hnahi aiontc`i pir ng aik`nkf`i, ki ns pukcjgn,`njc`i f gf cknxcstnkacf `ng rnqucscti ck`cspnksfjgn `ng`föi pftrcoikcfg y `ng `ngcti `n gnscñk `n aiklcfkzf.

    HNAHI R^KCJGN4 Aik`uatf `ng aik`nkf`i. Mfstis rnsnrvf`is

    Gf aik`uatf `ng aik`nkf`i `nktri `ng æojcti pnkfg kiaikstctuyn hnahi pukcjgn, puns ki nxcstn pnrducacipftrcoikcfg fgmuki fg Nstf`i, f oæs `n, trftfrsn `nmfstis rnsnrvf`is, gf utcgczfacñk `n gis ocsois kipun`n rnvnstcr uk hnahi pukcjgn (\iti nk `csc`nkacf `ngf Ockcstrf Ruahntf `n Airrnf).

    RZND^@CACFGC@F@

    Ng lfggi nk aunstcñk, `catf`i pir ng Prcjukfg `n Aunktfs,Qnmuk`f Qfgf, ki aikstctuyn ukf aunstcñk prndu`cacfg,

     yf qun nstn ns rnsugtf`i `n uk ducaci f`ockcstrftcvi, ngocsoi ki ckvnstcmf gf aiocscñk `n `ngctis aiktrf gff`ockcstrfacñk pôjgcaf kc duzmf f sus futirns, fktn nstfsctufacñk, gf lcsafgïf pun`n ckcacfr gf ckvnstcmfacñkpfrfgngfonktn fg ducaci `n rnk`cacñk `n aunktfs, sck qunng ocsoi copirtn ukf sunrtn `n `ijgn duzmfocnkti, pirtfg, gf `nacscñk qun rnafynrn nk ng lunri f`ockcstrftcviki afusfrf nstf`i nk rngfacñk fg lunri pnkfg, yvcanvnrsf (\iti nk `csc`nkacf `n gf Ockcstrf Ruahntf `nAirrnf).

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² =>:/:228  

    @NAGFZFACÑK @NG COR^PF@I4 @nagfrfacñk ck`fmftircf.Nvfgufacñk nk aiktrf `ng coputf`i

    @ng fkægcscs `ng frtïaugi 3< `ng ARR sn `nsprnk`n qun gf`nagfrfacñk ck`fmftircf pun`n snr tnkc`f ckaguscvn nk

    aiktrf `ng fausf`i, yf qun gf gny nxprnsf qun nsti ki snpi`ræ hfanr sc ns qun ng fati ki rnvcstcñ gfslirofgc`f`ns rnqunrc`fs. Nk gf Aikstctuacñk y ng Rfati`n Qfk Disã `n Aistf Zcaf, ki nxcstn prihcjcacñk fgmukfpfrf nvfgufr gf `nagfrfacñk `ng coputf`i nk su aiktrf.

    Nk kunstrf gnmcsgfacñk kf`f ck`caf qun gf `nagfrfacñkck`fmftircf ki pun`f snr nvfguf`f nk aiktrf `ngfausf`i.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    44/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    00/:228  

    F@IGNQANKPN CKLZFAPIZ

    Ns ckfpgcafjgn ng Añ`cmi `n gf Kcönz y gf F`ignsankacf fgafsi aikarnti, ti`f vnz qun ng aik`nkf`i, fg tcnopi `ngf rnfgczfacñk `ng hnahi, hf sijrnpfsf`i gf lrfkdf ntfrcfaujcnrtf pir gf gny y pir nk`n, nxaguc`i `ng aiktnxtikiroftcvi qun rnmugf ng scstnof `n pukcacñk `n gisf`ignsanktns f gf guz `n gf prnvcscñk aiktnkc`f nk ngFrt. 63:, nknrvfk`i tfojcãk ti`f piscjcgc`f` `n gffpgcafacñk `ng Frt. :2= `ng ocsoi aunrpi gnmfg, punstiqun gf fpgcafacñk `n nstn ôgtcoi, nstæ aik`cacikf`i fqun gf n`f` jcigñmcaf `ng dustcacfjgn ki fgafkan gis`cnaciahi föis auopgc`is.

    On`c`f prcvftcvf `n gcjnrtf`. Cktnrãs Qupnrcir

    Fg ki snr ng aik`nkf`i f`ignsanktn fg tcnopi `n hfjnr

    aiontc`i ng hnahi qun scrvcñ `n mãknscs f gf sfkacñkpnkfg qun sn gn fpgcañ, ofg pun`n prntnk`nr fpripcfrsn`n gis jnknlcacis qun airrnspik`nk pir gny f itris`nstckftfrcis (8 föis `n on`c`f prcvftcvf `n gcjnrtf`)qun, fopfrf`is pir ng prckacpci `n cktnrãs supnrcir,nstæk siontc`is f ukf nspnacfg rnmugfacñk, ukfnstruaturf gñmcaf, uk aikdukti froikcisi ck`csmrnmfjgn`n `cspisctcvis pnkfgns `n lik`i y lirof `n afræatnrtuctcvi y n`uafacikfg qun rnaikian uk priluk`i afojci

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    45/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    0= 

    `n gf aikacnkacf aioukctfrcf nk rngfacñk f gis onkirnscklrfatirns `n gf gny pnkfg.

    Rfrf snr sudnti `ng Añ`cmi `n gf Kcönz y `n gfF`ignsankacf ns aik`cacñk qun ng cklrfatir `n gf gnypnkfg tnkmf afgc`f` `n f`ignsanktn- nktrn aftiran y`cnacscntn föis- fg tcnopi `n rnfgczfr gf aik`uatfpukcjgn. Ng hnahi `n qun nk su priansfocnkti sn hfyfkfpgcaf`i gfs rnmgfs `ng Frt. 0:= `ng ARR (Rrian`cocnktipfrf Onkirns), pir trftfrsn `n ukf aunstcñk `n ir`nkpriansfg, ki tcnkn ckac`nkacf nk gf ofyir i onkir`urfacñk `n gf sfkacñk pnkfg fpgcafjgn y qun nknsnkacf, ns oftnrcf `ng `nrnahi pnkfg `n lik`i.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 82>/:228  FAGFZFPIZCF

    Gf aiktrf`caacñk nktrn ng aiksc`nrfk`i y gf pfrtnrnsigutcvf ns uk nrrir sujsfkfjgn on`cfktn ng rnaursi`n fagfrftircf, ki pgfktnf`i ipirtukfonktn.

    GNS RNKFG4 Gny pnkfg oæs jnkcmkf

    Gf gny oæs lfvirfjgn pun`n snr `n lik`i i `n lirof ypistnrcir f gf snktnkacf `nlckctcvf.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 61::/:228

    @^@F

    Ng prckacpci `n qun `u`f dunmf f lfvir `ng priansf`i nsvcigf`f aufk`i nk gfs snktnkacfs aik`nkftircfs, gfocsof ns utcgczf`f nk aiktrf `ng fausf`i, lirdfk`i ukfsupunstf anrtnzf ki nxcstnktn scqucnrf nk ng ngnonktiijdntcvi `ng tcpi, pnrducaci pftrcoikcfg, onkis fôk ng

    `igi.

    CK @^JCI RZI ZNI4 Rrckacpci `n ckiankacf. Anrtnzf.Fjsiguacñk  

    Ns knansfrcf anrtnzf nk gf augpfjcgc`f` `n gfs pnrsikfssiontc`fs f uk priansi pnkfg, pfrf qun gf snktnkacfrnafï`f `nvnkmf dustf. Gf fusnkacf `n gf ocsof, vcigfnxprnsfonktn ng prckacpci `n ckiankacf qun aiklirofuki `n gis pcgfrns aikstctutcvis `ng kunvi priansipnkfg.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    46/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    08 

    Ng ck `ujci pri rni, ns ukf rnmgf `n ducaci qun dunmf nkoftnrcf prijftircf frridfk`i gf afrmf `n gf augpfjcgc`f`

    `ng coputf`i sijrn gf pfrtn fausf`irf, gf qun `njnrætrfjfdfr pfrf prijfrgf oæs fggæ `n ti`f `u`f rfzikfjgn,`n ofknrf qun ki nxcstn nsn mrf`i `n anrtnzf, pnrscstnng nstftus jæscai `n gcjnrtf` copikcãk`isn gffjsiguacñk.

    GNQCÑK @N AIKLCFKTF4 Aiksuofacñk y augockfacñk.Aikaguscñk `ng cgïacti

    Gf gnscñk `n aiklcfkzf ns uk `ngcti qun `njn`ntnrockfrsn fktn gf ukc`f` `n gf mnstcñk, ki pun`n

    lrfmonktfrsn, onkis pfrf su fkægcscs5 puns nsnxprnscñk `ng ofkndi `n uk aikdukti `n jcnkns, yf qunaf`f ipnrfacñk lirof pfrtn `n gf f`ockcstrfacñk.

    Nk gf gnscñk `n aiklcfkzf ng jcnk pritnmc`i ns ngpftrcoikci, gi afrfatnrïstcai ns su pfrtcaugfr lirof `ngnscikfr ng pftrcoikci fdnki on`cfktn gf cklrfaacñk `ng`njnr `n lc`ngc`f` qun aiontn uk futir5 ng `njnr `nauc`f`i auyi ircmnk ns gf prcvcgnmcf`f piscacñk qun

    iaupf ng fmnktn rnspnati `n gf f`ockcstrfacñk `n gisjcnkns naikñocais fdnkis aiklcf`is f su afrmi.

    Gf aiksuofacñk `ng `ngcti (gnscñk sn aiklcfkzf) snprnacsf fg oionkti `ng qucnjrn `ng pftrcoikci nk`ntrconkti `ng pritnmc`i, ns `nacr fg oionkti nk qun snrnfgczf ng pnrducaci, y sn jnknlcacf ng futir, y nstn`npnk`n `n su aiktnkc`i, pfrf `ntnrockfrsn nk guariansfktn i `föi nonrmnktn, pnri fojis rnqucnrnk `ngpriansi `n aiksuofacñk y augockfacñk aik ng rnsugtf`i

    nlnatcvi y prijf`i, ng pnrducaci.

    @urfktn gf mnstcñk `ng fmnktn, ns `nacr fg tãrocki `n gfmnstcñk f`ockcstrftcvf `n austi`cf `ng pftrcoikci fdnki,ns aufk`i aikaguyn gf piscjgn pnrpntrfacñk `ng cgïacti(gnscñk `n aiklcfkzf), y aufk`i sn `ntnrockf ngrnsugtf`i.

    RZ^NJF4 Kugc`f`

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    47/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    03 

    Gf ijtnkacñk `n prunjfs `n lirof cgnmfg, vcacf `nkugc`f` ãstfs, pikn nk tngf `n ducaci su vnrfac`f`, sc kins fopfrf`f aik itris ngnonktis `ntnrockfktns `n gf

    anrtnzf qun prntnk`nk `noistrfr, y aufk`i nsf piscjgncgnmfgc`f` ki vcign kirofs aikstctuacikfgns.

    QNKPNKACF AIK@NKFPIZCF4 Anrtnzf fjsigutircf

    Ng Prcjukfg `n Oãrcti hf `ntnrockf`i qun ng aik`nkf`ilun ofg f`ockcstrf`ir `n ukf lirof fkñofgf `nrfzikfocnkti gñmcai, f trfvãs `n ukf pnrcacf aiktfjgn, giqun sc ki sn nkaunktrf ukc`i f itrfs prunjfs qun gi`itnk `n gf lunrzf knansfrcf pfrf aikstctucrgi nk anrtnzffjsigutf sijrn gi prnsuoc`i, ki pi`rïf aikstctucr

    kukaf sustnkti `n aik`nkf.

    PCRI RNKFG4 Knxi afsufg

    Ng knxi afusfg `ntnrockf`i `n aikliroc`f` f gf tnirïf`n gf aik`ctci sckn quf kik,  `n gf nqucvfgnkacf `n gfsaik`cacikns, sn `ntnrockf nk `is snktc`is, prconri nkgf rnprnsnktfacñk `ng hnahi pir pfrtn `ng futir, supripcf afusfgc`f` nk ng cgïacti, y pistnrcironktn gfafusfgc`f` nxtnk c̀`f f gf rnfgczfacñk ocsof, ns `nacr, gfnxtnrcirczf`f. 

    Qujsukacñk `ng tcpi pnkfg

    Qc fg suprcocr f gf pnrsikf fkfgczf`f nk gf prnmuktf `nsujsukacñk, ng hnahi nk sï ki iaurrn i afojcf ngrnsugtf`i, pir gi tfkti sn `ntnrockf gf afusfgc`f` `ngocsoi nk ng rnsugtf`i y sc nk su afsi ng hnahi, ngrnsugtf`i ki vfrïf, nktikans scopgnonktn gf afusfgc`f``ng supunsti pfrtïacpn ki nstæ prijf`f, kc `noistrf`f.

    Gf `ntnrockfacñk `n knxi afusfg ns ckhnrnktn f gfpiscjcgc`f` `n fpgcafr ukf aik`nkf, yf qun gf prnmuktf`n sujsukacñk pfrf `ntnrockfr ukf aik`uatf `nktri `nuk tcpi pnkfg, knansctf ng fkægcscs `n gis ngnonktisijdntcvis y sujdntcvis `ng tcpi gnmfg, ns `nacr `nktri `nãstis prconris sn rnqucnrnk knansfrcfonktn 6´ ng ijdnti5:´ ng rnsugtf`i5 y 1´ ng knxi afusfg.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    48/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    >2 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 61:0/:228

    GNS RNKFG4 Gny pnkfg oæs jnkcmkf

    Gf gny oæs jnkcmkf `njn snr itrf, `n lik`i i `n lirof,sfkacikf`f `nspuãs `n gf snktnkacf rnaurrc`f. Gfjnknvignkacf `n gf gny `njn on`crsn nktrn gf kiroftcvfvcmnktn fg oionkti `n aiontnr ng hnahi y gf kunvf gnyqun nktrn f rnmcr aik pistnrcirc`f` f gf snktnkacf`nlckctcvf ftfaf`f.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Znaursi `n rnvcscñk nk ng priansi pnkfg ocgctfr

    Gf rnvcscikcstf prntnk`n gf fpgcafacñk `ng frt. 6>2 `ng

    Añ`cmi Rnkfg Ocgctfr, ns `nacr `ng ocsoi aunrpikiroftcvi yf nopgnf`i nk gf snktnkacf `nlckctcvfrnaurrc`f. Ki prian`n gf rnvcscñk.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 6111/:228

    RNKF4 Zn`uaacñk `n gf pnkf

    Gf Airtn Quprnof `n Dustcacf, Qfgf Rnkfg, nk

    rnctnrf`is lfggis, sn hf prikukacf`i f lfvir `n gfrn`uaacñk `n gf aik`nkf scnoprn y aufk`i nxcstf`nspripiracñk nktrn ng mrf`i `n rnpriahn `ng futir y ngqufktuo `n gf pnkf copunstf. 

    Aufktclcafacñk `n gf pnkf

    Gf aufktclcafacñk `n gf pnkf ki ns oftnrcf `n fkægcscs`n kckmuki `n gis Prcjukfgns `n Fgzf`f (nktcãk`fsn pirtfg  ‑   Prcjukfg `n Fpngfacñk y Airtn Quprnof `n

     Dustcacf), puns gf ocsof aikstctuyn ukf lukacñk `n gis

     Prcjukfgns `n Ducaci, sfgvi qun sn trftn `ngf`vnkcocnkti `n ukf gny oæs jnkcmkf y sn rnfgcan ukfrn`uaacñk onrfonktn oftnoætcaf, sck fkfgczfr pfrf gfaufktclcafacñk, ng mrf`i `n rnpriahn y gfs acraukstfkacfspnrsikfgns y læatcafs yf fprnacf`fs `nktri `ng ducacipnkfg (\iti nk `csc`nkacf `n gf Ockcstrf Ruahntf `nAirrnf). 

    Ki airrnspik`n, vïf rnaursi `n rnvcscñk, fkfgczfrkunvfonktn gis lfatirns aiktnkc`is nk ng frtïaugi `ng

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    49/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    >6 

    Añ`cmi Rnkfg pfrf gf on`cacñk `n gf pnkf, tfrnf pripcf`ng trcjukfg `n oãrcti (\iti nk `csc`nkacf `n gf OckcstrfRuahntf `n Airrnf).

    Rrckacpci `n pripiracikfgc`f`

    @n gis frmuonktis læatcais y durï`cais qun scrvcnrik `nsustnkti f gis lfggis, nlnatcvfonktn sn nvc`nkacf uknxansi nk gfs pfutfs tnopirfgns `n fpgcafacñk `ngqufktuo `n gf aik`nkf nk rngfacñk fg cgïacti pnrpntrf`i,gi qun ck`u`fjgnonktn aikstctuyn uk qucnjrn `ngprckacpci `n pripiracikfgc`f`, nk ftnkacñk fg prnanptiaikstctuacikfg aiktnkc`i nk ng frtïaugi :2 `n gfAikstctuacñk, ng aufg mufr`f rngfacñk aik ng ijdnti y gis

    lckns `n gf pnkf.

    On`cacñk `n gf pnkf. Lfaugtf`ns `csarnacikfgns `ng trcjukfg

    Nk ng nstu`ci `ng frtïaugi `ng Añ`cmi Rnkfg ‑ on`cacñk`n gf pnkf-, ng trcjukfg ki hf tiof`i nk aunktf ngnlnati `n gf pnkf nk gf vc`f luturf nk siacn`f` `ngaik`nkf`i, ftnk`cnk`i f su afgc`f` `n `ngckaunktnprcofrci y gfs pnrkcacisfs aiksnaunkacfs qunfafrrnfrïfk gf rnaguscñk nk uk nstfjgnacocnkti

    pnkctnkacfrci `n ukf pnrsikf f`ugtf, aik prnpfrfacñkfaf`ãocaf ocgctfr, qun pir gf oi`fgc`f` `n gf aiocscñk`ng ckdusti pnkfgonktn rnprijf`i, ki rnvcstn nk sï gfsafrfatnrïstcafs `n uk `ngckaunktn qun pun`f snraiksc`nrf`i `n nxtrnof pngcmrisc`f` pfrf gf siacn`f`,pir gi aufg, ki sn dustclcaf gf pnrscstnkacf `n ukfaik`nkf qun nk ng afsi pfrtcaugfr, rnsugtf crrfacikfg,pu`cnk`i ng dustcacfjgn rnf`fptfr su aik`uatf jfdi ukrãmconk `n prcvfacñk `n gcjnrtf` ki ouy prigikmf`i5tfopiai lunrik sipnsf`fs gf vc`f fktnrcir `ng futir, y

    sus aik`cacikns pnrsikfgns, su aik`uatf pistnrcir f gfrnfgczfacñk `ng hnahi, yf qun ng ocsoi nk kckmôkoionkti ijstruyñ gf ckvnstcmfacñk pnkfg y oæs fôk, fgoionkti `n gf on`cacñk `n gf aik`nkf rnaikian gf kinxcstnkacf `ng `föi pftrcoikcfg f gf vïatcof, pir gi qunng pnrducaci afusf`i sn nkaunktrf rn`uac`i.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    50/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    >: 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 61

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    51/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    >1 

    FA^NZ@IQ S QNKPNKACFQ

    FÖI :223

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    52/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    >0 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 666/:223

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4  F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ng

    rnaursi `n rnvcscñk  

    Ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk ns rnahfzf`i nk rfzñk qun kinxcstn lfggi pistnrcir lcron qun `nagfrn gf lfgsn`f` `n gfstnstcoikcfgns qun scrvcnrik `n jfsn f gf snktnkacfrnaurrc`f, y f`noæs ki rnsugtf nvc`nktn gf lfgsn`f` `ngfs ocsofs.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 6:3/:223

    O^GPF4 Rnkf `n ougtf aiopgnonktfrcf  Znspnati f gf ougtf aiopgnonktfrcf fpgcaf`f, lunvcigf`i ng frt. 6:>, :´ pærrfli, `ng Añ`cmi RriansfgRnkfg, oitcvi `n kugc`f` `n nsf pfrtn `n gf aik`nkf,qun pnroctn fjsigvnr `crnatfonktn `n `cahf pnkf fgaik`nkf`i (frt. 08> `ng ARR).

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4  F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ngrnaursi `n rnvcscñk. Lfgtf `n luk`fonktfacñk  

    Qn hfan gumfr pfracfgonktn f gf rnvcscñk `n gfssnktnkacfs copumkf`fs y sn fjsungvn fg aik`nkf`i `ngf pnkf `n ougtf aiopgnonktfrcf pirqun su fpgcafacñkki lun luk`fonktf`f (lfgtfk oitcvis `n hnahi y `n`nrnahi nk qun sn jfsñ tfg `nacscñk).

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 612/:223

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ngrnaursi

    Ng oikti ngnvf`i, `n :2.222 `ñgfrns, `njcñ nxprnsfrsnnk oikn`f kfacikfg, y rngfacikf`i aik ng pnsi y vfgir`n gf `rimf ckafutf`f, pfrf nvfgufr gf copirtfkacf `ngcktnkti `n nkrcqunacocnkti.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    53/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    >> 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² :81/:223

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4  F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ng

    rnaursi `n rnvcscñk  Ki ns f`ocscjgn ng nstu`ci `ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñkprnsnktf`i, nk rfzñk `n qun gf snktnkacf aik`nkftircfki nstæ lcron, y ki pun`n snr rnvcsf`f.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 168/:223

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4  Lfgsn`f`ns c`nigñmcafs nckaikmrunkacfs  

    Ki sn hfan gumfr fg rnaursi `n rnvcscñk, `njc`i f qun

    `nvcnkn fdnkf f gf vïf rnaurscvf cktnktf`f gfs supunstfslfgsn`f`ns c`nigñmcafs, iocscikns n ckaikmrunkacfsfgnmf`fs nk ng priansi `n vfgirfacñk prijftircf y sunlcafacf nk gf farn`ctfacñk `n gis nxtrnois ckviguarf`isnk gf fausfacñk y snktnkacf aik`nkftircf5 pir gi qun kisn aiklcmurf gf afusfg copntrf`f.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² >2

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    54/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    >/:223

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4  Rrian`nkacf y auopgcocnkti `n gf

     pnkf  Qn `nagfrf ckf`ocscjgn ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk aufk`iaiktrf ng aik`nkf`i sn hf copfrtc`i ir`nk `n afpturf ysu rnocscñk f gf pnkctnkacfrïf rnmcikfg, pfrf ngauopgcocnkti `n gf pnkf, pir rnhusfrsn f prnsnktfrsn ffanptfr gfs aik`cacikns, gfs qun sn `ndfrik sck nlnati.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² =0=/:223

    KCÖNT S F@IGNQANKACF4 F`ignsanktn cklrfatir

    Ng f`ignsanktn, ns ti`f pnrsikf huofkf `ns`n gis 60 fgis 6= föis5 ki f gis 63 föis `n n`f`, aioi nk ng afsi,n`f` nk gf qun ng fausf`i aiontcñ ng hnahi pukcjgn, nkaiksnaunkacf ki sn hfan gumfr fg rnaursi `n rnvcscñk.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 8:>/:223

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Lfggis ckaikmrunktns  Gis lfggis copumkf`is y fausf`is `n ckaikmrunktnsnktrn sï hfk sc`i nofkf`is `n ñrmfkis durcs`caacikfgns`clnrnktns, (Prcjukfg `n Fpngfacikns y Airtn Quprnof `n

     Dustcacf) nk ng ocsoi prian`cocnkti pnkfg5 scnk`i gfôkcaf rnsiguacñk qun f`qucnrn ng mrf`i `n lcronzf nk gfafusf pfrtcaugfr ns ng lfggi nofkf`i `n gf AirtnQuprnof `n Dustcacf (`n faunr`i fg frt. =6 cka. :´ `ngARR), pir fmitfr gf afusf pnkfg nk snktc`i lirofg ysustfkacfg, ki mizfk`i ng `catf`i pir ng Prcjukfg `nFpngfacñk `ng ocsoi mrf`i `n lcronzf rnqunrc`i pir ng

    frt. 6:= `ng ARR.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 8>0/:223

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Hnahi kunvi  F tïtugi `n hnahis kunvis i kunvis ngnonktis `nprunjfs, nxcmn gf kiroftcvf aioi aik`cacñk `nprian`nkacf `ng rnaursi, snfk sijrnvckcnktns f gfaik`nkf i `nsaujcnrtfs `nspuãs `n qun nggf hfyfrnafï`i y scnoprn y aufk`i `ndnk trfsuktfr ukf

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    55/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    >= 

    cknquïviaf y prnacpuf ckac`nkacf sijrn ng afu`fgprijftirci onrctf`is nk gf snktnkacf rnvcsf`f.

    Pnstcoikci `n gf vïatcof^k tnstcoikci `n gf vïatcof rnfgczf`f fktn nsarcjfkipôjgcai nk ng qun gf ocsof rnaikian qun ng aik`nkf`iki hf fjusf`i `n nggf, sck kckmôk tcpi `n `iauonktiqun farn`ctn tfgns fsnvnrfacikns, ki ns sulcacnktn pfrfrnstfr arn`cjcgc`f` fg lfggi ftfaf`i.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 8>>/:223

    RNKF4 @ntnrockfacñk `n gf pnkf. Ftrcjuacñk `n gis trcjukfgns `n ducaci

    Gf `ntnrockfacñk `n gf pnkf ki ns oftnrcf `n fkægcscs`n kckmuki `n gis Prcjukfgns `n Fgzf`f, aikstctuyn ukfaunstcñk qun nstæ `ngcoctf`f pfrf gis Prcjukfgns `n

     Ducaci, `njc`i f qun ti`i gi rngftcvi f su `ntnrockfacñk`npnk`n `n ukf snrcn `n ngnonktis y fprnacfacikns `nhnahi, `njnk snr nxaguscvfonktn nstu`cf`is pir ngñrmfki snktnkacf`ir.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 32

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    56/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    >8 

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    57/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    >3 

    FA^NZ@IQ S QNKPNKACFQ

    FÖI :262

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    58/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    59/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    60/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    61/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    62/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    63/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

     

    FA^NZ@IQ S QNKPNKACFQ

    FÖI :266

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    64/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    65/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    66/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    /:266

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Hnahi kunvi  Aufk`i ng rnvcscikcstf sn gcoctf f nkliafr `n itrfofknrf hnahis yf `njftc`is nk ng ducaci i prunjfs yffpirtf`fs y nxfockf`fs nk su ipirtukc`f` pir ng

     duzmf`ir, ki prian`n gf ckviafacñk `n nsf afusfg, punsnk tfgns afsis, gi kunvi ki ns kc ng hnahi kc gf prunjf,scki ng arctnrci aik ng aufg sn gi nxfockf y ki ns nsi gi

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    67/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    68/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    =2 

    lfaugtftcvfonktn, aufk`i ng futir sn nkrcqunacñon`cfktn ng hnahi i gi cktnktñ.

    Nk gf afusf ki sn onkacikfrik qun gf ougtf lunfpgcaf`f aioi pnkf aiopgnonktfrcf, kc sn fkfgczf aikgf sfkf arctcaf gf rngfacñk nktrn gf afktc`f` `n `rimf`naiocsf`f y ng vfgir `n gf ocsof, `n `ik`n rnsfgtfrïfng nkrcqunacocnkti on`cfktn ng hnahi, pir gi qun gffpgcafacñk `n `is pnkfs prckacpfgns, nk lirof aikduktf,pir uk ocsoi hnahi pnkfg sn hfggf vn`f`i.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 061/:266

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK 4  Znaursi `n rnvcscñk nk ng priansi pnkfg  

    Aufk`i sn `nagfrf gf fjsiguacñk `n rnpriahn `n uki `ngis nkafusf`is, pir gf fpgcafacñk `ng prckacpci `n gf`u`f rfzikfjgn nk gf `noistrfacñk læatcaf `ng pnrducacipftrcoikcfg, c`ãktcafs aiksc`nrfacikns `njnk snrfpgcafjgns f uk ai-priansf`i, nk rfzñk `n ki nxcstcrcopn`conkti fgmuki pfrf qun f ãstn, snfk fpgcaf`is gisocsois nlnatis `n fqunggf rnsiguacñk.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 013/:266

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Znnxfonk `n gf afusf  Gis fmrfvcis `ng rnaurrnktn sn anktrfrik nk gf nrrñknfafgclcafacñk `ng Prcjukfg `n Oãrcti, fgu`cnk`i gf ockirïf`n n`f` `n gfs vïatcofs `ng hnahi fquï duzmf`i, pnri kifpirtf kckmôk ngnonkti aioi prunjf `n nggi, ki fgnmfhnahi kunvi i prunjf qun fonrctn gf hfjcgctfacñk `nnstf ckstfkacf rnvcsirf.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 0=0/:266

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4  F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ngrnaursi `n rnvcscñk  

    Ki airrnspik`n gf fguscñk `n ‗ckaiopftcjcgc`f`‟ `n

    snktnkacfs fgnmf`f aioi oitcvi pir gis rnvcscikcstfs,hfjc`f aunktf qun `cahf pnaugcfrc`f` `njn surmcr `nukf ocsof sctufacñk i knxi læatcai5 nxtrnoi qun ki sn`f nk ng prnsnktn afsi, puns gf durcspru`nkacf trfï`f f

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    69/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    =6 

    aigfacñk airrnspik`n f afsis qun ki mufr`fk kckmôktcpi `n aiknxcñk aik ng fkfgczf`i.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 030/:266

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4  Fpgcafacñk `n gf gny oæs lfvirfjgn.Añ`cmi `n gf Kcönz y gf F`ignsankacf  

     Pnkcnk`i nk aunktf qun ng aik`nkf`i fg oionkti `n gfpnrpntrfacñk `ng hnahi aiktfjf aik 68 föis `n n`f`, kiairrnspik`n gf fpgcafacñk rntrifatcvf `ng Frt. :2= `ngAñ`cmi `n gf Kcönz y `n gf F`ignsankacf f gf sctufacñkpriansfg `ng aik`nkf`i pir ki vnrclcafrsn nk ng rnvcscikcstfng prnsupunsti pfrf su fpgcafacñk, ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk

    cktnktf`f pir ng @nlnksir `njn snr rnahfzf`i, pir sukitircf coprian`nkacf.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 0/:266

    RZIANQI RNKFG4 Rn`c`i `n Fagfrftircf  Qn hfan gumfr f gf fagfrftircf aufk`i sn f`vcnrtn uknrrir oftnrcfg nk gf pfrtn rnsigutcvf `ng lfggi qun snaiktrfpikn aik gi nstu`cf`i y rnsungti nk ng aunrpi `ngocsoi.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K²

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    70/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    =: 

    gf cktnrpiscacñk `n gf rnvcscñk sn hf auopgc`i gffutikitclcafacñk, gi qun scmkclcaf, sck `u`f piscjgn, qun gf`nacscñk copumkf`f ki sn hfggfjf fôk lcron, rnqucscti

    luk`fonktfg pfrf pgfktnfr ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk y onkisfôk pun`n `n`uacrsn gf nxtckacñk `n gf faacñk, puns nggfairrnspik`n f itri nstf`ci priansfg. Nk aiksnaunkacf, fgki hfggfrsn lcron gf aunstcikf`f snktnkacf `ng Prcjukfg `nFpngfacñk, nk ng oionkti `n pgfktnfrsn gf rnvcscñk, ngrnaursi ns ckf`ocscjgn.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² =18/:266

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4  F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ng

    rnaursi `n rnvcscñk. Aisf duzmf`f  Agfrfonktn gf kirof nstfjgnan aioi rnqucscti qun gfsrnsiguacikns `catf`fs nk gis priansis pnkfgns, qun gf pfrtnaiksc`nrf ckaiopftcjgn, ckaikacgcfjgn i aiktrf`catircfs,(Qnktnkacfs @nlckctcvfs i Futis Cktnrgiautircis), nstfs`njnk tnknr afræatnr `n aisf duzmf`f, ns `nacr qun ngpriansi hfyf aikaguc`i, tfg sctufacñk ki sn aikstftf nk ngprnsnktn rnaursi5 yf qun ukf `n gf rnsiguacñk fmrnmf`fki tcnkn gf vcrtufgc`f` `n piknr lck f gf afusf.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 332/:266

    RZ^NJF @N PNQPCMIQ4 Rrunjf `n tnstcmis nk oftnrcf pnkfg.Fprnacfacñk `n gf prunjf tnstcoikcfg. Zntrfatfacñk

    Gf lfgsn`f` nk ng tnstcoikci, kfac`f `n gf rntrfatfacñk,`njn snr ijdnti `n `noistrfacñk nk ducaci prnvci.

    Nk gf prunjf `n tnstcmis gf scopgn afgclcafacñk `nprnscikf`is u ilnrtf`is pir uk prnaci pfrf su pistnrcirrntrfatfacñk, sck ukf lñrougf gnmfg `n `noistrfacñk `n nsnnxtrnoi, gis hfan af`uafr5 pirqun af`f tnstcoikci nsvfgirf`i `nktri `n ukf ukc`f` lirofg y durï`caf, ns `nacr,qun ng uki y ng itri ki sn nstæk `nstruynk`irnaïpriafonktn.

    Gis nxæonkns tnstclcafgns ki sik tnkc`is aioi prunjfsnxaguynktns ng uki aik ng itri, pirqun `njnk snrnxfockf`is scnoprn ck`cvc`ufgonktn, yf qun af`f tnstcmihfan f su pripcf cktnmrc`f`, kfac`f `n gf nsnkacf durï`caf`n gf onti`igimïf qun copnrftcvfonktn sn fpgcaf, aiklirongf kirof priansfg airrnspik`cnktn.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    71/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    =1 

    FA^NZ@IQ S QNKPNKACFQ

    FÖI :26:

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    72/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    =0 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 63/:26:

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Onkirns f`ugtis. Fpgcafacñk `n gf gny

    oæs lfvirfjgnGfs pnrsikfs `n `cnz y iahi föis `n n`f` nstæknxaguc`is `n gis jnknlcacis `n gf Gny 63/:26:

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Rrian`nkacf `ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk.Znvfgirfacñk `n prunjfs

    Gf prihcjc`f rnvfgirfacñk `n gf prunjfs, nstæ dustclcaf`f

    pir ng `njc`i priansi, gf sfkf arïtcaf y gf ckon`cfacñk`ng ñrmfki aiopntnktn. S gf lfgtf `n itrf gny oæsjnkcmkf, tfopiai pnroctn hfanr gumfr gf rnvcscñk.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² ::8/:26:

    D^ZCRZ^@NKACF4 Zn`uaacñk `n sfkacikns

    ^kf snktnkacf ki ns durcspru`nkacf, sijrn ti`i aufk`instã `n pir on`ci gf copiscacñk `n pnkfs, `ñk`n gfsacraukstfkacfs pripcfs `n af`f sctufacñk, trfsacnk`nk

    oæs fggæ `n scocgctu` nk tcpis pnkfgns, yf qun gffpgcafacñk `n ukf sfkacñk ijn`nan f uk fkægcscsfdustf`i f af`f nxtrnoi `ng Frtïaugi `ng AR, ns `nacr,gf sigf rn`uaacñk `n sfkacikns ki copirtf gf knansfrcf iscqucnrf gf piscjcgc`f` `n rn`uaacikns f afsis aik tcpispnkfgns scocgfrns, scki gi fonrctfk gfs acraukstfkacfspnrsikfgns `n af`f aik`nkf`i.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    73/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    => 

    D^ZCRZ^@NKACF4 Afojci  

    Gf rn`uaacñk `n gfs sfkacikns copunstfs pir ñrmfkiscklnrcirns nk itris afsis, ki copirtf uk afojci `n

     durcspru`nkacf, kc gf fpgcafacñk `n ukf gny oæs jnkcmkf,puns nk acraukstfkacfs pripcfs `n af`f afsi trfï`i fnstu`ci y fkægcscs, gf Qfgf Rnkfg hf rnspntf`i gfgnmcsgfacñk vcmnktn y gfs pfutfs tnopirfgns `n fpgcafacñk`n gfs aik`nkfs, tnkcnk`i nk aiksc`nrfacñk ti`is gisnxtrnois vfgirftcvis knansfrcis fg rnspnati.

    RNKF4 Aufktclcafacñk. Aiopntnkacf `n gis Prcjukfgns `n Ducaci.Gny oæs jnkcmkf

    Gf aufktclcafacñk `n gf pnkf ki ns oftnrcf `n fkægcscs

    `n kckmuki `n gis Prcjukfgns `n Fgzf`f, puns gf ocsofaikstctuyn ukf aunstcñk qun nstæ `ngcoctf`f pfrf gflukacñk `n gis Prcjukfgns `n Ducaci, sfgvi qun sn trftn`ng f`vnkcocnkti `n ukf gny oæs jnkcmkf y sn rnfgcanukf rn`uaacñk onrfonktn oftnoætcaf, sck fkfgczfrpfrf gf aufktclcafacñk, ng mrf`i `n rnpriahn y gfsacraukstfkacfs pnrsikfgns y læatcafs yf fprnacf`fs`nktri `ng ducaci pnkfg.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4  F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ngrnaursi `n rnvcscñk. Acraukstfkacfs pnrsikfgns4 n`f` y

     pngcmrisc`f` K² ::8/:26:  Gfs fgnmfacikns `n gf n`f` `ng aik`nkf`i y gf fusnkacf`n pngcmrisc`f` `ng ocsoi aioi hnahis kunvis ingnonktis prijftircis kunvis, ki tcnknk gf vcrtufgc`f``n rnvnrtcr gf snktnkacf aik`nkftircf, sik fspnatis qun

     yf hfk sc`i aiksc`nrf`is pir gis duzmf`irns fgoionkti `n copiknr gf aik`nkf, pir gi qunairrnspik`n ng rnahfzi `ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 1

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    74/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    =1/:26:

    FAGFZFPIZCF4 Rn`c`i `n fagfrftircf nk gi pnkfg

    Airrnspik`n airrnmcr ng nrrir oftnrcfg nk ngaiksc`nrfk`i `ng faunr`i y snktnkacf copumkf`irn`uacãk`isn gf pnkf copunstf f gis aik`nkf`is, fikan (66) föis `n prcvfacñk `n gcjnrtf` y ki 68 föis.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    75/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    == 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 0>8/:26:

    FAGFZFPIZCF4 Nrrir oftnrcfg  

    @njc`i fg nrrir oftnrcfg ckviguktfrci (iocscñk `ngpftriackfktn nk gf pfrtn rnsigutcvf), sn rnfgczf gffagfrftircf `n ilcaci pnrtcknktn, f tnkir `n gfs`cspiscacikns `ng Frt.6:< `ng Añ`cmi Rriansfg Rnkfg, nkaikair`fkacf aik ng Frt.6= `n gf Gny K´ .

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 0>3/:26:

    ZNJNG@ÏF @NG D^QPCACFJGN. Ckf`ocscjgc`f` `ng rnaursi `nrnvcscñk. Qiontcocnkti f gis ofk`ftis `n gf dustcacf

    Rfrf ng ndnracaci `n gis `nrnahis priansfgns ns aik`cacñkcksisgfyfjgn qun ng dustcacfjgn nstã siontc`i f gisofk`ftis `n gf dustcacf5 nk afsi aiktrfrci ki pun`nrnagfofr dustcacf qucãk sn ounstrf rnocsi fgauopgcocnkti `n gi `nac`c`i pir ng ñrmfki durcs`caacikfgaioi airigfrci `ng priansi pnkfg, pir gi qunairrnspik`n `nagfrfr ckf`ocscjgn ng rnaursinxtrfir`ckfrci `n rnvcscñk.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² >>1/:26:

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Hnahi kunvi. PnstclcafgnsGfs vnrscikns cktnrnsf`fs i rnctnrf`fs, ftrcjuc`fs fitrfs pnrsikfs, aioi `nagfrfacñk `n viguktf`,aikstfkacfs i tnstclcafgns pistnrcirns f uk ducaci irfgqun cktnktfk oi`clcafr ng aiktnkc`i y rnsugtf`i `ngocsoi, ki vfgnk pfrf fgtnrfr, gf lcdfacñk `n hnahis yvfgirfacñk `n prunjfs, rnfgczf`fs aikliron f gf sfkfarïtcaf pir ng Prcjukfg `n Qnktnkacf, qun scrvnk pfrf

    nstfjgnanr gf aisf duzmf`f, y gf snmurc`f` durï`caf.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² >>0/:26:

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4  F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ngrnaursi `n rnvcscñk. Hnahi kunvi. Nstu`ci pscaigñmcai  

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    76/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    =8 

    Airrnspik`n rnahfzfr ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk aufk`i ngrnvcscikcstf sn acrauksarcjn f nkliafr `n itrf ofknrf gfsacraukstfkacfs læatcafs `njftc`fs y farn`ctfs nk ng ducaci,

    (actfk`i gf nxcstnkacf `n uk nstu`ci pscaigñmcai qun `nkitfukf supunstf ckactfacñk pir pfrtn `n gf of`rn `n gfvïatcof f onktcr, `n lirof f ckarcockfr f su fjungi), qun`n hfjnrsn aikiac`i nk ng ducaci, hujcnrf ircnktf`i gfaikaguscñk `n itrf lirof, aik gf prntnkscñk `n qun nstfacraukstfkacf pun`f aiksc`nrfrsn aioi hnahi kunvi,afpfz `n fgtnrfr sustfkacfgonktn ng vnrn`cati aik`nkftirci.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K²

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    77/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    =3 

    D^ZCQRZ^@NKACF

    Fg aikdukti `n lfggis aickac`nktns sijrn gfcktnrprntfacñk `n gf gny pnkfg  ‑   `iatrckfrcfonktn

    aikiac`f aioi durcspru`nkacf kiroftcvf  ‑   ns qun nggnmcsgf`ir pnkfg gn rnaikian c`iknc`f` oitcvfacikfg pfrfrnspfg`fr ng rnaursi rnvcscvi rnagfofk`i su fpgcafacñkpnrsikfgczf`f nk ng afsi aikarnti f qucãk sn nkaunktrfnk cmufg acraukstfkacf `n fquãg qun pri`cmñ gfcktnrprntfacñk arnf`irf `n gf durcspru`nkacf y nk gfon`c`f qun gn rnsugtn lfvirfjgn.

    HNAHI K^N\I

    Gis hnahis kunvis i sijrnvckcnktns, tfg aioi gi

    rnqucnrn gf prnanptcvf rctufg nk fkægcscs (Frt. 086 cka. 0`ng ARR), `njnk trftfrsn `n hnahis qun ggnmfsnk faikiacocnkti `n gfs pfrtns aik pistnrcirc`f` f gfsnktnkacf aik`nkftircf y qun mufr`fk ïktcof rngfacñk ngfaiktnanr `ngcatcvi flcrof`i aioi nxcstnktn nk ng lfggi,sck qun fg tcnopi `n `catfrsn ãstf, fqunggis hfyfknxcstc`i.

    RZCKACRCIQ MNKNZFGNQ

    Ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk, pir su nspnacfg kfturfgnzf, kirnaikian piscjcgc`f` `n ãxcti i frmuonktis sustnktf`ink aunstcikns ki afptf`fs pir gis prnanptis gnmfgns qun`nsarcjnk gf aiklcmurfacñk `n gfs afsuïstcafs frm÷c`fsaioi luk`fonktis y pir nk`n, ckafpfz `n sustnktfr ng`nspgfzfocnkti `n gf aisf duzmf`f aik fgtnrfacñk `n gfsaiksnaunkacfs durï`cafs qun gns sik aiksustfkacfgns.

    CKPNZRZNPFACÑK ZNQPZCAPC\F

    Gf cktnrprntfacñk rnstrcatcvf ns ckhnrnktn fg rnsirtn

    copumkftcaci cktnrpunsti pirqun tcnkn pir lckfgc`f``ndfr sck nlnati uk lfggi lcron, gi qun hfan knansfrci qunsn auopgf uk oïkcoi `n aik`cacikns prnsarctfs nk susagæusugfs oitcvfacikfgns, `n lirof tfg, qun nktrn giscktnrnsns mnknrfgns `n gf siacn`f` y gis `nrnahis `ngcoputf`i, nxcstf uk nqucgcjrci qun pnroctf gf vcmnkacf`n gfs mfrfktïfs `n fojis, pnri sck `nson`ri `n gfmfrfktïf `ng prckacpci `n snmurc`f` durï`caf qunrnaikian ck`u`fjgn rfïz aikstctuacikfg.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    78/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    82 

    RZCKACRCIQ MNKNZFGNQ

    Ng rnon`ci qun sn aiklïf fg rnaursi `n rnvcscñk pnkfg kitcnkn ng pripñscti `n airrnmcr gf nqucviaf`f vfgirfacñk

    `n gis ngnonktis qun nstfjfk prnsnktns nk ng priansi,scki ng `n pnroctcr pik`nrfr gis qun pir ki hfjnr nstf`iprnsnktns nktikans, pu`cnrik cklgucr pfrf pi`nr frrcjfrf ukf `nacscñk `cstcktf.

    FRGCAFACÑK @N GF GNS OÆQ LF\IZFJGN

    Gis ngnonktis aiklcmurftcvis `n gf afusfg nstfjgnac`f nkng Frt. 086 cka. > `ng ARR nstæk `ntnrockf`is pir4 f) Gfnxcstnkacf `n ukf snktnkacf aik`nkftircf lcron qun

    ipnrf aioi aik`cacñk mnkãrcaf `n ti`i rnaursi `nrnvcscñk, aufgqucnrf snf ng oitcvi5 j) uk afojci

     durcspru`nkacfg, sijrn gf oftnrcf rnvcsf`f nk mrf`i `nscocgctu` mnknrf`f pir gf Airtn Quprnof `n Dustcacf ypistnrcir f gf snktnkacf aik`nkftircf rnafï`f,nxaguyãk`isn gf nofkf`f `n uk ñrmfki durcs`caacikfg`cstckti y a) qun `cahf durcspru`nkacf lfvirnzaf fgaik`nkf`i.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² =08/:26:ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ngrnaursi `n rnvcscñk. Znjng`ïf `ng dustcacfjgn  

    Rfrf ng ndnracaci `n gis `nrnahis priansfgns ns aik`cacñkcksisgfyfjgn qun ng dustcacfjgn sn nkaunktrn siontc`i fgis ofk`ftis `n gf dustcacf5 nk afsi aiktrfrci ofgpun`n rnagfofr dustcacf qucnk sn ounstrf rnocsi fgauopgcocnkti `n gi `nac`c`i pir ng ñrmfki durcs`caacikfgaioi airigfrci `ng priansi pnkfg.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 61:

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    79/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    86 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 60=2/:26:

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Hnahi kunvi. Rnrcacf faac`nktigñmcaf

    Gis copumkfktns ilrnacnrik gf pnrcacf faac`nktigñmcafaioi hnahi kunvi, pnri `cahf prunjf ki lun aiktrigf`fpir gfs `noæs pfrtns nk ng priansi pnkfg, qucnkns kituvcnrik gf ipirtukc`f` `n nxpiknr gis puktis `npnrcacf qun arnïfk pnrtcknktns fsï aioi tfopiaicktnrvckcnrik nk ng kiojrfocnkti `ng prilnscikfgnkafrmf`i `n rnfgczfr `cahf gfjir acnktïlcaf, pir gi qunsn rnahfzf ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk cktnrpunsti.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² :2/:26:

    ZNA^ZQI @N AFQFACÑK. ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 On`cacñk`n gf pnkf

    Ng copumkfktn, fg cktnrpiknr ng rnaursi `n afsfacñk nkgf prnsnktn afusf, yf sigcactñ f gf Qfgf Rnkfg ng fkægcscs`ng auopgcocnkti i ki pir pfrtn `ng Prcjukfg `n Oãrcti`n gfs `cspiscacikns `ng Frt. `ng añ`cmi `n lik`i ngaufg hfan rnlnrnkacf f gfs jfsns `n gf on`cacñk `n gfpnkf, fsï aioi tfojcãk `n gf airrnatf rnvcscñk i ki `ng

    lfggi `ng Prcjukfg `n Qnktnkacf pir pfrtn `ng Prcjukfg `nFpngfacikns, y nk `cahf ipirtukc`f` gf Qfgf Rnkfgaiksc`nrñ qun gf luk`fonktfacñk `n gf pnkf copunstflun fair`n f `nrnahi, pir gi qun ng fmrfvci ki pun`nvigvnr f snr fkfgczf`i nk gf trfoctfacñk `ng rnaursi `nrnvcscñk.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Hnahi kunvi

    Ng rnaurrnktn ilrnacñ hnahis kunvis pnri ki frmuonktñfanraf `n añoi gis ocsois vfk f `noistrfr qun ng

    hnahi pukcjgn ki nxcstcñ i qun ng coputf`i ki giaiontcñ, pfrf fsï pi`nr airrnmcr ukf snktnkacf lcron yndnautircf`f, pir gi qun ki sn hfan gumfr fg rnaursi `nrnvcscñk cktnrpunsti. 

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    80/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    8: 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² :013/:26:

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Hnahi kunvi

    Gfs prunjfs prnsnktf`fs, f tïtugi `n hnahis kunvis,ki fpirtfk hnahis kunvis yf qun lunrik prnsnktf`isnk gf ntfpf prnpfrftircf - airrnspik`nk f pnrci`isfkufgns nxtrföis fg aufg sn afptñ gf cgcactu` y pir gfqun sn duzmñ gf aik`uatf `ng rnvcscikcstf y qunairrnspik`ïf fg föi :220.

    Gis `iauonktis prnsnktf`is aioi ngnonktisprijftircis fktns `ng `catf`i `n gf snktnkacfaik`nkftircf yf lunrik dustcprnacf`is ipirtukfonktn,

    ki scnk`i ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk c`ñkni pfrf priynatfruk kunvi priansi pnkfg sijrn ngnonktis `n ducacis qunipirtukfonktn hfk sc`i sngnaacikf`is, `csautc`is yvfgirf`is aik fopgctu` nk gf ckstfkacf durcs`caacikfgaik snondfktn aikaguscñk `nlckctcvf, gi qun, `n pir sï ,`nsafrtf gf nxcstnkacf `n hnahis kunvis i kunvisngnonktis `n prunjfs afgclcafjgns `n kivn`isis qun`njnk snr aufgc`f`ns qun knansfrcfonktn `njnk ftfvcfrf gfs afusfgns ckviaf`fs pfrf su ipnrftcvc`f`.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Rrian`nkacf `ng ZnaursiFg ki aiklcmurfrsn gf afusfg copntrf`f nk gis tãrockis`ng Frtïaugi 086 cka. 0 `ng ARR, `ng `cmnstickstruonktfg, airrnspik`n ki hfanr gumfr, pircoprian`nktn, fg rnaursi `n rnvcscñk cktnrpunsti.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    81/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    81 

    FA^NZ@IQ S QNKPNKACFQ

    FÖI :261

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    82/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    80 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 83/:261

    NQP^RNLFACNKPNQ4 Gnmcsgfacñk fpgcafjgn  

    Ng frtïaugi :< `n gf Gny 6102/88, tcpclcaf gfs fatcvc`f`nstnk`cnktns f gf nxpirtfacñk i copirtfacñk `nnstupnlfacnktns, ns `nacr, gis fatis prnpfrftircis `n gfaik`uatf prnvcstf nk ng frtïaugi :6 oi`clcaf`i pir gfGny 6886/2:. Qc jcnk gis ofrais pnkfgns nktrn ng hnahiaiksuof`i y gis fatis `n prnpfrfacñk, snrïfk`nspripiracikf`is nk ng afsi, sik hnahis pukcjgnsfutñkiois, y gf `nspripiracikfgc`f` rnlnrc`f pir gf`nlnksf `njnrïf snr nstu`cf`f nk ng æojcti gnmcsgftcvi, yki durcs`caacikfg.

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4 Oi`clcafacñk `n gf aik`nkf. Znaursi`n rnvcscñk nk ng priansi pnkfg. Gny kunvf  

    Rfrf gf prian`nkacf `ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk (Frt. 086cka. >) ns aik`cacñk sckn quf kik, gf fpfrcacñk `n ukfgny kunvf qun ki hfyf sc`i aikiac`f fg oionkti `n`catfrsn gf snktnkacf aik`nkftircf y qun oi`clcqun gfsctufacñk `ng aik`nkf`i.

    Ng rnvcscikcstf prntnk`n ukf kunvf sujsukacñk sijrngis ocsois hnahis rnspnati f itri tcpi pnkfg sck qun ãgocsoi aikstctuyf ukf gny kunvf, aunstcñk qun rnsugtffdnkf f gf kfturfgnzf ocsof `n gf rnvcscñk.

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 610/:261

    ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑK4  Hnahi kunvi. F`ocscjcgc`f` y prian`nkacf `ng rnaursi `n rnvcscñk  

    Aufk`i ng rnvcscikcstf sn gcoctf f nkliafr durï`cafonktn `n itrf ofknrf hnahis yf `njftc`is nkng ducaci i prunjfs yf fpirtf`fs y nxfockf`fs nk suipirtukc`f` pir ng duzmf`ir, ki prian`n gf ckviafacñk`n nsf afusfg, puns nk tfgns afsis, gi kunvi ki ns kc nghnahi kc gf prunjf, scki ng arctnrci aik ng aufg sn ginxfockf y ki ns nsi gi qun gf gny hf ngnvf`i f gfaftnmirïf nxanpacikfg `n oitcvi `n rnvcscñk.

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    83/798

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    84/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    8

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    85/798

    LFGGIQ @N GF AIZPN Q^RZNOF @N D^QPCACF

    8= 

    FA^NZ@IQ S QNKPNKACFQ

    FÖI :22=

  • 8/17/2019 Recurso Extraordinario de Revision - Suplemento 1 - Ano 2014 - Portalguarani

    86/798

    ZNA^ZQI NXPZFIZ@CKFZCI @N ZN\CQCÑK :22=-:261

    88 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF K² 1/:22=

    AF^QF4 ‗ZNA^ZQI @N ZN\CQCÑKRZIOI\C@I RIZ D.L.Z.G., JFDIRFPZIACKCI @N FJIMF@IQ, NK GFAF^QF4 \.I.N. S IPZIQ Q/ GNQCÑK @NAIKLCFKTF S IPZIQ ‟. 

    FA^NZ@I S QNKPNKACF KÔONZI4 PZNQNk gf acu`f` `n Fsukacñk, Afpctfg `n gf Znpôjgcaf `ng

    Rfrfmufy, f gis uk `ïfs `ng ons `n lnjrnri, `ng föi `is ocgscntn, nstfk`i rnukc`is nk gf Qfgf `n Faunr`is `n gf Airtn

    Quprnof `n Dustcacf, gis Qnöirns Ockcstris `n gf Qfgf Rnkfg,@iatirns ]CG@I ZCNKTC MFGNFKI, FGCACF JNFPZCTR^AHNPF @N AIZZNF y QCK@^GLI JGFKAI, jfdi gfprnsc`nkacf `ng prconri `n gis kiojrf`is, fktn oï, gfQnarntfrcf futirczfkt