reference texts for medical practice in remote and tropical settings

3
Wilderness and Environmental Medicine, 8,48-50 (1997) Letter to the editors , Reference texts for medical practice in remote and tropical settings To the Editors: Four fifths of the more than five billion people on our planet are living in the developing world [1]. Primary health care will be increasingly important in these often tropical and remote areas. Physicians trained in the West will continue to be in positions to provide medical care in developing coun- tries either while serving in local medical facilities or during adventure travel. Several years ago while working in a remote area of Nepal, I was called in the night to assist at a home delivery that had become complicated. On my arrival, fortuitously along with the local Lama, shaman, and midwife, I discov- ered a healthy newborn and a mother with retained placenta and postpartum hemorrhage. Having come prepared, I even- tually consulted the definitive and voluminous 1500-page obstetrics text that I had noticed in the clinic and brought along on the one-mile hike to the house call. Reading on the dirt floor by dim candlelight, I was appreciative of the text's clear and concise recommendation: "Proceed to the oper- ating room at once[!]" Since then, my pack carried to house calls in remote villages is free of those weighty reference books that serve so well for medical practice in the United States. Selection criteria There is a growing medical literature suitable for clinical reference by physicians who are practicing in a remote area or developing country. These texts tend to be different from those physicians find useful in clinical settings in developed countries. The scope of the presenting illness may be unfa- miliar. Clinical conditions often involve unreliable or non- existent lighting, heating, water and power sources, as well as limited staff, supplies, equipment, pharmacy, laboratory, and diagnostic studies. Referral to larger centers or special- ists may not be available because of the remote location, inadequate transportation, lack of patient resources, and/or patients' social standing or political status. The texts listed in this article were selected primarily on utility and appropriateness for this setting and, where alter- natives were available, on considerations of weight and cost. All texts listed are soft cover or small-format hard cover, printed on thin Bible paper. Several are published in low-cost editions for use in developing countries, produced by nonprofit organizations, and/or available in languages in 108D--6032 © 1997 Chapman & Hall addition to English. The address from which to obtain the title and the languages available in addition to English fol- low each citation. During several years of working in re- mote and/or tropical areas, I have found these texts particu- larly helpful with daily clinical duties. The surgical manuals are unique and essential to augment the skills and training of both primary-care physicians and surgeons who are caring for patients in remote or tropical settings. In addition, the clinical manuals addressing the medical problems common to developing countries includ- ing tuberculosis, leprosy, AIDS, parasitic and other infec- tious disease, complicated obstetrics, comprehensive ortho- pedics, nutrition, and sanitation have often proved invalu- able. Training of health care workers is commonly an important responsibility of physicians working in develop- ing countries; consequently a section listing appropriate manuals is included. Selected reference texts Note: Brackets [ ] following each citation designate the address from which to obtain a copy of the text. COMPREHENSIVE (INCLUDING INTERNAL MEDICINE, PEDIATRICS, OBSTETRICS, ETC.) Berkow, R., Fletcher, AJ., eds. The Merck Manual. 16th ed. Rah- way, NJ: Merck, 1992:2696. [Merck Sharp and Dohme Re- search Laboratories, West Point, PA 19486, USA] Hope, R.A., Longmore, J.M., Hodgetts, TJ., Ramrakha, P.S. Ox- ford Handbook of Clinical Medicine. 3rd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995:837. [Oxford University Press, Walton Street, Oxford OX2 6DP UK] ColIier, J.B., Longmore, J.M., Harvey, J.H. Oxford Handbook of Clinical Specialties. 3rd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995:811. [Oxford University Press] DENTISTRY ,Dickson, M. Where There Is No Dentist. Palo Alto: Hesperian Foundation, 1993:188. (Available in English and Portuguese.) [The Hesperian Foundation, P.O. Box 1692, Palo Alto, CA 94302, USA] King, M., Bewes, P., Cairns, J., Thornton, J., eds. Primary Sur- gery. Vol. I. Non-Trauma. (See "Surgery" below.) DERMATOLOGY Canizares, O. A Manual of Dermatology for Developing Countries. 2nd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1993:370. [Oxford University Press]

Upload: james-a-litch

Post on 08-Aug-2016

227 views

Category:

Documents


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Reference texts for medical practice in remote and tropical settings

Wilderness and Environmental Medicine, 8,48-50 (1997)

Letter to the editors,

Reference texts for medical practice in remote andtropical settings

To the Editors:

Four fifths of the more than five billion people on our planetare living in the developing world [1]. Primary health carewill be increasingly important in these often tropical andremote areas. Physicians trained in the West will continue tobe in positions to provide medical care in developing coun­tries either while serving in local medical facilities or duringadventure travel.

Several years ago while working in a remote area ofNepal, I was called in the night to assist at a home deliverythat had become complicated. On my arrival, fortuitouslyalong with the local Lama, shaman, and midwife, I discov­ered a healthy newborn and a mother with retained placentaand postpartum hemorrhage. Having come prepared, I even­tually consulted the definitive and voluminous 1500-pageobstetrics text that I had noticed in the clinic and broughtalong on the one-mile hike to the house call. Reading on thedirt floor by dim candlelight, I was appreciative of the text'sclear and concise recommendation: "Proceed to the oper­ating room at once[!]" Since then, my pack carried to housecalls in remote villages is free of those weighty referencebooks that serve so well for medical practice in the UnitedStates.

Selection criteria

There is a growing medical literature suitable for clinicalreference by physicians who are practicing in a remote areaor developing country. These texts tend to be different fromthose physicians find useful in clinical settings in developedcountries. The scope of the presenting illness may be unfa­miliar. Clinical conditions often involve unreliable or non­existent lighting, heating, water and power sources, as wellas limited staff, supplies, equipment, pharmacy, laboratory,and diagnostic studies. Referral to larger centers or special­ists may not be available because of the remote location,inadequate transportation, lack of patient resources, and/orpatients' social standing or political status.

The texts listed in this article were selected primarily onutility and appropriateness for this setting and, where alter­natives were available, on considerations of weight andcost. All texts listed are soft cover or small-format hardcover, printed on thin Bible paper. Several are published inlow-cost editions for use in developing countries, producedby nonprofit organizations, and/or available in languages in

108D--6032 © 1997 Chapman & Hall

addition to English. The address from which to obtain thetitle and the languages available in addition to English fol­low each citation. During several years of working in re­mote and/or tropical areas, I have found these texts particu­larly helpful with daily clinical duties.

The surgical manuals are unique and essential to augmentthe skills and training of both primary-care physicians andsurgeons who are caring for patients in remote or tropicalsettings. In addition, the clinical manuals addressing themedical problems common to developing countries includ­ing tuberculosis, leprosy, AIDS, parasitic and other infec­tious disease, complicated obstetrics, comprehensive ortho­pedics, nutrition, and sanitation have often proved invalu­able. Training of health care workers is commonly animportant responsibility of physicians working in develop­ing countries; consequently a section listing appropriatemanuals is included.

Selected reference texts

Note: Brackets [ ] following each citation designate theaddress from which to obtain a copy of the text.

COMPREHENSIVE (INCLUDING INTERNALMEDICINE, PEDIATRICS, OBSTETRICS, ETC.)

Berkow, R., Fletcher, AJ., eds. The Merck Manual. 16th ed. Rah­way, NJ: Merck, 1992:2696. [Merck Sharp and Dohme Re­search Laboratories, West Point, PA 19486, USA]

Hope, R.A., Longmore, J.M., Hodgetts, TJ., Ramrakha, P.S. Ox­ford Handbook of Clinical Medicine. 3rd ed. Oxford: OxfordUniversity Press, 1995:837. [Oxford University Press, WaltonStreet, Oxford OX2 6DP UK]

ColIier, J.B., Longmore, J.M., Harvey, J.H. Oxford Handbook ofClinical Specialties. 3rd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press,1995:811. [Oxford University Press]

DENTISTRY

,Dickson, M. Where There Is No Dentist. Palo Alto: HesperianFoundation, 1993:188. (Available in English and Portuguese.)[The Hesperian Foundation, P.O. Box 1692, Palo Alto, CA94302, USA]

King, M., Bewes, P., Cairns, J., Thornton, J., eds. Primary Sur­gery. Vol. I. Non-Trauma. (See "Surgery" below.)

DERMATOLOGY

Canizares, O. A Manual ofDermatology for Developing Countries.2nd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1993:370. [OxfordUniversity Press]

Page 2: Reference texts for medical practice in remote and tropical settings

Letter to the editors

EMERGENCY MEDICINE/TRAUMA

King, M. ed. Primary Surgery. Vol. 2. Trauma. (See "Surgery"below).

Mengert, T.J., Eisenberg, M.S., Copass, M.K. Emergency MedicalTherapy. 4th ed. Philadelphia: Saunders, 1996:992. [W.B.Saunders Co., The Curtis Center, Independence Square West,Philadelphia, PA 19106, USA]

FAMILY PLANNING

King, M., King, F., and Martodipoero, S. Primary Child Care. AManualfor Health Workers. Oxford: Oxford University Press,1978:314. [TALC]

Klein, S. A Book for Midwives. A Manual for Traditional BirthAttendants and Community Midwives. Palo Alto: The Hesper­ian Foundation, 1995:519. [The Hesperian Foundation]

Kleinman, R.L., ed. Family Planning Handbook for Doctors. 6thed. London: International Planned Parenthood Federation(IPPF), 1988:361. (Available in English, French, and Span­ish.) [IPPF, P.O. Box, 759, Inner Circle, Regent's Park, Lon­don, NWl 4LQ, UK]

HEALTH WORKER TRAINING

Werner, D. Where There Is No Doctor. Palo Alto: Hesperian Foun­dation, 1994:565. (Available in English, English for Africa,Hindi, Portuguese, and Spanish.) [Hesperian Foundation]

Werner, D., Bower, B. Helping Health Workers Learn. Palo Alto:Hesperian Foundation, 1991:632. (Available in English andSpanish.) [Hesperian Foundation]

IMMUNIZAnON FOR TRAVEL

Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Health Infor­mation for International Travel. Atlanta, GA: CDC, 1990.[Superintendent of Documents, US Government Printing Of­fice, Washington, DC 20402, USA]

INFECTIOUS DISEASEffROPICAL MEDICINE

Bell, D.R., ed. The Lecture Notes on Tropical Medicine. 4th ed.Oxford: Blackwell Scientific Publications, 1995:368. [Black­well Mosby Book Distributors, 11830 Westline IndustrialDrive, St. Louis, MO 63141, USA]

Benenson, A.S., ed. Control ofCommunicable Diseases in Man. 16thed. Washington, DC: American Public Health Association(APHA), 1995:577. (Available in Arabic, English, Farci, French,Italian, Japanese, Portuguese, Spanish, and Turkish.) [APHA,1015 Fifteenth Street, NW, Washington, DC 20005, USA]

Crofton, J., Home, N., Miller, F. Clinical Tuberculosis. London:Macmillan, 1992:210. [TALC]

Gilles, H.M. Management of Severe and Complicated Malaria. APractical Handbook. Geneva: World Health Organization(WHO), 1991 :66. [Distribution and Sales, WHO, 1211Geneva 27, Switzerland]

Sanford, J.P., Gilbert, D.N., Gerberding, J.L., Sande, M.A. TheSanford Guide to Antimicrobial Therapy. Dallas: Antimicro­bial Therapy, Inc., 1996:125. [Antimicrobial Therapy, Inc.,5910 N. Central Expressway, Suite 1995, Dallas, TX 75206,USA]

49

World Health Organization (WHO) A Guide to Leprosy Control.2nd ed. Geneva: WHO, 1988:121. [WHO]

World Health Organization (WHO). Guidelinesfor Clinical Man­agement ofHIV Infection in Adults. Geneva: WHO, 1991:86.(Available in English and French.) [WHO]

World Health Organization (WHO). Guidelinesfor Clinical Man­agement of HIV Infection in Children. Geneva: WHO, 1993:88. (Available in English and French.) [WHO]

World Health Organization (WHO). Treatment of Tuberculosis:Guidelines for National Programmes. Geneva: WHO, 1993:43. (Available in English, French, and Spanish.) [WHO]

LABORATORY

World Health Organization (WHO). Manual of Basic Techniquesfor a Health Laboratory. Geneva: WHO, 1980:478. (Avail­able in Chinese, English, French, and Spanish.) [WHO]

OBSTETRICS

Bergstrom, S., Hojer, B., Liljestrand, J., and Tunell, R. PerinatalHealth Care With Limited Resources. London: MacmillanEducation Ltd., 1994:186. [TALC]

Driessen, F. Obstetric Problems, A Parctical Manual. Nairobi,Kenya: African Medical and Research Foundation, 1991 :27S.[TALC]

King, M., Bewes, P., Cairns, J., Thornton, J., eds. Primary Sur­gery. Vol. 1. Non-Trauma. (See "Surgery" below.)

ORTHOPEDICS

King, M., ed. Primary Surgery. Vol. 2. Trauma. (See "Surgery"below.)

McRae, R. Practical Fracture Treatment. 2nd ed. New York:Churchill Livingstone, 1993:328. [Churchill Livingstone]

PEDIATRICS

Ebrahim, GJ. Paediatric Practice in Developing Countries. Lon­don: Macmillan, 1988:321. [TALC]

King, M., King, F., and Martodipoero, S. Primary Child Care. AManualfor Health Workers. Oxford: Oxford University Press,1978:314. [TALC]

Stanfield, P., Brueton, M., Chan, M., Parkin, M., and Waterson, T.,eds. Diseases of Children in the Subtropics and Tropics. 4thed. London: Edward Arnold and Educational Low-PricedBooks Scheme (ELBS), 1991:1076. [Tropical HealthTechnology\ELBS, 14 Bevills Close, Doddington, March,Cambridgeshire, PElS OTT, UK]

PHARMACOLOGY

Joint Formulary Committee. British National Formulary. London:British Medical Association, 1995:668. [British Medical As­sociation, Tavistock Square, London, WCIH 9JP, UK]

SURGERY

King, M., Bewes, P., Cairns, J., Thornton, J., eds. Primary Sur­gery. Vol. 1. Non-Trauma. Oxford: Oxford University Press,

Page 3: Reference texts for medical practice in remote and tropical settings

50

1993:640. [Teaching-aids at Low Cost (TALC), P.O. Box 49,St. Albans, Herts, ALl 5TX, UK]

King, M., ed. Primary Surgery. Vol. 2. Trauma. Oxford: OxfordUniversity Press, 1987:400. [TALC]

King, M., ed. Primary Anaesthesia. Oxford: Oxford UniversityPress, 1986:169. [TALC]

VETERINARY MEDICINE

Aniello, S., Mays, A., Bergeron, J., eds. The Merck VeterinaryManual. 7th ed. Rahway, NJ: Merck, 1991:1832. [MerckSharp and Dohme Research Laboratories]

WATER AND SANITATION

Morgan, P. Rural Water Supplies and Sanitation. London: Mac­millan Publishers Ltd., 1990:358. [TALC]

WILDERNESS MEDICINE

Wilkerson, J.A., ed. Medicine for Mountaineering and Other Wil­derness Activities. 4th ed. Seattle: Mountaineers Books, 1992:416. [The Mountaineers, 300 Third Avenue W., Seattle, WA98119, USA]

Letter to the editors

Conclusion

Creative problem solving, adaptability, flexibility, and hu­mor serve well in remote settings. A good beginning beforeleaving home is to adjust the clinical reference library oneplans to bring along and rely on in the new and challengingpractice setting. This list is offered as a starting point.

Acknowledgments

I am indebted to the numerous colleagues in Alaska, En­gland, India, Nepal, and Tibet from whom so much has beengained.

Reference

1. United Nations. World Population Prospects: The 1994 Revi­sion. New York: United Nations, 1994.

JAMES A. LITCH, MD

Bozeman, Montana, USA, andHimachal Pradesh, India