regime shifts in ecology and evolution

48
Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements Regime shifts in ecology & evolution @cboettig Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 1/45

Upload: carl-boettiger

Post on 18-Dec-2014

335 views

Category:

Education


6 download

DESCRIPTION

Pr

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Regime shifts in

ecology & evolution

@cboettig

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 1/45

Page 2: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 2/45

Page 3: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 3/45

Page 4: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Regime

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 4/45

Page 5: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Shifts

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 5/45

Page 6: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

〈 Ecologist 〉

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 6/45

Page 7: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

started in physics. . .

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 7/45

Page 8: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Digging for dinosaurs

sponsored by National Geographic

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 8/45

Page 9: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Peter Wainwright

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 9/45

Page 10: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Peter’s dives

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 10/45

Page 11: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 11/45

Page 12: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 12/45

Page 13: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 13/45

Page 14: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

A release of constraint?

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 14/45

Page 15: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 15/45

Page 16: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 16/45

Page 17: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 17/45

Page 18: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 18/45

Page 19: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 19/45

Page 20: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

How do we get anevolutionary time seriesfrom present-day species?

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 20/45

Page 21: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

XT1 = X0︸︷︷︸where you start

e−α1T1+

θ1(1− e−α1T1

)︸ ︷︷ ︸Where you are going

+

∫ T1

0σ1e

α1(s−T1)dWs︸ ︷︷ ︸Random shocks along the way

Solves as:

E(Xi) =n∑i=0

eγi

[θi(1− eαiti

) ]

Cov(Xi, Xj) =k∑s=0

[eγs+γ′

sσ2s

2αs

(1− e−2αsts

)]

γi = −n∑

j=i+1αjtj

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 21/45

Page 22: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Candidate models

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 22/45

Page 23: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 23/45

Page 24: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 24/45

Page 25: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 25/45

Page 26: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 26/45

Page 27: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Phylogenetic Monte Carlo

← Fits both models

to this data

LogLik(simple)LogLik(complex)

Simulate from

simple model →complex

model →

Likelihood ratio

frequency

Boettiger et al. 2012, Evolution, pmc R package

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 27/45

Page 28: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 28/45

Page 29: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Part II

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 29/45

Page 30: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 30/45

Page 31: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 31/45

Page 32: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Coral Bleaching

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 32/45

Page 33: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Eutrophication

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 33/45

Page 34: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 34/45

Page 35: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 35/45

Page 36: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

ddtE(xi) = 2

√r(t)(

√r(t) + θ − xi) (1)

ddtV (xi) = −2

√r(t)V (xi) + σ2(

√r(t) + θ) (2)

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 36/45

Page 37: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carver

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 37/45

Page 38: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Boettiger et al. 2012, PRSICarl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 38/45

Page 39: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 39/45

Page 40: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 40/45

Page 41: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Unifying challenges in regime shifts

Weak signals

Uncertainty quantificationComputationally intensiveStatistical power is data limited

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 41/45

Page 42: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Unifying challenges in regime shifts

Weak signalsUncertainty quantification

Computationally intensiveStatistical power is data limited

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 41/45

Page 43: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Unifying challenges in regime shifts

Weak signalsUncertainty quantificationComputationally intensive

Statistical power is data limited

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 41/45

Page 44: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Unifying challenges in regime shifts

Weak signalsUncertainty quantificationComputationally intensiveStatistical power is data limited

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 41/45

Page 45: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Why Open Source?

Reproduceresearch

Find & fix bugs

Extend into newsoftware

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 42/45

Page 46: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Code

Literature

Discussions

Lab Notebook

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 43/45

Page 47: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

The Open Lab Notebook

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 44/45

Page 48: Regime shifts in ecology and evolution

Introduction Early Warning Conclusions Acknowledgements

Acknowledgements

Image creditsMichael Najjar

Arkive.org

Millennium Ecosystem Assessment

Flickr user gfpeck

Boettiger et al 2012

Scheffer et al. 2001

Westneat & Alfaro 2005

http://carlboettiger.info/

Carl Boettiger, UC Davis [email protected] Regime shifts in ecology and evolution 45/45